Canada Slim and the King of Pain

Eskişehir, Turkey, Saturday 28 May 2022

I am often asked, usually in a tone of utter astonishment:

Why are you in Turkey and not in Switzerland?

Above: Fairytale Castle, Sazova Park, Eskişehir, Turkey

I am often asked, usually in a tone of complete confusion:

Why have you chosen to live alone and not remain with your wife back in Landschlacht?

Above: Landschlacht, Canton Thurgau, Switzerland

I am often asked, usually in a tone of total concern:

How do you feel being so far removed from the life you led back in Switzerland (or going further back, in Canada)?

Above: Flag of Canada

How can you possibly be happy?

The explanations are not so easy to elucidate.

“To travel hopefully is a better thing than to arrive.”

Robert Louis Stevenson

Above: Robert Louis Stevenson (1850 – 1894)

Certainly, the idea of going off to the unknown to seek adventures holds more than a touch of romance for me.

In my own humble way I might compare myself to early heroic explorers such as Ferdinand Magellan or to fictional travellers in the vein of Phileas Fogg, as circumnavigators of our planet have always captured the imagination of my adventurous soul.

Above: Ferdinand Magellan (1480 – 1521)

Above: First edition of Jules Verne’s Around the World in Eighty Days

I will openly admit that nothing can compare with the joy of the open road.

The sense of possibility and adventure brings feelings of exhilaration, too long submerged in the workaday routines of home.

Cheap air travel – Sorry, Greta Thunberg. – has opened up parts of the globe – for better or worse – once reserved for the seriously affluent.

The sense of possibility and adventure brings feelings of exhilaration, too long submerged in the workaday routines of home.

Cheap air travel – Sorry, Greta Thunberg. – has opened up parts of the globe – for better or worse – once reserved for the seriously affluent.

Above: Greta Thunberg

When travelling in far-flung corners of the world, you can escape the demands of modern life:

The chores, the clutter, the technology (this latter not so easy for millennials to abandon).

Above: Young adults using their mobile phones individually at a party

It is said that there is no fool like an old fool.

Should I not, a man who probably has fewer years ahead than behind, finally accept my fate, stay settled and be content with my assigned lot in life?

But whatever your stage in life, travelling spontaneously means you have the freedom to choose from an infinite spectrum of possibilities.

Those who have experienced independent travel have been smitten by the travel bug, moulded by Wanderlust, and will forever after long to visit more places, see more wonders and spend a longer time abroad.

I have been travelling, punctuated by periods of work to fund my travels, since my mid-20s.

Above: Your humble blogger

I met my wife when I was 30.

Above: Edmund Blair Leighton, The Wedding

Prior to my present circumstances in Turkey, I have lived and worked as a teacher in South Korea, Germany and Switzerland.

Above: Flag of South Korea

Above: Hwaseong Fortress, Suwon, South Korea

I have spent the last two decades in the last two aforementioned countries because of my relationship with my wife.

But part of the equation that determines a man’s total self-actualization is his ability to find happiness in the activities that generate his income.

In Germany this was easier.

Above: Flag of Germany

In Switzerland, my wife’s employment opportunities as a doctor were enhanced.

As a ESL teacher, my employment bonanza turned to dust in Switzerland.

Coming to Switzerland gave new life to my wife.

Coming to Switzerland was career suicide for me.

Above: Flag of Switzerland

The memory of a life that once was, where trekking in hinterlands was within the grasp of this ordinary man, gave me longing from a fascination ne’er forgotten for destinations as yet undiscovered.

Faraway places
With strange soundin’ names
Faraway over the sea
Those faraway places
With the strange soundin’ names
Are callin’, callin’ me

Goin’ to China
Or maybe Siam
I want to see for myself
Those faraway places
I’ve been readin’ about
In a book that I took from a shelf

I start getting restless
Whenever I hear
The whistle of a train
I pray for the day
I can get underway
And look for those castles in Spain

They call me a dreamer
Well, maybe I am
But I know that I’m burnin’ to see
Those faraway places
With the strange soundin’ names
Callin’, callin’ me

Of course, the practical, the logical reasoning that is the Germanic temperament invariably asks how such adventures can be afforded.

Magellan had the backing of the King and Queen of Spain, Phileas Fogg was a gentleman of independent means, and Michael Palin could always call on the resources of the BBC.

How can ordinary people possibly make their dreams a reality?

Above: Flag of the Spanish Empire (1516 – 1700)

Above: Michael Palin

I am a loveable idiot.

In my youth when I wanted to go somewhere I just went.

Once upon a time I entered the US with $10 Canadian in my pocket and left the US eight months later with $10 American.

Above: Flag of the United States of America

I walked many miles across the expanse of Canada with often minimal money and with no inkling where I might lay my head each evening.

Above: Canada (in green)

Like Blanche of A Streetcar Named Desire, I have always depended on the kindness of strangers and my own resourcefulness within the limits of the law.

The conventional means is to work hard all one’s life until that glorious wondrous day when you have the financial wherewithal to travel indefinitely.

But that makes the assumption that when that day arrives (if that day arrives) that a person has both the opportunity and the health to do so.

Grim spells of work, denying yourself the living of life may be a truly honourable, safe and secure, way of joining that safari in Tanzania, that diving in the Philippines, that bungee jumping in New Zealand sometime in the uncertain future.

Above: Flag of Tanzania

Above: Flag of the Philippines

Above: Flag of New Zealand

But what if it were possible to skip this decades-long, lifetime-long stage and head off into the horizon sooner than one’s senior years?

Instead of trying to finance the expensive trips advertised in the glossy travel brochures, what about trying to find alternative ways of experiencing those same places at a fraction of the cost?

Above: Travel agent, The Truman Show

Above: Jim Carrey (Truman Burbank), The Truman Show

Working in a faraway place allows the traveller to see how daily life is lived there.

Certainly, it is cheaper and quicker and far more satisfying a solution than waiting until I can afford to travel continuously in comfort.

And working abroad is an excellent way to experience a foreign culture from the inside.

The plucky Brit spending a few months on a Queensland outback station will have a different life experience than someone tending bar in Queens all their lives in the hopes that they might one day be able to afford that Florida fortnight in a resort hotel.

Above: Outback station, Queensland, Australia

Above: Bar, Queens, New York City, USA

Phil Tomkins, a 45-year-old Englishman who spent a year teaching on the tiny Greek island of Kea, (as quoted in Susan Griffith’s Work Your Way Around the World) describes the thought processes that galvanized him into action:

I think it comes down to the fact that we are only on this planet for a finger-snap of time.

If you have any kind of urge for a bit of adventure, then my advice would be to go for it!

Even if it all goes horribly wrong, you can look people in the eyes and say:

“At least, I gave it a try!”

You can work nine-to-five in an office or factory all day, come home, switch on the Idiot Lantern (what we North Americans call the Boob Tube) and sit there watching Michael Palin travelling the world – or you can be bold, seize the day, and do something amazing.

One thing I can guarantee:

When we are lying on our deathbed many years from now, we will not be saying to ourselves:

“Oh, I wish I had spent more time at the dead-end job and had a little less adventure in my life!”

Above: Ioulida, Kea, Greece

Above: Flag of Greece

Anyone with a taste for adventure and a modicum of nerve (or folly, depending on your point-of-view) has the potential for exploring the far-flung corners of the globe on very little money.

I am a loveable idiot, incomprehensible to many, more logical, folks.

For example, the textile factory that funds my weekly journey and sojourn in Denizli cheerfully, uncomplainingly paid for me to stay in a luxury hotel, the Park Dedeman.

There was absolutely no reason to complain about the standards of the services this hotel provided.

Above: Hotel Park Dedeman, Denizli, Turkey

I learned that were cheaper places for the company to put me up and since last week I am now to be a regular weekly guest at the Denizli Öğretmen Evi (Teachers’ House) at one third the cost of the Dedeman but with the same basic amenities provided in a less lavish form.

Granted this is not my money to worry about, but the OE feels more real, more authentic an experience than the Dedeman.

And, perhaps, if a decision for the continuation of ESL courses at the company hinges upon the cost of accommodating me in Denizli then I have made it easier for them to prolong the programme.

More importantly (at least to me) it is good to remind myself that comfort does not equal cultural experience.

The OE has few, if any, foreign guests.

And for Turks the OE is affordable, especially at time when the Turkish economy is hurting.

As for the textile factory that foots my bill, whether they acknowledge it or not, I have saved them money and have shown them, whether they see it or not, that I value their custom and wish to make it clear that I consider their needs as much as I own.

A luxury suite at a fancy hotel is nice, but is it a requirement for me?

No.

Above: Öğretmen Evi, Denizli, Turkey

I am often asked:

Wouldn’t the burden of being a stranger in a strange land be easier if shared?

Wouldn’t living abroad be more pleasant when someone were there by your side?

Are you not lonely sometimes?

Don’t you miss the wife?

To their surprise (and occasionally mine)(and to the consternation of the wife), loneliness is rarely an issue since solo travelling, solitary living, allows me to meet and be befriended by local people.

I have travelled quite pleasantly with my wife, but travelling with a significant other lacks the sense of possibility and adventure that I love most about travelling, about living abroad.

Whatever situations I get myself into when I am on my own, I have to get out of by myself.

Certainly there are sunsets I long to share and nights without end best survived together, but by the same token, the glorious moments, the feelings of triumph and absolute freedom, are uniquely mine.

Certainly we keep in communication with one another, thanks to the wonders of modern communication such as WhatsApp and Skype, for we remain married to one another at this time.

Above: WhatsApp logo

Above: Skype logo

Despite the limitations that time and distance create, I act responsibly to the best of my ability.

Do I honestly believe that she will wait indefinitely for me to end this “phase” of living and working abroad?

No, I do not believe so, for in my (albeit, limited) understanding of women, she craves the companionship that a constant partner provides.

I am not constantly consistently there.

And I cannot predict when this “phase” will end or even if it will end.

And let’s get real about the elephant in the room:

Sex.

Sex isn’t a separate part of a person.

Your heart, spirit, mind and body need to be along for the ride.

Sex is a spiritual practice, capable of transforming your whole outlook and refreshing your sense of glory in being alive.

And as much as self-manipulation is an essential and healthy part of a person’s sexuality throughout life, as much as it is the way to develop appreciation of ourselves and our sensory potential and realize that we own our own sexual energy, it is unfair to expect that self-love will indefinitely satisfy those who crave the intimacy of companionship.

My wife is a woman and women crave companionship.

She will not wait indefinitely nor is it reasonable to have such an expectation.

We are all animals, to one degree or another.

We like eating, drinking, sleeping, sex.

But what separates us from the animals is our ability to control our baser instincts.

You and me, baby, ain’t nothin’ but mammals
So let’s do it like they do on the Discovery Channel
(Do it again now)
You and me, baby, ain’t nothin’ but mammals
So let’s do it like they do on the Discovery Channel

I need food and drink and sleep to survive, but sex is a privilege not a right, a pleasure not a necessity.

And while I am married I refrain from the temptation of the latter as I seek to find myself in the adventure of solo living, of solo travelling.

Being alone, as much as there are moments when I miss the companionship of my wife, makes me more conscious of being alive when I am journeying in new and exciting ways.

Being in alien places and cultures gives me an increased connection with myself, because it is there in these new situations that my consciousness wakes up.

Above: James Stewart (George Bailey) and Thomas Mitchell (Uncle Billy), It’s A Wonderful Life

Away from Landschlacht, Switzerland, away from Lachute, Canada, I realize that I have turned off the unconscious autopilot that ran my normal life.

Above: rue Principale, Lachute, Québec, Canada

Away from the familiar, away from the safety and security, away from the routine, I start to take conscious control of my life.

Life becomes more immediately lived, with sometimes penury acting as a spur to action, with necessity becoming the mother of invention.

Of course, things can go desperately wrong.

Accidents will happen.

Folks get murdered, kidnapped, robbed.

You may get sick or lonely or fed up, have a demoralizing run of bad luck, fail to find a good job, begin to run out of money.

And, let me be honest, a job is a job is a job, whether it is in Switzerland or Swaziland, Canada or Costa Rica.

But when a job abroad does not work out successfully, the foreign experience is nevertheless more memorable than just staying at home.

Above: Travel agency poster, The Truman Show

Travelling is difficult at times.

Nothing much is familiar when we get to wherever we are going.

For many people, this is a strain.

Because they don’t understand everything that is happening, they try to diminish the experience, to make it unimportant and less real.

In my writing I try to show the reader how to accept, as calmly as possible, the sights and experiences of a strange place.

I try to make the foreign feel more familiar.

Part of that familiarization is the acceptance that life is not always fair, that experience will not always be positive or cheery.

Guidebooks tend to stress fun and ignore problems, but this attitude is not necessarily helpful.

Warnings and precautions should make a trip easier and more enjoyable rather than nerve-wracking.

On Thursday 19 May, a banking holiday in Turkey when many institutions (including schools) were closed, “the boys” (the male staff of Wall Street English Eskisehir) went to a hammam (a Turkish bathhouse) but those who have never done so were nervous and reluctant about the entire adventure.

Above: Kaplicar Ilicar Hamam, Eskişehir, Turkey

(The Commemoration of Atatürk, Youth and Sports Day (Turkish: Atatürk’ü Anma, Gençlik ve Spor Bayramı), is an annual Turkish national holiday celebrated on 19 May to commemorate Mustafa Kemal Atatürk’s landing at Samsun on 19 May 1919, which is regarded as the beginning of the Turkish War of Independence in the official historiography.)

Above: Mustafa Kemal Atatürk (1881 – 1938)

I, on the other hand, wish I could have joined them, but duty determined that I had to, once again, travel on Thursdays to Denizli.

Above: Bird’s eye view of Denizli, Turkey

I reminded the hammam newbies that when you feel nervous while travelling – for it is the foreigners, the “recent” residents of Turkey, who have yet to try much of what Turkey has to offer – either out of ignorance of what is happening or out of fear of what you have heard might happen, you cut yourself off from experience – good or bad.

Above: Flag of Turkey

You communicate in only one sense:

Defensively.

That is why tourists often speak to the locals in tones one would address a lamppost.

When you are relaxed you can communicate – a lesson my foreman Rasool frequently tries to teach me at work – even if it is just a quick smile or a passing greeting.

Above: Rasool Ajini

So, this is one of the main purposes of my writing:

To help travellers – And aren’t we all travellers in one way or another? – be both aware and appreciative of what they see and experience, to lessen the impact, not only on the reader, but on the places and people they travel to see.

Wherever you happen to be geographically, travel actually takes place in your brain.

Wherever you go there you are.

But I think that far too many folks expect to find home teleported to the places they have travelled.

Unfortunately, the landscape reflects this expectation as it seems to be continually transformed into the familiarity of the place you left behind upon the place wherever you find yourself now.

Home is so sad.

It stays as it was left, shaped to the comfort of the last to go, as if to win them back.

Philip Larkin, “Home Is So Sad

Above: Philip Larkin (1922 – 1985)

I was lucky, I know, to have been setting out at that time, in a landscape not yet bulldozed for speed.

Many of the country roads still followed their original tracks, drawn by packhorse or lumbering cartwheel, hugging the curve of a valley or yielding to a promontory like the wandering line of a stream.

It was not, after all, so very long ago, but no one could make the journey today.

Many of the old roads have gone.

The motor car, since then, has begun to cut the landscape to pieces, through which the hunched-up traveller races at gutter height, seeing less than a dog in a ditch.

Laurie Lee, As I Walked Out One Midsummer Morning

Above: Laurie Lee (1914 – 1997)

Of course the world has been forced to concede even more ground in the search for greater speed and efficiency today.

Movement costs money and the faster the journey the quicker the expenditure.

The longer the stop, the longer the trip.

Faster the journey, lesser the experience.

The slower the journey, the greater sense of meaning the experience has.

Train traveller Paul Theroux spoke of the misery of air travel:

You define a good flight by negatives:

You didn’t get hijacked, you didn’t crash, you didn’t throw up, you were not late, you were not nauseated by the food.

So you are grateful.

Paul Theroux, The Old Patagonian Express

An uncomfortable truth about the modern holiday is that now, paradoxically, we can move so quickly around the world, most of us don’t actually travel any more.

We only arrive.

For some people, much of the enjoyment of a trip is in the advance planning.

They haunt libraries, bookstores and the Internet, send off for brochures and itineraries, draw lines and “X”s on maps and consult calendars for a propitious departure date.

Nothing is left to the imagination.

Everything that could be conceivably be attractive has been packaged and sanitized for your protection so that you can consume whatever you want, go wherever you want, without any need for individual search or discovery.

Personal interests and energy levels are very important, but many travellers fail to take these factors into account, however, and instead force themselves into the type of trip they assume they should be making.

Frantic frenzy, fumbling from church to ruin, cathedral-gazing and temple-crawling, leaves even the mighty weak.

I am my selfie, my companion my camera, plastic electronics grafted to faces capturing faces, a part of the landscape and yet apart from it, we are overexposed and under-stimulated.

Souvenirs of the surreal, not knowing where we are nor really caring to know.

Photographs are not memories.

The most important parts of any trip – how you felt and what you learned – collect in your mind over time.

If it was truly important, you will remember it.

You may not understand why the thing you remember is valuable when it seemed less crucial at the time, but that realization comes only with time.

All the things you can see in your mind, the experiences you are so rapturously seeking to reveal cannot, can never be, captured in a snapshot, or vicariously shared in a video.

Photographs break the spell of imagination.

Snapshots lack magic.

Videos fail to capture the vibrancy of experience.

Midnight, not a sound from the pavement
Has the moon lost her memory?
She is smiling alone
In the lamplight, the withered leaves collect at my feet
And the wind begins to moan

Memory, all alone in the moonlight
I can dream of the old days
Life was beautiful then
I remember the time I knew what happiness was
Let the memory live again

Every street lamp seems to beat
A fatalistic warning
Someone mutters and the street lamp sputters
And soon it will be morning

Daylight, I must wait for the sunrise
I must think of a new life
And I mustn’t give in
When the dawn comes, tonight will be a memory too
And a new day will begin

Burnt out ends of smoky days
The stale, cold smell of morning
A street lamp dies, another night is over
Another day is dawning

Touch me, it’s so easy to leave me
All alone with the memory
Of my days in the sun
If you touch me, you’ll understand what happiness is
Look, a new day has begun

Above: Logo of the musical Cats

We have forgotten the thrill of living in the moment, which is the real destination of all journeys, is what the greatest travel writers reveal and revel in their meticulous descriptions of the places they go and the people they meet.

It is only when you learn of the existence of moments that have the capacity to change your life forever do you begin to understand the beauty and majesty of existence, that the meaning of life is in the living of life.

When we seize the moment and embrace the fleeting opportunity it brings then do we truly live.

To truly travel is to slowly pick at the fabric of national identity as boundaries between nations are revealed as the transitional ideas they are.

There is a tendency to view the world in terms of miles/kilometres rather than actual geography, for actual geography has been been terraformed into miles of roads jammed with traffic.

A few hundred years ago there was no option but to travel slowly along the contours and channels of the earth and sea.

Indeed, that was the very definition of travel.

The effort required in those days meant that those who did go on long journeys came back as heroes, viewed by their home-locked peers as superior men and women.

Above: Spirit of St. Louis, National Air and Space Museum, Washington DC.
The Spirit of St. Louis is the custom-built single engine, single seat monoplane that was flown solo by Charles Lindbergh (1902 – 1974) on 20 – 21 May 1927, on the first non-stop flight from New York to Paris.

In 1749, Thomas Nugent, who wrote a guidebook of destinations one might seek on a Grand Tour, describes travel as:

The only means of improving the understanding and of acquiring a high degree of reputation.

The first civilized nations honoured even such as made but short voyages the title of philosophers and conquerors.

Nugent traces the lineage of those who head abroad to seek knowledge back to the Argonauts and Odysseus in Homer’s Odyssey.

I am not sure anyone would draw such a grandiose comparison with the average holidaymaker today.

Above: Thomas Nugent (1700 – 1772)

We have become a world of people speeding across the planet in quest of somewhere else and not seeing anything of anywhere we speed through.

Time is limited, we cry, and so we travel great distances at a marathon pace in order to see as much as possible.

Why is everyone in such a rush?

Above: Cover of U2’s “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For

We are a disconcerting congregation of the damned, discouraged and exhausted and spaced-out from driving or riding thousands of miles in a few days with the sole thought of finding a hotel room that offers the comforts of the home we so eagerly abandoned for a taste of the “exotic” somewhere else.

The most lasting impression instead is smelly gas stations, lousy breakfasts with cold coffee, hotel lobbies and ragged folks trying to shine your shoes whenever the weary traveller unwisely slumps down upon a park bench in an urban jungle.

Cover as many miles as you can between dawn and collapse.

Travel so fast that today might still be yesterday in the half-remembered remnants of the elusive moment.

See as much as you can see and remember little, if anything, of what you saw.

The speed at which you travel defines the experience.

A road is a tunnel that traps you in linear places, linear concepts and conceptions, linear time, an unwelcome refugee in Flatland.

The road provides ease and convenience, but cheats you of everything you might learn if only you had the time, courage and curiosity to leave it.

Walking is a virtue, tourism is a deadly sin.

Bruce Chatwin, What Am I Doing Here?

Above: Bruce Chatwin (1940 – 1989)

All horsepower corrupts.

Patrick Leigh Fermor, A Time of Gifts

Above: Patrick Leigh Fermor (1915 – 2011)

Perhaps we do not need to travel far.

Perhaps the beauty of treating your own home with a sense of adventure, forearmed with the local knowledge others normally don’t have time to acquire, may teach us to notice, may teach us to reflect upon Life itself and the life and lives that surround us.

Perhaps then our lives might be enriched.

Perhaps then we might finally see the world and the way we live in life-enhancing ways.

Life is too short and too precious for us to pass through it without leaving a few footprints behind us, without acquiring a few memories worth remembering.

A man’s experience in a certain place at a certain time must be unique, in some way different from the experience of others.

We need to leave a mark of the choices we make (or don’t make) that map our lives into the journeys they become.

These milestones, these footprints, are the actions we make in the moment, the ones that change our loves and our lives forever.

Henry David Thoreau wrote in the conclusion of Walden (his treatise on the succour to be found in a simple rural life away from the world of busy men):

If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer.

Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away.

Above: Henry David Thoreau (1817 – 1862)

Nevertheless, the question remains:

Why did you leave?

For ultimately you cannot escape yourself.

Wherever you go there you are.

When I was young, it seemed that life was so wonderful
A miracle, oh it was beautiful, magical
And all the birds in the trees, well they’d be singing so happily
Oh joyfully, playfully watching me
But then they send me away to teach me how to be sensible
Logical, oh responsible, practical
And they showed me a world where I could be so dependable
Oh clinical, oh intellectual, cynical

There are times when all the world’s asleep
The questions run too deep
For such a simple man
Won’t you please, please tell me what we’ve learned
I know it sounds absurd

Please tell me who I am

I said, watch what you say or they’ll be calling you a radical
Liberal, oh fanatical, criminal
Won’t you sign up your name, we’d like to feel you’re acceptable
Respectable, oh presentable, a vegetable
Oh, take it take it yeah

But at night, when all the world’s asleep
The questions run so deep
For such a simple man
Won’t you please tell me what we’ve learned
I know it sounds absurd
Please tell me who I am, who I am, who I am, who I am
‘Cause I was feeling so logical
D-d-digital
One, two, three, five
Oh, oh, oh, oh
It’s getting unbelievable

There’s a little black spot on the sun today
It’s the same old thing as yesterday
There’s a black hat caught in a high tree top
There’s a flag pole rag and the wind won’t stop
I have stood here before inside the pouring rain
With the world turning circles running ’round my brain
I guess I’m always hoping that you’ll end this reign
But it’s my destiny to be the king of pain

The Police musician Sting (Gordon Sumner) married actress Frances Tomelty on 1 May 1976.

They had two children: Joseph (born 23 November 1976) and Fuschia Katherine (“Kate“) (born 17 April 1982).

In 1980, Sting became a tax exile in Galway, Ireland.

Above: Sting

Galway (Irish: Gaillimh) is the county town of County Galway on the west coast of Ireland.

It is Ireland’s 4th largest city, with a population in 2016 of 79,934, but its historic centre on the east bank of the River Corrib is compact and colourful.

It is a party town, with live music and revellers spilling onto its pedestrianised central street.

It is also a base for exploring the scenic surrounding county.

It is a lively, buzzing colourful city that feels well-connected to the rest of the world.

Above: Images of Galway, Ireland

Eyre Square is the place to begin exploring the city, as it is the transport hub and with a cluster of hotels and eating places.

It is an attractive green space, with a pedestrianised shopping mall just south.

Artwork includes the “Galway Hooker” (a fountain styled like a traditional fishing boat), the Browne Doorway (from the house of one of the ruling families), and a bust of JF Kennedy who visited in 1963.

Above: Galway Hookers Fountain and Browne Doorway, Eyre Square, Galway, Ireland

The square is officially named after JFK but this never stuck.

Above: John F. Kennedy (1917 – 1963)

It has always been called Eyre Square after the mayor who presented this plot of land to the city in 1710.

And, may the saints preserve us, so shall it ever be.

Above: Eyre Square, Galway, Ireland

The historic spine of the city leads from Eyre Square southwest to the river, to William Street, then Shop Street, then High Street, then Quay Street, all pedestrianised, an agreeable stroll from park to pub to pub to eating place to pub.

At the top of Shop Street, Lynch’s Castle is a fine medieval town house, once home to the Lynch dynasty.

But nowadays it is a branch of Allied Irish Banks:

You are welcome to look in during opening hours, but there is not much to see.

Above: Lynch’s Castle, Galway, Ireland

The Claddagh Ring is a style of mani in fede finger ring:

Two hands join to clasp a heart.

It has been a design for wedding or engagement rings since medieval times, but it became a Galway tradition from 1700, when the jewellers worked near an Cladach, the city shore.

It became popular from the late 20th century, and legends were embellished around it as ingeniously as its designs.

Above: A Claddagh ring

The Claddagh Museum hews to the “Joyce” legend, after a man captured by Algerian corsairs who learned the design in captivity.

Above: Claddagh Museum, Galway, Ireland

He returned to Galway where of course his sweetheart had remained true.

Ah, love.

The heart is often surmounted by a crown, or isn’t, depending on your allegiances in that matter. 

Free is the museum.

(No, not the rings though).

Above: View of the Claddagh, Galway, Ireland

It is a collegiate church which doesn’t have a resident priest, but members of a seminary (a College of Vicars) take turns.

St Nicholas is the largest medieval church still in everyday use in Ireland.

It was founded in 1320 and enlarged over the following two centuries.

Above: St. Nicholas Collegiate Church, Galway, Ireland

It is dedicated to St Nicholas of Myra (modern Demre, Turkey) (circa 300 AD), patron saint of seafarers, and the story of Columbus worshipping here is credible.

Above: Nicholas of Myra (270 – 343)

Above: Photograph of the desecrated sarcophagus in the St. Nicholas Church, Demre, Turkey, where his bones were kept before they were removed and taken to Bari (Italy) in 1087

Above: Myra Rock Tombs, Demre, Turkey

Above: Christopher Columbus (1451 – 1506)

There are large tombs of the Lynch family, and a plaque at the Lynch memorial window claims to be the spot where 15th century mayor James hanged his own son Walter for killing a Spanish visitor, or so goes the tale.

Above: Lynch Memorial Window, St. Nicholas Collegiate Church, Galway, Ireland

In 2002 St Nick’s conducted the first blessing of a same-sex partnership (the Avowing Friendship Service for a lesbian couple) in an Irish church, but the Bishop prohibited any such unbiblical goings-on in future.

Above: LGBT rainbow flag

Although the church is Protestant (which it obviously wasn’t in Columbus’ day), in 2005 it was used by an RC congregation while their own St Augustine Church was refurbished.

It is also used for worship by the Romanian, Russian Orthodox and the Mar Thoma Syrian congregations.

When in Rome, as they say…..

It is X o’clock, what faith shall we follow now?

Above: Interior of St. Nicholas Collegiate Church, Galway, Ireland

The Hall of the Red Earl is the earliest medieval structure to be seen within the walls of the city.

It was built by the de Burgo family in the 13th century and was the main municipal building, acting as town hall, court house and tax collection office.

Above: Hall of the Red Earl as it once appeared

But a fragment is all that remains, protected behind glass, and it won’t take a minute to see.

The modern building adjoining is the base of Galway Civic Trust, and their guided walks through the city start here. 

Free.

Above: Ruins of the Hall of the Red Earl, Galway, Ireland

Medieval Galway had city walls, which, in 1584, were extended to protect the quays at the river outlet.

This extension, the Spanish Arch, known as “the head of the walls” (ceann an bhalla), is nowadays almost the only remnant of those walls.

In the 18th century the quays were extended, and two arches were cut in the walls to improve street access to the quays.

They were probably originally known as the “Eyre Arches“, but Galway was Ireland’s main port for trade with Spain and Portugal.

In 1755, the Lisbon Tsunami wrecked the arches, but one was later reopened, so they became known as the Spanish Arch and the Blind Arch.

It is a pleasant area to sit or stroll.

Above: Spanish Arch, Galway, Ireland

On the west bank of the River Corrib as it enters the sea is the ancient neighbourhood of The Claddagh.

For centuries it was an Irish-speaking enclave outside the city walls.

Claddagh residents were mainly fisher folk and were governed by an elected ‘King‘.

The King of the Claddagh settled or arbitrated disputes among the locals and had the privilege of a white sail on his fishing boat.

The last true king, Martin Oliver, died in 1972.

The title is still used but in a purely honorary and ceremonial context.

The current King is Michael Lynskey.

God save the King.

Long may he reign.

Above: Claddagh, Galway, Ireland

The Galway City Museum has three floors of galleries with seven long-term exhibitions on Galway’s archaeology, history and links to the sea.

Two halls have rotating exhibitions. 

The Museum has two main sections: one about the heritage of Galway and one about Irish artists from the second half of the 20th century.

Above: Galway City Museum

This Museum also houses the statue of the poet, Pádraic Ó Conaire, which was originally located in the Kennedy Park section of Eyre Square, prior to the Square’s renovation.

Free.

Above: Pádraic Ó Conaire (1882 – 1928)

Nora Barnacle (1884 – 1951) grew up in Galway and came to live here with her mother who had separated from Nora’s drunkard father.

Nora’s boyfriends had a habit of dying, so she left for Dublin where in 1904 she met James Joyce, and “knew him at once for just another Dublin jackeen chatting up a country girl“.

Soon she would have cause to bemoan his drinking, hanging about with artistic ne’er-do-wells, spendthrift ways, obscure nonsensical writing style, and his demands for English puddings.

Above: James Joyce family, Paris, 1924
Clockwise from top left –
James Joyce, Giorgio Joyce (1890 – 1976), Nora Barnacle, Lucia Joyce (1907 – 1982)

They lived mostly in Trieste and Paris then Zürich, where James died and Nora lived out her own final years.

Above: Statue of James Joyce (1882 – 1941), Trieste, Italy

Above: Plaque at rue de l’Odeon 12, Paris, France
In 1922, at this location, Mlle. Sylvia Beach published Ulysses by James Joyce

Above: James Joyce grave, Fluntern Cemetery, Zürich, Switzerland

Her house in Galway was a small museum – indeed, the smallest museum in all of Ireland – of Joyce memorabilia (including letters, but not the hotties), but was closed in 2020.

Above: Nora Barnacle House, Galway, Ireland

Above: Nora Barnacle House, Galway, Ireland

Galway Cathedral is Roman Catholic cathedral, built 1958-1965, on the site of an old prison.

It is an imposing limestone building in a mixture of retro-classical styles, which some detest.

The dome, pillars and round arches are Renaissance, while a Romanesque portico dominates the main façade.

Michael Browne (Bishop 1937-1976) published an account of the preparation, design, building work and layout.

The organ was re-conditioned in 2007 and recitals show off the acoustics.

There are regular masses, with one Sunday mass in Gaelic.

Above: Galway Cathedral, Galway, Ireland

The River Corrib flows for 6 km south from Lough Corrib to enter Galway Bay.

In 1178 the friars of Claire Galway cut a new channel out of the lough, east of the original outflow, and this became the main course of the river.

It passes the ruin of Menlo Castle to reach the northwest edge of the city at a salmon weir:

Watch them swim upriver in early summer.

The last kilometre of the river is very fast, great for driving waterwheels but not navigable, so the Eglinton Canal was cut in the 19th century, with swing bridges, locks, and side-races for mills.

The swing bridges have been replaced by fixed bridges so the Canal is no longer navigable except by kayak.

Above: Salmon Weir Bridge, Corrib River, Galway, Ireland

University Quad was the original quadrangle of the college that opened in 1849 and became one of the three colleges of Queens University of Ireland (the others being Belfast and Cork).

Since 1997, it has been known as the National University of Ireland Galway.

The Quad buildings are in mock Tudor Gothic style modelled on Oxford’s Christ Church, so their aspirations are clear.

They are nowadays the admin offices of a huge modern campus stretching from the river and canal to Newcastle Road, then continuing west of that as University Hospital. 

Free.

Above: Coat of arms of the Queen’s University of Ireland

The Promenade is the main shoreline attraction, stretching for 2 km into Salthill.

Traditionally you turned around once you had kicked the wall at the two-level diving platform at the junction of Threadneedle Road.

Lots of pubs and B&Bs along here.

It has long been hoped to extend the promenade west to Silverstrand, and to reinforce the crumbling coast against sea erosion.

By 2015, this plan had reached design stage, but with no prospect of the funding that would enable it to go to tender, and it has all gone very quiet since then.

So you can pick your own way along the headland west of Salthill but there is no paved promenade.

Above: The Promenade, Galway, Ireland

Galway Atlantaquaria is a large aquarium that majors on local marine life, so you will see sharks.

But they are Irish sharks and proud of it.

Staff display the various beasties:

Care to cuddle a huge crab? 

Mutton Island is connected to the mainland at Claddagh by a one-kilometre causeway.

(Don’t confuse it with Mutton Island off Quilty in County Clare.)

It is popular for wedding photos taking in the lighthouse foreground and cityscape background, while artfully avoiding the sewage plant.

Above: Mutton Island, Galway, Ireland

Fort Hill Cemetery, on Lough Atalia Road, is the oldest cemetery still in use in Galway City.

Inside the main gate is a memorial to sailors of the Spanish Armada who were buried here in the 1580s.

Above: Forthill, Galway, Ireland

Above: Spanish Armada sailors memorial

Above: English ships and the Spanish Armada

Rahoon Cemetery (officially known as Mount St. Joseph Cemetery), Rahoon Road, on the western edge of the city affords splendid panoramic views of the city.

Above: Rahoon Cemetery, Galway, Ireland

Among the people buried here are: 

  • Michael Bodkin (an admirer of Nora Barnacle who was the inspiration for James Joyce’s character, “Michael Furey” in The Dead

Above: Grave of Michael Bodkin

  • Michael Feeney (the “lover” in Joyce’s poem She Weeps Over Rahoon)

  • actress Siobhán McKenna 

Above: Siobhán McKenna (1922 – 1986)

Bohermore Cemetery (or the New Cemetery, as it is more popularly known), Cemetery Cross, Bohermore, was opened in 1880.

Above: Bohermore Cemetery, Galway, Ireland

It contains two mortuary chapels and is the burial place of several important Galwegians, including: 

  • Pádraic Ó Conaire, the Gaelic author 

  • William Joyce, more widely known as Lord Haw-Haw the Nazi propagandist 

Above: William Joyce (1906 – 1946)

  • Augusta, Lady Gregory, co-founder of the Abbey Theatre in Dublin

Above: Lady Augusta Gregory (1852 – 1932)

Above: Abbey Theatre, Dublin, Ireland

  • Michael Morris, 3rd Baron Killanin, a senior member of one of the Tribes of Galway and former world president of the International Olympic Committee

Above: Lord Killanin (1914 – 1999)

  • A memorial to the 91 people who died on 14 August 1959, when Dutch KLM Flight 607-E crashed into the sea 180 km (112 mi) west of Galway, can be seen just inside the main gates. Several bodies of the passengers are buried around the memorial.

Galway is known as Ireland’s Cultural Heart (Croí Cultúrtha na hÉireann) and hosts numerous festivals, celebrations and events.

Every November, Galway hosts the Tulca Festival of Visual Arts, as well as numerous festivals.

On 1 December 2014, the Director General of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) announced the official designation of Galway as a UNESCO City of Film.

In 2004, there were three dance organisations, ten festival companies, two film organisations, two Irish language organisations, 23 musical organisations, twelve theatre companies, two visual arts groups, and four writers’ groups based in the city.

Furthermore, there were 51 venues for events, most of which were specialised for a certain field (e.g. concert venues or visual arts galleries), though ten were described as being ‘multiple event‘ venues.

In 2007, Galway was named as one of the eight sexiest cities in the world.

Above: Galway, Ireland

A 2008 poll ranked Galway as the 42nd best tourist destination in the world, or 14th in Europe and 2nd in Ireland (behind Dingle).

Above: Strand Street, Dingle, Ireland

It was ranked ahead of all European capitals except Edinburgh, and many traditional tourist destinations (such as Venice).

Above: Edinburgh, Scotland

Above: Images of Venice, Italy

The New Zealand Herald listed Galway as one of ‘five great cities to visit in 2014‘.

Galway has a vibrant and varied musical scene. 

Galway and its people are mentioned in several songs, including Ed Sheeran’s Galway Girl (2017).

Above: Cover art, Galway Girl, Ed Sheeran

Many sporting, music, arts and other events take place in the city.

Galway has a diverse sporting heritage, with a history in sports ranging from horse racing, Gaelic games, soccer and rugby to rowing, basketball, motorsport, greyhound racing and others.)

Above: Galway Races

Above: Galway hurling

Above: Galway United Football Club badge

Why can’t a man and his family live here forever in a state of perpetual happiness?

(A tax exile is a person who leaves a country to avoid the payment of income tax or other taxes.

It is a person who already owes money to the tax authorities or wishes to avoid being liable in the future to taxation at what they consider high tax rates, instead choosing to reside in a foreign country or jurisdiction which has no taxes or lower tax rates.

In general, there is no extradition agreement between countries which covers extradition for outstanding tax liabilities.

Going into tax exile is a form of tax mitigation or avoidance.

A tax exile normally cannot return to their home country without being subject to outstanding tax liabilities, which may prevent them from leaving the country until they have been paid.

Most countries tax individuals who are resident in their jurisdiction.

Though residency rules vary, most commonly individuals are resident in a country for taxation purposes if they spend at least six months (or some other period) in any one tax year in the country, and/or have an abiding attachment to the country, such as owning a fixed property.)

Switzerland has seen its share of tax exiles from other lands.

Above: Coat of arms of Switzerland

Noel Coward left the UK for tax reasons in the 1950s, receiving harsh criticism in the press. 

He first settled in Bermuda but later bought houses in Jamaica and Switzerland (in the village of Les Avants, near Montreux), which remained his homes for the rest of his life.

Above: Noel Coward (1899 – 1973)

David Bowie moved from the United Kingdom to Switzerland in 1976, first settling in Blonay and then Lausanne in 1982.

Above: David Bowie (1947 – 2016)

Roger Moore became a tax exile from the United Kingdom in 1978, originally to Switzerland, and divided his year between his three homes: an apartment in Monte Carlo, Monaco, a chalet in Crans-Montana, Switzerland and a home in the south of France.

Above: Roger Moore (1927 – 2017)

In April 2009, the Sunday Times Rich List estimated Sting‘s wealth at £175 million and ranked him the 322nd wealthiest person in Britain.

A decade later, Sting was estimated to have a fortune of £320 million in the 2019 Sunday Times Rich List, making him one of the ten wealthiest people in the British music industry.

In 1982, after the birth of his second child, Sting separated from Tomelty.

Above: Wedding of Sting and Frances Tomelty

Above: Trudie Styler and Sting

The split was controversial.

As The Independent reported in 2006:

Tomelty just happened to be Trudie’s best friend.

Sting and Frances lived next door to Trudie in Bayswater, West London, for several years before the two of them became lovers.

When you take the Tube in London you get from A to B very quickly.

It is undoubtedly efficient and much more practical when it comes to getting to and from work, but it is utterly hopeless when it comes to developing a sense of the place.

This is why London is so daunting for tourists, for the Tube leaves the tourist with mere snippets of memories of disparate places that have no obvious link.

London is a mish-mash of postcard pictures, each surrounded by…..

Nothing at all.

Above: Map of the London Underground

Above: The nickname “Tube” comes from the almost circular tube-like tunnels through which the small profile trains travel.

Above: London, England

The multiplication of technologies in the name of efficiency is actually eradicating free time by making it possible to maximize the time and place for production and minimize the unstructured time in between.

New timesaving technologies make most workers more productive, not more free, in a world that seems to be accelerating around them.

Too, the rhetoric of efficiency around these technologies suggests that what cannot be quantified cannot be valued – that that vast array of pleasures which fall into the category of doing nothing in particular, of woolgathering, cloud-gazing, wandering, window-shopping, are nothing but voids to be filled by something more definite, more productive, or faster-paced….

The indeterminacy of a ramble, on which much may be discovered, is being replaced by the determinate shortest distance to be traversed with all possible speed, as well as by the electronic transmissions that make real travel less necessary….

Technology has its uses, but I fear its false urgency, its call to speed, its insistence that travel is less important than arrival.

I like walking because it is slow and I suspect that the mind, like the feet, works at about three miles an hour.

If this is so, then modern life is moving faster than the speed of thought, or thoughtfulness.

Walking is about being outside, in public space, and public space is also being abandoned and eroded in older cities, eclipsed by technologies and services that don’t require leaving home, and shadowed by fear in many places (and strange places are always more frightening than known ones, so the less one wanders the city the more alarming it becomes, while the fewer the wanderers the more lonely and dangerous it really becomes).

Rebecca Solnit, Wanderlust: A History of Walking

The news, with its stories of crime-ridden chaos, leave the London of the brain flitting between terror and tourist cliché.

All its magic and history seems lost.

But take the time to walk around London, through all its parks, and you will begin to piece together the way one part of London ends and another begins.

Get lost and let serendipity show you forgotten corners and shadowy streets that are the London between Tube stations.

You might even pick up a sense of the contours that cities do a good job of hiding.

Maps are of little practical use without a landscape and a sense of place.

The slower the journey, the greater sense of meaning, the more meaningful the experience.

Historic, sprawling, sleepless London can be a wonderful place to visit, a wonderful place to live.

Monuments from the English capital’s glorious past are everywhere, from medieval banqueting halls to the great churches of Christopher Wren.

Above: Christopher Wren (1632 – 1723)

Above: St. Paul’s Cathedral, London, England

The modern skyline is dominated by a new generation of eye-grabbing, cloud-scratching, skyscrapers, colossal companions of Ferris wheels and giant walkie talkies.

Above: London Eye

Whether you spend your time relaxing in Bloomsbury’s quiet Georgian squares, drinking real ale in a Docklands riverside pub or checking out Peckham’s galleries, you can discover a London that is still identifiably a collection of villages, each with a distinct personality.

London is incredibly diverse, offering cultural and culinary delights from all around the world.

Above: Bloomsbury Square, London, England

Above: Docklands, London, England

Above: Peckham, London, England

Certainly, London is big.

In fact, it once was the largest capital city in the European Union (pre-Brexit), stretching for more than 30 miles from east to west, with a population fast approaching 9 million.

Above: Flag of the European Union

Above: Brexit flag

London’s traditional landmarks – Big Ben, Westminster Abbey, Buckingham Palace, St. Paul’s Cathedral, the Tower of London, and the like – continue to draw in millions of tourists every year.

Things change fast, though, and the regular emergence of new attractions ensures that there is plenty (too much) to do even for those who have visited before.

Above: Clock Tower, Westminster Palace, London, England

Above: Aerial view of Buckingham Palace, London, England

Above: St. Paul’s Cathedral during the Blitz, 29 December 1940

Above: Aerial view of the Tower of London

London’s museums, galleries and institutions are constantly reinventing themselves, from the V & A (Victoria and Albert) to the British Museum.

Above: Victoria and Albert Museum entrance, London, England

Above: Aerial view of the British Museum, London, England

The City boasts the Tate Modern (the world’s largest modern art museum) and the Shard (Europe’s highest building).

Above: Tate Modern, London, England

Above: The Shard, London, England

But the biggest problem for newcomers remains:

London is bewilderingly amorphous.

Local Londoners cope with this by compartmentalizing the City (and themselves), identifying strongly with the neighbourhoods in which they work and/or live, only making occasional forays outside of their comfort zones when shopping or entertainment beckons.

Above: Tower Bridge, London, England

The solution to discovering a place for what it truly is may be found by simply wandering.

In a city, every building, every storefront, opens onto a different world, compressing all the variety of human life into a jumble of possibilities made rich by all its complexities and contradictions.

The ordinary offers wonder and the people on the street are a multitude of glimpses into lives utterly different from your own.

Cities offer anonymity, variety and conjunction, qualities best basked in by walking.

A city is greater than its parts and contains more than any inhabitant will ever possibly know.

A great city makes the unknown possible and spurs the imagination.

Above: London, England

There are fewer greater delights than to walk up and down them in the evening alone with thousands of other people, up and down, relishing the lights coming through the trees or shining from the facades, listening to the sounds of music and foreign voices and traffic, enjoying the smell of flowers and good food and the air from the nearby sea.

The sidewalks are lined with small shops, bars, stalls, dance halls, movies, booths lighted by acetylene lamps.

And everywhere are strange faces, strange costumes, strange and delightful impressions.

To walk up such a street into the quieter, more formal part of town, is to be part of a procession, part of a ceaseless ceremony of being initiated into the city and rededicating the city itself.

J.B. Jackson, The Stranger’s Path

Above: John Brinckerhoff Jackson (1909 – 1996)

People and places become one another and this kind of realism can only be gained by walking.

Above: Tramway, Eskişehir, Turkey

Allow me to introduce myself – first negatively.

No landlord is my friend and brother, no chambermaid loves me, no waiter worships me, no boots admires and envies me.

No round of beef or tongue or ham is expressly cooked for me, no pigeon pie is especially made for me, no hotel-advertisement is personally addressed to me, no hotel room tapestried with great coats and railway wrappers is set apart for me, no house of public entertainment in the United Kingdom greatly cares for my opinion of its brandy or sherry.

When I go upon my journeys, I am not usually rated at a low figure in the bill.

When I come home from my journeys, I never get any commission.

I know nothing about prices, and should have no idea, if I were put to it, how to wheedle a man into ordering something he doesn’t want.

As a town traveller, I am never to be seen driving a vehicle externally like a young and volatile pianoforte van, and internally like an oven in which a number of flat boxes are baking in layers.

As a country traveller, I am rarely to be found in a gig, and am never to be encountered by a pleasure train, waiting on the platform of a branch station, quite a Druid in the midst of a light Stonehenge of samples.

And yet – proceeding now, to introduce myself positively – I am both a town traveller and a country traveller, and am always on the road.

Figuratively speaking, I travel for the great house of Human Interest Brothers, and have rather a large connection in the fancy goods way.

Literally speaking, I am always wandering here and there from my rooms in Covent Garden, London – now about the city streets: now, about the country by-roads – seeing many little things, and some great things, which, because they interest me, I think may interest others.

These are my chief credentials as the Uncommercial Traveller.”

There is a subtle state most dedicated urban walkers know, a sort of basking in solitude – a dark solitude punctuated with encounters as the night sky is punctuated with stars.

In the country, one’s solitude is geographical – one is altogether outside society, so solitude has a sensible geographical explanation and there is a kind of communion with the nonhuman.

In the city, one is alone because the world is made up of strangers.

To be a stranger surrounded by strangers, to walk along silently bearing one’s secrets and imagining those of the people one passes, is among the starkest of luxuries.

The uncharted identity with its illimitable possibilities is one of the distinctive qualities of urban living, a liberatory state for those who come to emancipate themselves from family and community expectation, to experiment with subculture and identity.

It is an observer’s state, cool, withdrawn, with senses sharpened, a good state for anybody who needs to reflect and create.

In small doses, melancholy, alienation and introspection are among life’s most refined pleasures.

Rebecca Solnit, Wanderlust: A History of Walking

It was Dr Samuel Johnson, the man many thank for our modern dictionary, who wrote in the 18th century:

You find no man, at all intellectual, who is willing to leave London.

Sir, when a man is tired of London, he is tired of life.

For there is in London all that life can afford.

Above: Samuel Johnson (1709 – 1784)

Above: Dr. Johnson’s House, London, England

Why can’t a man and his family live here forever in a state of perpetual happiness?

There’s a little black spot on the sun today, that’s my soul up there
It’s the same old thing as yesterday, that’s my soul up there
There’s a black hat caught in a high tree top, that’s my soul up there
There’s a flag pole rag and the wind won’t stop, that’s my soul up there
I have stood here before inside the pouring rain
With the world turning circles running ’round my brain
I guess I’m always hoping that you’ll end this reign
But it’s my destiny to be the king of pain

Actually, it was something I said.

I’d just left my first wife – a very painful break – and I went to Jamaica to try and pull myself together.

I was fortunate to be able to go to Jamaica, I have to say, and stayed at this nice house and was looking at the sun one day.

I was with Trudie, who is now my current wife, and said:

“Look, there’s a little black spot on the sun today.”

And there’s a pause.

I said:

“That’s my soul up there.”

I was full of hyperbole.

I said that.

I went back in and wrote it down.

Above: Flag of Jamaica

Jamaica is the Caribbean country that comes with its own soundtrack, a singular rhythm beyond its beaches and resorts.

This tiny island has musical roots that reach back to the folk songs of West Africa and forward to the electronic beats of contemporary dance.

Jamaica is a musical powerhouse, which is reflected not only in the bass of the omnipresent sound systems that bombard the island, but in the lyricism of the patois language and the gospel harmonies that rise from the nation’s many churches.

Music is life and life is music in Jamaica.

And only those tone deaf to the rhythm of life fail to be swayed by its beat.

Jamaica is a powerfully beautiful island, a land of crystalline waters flowing over gardens of coral, lapping onto soft sandy beaches, rising past red soil and lush banana groves into sheer mountains.

Waterfalls surprise, appearing out of nowhere, ever present seemingly everywhere.

Jamaica is a great green garden of a land.

Understand the island’s cyclical rhythms that set the pace of Jamaican life and you may then begin to understand Jamaican culture.

You may discover that the country has a rhythm filled with concepts hidden from your understanding, but Jamaica will teach your heart to dance to its pace.

Nature is a language and Jamaica is one of its dialects.

Understanding its language we begin to experience Jamaica.

Climb the peak of Blue Mountain by sunrise, your path lit by the sparks of a myriad of fireflies.

Above: Blue Mountain, Jamaica

Attending a nightclub or a street dance, Kingston nightlife is a sweaty, lively, no-holds-barred event.

Dance, bump and grind, o ye young and young at heart.

Dance till dawn, doze till dusk, do it all again.

Above: Kingston, Jamaica night

Walk the snowy sands of Negril’s Seven Mile Beach.

Wander past the nude sunbathers.

See the sun sink behind the horizon in a fiery ball.

Plunge into the ocean to scrub your soul.

Fend off the hustlers offering redemption.

Dive into the cerulean waters that caress the cliffs.

Above: Negril, Jamaica

Get into reggae, cowboy.

On Jamaica’s east coast, past stretches of jungle and beach that is completely off the radar of most tourists, look to the hills for one of the island’s most beautiful cascades, Reach Falls.

Clamber up slippery rocks, over neon green moss and into cool mountain pools of the freshest spring water.

Dive under tunnels and through blizzards of snow white cascading foam.

Celebrate life.

Above: Reach Falls, Portland, Jamaica

Remember Marley in Bob’s creaky Kingston home crammed with memorabilia.

Above: Bob Marley (1945 – 1981)

These will not move you.

Above: Bob Marley statue, Kingston, Jamaica

Above: Bob Marley House, Kingston, Jamaica

Instead you will be drawn to his untouched bedroom adorned with objects of spiritual significance to the artist, to the small kitchen where he cooked, to the hammock in which he lay to seek inspiration from the distant mountains, to the room riddled with bullet holes where he and his wife almost died in an assassination attempt.

The quiet intimacy and the modest personal effects speak eloquently of Bob Marley’s turbulent life.

Above: Bedroom, Bob Marley House, Kingston, Jamaica

A treasure island needs a Treasure Beach.

Here, instead of huge all-inclusive resorts, you will find quiet, friendly guesthouses, artsy enclaves dreamed up by theatre set designers, Rasta retreats favoured by budget backpackers, and private villas that are some of the classiest, most elegant luxury residences in the country.

Above: Treasure Beach, Jamaica

The sleepy fishing village of Port Royal hints of past glories that made it the pirate capital of the Caribbean and once the “wickedest city on Earth“.

Above: Old Port Royal

Follow in the footsteps of pirate Sir Henry Morgan along the battlements of Fort Charles, still lined with cannons to repel invaders.

Above: Henry Morgan (1635 – 1688)

Above: Fort Charles, Port Royal, Jamaica

Become disoriented inside the Giddy House artillery store, a structure tipped at a jaunty angle.

Above: Giddy House, Port Royal, Jamaica

Admire the treasures in the Maritime Museum, rescued from the deep after 2/3 of the town sank beneath the waves in the monstrous 1692 earthquake.

Above: Port Royal, Jamaica

The resorts of Montego Bay are indeed crowded with people, but wait until you dive into the surrounding waters.

The waters are crowded, but not with bathers.

The sea is alive with a kaleidoscope of multicoloured fish and swaying sponges.

And yet despite all the tropical pastels and cool blue hues, this is a subdued seascape, a silent and delicate marine ecosystem.

Electricity for the eyes and a milestone of memory for those fortunate enough to have come here.

Above: Montego Bay, Jamaica

The best sea walls are to be found at the Point, while more advanced divers should explore the ominous (and gorgeous) Widow Makers Cave.

Above: Widowmakers Cave, Jamaica

Cockpit Country in the island’s interior is some of the most rugged terrain throughout the Caribbean, a series of jungle-clad round hills intersected by powerfully deep and sheer valleys.

Rain gathers in these mountains and water percolates through the rocks, creating an Emmental Swiss cheese of sinkholes and caves.

Above: Cockpit Country, Jamaica

Since most of the trails here are badly overgrown, the best way to appreciate the place is to hike the old Barbecue Bottom Road along its eastern edge or go spelunking in the Printed Circuit Cave.

Above: Barbecue Bottom Road, Cockpit Country, Jamaica

Above: Printed Circuit Cave, Jamaica

Set off by boat in the Black River Great Morass, gliding past spidery mangroves and trees breaded with Spanish moss, whilst white egrets flap overhead.

Local women sell bags of spicy “swimp” (shrimp) on the riverside as they point to a beautiful grinning crocodile cruising by.

Above: Black River Great Morass, Jamaica

The best experiences in Jamaica are extremely sensory affairs, but Boston Bay may be the only one that is more defined by smell than sight or sound.

It may be the birthplace of jerk, the spice rub that is Jamaica’s most famous contribution to the culinary arts.

Above: Jerk chicken

The turnoff to Boston Bay, a lovely beach, is lined with jerk stalls that produce smoked meats that redefine what heat and sweet can do as complementary gastronomic qualities.

Jerk is much like Jamaica:

Freaking amazing.

Above: Boston Bay Beach, Jamaica

Why can’t a man and his family live here forever in a state of perpetual happiness?

Above: Happy, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

There’s a fossil that’s trapped in a high cliff wall, that’s my soul up there
There’s a dead salmon frozen in a waterfall, that’s my soul up there
There’s a blue whale beached by a springtide’s ebb, that’s my soul up there
There’s a butterfly trapped in a spider’s web, that’s my soul up there
I have stood here before inside the pouring rain
With the world turning circles running ’round my brain
I guess I’m always hoping that you’ll end this reign
But it’s my destiny to be the king of pain

King of Pain” was released as the second single in the US and the fourth single in the UK, taken from the Police‘s 5th and final album, Synchronicity (1983).

The song was released after the eight-week appearance of “Every Breath You Take” on top of the charts. 

Sting‘s fascination with Carl Jung and, to a greater extent, Arthur Koestler inspired him to write the track.

There’s a king on a throne with his eyes torn out
There’s a blind man looking for a shadow of doubt
There’s a rich man sleeping on a golden bed
There’s a skeleton choking on a crust of bread

Carl Gustav Jung (1875 – 1961) was a Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who founded analytical psychology.

Above: Carl Jung

Jung’s work has been influential in the fields of psychiatry, anthropology, archaeology, literature, philosophy, psychology, and religious studies.

Jung worked as a research scientist at Zürich’s famous Burghölzli Hospital.

Above: Klinik Burghölzli, Zürich, Switzerland

During this time, he came to the attention of Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis.

The two men conducted a lengthy correspondence and collaborated, for a while, on a joint vision of human psychology.

Freud saw the younger Jung as the heir he had been seeking to take forward his “new science” of psychoanalysis and to this end secured his appointment as president of his newly founded International Psychoanalytical Association.

Above: Sigmund Freud (1856 – 1939)

Jung’s research and personal vision, however, made it impossible for him to follow his older colleague’s doctrine and a schism became inevitable.

This division was personally painful for Jung and resulted in the establishment of Jung’s analytical psychology as a comprehensive system separate from psychoanalysis.

Among the central concepts of analytical psychology is individuation — the lifelong psychological process of differentiation of the self out of each individual’s conscious and unconscious elements.

Jung considered it to be the main task of human development.

He created some of the best known psychological concepts, including synchronicity, archetypal phenomena, the collective unconscious, the psychological complex, extraversion and introversion.

Jung was also an artist, craftsman, builder and a prolific writer.

Many of his works were not published until after his death and some are still awaiting publication.

Above: Jung outside Burghölzli in 1910

I cannot say that I completely understand or agree with Jungian theory.

Take collective unconsciousness as an example.

According to Jung, whereas an individual’s personal unconscious is made up of thoughts and emotions which have, at some time, been experienced or held in mind, but which have been repressed or forgotten, in contrast, the collective unconscious is neither acquired by activities within an individual’s life, nor a container of things that are thoughts, memories or ideas which are capable of being conscious during one’s life.

The contents of it were never naturally “known” through physical or cognitive experience and then forgotten.

Above: Carl Jung’s Black Book

In more ways than one, these ideas are too deep for me.

According to Jung, the collective unconscious consists of universal heritable elements common to all humans, distinct from other species.

It encapsulates fields of evolutionary biology, history of civilization, ethnology, brain and nervous system development, and general psychological development.

Considering its composition in practical physiological and psychological terms, Jung wrote:

It consists of pre-existent forms, the archetypes, which can only become conscious secondarily and which give definite form to certain psychic contents.”

Jung wrote about causal factors in personal psychology, as stemming from, influenced by an abstraction of the impersonal physical layer, the common and universal physiology among all humans.

Where upon this point my response is at a Homer Simpson level of incomprehension and incredulity.

Above: Homer Simpson, The Simpsons

Jung considers that science would hardly deny the existence and basic nature of ‘instincts‘, existing as a whole set of motivating urges.

The collective unconscious acts as the frame where science can distinguish individual motivating urges, thought to be universal across all individuals of the human species, while instincts are present in all species.

Jung contends:

The hypothesis of the collective unconscious is, therefore, no more daring than to assume there are instincts.”

So, it’s not my fault, blame my instincts?

The archetype is a concept “borrowed” from anthropology to denote a process of nature.

Jung’s definitions of archetypes varied over time and have been the subject of debate as to their usefulness. 

Archetypal images, also referred to as motifs in mythology, are universal symbols that can mediate opposites in the psyche, are often found in religious art, mythology and fairy tales across cultures.

Jung saw archetypes as pre-configurations in nature that give rise to repeating, understandable, describable experiences.

In addition the concept takes into account the passage of time and of patterns resulting from transformation.

Archetypes are said to exist independently of any current event or its effect.

They are said to exert influence both across all domains of experience and throughout the stages of each individual’s unique development.

Being in part based on heritable physiology, they are thought to have “existed” since humans became a differentiated species.

They have been deduced through the development of storytelling over tens of thousands of years, indicating repeating patterns of individual and group experience, behaviours and effects across the planet, apparently displaying common themes.

Our history is a story and the expression of that story determines or results from our psychology?

Above: The Thinker, Auguste Rodin, Paris, France

According to Jung, there are “as many archetypes as there are typical situations in life“. 

He asserted that they have a dynamic mutual influence on one another.

Their alleged presence could be extracted from thousand-year-old narratives, from comparative religion and mythology.

Above: Memories, dreams and reflections, Carl Jung

So, as Leonard Cohen suggests:

Let us compare mythologies?

Above: Leonard Cohen (1934 – 2016)

According to Jung, the shadow exists as part of the unconscious mind and is composed of the traits individuals instinctively or consciously resist identifying as their own and would rather ignore, typically: repressed ideas, weaknesses, desires, instincts and shortcomings.

Above: Psychology of the Unconscious, Carl Jung

I wish I could repress my weaknesses and shortcomings!

Above: Scene from A Knight’s Tale

Much of the shadow comes as a result of an individual’s adaptation to cultural norms and expectations.

Thus, this archetype not only consists of all the things deemed unacceptable by society, but also those that are not aligned with one’s own personal morals and values.

Jung argues that the shadow plays a distinctive role in balancing one’s overall psyche, the counter-balancing to consciousness – “where there is light, there must also be shadow“.

Without a well-developed shadow (often “shadow work“, “integrating one’s shadow“), an individual can become shallow and extremely preoccupied with the opinions of others – that is, a walking persona.

Not wanting to look at their shadows directly, Jung argues, often results in psychological projection.

Individuals project imagined attitudes onto others without awareness.

The qualities an individual may hate (or love) in another, may be manifestly present in the individual, who does not see the external, material truth.

Above: Psychological Types, Carl Jung

Sounds like the old adage:

When I point my finger at you, three fingers of my hand are pointing back at me.

In order to truly grow as an individual, Jung believed that both the persona (the person we project?) and the shadow (who we really are?) should be balanced.

The shadow can appear in dreams or visions, often taking the form of a dark, wild, exotic figure.

The Shadow knows?

Jung was one of the first people to define introversion and extraversion in a psychological context.

In Jung’s Psychological Types, he theorizes that each person falls into one of two categories:

The introvert or the extravert.

The introvert is focused on the internal world of reflection, dreaming and vision.

Thoughtful and insightful, the introvert can sometimes be uninterested in joining the activities of others.

The extravert is interested in joining the activities of the world.

The extravert is focused on the outside world of objects, sensory perception and action.

Energetic and lively, the extravert may lose their sense of self in the intoxication of Dionysian pursuits.

Jungian introversion and extraversion is quite different from the modern idea of introversion and extraversion.

Modern theories often stay true to behaviourist means of describing such a trait (sociability, talkativeness, assertiveness, etc.), whereas Jungian introversion and extraversion are expressed as a perspective:

Introverts interpret the world subjectively, whereas extraverts interpret the world objectively.

By both the modern as well as the Jungian definition, I cannot decide whether I am an extraverted introvert or an introverted extravert.

In Jung’s psychological theory, the persona appears as a consciously created personality or identity, fashioned out of part of the collective psyche through socialization, acculturation and experience.

Jung applied the term persona, explicitly because, in Latin, it means both personality and the masks worn by Roman actors of the classical period, expressive of the individual roles played.

The persona, he argues, is a mask for the “collective psyche“, a mask that ‘pretends‘ individuality, so that both self and others believe in that identity, even if it is really no more than a well-played role through which the collective psyche is expressed.

Jung regarded the “persona-mask” as a complicated system which mediates between individual consciousness and the social community:

It is “a compromise between the individual and society as to what a man should appear to be“. 

But he also makes it quite explicit that it is, in substance, a character mask in the classical sense known to theatre, with its double function:

Both intended to make a certain impression on others and to hide (part of) the true nature of the individual.

The therapist then aims to assist the individuation process through which the client (re)gains their “own self” – by liberating the self, both from the deceptive cover of the persona, and from the power of unconscious impulses.

Jung has become enormously influential in management theory:

Not just because managers and executives have to create an appropriate “management persona” (a corporate mask) and a persuasive identity, but also because they have to evaluate what sort of people the workers are, to manage them (for example, using personality tests and peer reviews).

Above: Cover art, “Who are you?“, The Who

Jung’s work on himself and his patients convinced him that life has a spiritual purpose beyond material goals.

Our main task, he believed, is to discover and fulfill our deep, innate potential.

Based on his study of Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, Gnosticism, Taoism, and other traditions, Jung believed that this journey of transformation, which he called individuation, is at the mystical heart of all religions.

It is a journey to meet the self and at the same time to meet the Divine.

He believed that spiritual experience was essential to our well-being, as he specifically identified individual human life with the universe as a whole.

Above: Michelangelo’s The Creation of Adam, Sistine Chapel, Vatican City

In 1959, Jung was asked by host John Freeman on the BBC interview program Face to Face whether he believed in God, to which Jung answered:

I do not need to believe.

I know.

Jung’s idea of religion as a practical road to individuation is still treated in modern textbooks on the psychology of religion, though his ideas have also been criticized.

Above: Carl Jung (left) and John Freeman (right), 1959

Jung had an apparent interest in the paranormal and occult. 

Jung’s ideas about the paranormal culminated in “synchronicity” – the idea that certain coincidences manifest in the world and have exceptionally intense meaning to observers.

Such coincidences have great effect on the observer from multiple cumulative aspects:

  • from the immediate personal relevance of the coincidence to the observer
  • from the peculiarities of (the nature of, the character, novelty, curiosity of) any such coincidence
  • from the sheer improbability of the coincidence, having no apparent causal link

Despite his own experiments he failed to confirm the phenomenon.

Jung proposed that art can be used to alleviate or contain feelings of trauma, fear, or anxiety and also to repair, restore and heal.

In his work with patients and his own personal explorations, Jung wrote that art expression and images found in dreams could help recover from trauma and emotional distress.

At times of emotional distress, he often drew, painted, or made objects and constructions which he recognized as more than recreational.

Above: An art therapist watches over a person with mental health problems during an art therapy workshop in Dakar, Senegal

Jung stressed the importance of individual rights in a person’s relation to the state and society.

He saw that the state was treated as “a quasi-animate personality from whom everything is expected” but that this personality was “only camouflage for those individuals who know how to manipulate it”, and referred to the state as a form of slavery.

He also thought that the state “swallowed up people’s religious forces“, and therefore that the state had “taken the place of God“— making it comparable to a religion in which “state slavery is a form of worship“.

Jung observed that “stage acts of the state” are comparable to religious displays:

Brass bands, flags, banners, parades and monster demonstrations are no different in principle from ecclesiastical processions, cannonades and fire to scare off demons.

Above: Nuremburg Rally, 5 – 10 September 1934

From Jung’s perspective, this replacement of God with the state in a mass society leads to the dislocation of the religious drive and results in the same fanaticism of the church-states of the Dark Ages — wherein the more the state is ‘worshipped‘, the more freedom and morality are suppressed.

This ultimately leaves the individual psychically undeveloped with extreme feelings of marginalization.

In the 1936 essayWotan, Jung described the influence of Adolf Hitler on Germany as “one man who is obviously ‘possessed’ has infected a whole nation to such an extent that everything is set in motion and has started rolling on its course towards perdition.

He would later say, during a lengthy interview with H.R. Knickerbocker in October 1938:

Hitler seemed like the ‘double’ of a real person, as if Hitler the man might be hiding inside like an appendix, and deliberately so concealed in order not to disturb the mechanism.

You know you could never talk to this man.

Because there is nobody there.

It is not an individual.

It is an entire nation.

Above: Adolf Hitler (1889 – 1945)

There’s a red fox torn by a huntsman’s pack
(That’s my soul up there)
There’s a black-winged gull with a broken back
(That’s my soul up there)
There’s a little black spot on the sun today
It’s the same old thing as yesterday

Arthur Koestler (1905 – 1983) was a Hungarian British Jewish author and journalist.

Above: Arthur Koestler

Koestler was born in Budapest and, apart from his early school years, was educated in Austria.

In 1931, Koestler joined the Communist Party of Germany, but he resigned in 1938 because Stalinism disillusioned him.

Above: Symbol of the German Communist Party

Having moved to Britain in 1940, he published his novel Darkness at Noon, an anti-totalitarian work that gained him international fame.

Over the next 43 years, Koestler espoused many political causes and wrote novels, memoirs, biographies, and numerous essays.

In 1949, Koestler began secretly working with a British Cold War anti-communist propaganda department known as the Information Research Department (IRD), which would republish and distribute many of his works, and also fund his activities.

Above: Carlton House Terrace, London, England – the original home of the Information Research Department’s propaganda activities, it was the location of the German Embassy until 1945

In 1968, he was awarded the Sonning Prize “for his outstanding contribution to European culture“.

In 1972, he was made a Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE).

Above: CBE medal

In 1976, he was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease and in 1979 with terminal leukaemia.

On 1 March 1983, Koestler and his wife Cynthia jointly committed suicide at their London home by swallowing lethal quantities of barbiturate-based Tuinal capsules.

Above: Arthur Koestler (1905 – 1983)

As a Hungarian-born novelist who resided in England, Koestler was enthralled with parapsychology and the unexplained workings of the mind.

(He wrote the book titled The Ghost in the Machine in the late ’60s, after which the Police named their 4th album).

I’ve stood here before inside the pouring rain
With the world turning circles running ’round my brain
I guess I’m always hoping that you’ll end this reign
But it’s my destiny to be the king of pain

A music video of King of Pain was made but only released in Australia.

Above: Clip from the video of King of Pain

The lyrics in King of Pain paint exactly the kind of bleak and hopeless picture of the world that someone in the midst of a depressive episode would experience.

The imagery Sting creates relates not just to the suffering of the living, but to a kind of randomness in the world that affects all things.

Beyond the fox, the gull, the whale, the living things, there is also a hat in a tree and a rag on a flagpole, not to mention the sunspots themselves.

All of these, together, suggest a kind of negative naturalistic view of the world (and the universe), a view where things “just happen” and traits “just are“, all of it out of anyone’s control.

In this world view, pain and suffering and death are simply part of a meaningless lottery.

Sting is saying, in a nutshell:

If nature can be so random and so indifferent, then why in the world should we expect nature to be any more kind to us?

We are no more entitled than the whale, the fox or the butterfly.

Like any chaotic system, sunspots are paradoxically both random and predictable.

Each spot (“soul“) is random as to where specifically it appears and the course of its “life“.

Still, when they’re viewed collectively, sunspots are cyclical, following an 11-year pattern.

Basically, King of Pain is a guy saying how depressed he is, but it is a surprisingly beautiful song if you really listen.

It’s about a man saying he is destined to always be hurting, that the pain will never go away no matter what he does or where he goes.

He is asking for someone to help him, but ultimately knows they can’t.

This is a song about depression.

The black spot on the sun is a day (or a life) that starts out good, but is destined to tank.

And this has happened often.

History repeats itself.

It’s the same old thing as yesterday.

The rain is pouring, the wind won’t stop, the world is doing circles —

Life sucks.

The end of the reign refers to a desire for all this to stop and the destiny is his doubt that it will.

King of pain
King of pain
King of pain
I’ll always be king of pain
I’ll always be king of pain
I’ll always be king of pain
I’ll always be king of pain
I’ll always be king of pain
I’ll always be king of pain
I’ll always be king of pain

And yet, somehow, somewhere, there is beauty in the dissonance.

And it is this beauty in the dissonance that reminds me once again of St. Gallen.

Above: Bird’s eye view of St. Gallen, Switzerland

Gustav Adolf (1778 – 1837), former king of Sweden (1792 – 1809), spent the last years of his life in St. Gallen and died there in 1837.

In October 1833 he went to Weisses Rössli (“The White Horse“), an inn in St. Gallen.

He decided to spend the rest of his life in quiet resignation with Rössli landlord Samuel Naf in St. Gallen.

A man born in a palace, living his last years in an inn “by no means of the first order”.

There is no monument to remind us of him.

No street is named after him.

No city tour deals with him.

He is only mentioned by two measly building plaques.

One is located on the busy arterial road to Basel’s St. Johann suburb.

The other is practically invisible above a shop window in St. Gallen’s Old Town.

This King hardly left any traces of himself.

Above: Gustav IV Adolf of Sweden

Gustav Adolf was born in Stockholm, the son of King Gustav III of Sweden and Queen Sophia Magdalena of Denmark.

Above: Sophia Magdalena of Denmark (1746 – 1813)

Early on, malicious rumors arose that Gustav III would not have been the father of the child but the nobleman, Adolf Fredik Munck, from the eastern half of Finland. 

He had been helpful in the royal couple’s sexual debut. 

Although the royal couple showed all signs of a happy marriage at the time of the Queen’s first pregnancy, the rumour was passed on, even by Gustav III’s brother Duke Karl and by him to the brothers’ mother Louise, which led to a break between the King and her, which was not addressed until Louise’s deathbed. 

The rumour was so entrenched that it was in the Swedish nobility’s Ättar paintings under Count Munck af Fulkila that he is believed to have been secretly married to Queen Sophia Magdalena, and “is presumed to be the father of Gustaf IV Adolf”

The King was nevertheless deeply involved in the upbringing of his eldest son. 

Above: Adolf Fredrik Munck (1749 – 1831)

Stockholm is the capital and largest city of Sweden as well as the largest urban area in Scandinavia.

Approximately 980,000 people live in the municipality, with 1.6 million in the urban area, and 2.4 million in the metropolitan area.

The city stretches across 14 islands where Lake Mälaren flows into the Baltic Sea.

Outside the city to the east, and along the coast, is the island chain of the Stockholm Archipelago, with some 24,000 islands, islets and skerries.

Over 30% of the city area is made up of waterways, and another 30% is made up of green areas.

The air and water here are said to be the freshest of any European capital.

Above: Stockholm, Sweden

The area has been settled since the Stone Age, in the 6th millennium BCE.

It was founded as a city in 1252 by Swedish statesman Birger Jarl.

It is also the county seat of Stockholm County and for several hundred years was also the capital of Finland which then was a part of Sweden.

Above: Flag of Stockholm

Stockholm is the cultural, media, political and economic centre of Sweden.

The Stockholm region alone accounts for over a third of the country’s GDP. 

It is among the top 10 regions in Europe by GDP per capita.

Above: Stockholm City Hall

Ranked as an alpha-global city, it is the largest in Scandinavia and the main centre for corporate headquarters in the Nordic region.

Above: Kista Science Tower, Stockholm – This is the tallest office building in Scandinavia.

As of the 21st century, Stockholm struggles to become a world leading city in sustainable engineering, including waste management, clean air and water, carbon-free public transportation, and energy efficiency.

Lake water is safe for bathing, and in practice for drinking (though not recommended).

Above: Kastellet Citadel, Kastellholmen, Stockholm

The city is home to some of Europe’s top ranking universities, such as the Stockholm School of Economics, Karolinska Institute, the KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Stockholm University.

Stockholm hosts the annual Nobel Prize ceremonies and banquet at the Stockholm Concert Hall and Stockholm City Hall.

Above: Nobel Prize medal

Untouched by wars for a long time, Stockholm has some great old architecture to see.

The exception would be Norrmalm, where much was demolished in the 1950s and 1960s to give place to what was then more modern buildings.

Looking at it the other way around, if interested in this kind of architecture this is the place to go.

Above: Hamngatan, a street in Norrmalm, Stockholm

Stockholm’s Old Town (Gamla Stan) is the beautifully preserved historical centre, best covered on foot, dominated by the Stockholm Palace (Stockholms slott).

Above: Stockholm Palace

Other highlights include: 

  • Storkyrkan, the cathedral of Stockholm, which has been used for many royal coronations, weddings and funerals

Above: The Royal Cathedral, Stockholm

  • Riddarholmskyrkan, a beautifully preserved medieval church, which hosts the tombs of many Swedish kings and royals, surrounded by former mansions.

Above: Riddarholmen Church, Stockholm, Sweden

Stockholm has several interesting churches, from medieval times to the 20th century.

Most of them are in active use by the Church of Sweden.

Above: Coat of arms of the Church of Sweden

There is also a synagogue in Östermalm and a mosque on Södermalm.

Above: The Great Synagogue, Stockholm

Above: Stockholm Mosque

The woodland cemetery, Skogskyrkogården, in Söderort is one of few UNESCO World Heritage sites from the 20th century.

Above: Skogskyrkogården, Stockholm

Also in southern Stockholm is the Ericsson Globe (Söderort), a white spherical building used for hockey games and as a concert venue.

Occasionally, at least at game nights, it is lit by coloured light.

The Globe is the heart of the Sweden Solar System, the world’s largest scale model of any kind.

With the Globe as the Sun, models of the planets are displayed at Slussen (Mercury), the Royal Institute of Technology (Venus), the Natural History Museum (Earth and Moon), Mörby Centrum (Mars), Arlanda Airport (Jupiter) and Uppsala (Saturn).

Above: The Ericson Globe, Stockholm

Stockholm has more than 70 museums, ranging from those large in size and scope to the very specialized, including the Butterfly Museum, the Spirits Museum, and the Dance Museum, to name but a few.

Above: The Museum of Spirits, Stockholm

Above: Dance Museum, Stockholm

As of 2016, many of them have free entrance.

A brief selection:

  • The Natural History Museum has extensive exhibits for all ages, including an Omnimax cinema. 

Above: Natural History Museum, Stockholm

  • The Army Museum displays Sweden’s military history, with its frequent wars from the Middle Ages until 1814, then followed by two centuries of peace.

Above: Army Museum, Stockholm

  • The Swedish History Museum features an exhibition on Vikings.

Above: Swedish History Museum, Stockholm

  • The Museum of Modern Art

Above: Museum of Modern Art, Stockholm

  • The Vasa Museum displays the Vasa, a 17th-century warship that sunk in Stockholm Harbour on its maiden voyage, and authentic objects from the height of the Swedish Empire. One of the city’s most prized museums, the Vasa Museum, is the most visited non-art museum in Scandinavia.

Above: Vasa Museum, Stockholm

Above: Vasa Museum logo

  • Skansen is an open-air museum containing a zoo featuring Swedish fauna, as well as displays of Sweden’s cultural heritage in reconstructed buildings. 

Above: Skansen Open Air Museum, Stockholm

  • Nordiska Museet displays Swedish history and cultural heritage.

Above: Nordiska Museet, Stockholm

  • The Swedish Music Hall of Fame features the ABBA Museum.

Above: Benny Andersson, Anni-Frid Lyngstad (Frida), Agnetha Fältskog, and Björn Ulvaeus (ABBA)

  • Lidingö is an open-air sculpture museum.

Above: Lindingö, Stockholm

  • Fotografiska Södermalm is a photo gallery opened in 2010.

Above: Swedish Museum of Photography, Stockholm

  • For the real Viking buff, there is Birka, the site of a former Viking city.

Above: The Viking village of Birka, Stockholm

Beyond the art museums mentioned above, Stockholm has a vivid art scene with many art galleries, exhibition halls and public art installation.

Some of the galleries are:

  • Galleri Magnus Karlsson 

  • Lars Bohman Gallery

  • Galerie Nordenhake

  • Magasin 3

The Royal Institute of Art and the University College of Arts, Crafts and Design hold regular exhibitions.

Above: The Royal Academy of Fine Arts, Stockholm

The Stockholm Metro, opened in 1950, is well known for the décor of its stations.

It has been called the longest art gallery in the world.

Some stations worth to mention are:

  • the moody dark blue cave of Kungsträdgården

Above: Kungsträdgården Metro Station

  • the giant black and white “drawings” by Siri Derkert at Östermalmstorg

Above: Östermalmstorg Metro Station

  • the celebration of science and technology at Tekniska Högskolan 

Above: Tekniska Högskolan Metro Station

  • Rissne has a fascinating timeline of human history on its walls.

Above: Rissne Metro Station

A written description in English to the art in the Stockholm Metro can be downloaded for free.

Above: Stockholm Metro logo

Sweden’s national football arena is located north of the city centre, in Solna. 

Above: Friends Arena, Stockholm

Avicii Arena, the national indoor arena, is in the southern part of the city.

Above: Avicii Arena (Ericsson Globe), Stockholm

The city was the host of the 1912 Summer Olympics.

Stockholm is the seat of the Swedish government and most of its agencies, including the highest courts in the judiciary, and the official residencies of the Swedish monarch and the Prime Minister.

Above: Flag of Sweden

The government has its seat in the Rosenbad building, the Riksdag (Swedish parliament) is seated in the Parliament House.

Above: Rosenbad Building, Stockholm

The Prime Minister’s Residence is adjacent at Sager House.

Above: Swedish Prime Minister Magdalena Andersson

Above: Sager House, Stockholm

Stockholm Palace is the official residence and principal workplace of the Swedish monarch, while Drottningholm Palace, a World Heritage Site on the outskirts of Stockholm, serves as the Royal Family’s private residence.

Above: King Carl XVI Gustav of Sweden

Above: Aerial view of Stockholm Palace

Above: Drottningholm Palace, Stockholm

Stockholm is the hub of most Swedish rail and bus traffic and has two of the country’s busiest airports nearby, so it is a good starting point for visiting other parts of Sweden.

Above: Swedish National Railways logo

Above: Stockholm Central Station

Above: Bus travel in Sweden

Above: Stockholm Arlanda Airport

Stockholm has been the setting of many books and films, including some of Astrid Lindgren’s works and Nordic Noir works, such as Stieg Larsson’s Millennium.

Above: Astrid Lindgren (1907 – 2002)

Above: Cover of Pippi Långstrump Går Ombord (Pippi Longstocking Goes On Board), 1946

Above: Stieg Larsson (1954 – 2004)

Why can’t a man and his family live here forever in a state of perpetual happiness?

Above: A screenshot of the 1969 television series, showing Inger Nilsson as Pippi Longstocking

In 1792, King Gustav III was mortally wounded by a gunshot in the lower back during a masquerade ball as part of an aristocratic-parliamentary coup attempt, but managed to assume command and quell the uprising before succumbing to spesis 13 days later, a period during which he received apologies from many of his political enemies.

At the age of 13, Gustav Adolf went through the murder of his father, a trauma that left deep traces. 

Some have suggested that this also affected his life.

Above: Gustav III of Sweden (1746 – 1792)

Upon Gustav III’s assassination in March 1792, Gustav Adolf succeeded to the throne at the age of 14, under the regency of his uncle, Charles, Duke of Södermanland, who was later to become King Charles XIII of Sweden when his nephew was forced to abdicate and was banished from the country in 1809.

Above: King Charles XIII of Sweden (1748 – 1818)

In August 1796, his uncle the regent arranged for the young King to visit St. Petersburg.

Above: The Winter Palace, St. Petersburg, Russia

The intention was to arrange a marriage between the young King and the Grand Duchess Alexandra Pavlovna, a granddaughter of Russian Empress Catherine the Great.

Above: Grand Duchess Alexandra Pavlovna of Russia (1783 – 1801)

However, the whole arrangement foundered on Gustav’s unwavering refusal to allow his intended bride liberty of worship according to the rites of the Russian Orthodox Church.

Above: Cross of the Russian Orthodox Church

Nobody seems to have suspected the possibility at the time that emotional problems might lie at the root of Gustav’s abnormal piety.

On the contrary, when he came of age that year, thereby ending the regency, there were many who prematurely congratulated themselves on the fact that Sweden had now no disturbing genius, but an economical, God-fearing, commonplace monarch.

Gustav Adolf’s prompt dismissal of the generally detested Gustaf Adolf Reuterholm, the duke-regent’s leading advisor, added still further to his popularity.

Above: Gustaf Adolf Reuterholm (1756 – 1813)

On 31 October 1797 Gustav married Frederica Dorothea, granddaughter of Karl Friedrich, Margrave of Baden, a marriage which seemed to threaten war with Russia but for the fanatical hatred of the French Republic shared by the Russian Emperor Paul and Gustav IV Adolf, which served as a bond between them.

Above: Queen Frederica of Sweden (1781 – 1826)

Above: Russian Emperor Paul I (1754 – 1801)

Indeed, the King’s horror of Jacobinism (ardent or republican support of a centralized and revolutionary democracy or state) was intense, and drove him to become increasingly committed to the survival of Europe, to the point where he postponed his coronation for some years, so as to avoid calling together a Diet.

Nonetheless, the disorder of the state finances, largely inherited from Gustav III’s war against Russia, as well as widespread crop failures in 1798 and 1799, compelled him to summon the Estates to Norrköping in March 1800 and on 3 April the same year.

When the King encountered serious opposition at the Riksdag, he resolved never to call another.

Above: The Museum of Work, Strykjärnet (Clothes Iron) Building, Motala River, Norrköping, Sweden

His reign was ill-fated and was to end abruptly.

In 1803, England declared war on France. 

Behind this declaration of war was that England did not want to be challenged as the dominant colonial power.

As it was impossible for England to defeat France alone, allies were needed. 

Many countries were reluctant to enter into a Coalition against Napoleon, but the decisive factor was that in May 1805 Napoleon was crowned King of Italy. 

Above: Emperor Napoleon I of France (1769 – 1821)

Russia had already in April 1805 common cause with the British.

In August of the same year Austria and Sweden joined the Coalition.

Contributing to Sweden joining the Coalition was the assassination of Duke Louis Antoine Henri de Bourbon, which took place after France violated the territory of neutral Baden.

This assassination upset the whole of Europe and intensified Gustav’s hatred of Napoleon, but the decision for Sweden to go to war was not only based on emotions. 

Above: Duke of Énghien, Louis-Antoine de Bourbon-Condé (1772 – 1804) –  More famous for his death than for his life, he was executed on charges of aiding Britain and plotting against France, shocking royalty across Europe.

Early in 1804, Napoleon Bonaparte, then First Consul of France, heard news which seemed to connect the young Duke with the Cadoudal Affair, a conspiracy which was being tracked by the French police at the time.

It involved royalists Jean-Charles Pichegru and Georges Cadoudal who wished to overthrow Bonaparte’s regime and reinstate the monarchy.

Above: General Charles Pichegru (1761 – 1804)

Above: Georges Cadoudal Coutan (1771 – 1804)

The news ran that the Duke was in company with Charles François Dumouriez and had made secret journeys into France.

Above: General Charles François du Périer Dumouriez (1739 – 1823)

This was false.

There is no evidence that the Duke had dealings with either Cadoudal or Pichegru.

However, the Duke had previously been condemned in absentia for having fought against the French Republic in the Armée des Émigrés (counter-revolutionary armies raised outside France by and out of royalist émigrés, with the aim of overthrowing the French Revolution, reconquering France and restoring the monarchy.

Above: Troops of the Armées des émigrés at the Battle of Quiberon, 23 June – 21 July 1795

Napoleon gave orders for the seizure of the Duke.

French dragoons crossed the Rhine secretly, surrounded his house and brought him to Strasbourg (15 March 1804), and thence to the Château de Vincennes, near Paris, where a military commission of French colonels presided over by General Hulin was hastily convened to try him.

Above: Château de Vincennes, France

The Duke was charged chiefly with bearing arms against France in the late war, and with intending to take part in the new Coalition then proposed against France.

The military commission, presided over by General Hulin, drew up the act of condemnation, being incited thereto by orders from Anne Jean Marie René Savary, who had come charged with instructions to kill the Duke.

Above: General Pierre Augustin Hulin (1758 – 1841)

Above: Anne Jean Marie René Savary, 1st Duke of Rovigo (1774 – 1833)







Savary prevented any chance of an interview between the condemned and the First Consul.

On 21 March, the Duke was shot in the moat of the castle, near a grave which had already been prepared.
A platoon of the Gendarmes d’élite was in charge of the execution.

The Duke’s last words were:

I must die then at the hands of Frenchmen!





Above; The execution of the Duke of Énghien






In 1816, his remains were exhumed and placed in the Holy Chapel of the Château de Vincennes.

Royalty across Europe were shocked and dismayed at the duke’s death.

Tsar Alexander I of Russia was especially alarmed.

He decided to curb Napoleon’s power. 

Baden was the territory of the Tsar’s father-in-law, and the German principalities were part of the Holy Roman Empire of which Russia was a guarantor.







Above: Russian Tsar Alexander I (1777 – 1825)






 

Enghien was the last descendant of the House of Condé.

His grandfather and father survived him, but died without producing further heirs.

It is now known that Joséphine (Napoleon’s wife) and Madame de Rémusat had begged Bonaparte to spare the Duke, but nothing would bend his will.

Above: Joséphine de Beauharnais (1763 – 1814)

Above: Claire Élisabeth Jeanne Gravier de Vergennes, comtesse de Rémusat (1780 – 1821)

Whether Talleyrand, Fouché or Savary bore responsibility for the seizure of the Duke is debatable, as at times Napoleon was known to claim Talleyrand conceived the idea, while at other times he took full responsibility himself.

Above: Diplomat Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord (1754 – 1838)

Above: Joseph Fouché, 1st Duc d’Otrante, 1st Comte Fouché (1759 – 1820)

On his way to St. Helena and at Longwood, Napoleon asserted that, in the same circumstances, he would do the same again.

Above: Location of St. Helena

Above: Longwood House, Longwood, St. Helena

He inserted a similar declaration in his will, stating that:

It was necessary for the safety, interest, and the honour of the French people as when the Comte d’Artois, by his own confession, was supporting sixty assassins at Paris.

Above: King Charles X of France, Count of Artois (1757 – 1836)

The execution shocked the aristocracy of Europe, who still remembered the bloodletting of the Revolution.

Above: Nine émigrés executed by guillotine, 1793

Either Antoine Boulay, comte de la Meurthe (deputy from Meurthein the Corps législatif) or Napoleon’s chief of police, Fouché, said about the Duke’s execution: 

C’est pire qu’un crime, c’est une faute.”, a statement often rendered in English as:

It was worse than a crime.

It was a blunder.”

The statement is also sometimes attributed to Talleyrand.

Above: Sketch of Antoine Jacques Claude Joseph, comte Boulay de la Meurthe (1761 – 1840)

In contrast, in France the execution appeared to quiet domestic resistance to Napoleon, who soon crowned himself Emperor of the French. 

Cadoudal, dismayed at the news of Napoleon’s proclamation, reputedly exclaimed:

We wanted to make a King, but we made an Emperor.”

Above: The coronation of Napoleon I, 2 December 1804

From the beginning, Sweden was part of a seemingly strong alliance, which could have good opportunities to beat Napoleon. 

In August 1805 it was not possible to predict the Russian-Austrian loss at the Battle of Austerlitz in December 1805, the collapse of Prussia at the Battle of Jena-Auerstedt in October 1806, and the loss of the Russians in the Battle of Eylau in February 1807.

Above: Battle of Austerlitz, Austria, 2 December 1805

Above: Battle of Jena-Auerstedt, Germany, 14 October 1806

Above: Battle of Eylau, Russia, 7 – 8 February 1807

These setbacks totally changed Sweden’s chances of success.

Gustav IV Adolf’s policies and stubbornness at the time of Napoleon’s march through Europe diminished confidence in him as regent, which affected him less because he was convinced of the validity of his divine right to rule.

Above: Gustav IV Adolf’s personal coat-of-arms

Gustav IV Adolf’s personal aversion to the French Revolution and Napoleon, and his unrealistic view of Sweden’s military force led Sweden to declare war on France (Swedish-French War: 1805 – 1810). 

Contributing to the War was that Sweden was dependent on trade with Great Britain, and therefore opposed the Continental Blockade against Great Britain. 

In 1805, he joined the Third Coalition against Napoléon.

The war was fought largely on German soil. 

The starting point for the Swedish troop movements was Swedish Pomerania. 

Above: Swedish Pomerania (orange) within the Swedish Empire (green)

At the beginning of November 1805, there was an army consisting of just over 12,000 Swedes and Russians standing in Swedish Pomerania. 

The plan was to move to Hanover via the fortress Hameln, which was in French hands, where the English were on site. 

Above: Modern Hannover, Germany

The plan was delayed by Prussia’s hesitation. 

When the plan could finally be put into action, Napoleon had won his great victory at Austerlitz. 

After this, Prussia entered into a treaty with Napoleon, which meant that Swedes, Russians and Englishmen now had to leave Prussia. 

The Swedes reluctantly withdrew to Swedish Pomerania.

During the summer of 1806, Prussia changed sides in the war. 

Above: Flag of the Kingdom of Prussia (1701 – 1918)

The Swedes were now allowed to occupy Saxony-Lauenburg, but in the autumn of the same year the French reaped new successes, and Prussia and the rest of Germany were flooded by French troops. 

The Swedes were now forced to retreat to Lübeck. 

Above: Modern Lübeck, Germany

The plan was to be able to retreat from there by sea to Stralsund in Swedish Pomerania. 

Above: Modern Stralsund, Germany

However, the Swedes were surprised by the French during the preparations for sea transport.

On 6 November,1,000 Swedish soldiers had to capitulate. 

Most had already packed their rifles! 

This “battle” is called the Surprise in Lübeck.

Above: Battle of Lübeck, 7 November 1806

At the beginning of 1807, the French began a siege of Stralsund. 

As the French were also engaged in warfare elsewhere, their numbers steadily declined. 

The Swedes therefore decided to launch an offensive to lift the siege. 

The capture of Stralsund was successfully implemented on 1 April, which led to the Swedes being able to occupy the surrounding landscape, including Usedom and Wolin.

Above: Siege of Straslund, 24 July – 24 August 1807












Above: Map of Wolin, Poland






However, the French chose to attack again.
 
A 13,000-strong army, based in Szczecin, attacked the Swedes on 16 April. 




Above: Modern Szczecin, Poland




The left wing of the Swedish army had to withdraw, and another division in Ueckermünde was cut off. 

On 17 April, the cut-off force tried to get out of there by sea, but was attacked under the cargo of ships. 

The Battle of Ueckermünde ended with the capture of 677 men.

Above: Modern Ueckermünde, Germany

Gustav IV Adolf did not give up hope. 

He managed, with Russia’s help, to gather a force of 17,500 men, partly sub-standardly trained. 

Against these stood the French army of 40,000 men. 

Above: King Gustav IV Adolf of Sweden

On 13 June 1807, the Swedish army began to move, but in early July, Russia and Prussia made peace with France. 

The Swedish force was therefore forced to withdraw to Stralsund, after which they quickly retreated to Rügen. 

Above: Map of Rügen, Germany

Above: Cape Arkona, Rügen, Germany

The French command finally agreed to give the Swedes free exit. 

The French then ruled Sweden in Pomerania.

At the Peace of Paris, Sweden regained Swedish Pomerania, but it was still forced to join the Continental System, which meant that Sweden was not allowed to buy British goods. 

Above: French Empire (dark green), client states (light green), Continental System/Blockade (blue), 1812

When his ally, Russia, made peace and concluded an alliance with France at Tilsit in 1807, Sweden and Portugal were left as Great Britain’s sole European allies.

Above: Meeting of Russian Emperor Alexander I and French Emperor Napoleon I in a pavilion set up on a raft in the middle of the Neman River, Tilsit, Russia, 25 June 1807

On 21 February 1808, Russia invaded Finland, which was ruled by Sweden, on the pretext of compelling Sweden to join Napoléon’s Continental System. 

Denmark likewise declared war on Sweden. 

In just a few months almost all of Finland was lost to Russia.

Above: Notable locations of the Finnish War (21 February 1808 to 17 September 1809) fought between Sweden and Russia

As a result of the war, on 17 September 1809, in the Treaty of Hamina, Sweden surrendered the eastern third of Sweden to Russia.

The autonomous Grand Duchy of Finland within Imperial Russia was established.

By the time the peace treaties were signed, however, the King had already been deposed.

Dissatisfaction with the King had grown for several years and now his opponents took action. 

Gustav Adolf’s inept and erratic leadership in diplomacy and war precipitated his deposition through a conspiracy of army officers.

An uprising broke out in Värmland (a county north of Stockholm) where Lieutenant Colonel Georg Adlersparre on 7 March 1809 took command of the Northern Army, and triggered the Coup of 1809 by raising the flag of rebellion in Karlstad and starting to march upon Stockholm.  

Above: Georg Adlersparre (1760 – 1835)

When this news reached Stockholm, Gustav Adolf decided to leave the capital and take command of the southern army, in order to then be able to strike at the rebels. 

The coup plotters, some of whom were in Stockholm, realized that they needed to strike quickly and prevent the King from travelling. 

On 13 March, Carl Johan Adlercreutz and six other officers marched up to the Castle and declared that:

The whole nation is astonished at the unfortunate position of the Kingdom and the King’s promised departure and is determined to turn it down.

Above: Carl Johan Adlercreutz (1757 – 1815)

To prevent the King from joining loyal troops in Scania (southernmost Sweden), seven of the conspirators led by Adlercreutz broke into the royal apartments in the Palace and seized the King.

Above: The arrest of King Gustav IV Adolf, 13 March 1809

They imprisoned him and his family in Gripsholm Castle.

Above: Gripsholm Castle, Mariefred, Sweden

On 12 March 1809, King Gustav IV Adolf left Queen Frederica and their children at Haga Palace to deal with the rebellion of Georg Adlersparre.

Above: Haga Castle, Stockholm

The day after he was captured at the Royal Palace in Stockholm, imprisoned at Gripsholm Castle and deposed in favour of his uncle, who succeeded him as Charles XIII of Sweden on 6 June.

According to the terms of the deposition made on 10 May 1809, Frederica was allowed to keep the title of Queen even after the deposition of her spouse.

Frederica and her children were kept under guard at Haga Palace.

The royal couple was initially kept separated because the coup leaders suspected her of planning a coup.

During her house arrest, her dignified behavior reportedly earned her more sympathy than she had been given her entire tenure as Queen.

Her successor, Queen Charlotte, who felt sympathy for her and often visited her, and wished to preserve the right to the throne for Frederica’s son, Gustav.

Frederica told her that she was willing to separate from her son for the sake of succession, and requested to be reunited with her spouse.

Her second request was granted her after intervention from Queen Charlotte.

Above: Queen Charlotte of Sweden and Norway (1759 – 1818)

Frederica and her children joined Gustav Adolf at Gripsholm Castle after the coronation of the new monarch on 6 June.

The relationship between the former King and Queen was reportedly well during their house arrest at Gripsholm.

During her house arrest at Gripsholm Castle, the question of her son Crown Prince Gustav’s right to the throne was not yet settled and a matter of debate.

Above: Prince Gustav of Vasa (1799 – 1877)

There was a plan by a military faction led by General Eberhard von Vegesack to free Frederica and her children from the arrest, have her son declared monarch and Frederica as regent of Sweden during his minority.

These plans were in fact presented to her, but she declined:

The Queen displayed a nobility in her feelings, which makes her worthy of a crown of honor and placed her above the pitiful earthly royalty.

She did not listen to the secret proposals, made to her by a party, who wished to preserve the succession of the Crown Prince and wished, that she would remain in Sweden to become the regent during the minority of her son.

She explained with firmness, that her duty as a wife and mother told her to share the exile with her husband and children.

Above: Eberhard von Vegesack (1763 – 1818)

The King’s uncle, Duke Charles (Karl), later King Charles XIII, was thereupon persuaded to accept the leadership of a provisional government, which was proclaimed the same day.

A Diet, hastily summoned, solemnly approved of the revolution.

On 29 March, Gustav IV Adolf, to save the Crown for his son, voluntarily abdicated, but on 10 May the Riksdag of the Estates, dominated by the Army, declared that not merely Gustav but his whole family had forfeited the throne, perhaps an excuse to exclude his family from succession based on the rumours of his illegitimacy.

A more likely cause, however, is that the revolutionaries feared that Gustav’s son, if he inherited the throne, would avenge his father’s deposition when he came of age.

Above: Prince Gustav Vasa of Sweden

In the writing of history, the image of Gustav IV Adolf and his government was long drawn by the men of 1809 and their successors. 

They portrayed Gustav IV Adolf as an untalented and emotionally tense person whose policy was dictated by temporary and emotional factors that occasionally took on purely mind-boggling expressions, medals awarded by Gustaf IV Adolf were recalled and replaced with new ones without his name and signs, emblems, memorials and the like. which bore his name was removed. 

This is one of the few cases in Sweden where the state and its authorities have made an attempt at damnatio memoriae to erase the memory of someone.

Above: An example of damnatio memoriae, Roman Emperor Septimius Severus (145 – 211) and his family with the face of his son Geta (189 – 211) erased

On 5 June, Gustav’s uncle was proclaimed King Charles XIII, after accepting a new liberal Constitution, which was ratified by the Diet the next day.

Above: Royal monogram of King Charles XIII of Sweden

Gustav and his family were expelled out of the country.

Via three separate carriages. Gustav Adolf and Frederica travelled in one carriage, escorted by General Skjöldebrand.

Their son Gustav travelled in the second with Colonel Baron Posse.

Their daughters (Sophie, Amalia and Cecilia) and their governess Von Panhuys travelled in the last carriage escorted by Colonel von Otter.

Frederica was offered to be escorted with all honours due to a member of the House of Baden if she travelled alone, but declined and brought no courtier with her, only her German chamber maid Elisabeth Freidlein.

The family left for Germany by ship from Karlskrona on 6 December 1809. 

Above: Images from modern Karlskrona, Sweden

Thus the exile of a king and his family began.

Here is where this instalment of his story (and my own) ends.

To be continued…..

In my eyes
Indisposed
In disguises no one knows
Hides the face
Lies the snake
And the sun in my disgrace
Boiling heat
Summer stench
Neath the black, the sky looks dead
Call my name
Through the cream
And I’ll hear you scream again

Black hole sun
Won’t you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won’t you come
Won’t you come
Won’t you come

Stuttering
Cold and damp
Steal the warm wind, tired friend
Times are gone
For honest men
Sometimes, far too long for snakes
In my shoes
Walking sleep
In my youth, I pray to keep
Heaven send
Hell away
No one sings like you anymore

Black hole sun
Won’t you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won’t you come
Won’t you come

Black hole sun
Won’t you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won’t you come
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come? (Black hole sun, black hole sun)

Hang my head
Drown my fear
Till you all just disappear

Black hole sun
Won’t you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won’t you come
Won’t you come

Black hole sun
Won’t you come
And wash away the rain?
Black hole sun
Won’t you come
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come (Black hole sun, black hole sun)
Won’t you come
Won’t you come

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Lonely Planet, The World / Rough Guide to London / Rough Guide to Switzerland / Steve Biddulph, Manhood / Carl Franz and Lorena Havens, The People’s Guide to Mexico / Susan Griffith, Work Your Way Around the World / Dan Kieran, The Idle Traveller: The Art of Slow Travel / Rebecca Solnit, Wanderlust: A History of Walking / Chiang Lee, The Silent Traveller in Oxford

Canada Slim and the Golden Fleece

Eskişehir, Turkey, Sunday 15 May 2022

Thursday and I was once again back on the road to Denizli.

Once again the bus stopped at Kütahya and Afyonkarahisar, Dinar and Dazkiri, with a rare request stop today at Sandikli, before finally arriving at Denizli en route to the bus’s final destinations of Aydin and Bodrum.

The return trip the next day did not vary either:

As usual, there are stops in Uşak and Kütahya before the return back to Eskişehir.

Another week means another day spent in the textile factories of Denizli.

Above: View of Denizli from above

Denizli is an industrial city in the southwestern part of Turkey and the eastern end of the alluvial valley formed by the river Büyük Menderes, where the plain reaches an elevation of about 350 metres (1,148 ft).

The Büyük Menderes River (historically the Maeander or Meander, from Ancient Greek: Μαίανδρος, Maíandros / Turkish: Büyük Menderes Irmağı) rises in west central Turkey near Dinar before flowing west through the Büyük Menderes graben (fault formations) until reaching the Aegean Sea in the proximity of the ancient Ionain city of Miletus.

Above: Hancalar Bridge, Menderes River, Çal, Denizli Province

The word “meander” is used to describe a winding pattern, after the River.

Above: The Great Mederes River

The Büyük Menderes basin in Turkey has five wetlands and the Büyük Menderes river delta is an internationally recognised Important Bird and Biodiversity Area (IBA) for breeding and wintering water birds.

The cities Denizli and Uşak in the area are home to 60% of Turkey’s textile and leather exports.

The Büyük Menderes River contains domestic wastewater originating from settlements and industrial wastewater from industrial establishments.

It is polluted by the effects of excessive, untimely and incorrect use of fertilizers and pesticides. 

From a bird’s eye view of the basin, it is seen that the inadequacy of land use designs, the ruthless destruction of soil and biodiversity with chemicals as a result of too much production, the increase in population and the deterioration of the life balance. 

The discharge of technological, domestic and urban wastes into Büyük Menderes, which continues its function as a waste receiver and transporter environment, has resulted in the deterioration of the ecological balance formed over millions of years in only a few decades. 

In Denizli, Usak and Aydin, there are 20 types of industrial establishments that drain their wastewater into the Büyük Menderes river without treatment. 

According to the DSI basin statistics, the number of municipalities in the Büyük Menderes River Basin is given as 165. 

Only six of them have sewerage networks. 

In the lower basins, the pollution is getting more intense and the river ecosystem is about to disappear.

The region is under threat as the river delta has reached critical pollution levels.

Above: The Great Menderes River

From the food we eat to the fibres we wear, every living thing relies on water.

Climate change, population growth and changing consumption patterns have put fresh water systems at greater risk.

For this reason, the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) has developed a joint project with government, businesses and communities to ensure a sustainable future for the beautiful Büyük Menderes region.

Through the implementation of water stewardship this programme aims to serve as a model in the conservation and sustainable use of water resources that can be scaled up to other basins in Turkey.” World Wildlife Fund for Nature

Denizli is located in the country’s Aegean region.

The city has a population of about 646,278 (2018 census).

This is a jump from 389,000 in 2007, due to the merger of 13 municipalities and 10 villages when the area under Denizli Municipality jurisdiction increased almost fivefold and the population around 50%.

Denizli (Municipality) is the capital city of Denizli Province.

Denizli has seen economic development in the last few decades, mostly due to textile production and exports.

Above: Denizli city emblem

Denizli, an industrial, export and trade centre, is also home to nearly 65,000 university students. 

The literacy rate in Denizli is around 99%. 

As a result of the high importance given to education in the Province, it has a permanent place in the interprovincial success ranking especially in secondary education and university entrance exams such as ÖSS, LGS, SBS, being in the first three places (mostly 1st place) every year. 

For this reason, Denizli Province has an image that is known throughout the country for its high education level and quality, and its successful students. 

In addition, Pamukkale University, established on 3 July 1992, brought a different socio-economic and cultural dynamism and vitality to Denizli.

Above: Logo of Pamukkale University

Hosting millions of local and foreign tourists a year, Denizli is not only a tourism city, but also an education, congress, cultural and artistic centre with local, national and international events.

Denizli attracts visitors to the nearby mineral-coated hillside hot spring of Pamukkale and red thermal water spa hotels of Karahayit just 5 kilometres (3 miles) north of Pamukkale.

Above: Pamukkale

Above: Karahayit

Recently, Denizli became a major domestic tourism destination due to the various types of thermal waters in Sarayköy, Central/Denizli (where Karahayıt and Pamukkale towns are located), Akköy (Gölemezli), Buldan (Yenicekent) and Çardak districts.

Above: Saraköy

Above: Akköy

Above: Buldan

Above: Çardak

The ancient ruined city of Hierapolis, as well as ruins of the city of Laodicea on the Lycus, the ancient metropolis of Phrygia.

Above: Hierapolis

Above: Laodicea on the Lycus

Also Honaz, about 10 mi (16 km) west of Denizli, was in the 1st century CE the city of Colossae.

Above: Colossae

Denizli is a new city, located on the northern slopes of Akdağ (Babadağ), on a plateau slightly split by the streams that meet the Aksu Stream, a tributary of Büyük Menderes.

The main city of the province was Laodicea, seven kilometers north from here.

Laodicea (Laodikeia), devastated as a result of the wars between the Seljuks and Byzantines and with its waterways deteriorated, started to be abandoned and settlement started from the 11th century to move towards Denizli, where there are abundant water resources. 

Ibn Battuta visited the city, noting that:

In it there are seven mosques for the observance of Friday prayers, and it has splendid gardens, perennial streams, and gushing springs.

Most of the artisans there are Greek women, for in it are many Greeks who are subject to the Muslims and who pay dues to the sultan, including the jizyah and other taxes.

Above: Ibn Battuta (1304 – 1369)

In the 17th century, the Turkish traveler Evliya Çelebi visited Denizli and recorded the town as follows:

The city is called by Turks Denizli (which means has abundant of water sources like sea in Turkish) as there are several rivers and lakes around it.

In fact it is a four-day trip from the sea.

Its fortress is a square shape built on flat ground.

It has no ditches.

Its periphery is 470 steps long.

It has four gates.

These are:

  • the Painter’s Gate in the north
  • the Saddlemaker’s Gate in the east
  • the new Mosque Gate in the south
  • the Vineyard Gate in the west.

There are some 50 armed watchmen in the fortress and they attend the shops.

The main city is outside the fortress with 44 districts and 3,600 houses.

There are 57 small and large mosques and district masjids, seven madrashas, seven children’s schools, six baths and 17 dervish lodges.

As everybody lives in vineyards the upper classes and ordinary people do not flee from each other.”

Above: Statue of Evliya Çelebi (1611 – 1682)

Denizli suffered great damage during the earthquake of 1703 and was later rebuilt. 

Denizli, located on a natural road that enters the interior from the Aegean coasts, became rapidly crowded as a result of the development of this location and the agricultural activities around it, especially after the improvement of the highways in the 1950s.

Its population, which was 22,000 in 1950, has increased approximately 25 times in the past 60 years. 

Above: Denizli Museum

Denizli is now one of the most developed cities of Turkey. 

It is among the most important capitals of textile in the world. 

It has a good reputation in the US and the European Union markets for towels, bathrobes and home textiles. 

In addition, Serinhisar District meets 85% of Turkey’s need for chickpeas and chickpea products. 

Denizli is among Turkey’s ten largest economies. 

Its weather and nature reflect the averages of the Aegean region.

The weather is hot in Denizli in summers, whereas in winters, it may occasionally be very cold with snow on the mountains that surround the city.

Some years, snow can be observed in the urban areas.

Springs and autumns are rainy, mild climate, warm.

The vegetation of Denizli is maquis (small shrubs). 

59% of Denizli is covered with forests, 10% is meadows and pastures, 43% is cultivated and planted land. 

The part that is not suitable for cultivation is only 1%.

The vegetation of the Province is mostly composed of forest trees and maquis unique to the Mediterranean climate. 

There are tree species such as larch, red pine, cedar, juniper, oak, chestnut, plane tree, ash, alder (Paint tree), log in the forests. 

The wide areas on the foothills below the borders where the forests begin are covered with bushes and heaths.

I can often see part of these forests from my room in the Hotel Park Dedeman.

The economy of Denizli is based on industry and trade. 

Denizli is an export and industrial city. 

Its service sector is also highly developed and has grown tremendously in the last 15 years. 

Denizli has also exported copper wire to the US.

45% of the population is engaged in agriculture, fishing, beekeeping, forestry and animal husbandry. 

30% of all income comes from industry. 

Denizli is one of the leading exporting cities known as “Anatolian Tigers” in Turkey. 

It is one of Turkey’s locomotive industrial cities with billions of dollars in exports every year.

 

Although Denizli is known as the capital of textile in Turkey, due to the economic losses experienced in textile in recent years, the economic balances have shifted to the marble and natural stone sector. 

Travertine and its derivatives marble and natural stone are exported from Denizli to all countries of the world.

Industry in Denizli is highly developed.

Weaving, energy, automotive sub-industry, mining and metal industries are at the forefront.

Above: Denizli travertine

textile is a flexible material made by creating an interlocking bundle of yarns or threads, which are produced by spinning raw fibers (from either natural or synthetic sources) into long and twisted lengths.

Textiles are then formed by weaving, knitting, crocheting, knotting, tatting, felting, bonding or braiding these yarns together.

The related words “fabric” and “cloth” and “material” are often used in textile assembly trades (such as tailoring and dressmaking) as synonyms for textile.

However, there are subtle differences in these terms in specialized usage.

A textile is any material made of interlacing fibers, including carpeting and geotextiles, which may not necessarily be used in the production of further goods, such as clothing and upholstery.

The word ‘textile‘ comes from the Latin adjective textilis, meaning ‘woven‘, which itself stems from textus, the past participle of the verb texere, ‘to weave‘.

Originally applied to woven fabrics, the term “textiles” is now used to encompass a diverse range of materials, including fibres, yarns and fabrics, as well as other related items.

fabric is a material made through weaving, knitting, spreading, felting, stitching, crocheting or bonding that may be used in the production of further products, such as clothing and upholstery, thus requiring a further step of the production. 

The word ‘fabric‘ also derives from Latin, with roots in the Proto-Indo-European language.

Stemming most recently from the Middle French fabrique, (‘building or thing made‘), and earlier from the Latin fabrica (‘workshop; an art, trade; a skillful production, structure, fabric‘), the noun fabrica stems from the Latin faber, (‘artisan who works in hard materials‘), which itself is derived from the Proto-Indo-European dhabh, meaning ‘to fit together‘.

Cloth may also be used synonymously with fabric, but often specifically refers to a piece of fabric that has been processed or cut.

The word ‘cloth‘ derives from the Old English clað, meaning a ‘cloth, woven or felted material to wrap around ones body‘, from the Proto-Germanic kalithaz, similar to the Old Frisian klath, the Middle Dutch cleet, the Middle High German kleit and the German kleid, all meaning ‘garment‘.

The precursor of today’s textiles includes leaves, barks, fur pelts, and felted cloths.

The Banton Burial Cloth, the oldest existing example of warp ikat in Southeast Asia, is displayed at the National Museum of the Philippines.

The cloth was most likely made by the native Asian people of the northwest Romblon.

Above: Remnants of the Banton Burial Cloth

Above: Logo of the National Museum of the Philippines

The first clothes, worn at least 70,000 years ago and perhaps much earlier, were probably made of animal skins and helped protect early humans from the elements. At some point, people learned to weave plant fibers into textiles.

The discovery of dyed flax fibers in a cave in the Republic of Georgia dated to 34,000 BCE suggests that textile-like materials were made as early as the Paleolithic era.

The speed and scale of textile production have been altered almost beyond recognition by industrialization and the introduction of modern manufacturing techniques.

Above: Flag of the Republic of Georgia

Textiles have an assortment of uses, the most common of which are for clothing and for containers, such as bags and baskets.

In the household, textiles are used in carpeting, upholstered furnishings, window shades, towels, coverings for tables, beds, and other flat surfaces, and in art.

In the workplace, textiles can be used in industrial and scientific processes, such as filtering.

Miscellaneous uses include flags, backpacks, tents, nets, handkerchiefs, cleaning rags, and transportation devices, such as balloons, kites, sails and parachutes.

Textiles are also used to provide strengthening in composite materials such as fibreglass and industrial geotextiles.

Textiles are used in many traditional hand crafts, such as sewing, guilting and embroidery.

Textiles produced for industrial purposes, and designed and chosen for technical characteristics beyond their appearance, are commonly referred to as technical textiles. 

Technical textiles include:

  • textile structures for automotive applications
  • medical textiles (such as implants)
  • geotextile (reinforcement of embankments)
  • agrotextiles (textiles for crop protection)
  • protective clothing (such as clothing resistant to heat and radiation for fire fighter clothing, against molten metals for welders, stab protection, and bullet proof vests).

Due to the often highly technical and legal requirements of these products, these textiles are typically tested in order to ensure they meet stringent performance requirements.

Other forms of technical textiles may be produced to experiment with their scientific qualities and to explore the possible benefits they may have in the future.

Threads coated with zinc oxide nanowires, when woven into fabric, have been shown capable of “self-powering nanosystems“, using vibrations created by everyday actions like wind or body movements to generate energy.

Above: Textile market, Karachi, Pakistan

Textiles are made from many materials, with four main sources:

  • animal (wool, silk)
  • plant (cotton, flax, jute, bamboo)
  • mineral (asbestos, glass fibre)
  • synthetic (nylon, polyester, acrylic, rayon).

The first three are natural.

In the 20th century, they were supplemented by artificial fibers made from petroleum.

Textiles are made in various strengths and degrees of durability, from the finest microfibre made of strands thinner than one denier to the sturdiest canvas. 

Textile manufacturing terminology has a wealth of descriptive terms, from light gauze-like gossamer to heavy grosgrain cloth and beyond.

Above: Fabric shop, Mukalia, Yemen



Animal textiles are commonly made from hair, fur, skin or silk (in the case of silkworms).

  • Wool refers to the hair of the domestic sheep or goat, which is distinguished from other types of animal hair in that the individual strands are coated with scales and tightly crimped.

Wool as a whole is coated with a wax mixture known as lanolin (sometimes called wool grease), which is waterproof and dirtproof.

The lanolin and other contaminants are removed from the raw wool before further processing.

Woolen refers to a yarn produced from carded, non-parallel fibre, while worsted refers to a finer yarn spun from longer fibers which have been combed to be parallel.

  • Other animal textiles which are made from hair or fur are alpaca wool, vicuna woolllama wool, and camel hair, generally used in the production of coats, jackets, ponchos, blankets and other warm coverings.
  • Cashmere, the hair of the Indian cashmere goat, and mohair, the hair of the North African angora goat, are types of wool known for their softness and are used in the production of sweaters and scarfs.
  • Angora refers to the long, thick, soft hair of the angora rabbit. 
  • Qiviut is the fine inner wool of the muskox.

Above: Alpaca wool textiles, Otavalo Artisan Market, Ecuador

Wool is produced by follicles which are small cells located in the skin.

These follicles are located in the upper layer of the skin (called the epidermis) and push down into the second skin layer (called the dermis) as the wool fibers grow.

Follicles can be classed as either primary or secondary follicles.

Primary follicles produce three types of fiber:

  • kemp
  • medullated fibers
  • true wool fibers.

Secondary follicles only produce true wool fibers.

Medullated fibers share nearly identical characteristics to hair and are long but lack crimp and elasticity.

Kemp fibers are very coarse and shed out.

Above: Wool before processing

Wool’s crimp and, to a lesser degree, scales, make it easier to spin the fleece by helping the individual fibers attach to each other, so they stay together.

Because of the crimp, wool fabrics have greater bulk than other textiles.

They hold air, which causes the fabric to retain heat.

Wool has a high specific thermal resistance, so it impedes heat transfer in general.

This effect has benefited desert peoples, such as the Bedouins and Tuaregs, who use wool clothes for insulation.

Felting of wool occurs upon hammering or other mechanical agitation as the microscopic barbs on the surface of wool fibers hook together.

Felting generally comes under two main areas: dry felting or wet felting.

Wet felting occurs when water and a lubricant (especially an alkali such as soap) are applied to the wool which is then agitated until the fibers mix and bond together.

Temperature shock while damp or wet accentuates the felting process.

Some natural felting can occur on the animal’s back.

Above: Wool samples

Wool has several qualities that distinguish it from hair/fur:

It is crimped and elastic.

The amount of crimp corresponds to the fineness of the wool fibers.

A fine wool, like merino, may have up to 40 crimps per centimetre (100 crimps per inch), while coarser wool, like karakul, may have less than one crimp per centimeter (one or two crimps per inch).

In contrast, hair has little, if any, scale, and no crimp, and little ability to bind into yarn.

Above: Unshorn Merino sheep

On sheep, the hair part of the fleece is called kemp.

The relative amounts of kemp to wool vary from breed to breed and make some fleeces more desirable for spinning, felting or carding into batts for quilts or other insulating products, including the famous tweed cloth of Scotland.

Wool fibers readily absorb moisture, but are not hollow.

Wool can absorb almost one-third of its own weight in water.

Wool absorbs sound like many other fabrics.

It is generally a creamy white color, although some breeds of sheep produce natural colors, such as black, brown, silver, and random mixes.

Above: Wool samples, Auction House, Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia

Wool ignites at a higher temperature than cotton and some synthetic fibers.

It has a lower rate of flame spread, a lower rate of heat release, a lower heat of combustion, and does not melt or drip. 

It forms a char that is insulating and self-extinguishing, and it contributes less to toxic gases and smoke than other flooring products when used in carpets.

Wool carpets are specified for high safety environments, such as trains and aircraft.

Wool is usually specified for garments for firefighters, soldiers, and others in occupations where they are exposed to the likelihood of fire.

Above: Fleece of fine New Zealand Merino wool and combed wool top on a wool table

Wool causes an allergic reaction in some people.

Above: Johnny Galecki (Leonard Hofstadter), The Big Bang Theory

Animal breeding has been an important part of human life throughout history and has provided great benefits.

The aim of animal breeding is to conduct profitable breeding by raising high-yielding and healthy animals.

The elements that determine the profitability of animal breeding are breed of the animals raised, breeding techniques and market conditions.

On a good day, outside of Dinar or Uşak I sometimes see flocks of sheep.

Suddenly it is a timeless moment.

Sheep have had a strong presence in many cultures, especially in areas where they form the most common type of livestock.

In the English language, to call someone a sheep or ovine may allude that they are timid and easily led.

In contradiction to this image, male sheep are often used as symbols of virility and power; the logos of the Los Angeles Rams football team and the Dodge Ram pickup truck allude to males of the bighorn sheep, Ovis canadensis.

Above: Uniforms of the Los Angeles Rams National Football League (NFL) team

Above: Bighorn ram

Counting sheep is popularly said to be an aid to sleep.

Some ancient systems of counting sheep persist today.

Sheep also enter in colloquial sayings and idiom frequently with such phrases as “black sheep“.

To call an individual a black sheep implies that they are an odd or disreputable member of a group.

This usage derives from the recessive trait that causes an occasional black lamb to be born into an entirely white flock.

These black sheep were considered undesirable by shepherds, as black wool is not as commercially viable as white wool.

Citizens who accept overbearing governments have been referred to by the portmanteau neologism of sheeple.

(Sheeple is a derogatory term that highlights the passive herd behavior of people easily controlled by a governing power or market fads which likens them to sheep, a herd animal that is “easily” led about.

The term is used to describe those who voluntarily acquiesce to a suggestion without any significant critical analysis or research, in large part due to the majority of a population having a similar mindset.

Above: Donald Trump

Word Spy defines it as “people who are meek, easily persuaded, and tend to follow the crowd (sheep + people)“.

Merriam-Webster defines the term as “people who are docile, compliant, or easily influenced: people likened to sheep“.

The word is pluralia tantum, which means it does not have a singular form.

While its origins are unclear, the word was used by W. R. Anderson in his column Round About Radio, published in London 1945, where he wrote:

The simple truth is that you can get away with anything, in government.

That covers almost all the evils of the time.

Once in, nobody, apparently, can turn you out.

The People, as ever (I spell it “Sheeple”), will stand anything.

Above: Logo of Turkey’s reigning government party, the Justice and Development Party (AKP)

Another early use was from Ernest Rogers, whose 1949 book The Old Hokum Bucket contained a chapter entitled “We the Sheeple“.

The Wall Street Journal first reported the label in print in 1984.

The reporter heard the word used by the proprietor of the American Opinion bookstore.

In this usage, taxpayers were derided for their blind conformity as opposed to those who thought independently.

The term was first popularized in the late 1980s and early 1990s by conspiracy theorist and broadcaster Bill Cooper on his radio program The Hour of the Time which was broadcast internationally via shortwave radio stations.

The program gained a small, yet dedicated following, inspiring many individuals who would later broadcast their own radio programs critical of the United States government.

Above: Bill Cooper (1943 – 2001)

This then led to its regular use on the radio program Coast to Coast AM by Art Bell throughout the 1990s and early 2000s.

These combined factors significantly increased the popularity of the word and led to its widespread use.

Above: Art Bell (1945 – 2018)

The term can also be used for those who seem inordinately tolerant, or welcoming, of widespread policies.

In a column entitled “A Nation of Sheeple“, columnist Walter E. Williams writes:

Above: Walter E. Williams (1936 – 2020)

Americans sheepishly accepted all sorts of Transportation Security Administration nonsense.

In the name of security, we’ve allowed fingernail clippers, eyeglass screwdrivers, and toy soldiers to be taken from us prior to boarding a plane.“)

Somewhat differently, the adjective “sheepish” is also used to describe embarrassment.

In antiquity, symbolism involving sheep cropped up in religions in the ancient Near East, the Middle East, and the Mediterranean area: Çatalhöyük, ancient Egyptian religion, Canaanite and Phoenician traditions, Judaism, Greek religion, and others.

Religious symbolism and ritual involving sheep began with some of the first known faiths:

Skulls of rams (along with bulls) occupied central placement in shrines at the Çatalhöyük settlement in 8,000 BCE.

Above: Ruins of Çatalhöyük, Konya Plain, Turkey

In ancient Egyptian religion, the ram was the symbol of several gods: Khnum, Heryshaf and Amun (in his incarnation as a god of fertility).

Above: Pyramids of Giza, Cairo, Egypt

Other deities occasionally shown with ram features include the goddess Ishtar, the Phoenician god Baal-Hamon, and the Babylonian god Ea-Oannes.

Above: Goddess Ishtar on an Akkadian seal

In Madagascar, sheep were not eaten as they were believed to be incarnations of the souls of ancestors.

Above: Flag of Madagascar

There are many ancient Greek references to sheep: that of Chrysomallos, the golden-fleeced ram, continuing to be told through into the modern era. 

Astrologically, Aries, the ram, is the first sign of the classical Greek zodiac.

The sheep is the eighth of the twelve animals associated with the 12-year cycle of in the Chinese zodiac, related to the Chinese calendar.

In Mongolia, shagai are an ancient form of dice made from the cuboid bones of sheep that are often used for fortunetelling purposes.

Above: Flag of Mongolia

Above: Shagai

Sheep play an important role in all the Abrahamic faiths: 

Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, King David and the Islamic prophet Muhammad were once all shepherds.

Above: Guercino’s Abraham (2150 – 1975 BCE), Banishment of Hagar and Ismael, 1657

Above: (right foreground) Isaac

Above: Rembrandt’s Jacob wrestling with the angel, 1659

Above: Guido Reni’s Moses with the Tables of the Law, 1624

Above: Gerard von Horst’s King David (r. 1010 – 970 BCE) playing the harp, 1622







Above: “Muhammad, the Messenger of God“, inscribed on the gates of the Prophet’s Mosque, Medina, Saudi Arabia

According to the Biblical story of the Binding of Isaac, a ram is sacrificed as a substitute for Isaac after an angel stays Abraham’s hand.

Above: Caravaggio’s Sacrifice of Isaac, 1603

(In the Islamic tradition, Abraham was about to sacrifice Ishmael). 

Above: Ibrahim’s Sacrifice, Timurid Anthology, 1411

Eid al-Adha is a major annual festival in Islam in which sheep (or other animals) are sacrificed in remembrance of this act.

Sheep are occasionally sacrificed to commemorate important secular events in Islamic cultures.

Above: Eid prayer, Badshahi Mosque, Lahore, Pakistan

Greeks and Romans sacrificed sheep regularly in religious practice.

Judaism once sacrificed sheep as a Korban (sacrifice), such as the Passover lamb.

Above: Practice of Passover sacrifice by Temple Mount activists, Jerusalem, Israel, 2012

Ovine symbols — such as the ceremonial blowing of a shofar — still find a presence in modern Judaic traditions.

Above: Shofar

Collectively, followers of Christianity are often referred to as a flock, with Christ as the Good Shepherd.

Above: Bernhard Plockhurst’s The good shepherd

Sheep are an element in the Christian iconography of the birth of Jesus.

Above: Giotto’s Birth of Jesus, Scrovegni Chapel, Padua, Italy

Some Christian saints are considered patrons of shepherds, and even of sheep themselves.

Above: Statue of Saint Drogo of Sebourg (1105 – 1186), Église de Saint-Droun de Sebourg, France

Christ is also portrayed as the sacrificial lamb of God (Agnus Dei).

Easter celebrations in Greece and Romania traditionally feature a meal of Paschal lamb.

Above: Flag of Greece

Above: Flag of Romania

A church leader is often called the pastor, which is derived from the Latin word for shepherd.

In many western Christian traditions bishops carry a staff, which also serves as a symbol of the episcopal office, known as a crosier, which is modeled on the shepherd’s crook.

Above: A crosier

Above: A shepherd’s crook

Sheep are key symbols in: 

  • fables and nursery rhymes like The Wolf in Sheep’s Clothing, Little Bo Peep, Baa Baa Black Sheep, and Mary Had a Little Lamb

  • novels such as George Orwell’s Animal Farm and Haruki Murakami’s A Wild Sheep Chase

Above: Eric Arthur Blair (aka George Orwell) (1903 – 1950)

Above: Haruki Murakami

Above: Japanese first edition of A Wild Sheep Chase

  • songs such as Bach’s “Schafe können sicher weiden” (sheep may safely graze) and Pink Floyd’s “Sheep

Above: Johann Sebastian Bach (1685 – 1750)

  • poems like William Blake’s “The Lamb

Above: William Blake (1757 – 1827)

According to data from 2017, the number of cattle in Turkey is 16 million, 105 thousand, the number of sheep is 33 million, 677 thousand, and the number of goats is 10 million, 636 thousand.

The total milk production amounted to 20 million, 699 thousand tons, of which 1.344 million tons were produced from sheep.

The production of red meat was 1,126,403 tons, of which 100,058 tons were met by sheep.

Above: Flag of Turkey

In the region of Uşak, there are 376,104 sheep and 4,260 sheep-raising businesses.

Above: Ancient Phrygian Cilandiras bridge in Uşak Province

In sheep breeding, the main objective is undoubtedly economic production and/or breeding.

In order to achieve this goal, environmental factors (maintenance, nutrition, shelter, health protection, etc.) that will have an impact on yields must be improved or the genetic makeup of animals must be improved or both of them should be addressed together.

The desired production goal is often not achieved by improving either environmental conditions or the genetic makeup alone.

For this reason, firstly, breeds suitable for the existing region and the conditions of the business should be selected, while at the same time appropriate environmental conditions must be provided for these breeds.

Besides strategic importance, agriculture is one of the most important sectors in Turkey for many reasons, such as the high number of people living in rural areas, traditional conception of production, employment opportunities and contribution to economy.

Uşak has a population of 500,000 (2016 census) and is the capital of Uşak Province.

Uşak is situated at a distance of 210 km (130 mi) from Izmir, the region’s principal metropolitan centre and port city.

Benefiting from its location at the crossroads of the Central Anatolian plateau and the coastal Aegean region, and from a climate and agricultural production incorporating elements of both of these zones, Uşak has also traditionally had a strong industrial base.

In pre-industrial times, Uşak was already a major center of production and export, particularly of Ushak carpets.

Ushak carpets are also called Holbein carpets in reference to the 16th century painter Hans Holbein the Younger who depicted them in minute detail in his paintings, reflecting their popularity in European markets.

Above: Self-portrait, Hans Holbein the Younger (1497 – 1543)

At least since the 17th century there was trade between Uşak and the Dutch Republic as reflected in the rug shown thrown over the bannister in Vermeer’s painting “The Procuress“.

Above: Flag of the Netherlands

The rug was probably produced in Uşak and covers a third of the painting and shows medallions and leaves.

Above: Self-portrait, Johannes Vermeer (1632 – 1675)

Above: Johannes Vermeer’s The Procuress, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Dresden, Germany

The level of international popularity attained by Uşak’s carpets became such that the word “Ushak” is considered an English word of Turkic origin.

Although Uşak’s carpet patterns have evolved since then, large-scale weaving still continues and the name of the city still has an important presence in the market for carpets, both hand-woven and industrial.

On the other hand, the district of Eşme, which is also in Uşak Province, is famous for its kilims.

Above: Uşak Holbein carpet

Above: A kilim – a tapestry-woven carpet

Uşak was the first city in Turkey to have an urban electricity network, and the first city where a collective labour relations agreement was signed, during the Ottoman era, between leather industry employees and workers.

It was here that the first factory of Republican Turkey, a sugar refinery, was set up through a private sector initiative among local businessmen.

The tradition of industriousness continues today in Uşak.

In the city center, there is the Uşak Organized Textile Industrial Zone and the Mixed (Leather) Organized Industrial Zone. 

Above: Uşak

Uşak is an industrial city producing yarn, raw and printed cloth, fiber, blanket, leather, ceramics and carpets.

There are 127 schools and institutions in Uşak, including primary and secondary education and vocational and technical education. 

Uşak University was established on 17 December 2006.

Above: Logo of Uşak University

In the early 20th century, mercury was discovered in Uşak.

Above: Liquid mercury

Among other district centers in Uşak Province, Banaz is the largest and is notable for its varied agricultural production as well as for its forests. 

Above: Banaz train station

Meanwhile Ulubey’s canyon is a natural site attracting many visitors.

Above: Ulubey Canyon

In 2015, the total number of sheep raising businesses registered in Uşak Food Agriculture and Livestock Provincial Directorate was 4,260.

The sheep raising businesses’ average time of being involved in the activity of sheep raising is 9.8 years.

When the reasons for them to be involved in sheep raising are examined, it is seen that for 54% of them it is the sole source of income, 25.6% of them have to support their families and 12.4% love doing it.

81.1% learned sheep raising from their ancestors.

77.4% are members of the Association of Breeding Sheep and Goat Raisers while 5.6% are not.

35.4% provide their breeding animals from both their herds and other herds, 25.6% provide them only from their own herds, 34.5% provide from other herds and 0.5% from other cities.

90% of the shepherds are from among the family members and 6.5% of them are hired.

Of the shepherds, 89.5% are males and 4% are females.

When the shepherds’ level of education is examined, it is seen that 3% of them are illiterate, 2.8% are just literate, 27.9% are elementary school graduates, 1.7% are middle school graduates and 1.2% are high school graduates.

There are almost no university graduates amongst sheep breeders in the country.

Of the participating sheep raising businesses, 46.3% use metal waterers and 42% use plastic waterers.

Of the businesses, 49% use wooden mangers and 43.6% use metal mangers.

They are followed by plastic and cement mangers (12% and 10%, respectively).

As the source of water, 69% of the sheep raising businesses use fountains, 21% use lakes and 4.2% use well water.

90% of sheep pens are located in villages.

61% of the pens are independently located away from the farm buildings.

69% of the roofs of the pens are constructed with tiles.

60% of the walls of the pens are built of bricks.

77% of the floors of the pens are soil.

59% of the pens possess a ventilation chimney.

59% of the pens possess no shade for the sheep.

88% of the pens possess no baths for the beasts.

Only 23% of sheep actually graze for their fodder.

80% of sheep spend their nights outdoors.

95% of sheep pens have a hayloft.

44% of the sheep pens are complete enclosures.

88% of the sheep pens lack milking facilities.

82% of the pens are cleaned every winter.

89% of the pens are aired out every winter.

In Uşak, the mating of sheep is performed by using both the free insemination and controlled mating.

The businesses prefer the free insemination method with 89.0% and controlled mating with 6.1% and class style with 0.7%.

While 80.4% of the businesses keep rams within the herd throughout the year, 15.4% of them keep them in the herd during the period of mating of sheep.

The period of meeting of sheep ends in September with 48% and there are some businesses ending their sheep mating period in October or November.

The time of insemination is at night with 63.6% and towards the end of the evening with 10.5%.

Mating of sheep is performed in the village (14.5%), the summer range (3.3%), on grazing land (6.8%) and in the sheep pen (64.3%).

The number of sheep reserved for a ram is 25 on average.

In Uşak, free insemination is used for the mating of sheep with 89.0%; in 80.4% of the businesses, rams are kept in the herd throughout the year and 15.4% of them keep rams in the herd only in the sheep mating period.

Depending on the time of mating of sheep, births to lambs are given in December (74.6%), January (9.1%), February (4.7%) and other months (5.6%).

In 84.9% of the sheep raising businesses, care of the umbilical cord is not performed.

While 31% of the businesses wean their lambs when they are three months old, 24.5% of them let lambs suck their mothers for five months.

Of the businesses, 76% do not perform milking until lambs are weaned.

A majority of the sheep-raising businesses in Uşak (62.2%) stated that they start extra feeding in the first month of the birth.

While 42.7% of the businesses start milking in May, 36.4% start in April and 7.9% start in March.

While a majority of the businesses (52%) end milking in August, 17.7% end it in July and 15.4% in September.

While a high majority of the businesses (81.6%) perform single milking a day, 9.6% of the businesses perform two milkings.

The time of milking is morning in 22.1% of the businesses, afternoon-evening in 51.3% of the businesses and morning-evening in 13.8% of the businesses.

While milking is usually performed by family members (83.7%), in some businesses shepherds (5.8%) perform milking and in 1.6% of the businesses this is done by milkers.

In 5.6% of the businesses, milking is performed by females and males together, in 77.4% of them only by females and in 4.7% by males.

In 67.1% of the businesses udder cleaning is not done and in 20.7% it is done.

Above: Sheep dairy farm, Aveyron, France

Sheep are clipped once a year.

Clipping of sheep is performed in Uşak in different months (May, June, August and September).

May and June are preferred more.

Clipping is usually performed by the owner of the herd (80.2%).

While clipping is mostly performed with a machine with 66%, a clipper is used in 29.6%.

When the information about extra feeding before the mating of sheep is examined, it is seen that while 36.1% of the businesses carry out extra feeding before the mating of sheep and 59% of them don’t.

The businesses carrying out extra feeding do this with rams and sheep (20%), with only rams (16.1%) and with only sheep (12%).

The most prominent sources of feed of the sheep raising businesses are: factory feed, particle feed, chaff, straw, or silage.

In extra feeding, the most commonly used source of it is factory feed (30.8) followed by particle feed (15.2%).

In the winter feeding of sheep, mostly barley is used (73.9%).

Some businesses use wheat, factory feed, beet pulp, cotton pulp, silage, tare, alfalfa, oat, hay and straw together with barley.

In pregnant sheep, while the rate of businesses performing extra feeding is 54.3%, 39.6% do not perform extra feeding.

The rate of extra feeding is 12% at the beginning of pregnancy, 9.6% at the middle of pregnancy and 36.4% at the end of pregnancy.

It was found that the rate of the businesses performing extra feeding to animals before the mating of sheep is 23.5%.

In the sheep raising businesses, 55.2% of the milk is used in cheese production.

The rest is used to make yogurt and to meet the needs of their own families (milk, yogurt and cheese).

Above: Feta cheese

Of the lambs obtained in the sheep raising businesses, 58.3% are sold to tradesmen after they have been weaned, 15.6% are fed up in the business, 15.6% are spared as breeding animals, and 10.5% are either sold to tradesmen, or sold as breeding animals, or fed up in the business.

Vaccination programs applied by sheep raising businesses in Uşak include enterotoxemia, brucella, smallpox, foot-and-mouth, plague, and bluetongue vaccines.

Of the sheep-raising businesses, 90% have a health protection schedule.

The control of vaccine programs is done by veterinary surgeons (84.1%), by veterinary health officials (3.0%) and by the business owners themselves (9.1%).

The sheep-raising businesses stated that they conduct disinfection in sheep pens.

The rate of the businesses conducting cleaning and disinfection in spring, summer, autumn and winter is 63.2%, 7.5%, 15.9% and %0.5, respectively and 72.7% of the disinfection is done by lime, 13.3% by chemical medicine and 2.3% by burning.

While the rate of those which have bath pits for sheep in the sheep pen is 8.4%, the rate of those which do not have bath pits is 91.6%.

The rate of those bathing their sheep at least once a year is 18.6% and the rate of those bathing their sheep more than once is 5.4%.

The rate of those conducting struggles with parasites at least once is 29.4%, the rate of those conducting it twice is 64.8% and the rate of those doing it more than three times is 5.8%.

It was found that 59.8% of the sheep-raising businesses get information from veterinary surgeons when they want to use any medicine, 38.1% from the City and Provincial Directorates of Agriculture, and 1.0% from other business owners in the village.

The rate of the sheep-raising businesses which apply all of the protective vaccines was found to be 64.9%.

The businesses apply their vaccines according to schedule with 84%, while 16% of them apply them randomly or when a disease emerges.

In 94.3% of the businesses, veterinary surgeons give the vaccines, while 5.7% themselves give the vaccines.

As breeders generally think that health protection program generally bring extra costs, they can ignore such protection programs.

As a result of this, increases occur in lamb deaths, deterioration in growth and decline in yields by adults, leading to important losses.

The distribution of the problems that seem to be important for sheep raising is as follows:

  • high cost of feed + inadequate and poor quality grazing lands (80.2%)
  • inadequate and poor quality grazing lands (6.4%)
  • high cost of feed + inadequate and poor quality gazing lands + animal diseases (3.5%)
  • high cost of feed + inadequate and poor quality grazing lands + low sale prices (3.3%)
  • high cost of feed (3.2%) and animal diseases and other reasons (3.4%).

The sheep raising businesses made the following suggestions to make sheep raising more profitable:

  • marketing price + improving grazing lands (30.0%)
  • improving the genetic make-up of the herd + marketing price + improving grazing lands + expanding land areas for the cultivation of feed crops (16.2%)
  • improving the generic make-up of the herd + marketing + improving grazing lands (11.3%)
  • marketing price + improving grazing lands + expanding land areas for the cultivation of feed crops (9.6%)
  • only marketing (8.2%)
  • only improving grazing lands (4.4%)
  • improving the genetic make-up of the herd + marketing price + cheap credit + improving grazing lands + expanding land areas for the cultivation of feed crops (7.1%)
  • marketing price + cheap credit + improving grazing lands (5.2%)
  • expanding land areas for the cultivation of feed crops (5.7%)
  • feed + supply of breeding animals, improving and cheap credit (2.3%).

In 3% of all the cultivated lands, feed crops are grown while in countries having a developed animal breeding sector, nearly 25% of the cultivated lands are allocated to cultivation of feed crops and even in some countries, this rate can reach 50%.

On the other hand, the main problems of the sheep raising businesses were found to be as follows:

  • marketing (39.1%)
  • high feed prices (23.1%)
  • inadequate grazing lands (21.8%)
  • credit problem (9.2%)
  • education and health problems (6.8%)

Of these businesses, 51.4% want a solution to the marketing problem, 15.1% to the grazing land problem, 14.7% to the credit problem, 10% to the health problem, 7.7% to the problem of breeding animals.

In Uşak, the Pırlak breed is widely raised (90.7%).

Though all of the business owners are literate, there are almost no university graduate business owners.

Sheep breeding primarily relies on grazing lands.

The mating of sheep is generally performed through free insemination.

The sheep pens, waterers and mangers possessed by the businesses are generally made up of regional and cheap materials.

The sizes such as length, width and height are sufficient and the sheep pens are usually built in the village under, next to the house.

The income sources of the businesses are milk, yoghurt, sale of breeding and butchery animals.

Yet, there are serious problems regarding packaging and marketing of products.

It can be argued that there is a certain level of consciousness of the animal health and anticipated importance is attached to vaccination.

The most important problems of sheep breeding are high feed prices, low product prices, inadequate and poor quality of grazing lands, and animal diseases.

In order to make sheep raising more attractive, the prices of the products should be increased, grazing lands should be improved, the genetic structure of the herd should be improved, the amount of land area where feed crops are cultivated should be expanded and suitable credit conditions should be provided.

On the other hand, they need to be informed about sheep mating, lamb growing, stock, milking hygiene, general sheep feeding practices and marketing.

Moreover, new breeds with better birth and milk efficiency can be introduced to the breeders apart from the Pırlak breed, works should be conducted on how to enhance birth efficiency, on out-of-season lambing and on intensive lamb breeding.

The herd health management and preventive medicine programs are designed to minimize anticipated problems and to enhance herd yield and may change from business to business.

Therefore, they should be designed to increase birth efficiency, decrease the rate of death, accelerate the growth, improve carcass quality, improve care and feeding practices to increase the amount and quality of milk, enhance animal raising techniques, improve vaccination program and parasite control and manure management.

For the successful application of health protection programs and accomplishment of the anticipated outcomes, there is a need for conscious and educated breeders.

In February 2018, the government of Turkey announced that it would “distribute 300 sheep to every farmer” in Turkey who wants it in a bid to revive the livestock sector, to encourage farmers not to move to urban areas, and to ease high meat prices, Agriculture and Livestock Minister Ahmet Eşref Fakıbaba stated.

Above: Ahmet Eşref Fakıbaba

We will distribute 300 sheep to every farmer.

Our priority is preventing more farmers from moving to urban areas, not to motivate people who live in the cities to move to villages.

When distributing those animals, regions with pastures will be given priority,” Fakıbaba said, speaking at a sector summit in the eastern province of Kars hosted by Hürriyet and Denizbank.

Above: Logo of Hürriyet newspaper

He also noted that the government has been working on how to curb imports and support animal breeding, amid criticism of rising imports of meat and struggling domestic production.

We have done the math.

If we provide 300 sheep and a year later they give birth to 300 lambs, breeders will keep those lambs and the state will buy back the sheep to redistribute to other farmers,” Fakıbaba said.

He also added that the government will also pay for the veterinary costs, social security and the minimum wage.

I have not heard what has happened to this notion since.

Sheep shearing is the process in which a worker (a shearer) cuts off the woolen fleece of a sheep.

After shearing, wool classers separate the wool into four main categories:

  • fleece (which makes up the vast bulk)
  • broken
  • bellies
  • locks

The quality of fleeces is determined by a technique known as wool classing, whereby a qualified person, called a wool classer, groups wools of similar grading together to maximize the return for the farmer or sheep owner.

In Australia, before being auctioned, all Merino fleece wool is objectively measured for average diameter (micron), yield (including the amount of vegetable matter), staple length, staple strength, and sometimes colour and comfort factor.

Above: Machine shearing a Merion sheep, Yallingup, Western Australia.
The shearer is using a sling for back support.

Wool straight off a sheep is known as “raw wool”, “greasy wool” or “wool in the grease“.

This wool contains a high level of valuable lanolin, as well as the sheep’s dead skin and sweat residue, and generally also contains pesticides and vegetable matter from the animal’s environment.

Before the wool can be used for commercial purposes, it must be scoured, a process of cleaning the greasy wool.

Scouring may be as simple as a bath in warm water or as complicated as an industrial process using detergent and alkali in specialized equipment.

In northwest England, special potash pits were constructed to produce potash used in the manufacture of a soft soap for scouring locally produced white wool.

Above: Potash, Yorkshire, England

Vegetable matter in commercial wool is often removed by chemical carbonization. 

In less-processed wools, vegetable matter may be removed by hand and some of the lanolin left intact through the use of gentler detergents.

This semi-greasy wool can be worked into yarn and knitted into particularly water-resistant mittens or sweaters, such as those of the Aran Island fishermen.

Lanolin removed from wool is widely used in cosmetic products, such as hand creams.

Above: Wool before and after scouring

Typically each adult sheep is shorn once each year (a sheep may be said to have been “shorn” or “sheared“, depending upon dialect).

The annual shearing most often occurs in a shearing shed, a facility especially designed to process often hundreds and sometimes more than 3,000 sheep per day.

Sheep are shorn in all seasons, depending on the climate, management requirements and the availability of a wool classer and shearers.

Ewes are normally shorn prior to lambing in the warmer months, but consideration is typically made as to the welfare of the lambs by not shearing during cold climate winters.

However, in high country regions, pre-lamb shearing encourages ewes to seek shelter among the hillsides so that newborn lambs aren’t completely exposed to the elements.

Shorn sheep tolerate frosts well, but young sheep especially will suffer in cold, wet windy weather (even in cold climate summers).

In this event they are sheltered for several nights until the weather clears.

Some sheep may also be shorn with stud combs, commonly known as cover combs, which leave more wool on the animal in colder months, giving greater protection.

Sheep shearing is also considered a sport with competitions held around the world. 

It is often done between spring and summer.

Above: Shorn sheep

(Sheep shearing and wool handling competitions are held regularly in parts of the world, particularly Ireland, the UK, South Africa, New Zealand and Australia.

Above: Flag of Ireland

Above: Flag of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Above: Flag of South Africa

Above: Flag of New Zealand

Above: Flag of Australia

As sheep shearing is an arduous task, speed shearers, for all types of equipment and sheep, are usually very fit and well trained.

In Wales a sheep shearing contest is one of the events of the Royal Welsh Show, the country’s premier agricultural show held near Builth Wells.

Above: Flag of Wales

Above: Royal Welsh Agricultural Show Ground, Llanelwedd, Bulith Wells, Powys, Wales

The world’s largest sheep shearing and wool handling contest, the Golden Shears, is held in Wairarapa, New Zealand.

Above: Golden Shears Competition, 2007

The shearing World Championships are hosted by different countries every two to three years and eight countries have hosted the event.

The first World Championships were held at the Bath & West Showground, England, in 1977, and the first Machine-Shearing winner was Roger Cox from New Zealand.

Above: Bath and West Showground

Above: (left foreground) Roger Cox

Other countries that have hosted the sheep shearing World Championships have been:

  • New Zealand (3 times)
  • England (3 times)

Above: Flag of England

  • Australia (twice)
  • Wales
  • Ireland
  • Scotland

Above: Flag of Scotland

  • South Africa
  • Norway

Above: Flag of Norway

Out of 13 World Championships, New Zealand have won the team machine contest ten times.

Famous New Zealand sheep-shearer David Fagan has been World Champion a record five times.

Above: David Fagan (middle foreground)

In October 2008 the event was hosted in Norway.

It was the first time ever that the event was hosted by a non-English speaking country.

Above: Coat of arms of Norway

The newly crowned World Machine Shearing champion is Paul Avery from New Zealand.

New Zealand also won the team event.

Above: Paul Avery

The traditional blade-shears World Champion is Ziewilelle Hans from South Africa.

A record 29 countries competed at the 2008 event.

World Blade Shearing has been dominated by South African and Lesotho shearers, Fine Wool machine shearing dominated by Australian shearers, and New Zealand dominating the Strong Wool machine shearing.)

Today large flocks of sheep are mustered, inspected and possibly treated for parasites, such as lice, before shearing can start. then shorn by professional shearing teams working eight-hour days, most often in spring, by machine shearing.

These contract-teams consist of shearers, shed hands and a cook (in the more isolated areas).

Their working hours and wages are regulated by industry awards.

A working day starts at 0730 and the day is divided into four “runs” of two hours each.

Smoko” breaks are a half-hour each and a lunch break is taken at midday for one hour.

Most shearers are paid on a piece-rate per sheep.

Shearers who “tally” more than 200 sheep per day are known as “gun shearers“.

Typical mass shearing of sheep today follows a well-defined workflow:

  • remove the wool
  • throw the fleece onto the wool table
  • skirt, roll and class the fleece
  • place it in the appropriate wool bin
  • press and store the wool until it is transported.

In 1984, Australia became the last country in the world to permit the use of wide combs, due to previous Australian Workers’ Union rules.

Although they were once rare in sheds, women now take a large part in the shearing industry by working as pressers, wool rollers, rouseabouts, wool classers and shearers.

A sheep is caught by the shearer, from the catching pen, and taken to his “stand” on the shearing board.

It is usually shorn using a mechanical handpiece.

(Whatever device is used, shearers must be careful to keep it clean so as to prevent the spread of disease amongst a flock.

Blade shearing has recently made a resurgence in Australia and the UK but mostly for sport rather than commercial shearing.

Some competitions have attracted almost 30 competitors and there have even been shows created just for blade shearers to compete in.

Blade shears consist of two blades arranged similarly to scissors except that the hinge is at the end farthest from the point (not in the middle).

The cutting edges pass each other as the shearer squeezes them together and shear the wool close to the animal’s skin.

Blade shears are still used today but in a more limited way.

Blade shears leave some wool on a sheep and this is more suitable for cold climates, such as the Canterbury high country in the South Island of New Zealand where approximately half a million sheep are still shorn with blade shears each year.

Above: New Zealand

For those areas where no powered-machinery is available blade shears are the only option.

In Australia, blades are more commonly used to shear stud rams.

Above: Coat of arms of Australia

Machine shears, known as handpieces, operate in a similar manner to human hair clippers in that a power-driven toothed blade, known as a cutter, is driven back and forth over the surface of a comb and the wool is cut from the animal.

The original machine shears were powered by a fixed hand-crank linked to the handpiece by a shaft with only two universal joints, which afforded a very limited range of motion.

Later models have more joints to allow easier positioning of the handpiece on the animal.

Electric motors on each stand have generally replaced overhead gear for driving the handpieces.

The jointed arm is replaced in many instances with a flexible shaft.

Smaller motors allowed the production of shears in which the motor is in the handpiece.

These are generally not used by professional shearers as the weight of the motor and the heat generated by it becomes bothersome with long use.)

The wool is removed by following an efficient set of movements, devised by Godfrey Bowen in about 1950 (the Bowen Technique) or the Tally-Hi method developed in 1963 and promoted by the Australian Wool Corporation.

Above: NZ farmer / world-acclaimed sheep shearer Godfrey Bowen (1922 – 1994)

Sheep struggle less using the Tally-Hi method, reducing strain on the shearer and there is a saving of about 30 seconds in shearing each one.

The shearer begins by removing the belly wool, which is separated from the main fleece by a rouseabout, while the sheep is still being shorn.

A professional or “gun” shearer typically removes a fleece, without significantly marking or cutting the sheep, in two to three minutes, depending on the size and condition of the sheep — less than two minutes in elite competitive shearing.

The shorn sheep is released and removed from the board via a chute in the floor or in a wall, to an exterior counting-out pen.

The CSIRO (Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization) in Australia has developed a non-mechanical method of shearing sheep using an injected protein that creates a natural break in the wool fibres.

After fitting a retaining net to enclose the wool, sheep are injected with the protein.

When the net is removed after a week, the fleece has separated and is removed by hand. 

In some breeds a similar process occurs naturally

Once the entire fleece has been removed from the sheep, the fleece is thrown, clean side down, on to a wool table by a shed hand (commonly known in New Zealand and Australian sheds as a rouseabout or rousie).

The wool table top consists of slats spaced approximately 12 cm apart.

This enables short pieces of wool, the locks and other debris, to gather beneath the table separately from the fleece.

The fleece is then skirted by one or more wool rollers to remove the sweat fribs and other less desirable parts of the fleece.

The removed pieces largely consist of shorter, seeded, burry or dusty wool etc. which is still useful in the industry.

As such they are placed in separate containers and sold along with fleece wool.

Other items removed from the fleece on the table, such as faeces, skin fragments or twigs and leaves, are discarded a short distance from the wool table so as not to contaminate the wool and fleece.

Above: Throwing a fleece onto a wool table

Following the skirting of the fleece, it is folded, rolled and examined for its quality in a process known as wool classing, which is performed by a registered and qualified wool classer.

Based on its type, the fleece is placed into the relevant wool bin ready to be pressed (mechanically compressed) when there is sufficient wool to make a wool bale.

Above: Wool sorting bins

In some primitive sheep (for example in the Shetlands), there is a natural break in the growth of the wool in spring.

By late spring this causes the fleece to begin to peel away from the body, and it may then be plucked by hand without cutting – this is known as rooing.

Individual sheep may reach this stage at slightly different times.

Above: Shetland sheep

Animal welfare organizations have raised concerns about the abuse of sheep during shearing, and have advocated against the selling and buying of wool products.

Sheep shearers are paid by the number of sheep shorn, not by the hour, and there are no requirements for formal training or accreditation.

Because of this it is alleged that speed is prioritised over precision and care of the animal.

In 2013, an anonymous shearer reported instances of animal abuse by workers, an allegation to which an Australian Worker’s Union representative added that he had witnessed “shearers gouge eyes and break sheep jaws.”

Australian Wool Innovation insisted that animal welfare was a priority among shearers. 

The following year, the RSPCA (Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) began a cruelty investigation following the release of video footage that PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) said was taken in more than a dozen shearing sheds in New South Wales, Victoria and South Australia. 

Above: Logo of the RSPCA (Australia)

The Guardian reported that the video showed “sheep being roughly handled, punched in the face and stamped upon.

One sheep was beaten with a hammer while another was shown having a deep cut crudely sewn up.

The Shearing Contractors Association of Australia “applauded” the investigation.

Wool Producers Australia President Geoff Fisken said the behavior shown in the video was “unacceptable and unsupportable“, but that “we’re sure it doesn’t portray the 99.9% majority of wool shearers – and those shearers would be appalled by it as well“.

More recent footage and images of Australian workers abusing sheep have been released by anonymous sources, some of which was included in Dominion, a recent Australian documentary on animal farm abuses.

No comment has been made about this by the Shearing Contractors Association of Australia.

A culture has evolved out of the practice of sheep shearing, especially in post-colonial Australia and New Zealand.

The sheep-shearing feast is the setting for Act IV of William Shakespeare’s A Winter’s Tale

Above: William Shakespeare (1564 – 1616)

Thomas Tusser provides doggerel verse for the occasion:

Wife make us a dinner, spare flesh neither corne,
Make wafers and cakes, for our sheepe must be shorne,
At sheep shearing neighbors none other thing craue,
but good cheer and welcome, like neighbors to haue

Above: Thomas Tusser (1524 – 1580)

The expression that Australia’s wealth rode on the sheep’s back in parts of the 20th century no longer has the currency it once had.

Above: Jason returns with the Golden Fleece

The Golden Fleece, originally known as Shearing at Newstead, is an 1894 painting by the Australian artist Tom Roberts.

The painting depicts sheep shearers plying their trade in a timber shearing shed at Newstead North, a sheep station near Inverell on the Northern Tablelands of New South Wales.

Above: Tom Roberts’ The Golden Fleece, 1894

The same shed is depicted in another of Roberts’ works, Shearing Shed, Newstead (1894).

Above: Tom Roberts’ Shearing shed, Newstead, 1894

The painting was originally titled Shearing at Newstead, but was renamed The Golden Fleece after the Golden Fleece of Greek mythology to honour the wool industry and the nobility of the shearers.

This was in keeping with Roberts’ conscious idealisation of the Australian pastoral worker and landscape.

Above: Tom Roberts (1856 – 1931)

The painting, said to be “an icon of Australian art“, is part of the collection of the Art Gallery of New South Wales.

Above: Art Gallery of New South Wales, The Domain, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

During Australia’s long weekend in June 2010, 111 machine shearers and 78 blade shearers shorn 6,000 Merino ewes and 178 rams at the historic 72-stand North Tuppal station.

Above: North Tuppal Station, Tocumwal, New South Wales, Australia

Along with the shearers there were 107 wool handlers and penners-up and more than 10,000 visitors to witness this event in the restored shed.

Many stations across Australia no longer carry sheep due to lower wool prices, drought and other disasters, but their shearing sheds remain, in a wide variety of materials and styles, and have been the subject of books and documentation for heritage authorities.

Some farmers are reluctant to remove either the equipment or the sheds, and many unused sheds remain intact.

Australia’s sheep shearers have long been celebrated in verse and art as the hard men of the country’s inland, but now they are fleeing because the animals have grown too big.

The pursuit of a crossbreed with both a full fleece of wool and that can then be sold for meat has created sheep almost double the weight they were 35 years ago.

As a result, battered shearers are deserting in droves.

Of more than 4,000 wool handlers trained in 2019, fewer than half have stayed in the job, according to Australian Wool Innovation, the industry body.

When I started shearing in the late Eighties, you had to be careful with merino ewes so you didn’t break their front legs while handling them.“, Phil Rourke, a veteran shearer said.

But now the average merino ewe is so heavy and strong that you can’t even tip it without busting your guts.

Rourke’s view that sheep are growing to an unmanageable size is echoed by shearers’ associations and livestock specialists.

Jason Letchford, Secretary of the Shearing Contractors Association of Australia, said that farmers faced the prospect of being without hundreds of shearers for the coming season.

It is absolutely a concern for us at the moment.“, Letchford told The Land newspaper.

We have got a national flock of 68 million sheep, so you are talking about 10% of the nation’s sheep that won’t be shorn by the workforce we would normally have here to do them.”

Glenn Haynes, the Association’s Executive Officer, said the size of sheep was the biggest reason young people gave up.

Some even leave within a couple of weeks.“, he added.

The notion that Australia’s shearers might one day be scared off by sheep would have been unimaginable to the impressionist Tom Roberts, whose celebrated 1890 work “Shearing the Rams” depicted the strapping shearers behind the wool boom.

The much-loved bush song “Click Go the Shears“, which appeared a year later, also romanced their life.

In 1985, the average weight of a Dorset ewe in Australia was 55kg, but by 2015 it has increased to 90kg.

Rourke said that during the busy season he woke up unable to feel his arms.

You are getting the daylights kicked out of you all day.”

Approximately 90% of the world’s sheep produce wool.

One sheep produces anywhere from 2 to 30 pounds of wool annually.

The wool from one sheep is called a fleece.

From many sheep, a clip.

The amount of wool that a sheep produces depends upon its breed, genetics, nutrition and shearing interval.

Lambs produce less wool than mature animals.

Due to their larger size, rams usually produce more wool than ewes of the same breed or type.

Long wool sheep usually produce the heaviest fleeces because their fibers, though coarser, grow the longest.

Hand spinners tend to prefer wool from the long wool breeds because it is easier to spin.

Some sheep produce very coarse fibers.

This type of wool is called carpet wool, and as the name suggests is used to make carpets and tapestries.

According to the International Wool Textile Organization (IWTO), 41% of world wool production is classified as coarse wools.

Above: Coarse wool ewes

Medium wool sheep, raised more for meat than fiber, produce the lightest weight, least valuable fleeces.

Medium wool is usually made into blankets, sweaters, or socks or it is felted.

According to the IWTO, 22% of world wool production is classified as medium wools.

Above: Medium wool ewes

Fine wool sheep produce fleeces which usually have the greatest value due to their smaller fiber diameter and versatility of use.

Garments made from fine wool are less likely to itch.

According to the IWTO, 37% of world wool production is classified as fine wools.

Above: Fine wool rams

Hair sheep shed their coats and produce no usable fibers.

The “fleeces” from hair sheep and hair x wool crosses should be discarded.

Their inclusion in a wool clip can contaminate the entire clip.

Even raising wool sheep along side hair sheep or other shedding animals could potentially affect fleece quality of the wooled sheep.

Hair will not accept dye.

Above: Fleeces

The value of wool is based on its suitability for specific end uses, as well as the fundamentals of the world wool market.

Raw wool is usually purchased on the basis of grade.

Grade denotes the average fiber diameter and length of individual fibers.

The grade (or price) is reduced if the wool is dirty and contains a lot of vegetable matter or other contaminants.

Above: Learning to grade wool

In the commercial market, white wool is more valuable than coloured wool because it can be dyed any colour.

Even the wool from sheep with white faces is more valuable than the wool from sheep with dark or moddled faces because the fleeces from non-white face sheep may contain coloured wool or hairs which cannot be dyed.

In contrast, naturally-colored wools are often favoured in the niche markets.

Large producers of wool usually sell their wools to warehouses or directly to wool mills.

Sometimes the wool is sold on a clean (scoured) basis with the lower quality belly wool being removed from the clip.

Small producers usually sell (raw) through wool pools.

A wool pool is a collection point for wool from many producers.

At the pool, wool is sorted and packaged into different lots.

The entire pool is sold to one mill, often via silent bid.

Above: Wool at a wool mill

Some producers sell their wool to hand spinners or have it made into yarn or blankets.

When prices are low, some producers throw their wool away or give it to their shearer.

Above: Unloading wool at the wool pool

In 2019, the average price paid for wool sold in the United States was $1.89 per pound (grease) for a total value of $45.4 million.

In 2019, 24 million pounds of wool was harvested from 3.32 million head of sheep and lambs.

Above: Flag of the United States of America

The average fleece weight was 7.2 pounds (3.27 kg), compared to almost 10 lbs. (4.5 kg) in Australia.

Above: Australia

In the US, Nevada sheep boasted the heaviest fleece weights: 9.2 lbs. in 2019.

Above: Flag of Nevada

Sheep producers can get more money for their wool if they direct market it to hand spinners or add value to it.

In niche markets, there is no upper limit as to what wool can sell for.

Above: Wool buyers’ room at a wool auction, Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia

Wool is a freely-traded international commodity, subject to global supply and demand.

While wool represents only 3% of world fiber production, it is important to the economy and way of life in many countries.

Above: Wool garments

Though China is the largest producer of wool, Australia dominates the world wool market.

China is the largest wool buyer.

Above: Flag of China

The United States accounts for less than 1% of the world’s wool production and is a net importer of wool.

In the US, the top states for wool production are California, Colorado, Wyoming and Utah.

Above: Flag of California

Above: Flag of Colorado

Above: Flag of Wyoming

Above: Flag of Utah

Most people know that wool comes from sheep, but how it transforms from a sheep’s fluffy coat to material that is ready to be worn is a journey.

Wool goes through a multi-step process to clean it, regularize it, and transform it into soft yarn.

Although machinery can make the process much faster today, in most ways the process is the same as how people have been preparing wool for centuries.

Above: Sjolingstad Woolen Mill Museum, Norway

Every year, at the end of winter, sheep farmers shear their sheep, using an electric tool similar to a razor that removes all of the sheep’s fleece in one piece.

A single sheep’s annual fleece can weigh over 8 kilos, although most are around 3 – 4 kilos.

When done with care, shearing doesn’t harm the sheep.

Shearing leaves them with a thin, cool coat for the summer months.

Without shearing, the sheep’s fleece can severally overgrow, such as the famous case of “Shrek the Sheep”.

Above: Shrek the sheep

(Shrek (27 November 1994 – 6 June 2011) was a Merino wether (castrated male sheep) belonging to Bendigo Station, a sheep station near Tarras, New Zealand, who gained international fame in 2004, after he avoided being caught and shorn for six years.

Above: Bendigo Station, Central Otago, South Island, New Zealand

Merinos are normally shorn annually, but Shrek apparently hid in caves, avoiding muster (round-up).

He was named after the fictional ogre in books and films of the same name.

Above: Shrek the ogre

After finally being caught on 15 April 2004, the wether was shorn by a professional in 20 minutes on 28 April.

The shearing was broadcast on national television in New Zealand.

Above: Coat of arms of New Zealand

His fleece contained enough wool to make 20 large men’s suits, weighing 27 kg (60 lb) – an average Merino fleece weighs around 4.5 kg (10 lb), with exceptional weights up to around 15 kg (33 lb).

Shrek became a national icon.

He was taken to Parliament to meet New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark, in May 2004, to celebrate his 10th birthday.

Above: Helen Clark

In November 2006, 30 months after his initial shearing, Shrek was shorn again, on an iceberg floating off the coast of Dunedin, New Zealand.

Shrek was euthanized on 6 June 2011 on a veterinarian’s advice.

He was 16.)

Above: Shrek, 2009

The wool is then sorted and prepared for cleaning.

A simple step of washing the wool with removes dirt, other contaminants, and natural oils from the wool.

Some of these by-products of cleaning the wool get used for other purposes.

Lanolin, a wax secreted by sheep that helps to protect their wool, is included in many beauty products such as skin moisturizer.

Above: Tins of wool fat, Centre touristique de la Laine et de la Mode, Verviers, Belgium

Next, the wool fibers go through carding, a process that pulls them through fine metal teeth.

Sheep wool is naturally curly.

Carding straightens out the fibers and makes them soft and fluffy.

Originally, carding would be done by hand using two metal combs.

Today, most manufacturers use machines to card large batches of wool more quickly.

By the end of carding, the wool fibers are lined up into a thin, flat piece.

These sheets can then be drawn into long, thin pieces called rovings.

Spinning turns the wool pieces into a material that is usable.

Spinning uses a wheel to spin 2 – 5 strands of wool together.

This forms long, strong pieces of wool that you would recognize as yarn.

Different processes create different kinds of yarn that work for distinct final products.

Worsted spinning, for example, makes a smooth, thin yarn that’s perfect for suits and other garments made with the finer material.

Woolen spinning, on the other hand, makes a thicker yarn that is perfect for knitting.

Some wool yarn is sold directly to consumers, who use it to craft handmade scarves, sweaters and other clothing.

Other yarn forms the raw material for all kinds of wool products, from shoes to coats.

It is woven into pieces of fabric that are ready to be shaped by fashion designers.

Wool quickly absorbs water, which makes it very easy to dye.

It can be dyed at almost any stage of the process, depending on what the final product will be.

Simply submerging the wool into boiling water with the dye material, or applying colorful dyes directly to the fabric, produces the desired colour.

The process of transforming a sheep’s fleece into soft and cozy wool is truly an art form that needs to be carefully managed.

Although the process can be time-consuming, the end product carries many natural benefits. 

Domestication is when an organism is trained or adapted to live with people.

Domestication often changes the appearance and behavior of the organism.

While dogs were the first animal to be domesticated, sheep and goats are tied for second and are the first animals to be domesticated for agricultural purposes.

They were domesticated over 10,000 years ago.

Life expectancy is how long an organism is expected to live.

Typically, the life expectancy of an animal increases with size.

For example, cows usually live longer than sheep.

The life expectancy of sheep is similar to large breeds of dogs, about 10 to 12 years.

Some breeds are known for being longer-lived, e.g. Merino.

According to the Guinness Book of World Records, the oldest sheep lived to be 23.

She was a Merino.

However, the length of a sheep’s productive lifetime tends to be much less.

This is because a ewe’s productivity usually peaks between 3 and 6 years of age and begins to decline after the age of 7.

As a result, most ewes are removed from a flock before they would reach their natural life expectancy.

It is also necessary to get rid of older ewes in order to make room for younger ones.

The younger animals are usually genetically superior to the older ones.

In harsh environments (e.g. where forage is sparse), ewes are usually culled at a younger age because once their teeth start to wear and break down, it becomes more difficult for them to maintain their body condition and consume enough forage to feed their babies.

It is possible for a ewe to be productive past 10 years of age, if she is well-fed and managed and stays healthy and sound.

The approximate age of a sheep can be determined by examining their upper incisor teeth.

At birth, lambs have eight baby (or milk) teeth or temporary incisors arranged on their lower jaw.

They don’t have any teeth on their top jaw, only a dental pad.

At approximately one year of age, the central pair of baby teeth is replaced by a pair of permanent incisors.

At age 2, the second pair is replaced by permanent incisors.

At 3 and 4 years, the third and fourth pairs of baby teeth are replaced.

At approximately four years of age, a sheep has a full mouth of teeth.

As it ages past four, the incisor teeth will start to spread, wear, and eventually break.

When a ewe has lost some of her teeth, she’s called a “broken mouth” ewe.

When she’s lost all her teeth, she’s called a “gummer“.

A sheep with no incisor teeth can still survive because it uses mostly its molars for chewing feed.

However, it will have a harder time grazing, especially short vegetation.

A sheep that has rolled over onto its back is called a “cast” sheep.

It may not be able to get up without assistance.

This happens most commonly with short, stocky sheep with full fleeces on flat terrain.

Heavily pregnant ewes are most prone.

Cast sheep can become distressed and die within a short period of time if they are not rolled back into a normal position.

When back on their feet, they may need supported for a few minutes to ensure they are steady.

Vital signs are measures of various physiological statistics.

A sheep’s vital signs can help determine if it is sick or in distress.

The average body temperature of a healthy sheep is 102° – 103° Fahrenheit, with a heart rate of 60 to 90 beats per minute and a respiration rate of 12 to 20 breaths a minute.

Sheep are a prey animal.

When they are faced with danger, their natural instinct is to flee not fight.

Their strategy is to use avoidance and rapid flight to avoid being eaten.

Some primitive sheep breeds may be able to more effectively evade predators, as their natural instincts are stronger.

Domesticated sheep have come to rely on man for protection from predators.

After fleeing, sheep will reform their group and look at the predator.

They use their natural herding instinct to band together for safety.

A sheep that is by itself is vulnerable to attack.

Sheep tracks are never straight.

The winding of trails allows sheep to observe their backside first with one eye, then the other.

Sheep can spot dogs or other perceived forms of danger from 1,200 to 1,500 yards away.

Sheep have excellent senses.

Their wide angle of vision allows them to see predators.

They can direct their ears to the direction of sound.

They are very sensitive to what different predators smell like.

Sheep have an amazing tolerance for pain.

They do not show pain, because if they do, they will be more vulnerable to predators who look for those who are weak or injured.

The easiest way to tell the difference between a sheep and a goat is to look at their tails.

A goat’s tail goes up (unless it is sick, frightened or in distress.

A sheep’s tail hangs down and is often docked (shortened) for supposedly health and sanitary reasons.

Another big difference between a sheep and a goat is their foraging behaviour and diet selection.

Goats are natural browsers, preferring to eat leaves, twigs, vines and shrubs.

They are very agile and will stand on their hind legs to reach vegetation.

Goats like to eat the tops of plants.

Sheep are grazers, preferring to eat short tender grasses and clover.

Their dietary preference is forbs (broadleaf weeds) and they like to graze close to the soil surface.

Goats require and select a more nutritious diet.

Sheep and goats usually exhibit different behaviour.

Goats are naturally curious and independent, while sheep tend to be more distant and aloof.

Above: Pymgy goat, Fiesch, Valais, Switzerland

Sheep have a stronger flocking instinct and become very agitated if they are separated from the rest of the flock.

It is easier to keep sheep inside a fence than goats.

Sheep have a strong instinct to follow the sheep in front of them.

When one sheep decides to go somewhere, the rest of the flock usually follows, even if it is not a good “decision“.

For example, sheep will follow each other to slaughter.

If one sheep jumps over a cliff, the others are likely to follow.

Even from birth, lambs are conditioned to follow older members of the flock.

This instinct is “hard-wired” into sheep.

This is not something sheep “think” about.

There is a certain strain of sheep in Iceland known as leader sheep.

The Icelandic leader sheep is a separate line within the Icelandic breed of sheep.

Above: Flag of Iceland

As the name implies these sheep were leaders in their flocks.

The leadership ability runs in bloodlines and is equally in males and females.

Leader sheep are highly intelligent animals that have the ability and instinct to lead a flock home during difficult conditions.

Sheep of this strain have the ability, or instinct, to run in front of the flock, when it is driven home from the mountain pastures in autumn, from the sheep sheds to the winter pasture in the morning and back home in the evening, through heavy snowdrifts, over ice-covered ground, or across rivers.

Sometimes the leaders would take the whole flock of grazing sheep on winter pasture back to the farm, early in the day, if a blizzard was on its way.

They have an exceptional ability to sense danger.

There are many stories in Iceland of leader sheep saving many lives during the fall round-ups when blizzards threatened shepherds and flocks alike.

Sheep are gregarious.

They will usually stay in a group while grazing.

In fact, a sheep will become highly agitated if it is separated from the group.

It is the banding together in large groups which protects sheep from predators which will go after the outliers in the flock.

Sheep are a very social animal.

Animal behaviorists note that sheep require the presence of at least 4 or 5 sheep which, when grazing together, maintain a visual link to each other.

Flocking instinct is strongest in the fine wool breeds, but exists in all sheep breeds to some extent.

It is the sheep’s flocking instinct that allows sheep herders to look after and move large numbers of sheep and lambs.

Due to their strong flocking instinct and failure to act independently of one another, sheep have been universally branded “stupid“.

But sheep are not stupid.

Their only protection from predators is to band together and follow the sheep in front of them.

If a predator is threatening the flock, this is not the time to act independently.

At the same time, there is a growing body of evidence that sheep may actually possess some smarts.

Hungry sheep on the Yorkshire Moors (Great Britain) taught themselves to roll 8 feet (3 meters) across hoof-proof metal cattle grids to raid villagers’ valley gardens.

Above: North Yorkshire Moors, England

According to a witness:

They lie down on their side or sometimes their back and just roll over and over the grids until they are clear.

I’ve seen them doing it.

It is quite clever, but they are a big nuisance to the villagers.

[BBC News, July 2004]

A study of sheep psychology has found man’s woolly friend can remember the faces of more than 50 other sheep for up to two years.

They can even recognize a familiar human face.

The hidden talents of sheep revealed by a study in the journal Nature suggest they may be nearly as good as people at distinguishing faces in a crowd.

Researchers say:

Sheep form individual friendships with one another, which may last for a few weeks.

It’s possible they may think about a face even when it’s not there.

Researchers also found female sheep had a definite opinion about what made a ram’s face attractive.

According to researchers in Australia, sheep can learn and remember.

Researchers have developed a complex maze test to measure intelligence and learning in sheep, similar to those used for rats and mice.

Using the maze, researchers have concluded that sheep have excellent spatial memory and are able to learn and improve their performance.

And they can retain this information for a six-week period.

The maze uses the strong flocking instinct of sheep to motivate them to find their way through.

The time it initially takes an animal to rejoin its flock indicates smartness, while subsequent improvement in times over consecutive days of testing measures learning and memory.

Scientists at the University of Cambridge discovered that sheep have brain power to equal rodents, monkeys, and in some tests, humans.

They discovered the sheep “intelligence” while researching neurodegeneration, with a focus on Huntington’s disease, an inherited disorder that leads to nerve damage and dementia.

Above: Coat of arms of the University of Cambridge, England

The scientists put sheep through a set of challenges often given to humans suffering from Huntington’s.

The sheep showed that they had advanced learning capabilities, as they were able to navigate the challenges in the same way as humans and primates.

New research is suggesting that sick sheep could actually be smart enough to cure themselves.

Australian researchers believe that sick sheep may actually seek out plants that make them feel better.

There has been previous evidence to suggest that animals can detect what nutrients they are deficient in and can develop knowledge about which foods are beneficial or toxic.

Sheep are individuals, as are all the creatures great and small on the planet, however unnoticed, unstudied or unsung.

When we treat an animal as a pet, because of illness, accident or bereavement, it will exhibit great intelligence, a huge capacity for affection and an ability to adapt to unusual routines.

Perhaps everything boils down to the amount of time spent with any one animal.

Perhaps that is true of humans too.

Above: Cast of the BBC 1978 TV series All Creatures Great and Small
(left to right) Christopher Timothy (James Herriot), Robert Hardy (Siegfried Farnon), Peter Davison (Tristan Farnon), Mary Hignett (Helen Herriot) and Carol Drinkwater (Mrs. Edna Hall)

Animals are individuals.

Farmed animals are usually kept in large groups, but this does not mean that individuality disappears.

Their levels of intelligence vary, just as much as is true of humans.

No teacher ever expects, or wants, all his students in the classroom to be identical.

No one wants to create a society in which everyone wears the same clothes or shares the same hobbies.

Just because we are not clever enough to notice the differences between individual sheep is not a reason for presuming that there are none.

Animals and people can appear to lose their identities or become institutionalized if forced to live in unnaturally crowded, featureless regimented or boring conditions.

When this happens it is not proof that individuals are all the same or want to be treated as such.

We judge the comparative intelligence of different species by human standards.

Yet why should human criteria have any relevance to other species?

If an animal’s intelligence is sufficient to make it a success as that animal, what more could be desired?

Those who spend a lifetime observing animals witness amazing examples of logical, practical intelligence and some cases of outright stupidity.

Qualities also seen in human beings.

Animals merely get on with the day-to-day business of living, solving or failing to solve problems as they arise.

The important point is that animals should be given the wherewithal to succeed as animals, not as some inadequate servants of human beings.

Physical and mental development is affected by diet and freedom.

No one would expect a child to develop normally when kept in cramped unfriendly conditions, deprived of parents and siblings, with restricted exercise and the same diet everyday.

Yet many farmers and the government departments that inform them seem to expect farm animals to develop normally in such circumstances.

If you give animals the opportunity and time to choose between several alternatives, then they will choose what is best for them, and they will not all choose the same thing.

Goats will seek shelter more readily than sheep.

Neither species likes to get its feet wet and both prefer upland grazing to lowland.

In a fight, a ram will back up to charge and butt heads.

During confrontation, such fighting behaviour favours the ram.

Sheep and goats have numerous physical differences.

Most goats have hair coats that don’t require shearing or combing.

Most sheep grow wooly coats that need to be sheared at least once a year.

Sheep have an upper lip that is split by a distinct philtrum (groove).

The goat does not.

Male goats have glands beneath their tails.

Sheep have face or tear glands beneath their eyes and foot or scent glands between their toes.

Male goats develop a distinct odor as they reach sexual maturity.

The odor is very strong during the rutting (mating) season.

Most goats are naturally horned.

Some goats have beards.

Many breeds of sheep are naturally hornless (polled).

Some sheep have manes.

Tails are a natural part of sheep.

Lambs are born with tails.

The length of a lamb’s tail is usually half-way between the length of its mother’s tail and its father’s tail.

In fact, tail length is one of the most heritable traits in sheep.

Up to 84% of the variation in sheep tail length is due to genetics.

The purpose of the sheep’s tail is to protect the sheep’s anus, vulva, and udder from weather extremes.

Sheep lift their tails when they defecate and use their tails, to some extent, to scatter their feces.

Under modern sheep production systems, tails are usually docked (shortened) to prevent fecal matter from accumulating on the back side of the sheep, which can result in fly strike (wool maggots).

Left untreated, fly strike can be fatal, as the maggots eat away at the sheep’s flesh.

Tail docking also makes it easier to shear the sheep and process them for meat.

The tail does not interfere with breeding or lambing.

There are different methods that can be used to dock the tails of lambs.

The most common method is to put a rubber band (ring) around the tail.

When this method is used, it is recommended that lambs be docked at a young age (1 to 7 days) to minimize the stress and pain experienced by the lamb.

The dock (tail) should be left long enough to cover the ewe’s vulva and ram’s anus.

Short tail docks may contribute to the incidence of rectal prolapses.

While some animal activists claim that tail docking is an inhumane practice made necessary by modern production practices, this claim is simply untrue.

When done properly, tail docking is not inhumane.

While it causes some pain, it does not affect the health or growth of the lamb.

Tail docking is done to protect the health and hygiene of sheep and lambs.

Liquid feces (diarrhea) can occur in all production systems, thus, putting the sheep at risk for flystrike.

I strongly disagree with this practice.

The mutilation of animals has its roots in propaganda, custom and thoughtless adherence to tradition, which cannot be justified on any grounds.

If lambs’ tails get dirty, the cause needs to be addressed.

It is NOT a solution to cut off their tails.

Sheep are over one year of age.

They usually produce offspring.

Lambs are less than one year of age.

They usually do not produce offspring.

A yearling is an animal between 1 and 2 years of age that may or may not have produced offspring.

In other countries, a yearling ewe is called a hogget, shearling, gimmer, theave or teg.

Lamb is also the term for the flesh of a young domestic sheep eaten as food.

Above: Shoulder of lamb

The meat from a sheep that is older than 12 months is called mutton.

Yearling mutton is the meat from a sheep between 1 and 2 years of age.

Mutton has a much stronger flavour than lamb.

Above: Mutton steak

An abattoir is a building where animals are slaughtered and processed into meat products.

It comes from the French word, abattre, “to strike down“.

Above: Lovis Corinth’s In the slaughterhouse, 1893



A female sheep is called a ewe.

Yoe is a slang term for ewe.

A young female is called a ewe lamb.

The process of giving birth to lambs is called lambing.

Another word for birthing is parturition.

Another word for pregnancy is gestation.

A male sheep is called a ram.

Buck is the slang term for ram.

A young male is called a ram lamb.

In parts of the United Kingdom, a ram is called a tup and the mating season is called tupping.

A castrated male sheep is called a wether.

Wethers are less aggressive than rams.

A group of sheep is called a flock.

Larger groups of sheep are called bands or mobs.

A shepherd is a person who cares for sheep.

A sheepherder is a herder of sheep (on open range).

It is someone who keeps the sheep together in a flock.

In the US, the sheepherder is not usually the owner of the sheep.

A farm is an area of land, including various structures, devoted primarily to the practice of producing and managing food.

It usually includes cultivated land for producing crops.

A ranch is a farm consisting of a large tract of land along with facilities needed to raise livestock.

In 2014, it was estimated that 61,712 adult sheep and 132,683 lambs were killed by predators in the United States, costing farmers and ranchers almost $32.6 million.

In 2014, predation accounted for 28.1% of sheep losses and 36.4% of lamb losses.

Above: Fox

Coyotes were responsible for the majority of losses due to predation.

Above: Coyote

However, in terms of number of sheep operations affected, free-ranging or wild dogs may be the most common predator problem.

Some producers experience few or no problems with predators, while countless others battle the problem or have been driven out of the sheep business due to catastrophic losses.

Sheep have many natural predators: coyotes, wolves, foxes, bears, dogs, eagles, bobcats, etc.

Sheep are vulnerable to predators because they are basically defenseless and have no means of protecting themselves.

Above: Cougar

Each predator species has traits peculiar to it.

Coyotes typically attack sheep at the throat.

Above: Coyote attacking a lamb

Dogs are usually indiscriminate in how and where they attack.

Young or inexperienced coyotes may attack any part of the body as dogs would.

Coyotes, foxes, mountain lions and bobcats usually feed on a carcass at the flanks or behind the ribs and consume viscera, such as liver, heart and lungs.

Above: Bobcat

Bears usually prefer meat to viscera and often eat the udder of lactating ewes.

Above: Black bear

Eagles skin out carcasses and leave much of the skeleton intact on larger animals.

With lambs, eagles may bite off and swallow the ribs.

Above: Golden eagle

Smaller predators, such as coyotes, foxes and bobcats, select lambs over adult sheep.

Bears and mountain lions take adult sheep as well as lambs.

Coyotes, dogs, bears and mountain lions may kill more than one animal in a single episode, but often only one of the animals is fed upon.

Above: Sheep skull

While no technique is 100% effective, there are some techniques that shepherds can employ to protect their sheep from predators.

The most obvious way is to keep sheep and lambs safe by penning them at night or bedding them nearby.

Employ sheep herders will provide some protection from predators.

Certain types of fences (net and high-tensile electric) will aid in keeping predators out.

Fencing is particularly effective when incorporated with other methods of predator control, such as livestock guardians.

Livestock guardians are becoming increasingly popular with shepherds.

Three animals are used as livestock guardians:

  • dogs
  • llamas
  • donkeys

A dog generally stays with the sheep without harming them and aggressively repels predators.

Llamas and donkeys have an inherent dislike of dogs.

Above: Llama

In fact, any animal that displays aggressive behaviour to intruding predators may be a deterrent.

Above: Donkey

While some people may find lethal control methods (shooting, trapping, snaring, denning and poisoning) distasteful, sometimes they are the only method to remove individual predators, particularly those killing large numbers of sheep.

Because they are a prey animal, sheep require excellent senses to enhance their chances of survival in the wild.

Sheep depend heavily on their vision.

They have excellent peripheral vision and can see behind themselves without turning their heads.

However, they have poor depth perception.

They cannot see immediately in front of their noses.

Some vertical vision may also have been sacrificed in order to have a wider field of vision.

For example, it is doubtful that a sheep would be able to see something in a tree.

Contrary to previous thought, sheep and other livestock perceive colours, though their colour vision is not as well-developed as it is in humans.

Sheep will react with fear to new colours.

Sheep have excellent hearing.

They can direct their ears in the direction of a sound.

Sound arrives at each ear at slightly different times, with a small difference in amplitude.

Sheep are frightened by high-pitched and loud noises, such as barking dogs or firecrackers.

Sheep have an excellent sense of smell.

They are very sensitive to what different predators smell like.

Smell helps rams locate ewes in heat and ewes locate their lambs.

Sheep also use their sense of smell to locate water and determine subtle or major differences between feeds and pasture.

The sense of taste in sheep is probably not as important as the other senses.

However, sheep have the ability to differentiate different feedstuffs and taste may play a role in this ability.

When presented with a variety of feeds, sheep will select certain feeds over others.

Sheep will select different types and species of plants than other livestock.

Since the sheep’s body is covered with wool or coarse hair, only the nose, lips, mouth, and maybe ears readily lend themselves to touching behaviour.

However, touching is important to the interaction between sheep.

Lambs seek bodily contact with their mothers and the ewes respond to touching in many ways, including milk letdown in response to the nuzzling/suckling stimulus of lambs.

When young lambs sleep, they will seek out their mothers and lie close to them.

Making animals happy and allowing them to express their natural behavioural instincts is not just morally and ethically essential.

It also makes sound financial sense.

Happy animals grow faster.

Children under stress eat and sleep less well than those who are happy and relaxed.

Unhappy children develop real and imaginary ailments.

Stress can be reduced or eliminated by improving existing conditions.

A change of environment or diet, more understanding or love, all play their part.

It is the same with animals.

It is misplaced conceit to believe that any manmade environment can equal or better the natural one.

No artificially manufactured conditions can match the reassurance, stability, attention, companionship and appropriate food that nature provides.

Albert Einstein said that the only really valuable thing is intuition.

I believe that he was right.

Above: Albert Einstein (1879 – 1955)

Instinct and intuition are the most useful tools any living creature possesses.

We suppress instinct in animals and in children at a huge risk to the world.

Wherever the pursuit of maximum profit had led to intensification, it has been animals that have suffered most.

The Story of the Golden Fleece

Athamas the Minyan, a founder of Halos in Thessaly, but also the King of the city of Orchomenus in Boetia (a region of southeastern Greece), took the goddess Nephele as his first wife.

Above: John Flaxman’s The Fury of Athamas

Above: Remains of ancient Halos, Thessaly, Greece

Above: Ruins of the Acropolis of Orchomenus

Above: Punishment of Ixion: In the center is Mercury holding the caduceus. On the right is Juno on her throne, and behind her Iris stands and gestures. On the left is Vulcanus (blond figure) manning the wheel, with Ixion already tied to the wheel. Nephele sits at Mercury’s feet. Roman fresco from the eastern wall of the triclinium in the Casa dei Vettii (“House of the Vetii”) in Pompeii, Italy

They had two children, the boy Phrixus (whose name means “curly” as in the texture of the ram’s fleece) and the girl Helle.

Above: Helle and Phrixus, Fresco, Pompeii

Later Athamas became enamored of and married Ino, the daughter of Cadmus.

Above: Cadmus fighting the dragon, Louvre Museum, Paris, France

When Nephele left in anger, drought came upon the land.

Ino was jealous of her stepchildren and plotted their deaths.

In some versions, she persuaded Athamas that sacrificing Phrixus was the only way to end the drought.

Above: Statue of Ino, Cour Carrée, Palais du Louvre, Paris, France

Nephele, or her spirit, appeared to the children with a winged ram whose fleece was of gold.

The ram had been sired by Poseidon in his primitive ram-form upon Theophane, a nymph and the granddaughter of Helios, the sun god.

Above: Statue of Poseidon, National Archaeological Museum, Athens, Greece

Above: Theophane

Above: Helios, Fresco, Pompeii

According to the Latin author Hyginus (64 BCE – 17 CE), Poseidon carried Theophane to an island where he made her into a ewe so that he could have his way with her among the flocks.

There Theophane’s other suitors could not distinguish the ram-god and his consort.

Nephele’s children escaped on the yellow ram over the sea, but Helle fell off and drowned in the strait now named after her, the Hellespont.

The ram spoke to Phrixus, encouraging him and took the boy safely to Colchis (modern day Georgia), on the easternmost shore of the Euxine Sea (Black Sea).

In essence, this act returned the ram to the god Poseidon, and the ram became the constellation Aries.

Phrixus settled in the house of Aeetes, son of Helios the sun god.

Above: Bartolomeo di Giovanni’s King Aeetes, 1487

He hung the Golden Fleece preserved from the ram on an oak in a grove sacred to Ares, the god of war and one of the Twelve Olympians.

Above: Statue of Ares

Above: The Twelve Olympians igures from left to right are – Hestia (goddess of the hearth), with scepter; Hermes (messenger of the gods), with cap and staff; Aphrodite (goddess of love and beauty), with veil; Ares (god of war), with helmet and spear; Demeter (goddess of agriculture), with scepter and wheat sheaf; Hephaestus (god of fire and metal-working), with staff; Hera (queen of the gods), with scepter; Poseidon (god of the sea), with trident; Athena (goddess of wisdom and the arts), with owl and helmet; Zeus (king of the gods), with thunderbolt and staff; Artemis (goddess of the hunt and moon), with bow and quiver; and Apollo (god of the sun), with “kithara.”, Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, Maryland

The fleece was guarded by a never-sleeping dragon with teeth that could become soldiers when planted in the ground.

The dragon was at the foot of the tree on which the fleece was placed.

Pelias was power-hungry and sought to gain dominion over all of Thessaly.

Above: Map of ancient Thessaly

Pelias was the progeny of a union between their shared mother, Tyro (“high born Tyro“), the daughter of Salmoneus, and the sea god Poseidon.

In a bitter feud, he overthrew Aeson (the rightful king), killing all the descendants of Aeson that he could.

He spared his half-brother for unknown reasons.

Aeson’s wife Alcimede I had a newborn son named Jason whom she saved from Pelias by having female attendants cluster around the infant and cry as if he were stillborn.

Fearing that Pelias would eventually notice and kill her son, Alcimede sent him away to be reared by the centaur Chiron.

Above: Eugène Delacroix’s The Education of Achilles, Palais Bourbon, Paris, France

She claimed that she had been having an affair with him all along.

Pelias, fearing that his ill-gotten kingship might be challenged, consulted the Oracle, who warned him to beware of a man wearing only one sandal.

Above: John William Waterhouse’s Consulting the Oracle, 1884

Many years later, Pelias was holding games in honour of Poseidon when the grown Jason arrived in Iolcus, having lost one of his sandals in the River Anauros (“wintry Anauros“) while helping an old woman (actually the goddess Hera in disguise) to cross.

She blessed him, for she knew what Pelias had planned.

Above: Statue of Hera, Louvre Museum, Paris

When Jason entered Iolcus (present-day city of Volos), he was announced as a man wearing only one sandal.

Jason, aware that he was the rightful King, so informed Pelias.

Above: Pelias, King of Iolcos, stops on the steps of a temple as he recognises young Jason by his missing sandal, Roman fresco, Pompeii

Pelias replied:

“To take my throne, which you shall, you must go on a quest to find the Golden Fleece.”

Jason readily accepted this condition.

Above: Pelias (left) sends forth Jason (right), Stories from the Greek Tragedians, Alfred Church, 1879

Jason assembled for his crew, a number of heroes, known as the Argonauts after their ship, the Argo.

Above: Lorenzo Costa’s The Argo, 1500

Most accounts name the ship after her builder, Argus. 

Above: Argus building the Argo, with the help of Athena

Cicero (106 – 43 BCE) suggested that it was named after the “Argives“, a term commonly used by Homer for the Greek people of Argos. 

Above: Marble bust of Marcus Tullius Cicero, Prado Museum, Madrid, Spain

Above: View of modern Argos (Greece) as seen from the ancient theatre

Diodorus Siculus (90 – 30 BCE) reported that some thought the name was derived from an ancient Greek word for swift, which could have indicated that the ship was designed to move quickly.

Above: Fresco of Diodoro Siculus

The isle of Lemnos is situated off the Western coast of Asia Minor (modern day Turkey).

The island was inhabited by a race of women who had killed their husbands.

The women had neglected their worship of Aphrodite, and as a punishment the goddess made the women so foul in stench that their husbands could not bear to be near them.

Above: The isle of Lemnos as seen from space

The men then took concubines from the Thracian mainland opposite.

The spurned women, angry at Aphrodite, killed all the male inhabitants while they slept.

Above: Statue of Aphrodite, Baiae, Syracuse, Italy

The King, Thoas, was saved by Hypsipyle, his daughter, who put him out to sea sealed in a chest from which he was later rescued.

The women of Lemnos lived for a while without men, with Hypsipyle as their Queen.

Above: Hypsipyle saves Thoas

During the visit of the Argonauts the women mingled with the men creating a new “race” called Minyae.

Jason fathered twins with the Queen.

Heracles pressured them to leave as he was disgusted by the antics of the Argonauts.

He had not taken part, which is truly unusual considering the numerous affairs he had with other women.

Above: Francisco de Zurbarán’s Death of Heracles, 1634, Prado Museum, Madrid, Spain

After Lemnos, the Argonauts landed among the Doliones, whose King Cyzicus treated them graciously.

He told them about the land beyond Bear Mountain, but forgot to mention what lived there.

What lived in the land beyond Bear Mountain were the Gegeines, a tribe of six-armed Earthborn giants who wore leather loincloths.

Above: Gegeine, Nuremburg Chronicle, 1493

While most of the crew went into the forest to search for supplies, the Gegeines saw that few Argonauts were guarding the ship and raided it. 

Heracles was among those guarding the ship at the time and managed to kill most of them before Jason and the others returned.

Once some of the other Gegeines were killed, Jason and the Argonauts set sail.

Above: The Argo

The Argonauts departed, losing their bearings and landing again at the same spot that night.

In the darkness, the Doliones took them for enemies and they started fighting each other.

The Argonauts killed many of the Doliones, among them King Cyzicus.

Cyzicus’ wife killed herself.

The Argonauts realized their horrible mistake when dawn came and held a funeral for him.

Above: Bust of Cyzicus, Bandirma Museum, Turkey

Soon, Jason reached the court of Phineus of Salmydessus in Thrace. 

Zeus had sent the Harpies to steal the food put out for Phineus each day.

Jason took pity on the emaciated King and killed the Harpies when they returned.

In other versions, Calais and Zetes chase the Harpies away.

In return for this favour, Phineus revealed to Jason the location of Colchis and how to pass the Symplegades (or The Clashing Rocks) and then they parted.

Above: Phineas and the Harpies

The only way to reach Colchis was to sail through the Symplegades (Clashing Rocks), huge rock cliffs that came together and crushed anything that traveled between them.

Phineus told Jason to release a dove when they approached these Islands, and if the dove made it through, to row with all their might.

If the dove was crushed, he was doomed to fail.

Jason released the dove as advised, which made it through, losing only a few tail feathers.

Seeing this, they rowed strongly and made it through with minor damage at the extreme stern of the ship.

From that time on, the Clashing Rocks were forever joined leaving free passage for others to pass.

Above: Jason releases a dove at the Symplegades, Howard Davies illustration for Charles Kingsley’s The Heroes, 1900

Jason arrived in Colchis (modern Black Sea coast of Georgia) to claim the Fleece as his own.

It was owned by King Aeetes of Colchis.

The Fleece was given to him by Phrixus.

Aeetes promised to give it to Jason only if he could perform three certain tasks.

Presented with the tasks, Jason became discouraged and fell into depression.

Above: Jason and the Argonauts arriving at Colchis, Palais de Versailles, France

However, Hera had persuaded Aphrodite to convince her son Eros to make Aeetes’ daughter, Medea, fall in love with Jason.

As a result, Medea aided Jason in his tasks.

Above: Fresco of Medea, Herucaleum, Ercolano, Italy

First, Jason had to plow a field with fire-breathing oxen, the Khalkotauroi, that he had to yoke himself.

Medea provided an ointment that protected him from the oxen’s flames.

Above: Jean François de Troy’s Jason taming the Khalkotauri, 1743, Barber Institute of Fine Arts, Birmingham, England

Then, Jason sowed the teeth of a dragon into a field.

The teeth sprouted into an army of warriors (spartoi).

Medea had previously warned Jason of this and told him how to defeat this foe.

Before they attacked him, he threw a rock into the crowd.

Unable to discover where the rock had come from, the soldiers attacked and defeated one another.

Above: Leonard Thiry’s Jason ploughing the earth and sowing the dragon’s teeth, 1550

His last task was to overcome the sleepless dragon which guarded the Golden Fleece.

Jason sprayed the dragon with a potion, given by Medea, distilled from herbs.

Above: John William Waterhouse’s Jason and Medea, 1907

The dragon fell asleep, and Jason was able to seize the Golden Fleece.

In some versions of the story, Jason attempts to put the guard serpent to sleep.

The snake is coiled around a column at the base of which is a ram and on top of which is a bird.

Above: Jason and the Snake, Douris Cup, Vatican Museum

He then sailed away with Medea.

Medea distracted her father, who chased them as they fled, by killing her brother Apsyrtus and throwing pieces of his body into the sea.

Aeetes stopped to gather them.

Above: Herbert James Draper’s The Golden Fleece, 1904

In another version, Medea lured Apsyrtus into a trap.

Jason killed him, chopped off his fingers and toes, and buried the corpse.

In any case, Jason and Medea escaped.

Above: Leonard Thiry’s Aeetes Accepts the Dismembered Corpse of Absyrte, 1563, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven, Connecticut

On the way back to Iolcus, Medea prophesied to Euphemus, the Argo‘s helmsman, that one day he would rule Cyrene.

This came true through Battus, a descendant of Euphemus. 

Above: Euphemus, DC Comics

Zeus, as punishment for the slaughter of Medea’s own brother, sent a series of storms at the Argo and blew it off course.

The Argo then spoke and said that they should seek purification with Circe, a nymph living on the island of Aeaea.

Above: Honor Blackman as Hera, Jason and the Argonauts (1963 movie) – Her face was used as a model for the head on the stern of the ship. The sacred oak of the ship is here represented as the head of a woman with partial extending wings making up the stern of the ship. The painted head is modeled on the goddess Hera in the movie and has the ability to speak to Jason throughout the movie. Argus, the ship builder, said he was inspired to add that feature to the boat when creating it. Filmmakers gave this head the practical effect of being able to open and close when speaking to Jason.

Above: John William Waterhouse’s Circe Offering the Cup to Odysseus

After being cleansed, they continued their journey home.

Above: Map of Italy with Aeaea marked south of Rome, Abraham Ortelius, 1624

Chiron had told Jason that without the aid of Orpheus, the Argonauts would never be able to pass the Sirens — the same Sirens encountered by Odysseus in Homer’s epic poem, the Odyssey.

The Sirens lived on three small, rocky islands called Sirenum scopuli and sang beautiful songs that enticed sailors to come to them, which resulted in the crashing of their ship into the Islands.

Above: Statue of moaning Siren, Myrina, Turkey

When Orpheus heard their voices, he drew his lyre and played music that was more beautiful and louder, drowning out the Sirens’ bewitching songs.

Above: Ancient Roman floor mosaic image of Orpheus, Museo archaeologico regionale di Palermo, Italy

The Argo then came to the Island of Crete, guarded by the bronze man, Talos.

Above: (in red) Location of Crete

As the ship approached, Talos hurled huge stones at the ship, keeping it at bay.

Above: Talos tossing a stone, Cretan silver didrachma, Cabinet des médailles, Paris, France

Talos had one blood vessel which went from his neck to his ankle, bound shut by only one bronze nail (as in metal casting by the lost wax method).

Medea cast a spell on Talos to calm him.

She removed the bronze nail and Talos bled to death.

The Argo was then able to sail on.

Above: The death of Talos depicted on a 5th century BCE krater (vase), Jatta National Archaeological Museum, Ruvo di Puglia, Italy

Thomas Bullfinch has an antecedent to the interaction of Medea and the daughters of Pelias.

Above: Thomas Bullfinch (1796 – 1867)

Jason, celebrating his return with the Golden Fleece, noted that his father was too aged and infirm to participate in the celebrations.

He had seen and been served by Medea’s magical powers.

He asked Medea to take some years from his life and add them to the life of his father.

She did so, but at no such cost to Jason’s life.

Medea withdrew the blood from Aeson’s body and infused it with certain herbs.

Putting it back into his veins, returning vigour to him.

Above: Medea rejuvenates Aeson

Pelias’ daughters saw this and wanted the same service for their father.

Medea, using her sorcery, claimed to Pelias’ daughters that she could make their father smooth and vigorous as a child by chopping him up into pieces and boiling the pieces in a cauldron of water and magical herbs.

She demonstrated this remarkable feat with the oldest ram in the flock, which leapt out of the cauldron as a lamb.

The girls, rather naively, sliced and diced their father and put him in the cauldron.

Medea did not add the magical herbs.

Pelias was dead. 

Above: Georges Moreau de Tours’ The Murder of Pelias by His Daughters, 1878

Pelias’ son, Acastus, drove Jason and Medea into exile for the murder.

The couple settled in Corinth.

Above: View of modern day Corinth, Greece

In Corinth, Jason became engaged to marry Creusa, a daughter of the King of Corinth, to strengthen his political ties.

When Medea confronted Jason about the engagement and cited all the help she had given him, he retorted that it was not she that he should thank, but Aphrodite who made Medea fall in love with him.

Infuriated with Jason for breaking his vow that he would be hers forever, Medea took her revenge by presenting to Creusa a cursed dress, as a wedding gift, that stuck to her body and burned her to death as soon as she put it on.

Above: Presents from Medea to Creusa, Lucanian red-figure bell-krater from Apulia, 390 BCE, Louvre Museum, Paris

Creusa’s father, Creon, burned to death with his daughter as he tried to save her.

Then Medea killed the two boys that she bore to Jason, fearing that they would be murdered or enslaved as a result of their mother’s actions.

Above: Medea murders one of her children, Campanian red-figure neck-amphora from Cumae, 330 BCE, Louvre Museum, Paris

When Jason came to know of this, Medea was already gone.

She fled to Athens in a chariot of dragons sent by her grandfather, the sun god Helios.

Above: Medea on her chariot of dragons, Cleveland Museum, Ohio

Although Jason calls Medea most hateful to gods and men, the fact that the chariot is given to her by Helios indicates that she still has the gods on her side.

As Bernard Knox points out, Medea’s last scene with concluding appearances parallels that of a number of indisputably divine beings in other plays by Euripides.

Just like these gods, Medea “interrupts and puts a stop to the violent action of the human being on the lower level, justifies her savage revenge on the grounds that she has been treated with disrespect and mockery, takes measures and gives orders for the burial of the dead, prophesies the future,” and “announces the foundation of a cult.”

Above: Bernard Knox (1914 – 2010)

Later Jason and Peleus, father of the hero Achilles, attacked and defeated Acastus, reclaiming the throne of Iolcus for himself once more.

Jason’s son, Thessalus, then became King.

As a result of breaking his vow to love Medea forever, Jason lost his favor with Hera and died lonely and unhappy.

He was asleep under the stern of the rotting Argo when it fell on him, killing him instantly.

Above: Jason and the Argo

Pindar (518 – 438 BCE) employed the quest for the Golden Fleece in his 4th Pythian Ode (written in 462 BC), though the Fleece is not in the foreground.

Above: Bust of Pindar, Museo Archeologico Nazionale, Naples, Italy

When Aeetes challenges Jason to yoke the fire-breathing bulls, the Fleece is the prize:

Let the King do this, the captain of the ship!

Let him do this, I say, and have for his own the immortal coverlet, the fleece, glowing with matted skeins of gold.”

Above: Jason claims the Golden Fleece

Several euhemeristic attempts to interpret the Golden Fleece “realistically” as reflecting some physical cultural object or alleged historical practice have been made.

For example, in the 20th century, some scholars suggested that the story of the Golden Fleece signified the bringing of sheep husbandry to Greece from the east.

From Turkey?

In other readings, scholars theorized it referred to golden grain or to the sun.

A more widespread interpretation relates the myth of the fleece to a method of washing gold from streams, which was well attested (but only from c. 5th century BCE) in the region of Georgia to the east of the Black Sea.

Sheep fleeces, sometimes stretched over a wooden frame, would be submerged in the stream, and gold flecks borne down from upstream placer deposits would collect in them.

The fleeces would be hung in trees to dry before the gold was shaken or combed out.

Alternatively, the fleeces would be used on washing tables in alluvial mining of gold or on washing tables at deep gold mines.

Judging by the very early gold objects from a range of cultures, washing for gold is a very old human activity.

Strabo describes the way in which gold could be washed:

It is said that in their country gold is carried down by the mountain torrents, and that the barbarians obtain it by means of perforated troughs and fleecy skins, and that this is the origin of the myth of the Golden Fleece — unless they call them Iberians, by the same name as the western Iberians, from the gold mines in both countries.

Above: Strabo (64 BCE – 24 CE)

Another interpretation is based on the references in some versions to purple or purple-dyed cloth.

The purple dye extracted from the purple dye murex snail and related species was highly prized in ancient times.

Clothing made of cloth dyed with Tyrian purple was a mark of great wealth and high station (hence the phrase “royal purple“).

The association of gold with purple is natural and occurs frequently in literature.

Above: Purple-dyed fabric and the shells of the spiny dye murex sea snail

The following are the chief among the various interpretations of the Fleece:

  1. It represents royal power.
  2. It represents the flayed skin of Krios (‘Ram‘), companion of Phrixus.
  3. It represents a book on alchemy.
  4. It represents a technique of writing in gold on parchment.
  5. It represents a form of placer mining practiced in Georgia.
  6. It represents the forgiveness of the Gods.
  7. It represents a rain cloud.
  8. It represents a land of golden grain.
  9. It represents the spring-hero.
  10. It represents the sea reflecting the sun.
  11. It represents the gilded prow of Phrixus’ ship.
  12. It represents a breed of sheep in ancient Georgia.
  13. It represents the riches imported from the East.
  14. It represents the wealth or technology of Colchis.
  15. It was a covering for a cult image of Zeus in the form of a ram.
  16. It represents a fabric woven from sea silk.
  17. It is about a voyage from Greece, through the Mediterranean, across the Atlantic to the Americas.
  18. It represents trading fleece dyed murex-purple for Georgian gold.

Above: Jason claims the Golden Fleece

And what does it represent to me?

Sadness.

We live in a material world where man’s dominion over all other creatures great and small infers a need to exploit nature for possible profit.

The exploitation of the outdoors to improve our living conditions indoors.

We call sheep animals, thus negating the possibility that they possess feelings and intelligence and, maybe, souls, such as we humans lay claim.

Sheep can be very companionable and amazingly compassionate.

(Please refrain from sheep shagging jokes here, pundits.)

Sheep, like humans, can be highly intelligent and be very dim.

Sheep always run uphill if they sense danger.

Sheep are usually gentle and unaggressive.

Most sheep have long, wooly tails to keep them warm.

Sheep can live on grass alone, but like other things too such as tree leaves and apples.

A sheep’s thick coat protects it from heat and cold.

Sheep can stand very cold weather better than cows, pigs or hens.

Some sheep have good powers of concentration similar to that shown by humans engaged in watching television.

Sheep prefer running water to still water to drink.

Sheep have very long memories.

Sheep play almost continually when they are young.

Are sheep so unlike humans after all?

I am not suggesting we abandon the use or consumption of animals simply because we have created a system of animal husbandry that has grown dependent on this.

What I am suggesting is consideration and compassion towards all God’s creation of which we all are part of this symbiotic circle of life.

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Emilie Kip Baker, Stories of Old Greece and Rome / Burak Coşan, “Turkish government set to distribute 300 sheep to every farmer“, Hürriyet Daily News, 14 February 2018 / Sibel Alapala Demirhan, “Sheep farming in Uşak, Turkey: Economic structure, problems and solutions“, Saudi Journal of Biological Studies, Volume 26, Issue 2, February 2016 / Bernard Logan, “Australian shearers pack it in over sheer size of sheep“, The Times, 8 September 2020 / Rosamund Young, The Secret Life of Cows / http://www.baauki.com / http://www.sheep101.com

Swiss Miss and the Mama of the Mountains

Eskişehir, Turkey, Tuesday 9 April 2022

Psychology, not one of my strengths, is a topic on my mind these days.

I find myself from time to time in the midst of psychological conflict with a wife who cannot comprehend that my search for personal happiness cannot revolve around being with her constantly, that I must be fulfilled in all the roles a man must do, besides husband.

I am engaged in mental battle with a colleague at work in Eskişehir who desires me to humble myself and apologize to her for a wrong I neither meant nor directed at her.

Above: Sazova Park, Eskişehir, Turkey

I am reading Orhan Pamuk’s The Museum of Innocence slowly and minutely, finding myself disturbed by the plot therein.

I find myself remembering an evening meeting at the school with a student who is a psychiatrist by trade.

I had great difficulty in sticking to the script of my Encounter (the Wall Street English name for the language elicitation sessions we have) and found myself quizzing her as to the nature of her profession:

What was most difficult about her job?

What was most fulfilling about her job?

How did her job affect her personal life?

As a father figure to most of the people with whom I am acquainted with in Eskişehir I find myself a witness and councillor to the relationships they are engaged in.

Somehow they equate age with wisdom.

Though it is true that I know a thing or two because I have seen a thing or two, this does in no way negate the application of the adage “no fool like an old fool” to my character.

A friend has confessed to me their struggle between the desires of the day and the longings for tomorrow.

There is a romance here, but is there a future here?

There may be a future out there, but will there be romance over there?

Tough call.

Tough decision.

A hard choice between two uncertainties.

The “out there” is presently focused on Vietnam where potential employment awaits.

All I know of Vietnam is that which I read.

My experience with the ‘Nam is limited to the perspective of my friend Swiss Miss (Heidi Hoi) and her time spent there.

But perhaps the experience of my Swiss friend might be instructive for my Eskişehir friend?

Thus I return to Heidi‘s story…..

Sa Pa, Vietnam, March 2019

Sa Pa is a mountain town – home to a great diversity of ethnic minority peoples.

If you were expecting a quaint alpine town, recalibrate your expectations.

Modern tourism development has seen Sapa’s skyline continually thrust upwards.

But you’re not here to hang out in town.

Above: Sa Pa, Vietnam

This is northern Vietnam’s premier trekking base, from where hikers launch themselves into a surrounding countryside of cascading rice terraces and tiny hill-tribe villages that seem a world apart.

Once you’ve stepped out into the lush fields, you’ll understand the Sapa area’s real charm.

Most of the ethnic minority people work their land on sloping terraces since the vast majority of the land is mountainous.

Their staple foods are rice and corn.

Rice, by its very nature of being a labour-intensive crop, makes the daily fight for survival paramount.

The unique climate in Sa Pa has a major influence on the ethnic minorities who live in the area.

With sub-tropical summers, temperate winters and 160 days of mist annually, the influence on agricultural yields and health-related issues is significant.

The geographical location of the area makes it a truly unique place for many interesting plants and animals, allowing it to support many inhabitants.

Many very rare or even endemic species have been recorded in the region.

The scenery of the Sa Pa region in large part reflects the relationship between the minority people and nature.

This is seen especially in the paddy fields carpeting the rolling lower slopes of the Hoàng Lién Mountains.

The impressive physical landscape which underlies this has resulted from the work of the elements over thousands of years, wearing away the underlying rock.

On a clear day – (it does happen) – the imposing peak of Fan Si Pan comes into view.

The last major peak in the Himalayan chain, Fan Si Pan offers a real challenge to even the keenest walker, the opportunity of staggering views, and a rare glimpse of some of the last remaining primary rain forest in Vietnam.

Geology, climate and human activity have combined to produce a range of very distinct habitats around Sa Pa.

Especially important is Sa Pa’s geographic position, at the convergence of the world’s 14 “biomes” (distinct biographic areas), producing an assemblage of plant and animal species unique in the world.

In 2014, Sa Pa ranked #9 in the top 10 rice terrace destinations of the world by Spot Cool Stuff.

The best time to take great photos of the yellow rice terraces in Sapa is September.

Occasionally, thick white snow is recorded in Sapa in winter (December to February), giving adventurous travellers a rare chance to admire snow-capped mountains.

It is a one-of-a-lifetime experience in a tropical country like Vietnam.

The Hoàng Lién Mountains are home to a rich variety of plants, birds, mammals, amphibians, reptiles and insects, many only found in northwestern Vietnam.

For this reason, the Hoàng Lién Nature Reserve was made a National Park in 2006.

Above: Hoàng Lién National Park

Hoàng Lién covers much of the mountain range to the immediate south of Sa Pa.

Forest type and quality change with increasing altitude.

At 2,000 meters the natural, undisturbed forest begins to be seen.

Above 2,500 meters dwarf conifers and rhododendrons predominate in the harsh “elfin forest“, (so called because a lack of topsoil and nutrients means that fully mature trees grow to measure only a few meters in height).

Higher still, only the hardiest of plant species are found.

At over 3,000 meters, Fan Si Pan’s summit can only support dwarf bamboo.

Around 7 million minority people (nearly 2/3 of Vietnam’s total minority population) live in the northern uplands, mostly in isolated villages.

The largest ethnic groups are Thai and Muong in the northwest, Tay and Nung in the northeast and Hmong and Dao dispersed throughout the region.

Historically, all these peoples migrated from southern China at various times throughout history:

Those who arrived first, notably the Tay and Thai, settled in the fertile valleys where they now lead a relatively prosperous existence, while late arrivals, such as the Hmong and Dao, took to living on the higher slopes.

Despite government efforts to integrate them into the Vietnamese community, most continue to follow a way of life that has changed very little over the centuries.

For an insight into the minorities’ traditional cultures and highly varied styles of dress, visit Hanoi’s informative Museum of Ethnology before setting off into the mountains.

To get in shape for a trek through the valley, try taking a short but steep hike to the top of Ham Rong Mountain, which overlooks the town from an elevation of around 2,000 metres.

Stone steps lead up to the peak where there are fine panoramic views on a clear day.

The pathway is lined with potted orchids, landscaped gardens and depictions of cartoon characters like Mickey Mouse.

To find the entrance to the park, follow Ham Rong to the north of the church in the town centre.

Above: Ham Rong Mountain

Vietnam’s highest mountain, Fan Si Pan (3143m) lies less than 5 km as the crow flies from Sa Pa, but it’s an arduous three- to five-day round trip on foot.

The usual route starts by descending 300 metres to cross the Muong Hoa River and then climbs almost 2,000 metres on overgrown paths through pine forest and bamboo thickets before emerging on the southern ridge.

The reward is a panorama encompassing the mountain ranges of northwest Vietnam, south to Son La Province and north to the peaks of Yunnan in China.

Above: Mount Fan Si Pan

Although it is a hard climb, the most difficult aspect of Fan Si Pan is its climate:

Even in the most favourable months of November and December it is difficult to predict a stretch of settled clear weather and many people are forced back by cloud, rain and cold.

Setting on top highlight destinations in the Sapa travel guide for adventurous travellers, Fansipan Mount is not only the highest peak in all of Vietnam but also the “roof of the Indochina peninsula”.

The actual trek boasts breathtaking panoramic views of majestic mountains, lush valleys and dense forests, challenging both amateur and professional hikers.

Above: The roof of Indochina

The pristine and rustic beauty of the Cave of Fairies enchants thousands of travellers from the very first glimpse of an eye.

The emerald waters of the Chay River surrounded by high cliffs turns this limestone cave into a heavenly corner on earth with charming scenery.

Above: Entrance to the Cave of Fairies

The Cave of Fairies looks like something straight out of a Brothers Grimm fairy tale.

Above: Ho Dong Tien Cave: The Cave of Fairies

Perching on the peak of Tram Ton pass on the Hoang Lien Son mountain range is Heaven’s Gate.

About 18 kilometers to the north of Sapa, it boasts a great view looking over the valleys between Fansipan, the roof of Indochina Peninsula.

As its name reveals, this destination brings a little feeling of Heaven with a sublime scenery featuring majestic mountains and extreme abyss.

Setting foot on Heaven’s Gate to grasp the beautiful scenery of the winding pass roads below will be an unforgettable memory for newcomers to Sapa.

Above: Heaven’s Gate

A guide is essential to trace indistinct paths, hack through bamboo and locate water sources if climbing Mount Fan Si Pan.

Hmong guides are said to know the mountain best.

Sa Pa hotels and tour agents can arrange guides and porters as required.

A popular, hassle-free way to visit minority villages is to join one of the organized trips offered by tour agencies in Hanoi, Sa Pa, Bac Ha and Ha Giang.

Generally, you are better off going with local companies as they are more familiar with the villages visited.

While it is possible to go alone to places like Cat Cat near Sa Pa, independent trekking is generally frowned upon and locals may not be as welcoming as they are to groups.

With typical wooden houses, flowing streams, elaborate brocades, and hospitable ethnic people, the enchanting Cat Cat is the most beautiful ancient village in Sapa.

Being the home to the Hmong ethnic group, this little hamlet is where local inhabitants retain the cultivation of flax and cotton with a long-standing tradition of weaving beautiful brocade fabrics.

Drop by the village, you can learn about one-of-a-kind customs and practices of Hmong through their local life as well as get an insight into their traditional culture while enjoying the local hospitality.

Above: Cat Cat, Vietnam

Behaviour that we take for granted may cause offence to some ethnic minority people –

Remember that you are a guest.

Apart from being sensitive to the situation and keeping an open mind, the following rules should be observed when visiting the ethnic minority areas.

  • Dress modestly, in long trousers or a skirt, in a T-shirt or shirt.
  • Be sensitive when taking photographs, particularly of older people who are generally suspicious of the camera – always ask permission first.
  • Only enter a house when you’ve been invited, and be prepared to remove your shoes.
  • Small gifts, such as fresh fruit from the local market, are always welcome, and it’s also a good idea to buy craftwork produced by the villagers – most communities have some embroidery, textiles or basketry for sale.
  • As a mark of respect, learn the local terms of address, either in a dialect or at least in Vietnamese, such as chao ong, chao ba.
  • Try to minimize your impact on the fragile local environment: take litter back to the towns with you and be sensitive when using wood and other scarce resources.

Hiking and enjoying nature is the name of the game in Sapa.

The most prominent attraction in the area around Sapa is Fan Si Pan, which is the highest mountain in Vietnam.

It’s only 19km from town. 

This may seem like a short distance, but the trek is not easy.

The rough terrain and unpredictable weather present some difficulties.

Tourists who are fit and have mountain climbing experience will enjoy this attraction the most as the peak is accessible all year round.

Technical climbing skills are not necessary, but endurance is a must.

Towering above Sapa are the Hoang Lien Mountains, once known to the French as the Tonkinese Alps and now a National Park.

These mountains include the often-cloud-obscured Fansipan (3,143 metres), Vietnam’s highest peak, regularly dubbed ‘the Roof of Indochina‘.

Fansipan’s wild, lonesome beauty has been somewhat shattered with the opening of a 6,292-metre-long cable car, taking people across the Muong Hoa Valley and up to near the summit in 15 minutes.

Above: Lower end of Mount Fan Si Pan cable car

Buy tickets at the ticket office in Sapa’s main square, from where a funicular train (50,000 VND return) shuttles passengers to the lower cable-car station.

After the cable-car ride you still face 600 steps to the summit, or you can take another funicular (70,000 VND one way) from Do Quyen, passing a series of pagodas and Buddhas to the summit.

Above: Do Quyen Waterfall

Expect crowds or clouds, depending on the weather.

Fan Si Pan can be found in Hoàng Lién National Park, which is an attraction in itself.

The park covers a picturesque mountain landscape and several forests, and serves as the habitat for a diverse set of animals.

Some species can only be found in northwest Vietnam and are highly endangered.

Nature lovers will truly appreciate this park.

Above: Hoàng Lién National Park

Other attractions that are part of the Hoang Lien National Park include the Cat Cat Village and the Ta Phin Village and cave.

Above: Cat Cat, Vietnam

Above: Ta Phin, Vietnam

Above: Ta Phin Cave

Trekking is the main activity in Sapa. 

Trekking maps are available from the Tourist Information Centre on Fansipan Street.

These maps are invaluable if you want to trek around the area without a guide.

They show the walking trails and trekking routes around town.

Most hotels in Sapa offer tourists guided half-day and day long treks, but the best places to inquire about these treks are the Cha Pa Garden, Auberge Hotel, Cat Cat View Hotel and Mountain View Hotel.

While it is possible to go hiking around Sapa on your own, it is better to have the assistance of a guide to guarantee a more enriching experience.

When it comes to longer treks or overnight stays in the villages, the knowledge of a local will come in handy.

Regardless of being on a walking tour or not, tribal women will walk with you and try to assist you in any possible way hoping for a tip. 

Above: Sa Pa, Vietnam

The road between Sapa and Lai Chau crosses the Tram Ton Pass on the northern side of Mount Fan Si Pan, 15 km from Sapa.

At 1,900 metres it is Vietnam’s highest mountain pass and acts as a dividing line between two climatic zones.

The lookout points here have fantastic views in clear weather.

Above: Mount Fan Si Pan

On the Sapa side it is often cold and foggy, but drop a few hundred metres onto the Lai Chau side and it can be sunny and warm.

Surprisingly, while Sapa is the coldest place in Vietnam, Lai Chau can be one of the warmest.

Above: Lai Chau

Most people also stop at 100-metre-high Thac Bac (Silver Waterfall, admission 20,000 VND), 12 km from Sapa.

A one-way/return xe om here costs 80,000/150,000 dong.

Above: Thac Bac Waterfall

Tourists who want to learn something new can go on community-based tours to Sin Chai, a Hmong village.

On most tours, overnight stays are arranged so people can learn about textiles, or tribal music and dance.

This is what they came for.

Above: Sin Chai, Vietnam

Most visitors come to Sa Pa to trek to minority villages in the Muong Hoa Valley, which separates Sa Pa from Mount Fan Si Pan.

Until 2016, only a few hardy trekkers each year were successful in scaling Vietnam’s highest peak, but thousands now head there each day thanks to the completion of a controversial 7km, three-wire cable car from Sa Pa to the top.

Stretching 6,292 metres, Fansipan Legend is the longest three-wire cable car in the world.

Its altitude gain of 1,410 metres is also the world’s highest for a three-rope cable car.

Though this enormous project (costing $210 million) was strongly criticized by environmentalists for threatening the continued existence of rare species of flora and fauna, most visitors find it an exciting experience.

Gondolas hold up to 30 people.

The journey up takes around 20 minutes and offers eye-popping views of rice terraces in the valley, churning rivers, waterfalls and dense woodland near the summit.

Unfortunately, the summit itself is cloaked in cloud more often than not, but there is still no shortage of visitors queuing to snap a selfie at the top.

There are souvenir shops and restaurants at the lower and upper terminals.

Take a couple of layers to put on when you get out of the cable car at the top.

Allow a few hours at the top and be prepared to stand in long queues to get on board at weekends.

Above: The summit of Mount Fan Si Pan

But I don’t recommend this.

Instead, walk.

For walking has a multitude of amateurs.

Everyone walks.

It is an activity that requires openness, engagement and few expenses.

While walking, the body and the mind work together, so that thinking becomes almost a physical rhythmic act.

Isn’t it really quite extraordinary to see that, since Man took his first step, no one has asked himself why he walks, how he walks, if he has ever walked, if he could walk better, what he achieves in walking – questions that are tied to all the philosophical, psychological and political systems which preoccupy the world.

(Honoré de Balzac, Theorie de la Demarche)

Above: Honoré de Balzac (1799 – 1850)

For Heidi, there was a joy to finding that her body was adequate to get her where she was going.

It was a gift to develop a more tangible, concrete relationship to her neighbourhood and its residents.

On the trail there is a more stately sense of time one has afoot.

On public transit, where things must be planned and scheduled beforehand, everything feels rushed and ruined.

There is a sense of place that can only be gained on foot.

Too many people nowadays live in a series of interiors – home, car, gym, office, shops, cable car – disconnected from one another.

On foot everything stays connected, for while walking one occupies the spaces between these interiors in the same way one occupies these interiors.

One lives in the whole world rather than in interiors built up against it.

From Rebecca Solnit’s Wanderlust: A History of Walking:

I had told Sono about an ad I found in the Los Angeles Times a few months ago that I had been thinking about ever since.

It was for a CD-ROM encyclopedia and the text that occupied a whole page read:

You used to walk across town in the pouring rain to use our encyclopedia.

We are pretty confident that we can get your kid to click and drag.

I think it was the kid’s walk in the rain that constituted the real education, at least of the senses and the imagination.

It is the unpredictable incidents between official events that add up to a life, the incalculable that give it value.

The random, the unscreened, allows you to find what you don’t know you are looking for.

You don’t know a place until it surprises you.

Walking is one way of maintaining a bulwark against this erosion of the mind, the body, the landscape.

Every walker is a guard on patrol to protect the ineffable.

When you give yourself to places, they give you yourself back.

The more one comes to know them, the more one seeds them with the invisible crop of memories and associations that will be waiting for you when you come back, while new places offer up new thoughts, new possibilities.

Exploring the world is one of the best ways of exploring the mind.

Walking travels both terrains.

Certainly, Heidi could have ascended in comfort, speed and predictability up to the summit of Mount Fan Si Pan.

Certainly, she could have gazed upon the ground below like some Olympian goddess, but doing so the senses are denied forests of huge trees that rise above, plants and animals caressing the Earth that gave them life, all things that are beautiful about existence.

If you are looking for a true adventure in Sapa, skip the cable car and venture into the lush forests of Fan Si Pan.

A good traveller has no fixed plans and is not intent upon arriving.

Lao Tzu, Tao Te Ching

Above: Zhang Lu-Laozi (Lao Tzu) riding an ox through a pass: It is said that with the fall of the Chou dynasty, Lao Tzu decided to travel west through the Han Valley Pass. The Pass Commissioner, Yin-hsi, noticed a trail of vapor emanating from the east, deducing that a sage must be approaching. Not long after, Lao Tzu riding his ox indeed appeared and, at the request of Yin-hsi, wrote down his famous Tao Te Ching, leaving afterwards. This story thus became associated with auspiciousness.

My advice to the younger generation is:

Learn to relax and find meaning in the experience.

When you let go of the haste of normal life, it teaches you truths about yourself you had no idea you longed to know.

Amble out into the world at the whim of your curiosity, search for meaning, and follow whatever sparks your sense of adventure along the way.

Life is boundless and therefore fragmentary.

It is our imagination that brings meaning to these fragments, that gives these fragments a unity called Life.

All days are difficult.

The point is to find enough hope to get through the day.

Hope must be sought, discovered.

Walking is that quest for hope.

Writing is my expression of that quest for hope.

While it is possible to wander into the Muong Hoa Valley, pass through a couple of minority villages and return to Sa Pa in a day, for the full-on Sa Pa trekking experience you will want to overnight in a home-stay and get to know something about your hosts.

The cost to enter most villages is 50,000 dong, though this is included in the price of organized treks.

Expect to pay $60 per day per person for these, depending on the number of people in the group.

It is important to wear the right clothing when walking in these mountains:

Strong ankle support are the best footwear, though you can get away with training shoes in the dry season.

Choose thin, loose clothing.

Long trousers offer some protection from thorns and leeches.

Wear a hat and sunblock.

Take plenty of water.

Carry a basic medical kit.

If you plan on spending a night in a village, you will need warm clothing as temperatures can drop to around freezing.

You might want to take a sleeping bag, mosquito net and food, though these are usually provided on organized tours.

Finally, aggressive dogs can be a problem when entering villages, so it is a good idea to carry a strong stick when trekking.

Always be watchful for the venomous snakes that are common in this area.

The French first developed Sa Pa town, the gateway to the region, as a hill station and cool summer escape from Hanoi’s oppressive heat.

Their dominance in the area didn’t last long, though.

During the 1940s, Vietnamese independence fighters drove the colonists from the region, but not before the French bombed Sa Pa town, leaving nothing but ruins behind them.

It wasn’t until the 1990s that redevelopment began in earnest and tourists started to flock back to the region.

Now, trekking in Sa Pa is one of the biggest tourist activities in Vietnam.

Sa Pa town is the very definition of “tacky tourist town”, with hotels, happy hour signs and souvenir shops obliterating anything real, but Heidi has enjoyed waking up this morning to the quiet beauty of Sa Pa.

Sa Pa town is a crazy tourist trap with hundreds of guest houses offering happy hour cocktails and $5 beds.

A great place if drinking cheap cocktails with hordes of other tourists is your idea of a good time.

Walk along the maze of streets.

Above: Sa Pa, Vietnam

Venture into the Sa Pa Market to try fried banana, corn or sweet potato cake, or grilled fresh sweet potato or grilled corn sold by street vendors as an appetizer. 

If you are brave enough, try a grilled balut (put one balut on a cup, make a hole on top of the balut, add marinade and enjoy.

Above: Sa Pa Market

Walk further through small alleys where you can try different kinds of grilled sticks and rolls (beef, fish, pork or seafood on a stick or roll in mustard greens) and several glasses of inexpensive draft beer.

Or get a seat in a local restaurant, order a fresh salmon from local salmon farms in Sapa or sturgeon and let your chef to perform his skill. 

Salmon hotpot is perfect on a cool evening.

Above: Salmon hotpot

Although still beautiful and highly recommended visiting, Sa Pa is no longer the peaceful hill town it once was.

Many local stores have been replaced by stores selling items visitors need and want because it is more profitable for the local store owners. 

The streets are narrow, with many vans carrying visitors in and out, those same visitors walking the streets, and construction of new hotels contributing to the congestion. 

It can be a bit chaotic. 

So in Sa Pa town don’t expect unspoiled wilderness.

Above: Sa Pa, Vietnam

At the Sa Pa market, a tiny Hmong woman dressed in traditional clothing is waiting for Heidi.

She is the trekking guide, Mama of the Mountains.

The Hmong, known in China for centuries under the name Miao, used to be called Méo in Southeast Asia.

Above: Hmong women at market, Coc Ly, Vietnam

Their number is about three million and they are scattered over a vast territory stretching from southwest China (2 million) to North Vietnam (600,000), Laos (about 250,000), Thailand (150,000) and Myanmar (formerly Burma) (about 30,000).

Above: Flag of China

Above: Flag of Vietnam

Above: Flag of Laos

Above: Flag of Thailand

Above: Flag of Myanmar

They have been members of the Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organization (UNPO) since 2007.

Above: Flag of Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organization (UNPO)

The Hmong are easy to identify because of their red costume.

Above: Hmong costume

In the market food court, Heidi is given a bowl of tofu noodle soup for breakfast.

It is possibly vegetarian, though the piles of mystery meat on every table in the market do make visitors wonder.

Nourishment being the priority, Heidi slurps up the salty sour soup while her tour companions arrive in small, yawning groups.

After breakfast, the gang who had gathered to go trekking in Sapa splits into two groups and they set off up the backstreets and alleyways rising out of Sapa town.

After five minutes of hill climbing in the searing heat, everyone is drenched in sweat and panting hard.

After half an hour, everyone is questioning their life choices.

Heidi views her guide with great scepticism.

Mama – that’s what the guide insists her group calls her – is half Heidi‘s height, her English broken, her back slightly bent, her tone that will not suffer fools, but her smile is infectious.

To give the guide her credit, she knows exactly when to stop to prevent fainting or major heart trauma.

As they reach the day’s first real rest break, exposing a dramatic view of Sapa town far below, the clouds roll in and rain starts to drip out of the sky.

Nobody minds.

Everyone is hot and sticky and happy for the free shower.

The shower turns into a proper rain storm.

Sapa is home to Vietnam’s highest peak, Fan Si Pan, which tickles the clouds 3,143 metres above sea level, keeping watch over the terraced rice paddies that line Sapa’s steep valley walls.

Above: Sa Pa

Home to several ethnic minorities, chiefly the Hmong, the Dao and the Dai, Sapa has been attracting trekkers since the early 1900s.

They walk slowly along a small local path leading into the bottom of the valley, where some stalls are available that serve tea and fruits:

A perfect spot to take a rest and have lunch.

Above: The village of Lao Chai

After lunch, they visit the Tay people of Ta Van, which lies in the middle of the Muong Hoa Valley.

The Tay, who have been present in Vietnam from the beginning, are a branch of the Tay-Thai group.

In Sa Pa, the Tay ethnic group is concentrated in some southern communities, such as Ho village, Nam Sai village and Thanh Phu village.

It is easy to distinguish the Tay from other ethnic groups because their clothing is very different and has only one colour, dark indigo.

Above: Tay women

Above: Ta Van, Vietnam

They check in a local homestay for overnight.

The local hostess prepares dinner.

During dinner, Heidi tries to talk with them to understand more about their local life and thought. 

More rice?

More rice?

Have more rice?

Have more rice!

It wasn’t a question so much as a command — a very forceful command from their homestay host.

She had been around the entire table of trekkers twice already, wielding her plastic rice paddle like a sword.

After a meal that consists of great mountains of tofu, pumpkin, green beans, bean sprouts, mushroom stir fry and, for the carnivores in the group, fried pork, more rice is exactly what Heidi didn’t want.

When it was her turn to get third helpings, Heidi stretched her arms as far away from the tiny hostess and her plastic rice paddle as she could get.

No,” Heidi laughs.

No, I won’t eat it!

A minute later, after she thought had escaped, another half-cup of rice has been plopped it into her bowl.

At each meal, local women come around to sell their handmade bags, scarves and jewelry.

Even though Heidi isn’t interested, it doesn’t hurt to be friendly, make eye contact, and smile.

The vendors persist in showing her each item they have in their bags, so whether Heidi is friendly or not — she might as well make it a pleasant experience for everyone involved.

The native hill tribe women have learned that following trekkers and city walkers selling local crafts is a great business model. 

So it is best to expect and embrace it as part of the culture, while politely declining if you are not interested, or purchasing/donating if you are inclined. 

The local people are genuine and very friendly if you get to know them beyond their sales. 

Local hill tribe women wear traditional dress, not as much for tourists as it has been their tradition to wear it outside the home for centuries. 

It is not the tradition for men to do so. 

Acres and acres of rice paddies line the hillsides, passed down through the family for generations and still cultivated as a primary source of income.

Once the rice is finally eaten, the rice wine comes out in a much-used plastic 1.5L water bottle.

Once again, the hostess will not be denied.

The trekkers and their enthusiastic hostess down shot after shot of the fiery clear liquid, each drink being preceded by a group chant of “Một hai ba, yo!” or “One, two, three, cheers!”.

A messy, drunken evening ensues.

But the thing about messy drunken evenings at the end of a full day of trekking is that they invariably end early.

Everyone is snugly encamped under mosquito nets by 8:30 pm.

Before 11 pm, even the most foolhardy drinkers have turned out the lights and snored themselves to sleep.

Dreaming of the road ahead.

Not so early the next morning, they gather for a breakfast of thin pancakes with fresh local honey, bananas and fried eggs.

Heidi eats as much as her stomach can hold, knowing another day of heavy exertion lies ahead.

The large group sets off together, winding their way down through the village and out along a narrow muddy track onto the sparsely forested slopes of the mountain.

They pass tiny wooden houses where piglets, baby chicks, and puppies play in the dirt.

There are plenty of village children to meet, too.

Some kids are shy or indifferent to our passing.

Others shout “Hello!” or come running out for a high five.

Slightly ahead of the group, Heidi spots an adorable girl.

Xin chao!”, she shouts with a grin.

The little girl returns Heidi’s smile and her greeting.

With her mother and brother watching over her, Heidi bends down to say hello again and asks to take her picture.

The little girl strikes a perfect pose.

The streamlined group of long-term travellers falls into an easy rhythm as the rice fields and endless purple mountains spread out before them.

Today’s trek is much less hilly and far more satisfying than yesterday’s.

For a start, the clouds have rolled away and they enjoy spectacular views of the rice fields and orchards along the mountainside.

They are also further from Sa Pa town, meaning that they meet more locals and fewer tourists.

Finally, Heidi manages to have real conversations.

Between the quiet minutes of meditative walking, they share their most remarkable travel experiences, their embarrassing moments, their favourite music and their best travel tips.

They chat about the various study- and volunteer-abroad experiences each of them has had, how they handle pressures from family and friends back home, and their plans (or lack thereof) for the future.

Though Heidi enjoys the occasional party, this is what she was looking for on a group tour:

Meeting like-minded people with interesting observations about the world and their unceasing desire to explore it.

The village of Giang Ta Chai is the next stop, which we will reach by following a path over a bridge.

Lunch is provided near a waterfall, just before arrival at the village.

Above: Giang Ta Chai, Vietnam

Eventually, the trek returns to the hill above Hau Thao village.

Above: Hau Thao, Vietnam

They continue to trek to the next village of Ban Ho.

There lives the Tay tribe with their special wooden houses on stilts.

They overnight in Ban Ho village.

Above: Ban Ho, Vietnam

In the morning after breakfast the group walks around Ban Ho village and then trek to Love Waterfall to relax.

Above: Love Waterfall

The final day’s trek is all about making fast tracks back to Sa Pa town.

They follow a steep road that winds up out of the valley floor, taking them back the way they came.

Being on the road in a small group means they make quick time, though they still take plenty of breaks to high five the local kids, attempt to cuddle the large puppy population, and have at least one close encounter with a buffalo.

Once again, they are under the blistering sun for their climb.

A sticky layer of sunscreen, sweat, and rich red dirt envelops them all.

Clouds roll in, threatening more rain, but do little to cool the group.

They stop in a village café near their first night’s homestay for our final lunch of the trip.

It is a hub for people coming and going from Sapa, so once again Heidi is part of a noisy gang of tourists.

Mama shows up to herd the entire café full of trekkers to their various destinations:

Some are getting the 4 pm bus to Hanoi.

Others are taking the sleeper bus or the train.

Still others are hopping on a bus to Lao, while some are staying another night at the homestay.

The efficiency and humour Mama displays while arranging this frenzy of activity is a minor miracle.

The Hmong grow watermelons, oranges, dragon fruit and bananas in orchards around Fan Si Pan.

Tourism provides them with new opportunities to earn sustainable salary.

With that income, they can help their families and their communities.

Put on your trekking boots and step out into the lush green fields of Sapa in Vietnam.

Experience amazing nature brushed with every palette of green.

Meet and engage with the local minority people and immerse yourself into their culture. 

People often use “Sapa” to describe the entire region, not only the smaller Sapa town of 7,000, a hillside town overlooking the green surrounding ​valleys with views of Fan Si Pan, Vietnam’s highest peak, and the dozens of surrounding villages where 29,000 mostly native minorities have lived for hundreds of years. 

The area saw very few tourists before 1993, when both Vietnamese and foreign tourists started to come to see the beautiful terraced rice paddies, corn fields clinging to the sides of the valleys, the clouds rolling in and out, and to stay and relax in the beautiful countryside.

Of course, in conversations with Mama, Heidi wondered what it must be like to be a woman in Vietnam.

Women occupy both the domestic and outside sector in contemporary Vietnam.

Women’s participation in the economy, government, and society has increased.

In the domestic sphere, little progress has been made to improve gender relations.

Above: Young Vietnamese women

Traditional Confucian patriarchal values values have continued to persist, as well as a continued emphasis on the family unit.

This has comprised the main criticism of Vietnam Women’s Union, an organization that works towards advancing women’s rights.

Furthermore, recent shifts in Vietnam’s sex ratio show an increased number of men outnumbering women, which many researchers have stated to in part be caused by the two-child policy in Vietnam.

Confucianism’s emphasis on the family still impacts Vietnamese women’s lives, especially in rural areas, where it espouses the importance of premarital female virginity and condemns abortion and divorce.

Above: The teaching Confucius (551 – 479 BCE)

According to a 2006 study, over the past decades, little progression in gender relations have been made.

Household chores and labour are still primarily performed by Vietnamese women.

However, women in Vietnam have shown increased influence in familial decisions, such as household budgets and the education of the children.

In terms of childcare responsibility, men have shown an increased participation at the earlier ages of childcare, though women overall still bear the main responsibility. 

Women are seen primarily as mothers, and are considered to have shown “respect” to their husband’s lineage if they give birth to a boy.

While patrilineal ancestor worship shows girls as “outside lineage” (họ ngoại), it consider boys to be “inside lineage” (họ nội).

Vietnamese society tends to follow the ancestral line through males, pushing women to the periphery.

As aforementioned Vietnam has a two child policy.

Some families want at least one boy, but would prefer two boys to two girls, so they use ultrasound machines to determine the baby’s sex to later abort female offspring.

Above: Five sisters, Hanoi, Vietnam, 1953

The main religion in Vietnam are traditional folk beliefs.

This is not an organized religion, however it does adopt many Confucian views.

One of the main views that it takes from Confucius is the Patrilineal Society.

Men are the head of the family and more their lineage is to be protected.

As it pertains to motherhood, Vietnam women are seen as and used primarily as mothers.

Female virginity is of extreme importance, especially in rural areas, and the Society condemns abortion and female divorce.

As said, if a woman wants to show respect to her husband, the best way she can do that is to bear him a son.

Above: “Heaven will instruct the master like a wooden-clapper bell to awaken everyone to the Way.” — Analects 3.24

The issue of domestic violence has faced scrutiny in Vietnam.

In 2007, Vietnamese legislation passed the Law on Prevention and Control Domestic Violence, which reported that 32% of Vietnamese women have suffered sexual violence from their spouses, while 54% of women in Vietnam have suffered from emotional violence.

Speculation has rose on the viability of divorce as a solution to those in situations of domestic violence.

This is due to the prevalent local attitudes and measures taken towards preventing divorce in order to preserve the family unit, rather than helping victims escape domestic abuse.

Additionally, surveys have indicated that 87% of domestic violence victims in Vietnam do not seek support for their situation.

In a study comparing Chinese and Vietnamese attitudes towards women, more Vietnamese than Chinese said that the male should dominate the family and a wife had to provide sex to her husband at his will.

Above: A traditional Vietnamese country wedding

(From this male blogger’s point-of-view, I am not suggesting that a wife must provide sex to her husband at his will, but it is the hope that she wants to have sex with her partner with the same desired frequency.)

Violence against women was supported by more Vietnamese than Chinese.

Domestic violence was more accepted by Vietnamese women than Chinese women.

Some Vietnamese women from Lào Cai who married Chinese men stated that among their reasons for doing so was that Vietnamese men beat their wives, engaged in affairs with mistresses, and refused to help their wives with chores, while Chinese men actively helped their wives carry out chores and care for them.

Above: Lào Cai City, Vietnam

Vietnamese women travelling to China as mail order brides for rural Chinese men to earn money for their families and a rise in the standard of living, matchmaking between Chinese men and Vietnamese women has increased and has not been effected by troubled relations between Vietnam and China.

Above: Flags of Vietnam (left) and China (right)

Vietnamese mail order brides have also gone to Taiwan and South Korea for marriage.

Above: Flag of Taiwan

Above: Flag of South Korea

The main human rights issue in Southeast Asia is human trafficking.

According to one study, Southeast Asia is a large source of human trafficking, with many individuals who fall victim to human trafficking being sent to Australia.

Above: Flag of Australia

Vietnam, as well as other countries such as Cambodia, Laos, and the Philippines, are major source countries for human trafficking.

Above: Flag of Cambodia

Above: Flag of the Philippines

While many of the victims that are a part of human trafficking are forced/kidnapped/enslaved, others were lured in under the assumption that they were getting a better job.

According to a policy brief on human trafficking in Southeast Asia, although victims include girls, women, boys, and men, the majority are women.

Women tend to be more highly targeted by traffickers due to the fact that they are seeking opportunity in an area of the world where limited economic opportunities are available for them.

Unskilled and poorly educated women are commonly led into human trafficking.

According to the United Nations Office on Drug and Crime (UNODC) report, women are trafficked the most.

The main causes of human trafficking in Southeast Asia are universal factors such as poverty and globalization.

Industrialization is arguably also another factor of human trafficking.

Many scholars argue that industrialization of booming economies, like that of Thailand and Singapore, created a draw for poor migrants seeking upward mobility and individuals wanting to leave war torn countries.

These migrants were an untapped resource in growing economies that had already exhausted the cheap labor from within its borders.

A high supply of migrant workers seeking employment and high demand from an economy seeking cheap labor creates a perfect combination for human traffickers to thrive.

Above: Flag of Singapore

The sex industry emerged in Southeast Asia in the mid 20th century as a way for women to generate more income for struggling migrants and locals trying to support families or themselves.

Sex industries first catered to military personnel on leave from bases, but as military installations began to recede the industry turned its attention to growing tourism.

Above: Scene from Good Morning, Vietnam – Chintara Sukapatana (Trinh) and Robin Williams (Adrian Cronauer)

Even as the industry is looked down upon today there is still a large underground market that is demanding from traffickers.

Between 2005 and 2009, 6,000 women, as well as younger girls, were found to be in the human trafficking statistic.

The majority of the women and girls are trafficked to China, 30% are trafficked to Cambodia, and the remaining 10% are trafficked to the destinations across the world.

Several cases have occurred where Vietnamese women were abducted or deceived to be sold to Chinese men.

Totalling several thousands, in a significant number of cases the victims were underage.

Above: These Vietnamese girls were abducted and sold in China.

Overall literacy rates across Vietnam are high, with access to education being relatively equal between males and females.

However, regional differences are still apparent, especially amongst the mountainous northern regions.

For example, in one study, the region of Lai Chau was found to have a literacy rate for men double that of the women’s literacy rate in the region.

There is a gender gap in education, with males being more likely to attend school and sustain their education than females.

Women and men tend to be segregated into different jobs, with more women serving in educational, communications, and public services than men.

Above: Vietnamese village school, Tam Duòng

In contemporary Vietnam, there has been significant economic advancement for women, especially for middle-class Vietnamese women.

Middle-class women have increasingly become more involved in the workforce sector outside of the house, with 83% of “working-age women” being involved in the labour force.

These women have been taking on professions dealing with a variety of fields such as sales, marketing, and advertising.

Furthermore, women in the contemporary workforce and economy experience much higher wages than the generations before them.

However, research has shown that many inequalities for women still exist, with women still receiving uneven employment benefits compared to their male counterparts. 

According to one study, 76% of women in the labor force are concentrated in the agricultural sector.

And although under 10% of women in the labour force work in the textile industry, 80% of labourers in the textile industry are women.

Local credit associations do not feel secure giving loans to single mothers, which has resulted in a poverty increase for households that are led by a woman.

The average wage in the country of Vietnam was US$1,540 in 2012.

In 2011, studies showed “that women earn 13% less than men“.

The 2012 survey on workers’ salaries carried out by the Vietnam General Confederation of Labour (VGCL) in enterprises nationwide revealed that female workers’ salaries are only 70-80% of their male colleagues’.

The global average gender pay gap is hovering around 17%.

Above: Logo of the Vietnam General Confederation of Labour

According to Nguyen Kim Lan, ILO national project coordinator, the only two occupational fields where pay is equal is in logistics, and household care.

One reason for the disparity is that companies view women as wanting to stay at home and perform more gender role duties.

More than 70% of labourers in Vietnam are women.

The International Labour Organization recently stated that the gender pay gap has started to increase, according to the ILO Global Wage Report during the 2012 – 2013 period, compared to 1999 – 2007. 

A 2% increase in the gap was recorded in Vietnam in the period.

In recent decades, Vietnam has stressed the importance of gender equality.

Above: Emblem of Vietnam

To address this goal, the Vietnam Women’s Union, an organization founded in 1930 under the Vietnam Communist Party, has pursued the advancement of women in many arenas.

Above: Symbol of the Vietnamese Communist Party

However, they also stress many aspects of Confucian doctrine that keeps a male-dominated hierarchy in place.

As of 2000, their membership has expanded to 11 million, which compromises for 60% of the female population in Vietnam over the age of 18.

Because of their large membership, the Vietnam Women’s Union has frequently been regarded as the representative for women in politics.

Therefore, the VWU frequently advises during the policy-making of gender-related or women’s issues.

However, their role has been disputed due to its shortcomings in promoting women’s right effectively.

In the 1980s, the Vietnam Women’s Union increased paid maternity leave and received a promise that they would be asked before the government implemented any policies that could potentially affect the welfare of women.

However, the increased maternity leave was restored to its original length a few years later.

While there are limits in the Vietnam Women’s Union that prohibit gender change in certain areas, there does not seem to be other organized civil society groups that are fighting for women’s rights.

Two areas that have seen little change throughout recent decades are the roles women play in the family, specifically motherhood, and the human rights problems women traditionally face in the region.

In 2001, the Vietnam Women’s Union was appointed to head the planning of a new legislation, a Law on Gender Equality, which set out to equalize conditions between both genders.

The legislation included several stipulations, including laws pertaining to retirement age for both men and women.

The law went into effect mid 2007.

Their focus on Confucian values which uphold a male-dominated hierarchy has received criticism.

In numerous studies, the VWU has been criticized for its lack of action against gender norms while placing too much emphasis on family structure.

Furthermore, while their efforts have worked towards improving women’s status, the VWU faces criticism for their lack of advocacy towards women’s power.

Above: Logo of the Vietnam Women’s Union

Invariably, Heidi thinks of her life as a woman in Switzerland by comparison.

Above: Switzerland

Tradition dictates that the place of Swiss women is in the home in charge of housework and child care.

Being in a society with strong patriarchal roots, Swiss tradition also places women under the authority of their fathers and their husbands.

Such adherence to patriarchal domination changed and improved when the women of Switzerland gained their right to vote at the federal level on 7 February 1971.

However, despite of gaining status of having equal rights with men, some Swiss women still have to be able to attain education beyond the post-secondary level, thus they earn less money than men, and they occupy lower-level job positions.

According to swissinfo.ch in 2011, Switzerland’s State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (Seco) were encouraging business companies to “appoint more women to top-level positions“.

Those who are already working in business companies, according to same report, mentions that “women earn on average 20% less than men” in Switzerland, and the ratio was 6 out of 10 women were working part-time.

Prominent Swiss women in the fields of business and law include Emilie Kempin-Spyri (1853 – 1901), the first woman to graduate with a law degree and to be accepted as an academic lecturer in the country, and Isabelle Welton, the head of IBM Switzerland and one of few women in the country to hold a top-level position in a business firm.

Above: Emilie Kempin-Spyri

Above: Isabelle Welton

Above: Logo of International Business Machines (IBM)

Family life has been traditionally patriarchal, following the model of a male breadwinner and a female housewife.

In Europe, Switzerland was one of the last countries to establish gender equality in marriage:

Married women’s rights were severely restricted until 1988, when legal reforms providing gender equality in marriage, abolishing the legal authority of the husband, came into force (these reforms had been approved in 1985 by voters in a referendum, who narrowly voted in favour with 54.7% of voters approving).

Adultery was decriminalized in 1989.

In 1992, the law was changed to end discrimination against married women with regard to national citizenship.

Marital rape was criminalized in 1992.

In 2004 it became a state offense in Switzerland.

Divorce laws were also reformed in 2000 and 2005.

In 2013, further reforms to the Civil Code followed, removing the remaining discriminatory provisions regarding the spouses’ choice of family name and cantonal citizenship law.

Until the late 20th century, most cantons had regulations banning unmarried cohabitation of couples.

Above: Bern, the capital of Switzerland

The last canton to end such prohibition was Valais in 1995.

Above: Flag of the Canton of Valais

As of 2015, 22.5% of births were to unmarried women.

Women face significant struggles with regards to work for pay.

Although most women are employed, many are so on a part-time basis or in marginal employment.

The view that women, especially married women, should not work full-time remains prevalent.

Among the OECD, only the Netherlands has more women working part-time.

Above: Flag of the Netherlands

 

Although the law no longer requires the husband’s consent for a wife’s work, in job interviews women are often asked for it. 

Taxation penalizing dual-income families exists in some cantons.

The OECD has stated that:

The lack of family-friendly policy and workplace support makes it very difficult for many Swiss parents, usually mothers, to combine work and family life.”

The OECD has also urged Switzerland to end the practice of irregular and interrupted school hours which makes it difficult for mothers to work, and to revise its tax and supplementary benefits policies.

Above: Logo for Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development

Despite all these, women have a legal right to work and to not be discriminated in the workforce, under the 1996 equality law.

In 2005, paid maternity leave was introduced in Switzerland, after voters approved it in a referendum.

Four previous attempts to secure it had previously failed at the ballot box.

As in other Western countries, the 1990s and the 21st century saw reforms with regard to laws on domestic violence. 

Marital rape was made illegal in 1992, and since 2004 marital rape is prosecutable ex-officio (meaning it can be prosecuted even if the victim does not file an official complaint).

Switzerland also ratified the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings in 2012, and the Istanbul Convention in 2017.

Above: Women of Champery, Switzerland, 1912

Eskisehir, Turkey, Tuesday 10 May 2022

The Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence, better known as the Istanbul Convention, is a human rights treaty of the Council of Europe against violence against women and domestic violence which was opened for signature on 11 May 2011, in Istanbul, Turkey.

The Convention aims at prevention of violence, victim protection and to end the impunity of perpetrators.

As of March 2019, it has been signed by 45 countries and the European Union.

The Convention came into force on 1 August 2014.

Above: Signatories of the Istanbul Convention – Green: signed and ratified / Yellow: only signed / Red: not signed / Purple: denounced and withdrawn

In a press release in November 2018, the Council of Europe stated:

Despite its clearly stated aims, several religious and ultra conservative groups have been spreading false narratives about the Istanbul Convention.”

The release stated that the Convention does not seek to impose a certain lifestyle or interfere with personal organization of private life.

Instead, it seeks only to prevent violence against women and domestic violence.

The release states that:

The Convention is certainly not about ending sexual differences between women and men.

Nowhere does the Convention ever imply that women and men are or should be ‘the same’ and that the Convention does not seek to regulate family life and/or family structures:

It neither contains a definition of ‘family’ nor does it promote a particular type of family setting.”

According to Balkan Insight, criticism of the Convention, strongest in Central and Eastern Europe and mainly by the far right and national conservatives, has little foundation in its actual content.

Using disinformation, populist rhetoric, and appeals to Christian and Islamic morality, critics have managed to reframe what is essentially a set of guidelines that creates ‘a comprehensive legal framework and approach to combat violence against women’, into a sinister attempt by Western Europeans to foist their overly-liberal policies on reluctant societies further east.

In 2021, Turkey became the first and only country to withdraw from the Convention, after denouncing it on 20 March 2021.

The Convention ceased to be effective in Turkey on 1 July 2021, following its denunciation.

On 20 March 2021, Turkish President Erdoğan announced his country’s withdrawal from the Convention by a presidential decree published in the official government gazette.

Above: Flag of Turkey

(From The Guardian, 24 November 2014:

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has been accused of blatant sexism after declaring that women are not equal to men and claiming feminists in Turkey reject the idea of motherhood.

The devoutly Muslim president said biological differences meant women and men could not serve the same functions, adding that manual work was unsuitable for the “delicate nature” of women.

Above: Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

His comments ignited a firestorm of controversy on Twitter and one well-known female TV news anchor even took the unusual step of condemning the remarks during a bulletin.

Above: Logo of Twitter

Our religion Islam has defined a position for women: motherhood,” Erdoğan said at a summit in Istanbul on justice for women, speaking to an audience including his own daughter Sumeyye.

Above: Sumeyye Erdoğan and daughter Esra

Some people can understand this, while others can’t.

You cannot explain this to feminists because they don’t accept the concept of motherhood.

He recalled:

I would kiss my mother’s feet because they smelled of Paradise.

She would glance coyly and cry sometimes.

Motherhood is something else,” he said, claiming that it should be a woman’s priority because Islam exalts women as mothers.

Above: Mother and son, Tenzile and Recep Erdoğan

He went on to say that women and men could not be treated equally “because it goes against the laws of nature”.

Their characters, habits and physiques are different.

You cannot place a mother breastfeeding her baby on an equal footing with men.

You cannot make women work in the same jobs as men do, as in Communist regimes.

You cannot give them a shovel and tell them to do their work.

This is against their delicate nature.

Erdoğan was apparently referring to the practice during and after the Second World War for women in Communist states such as the USSR to do heavy manual work in factories or in roles such as tram drivers.

Above: Flag of the Soviet Union (1955 – 1991)

He complained that in previous decades in Turkey women in Anatolian villages had done the back-breaking work while their menfolk idled away the time.

Wasn’t it the case in Anatolia?

Our poor mothers suffered immensely and got hunchbacks while the men were playing cards and rolling dice at teahouses,” he said.

What women need is to be able to be equivalent, rather than equal.

Because equality turns the victim into an oppressor and vice versa.”

Erdoğan has been married since 1978 to his wife Emine, with whom he has two sons and two daughters.

Above: Emine Erdoğan

Aylin Nazliaka, an MP from the main opposition Republican People’s party said Erdoğan “ostracised” women by portraying them as delicate, weak and powerless and limiting their role to motherhood.

Erdoğan has publicly committed a hate crime.

But I will continue to fight this man who sees no difference between terrorists and feminists,” she said in a written statement.

Above: Aylin Nazliaka

Sule Zeybek, an anchorwoman at the Turkish broadcaster Kanal D, hit back at Erdoğan’s comments live on television during a news bulletin.

I am a feminist and thank God I’m a mum.

I wouldn’t kiss my mother’s feet but I have great respect for her,” she said.

Above: Sule Zeybek

The Islamic-rooted government of Erdoğan has long been accused by critics of seeking to erode the country’s secular principles and limiting the civil liberties of women.

Erdoğan has drawn the ire of feminist groups for declaring that every woman in Turkey should have three children and with proposals to limit abortion rights, the morning-after pill and caesarean sections.

Seen by critics as increasingly authoritarian, he has repeatedly lashed out personally at female journalists who displeased him.

Above: Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

But the government’s attitude towards women came under even greater scrutiny after the Deputy Prime Minister, Bülent Arinç, caused a furore in August by suggesting women should not laugh loudly in public.

Above: Bülent Arinç

Activists also say that government officials’ remarks about women and how they should be treated leave them exposed to violence.

According to non-governmental organisations, more than 200 women in Turkey died as a result of domestic violence in the first six months of 2014.)

Above: Feminist protest, Istanbul, 29 July 2017

The notification for withdrawal has been reported to the Secretary-General by Turkey on 22 March 2021 and the Secretary-General has announced that denunciation will enter into force on 1 July 2021.

The withdrawal has been criticized both domestically and internationally, including by the opposition parties in the country, foreign leaders, the Council of Europe, NGOs and on social media.

The COE Secretary-General Marija Pejčinović Burić described the decision as “devastating news” and a “huge setback” that compromises the protection of women in Turkey and abroad.

Above: Marija Pejčinović Burić

A CHP spokesperson claimed that the agreement cannot be withdrawn without parliamentary approval, since it was approved by Parliament on 24 November 2011.

According to the CHP and various lawyers, the right to approve the withdrawal belongs to the Parliament according to Article 90 of the Constitution.

Above: Logo of the Republican People’s Party (CHP)

However, the government claims that the President has the authority to withdraw from international agreements as stated in Article 3 of the Presidential Decree #9.

Above: The Court of Justice, Istanbul

The decision sparked protests across Turkey and comes at a time where the domestic violence against women and femicides in the country are soaring.

US President Joe Biden described the move as “deeply disappointing“.

Above: Joe Biden

The EU’s foreign policy chief Josep Borrell urged the authorities to reverse the decision. 

Above: Josep Borrell

In an official statement, the Turkish Presidency blamed the LGBT community for the withdrawal from the Convention, arguing that:

The Istanbul Convention, originally intended to promote women’s rights, was hijacked by a group of people attempting to normalize homosexuality – which is incompatible with Turkey’s social and family values.

Hence, the decision to withdraw.

(Homosexual activity is legal in Turkey.

However, LGBT people in Turkey face discrimination, harassment and even violence from their relatives, neighbors, etc.

The Turkish authorities have carried out many discriminatory practices.

Despite these, LGBT acceptance in Turkey is growing.

In a survey conducted by Kadir Has University in Istanbul in 2016, 33% of respondents said that LGBT people should have equal rights, which increased to 45% in 2020.

Another survey by Kadir Has University in 2018 found that the proportion of people who would not want a homosexual neighbour decreased from 55% in 2018 to 47% in 2019. 

A poll by Ipsos in 2015 found that 27% of the Turkish public was in favor of legalizing same-sex marriage and 19% supported civil unions instead.

Istanbul Pride was held for the first time in 2003.

Turkey became the first Muslim-majority country to hold a gay pride march.

It was also the first gay pride in the Middle East and the Balkans.

Above: Istanbul Pride, 2013 –
Istanbul Pride was organized in 2003 for the first time.
Since 2015, parades in Istanbul were denied permission by the government.
The denials were based on security concerns, but critics claimed the bans were ideological.
Despite the refusal hundreds of people defied the ban each year.)

(In 2002, Erdoğan said that:

Homosexuals must be legally protected within the framework of their rights and freedoms.

From time to time, we do not find the treatment they get on some television screens humane.

However, in 2017 Erdoğan has said that empowering LGBT people in Turkey was “against the values of our nation“.

Above: Flag of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender community

In 2020, amid the COVID-19 pandemic, Turkey’s top Muslim scholar and President of Religious Affairs, Ali Erbaş, said in a Friday Ramadan announcement that the country condemns homosexuality because it “brings illness“, insinuating that same sex relations are responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic.

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan backed Erbaş, saying that what Erbaş “said was totally right“.)

Above: Ali Erbaş

That view is shared by conservative groups and officials from Erdoğan’s Islamic-oriented ruling party, the AKP, who claim that the agreement is promoting homosexuality, encouraging divorce and undermining what constitutes a “sacred” family in their view. 

Above: Logo of the Justice and Development Party (AKP)

Answering to criticism over the legality of withdrawal by the Presidency instead of Parliament, Erdoğan insisted that the withdrawal was “completely legal“.

Above: Seal of the President of Turkey

On 29 June, Turkey’s top administrative court rejected a motion for stay of execution regarding Erdogan’s sole decision to withdraw from the Istanbul Convention on violence against women and ruled that it was legal for Erdoğan to withdraw the country out of the Convention since the authority to ratify and annul international agreements was among the president’s powers, according to Article 104 of the Constitution.)

Above: Logo of the Constitutional Court of Turkey

From Rebecca Solnit’s Wanderlust: A History of Walking:

Jean-Jacques Rousseau remarked in his Confessions:

I can only meditate when I am walking. When I stop, I cease to think. My mind only works with my legs.

Above: Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712 – 1778)

In 1749 the writer and encyclopedist Denis Diderot was thrown into jail for writing an essay questioning the goodness of God.

Above: Denis Diderot (1713 – 1784)

Rousseau, a close friend of Diderot’s at the time, took to visiting him in jail, walking the six miles from his home in Paris to the dungeon of the Château de Vincennes.

Above: Château de Vicennes

Though that summer was extremely hot, Rousseau walked because he was too poor to travel by other means.

In order to slacken my pace, I thought of taking a book with me.

One day I took the Mercure de France and, glancing through it as I walked, I came upon this question propounded by the Dijon Academy for the next year’s prize:

Has the progress of the sciences and arts done more to corrupt morals or improve them?

The moment I read that I beheld another universe and became another man.

Rousseau won the prize and the published essay became famous for its furious condemnation of such progress.

Above: Logo of the Académie des sciences, arts et humanités, Dijon

In his Discourse on Inequality, Rousseau portrays Man in his natural condition “wandering in the forests, without industry, without speech, without domicile, without war and without liaisons, with no need of his fellow men, likewise with no desire to harm them.”

In this ideology, walking functions as an emblem of the simple man and as, when the walk is solitary and rural, a means of being in nature and outside society.

The walker has the detachment of the traveller but travels unadorned and unaugmented, dependent on his or her own bodily strength rather than on conveniences that can be made and bought.

Walking is, after all, an activity essentially unimproved since the dawn of time.

Rousseau walked extensively throughout his life.

His wandering life began when he returned to Geneva from a Sunday stroll in the country, only to find that he had come back too late:

The gates of the city were shut.

Above: Geneva, Switzerland

Impulsively, the 15-year-old Rousseau decided to abandon his birthplace, his apprenticeship and eventually his religion.

He turned from the gates and walked out of Switzerland.

Above: Coat of arms of Switzerland

In Italy and France he found and left many jobs, patrons and friends during a life that seemed aimless….

Above: Flag of Italy

Above: Flag of France

Until the day he read the Mercure de France and found his vocation.

Ever after, he seemed to be trying to recover the carefree wandering of his youth.

He writes of one episode:

I do not remember ever having had in all my life a spell of time so completely free from care and anxiety as those seven or eight days spent on the road.

This memory has left me the strongest taste for everything associated with it, for mountains especially and for travelling on foot.

I have never travelled so except in my prime and it has always been a delight to me.

He continued to walk at every opportunity.

Elsewhere he claimed:

Never did I think so much, exist so vividly and experience so much.

Never have I been so much myself as in the journeys I have taken alone and on foot.

There is something about walking that stimulates and enlivens my thoughts.

When I stay in one place I can hardly think at all.

My body has to be on the move to set my mind going.

The sight of the countryside, the succession of pleasant views, the open air, a sound appetite and the good health I gain by walking, the easy atmosphere of an inn, the absence of everything that makes me feel my dependence, of everything that recalls me to my situation – all these serve to free my spirit, to lend a greater boldness to my thinking, so that I can combine them, select them and make them mine as I will, without fear or restraint.

It was, of course, an ideal walking that Rousseau described – chosen freely by a healthy person amid pleasant and safe circumstances.

It is this kind of walking that would be taken up by his countless heirs as an expression of well-being, harmony with nature, freedom and virtue.

Rousseau portrays walking as both an exercise of simplicity and a means of contemplation.

During the time he wrote the Discourses, he would walk alone in the Bois de Boulogne after dinner, “thinking over subjects for works to be written and not returning till night“.

Above: Bois de Boulogne as seen from the Tour d’Eiffel, Paris, France

A solitary walker is in the world, but apart from it, with the detachment of the traveller rather than the ties of the worker, the dweller, the member of a group.

Walking seems to have become Rousseau’s chosen mode of being, because within a walk he is able to live in thought and reverie, to be self-sufficient, and thus to survive the world.

Walking provides him with a literal position from which to speak.

As a literary structure, the recounted walk encourages digression and association.

A century and a half later, James Joyce and Virginia Woolf would, in trying to describe the workings of the mind, develop the style called stream of consciousness.

Above: James Joyce (1882 – 1941)

Above: Virginia Woolf (1882 – 1941)

In their novels Ulysses and Mrs. Dalloway, the jumble of thoughts and recollections of their protagonists unfolds best during their walks.

This kind of unstructured, associative thinking is the kind most connected to walking.

Walking is not an analytical act but an improvisational one.

Soren Kierkegaard is the other philosopher who has much to say about walking and thinking.

He chose Copenhagen as his place to walk and study his human subjects.

The streets of Copenhagen were his reception room.

Kierkegaard’s great daily pleasure seems to have been walking the streets of his city.

It was a way to be among people for a man who could not be with them, a way to bask in the faint human warmth of brief encounters, acquaintances’ greetings and overheard conversations.

Above: Nyhavn Canal, Copenhagen, Denmark

A lone walker is both present and detached from the world around, more than an audience but less than a participant.

Walking assuages or legitimizes this alienation:

One is mildly disconnected because one is walking, not because one is incapable of connecting.

Walking provided Kierkegaard, like Rousseau, with a wealth of casual contacts with his fellow humans and it facilitated contemplation.

Kierkegaard wrote:

In order to bear mental tension as mine, I need diversion, the diversion of chance contacts on the streets and alleys, because associations with a few exclusive individuals is actually no diversion.

He proposes that the mind works best when surrounded by distraction, that it focuses in the act of withdrawing from surrounding bustle rather than in being isolated from it.

Above: Soren Kierkegaard caricature, Corsaren satirical journal, 26 August 1846

He revelled in the turbulent variety of city life.

This very moment there is an organ grinder down in the street playing and singing.

It is wonderful.

It is the accidental and insignificant things in life that are significant.

Although his extensive walks were perceived as signs of idleness, they were in fact the foundation of his prolific work.

The city strolls distracted him so that he could forget himself enough to think more productively, for his private thoughts are often convolutions of self-consciousness and despair.

In a journal passage from 1848, he described how on his way home, “overwhelmed with ideas ready to be written down and in a sense so weak that I could scarcely walk“, he would often encounter a poor man.

If he refused to speak with him, the ideas would flee.

And I would sink into the most dreadful spiritual tribulation at the idea that God could do to me what I had done to that man, but if I took the time to talk with the poor man things never went that way.”

Above: Copenhagen

Like Rousseau, Kierkegaard is a hybrid, a philosophical writer rather than a philosopher proper.

Their work is often descriptive, evocative, personal and poetically ambiguous.

It has room for delight and personality and something as specific as the sound of an organ grinder in a street or rabbits on the island of Saint Pierre on the Lake of Bienne where Rousseau lived on the estate of Ermenonville.

Above: Château d’Ermenonville

Walking is a way of grounding one’s thoughts in a personal and embodied experience of the world that lends itself to writing.

Edmund Husserl described walking as the experience by which we understand our body in relationship to the world.

The body, he said, is our experience of what is always here.

The body in motion experiences the unity of all its parts as the continuous “here” that moves toward and through the various “theres“.

It is the body that moves but the world that changes, which is how one distinguishes the body from the world.

Above: German philosopher/mathematician Edmund Husserl (1859 – 1938)

Travel can be a way to experience this continuity of self amid the flux of the world and thus to begin to understand each and their relationship to each other.

Travel is about being utterly mobile, but the postmodern body is shuttled around by airplanes and hurtling cars, not even moving around by any apparent means muscular, mechanical, economic or ecological.

The body has become nothing more than a parcel in transit, a chess piece dropped on a square.

It does not move.

It is moved.

Walking returns the body to its original limits again, to something supple, sensitive and vulnerable.

Walking itself extends into the world.

The path is an extension of walking, the places set aside for walking are monuments to that pursuit.

Walking is a mode of making the world as well as being in it.

I find myself from time to time in the midst of psychological conflict with a wife who cannot comprehend that my search for personal happiness cannot revolve around being with her constantly, that I must be fulfilled in all the roles a man must do, besides husband.

A friend has confessed to me their struggle between the desires of the day and the longings for tomorrow.

Heidi was in turmoil having just ended a relationship and finding herself wondering why she was travelling and what would happen if she stopped.

From Dan Kieran’s The Idle Traveller – The Art of Slow Travel:

Slow travel rarely goes according to plan.

Everything you encounter in your life, whether you consider it to be real or imagined, ultimately resides in thoughts and concepts in your brain.

The “real” world is far larger and more complicated than the one we are aware of.

We are all planning for tomorrow at the expense of today, which stops us from living in the moment and having to accept the imperfect nature of things as they are.

By the time we get to tomorrow, our life experiences mean what we thought we wanted has changed.

Slow travel and you are rewarded with serendipitous delights.

We can control our own image of perfection and escape the tyranny of the real world not living up to what we want it to be, but we achieve this not by trying to conquer the world we live in, but by redesigning the focus of our lives internally.

This is achieved by travelling through a landscape, being passionately in love, not falling for the ambition of “tomorrow” and accepting the lifetime pursuit of expressing your own sense of creativity.

When to comes to travel, this falling out of control beyond the comprehension of your own imagination, this is the source of everything.

Man’s real home is not a house, but the Road.

Life itself is a journey to be walked on foot.

Bruce Chatwin

Above: Bruce Chatwin (1940 – 1989)

So, my advice to Heidi, my advice to my Eskişehir friend, my advice to myself, is clear.

Go for a walk.

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / The Rough Guide to Vietnam / Dan Kieran, The Idle Traveller / Rebecca Solnit, Wanderlust / “Recep Tayyip Erdogan: Women not equal to men“, The Guardian, 24 November 2014)

Canada Slim and the Pharmacy of the Soul

Eskişehir, Turkey, Monday 18 April 2022 AD (18 Nisan 5782 AM) (18 Ramadan 1443 AH) (18 Pasar 2022 CE)

Despite this being Easter Monday (Christian calendar), the 18th day of Nisan (Jewish Passover) and the 18th day of Ramadan, religion is not a divisive issue in this city.

Generally, some fast and others feast.

Some pray and others pass the time going about their lives as if this month is merely just one of twelve in the year.

Above: Praying hands, Albrecht Dürer

To know a person’s religion we need not listen to his profession of faith but must find his brand of tolerance.

Eric Hoffer (1902 – 1993)

It is easy to be dismissive of religion, the pomp and pagentry, the ceremony and sanctimony, the folks that violate the tenets of faith in the name of that faith.

It is easy to dismiss the possibility of God whose only true proof of existence is our inability to disprove His existence.

And yet despite the faithless, despite the hypocrisy of some, despite the death, deceit and destruction committed in His Name by those unrecognizable as believers despite the masks they wear, I cannot but acknowledge the true purpose of faith, the real reason for religion, which is encapsulated in one single solitary word:

Hope.

We hope that our lives have meaning.

We hope that the pain and sorrow and suffering may lead to dignity.

We hope that we are not alone in this valley of the shadow of death.

We hope that death has meaning beyond ourselves, in spite of ourselves.

We hope that those who harm and hurt and harass others will be meted that which they dealt.

We hope that the love we shared with others will sustain us, perhaps even beyond this mortal coil.

Of the three Abrahamic religions, Judaism offers an eternal Promised Land, Islam suggests that a good person leaves behind a legacy of continuing charity and an inheritance of knowledge and a testament of righteous offspring worthy of the name, and Christianity suggests that there is a promise of an afterlife and that resurrection beyond longevity is possible.

We hope our lives have meaning.

We hope our deaths can be faced with dignity and daring.

We hope that who we are was not for naught.

And for all its flaws, for all its phonies, for all its unclarity and uncertainty and a myriad of interpretations, religion, faith, in ourselves, in desperate quest of destinies too wonderful for dreams, faith gives us all the only thing that matters:

Hope.

When you’ve fallen on the highway
And you’re lying in the rain,
And they ask you how you’re doing
Of course you’ll say you can’t complain
If you’re squeezed for information,
That’s when you’ve got to play it dumb
You just say you’re out there waiting
For the miracle, for the miracle to come

Waiting for the Miracle“, Leonard Cohen (1934 – 2016)

I never want to be a man who steals hope.

That being said, how can anyone, such as I, sitting on the outside, possibly understand the deeper meaning of the reality of a religion if they have not personally lived it?

The answer, I have been assured by believers I have known, is personal.

Their moment of realization is beyond words.

Faith, by its very nature, is elusive.

Talk to me about the truth of religion and I will listen gladly.

Talk to me about the duty of religion and I will listen submissively.

But don’t come talking to me about the consolations of religion or I shall suspect that you don’t understand.

C. S. Lewis

Above: Clive Staples Lewis (1898 – 1963)

Here in Eskişehir, Turkey is celebrating Ramadan, a month of fasting, prayer, reflection and community.

In a religious life where faith, politics and culture are arguably more inextricably linked in any other religion, there are bound to be differences of opinion and controversial beliefs.

Essential truths can be either vaguely known, interpreted variously or just plain misunderstood.

Above: Halisi Cami (mosque), Eskişehir, Turkey

There is no reason to bring religion into it.

I think we ought to have as great a regard for religion as we can, so as to keep it out of as many things as possible.

Sean O’Casey

Above: Sean O’Casey (1880 – 1964)

The closest I have come to understanding faith in 2022 has been visits to St. Gallen, where today “half-assed Christians” (a term coined by a Catholic priest I once knew) will, for the first of only two annual visits to church – the other occasion being Christmas – will commemorate events two millennia past of a man who claimed to be the Son of God, preached and did all manner of miracles, was crucified as an enemy of the state, was resurrected and ascended to Heaven and will one day return to save the chosen few.

It is a nice story, difficult to prove, difficult to disprove.

It is a question of faith.

What do you choose to believe?

Above: Latin cross, a symbol of Christianity

It is in St. Gallen (among other places) where my faith – such as it is – finds its foundation, a harmony to my heart.

But this post is less a glorification of God as it is a monument to man, for much of the past decade found me working in St. Gallen and it is the people I have known there (and elsewhere) that have given me faith in humanity.

Perhaps the time has come to finally express my gratitude and to sing praises.

Above: Aerial view of St. Gallen, Switzerland

Sometimes I wonder if the manner in which Christianity was introduced to Switzerland is the reason why some Swiss view other faiths as so threatening to the fabric of Swiss life.

St. Gallen’s past may be a prime example of why the Swiss fear other religions following the examples of history.

Above: Flag of Switzerland

Religion to me has always been the wound, not the bandage.”

Dennis Potter

Above: Dennis Potter (1935 – 1994)

The main urban centre of eastern Switzerland, St. Gallen has been described as “a relaxed provincial city set amid rolling countryside between the Appenzell hills and the Lake of Constance (Bodensee), with a beautiful old quarter“.

I agree with this description save for one word:

Relaxed.

Above: Klosterviertel (cloister quarter), Altstadt (old city), St. Gallen, Switzerland

I lived in Switzerland for a decade and much of that period was spent working in St. Gallen either as a teacher or as a barista.

Neither position was relaxing.

Above: Panoramic view of St. Gallen

As the wife and I lived in Landschlacht, a mere 15 km from the German border, we were more likely to spend our free time in Konstanz due to its closer proximity and lower costs.

Above: Landschlacht, Switzerland

St. Gallen has meant, for the most part, work, work and more work.

This is not to say that I did not make any friends during my employment there nor would I say that there weren’t some moments when I, alone or accompanied by the wife, would travel to St. Gallen for leisure activities, such as theatres, restaurants and museums.

It is nonetheless a mistake to label St. Gallen as relaxed, for it is a Swiss city, and relaxing is not something at which the Swiss generally excel.

Above: St. Gallen

The centrepiece of St. Gallen is its extraordinarily lavish Baroque abbey, declared a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Above: Abbey Cathedral, St. Gallen

All the sweetness of religion is conveyed to the world by the hands of storytellers and image makers.

Without their fictions the truths of religion would for the multitude be neither intelligible nor even apprehensible.

Prophets would prophesy and the teachers teach in vain.

George Bernard Shaw

Above: George Bernard Shaw (1856 – 1950)

This has always struck me as an odd notion.

If God exists and is the Creator of all that is, why in Heaven’s name would He need to be celebrated in a lavish enclosure?

Nothing man can construct can ever compare with the majesty of nature.

If God exists then He cannot nor should not be contained with the confines of a cathedral or a Camii. (Turkish: mosque)

I have often said that within the confines of a city it is difficult to believe in God.

In the expanse of nature it is difficult to doubt that God doesn’t exist.

I think that lavish religious structures are never about glorifying God as much as they are for showing off the wealth of the community.

Do we build these magnificent temples for God’s glory?

Or for ours?

Above: Interior of the Abbey Cathedral

The Cathedral is impressive enough and serves as an ever present reminder that the city owes its name to the religious community that remains at its core.

This giant Baroque building is unmissable, its twin towers visible from most points.

Above: Kloster St. Gallen, 1769

Designed by Peter Thumb from Bregenz (Austria), it was completed in 1797 after just 12 years’ work.

Above: Peter Thumb (1681 – 1767)

Access is through the west door, although it is worth making your way around the church and looking at the outside from the enclosed Klosterhof (cloister yard), at the heart of the complex, where you can gaze up at the soaring east facade.

The interior is vast, a broad, brightly lit basilica with a triple-aisled nave and central cupola.

Although not especially high, the Cathedral has a sense of huge depth and breadth.

From the sandstone of the floor and the wood of the pews, fancy light-green stuccowork – characteristic of churches in the Konstanz region – draws your eye up the massive double-width pillars to the array of frescoes on the ceiling, which are almost entirely the work of one artist, Josef Wannenmacher.

The central cupola shows Paradise with the Holy Trinity, apostles and saints.

Above: Rotunda, Abbey Cathedral, St. Gallen

(“And the three men I admire the most

The Father, Son and the Holy Ghost

They took the last train for the coast

The day the music died“)

Don McLean

Details throughout the rest of the Cathedral are splendid:

  • the ornate choir screen
  • the richly-carved walnut-wood confessionals
  • the intricate choir stalls
  • at the back at the choir, the high altar flanked by black marble columns with gold trim

The south altar features a bell brought by Gall(us) on his 7th-century journey from Ireland.

Above: Inside the Abbey Cathedral, St. Gallen

Gall’s origin is a matter of dispute.

It is all a matter of what you choose to believe.

According to his 9th-century biographers in Reichenau, he was from Ireland and entered Europe as a companion of Columbanus (Columba).

Above: St. Peter and St. Paul Church, Reichenau Island, Germany

The Irish origin of the historical Gall was called into question by Gerrold Hilty (2001), who proposed it as more likely that he was from the Vosges or Alsace region.

Max Schär (2010) proposed that Gall may have been of Irish descent but born and raised in the Alsace.

Above: (in red) Location of the Alsace region, France

According to the 9th-century hagiographies, Gall as a young man went to study at Bangor Abbey.

The monastery at Bangor had become renowned throughout Europe as a great centre of Christian learning.

Above: Bangor Abbey, Northern Ireland

Studying in Bangor at the same time as Gall was Columbanus, who with 12 companions, set out about the year 589.

Gall and his companions established themselves with Columbanus at first at Luxeuil in Gaul.

Above: Bobbio Abbey (Italy) stained glass image of Columbanus (543 – 615)

Above: Cloister area, Luxeuil Abbey, France

In 610, Columbanus was exiled by leaders opposed to Christianity and fled with Gall to Alemannia. 

Due to dynastic conflicts between Theuderic II (587 – 613) and his brother Theudebert II (585 – 612), Columbanus lost support in the Frankish Empire and had to leave Luxeuil. 

The further missionary journey led the community around Columban from Metz up the Rhine and via Zürich and Tuggen finally via Arbon to Bregenz. 

Above: Metz, France

Above: Altstadt Zürich, Switzerland

Above: Tuggen, Canton Schwyz, Switzerland

In Bregenz, as in Arbon, they met a Christian community that had partially returned to paganism. 

Gall preached in the Alemannic language, in contrast to Columbanus, who did not speak it. 

Here, and before that in Tuggen, the religious people destroyed the statues of the local deities and threw them into the lake. 

As a result, these messengers of the faith antagonized some of the inhabitants, who complained to their Duke Gunzo. 

Two monks were killed after being ambushed.

(They were chasing a missing cow into the forest.)

The founding of a monastery in Bregenz failed and Columbanus traveled on to Bobbio in Italy in 612 to found a monastery at the invitation of the Lombard prince.

Above: Alemannia (orange) and Upper Burgundy (green), circa 1000 CE

Above: Bobbio, Italy

When Columbanus, Gall and their companions left Ireland for mainland Europe, they took with them learning and the written word.

Their effect on the historical record was significant as the books were painstakingly reproduced on vellum by monks across Europe.

Many of the Irish texts destroyed in Ireland during Viking raids were preserved in abbeys across the Channel.

Gall accompanied Columbanus on his voyage up the Rhine River to Bregenz, but when in 612 Columbanus travelled on to Italy from Bregenz, Gall had to remain behind due to illness and was nursed at Arbon.

Above: Columbanus and Gall on Lake Constance (Bodensee)

Above: Course of the Rhine River

Above: A view of modern Bregenz, Austria

Above: A view of modern Arbon, Switzerland

Gall remained in Alemannia, where, with several companions, he led the life of a hermit in the forests southwest of Lake Constance, near the source of the River Steinach.

Above: Steinach River, Mühlegg Gorge, St. Gallen

Cells were soon added for twelve monks whom Gall carefully instructed.

Gall was soon known in Switzerland as a powerful preacher.

When the See of Constance became vacant, the clergy who assembled to elect a new Bishop were unanimously in favour of Gall.

He, however, refused, pleading that the election of a stranger would be contrary to Church law.

Some time later, in the year 625, on the death of Eustasius, Abbott of Luxeuil, a monastery founded by Columbanus, members of that community were sent by the monks to request Gall to undertake the government of the monastery.

He refused to quit his life of solitude, and undertake any office of rank which might involve him in the cares of the world.

He was then an old man.

He died at the age of 95, circa 650, in Arbon.

His grave became a site of pilgrimage.

The supposed day of his death, 16 October, is still commemorated as Gallus Day.

Above: Gall, Tuggen coat of arms

From as early as the 9th century the fantastically embroidered Life of Saint Gallus was circulated.

Prominent was the story in which Gall delivered Fridiburga from a demon by which she was possessed.

Fridiburga was the betrothed of Sigibert III, King of the Franks, who had granted an estate at Arbon (which belonged to the royal treasury) to Gall so that he might found a monastery there.

Fridiburga was the daughter of the Alemannic Duke Gunzo. 

She was engaged to the Merovingian King Sigibert III (638 – 656), but she fell seriously ill shortly before the wedding. 

According to the Life of St. Gallus, Sigibert sent two bishops with rich gifts to Fridiburga to free her from the demon of illness, but in vain. 

Shortly afterwards, when Gall came to Überlingen, site of the Duke’s court, he healed Fridiburga. 

Above: Überlingen, Germany

She was then taken to Metz, where she was taken from the royal palace to the church of St. Stephen. 

On the advice of the bishops, Sigibert renounced his marriage to Fridiburga and then married Chimnechild in 646. 

Fridiburga lived as a nun in the Metz monastery of St. Peter, where she would became its abbess.

Above: Church of Saint Pierre aux Nonnains, Metz, France

Circa 612, Gall was, according to the lore, travelling south from the Bodensee into the forest.

Legend has it that Gall either fell over, or stumbled into, a briar patch.

After a long stay in Arbon, Gall decided in 612, together with the deacon Hiltibod of Arbon, to follow the Steinach River, which flows into Lake Constance

They moved along the stream into the Arbon forest – the whole area from Lake Constance to Appenzellerland was primeval forest at the time – and came to the waterfall at the Mühleggschlucht (mill slope canyon) gorge. 

Here Gall stumbled and fell into a thorn bush. 

He interpreted this as a divine sign to stay here. 

Above: Beginning of Mühleggschlucht Gorge near St. Georgen, Switzerland

Many depictions of Gall are therefore subtitled with the Latin Vulgate Bible verse:

Haec requies mea in saeculum saeculi.

Hic habitabo quoniam elegi eam.

(This is my resting place forever. 

I want to live here because I like it.)

Psalm 132: 14

Above: 8th century Vulgate Bible

Above: St. Gall and the founding of the monastery

Gall was sitting one evening warming his hands at a fire.

A bear emerged from the woods and charged.

The holy man rebuked the bear, so awed by his presence it stopped its attack and slunk off to the trees.

There it gathered firewood before returning to share the heat of the fire with Gall.

The legend says that for the rest of his days Gall was followed around by his companion the bear.

Images of Gall typically represent him standing with a bear.

Above: St. Gall with a bear

So either clumsiness or a trained bear led Gall to feel that he had received a sign from God – It’s nice that God has someone to communicate with. – and so chose the site to build his hermitage.

I guess nothing says security and sanctity more than accidental briar patches and firewood-fetching bears.

Above: Lyrics from “One of Us“, Joan Osborne

Afterwards, the people venerated Gall as a saint and prayed at his tomb for his intercession in times of danger.

After his death, a small church was erected, which developed into the Abbey of St. Gall, the nucleus of the Canton of St. Gallen.

The city of St. Gallen originated as an adjoining settlement of the Abbey.

Above: Plaque in honour of Gall, St. Gallen

Following Gall’s death, Charles Martel (688 – 741) had Othmar (689 – 759) appointed as custodian of St Gall’s relics.

Above: Charles Martel (688 – 741)

Othmar was of Alemannic descent, received his education in Rhaetia (Chur), was ordained priest, and for a time presided over a church in Rhaetia (Chur).

Above: Chur Cathedral

In 720 Waltram of Thurgau appointed Othmar superior over the cell of St. Gall and custodian of St Gall’s relics.

Othmar united into a monastery the monks that lived about the cell of St. Gall, according to the Rule of St. Columban, and became their first abbot.

Above: Collegiate Church of St. Gall and St. Othmar

He added a hospital and a school, which became the foundation upon which the famous Stiftsbibliothek (Monastery library) was built.

Above: The northwest wing of the monastery district from the outside – the Abbey Library is on the first and second floor

In 747, as a part of the reform movement of Church institutions in Alamannia, he introduced the Benedictine Rule, which was to remain in effect until the secularization and closure of the monastery in 1805.

Above: The oldest copy of the Rule of Saint Benedict, from the 8th century, Bodleian Library, Oxford, England

Othmar also provided for the needs of the surrounding community, building an almshouse as well as the first leprosarium (hospice for lepers) in Switzerland.

Above: Spinalonga, Crete, one of the last leper colonies in Europe, closed in 1957

When Carloman (713 – 754) renounced his throne in 747, he visited Othmar at St. Gall and gave him a letter to his brother Pepin (714 – 768), recommending Othmar and his monastery to the King’s liberality.

Othmar personally brought the letter to Pepin, and was kindly received.

Above: Charles Martel divides the realm between Pepin and Carloman

In 759, Counts Warin and Ruodhart tried to gain possession of some property belonging to St. Gall, Othmar fearlessly resisted their demands.

Hereupon they captured him while he was on a journey to Konstanz, and held him prisoner, first at the castle of Bodmann, then on the island of Werd in the Rhine River.

Above: Werd Island

At the latter place he died, after an imprisonment of six months, and was buried.

Above: Martyrdom of St. Othmar

Othmar’s cult began to spread soon after his death.

He is one of the most popular saints in Switzerland.

In 769 his body was transferred to the Monastery of St. Gall.

As the weather was very hot, when the men rowed his body across Lake Constance (Bodensee), they became extremely thirsty.

Legends say that the only barrel of wine they had left did not become empty, regardless of how much they drank.

Therefore, the wine barrel became one of Othmar’s attributes.

His cult was officially recognized in 864 by Bishop of Konstanz Solomon I (d. 871).

Above: Othmar of St. Gallen

Interesting side note connected with Solomon I:

In 847, his diocese was the first to be disturbed by the preachings of a false prophetess named Thiota.

Above: Cathedral of Konstanz, Germany

Thiota was a heretical Christian prophetess originally from Alemannia.

In 847 she began prophesying that the world would end that year.

Her story is known from the Annales Fuldenses which records that she disturbed the diocese of Solomon before arriving in Mainz.

A large number of men and women were persuaded by her “presumption” as well as even some clerics.

In fear, many gave her gifts and sought prayers.

Finally, the bishops of Gallica Belgica ordered her to attend a synod in St Alban’s Church in Mainz.

She was eventually forced to confess that she had only made up her predictions at the urging of a priest and for lucrative gain.

She was publicly flogged and stripped of her ministry, which the Fuldensian annalist says she had taken up “unreasonably against the customs of the Church.”

Shamed, she ceased to prophesy thereafter.

Above: 11th century Carolina copy Annales Fuldenses, Humanist Library, Schlettstadt, Alsace, France
The report is open for the year 855 with the earthquake in Mainz.

In 867 Othmar was solemnly entombed in the new church of St. Othmar at St. Gall.

He is represented in art as a Benedictine abbot, generally holding a little barrel in his hand, an allusion to the alleged miracle, that a barrel of Othmar never became empty, no matter how much he took from it to give to the poor.

Above: Statue of St. Othmar

Two monks of the Abbey of St Gall, Magnus von Füssen and Theodor, founded the monasteries in Füssen and Kempten in the Allgäu region.

Above: Statue of Magnus of Füssen

Above: St. Lawrence Church, Kempten Abbey, Allgäu, Bavaria, Germany

With the increase in the number of monks the Abbey grew stronger also economically.

Much land in Thurgau, Zürichgau, and in the rest of Alemannia as far as the Neckar River was transferred to the Abbey.

Above: St. Gallen Abbey

Under Abbot Waldo of Reichenau (740 – 814) copying of manuscripts was undertaken and a famous library was gathered.

Numerous Anglo-Saxon and Irish monks came to copy manuscripts here.

Above: Abbot Waldo of Reichenau meets Charlemagne

At Charlemagne’s (747 – 814) request, Pope Adrian I (700 – 795) sent distinguished chanters from Rome, who propagated the use of the Gregorian chant.

Above: 15th century miniature depicting Pope Adrian I greeting Charlemagne

In 744, the Alemannic nobleman Beata sold several properties to the Abbey in order to finance his journey to Rome.

Above: St. Peter’s Cathedral, Vatican City

In the 830s, under Abbot Gozbert (d. 850), Saint Gall became a cultural centre, as many still existing documents from his time affirm.

He paid special attention to the Abbey Library and had close ties to one of the main scribes there, Wolfcoz.

Above: Abbey Library

Wolfcoz I was a medieval scribe and painter of illuminated manuscripts, working in the scriptorium of the Abbey of Saint Gall.

He entered the monastery some time before 813.

Fourteen known documents by Wolfcoz’s hand were created between 816 and 822, including parts of the Wolfcoz Psalter and the Zürich Psalter.

In Wolfcoz’ time, the scriptorium of the Abbey entered a golden age, producing manuscripts of high quality and establishing the Abbey Library of Saint Gall as a centre of Alemannic German culture.

The Abbey Library still has three manuscripts penned by Wolfcoz. 

He developed the Allemanic minuscule and also the decoration of initials.

Above: Scribe in a scriptorium, Miracles de Notre Dame

Gozbert was the recipient (and employer?) of the Plan of Saint Gall, which was made around 820 in Reichenau.

How closely his monastery actually resembled this ideal plan is unknown. 

Above: The Carolingian monastery plan of St. Gallen is the oldest surviving architectural drawing in the West

The monastery was eventually freed from its dependence upon the Bishopric of Konstanz.

Above: Coat of arms of the Diocese of Konstanz

King Louis the Pious confirmed in 833 the immunity of the Abbey and allowed the monks the free choice of their abbot.

Above: King Louis / Ludwig the Pious (778 – 840)

In 854, finally, the Abbey of St Gall reached its full autonomy by King Louis the German (806 – 876) releasing the Abbey from the obligation to pay tithes to the Bishop of Konstanz.

Above: Louis the German (bottom) genuflecting at Christ on the cross

From this time until the 10th century, the Abbey flourished.

It was home to several famous scholars, including Notker of Liège (940 – 1008), Notker the Stammerer (840 – 912), Notker Labeo (950 – 1022), Tuotilo (850 – 915) and Hartker (who developed the antiphonal liturgical books (choir books) for the Abbey).

Above: Notker of Liège

Above: Notker the Stammerer

Above: Notker Labeo

Above: Copy of Tuotilo’s Cod. Sang. 53, Abbey Library, St. Gallen

Above: Printed antiphonary (ca. 1700), open to Vespers of Easter Sunday, Musée de l’Assistance Publique, Hôpitaux de Paris

During the 9th century a new, larger Church was built and the Library was expanded.

Manuscripts on a wide variety of topics were purchased by the Abbey and copies were made.

Over 400 manuscripts from this time have survived and are still in the Library today.

Above: Abbey Library

Emperor Louis the Pious (778 – 840) made the monastery an imperial institution.

Above: St. Gallen Abbey

In 926 the Magyars threatened the Abbey and the books had to be removed to Reichenau for safety.

Above: Hungarian invasions, 9th and 10th centuries CE

Not all the books were returned.

Above: Aerial view of Reichenau Island

Hungarian troops entered Swabia, as allies of the new Italian King, Hugh the Great (880 – 947), besieged Augsburg, and then occupied the Abbey of Saint Gallen, where they spared the life of the monk Heribald, whose accounts give a detailed description about their traditions and way of life. 

Above: Hugh the Great

Above: Town Hall Palace, Augsburg, Germany

The “Golden Age” of St. Gallen ended abruptly on 1 May 926, after travellers reported in the spring that the Hungarians were already advancing on their campaigns as far as Lake Constance. 

Since the dukes could not build up a joint defense in the divided East Frankish kingdom, they had nothing to oppose the plundering and pillaging gangs.

Above: Division of the Frankish Empire, 843

Abbot Engilbert decided to bring the students, the elderly and the sick to safety in the moated castle near Lindau, which belonged to the monastery.

Above: Lindau Island, Germany

Many of the writings were hidden in the friendly monastery of Reichenau.

The monks took themselves and the valuable cult objects to a refuge of safety in the Sitterswald. 

Above: Catholic Church, Sitterswald, Switzerland

At her express request, the hermit Wiborada was the only one left behind in the walled-up church of St. Mangen in the deserted town.

Above: St. Mangen Church, St. Gallen

From the Abbey the Magyars sent minor units to reconnoitre and plunder the surroundings.

When the Hungarians raided the city, they found nothing of value. 

They damaged buildings and altars and burned down the town’s wooden houses. 

The attackers also found Wiborada, but no entrance to their walled-up hermitage. 

Fire couldn’t harm her or the church, so the Hungarians uncovered the roof and killed her. 

The Hungarians did not dare to attack the monks’ refuge because of its inaccessible location. 

They were even attacked by the retreating monks. 

After the Hungarians left, the monks returned with the residents and rebuilt the damaged and burnt down houses. 

One of their units killed Wiborada who lived as an anchoress (female hermit) in a wood nearby.

Above: Church of St. Mangen

Wiborada was born to a wealthy noble family in Swabia.

When they invited the sick and poor into their home, Wiborada proved a capable nurse.

Her brother Hatto became a priest.

A pilgrimage to Rome influenced Hatto to decide to become a monk at the Abbey of Saint Gall, a decision which Wiborada supported.

After the death of their parents, Wiborada joined Hatto and became a Benedictine at the Abbey of Saint Gall.

Above: Portrayal of the young Ulrich with Wiborada

Wiborada became settled at the monastery and Hatto taught her Latin so that she could chant the Liturgy of the Hours.

There, she occupied herself by making Hatto’s clothes and helping to bind many of the books in the monastery library.

At this time, it appears that Wiborada was charged with some type of serious infraction or wrongdoing, and was subjected to the medieval practice of ordeal by fire to prove her innocence.

(Ordeal by fire was one form of torture.

The ordeal of fire typically required that the accused walk a certain distance, usually 9 feet (2.7 metres) or a certain number of paces, usually three, over red-hot ploughshares or holding a red-hot iron.

Innocence was sometimes established by a complete lack of injury, but it was more common for the wound to be bandaged and re-examined three days later by a priest, who would pronounce that God had intervened to heal it, or that it was merely festering — in which case the suspect would be exiled ot put to death.)

Above: After being accused of adultery Cunigunde of Luxembourg (975 – 104) proved her innocence by walking over red-hot ploughshares.

Although she was exonerated, the embarrassment probably influenced her next decision: withdrawing from the world and becoming an ascetic.

When she petitioned to become an anchoress, Solomon III, Bishop of Konstanz (r. 890 – 919), arranged for her to stay in a cell next to the Church of Saint George near the monastery, where she remained for four years before relocating to a cell adjoining the church of Magnus of Füssen in 891.

She became renowned for her austerity, and was said to have a gift of prophecy, both of which drew admirers and hopeful students.

Above: Wiborada with Solomon III, Bishop of Konstanz

One of these, a woman named Rachildis, whom Wiborada had cured of a disease, joined her as an anchoress.

Above: Healing of a sick person with the comb relic of Wiborada

A young student at St. Gall, Ulrich (890 – 973), is said to have visited Wiborada often.

Wiborda supposedly prophesied his elevation to the Episcopate of Augsburg.

(Ulrich was the first saint to be canonized not by a local authority but by the Pope.)

Above: Statue of Ulrich von Augsburg (890 – 973), St. Agatha Chapel, Disentis, Graubünden, Switzerland

In 925, Wiborada predicted a Hungarian invasion of her region.

Her warning allowed the priests and religious of St. Gall and St. Magnus to hide their books and wine and escape into caves in nearby hills. 

The most precious manuscripts were transferred to the monastery at Reichenau Island.

However, the main refuge castle for the monks and the Abbot was the Waldburg in the Sitterwood.

Abbot Engilbert urged Wiborada to escape to safety, but she refused to leave her cell.

On 8 May 926 the Magyar marauders reached St. Gall.

They burned down St. Magnus and broke into the roof of Wiborada’s cell.

Upon finding her kneeling in prayer, they clove her skull with a fokos (shepherd’s axe).

Above: Earliest representation of Wiborada

Her companion Rachildis was not killed, and lived another 21 years, during which her disease returned.

She spent the rest of her life learning patience through suffering.

Wiborada’s refusal to leave her cell and the part she played in saving the lives of the priests and religious of her convent have merited her the title of martyr.

Above: The martyrdom of Wiborada

On 26 April 937, a fire broke out and destroyed much of the Abbey and the adjoining settlement, though the library was undamaged.

About 954 they started to protect the monastery and buildings by a surrounding wall.

Circa 974 Abbot Notker (r. 971 – 975) (about whom almost nothing is known, except that he was the nephew of Notker Physicus (d. 975) – “the physician“) finalized the walling.

The adjoining settlements started to become the town of St Gall. 

Above: Abbey and surroundings, St. Gallen

The Abbey was the northernmost place where a sighting of the 1006 supernova was recorded, likely the brightest observed stellar event in recorded history.

Above: Remnant of Supernova 1006

In 1207, Abbot Ulrich von Sax was made a Prince of the Holy Roman Empire by King Philip of Germany (1177 – 1208).

Above: Coat of arms of the von Sax dynasty

The Abbey thus became a Princely Abbey (Reichsabtei).

As the Abbey became more involved in politics, it entered a period of decline.

Above: Philip of Swabia (1177 – 1208)

The city of St. Gallen proper progressively freed itself from the rule of the Abbot, acquiring imperial immediacy, and by the late 15th century was recognized as a Free Imperial City.

By 1353 the guilds, headed by the cloth weavers guild, gained control of the civic government.

In 1415 the City bought its liberty from German King Sigismund (1368 – 1437).

During the 14th century Humanists were allowed to carry off some of the rare texts from the Abbey Library.

Above: Sigismund of Luxembourg (1368 – 1437)

In the late 14th and early 15th centuries, the farmers of the Abbot’s personal estates (known as Appenzell, from the Latin abbatis cella meaning “cell (i.e. estate) of the Abbot“) began seeking independence.

In 1401, the first of the Appenzell Wars (1401 – 1429) broke out, and following the Appenzell victory at Stoss in 1405 they became allies of the Swiss Confederation in 1411.

Above: Battle of Vögelinsegg

Above: Battle of Stoss Pass (1405) Memorial

During the Appenzell Wars, the town of St. Gallen often sided with Appenzell against the Abbey.

So when Appenzell allied with the Confederation, the town of St. Gallen followed just a few months later.

The Abbey became an ally of several members of the Swiss Confederation (Zürich, Luzern, Schwyz and Glarus) in 1451, while Appenzell and St. Gallen became full members of the Swiss Confederation in 1454.

In 1457 the town of St. Gallen became officially free from the Abbey.

Above: Coat of arms of the City of St. Gallen

In 1468 Abbot Ulrich Rösch bought the County of Toggenburg from the representative of its counts, after the family died out in 1436.

In 1487 Rösch founded a monastery at Rorschach on Lake Constance, to which he planned to move.

Above: Rorschach, Switzerland

However, he encountered stiff resistance from the St. Gallen citizenry, other clerics, and the Appenzell nobility in the Rhine Valley who were concerned about their holdings.

Above: Abbot Ulrich Rösch (1463 – 1491)

The town of St. Gallen wanted to restrict the increase of power of the Abbey and simultaneously increase the power of the town.

The Mayor of St. Gallen, Ulrich Varnbüler, established contact with farmers and Appenzell residents (led by the fanatical Hermann Schwendiner) who were seeking an opportunity to weaken the Abbot.

Initially, Varnbüler protested to the Abbot and the representatives of the four sponsoring Confederate cantons (Zürich, Lucerne, Schwyz, and Glarus) against the construction of the new Abbey in Rorschach.

Then on 28 July 1489 he had armed troops from St. Gallen and Appenzell destroy the buildings already under construction.

Above: Portrait of Ulrich Varnbüler (1432 – 1496), Albrecht Dürer

When the Abbot complained to the Confederates about the damages and demanded full compensation, Varnbüler responded with a counter suit and in cooperation with Schwendiner rejected the arbitration efforts of the non-partisan Confederates.

He motivated the clerics from Wil to Rorschach to discard their loyalty to the Abbey and spoke against the Abbey at a town meeting in Waldkirch, where the popular league was formed.

He was confident that the four sponsoring cantons would not intervene with force, due to the prevailing tensions between the Confederation and the Swabian League.

He was strengthened in his resolve by the fact that the people of St. Gallen elected him again to the highest magistrate in 1490.

Above: The Abbot’s coat of arms

However, in early 1490 the four cantons decided to carry out their duty to the Abbey and to invade the St. Gallen canton with an armed force.

The people of Appenzell and the local clerics submitted to this force without noteworthy resistance, while the city of St. Gallen braced for a fight to the finish.

However, when they learned that their compatriots had given up the fight, they lost confidence.

The end result was that they concluded a peace pact that greatly restricted the city’s powers and burdened the city with serious penalties and reparations payments.

Above: Old houses of St. Gallen

Varnbüler and Schwendiner fled to the court of King Maximilian (1459 – 1519) and lost all their property in St. Gallen and Appenzell.

However, the Abbot’s reliance on the Swiss to support him reduced his position almost to that of a “subject district“.

Above: Maxmilian I, Holy Roman Emperor

The town adopted the Reformation in 1524, while the Abbey remained Catholic, which damaged relations between the town and Abbey.

Both the Abbot and a representative of the town were admitted to the Swiss Tagsatzung (parliament) as the closest associates of the Confederation.

In the 16th century the Abbey was raided by Calvinist groups, who scattered many of the old books. 

Above: Tadsatzung, Baden, 1531

In 1530, Abbot Diethelm began a restoration that stopped the decline and led to an expansion of the schools and library.

Under Abbot Pius Reher (r. 1630 – 1654) a printing press was started.

Above: Pius Reher (1597 – 1654)

In 1712 during the Toggenburg War (also called the Second War of Villmergen), the Abbey of St. Gall was pillaged by the Confederation.

They took most of the books and manuscripts to Zürich and Bern.

For security, the Abbey was forced to request the protection of the townspeople of St. Gallen.

Until 1457 the townspeople had been serfs of the Abbey, but they had grown in power until they were protecting the Abbey.

Above: Toggenburg War map – Protestant (green) / Catholic (yellow) / Neutral (grey)

Following the disturbances, the Abbey was still the largest religious city-state in Switzerland, with over 77,000 inhabitants.

A final attempt to expand the abbey resulted in the demolition of most of the medieval monastery.

The new structures, including the Cathedral by architect Peter Thumb (1681–1766), were designed in the late Baroque style and constructed between 1755 and 1768.

Above: St. Gallen Abbey

The large and ornate new Abbey did not remain a monastery for very long.

In 1798 the Prince-Abbot’s secular power was suppressed and the Abbey was secularized.

The monks were driven out and moved into other abbeys.

The Abbey became a separate See (a bishop’s ecclesiastical jurisdiction) in 1846, with the Abbey church as its Cathedral and a portion of the monastic buildings reserved for the Bishop.

Above: Abbey

The Abbey of St. Gall, the monastery and especially its celebrated scriptorium played an illustrious part in Catholic and intellectual history until it was secularised in 1798.

The former Abbey church became a Cathedral in 1848.

Since 1983 the abbey precinct has been a UNESCO World Heritage Site, as “a perfect example of a great Carolingian monastery”.

Above: Abbey

St. Gall is the name of a wheel shaped hard cheese made from the milk of Friesian cows, which won a Gold Medal at the World Cheese Awards held in Dublin 2008.

Canadian writer Robertson Davies, in his book, The Manticore, interprets the legend in Swiss psychologist Carl Jung (1875 – 1961) terms.

In the final scene of the novel where David Staunton is celebrating Christmas with Lizelloti Fitziputli, Magnus Eisengrim, and Dunstan Ramsay, he is given a gingerbread bear.

Ramsay explains that Gall made a pact of peace with a bear who was terrorizing the citizens of the nearby village.

They would feed the bear gingerbread and the bear would refrain from eating them.

The parable is presented as a Jungian exhortation to make peace with one’s dark side.

This Jungian interpretation is however incompatible with Catholic Orthodoxy which Gall promoted.

It is all a matter of what you choose to believe.

Even today, the Abbey Library is celebrated as Switzerland’s finest secular Rococo interior and one of the oldest libraries in Europe with its huge collection of rare medieval books and manuscripts.

The visitor enters beneath a sign that reads YUCHS IATREION (Greek for “Pharmacy of the Soul).

By the entrance are dozens of oversized felt grey slippers.

Slip your shoe-clad feet into a pair, to protect the inlaid wooden floor.

The 28m X 10m room is dynamic.

Designed by the same Peter Thumb who worked on the Cathedral, the Library’s orthodox Baroque architecture is overlaid with opulent Rococo decoration.

The four ceiling frescoes by Josef Wannenmacher depict with bold trompe l’oeil perspectives the early Christian theological Councils of Nicaea (modern Iznik, Turkey), Constantinople (modern Istanbul), Ephesus (modern Selçuk, Turkey), and Chalcedon (Kadiköy district, Istanbul).

Above: The Council of Nicaea, with Arius depicted as defeated by the council, lying under the feet of Emperor Constantine

Above: Miniature of the Council of Constantinople (AD 381). Emperor Theodosius I and a crowd of bishops seated on a semicircular bench, on either side of an enthroned Gospel Book. An heretic, Macedonius, occupies the lower left corner of the miniature.

Above: Council of Ephesus (431)

Above: Council of Chalcedon (451)

Among the wealth of smaller frescoes set among the ceiling stucco, in the corner directly above the entrance door, you will spot the Venerable Bede, a 7th century English monk from Northumbria who wrote one of the first histories of England.

Above: The Venerable Bede (672 – 735), The Last Chapter, J. Boyle Penrose

Above: Statue of the Venerable Bede, St. Gallen Abbey

The books are ranged on floor-to-ceiling shelves all around.

Its list of cultural treasures among its over 160,000 volumes is extraordinary.

There are more Irish manuscripts in St. Gallen than there are in Dublin, with 15 handwritten examples including a Latin manuscript of the Gospels dating from 750.

Other works include:

  • an astronomical textbook written in 300 BCE
  • copies made in the 5th century of works by Virgil, Horace and other classical authors
  • texts written by the Venerable Bede in his original Northumbrian language
  • the oldest book to have survived in German, dating from the 8th century

Above: Abbey Library

One of the more interesting documents in the Stiftsbibliothek is a copy of Priscian’s (circa 500) Institutiones grammaticae, (the standard textbook for the study of Latin during the Middle Ages), which contains the poem Is acher in gaith in-nocht, written in Old Irish.

Above: Institutiones Grammaticae, 1290, Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana, Firenze (Florence), Italy

The Library also preserves a unique 9th century document, known as the Plan of St. Gall, the only surviving major architectural drawing from the roughly 700-year period between the fall of the Western Roman Empire and the 13th century.

The Plan drawn was never actually built, and was so named because it was kept at the famous medieval monastery library, where it remains to this day.

The Plan was an ideal of what a well-designed and well-supplied monastery should have, as envisioned by one of the synods held at Aachen (814 – 817) for the reform of monasticism in the Frankish Empire during the early years of Emperor Louis the Pious.

Above: Plan of Saint Gall (simplified)

A late 9th century drawing of St. Paul lecturing an agitated crowd of Jews and Gentiles, part of a copy of a Pauline epistles produced at and still held by the Monastery, was included in a medieval drawing show at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City in the summer of 2009.

A reviewer noted that the artist had “a special talent for depicting hair, with the saint’s beard ending in curling droplets of ink“.

Above: Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City

St. Gall is noted for its early use of the neume, the basic element of Western and Eastern systems of musical notation prior to the invention of five-line staff notation.

The earliest extant manuscripts are from the 9th or 10th century.

A few treasures of the Library are displayed in glass cases, with exhibits changed regularly.

Incongruously (as in “What the Hell is this doing here?“), there is an Egyptian mummy dating from 700 BCE, a gift to the mayor of St. Gallen in the early 19th century.

Unsure of what to do with it, he plonked it in this corner of the Library, where it has since remained.

Above: Abbey Library

Diagonally opposite stands a beautifully intricate 2.3m-high globe depicting both celestial and earthly maps.

It is, in fact, a replica.

The original, dating from 1570, was stolen by Zürich troops in 1712 and stands in the National Museum.

To resolve the dispute, Canton Zürich agreed to produce this copy, which was completed in 2009.

Above: Abbey Library

I find myself thinking of the reverence that is given to copies.

A globe is replicated and its replication is mentioned in the smallest print possible with the least fanfare required.

Those who do not question its authenticity need not know it isn’t the original.

This leads to me to ponder:

How far from the origins of our religions have we strayed?

We are told that Christ existed but the proof lies solely in the Gospels which promote His Name.

We are told that Muhammad existed but it is blasphemy to even sketch a likeness of how the Prophet may have looked.

We choose to believe in that which we can neither prove nor disprove.

Much like love, faith is manifested not in what is professed but rather by how it is manifested in the lives of its true believers.

By deeds we decide our dedication.

By actions we activate our ardour.

Above: Prevailing world religions map

All of which leaves me thinking of the Chris Nolan film The Dark Knight….

It’s not about what I want, it’s about what’s FAIR!

You thought we could be decent men in an indecent time.

But you were wrong.

The world is cruel and the only morality in a cruel world is chance.

Unbiased, unprejudiced, fair.

Above: Aaron Eckhart as Harvey Dent/Two Face, The Dark Knight

Because sometimes…

The truth isn’t good enough.

Sometimes people deserve more.

Sometimes people deserve to have their faith rewarded.

Above: Christian Bale as Batman / Bruce Wayne, The Dark Knight

Perhaps this is why we build cathedrals and mosques and temples?

To show how our faith has rewarded us?

Above: Ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, Vatican City

Nothing left to do
When you know that you’ve been taken
Nothing left to do
When you’re begging for a crumb
Nothing left to do
When you’ve got to go on waiting
Waiting for the miracle to come

Waiting for the Miracle“, Leonard Cohen

Above: Leonard Cohen (1934 – 2016)

According to the 2000 census, 31,978 or 44.0% were Roman Catholic, while 19,578 or 27.0% belonged to the Swiss Reformed Church.

Of the rest of the population, there were 112 individuals (or about 0.15% of the population) who belong to the Christian Catholic faith, there were 3,253 individuals (or about 4.48% of the population) who belong to the Orthodox Church, and there were 1,502 individuals (or about 2.07% of the population) who belong to another Christian church.

There were 133 individuals (or about 0.18% of the population) who were Jewish, and 4,856 (or about 6.69% of the population) who were Muslim.

There were 837 individuals (or about 1.15% of the population) who belonged to another church (not listed on the census), 7,221 (or about 9.94% of the population) belonged to no church, were agnostic or atheist, and 3,156 individuals (or about 4.35% of the population) did not answer the question.

There are 28 sites in St. Gallen that are listed as Swiss Heritage Sites of National Significance, including four religious buildings:

  • the Abbey of St. Gallen

Above: St. Gallen Abbey

  • the former Dominican Abbey of St. Katharina

The St. Gallen Monastery of St. Catherine has had a turbulent history since it was founded in 1228.

The founding document dates dates back to 30 June 1228.

It is a late Gothic splendour – beautiful and one of the oldest buildings in the city.

The history of the order goes back to the 13th and 14th centuries.

The monastery was named after the martyr Catherine of Alexandria.

Until 1266 St. Catherine was a monastery of the Augustinians, until in 1368 the resident nuns adopted the Dominican rule.

The great fire of 20 April 1418 greatly affected the monastery.

The last woman entering the monastery, Katharina von Watt, was a sister of the longtime Mayor and patron of the Reformation, Joachim von Watt (Vadian).

In 1527 the monastery became a victim of the Reformation:

Council servants commissioned by the authorities entered into the monastery church and destroyed the cult objects.

In 1555 the last sisters left the St. Gallen Monastery of St. Catherine.

Today only the cloister and the church have survived from the monastery complex.

You can walk through the cloister and there is a library which can be visited.

There is also a old church (of course) but the opening times are said to be very special…

Above: The Monastery of St. Catherine, St. Gallen

  • the Reformed Church of St. Lawrence

The St. Laurenzen Church is the Evangelical Reformed parish church of the city of St. Gallen. 

The construction of the first church is estimated to be in the middle of the 12th century. 

The church was the political, religious and social center of the city republic of St. Gallen for almost 300 years and has had a lasting influence on the history of the city.

Today it is still a meeting room for the town’s local citizens. 

The church takes its name from the martyr Lawrence of Rome to whom it was dedicated. It is classified as a building worthy of national protection (highest of the three protection levels) and as a monument of national importance it is therefore under federal monument protection.

Above: Church of St. Lawrence, St. Gallen

  • the Roman Catholic parish church of St. Maria Neudorf

Above: St. Maria Neudorf, St. Gallen

One of the most important organs in Switzerland is located in the church of St. Maria Neudorf in the east of the city of St. Gallen. 

Their history and construction are not commonplace. 

It is a monumental organ that was built in 1927 by organ builder Willisau according to the principles of the Alsatian organ reform. 

It is the largest organ in the city of St. Gallen and, with its remote control, is one of the largest surviving organs from this period.

Above: Organ, St. Maria Neudorf

Also worth viewing are:

  • Greek Orthodox Church of St. Constantine and St. Helena with its Athonite icons and a stained glass window of the Last Judgment

Above: Greek Orthodox Church of St. Constantine and St. Helena, St. Gallen

Above: St. Constantine and St. Helena

Above: Details of the Last Judgment

  • Protestant Church of Linsebühl, an impressive new Renaissance building dating from 1897

The striking Linsebühl Church, built in 1895-1897 in neo-Renaissance style, is a little off the beaten track of traffic but still central. 

The richly decorated interior was extensively restored in 1992 and offers a festive and, at the same time, a somewhat playful atmosphere with excellent acoustics for music and singing.

The organ by the Goll company from Luzern, built in 1897 and restored in 1992, with pneumatic action, three manuals, a pedal and 38 registers, is one of the few surviving purely romantic organs and is known far beyond the city and canton borders.


In addition to the usually well-attended church services, some concerts take place in the Linsebühl church.

With its large forecourt and neighboring parish hall, it is also very suitable for weddings and other festive occasions.


With its galleries, the Church offers space for 810 people (The nave alone can hold ​​512 people).

Above: Linsebühl Reformed Church, St. Gallen

  • Catholic church of St. Martin in the Bruggen district, this concrete church built in 1936 was at that time glaringly modern

This third Catholic Church of St. Martin Bruggen was completed in 1936 next to its predecessor church. 

The first chapel was consecrated in 1600 and converted into a proper church in 1639. 

The second church was completed on the site of the first in 1785 and received a new tower in 1808. 

After the new building and the consecration of today’s church, the southwestern old church was demolished.

Above: St. Martin Church, Bruggen, St. Gallen

The church is named after Saint Martin of Tours. 

A life-size equestrian statue of him stands in front of the church, together with a beggar.

Above: St. Martin Bruggen Reformed Church, St. Gallen

(While Martin was a soldier in the Roman army and stationed in Gaul (modern-day France), he experienced a vision, which became the most-repeated story about his life.

One winter’s day, at the gates of Amiens, Martin met a poor, unclothed man. 

Martin was carrying nothing but his guns and military coat. 

In a merciful act, he divided his cloak with the sword and gave half to the poor man. 

The following night Christ appeared to Martin in a dream, dressed in half the cloak that he had given the beggar. 

I was naked and you clothed me….

What you did to one of these least of these my brothers, you did to me.” (Matthew 25: 35 – 40) )

Above: Martin and the beggar, El Greco

  • Synagogue St. Gallen, built by architects Chiodera and Tschudy, it is the only synagogue in the Lake Constance region that has been preserved in its original state.

Above: St. Gallen Synagogue

The first document mentioning Jews in St. Gall is dated in 1268.

In 1292 two houses in the town were inhabited by Jews.

On 23 February 1349, during the Black Death, Jewish inhabitants were burned or driven out.

Jews were not allowed to settle in St. Gall again until the 19th century.

The Jews, who then lived in a special quarter, the “Hinterlauben” or “Brotlauben” were accused of having poisoned the wells.

St. Gallen followed the example of other towns near the Lake of Constance, imprisoning the Jews, burning them alive, or at best expelling them and confiscating their property.

For a long time after this event no Jews lived in St. Gall.

In modern times the right of settlement was granted only very exceptionally to a few Jews, who had to pay heavily for the concession.

Even after the wars of independence the St. Gallen “Jews’ Law” of 15 May 1818, though not strictly enforced by the government, placed the Jews under severe restrictions.

These laws remained on the statute books until the emancipation of the Jews of Switzerland in February 1863.

On 8 April 1864, the present Jewish community was constituted, the members having moved to St. Gall from the nearby town of Hohenems (Austria).

On 21 September 1881, the present synagogue was consecrated.

Religious services were organized, Hebrew and religious classes founded.

Soon afterward the cemetery was laid out.

The dead had previously been conveyed to one of the neighboring communities.

Above: Jewish cemetery, St. Gallen

Jews played a prominent role in the St. Gall textile industry until 1912, especially in the famous embroidery branch.

In 1919 refugees from Eastern Europe settled in St. Gallen, forming a separate community.

German and Austrian Jewish refugees began crossing the border into the Canton in 1938, and a refugee care organization was set up there.

Above: Judaica – candlesticks, etrog box, shofar, Torah pointer, Tanach, natla

From 1939 to 1944 the town was the centre for preparing Jewish refugee children for Youth Aliyah to Palestine.

Above: Youth Aliyah commemorative stamp

In 1944, 1,350 Jews (mostly Hungarian) from the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp were brought to St. Gallen.

Above: A British Army bulldozer pushes dead bodies into a mass grave at Belsen, Germany, 19 April 1945

A year later 1,200 Jews from Theresienstadt concentration camp arrived.

Above: Memorial to Jewish Victims, Terezin (formerly Theresienstadt), Czech Republic

Above: Three Jewish children rescued from Theresienstadt recuperate in St. Gallen, 11 February 1945

Police officer Paul Grüninger, later designated as “Righteous among the Gentiles“, helped Jewish refugees after 1938.

Above: Righteous Among the Nations medal

He was ousted from office, lost his pension, and died in misery.

Years after his death, citizens fought successfully for his posthumous rehabilitation.

A square in St. Gallen is named after him.

Above: Paul Grüninger (1891 – 1972)

Above: Grüningerplatz, St. Gallen

Above: Paul Brüninger Bridge between Diepoldsau, Germany and Hohenems, Austria

The Jewish inhabitants of St. Gallen increased numerically over the course of time through frequent migrations from the communities of Endingen and Lengnau, Gailingen (Baden), Laupheim (Württemberg), and from other places.

The Jews of St. Gallen exceed 500 in a total population of over 33,000.

Above: Entry to the Jewish Museum of Switzerland, Basel

The El Hidaje Mosque is an unassuming building that received public attention when a man was shot dead during a Friday prayer on 22 August 2014.

Police arrested an individual with a handgun when they were called after reports of gunfire.

A man was found dead in the mosque’s prayer room, a police spokesman said.

Around 300 people were reportedly in the mosque for Friday prayers at the time of the shooting.

It was not immediately clear what the motive may have been.

Witnesses believe the killing may have been linked to a family dispute dating back a number of years, Swiss newspaper 20 Minutes reported.

The El-Hidaje mosque is used by St Gallen’s Albanian Muslim community.

Fehim Dragusha, a former Imam at the mosque, told Switzerland’s Radio FM1:

Albanians and Muslims should not bring problems from their home country into Switzerland.

Above: El-Hidaje Mosque, St. Gallen

There are at least 50 places of worship across St. Gallen where people can gather to publicly proclaim their devotion to God.

And in none of them do I get a sense of the presence of God (presuming His existence) within.

This is not to say that others are not inspired by their visits to these sanctuaries of faith, but I am not one of them.

I defend a person’s right to believe (or not believe) what they will providing this practice does no harm to others

For myself what religious feeling I may have experienced has always been in the midst of walking.

An activity of late that has gone sadly neglected since my return to Eskişehir last month, though walking is an activity that requires few expenses to do.

We live in a time where the lines of conflict have been drawn between secrecy and openness, between the consolidation and the dispersal of power, between privatization and public ownership, between power and life.

Walking has always been on the side of the latter.

Walking itself has not changed the world – though it does seem that so many religious leaders have found their particular testaments during such activity – but walking has been a rite, a tool, a reinforcement of a civil society that stands up to violence, to fear, and to repression.

Indeed, it is hard to imagine a viable civil society without the free association and the knowledge of the terrain that comes with walking.

A sequestered or passive population is not quite a citizenry.

Insidious forces are marshalled against the time, space and will to walk and against the version of humanity that act embodies.

One force is the filling-up of “the time in-between“, the time between places.

This time has been deplored as a waste, so it is filled with earphones and mobile phone screens.

The ability to appreciate this uncluttered time, the uses of the useless, has evaporated, as does appreciation of being outside – including outside the familiar.

Our mobile phones serve as a buffer against solitude, silence and thought.

We have become immobile and inactive.

We have forgotten that our bodies are built to be used, that our bodies were not meant to be passive, that our bodies are inherent sources of power.

While walking, the body and the mind can work together, so that thinking becomes a physical, rhythmic act.

Spirituality enters in as we move through urban and rural planes of existence.

Past and present combine as we relive events in our personal histories.

Each walk moves through space like a thread through fabric, sewing it together into a continuous experience – unlike the way other modes of travel chop up time and space.

It starts with a step and then another and then another, adding up like taps on a drum to a rhythm, the rhythm of walking.

Walking is an investigation, a ritual, a meditation.

We invest a universal act with particular meanings, from the erotic to the spiritual, from the revolutionary to the artistic.

A desk is no place to think on a large scale.

An absolutely new prospect is a great happiness and I can still get this any afternoon.

Two or three hours’ walking will carry me to as strange a country as I expect ever to see.

A single farmhouse which I had not seen before is sometimes as good as the dominions of the King of Dahomey.

There is in fact a sort of harmony discoverable between the capabilities of the landscape and the threescore and ten years of human life.

It will never become quite familiar to you.

Henry David Thoreau

Above: Henry David Thoreau (1817 – 1862)

It is the unpredictable incidents between official events that add up to a life, the incalculable that gives it value.

Walking is about being outside, in public space, but public space is being abandoned and eroded, eclipsed by technologies and services that don’t require leaving home.

Outside has been shadowed by fear, for strange places are always more frightening than familiar ones, so the less one wanders the more alarming it seems, and so the fewer the wanderers the more lonely and dangerous it really becomes.

Above: Rebecca Solnit’s Wanderlust (Dutch edition)

The newer the place, the less public space.

Malls have replaced Main Street, the streets have no sidewalks, buildings are entered through the garage, City Hall has no plaza, and everywhere everything has walls and bars and gates.

Fear has created the landscape where to be a pedestrian is to be under suspicion.

Too many have forgotten that it is the random, the unscreened, that allows you to find what you didn’t know you were looking for.

And you don’t know a place until it surprises you.

Above: Rebecca Solnit’s Wanderlust (Spanish edition)

But we have come to a place in society where the road ends, where there is no public space and we have paved Paradise to put up a parking lot, a world where leisure is shrinking and being crushed under the anxiety to produce, where bodies are not in the world but indoors in transport and buildings.

We have gained speed and lost purpose.

When you give yourself to places, they give you yourself back.

The more you come to know a place, the more you seed it with an invisible crop of memories and associations that will be waiting for your return, while new places offer up new thoughts and new possibilities.

Walking came from Africa, from evolution, and from necessity.

It went everywhere, usually looking for something.

And this is the essence of walking, the search for something intangible.

Above: (in green) Africa

This is the essence of the pilgrimage, a literal means of spiritual journey, wherein the journey is more significant than the destination itself, for it is the journey that develops us spiritually.

Walking lets us be in that non-believer’s Paradise, that Heaven on Earth, nature.

To consider Earth holy is to connect the lowest and most material to the most high and ethereal, to close the breach between matter and spirit.

The world is holy and the sacred is underfoot rather than above.

The journey of the outside is also a journey within.

And there have been people in St. Gallen that remind me of the holy underfoot and the surprising compassion of those not out to earn their own “salvation” but who only seek to help others to find theirs.

Each time we are reunited, Augustin and I stroll through town.

He does not point out the attractions, but somehow I feel that I am seeing St. Gallen through his eyes and not my own.

His manner of expression lends majesty to the path upon which we walk.

Above: My friend Augustin

I have known Augustin for a decade when we were both employed at the Starbucks Bahnhof St. Gallen.

He is truly a remarkable man.

Augustin – a wonderful mix of French and African…

As welcoming to Switzerland as rain in the desert….

When I broke both my arms in 2018 and needed to be rehabilitated in Mammern – 26 miles / 42 km northwest of St. Gallen – he was my sole visitor (save my wife) who came out to visit me.

Everyone has busy lives and yet he found the time – made the time – to visit someone who should have given him, should still give him, more of his time and attention.

Above: Augustin and your humble blogger, Mammern, Switzerland, 2 June 2018

On 22 January 2022, after very little contact or communication between us, he invited me to his new apartment he shares with his lady love Laura and he cooked us a delicious dinner and continuously gave and gave to me whatever I might desire.

I left his apartment feeling humbled and honoured by the hospitality and love shown to me.

May I always be worthy.

Above: Laura and Augustin

Augustin is one of the hardest workers I have ever had the honour of working with.

He truly gives the adage “It is not the job that brings dignity to the man. It is the man who brings dignity to the job.” meaning.

He is one of those rare individuals who may not have always been blessed with the wealth that others take for granted, but he remains generous to a fault.

He came to Switzerland in dire straits.

He spoke truth to power and his homeland’s government desired to imprison him for his sacrilege.

He remains an exile from his home, from his loved ones there, until the politics therein, perhaps, one day, changes.

He has since become a Swiss citizen and, as such, acts responsibly, deserving of that privilege.

He has built a life for himself, has found a lady love and has achieved a happiness he so richly deserves, for he has gotten from the universe what he has given to it and fortune has rewarded him accordingly.

His is one of those friendships, like so many friendships this rolling stone has been miraculously been blessed with, that needs no reciprocation and yet rewards those who treat him with dignity and respect.

Above: Coat of arms of Switzerland

Augustin is my mirror.

I cannot even begin to guess the mind of another person, but perhaps the dignity and respect I have shown him compels him to show me the same.

Despite this, I get the feeling that he does not give in order to get.

He is not good (at least, to me) out of any expectation.

Nor do I get a sense of his feeling entitled to reciprocation.

(Unlike some I have known…..)

Augustin, the Augustin I know, is a man fit to be any other man’s role model of what a good person is, of what a good person can be.

I am blessed by his friendship.

Above: Augustin

Perhaps I should not be so surprised and touched when people are nice to me.

And yet I am, almost every time, when an act of human kindness touches my life.

I am even surprised when my own wife is kind to me, for we have had our differences over the years.

(My sojourn in Turkey has not helped the relationship.)

Like most men, I am probably undeserving of a good woman’s (or perhaps even a bad woman’s) love.

Above: The Wedding, Edmund Blair Leighton

I think of my last visit to Switzerland and the friends I encountered when I was there:

  • Volkan, assistant Starbucks store manager and talented singer, is a man of surprising depth at times.
  • Nesha, of Belgrade and Herisau, has always been a friend with whom I can share moments of laughter.
  • Naomi, Canadian from Vancouver and Starbucks barista, a woman torn between ambition and affection, is a woman who leads with her heart despite the misgivings of her head.
  • Alanna, Canadian from Nova Scotia, Starbucks shift manager and independent store operator, is one of the strongest women I know, whose will is as powerful as her beauty.
  • Katja is a woman whose wanderlust and passion for life matches my own.
  • Sinan is a young man whose maturity belies the youthfulness of his features, a good father, a good husband, a good friend.
  • Michael is a young man who reminds me of myself in my younger days, so confident in what he knows, still unaware that the passage of time will confirm that there will always be more we don’t understand, that the knowledge we do have is merely a beginning, that it is never the completion of all we need to know, he is a young man who in discovering the world discovers himself.
  • Sonja, former Starbucks store manager, now an independent vendor in the Luzern region, is always compassionate to me whenever we see one another.
  • Ricardo, former Starbucks store manager, is another friend who is easy to misjudge, but, at least with me, he has proven ready to assist me should I ask him.
  • Pedro, Starbucks store manager, started at Starbucks shortly after I did, but unlike me was determined to rise within its ranks, is a person I am proud to know, for despite his success he has always respected that I walk a different path than he does.
  • Ute, my wife, my life, is as part of my being as breathing, a woman who deserves far better than myself, but Karma is a tricky thing!

These are the few I was fortunate enough to see during my last visit.

There remain others that time and circumstance prevented our reunion.

I have been blessed by these and other friends (and family) in other places (Canada, Britain, Australia, New Zealand, America, Germany, Austria, Paraguay, Turkey).

Do others see these friends different than I see them?

Most assuredly.

Some of my friends may not even like other friends of mine.

What may be said of their lives outside of my experience of them I can neither confirm nor deny.

I only judge them by their actions towards me.

And it is by their actions that I know them.

It is their actions towards me that restores my faith in humanity and in life itself.

They are my religion, my sustenance, the very breath I take, the reason I live, the courage to love.

Friends offer enormous comfort.

They help to structure your time.

They show you that you belong and can be cared about.

A man who lacks a network of friends is seriously impaired from living his life, from having a life worth living.

A man’s friends alleviate the neurotic overdependence on a wife or a girlfriend for every emotional need.

If a man, going through a “rough patch”, gets help from his friends as well as his partner, then his burden is shared.

If his problems are with his partner (as they often are) then his friends can help him through, talk sense into him, stop him acting stupidly and help him to release his grief.

I do not believe that men are as inarticulate as women claim.

We are simply inexperienced.

Our inarticulateness (a trait not shared by all men) simply comes from a history with a lack of sharing opportunities.

Millions of women complain about their male partner’s lack of feeling, their woodenness.

Men themselves (and I include myself in this) often feel numb and confused about what they really want.

But if men talked to each other more, perhaps they would understand themselves better.

Then perhaps we would then have more to say to our wives or girlfriends.

Sometimes only a man can understand what another man is feeling.

The same can be said for the empathy between women.

Men’s voices have a different tone than women’s.

Our feelings have a different tone as well.

We have more than enough feelings, but we lack the experience or opportunity to express them.

What does not help is that men are put into a double bind by society at large.

We are asked to simultaneously be more intimate and sensitive and yet be tough when needed.

As if feelings within a man need be as flexible as shifting gears in a car.

A considerable skill not innately part of ourselves.

We are reserved in expression, for expression requires trust in those who may listen.

Can we express hurt?

Can we express frustration?

Without fear of censure?

Without others minimizing these feelings?

Without advice given?

Without competition?

Men feel, but fear of showing weakness prevents expression.

Men can be noisy and wild and still be safe.

What annoys me about society is the demand that men must prove that they are men.

Men have nothing to prove.

Let men judge themselves by their own standards.

A man should not be judged for the manner in which he conveniently accommodates women.

Women have their own struggles.

Men have theirs.

Equality between the genders is only possible if there is negotiation and fairness, non-threatening behaviour (from both genders), mutual respect, mutual trust and support, honesty and accountability (from both genders), shared responsibility and economic partnership.

They are “my North, my South, my East and West,
My working week and my Sunday rest,
My noon, my midnight, my talk, my song.

W.H. Auden

Above: Wystan Hugh Auden (1907 – 1973)

Time and distance often separates us, but while I think of them they remain ever close to my heart and are embedded in my soul.

If there is a God – and sometimes I think there just might be – then He manifests Himself in the manner in which He blesses our lives with our fellow human beings.

Everyone I meet has proven to be either a blessing or a lesson in my life.

I am humbled.

I am grateful.

Another friend once described me in the following way:

You are a walking/living contradiction.

Shy and timid on one extreme, courageous and adventurous on the other, extremely intelligent and yet naive at the same time…”

(I have been called worse!)

Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)

Walt Whitman

Above: Walt Whitman (1819 – 1892)

I find myself remembering an old Facebook post I wrote during the days I travelled by train between Landschlacht and St. Gallen:

Above: Swiss Federal Railways network map

Normally I am unaffected by graffiti and undecided as to whether it should be viewed as an art form or as an act of vandalism.

But there is a graffiti scrawling on the wall of a factory (apple processing plant?) facing the railroad station of Neukirch-Egnach (between Romanshorn and St. Gallen) that always makes me smile for its powerful simplicity.

You are artwork.

Each and every one of us is a miracle, an artistic masterpiece.

Such a wise graffiti scrawl...

Heed the writing on the wall.

Above: Neukirch-Egnach Station, Switzerland

What a piece of work is man,

How noble in reason, how infinite in faculty,

In form and moving how express and admirable,

In action how like an angel,

In apprehension how like a god,

The beauty of the world,

The paragon of animals. 

Hamlet, Act 2, Scene ii, William Shakespeare

Above: Presumed portrait of William Shakespeare (1564 – 1616)

It is Easter Sunday, it is Passover, it is Ramadan.

I am merely a man.

Thank God.

Above: Michelangelo di Lodovico Buonarroti Simoni’s The Creation of Adam, Sistine Chapel, Vatican City

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Facebook / Rough Guide to Switzerland / Steve Biddulph, Manhood / Rebecca Solnit, Wanderlust: A History of Walking / Reuters, “One dead in shooting at mosque in Switzerland“, 23 August 2014

You CAN get what you want

Eskişehir, Turkey, Tuesday 11 April 2022

Last Saturday was a good day.

I completed a long blogpost, finally got the washing machine to function, had lunch with colleagues, worked the afternoon, then the day got interesting.

Ramadan 9, and my friend S. has been diligent in fasting.

She invited me to her home for iftar (the nightly feast that breaks the fast) and we spoke of many things: relationships, work, literature.

Above: Different types of food items on a typical Ifter plate

A woman who looks like a girl and thinks like a man is the best sort, the most enjoyable to be and the most pleasurable to have and to hold.

Julie Burchill

Above: Julie Birchill

She is a friend and it is glorious, for my being both married and old enough to be her father, there is no chemistry to worry about.

She cannot see me as more than a father figure and I see her like a little sister, so the conversation is uncomplicated and free from tension.

An aged man is but a paltry thing,

A tattered coat upon a stick, unless

Soul clap its hands and sing, and louder sing

For every tatter in its mortal dress

William Butler Yeats

Above: William Butler Yeats (1865 – 1939)

After dinner, she has plans, so I take my leave and make my way back home.

I pass the ES Park shopping mall and the Starbucks in front of it.

From behind me, a student calls my name and grabs my arm.

It is I., a woman less than half my age.

Time misspent in youth is sometimes all the freedom one ever has.”

Anita Brookner

Above: Anita Brookner (1928 – 2016)

She invites me to join her table where she sits with a male colleague.

She buys me a coffee.

We talk.

Another woman, another friend, again no chemistry to worry about.

The wisdom of age has rendered me meditative, contemplative.

Above: Auguste Rodin’s The Thinker, Paris, France

Age wins and one must learn to grow old.

I must learn to walk this long unlovely wintry way, looking for spectacles, shunning the cruel looking-glass, laughing at my clumsiness before others mistakenly condole, not expecting gallantry yet disappointed to receive none, apprehending every ache or shaft of pain, alive to blinding flashes of mortality, unarmed, totally vulnerable.”

Diana Cooper

Above: Diana Cooper (aka Lady Diana Manners) (1892 – 1986)

It is liberating to enjoy a woman’s company without the itch to be intimate, without the hunger to be in a relationship, without the fear of being alone compelling a pursuit of someone who then decides that you might or might be worthy of her time and attention, without the games that people play in pursuit of potential pleasure.

God created man, and finding him not sufficiently alone, gave him a companion to make him feel his solitude more keenly.

Paul Valéry

Above: Paul Valéry (1871 – 1945)

Just two people, being real, just talking, with no end goal except the enjoyment of the conversation.

It is relaxing not to have an agenda.

We men have got love well weighed up.

Our stuff can get by without it.

Women don’t seem to think that’s good enough.

They will write about it.

Kingsley Amis

Above: Kingsley Amis (1922 – 1995)

Just hanging out enjoying the warmer weather of the night.

S. tells me that her BF is playing drums at a club near my apartment.

After numerous previous invitations to see him perform I finally go to the club.

The band rocks, the music familiar and embracing.

A verbal art like poetry is reflective.

It stops to think.

Music is immediate.

It goes on to become.

W.H. Auden

Above: Wystan Hugh Auden (1907 – 1973)

I sit at a table secure in my solo situation nursing a cola.

Best to keep my senses about me in unknown territory.

I am warmly welcomed by G. and his friends.

G. surprises me from the moment he spots me in the crowd.

He asks the lead singer if they can play his request for me:

Ain’t no sunshine when she’s gone
It’s not warm when she’s away
Ain’t no sunshine when she’s gone
And she’s always gone too long
Anytime she goes away

Wonder this time where she’s gone
Wonder if she’s gone to stay
Ain’t no sunshine when she’s gone
And this house just ain’t no home
Anytime she goes away

And I know, I know, I know, I know
I know, I know, I know, I know, I know
I know, I know, I know, I know, I know
I know, I know, I know, I know, I know
I know, I know, I know, I know, I know
I know, I know
Hey, I ought to leave young thing alone
But ain’t no sunshine when she’s gone

Ain’t no sunshine when she’s gone
Only darkness every day
Ain’t no sunshine when she’s gone
And this house just ain’t no home
Anytime she goes away
Anytime she goes away
Anytime she goes away
Anytime she goes away

Bill Withers

It is a great feeling – music I love, a friendly atmosphere, no drama.

I am getting what I want, because there is nothing that I want that isn’t here already.

No expectations lead to no disappointments.

I simply let the night take me where it will.

There is something not quite right about night life, something shadowy in every sense.

However efficiently artificial light annihilates the difference between night and day, it never wholly eliminates the primitive suspicion that night people are up to no good.

A. Alvarez

Above: Al Alvarez (1929 – 2019)

I am a sensible man with a job requiring rest.

Been working like a dog gone crazy
I’ve been giving everything I’ve got
I need something short and sweet to save me
A little something that can hit the spot

I’ve been living like a man in a prison
I’ve been living like some monk in a cave
I need a woman with a good position
I start searching at the end of the day

Pack it in and go to town when the sun goes down
And do the tomcat prowl when the sun goes down

I’ve been punching out a clock since fifteen
I’ve been living on a working wage
You keep paying me and I’ll keep lifting
I keep a-lifting till the end of the day

Then pack it in and go to town
When the sun goes down
Do the moon dog howl when the sun goes down
And do the tomcat prowl when the sun goes down

Gotta find a way to ease that pressure
Gotta find a way to ease that pain
Gotta find myself some buried treasure
Gotta find it ‘fore the sun comes up again

It doesn’t matter if you’re sane or crazy
It doesn’t matter if you’re weak or strong
It doesn’t matter if your past is hazy
It doesn’t matter you can all come along

Pack it in and go to town when the sun goes down
And do the tomcat prowl when the sun goes down
Sun goes down
Pack it in and go to town when the sun goes down
And do the tomcat prowl when the sun goes down

Do the moon dog howl when the sun goes down

Doug and the Slugs

Many beautiful women in the club.

I acknowledge each and everyone of them.

And I walk home, alone and free.

I cannot walk through the suburbs in the solitude of the night without thinking that the night pleases us because it suppresses idle details, just as our memory does.

Jorge Luis Borges

Above: Jorge Luis Borges (1899 – 1986)

In bed just as Sunday morning begins, a smile on my face.

Know it sounds funny
But I just can’t stand the pain
Girl, I’m leaving you tomorrow
Seems to me girl
You know I’ve done all I can
You see I begged, stole
And I borrowed

Ooh, that’s why I’m easy
I’m easy like Sunday morning
That’s why I’m easy
I’m easy like Sunday morning

Why in the world
Would anybody put chains on me?
I’ve paid my dues to make it
Everybody wants me to be
What they want me to be
I’m not happy when I try to fake it!
No!

Ooh, that’s why I’m easy
I’m easy like Sunday morning
That’s why I’m easy
I’m easy like Sunday morning

I wanna be high, so high
I wanna be free to know
The things I do are right
I wanna be free
Just me, babe!

That’s why I’m easy
I’m easy like Sunday morning
That’s why I’m easy
I’m easy like Sunday morning
Because I’m easy
Easy like Sunday morning
Because I’m easy
Easy like Sunday morning

As slumber seizes my sensibilities I find myself feeling amazed that a talented intelligent man like G. confessed to me that he feels insecure about his talents and intelligence.

This confession and the enjoyment that the band brought me makes me think of the music and musicians I have loved.

All a musician can do is get closer to the sources of nature and so feel that he is in communion with the natural laws.

Then he can feel he is interpreting them to the best of his ability.

John Coltrane

Above: John Coltrane (1926 – 1967)

Music is the art of arranging sounds in time through the elements of melody, harmony, rhythm and timbre.

It is one of the universal cultural aspects of all human societies.

General definitions of music include common elements such as pitch (which governs melody and harmony), rhythm (and its associated concepts of tempo, meter and articulation), dynamics (loudness and softness), and the sonic qualities of timbre and texture (which are sometimes termed the “colour” of a musical sound).

Above: Allegory of music

I think the main thing a musician would like to do is give a picture to the listener of the many wonderful things he knows of and senses in the universe.

That’s what music is to me – it’s just another way of saying this is a big beautiful universe we live in, that’s been given to us, and here’s an example of just how magnificent and encompassing it is.”

John Coltrane

Different styles or types of music may emphasize, de-emphasize or omit some of these elements.

Music is performed with a vast range of instruments and vocal techniques ranging from singing to rapping.

There are solely instrumental pieces, solely vocal pieces (songs without instrumental accompaniment) and pieces that combine singing and instruments. 

If the music doesn’t say it, how can words say it for the music?”

John Coltrane

In its most general form, the activities describing music as an art form or cultural activity include the creation of works of music (songs, tunes, symphonies, and so on), the criticism of music, the study of the history of music, and the aesthetic examination of music. 

Ancient Greek and Indian philosophers defined music in two parts:

  • melodies (tones ordered horizontally)
  • harmonies (tones ordered vertically).

Above: Acropolis, Athens, Greece

Above: Taj Mahal, Agra, India

No one in the band is a musician.

We all hate the term.

We’re something close to factory workers.

Machinists.

Skilled operators.

John Lydon

Common sayings such as “the harmony of the spheres” and “it is music to my ears” point to the notion that music is often ordered and pleasant to listen to.

Above: Harmony of the World, Astrology, Ebenezer Sibley

However, 20th-century composer John Cage thought that any sound can be music, saying:

There is no noise, only sound.”

Above: John Cage (1912 – 1992)

I am not a musician.

I don’t go in too deep.

If you have the music in your head and you sing it with your body, then you’ll be all right.

Luciano Pavarotti

Above: Luciano Pavarotti (1935 – 2007)

The creation, performance, significance, and even the definition of music vary according to culture and social context.

Indeed, throughout history, some new forms or styles of music have been criticized as “not being music“, including Beethoven’s Grosse Fuge string quartet in 1825, early jazz in the beginning of the 1900s and hardcore punk in the 1980s.

Above: Ludwig van Beethoven (1770 – 1827)







Missed the Saturday dance
Heard they crowded the floor
Couldn’t bear it without you
Don’t get around much anymore

I thought I’d visit the club
Got as far as the door
They’d have asked me about you
Don’t get around much anymore

Darling, I guess that my mind’s more at ease
Oh, nevertheless, why stir up memories?

I’ve been invited on dates
Might have gone, but what for?
It’s awfully different without you
Don’t get around much anymore

Darling, I guess, my mind’s more at ease
But nevertheless, why stir up memories?

Been invited on dates
I might’ve gone, but what for?
It’s awfully different without you
Don’t get around much anymore

Oh baby, don’t get around much anymore

Duke Ellington

Above: Duke Ellington (1899 – 1974)

There are many types of music, including popular music, traditional music, art music, music written for religious ceremonies, and work songs such as chanteys.

Music ranges from strictly organized compositions — such as Classical music symphonies from the 1700s and 1800s — through to spontaneously played improvisational music such as jazz and avant garde styles of chance-based contemporary music from the 20th and 21st centuries.

Music can be divided into genres (e.g., country music) and genres can be further divided into subgenres (e.g., alternative country and country pop are two of the many country subgenres), although the dividing lines and relationships between music genres are often subtle, sometimes open to personal interpretation, and occasionally controversial.

Above: Hank Williams (1923 – 1953)

I’ve known a few guys who thought they were pretty smart
But you’ve got being right down to an art
You think you’re a genius
You drive me up the wall
You’re a regular original know-it-all

Oh-oo-oh, you think you’re special
Oh-oo-oh, you think you’re something else
Okay, so you’re a rocket scientist

That don’t impress me much
So you got the brains, but have you got the touch?
Now don’t get me wrong, I think you’re alright
But that won’t keep me warm in the middle of the night
That don’t impress me much
Ah-huh, yeah yeah

I never knew a guy who carried a mirror in his pocket
And a comb up his sleeve – just in case
And all that extra hold gel in your hair oughtta lock it
‘Cause Heaven forbid it should fall out of place

Oh-oo-oh, you think you’re special
Oh-oo-oh, you think you’re something else
Okay, so you’re Brad Pitt

Above: Brad Pitt

That don’t impress me much
So you got the looks, but have you got the touch?
Now don’t get me wrong, yeah, I think you’re alright
But that won’t keep me warm in the middle of the night
That don’t impress me much
Yeah!

You’re one of those guys that likes to shine his machine
You’ll make me take off my shoes before you let me get in
I can’t believe you kiss your car good night
Now c’mon, baby, tell me – you must be joking right!

Oh-oo-oh, you think you’re special
Oh-oo-oh, you think you’re something else
Okay, so you’ve got a car

That don’t impress me much
So you got the moves, but have you got the touch?
Now don’t get me wrong, yeah, I think you’re alright
But that won’t keep me warm in the middle of the night

That don’t impress me much
Oh, now you think you’re cool, but have you got the touch?
Now don’t get me wrong, yeah, I think you’re alright
But that won’t keep me warm on the long, cold, lonely night
That don’t impress me much
Uh-huh, yeah yeah

Okay, so what do you think, you’re Elvis or something?

Above: Elvis Presley (1935 – 1977)


That don’t impress me much
Oh no
That don’t impress me much
Oh no
Yeah, woo!
Oh no, alright, alright
You’re Tarzan


Captain Kirk maybe?

Above: William Shatner as Captain James T. Kirk of the Starship Enterprise, Star Trek (The Original Series)


John Wayne?

Above: Marion Robert Morrison (aka John Wayne) (1907 – 1979)


Whatever, nuh-uh
That don’t impress me much

Shania Twain

For example, it can be hard to draw the line between some early 1980s hard rock and heavy metal.

New York, New York, is everything they say
And no place that I’d rather be
Where else can you do a half a million things
All at a quarter to three

When they play their music, ooh that modern music
They like it with a lot of style
But it’s still that same old back beat rhythm
That really really drives ’em wild

Above: Manhattan, New York City

They say the heart of rock and roll is still beating
And from what I’ve seen I believe ’em
Now the old boy may be barely breathing
But the heart of rock and roll, heart of rock and roll is still beating

LA, Hollywood and the Sunset Strip
Is something everyone should see
Neon lights and the pretty pretty girls
All dressed so scantily

When they play their music, that hard rock music
They like it with a lot of flash
But it’s still that same old back beat rhythm
That really kicks ’em in the….

Above: Los Angeles, California

They say the heart of rock and roll is still beating
And from what I’ve seen I believe ’em
Now the old boy may be barely breathing
But the heart of rock and roll, heart of rock and roll is still beating

DC, San Antone and the Liberty Town, Boston and Baton Rouge
Tulsa, Austin, Oklahoma City, Seattle, San Francisco, too
Everywhere there’s music, real live music, bands with a million styles
But it’s still that some old rock and roll music
That really really drives ’em wild

Above: National Mall and the Lincoln Memorial, Washington DC

Above: San Antonio, Texas

Above: The liberty town, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Above: Boston, Massachusetts

Above: Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Above: Tulsa, Oklahoma

Above: Austin, Texas

Above: Images of Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Above: Seattle, Washington

Above: San Francisco, California

They say the heart of rock and roll is still beating
And from what I’ve seen I believe ’em
Now the old boy may be barely breathing
But the heart of rock and roll, heart of rock and roll is still beating

In Cleveland
Detroit!!
Huh, heart of rock and roll

Above: Images of Cleveland, Ohio

Above: Detroit, Michigan

Huey Lewis and the News

Within the arts, music may be classified as a performing art, a fine art, or as an auditory art.

Music may be played or sung and heard live at a rock concert or orchestra performance, heard live as part of a dramatic work (a music theatre show or opera), or it may be recorded and listened to on a radio, MP3 player, CD player, smartphone or as film score or TV show.

Above: Metallica

In many cultures, music is an important part of people’s way of life, as it plays a key role in religious rituals, rite of passage ceremonies (e.g., graduation and marriage), social activities (e.g., dancing) and cultural activities ranging from amateur karaoke singing to playing in an amateur funk band or singing in a community choir.

Above: James Brown (1933 – 2006)

I’m nothing special, in fact I’m a bit of a bore
If I tell a joke, you’ve probably heard it before
But I have a talent, a wonderful thing
‘Cause everyone listens when I start to sing
I’m so grateful and proud
All I want is to sing it out loud

So I say
Thank you for the music, the songs I’m singing
Thanks for all the joy they’re bringing
Who can live without it? I ask in all honesty
What would life be?
Without a song or a dance, what are we?
So I say thank you for the music
For giving it to me

Mother says I was a dancer before I could walk
She says I began to sing long before I could talk
And I’ve often wondered, how did it all start?
Who found out that nothing can capture a heart
Like a melody can?
Well, whoever it was, I’m a fan

So I say
Thank you for the music, the songs I’m singing
Thanks for all the joy they’re bringing
Who can live without it? I ask in all honesty
What would life be?
Without a song or a dance what are we?
So I say thank you for the music
For giving it to me

I’ve been so lucky, I am the girl with golden hair
I wanna sing it out to everybody
What a joy, what a life, what a chance

Thank you for the music, the songs I’m singing
Thanks for all the joy they’re bringing
Who can live without it, I ask in all honesty
What would life be?
Without a song or a dance what are we?
So I say thank you for the music
For giving it to me

So I say
Thank you for the music, for giving it to me

ABBA

People may make music as a hobby, like a teen playing cello in a youth orchestra, or work as a professional musician or singer.

The music industry includes the individuals who create new songs and musical pieces (such as songwriters and composers), individuals who perform music (which include orchestra, jazz band and rock band musicians, singers and conductors), individuals who record music (music producers and sound engineers), individuals who organize concert tours, and individuals who sell recordings, sheet music, and scores to customers.

Even once a song or piece has been performed, music critics, music journalists and music scholars may assess and evaluate the piece and its performance.

I’ve been alive forever
And I wrote the very first song
I put the words and the melodies together
I am music
And I write the songs

I write the songs that make the whole world sing
I write the songs of love and special things
I write the songs that make the young girls cry
I write the songs, I write the songs

My home lies deep within you
And I’ve got my own place in your soul
Now when I look out through your eyes
I’m young again, even tho’ I’m very old

I write the songs that make the whole world sing
I write the songs of love and special things
I write the songs that make the young girls cry
I write the songs, I write the songs

Oh, my music makes you dance and gives you spirit to take a chance
And I wrote some rock ‘n roll so you can move
Music fills your heart, well that’s a real fine place to start
It’s from me, it’s for you
It’s from you, it’s for me
It’s a worldwide symphony

I write the songs that make the whole world sing
I write the songs of love and special things
I write the songs that make the young girls cry
I write the songs, I write the songs

I write the songs that make the whole world sing
I write the songs of love and special things
I write the songs that make the young girls cry
I write the songs, I write the songs

I am music and I write the songs

Barry Manilow

I have been blessed by great music that evening and throughout my life.

I have visited many a music store – I am of an age that finds no enjoyment in downloading music from the Net. – and there I find a paradise.

The ears are caressed by sound, the eyes are dazzled by selection, the mind amused, the mood mellow.

Above: Scene from High Fidelity – John Cusack and Jack Black

In Turkey, surprisingly against prejudices, it is more difficult to find music stores here than in countries more “civilized“.

What, I am asked, you want to buy a CD player?!

A cassette player?!

Have you not heard of downloading?

Yes, and I still prefer the music store.

I met a girl who sang the blues and I asked her for some happy news
But she just smiled and turned away
I went down to the sacred store where I’d heard the music years before
But the man there said the music wouldn’t play

And in the streets, the children screamed
The lovers cried, and the poets dreamed
But not a word was spoken
The church bells all were broken

And the three men I admire most
The Father, Son and the Holy Ghost
They caught the last train for the coast
The day the music died

American Pie“, Don McLean

Drove downtown in the rain, 9:30 on a Tuesday night,
Just to check out the late-night record shop.
Call it impulsive, call it compulsive, call it insane,
But when I’m surrounded I just can’t stop.

Brian Wilson“, Barenaked Ladies

It has been open since 2020 and I would love to visit it, even though the group the store features is not one of my desert island favourite groups.

I saw her today at the reception
A glass of wine in her hand
I knew she would meet her connection
At her feet was her footloose man

No, you can’t always get what you want
You can’t always get what you want
You can’t always get what you want
But if you try sometime you’ll find
You get what you need

And I went down to the demonstration
To get my fair share of abuse
Singing, “We’re gonna vent our frustration
If we don’t we’re gonna blow a fifty-amp fuse”
Sing it to me, honey

You can’t always get what you want
You can’t always get what you want
You can’t always get what you want
But if you try sometimes, well, you just might find
You get what you need

I went down to the Chelsea drugstore
To get your prescription filled
I was standing in line with Mr. Jimmy
And, man, did he look pretty ill
We decided that we would have a soda
My favorite flavor, cherry red
I sung my song to Mr. Jimmy
Yeah, and he said one word to me, and that was “dead”
I said to him

You can’t always get what you want, well no
You can’t always get what you want. I tell you, baby
You can’t always get what you want, no
But if you try sometimes you just might find, uh, mm
You get what you need, oh yeah, woo!

I saw her today at the reception
In her glass was a bleeding man
She was practiced at the art of deception
Well, I could tell by her blood-stained hands, sing it

You can’t always get what you want, yeah
You can’t always get what you want, ooh yeah, child
You can’t always get what you want
But if you try sometimes you just might find
You just might find
You get what you need, ah yeah
Ah baby, woo!

You Can’t Always Get What You Want“, Honky Tonk Women, The Rolling Stones

It is a place where the committed fan can consider spending £535 on a Rolling Stones-themed crystal decanter, £110 on a “Stones red” bomber jacket, or £15 on a face mask made from cotton or, for £10 more, silk.

Big tongues are everywhere, mostly red, occasionally leopard print.

Above: Rolling Stones Shop, Carnaby Street, London, England

I can’t get no satisfaction
I can’t get no satisfaction
‘Cause I try, and I try, and I try, and I try
I can’t get no, I can’t get no

When I’m driving in my car
When a man come on the radio
He’s telling me more and more
About some useless information
Supposed to fire my imagination

I can’t get no, oh, no, no, no, hey, hey, hey
That’s what I say
I can’t get no satisfaction
I can’t get no satisfaction
‘Cause I try, and I try, and I try, and I try
I can’t get no, I can’t get no

When I’m watchin’ my TV
And a man comes on and tells me
How white my shirts can be
But, he can’t be a man ’cause he doesn’t smoke
The same cigarettes as me

I can’t get no, oh, no, no, no, hey, hey, hey
That’s what I say
I can’t get no satisfaction
I can’t get no girl reaction
‘Cause I try, and I try, and I try, and I try
I can’t get no, I can’t get no

When I’m ridin’ ’round the world
And I’m doin’ this and I’m signin’ that
And I’m tryin’ to make some girl, who tells me
Baby, better come back maybe next week
Can’t you see I’m on a losing streak?
I can’t get no, oh, no, no, no, hey, hey, hey
That’s what I say
I can’t get no, I can’t get no
I can’t get no satisfaction, no satisfaction
No satisfaction, no satisfaction
I can’t get no

The Rolling Stones

The venue is the world’s first permanent Rolling Stones shop, which will open in the spiritual home of all things cool, Carnaby Street in London’s West End.

It sells everything from T-shirts, hoodies and denim jackets to key rings, guitar plectrums and water bottles.

All with a Rolling Stones brand.

Please allow me to introduce myself
I’m a man of wealth and taste
I’ve been around for long long years
Stole a million men’s souls and faith

And I was ’round when Jesus Christ
Had his moment of doubt and pain
Made damn sure that Pilate
Washed his hands and sealed his fate

Above: Christ in the Wilderness, Ivan Kramskoy

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game

Stuck around St. Petersburg
When I saw it was a time for a change
Killed the Tsar and his ministers
Anastasia screamed in vain

Above: St. Petersburg riot, 4 July 1917

Above: Russian Tsar Nicholas II (1868 – 1918)

Above: Grand Duchess Anastasia Nikolaevna of Russia (1901 – 1918)

I rode a tank
Held a general’s rank
When the Blitzkrieg raged
And the bodies stank

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name, oh yeah
Ah, what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game, oh yeah

I watched with glee
While your kings and queens
Fought for ten decades
For the gods they made

I shouted out
“Who killed the Kennedys?”
When, after all,
It was you and me

Above: John F. Kennedy (1917 – 1963)

Above: Robert F. Kennedy (1925 – 1968)

Let me please introduce myself
I’m a man of wealth and taste
And I laid traps for troubadours
Who get killed before they reached Bombay

Above: Mumbai (formerly Bombay), India

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guessed my name, oh yeah
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game, oh yeah, get down, baby

Just as every cop is a criminal
And all the sinners saints
As heads is tails
Just call me Lucifer
‘Cause I’m in need of some restraint

Above: Illustration of Lucifer, Inferno, Dante Alligheri

So if you meet me
Have some courtesy
Have some sympathy, and some taste
Use all your well-learned politeness
Or I’ll lay your soul to waste, mm yeah

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guessed my name, mm yeah
But what’s puzzling you
Is the nature of my game, mm mean it, get down

Woo, who
Oh yeah, get on down
Oh yeah
Aah yeah

Tell me baby, what’s my name?
Tell me honey, can ya guess my name?
Tell me baby, what’s my name?
I tell you one time, you’re to blame

What’s my name
Tell me, baby, what’s my name?
Tell me, sweetie, what’s my name?

Sympathy for the Devil“, The Rolling Stones

The store is a collaboration between the band and the merchandising company Bravado, which has previously opened pop-up stores with merchandise for acts including Kanye West, Billie Eilish and Slipknot.

She take my money when I’m in need
Yeah, she’s a triflin’ friend indeed
Oh, she’s a gold digger
Way over town, that digs on me

Jamie Foxx and Kayne West

You ain’t nothin’ but a lost cause
And this ain’t nothin’ like it once was
I know you think you’re such an outlaw
But you got no job

Billie Eilish

A season at an end
A harvest of seclusion and regret
The burning can begin
A period of ash is what you get
The quiet is a curse
But my respect was shown to you by force
Another day too late
Another neck too eager for the rope
….

Yesterday was hard
Tomorrow’s just a promise of the same
When friends have all subscribed
To spitting on the ground to say my name
Fire on the ice
December in the summer kills the heart
Your hate is no surprise
I guess I have to die to play my part
…..

Hold the weight, never trust the one beside you
Carried away, you know just as much as I do
Hold the weight, do it all for what you really love
Carried away, use you up until you’ve had enough
….

True victims and survivors learn to make war
Don’t wanna be the sad man singing anymore
I did it all wrong, so I’d get it all right
We’re wasting all the candles, the dead need no light

A Liar’s Funeral, We Are Not Your Kind, Slipknot

David Boyne, Bravado’s managing director, said the aim was to create something that was more than a shop.

The number one objective was to make it experiential.“, he said.

It is about giving the fan, the customer, a journey of discovery.

This is our first permanent flagship store.

We are very proud with what we have delivered.

Above: David Boyne

The shop includes a glass floor featuring Stones song lyrics, screens showing footage of the band on tour, and fitting rooms with album artwork from “Exile on Main Street” and “Some Girls“.

When your spine is cracking and your hands they shake;
Heart is bursting and your butt’s going to break;
Woman’s cussing, you can hear her scream;
Feel like murder in the first degree
Ain’t nobody slowing down no way;
Everybody’s stepping on their accelerator;
Don’t matter where you are;
Everybody’s going to need a ventilator

Ventilator Blues“, Exile on Main Street, The Rolling Stones

I’ll never be your beast of burden
My back is broad, but it’s a-hurting
All I want is for you to make love to me
I’ll never be your beast of burden
I’ve walked for miles, my feet are hurting
All I want is for you to make love to me

Am I hard enough?
Am I rough enough?
Am I rich enough?
I’m not too blind to see

I’ll never be your beast of burden
So let’s go home and draw the curtains
Music on the radio
Come on, baby, make sweet love to me
….

I’ll never be your beast of burden
I’ll never be your beast of burden
Never, never, never, never, never, never, never be
I’ll never be your beast of burden
I’ve walked for miles, my feet are hurting
All I want is you to make love to me, yeah
I don’t need no beast of burden
I need no fussing, I need no nursing
Never, never, never, never, never, never, never be

Beast of Burden“, Some Girls, The Rolling Stones

At the front of the shop is a red metal sculpture that true diehards may recognize as being based on the opening of the 1966 track “Paint It Black“.

The background music is, of course, by the Stones.

I see a red door
And I want it painted black
No colors anymore
I want them to turn black

I see the girls walk by
Dressed in their summer clothes
I have to turn my head
Until my darkness goes

I see a line of cars
And they’re all painted black
With flowers and my love
Both never to come back

I’ve seen people turn their heads
And quickly look away
Like a newborn baby
It just happens everyday

I look inside myself
And see my heart is black
I see my red door
I must have it painted black

Maybe then, I’ll fade away
And not have to face the facts
It’s not easy facing up
When your whole world is black

No more will my green sea
Go turn a deeper blue
I could not foresee this thing
Happening to you

If I look hard enough
Into the setting sun
My love will laugh with me
Before the morning comes

I see a red door
And I want it painted black
No colors anymore
I want them to turn black

I see the girls walk by
Dressed in their summer clothes
I have to turn my head
Until my darkness goes

I wanna see it painted
Painted black
Black as night
Black as coal
I wanna see the sun
Blotted out from the sky
I wanna see it painted, painted, painted
Painted black, yeah

The Rolling Stones

Some will say that opening a bricks-and-mortar retail operation now, as the pandemic persists, is very risky.

Time will tell.“, said Boyle.

For us, it is about taking a really powerful, positive message to the marketplace.

It’s a cool store.

The store has teamed up with the French luxury brand Baccarat for a range of Rolling Stones glassware, which includes the decanter, tumblers and wine glasses.

John Pasche, who created the Rolling Stones’ now instantly recognisable lips and tongue logo – first used on the “Sticky Fingers” LP in 1971 – has created limited edition artworks, on sale from £1,195.

Childhood living is easy to do
The things you wanted I bought them for you
Graceless lady, you know who I am
You know I can’t let you slide through my hands

Wild horses couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses, couldn’t drag me away

I watched you suffer a dull aching pain
Now you decided to show me the same
No sweeping exits or offstage lines
Could make me feel bitter or treat you unkind

Wild horses couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses, couldn’t drag me away

I know I dreamed you a sin and a lie
I have my freedom but I don’t have much time
Faith has been broken, tears must be cried
Let’s do some living after we die

Wild horses couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses, we’ll ride them some day

Wild Horses“, Sticky Fingers, The Rolling Stones

The band may have a combined age of 305, but Boyne insisted they were as popular and relevant as ever.

They are definitely not has-beens.

I’m a ghost
Livin’ in a ghost town
I’m a ghost
Livin’ in a ghost town

You can come look for me
But I can’t be found
You can search for me
I had to go underground

Life was so beautiful
Then we all got locked down
Feel like a ghost
Living in a ghost town, yeah

Once this place was hummin’
And the air was full of drummin’
The sound of cymbals crashin’
Glasses were all smashin’
Trumpets were all screamin’
Saxophones were blarin’
Nobody was carin’
If it’s day or not

Woah, woah

I’m a ghost
Livin’ in a ghost town
I’m goin’ nowhere
Shut up all alone
So much time to lose
Just starin’ at my phone

Every night I am dreamin’
That you’ll come and creep in my bed
Please let this be over
Not stuck in a world without end
My friend

Woah
Woah, woah

Preachers were all preachin’
Charities beseechin’
Politicians dealin’
Thieves were happy stealin’
Widows were all weepin’
There’s no beds for us to sleep in
Always had the feelin’
It will all come tumblin’ down

I’m a ghost
Livin’ in a ghost town
You can look for me
But I can’t be found

Woah

We’re all livin’ in a ghost town (Woah)
Oh, livin’ in a ghost town (Woah)
We were so beautiful (Woah)
I was your man about town (Woah)

Livin’ in this ghost town (Woah)
Ain’t havin’ any fun (Woah)
If I wanna party (Woah)
It’s a party of one (Woah, woah)

Living in a Ghost Town“, The Rolling Stones

And that is exactly what this post is.

As I listen to the music, the music embraces me, caresses me, holds me to its bosom.

It is a party of one, a celebration of life, as the world slowly emerges from death by disease and returns to the destruction of war in faraway places with strange sounding names.

We don’t read and write poetry because it’s cute.

We read and write poetry because we are members of the human race.

And the human race is filled with passion.

And medicine, law, business, engineering, these are noble pursuits and necessary to sustain life.

But poetry, beauty, romance, love, these are what we stay alive for.

To quote from Whitman:

“O me! O life!

Of the questions of these recurring

Of the endless trains of the faithless

Of cities filled with the foolish

What good amid these, O me, O life?

Answer:

That you are here – that life exists, and identity.

That the powerful play goes on and you may contribute a verse.

Above: Walt Whitman (1819 – 1892)

That the powerful play goes on and you may contribute a verse.

What will your verse be?

Dead Poets Society, N.H. Kleinbaum

Above: Nancy H. Kleinbaum

Music is part of that powerful play.

Music is poetry, beauty, romance, love.

Thank Heaven for the music.

Above: Praying Hands, Albrecht Dürer

Here in Eskişehir, the sole place I have found laughingly calling itself a “music store” is the D & R Music and Book Store.

Music that I have the machinery – a CD/cassette player – to play in my apartment is limited to a set of shelves nearly invisible beside the store’s magazine selection.

In fairness, there is much in this city I have yet to explore.

But, as aforementioned, folks here look at me oddly when I say I am seeking a music CD of such-and-such artist or group.

My gym’s TV permanently placed on Channel Nr1 Türk has been playing the same selection of music since I joined it last year.

Tiesto’s The Business is permanently branded in my brain.

Let’s get down, let’s get down to business
Give you one more night, one more night to get this
We’ve had a million, million nights just like this
So let’s get down, let’s get down to business

Mama, please don’t worry ’bout me
‘Cause I’m about to let my heart speak
My friends keep telling me to leave this
So let’s get down, let’s get down to business

Back and forth, back and forth with the bullshit
I know I said it before, I don’t mean it
It’s been a while since I had your attention
So it might hurt to hear this

Dreams we have don’t ever fall away
We can’t leave ’em if we stay the same
And I can’t do this for another day
So let’s get down, let’s get down to business

Let’s get down, let’s get down to business
Give you one more night, one more night to get this
We’ve had a million, million nights just like this
So let’s get down, let’s get down to business

In my apartment no one tells me what music to play.

I have over 300 CDs (and some cassettes) I have had shipped from Switzerland.

Above: Logo of the Turkish National Post

I have YouTube and Spotify and now I have the option of the F-Spot and the bi-monthly performances of G. and his band.

Above: Logo of Spotify

I have radio through the Internet.

I live alone, but I am never lonely.

I have my books
And my poetry to protect me
I am shielded in my armor
Hiding in my room safe within my womb
I touch no one and no one touches me
I am a rock I am an island

And a rock feels no pain
And an island never cries

I Am a Rock“, Simon and Garfunkel

B.B. Bumble and the Stingers, Mott the Hoople, Ray Charles Singers
Lonnie Mack and twangin’ Eddie, here’s my ring, we’re goin’ steady
Take it easy, take me higher, liar liar, house on fire
Loco-motion, Poco, Passion, Deeper Purple, Satisfaction
Baby baby, gotta gotta, gimme gimme, gettin’ hotter
Sammy’s cookin’, Lesley Gore, Ritchie Valens, end of story
Mahavishnu, Fujiyama, Kama Sutra, Rama Lama
Richard Perry, Spector, Barry, Righteous, Archies, Nilsson Harry
Shimmy Shimmy Ko-Ko Bop it, Fats is back and Finger Poppin’

Above: The band Mott the Hoople

Above: Ray Charles (1930 – 2004)

Above: Lonnie Mack (1941 – 2016)

Above: Duane Eddy

Above: The band Poco

Above: The band Deep Purple

Above: Sam Cooke (1931 – 1964)

Above: Leslie Goldstein (aka Leslie Gore) (1946 – 2016)

Above: Richard Valenzuela (aka Ritchie Valens) (1941 – 1959)







Above: Mahavishnu Orchestra

Above: Richard Perry

Above: Phil Spector (1939 – 2021)

Above: Jeff Barry

Above: Barry White (1944 – 2003)

Above: The Righteous Brothers – Bobby Hatfield and Bill Medley

Above: Harry Nilsson (1941 – 1994)

Above: Antoine Domino (aka Fats Domino) (1928 – 2017)

Life is a rock
But the radio rolled me
Got to turn it up louder
So my DJ told me
(Woo-woo)

Life is a rock
But the radio rolled me (Life is a rock)
At the end of my rainbow (Woo-woo, life is a rock)
Lies a golden oldie

FM, AM, hits are clickin’ while the clock is tock-a-tickin’
Friends and Romans, salutations, Brenda and the Tabulations
Carly Simon, Noddy Holder, Rolling Stones, centerfolder
Johnny Cash and Johnny Rivers, can’t stop now, I got the shivers
Mungo Jerry, Peter Peter, Paul and Paula, Mary Mary
Dr. John the Nightly Tripper, Doris Day and Jack the Ripper
Gotta go so, gotta swelter, Leon Russell, Gimme Shelter
Miracles in Smokey places, slide guitars and Fender basses
Mushroom omelet, Bonnie Bramlett, Wilson Pickett, stomp and kick it

Above: The band FM

Above: Carly Simon

Above: Neville Holder (aka Noddy Holder)

Above: The Rolling Stones

Above: Johnny Cash (1932 – 2003)

Above: Johnny Rivers

Above: The band Mungo Jerry

Above: Peter, Paul and Mary

Above: Malcolm John Rebbennack Jr. (aka Dr. John the Night Tripper) (1941 – 2019)







Above: Doris Kappelhof (aka Doris Day) (1922 – 2019)

Above: Claude Leon Bridges (aka Leon Russell) (1942 – 2016)








Above: Smokey Robinson and the Miracles

Above: Bonnie Bramlett

Above: Wilson Pickett (1941 – 2006)

Life is a rock
But the radio
Life is a rock
But the radio, woo
(Woo-woo-woo)
(Woo-woo-woo)

Arthur Janov primal screamin’, Hawkins Jay and Dale and Ronnie
Kukla, Fran and Norman Okla, Denver John and Osmond Donny
J.J. Cale and ZZ Top and L.L. Bean and De De Dinah
David Bowie, Steely Dan, sing it prouder, C.C. Rider
Edgar Winter, Joanie Sommers, Ides of March, Johnny Thunders
Eric Clapton, pedal wah-wah, Stephen Foster, doo-dah, doo-dah
Good Vibrations, Help Me Rhonda, Surfer Girl and Little Honda
Tighter tighter, honey honey, sugar sugar, yummy yummy
CBS and Warner Brothers, RCA and all the others

Above: Arthur Janov (1924 – 2017)

Above: Jay Hawkins (1929 – 2000)

Above: Dale Hawkins (1936 – 2010)

Above: Ronnie Hawkins

Above: Kukla, Fran and Ollie

Above: Oklahoma University corner, Norman, Oklahoma

Above: Henry John Deutschendorf Jr. (aka John Denver) (1943 – 1997)

Above: Donnie Osmond

Above: John Weldon Cale (aka J. J. Cale) (1938 – 2013)

Above: The band ZZ Top

Above: David Robert Jones (aka David Bowie) (1947 – 2016)

Above: The band Steely Dan

Above: Edgar Winter

Above: Joan Drost (aka Joanie Sommers)






Above: The band The Ides of March

Above: John Anthony Genzale (aka Johnny Thunders) (1952 – 1991)

Above: Eric Clapton

Above: A wah-wah pedal for electric guitar sound effects

Above: “The father of American music” Stephen Foster (1826 – 1864)

Above: The band Bonzo Dog Doo Dah

Above: Logo of the Radio Corporation of America (1919 – 1986)

Life is a rock
But the radio rolled me (Life is a rock)
Got to turn it up louder (Woo-woo, life is a rock)
So my DJ told me (Life is a rock)
(Whoa-whoa, whoa-whoa)

Life is a rock
But the radio rolled me (Life is a rock) yeah
At the end of my rainbow (Woo-woo)
Lies a golden oldie
(Woo-woo, woo-woo, woo-woo-woo)


Listen, remember, they’re playin’ our song
(Woo-woo, woo-woo, woo-woo-woo)

(Please, Mister, please, don’t play B-17
It was our song, it was his song, but it’s over
Please, Mr., please, if you know what I mean
I don’t ever wanna hear that song again
)

Rock it, sock it, Alan Freed me, Murray Kaufman tried to lead me
Fish and swim and Boston Monkey, make it bad and play it funky
(I want to take you higher)

Above: Rock ’em Sock ’em Robots

Above: Alan Freed (1921 – 1965)

Above: Murray Kaufman (aka Murray the K) (1922 – 1982)

Above: Derek William Dick (aka Fish)

Above: Swim dance

Above: The band Boston

Freddie King and Albert King and B.B. King and frolicking
Get it on and not to worry, Pappalardi, Hale and Hearty, Yes
(Baby, baby, baby, Light My Fire)
(Celebrate, celebrate, dance to the music)

Above: Freddie King (1934 – 1976)

Above: Albert Nelson (aka Albert King) (1923 – 1992)

Above: Riley B. King (aka B. B. King) (1925 – 2015)

Above: Felix Pappalardi (1939 – 1983)

Above: Stan Laurel (1890 – 1965) and Oliver Hardy (1892 – 1957)

Above: The band Yes

There’s a perfect more than you would carry, words of Randy Newman
1-2-3, so long, Sophie, Anita, Freda
Aretha
(I wanna take you higher)
(Celebrate, celebrate, dance to the music)

Above: Randy Newman

Above: Sophie Tucker (1886 – 1966)

Above: Aretha Franklin (1942 – 2018)

Tito Puente, Boffalongo, Cuba, War and even Mongo
Lay it down while it’s hurtin’, Herbie’s Brass
(Baby, baby, baby, Light My Fire)
(Celebrate, celebrate, dance to the music)
(Baby, Everything is Alright, Uptight, Out of Sight)
Whoa

Above: Tito Puente (1923 – 2000)

Above: Cuba Gooding Sr. (1944 – 2017)

Above: The band War

Above: Mongo Santamaria (1917 – 2003)

California, Beatlemania, New York City, Transylvania
S&G, V&C, Bobby Vee and SRO, yeah
(Celebrate, celebrate, dance to the music)
(Baby, Everything is Alright, Uptight, Outta Sight)

Above: The Beatles

Above: Warner Bros. short film Transylvania 6-5000

Above: (Paul) Simon (right) and (Art) Garfunkel (left)

Above: Stanley Robert Vinton (aka Bobby Vinton)

Conway Twitty, do-wah-diddy, Conway Twitty, do-wah-diddy

Above: Harold Lloyd Jenkins (aka Conway Twitty) (1933 – 1993)





I have my favourite tunes.

I have my favourite books.

Life is good.

What’s the matter with the clothes I’m wearing?
Can’t you tell that your tie’s too wide?
Maybe I should buy some old tab collars?
Welcome back to the age of jive.
Where have you been hidin’ out lately, honey?
You can’t dress trashy till you spend a lot of money.
Everybody’s talkin’ ’bout the new sound
Funny, but it’s still rock and roll to me

What’s the matter with the car I’m driving?
Can’t you tell that it’s out of style?
Should I get a set of white wall tires?
Are you gonna cruise the miracle mile?
Nowadays you can’t be too sentimental
Your best bet’s a true baby blue Continental.
Hot funk, cool punk, even if it’s old junk
It’s still rock and roll to me.

Oh, it doesn’t matter what they say in the papers
‘Cause it’s always been the same old scene.
There’s a new band in town
But you can’t get the sound from a story in a magazine…
Aimed at your average teen

How about a pair of pink sidewinders
And a bright orange pair of pants?
You could really be a Beau Brummell baby
If you just give it half a chance.
Don’t waste your money on a new set of speakers,
You get more mileage from a cheap pair of sneakers.
Next phase, new wave, dance craze, anyways
It’s still rock and roll to me

What’s the matter with the crowd I’m seeing?
Don’t you know that they’re out of touch?
Should I try to be a straight ‘A’ student?
If you are then you think too much.
Don’t you know about the new fashion honey?
All you need are looks and a whole lotta money.
It’s the next phase, new wave, dance craze, anyways
It’s still rock & roll to me.
Everybody’s talkin’ ’bout the new sound
Funny, but it’s still rock and roll to me

But one does not stop buying books simply because one has no more shelves.

One does not stop buying music when there is an opportunity to do so.

I hope one day to return to London to see all those record shops that have opened and all those that remain.

And I will linger in each one for hours.

Wild horses will not drag me away.

Call it impulsive, call it compulsive, call it insane, but when I’m surrounded by music I just can’t stop.

I teach for a living, but literature and music is what makes life worth living.

I hope Heaven has music, but where there is music I am in Heaven.

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Mark Brown, “You can always get what you want“, The Times, 8 September 2020 / N.K. Kleinbaum, Dead Poets Society

Canada Slim and the Gates of Heaven

Eskişehir, Turkey, Saturday 9 April 2022 (Curmartesi 9 Nisan 2022 CE)(Ramadan 9, 1443 Anno Hegirae)

Strange days for me recently.

Turkey has entered into the 9th month of the Islamic calendar, Ramadan, with Turks all prepared to observe the month-long fast.

Mornings begin with drumming men marching down main streets before sunset.

The fasting, started in the early hours of Saturday 2 April, begins with a predawn meal named sahur and ends with iftar, the meal consumed after sunset.

Green lights appear on the local camii (mosque) to signal that iftar may begin.

On the first day of Ramadan, the eastern provinces of Iğdir and Hakkari had the earliest iftar at 1835 hours, while the northwestern provinces of Çanakkale and Edirne were the last to have iftar at 1946 hours.

Above: Ağri Mountain from Iğdir plain, Turkey

Above: Hakkari City, Turkey

Above: Waterfront, Çanakkale, Turkey

Above: Selimiye Mosque and the statue of architect Mimar Koca Sinan, Edirne, Turkey

Northern Sinop is the city that witnesses the longest time through Ramadan.

Believers in Sinop fasted for 14 hours 27 minutes on Saturday and will fast for 15 hours and 56 minutes on the last day of Ramadan.

Above: Sinop, Turkey

The southern province of Hatay has the shortest fasting time with 14 hours and 12 minutes on Saturday and will fast for 15 hours and 22 minutes on the last day of Ramadan.

Above: Bazaar, Antakya, Hatay Province, Turkey

The month of Ramadan will end on 30 April, following which Eid al-Fitr celebrations will start.

With the start of Ramadan, many nutritionists in Turkey have come to the forefront of public attention to give “safur and iftar tips” to fasting believers.

Above: Flag of Turkey

People should eat a protein-rich meal at sahur, mostly dairy products should be preferred.“, nutritionist Baran Mert told Demirören News Agency.

According to Mert, one should drink a minimum of two to two and a half litres of water between iftar and sahur.

When asked what to avoid at the start of iftar after hours of fasting, Mert said:

Believers should not eat continuously and rapidly after that.

I was recently asked by a friend whether or not I had a copy of the Qu’ran so he could begin to understand the religion that surrounds him, though his family back home is more interested in the Jewish and Christian sites of Asia Minor.

(I did.

I gave one to him.

Mosques that are tourist attractions often give away copies of the Qu’ran in various languages.

I have always believed that it is ignorant to criticize a religion if one is ignorant of that religion.

Kudos to my friend in seeking to understand the faith that surrounds him in his neighbourhood.)

He also asked if he need worry if he does not fast while Muslims around him do during Ramadan.

Ramadan is the 9th month of the Islamic calendar, observed by Muslims worldwide as a month of fasting (sawm), prayer, reflection and community.

A commemoration of Muhammad’s first revelation, the annual observance of Ramadan is regarded as one of the Five Pillars of Islam and lasts 29 to 30 days, from one sighting of the crescent moon to the next.

Above: “Muhammad, the Messenger of God” inscribed on the gates of the Prophet’s Mosque in Medina, Saudi Arabia

Fasting from dawn to sunset is fard (obligatory) for all adult Muslims who are not acutely or chronically ill, travelling, elderly, breastfeeding, diabetic or menstruating.

The predawn meal is referred to as suhur and the nightly feast that breaks the fast is called iftar.

Although fatwas have been issued declaring that Muslims who live in regions with a midnight sun or polar night should follow the timetable of Mecca, it is common practice to follow the timetable of the closest country in which night can be distinguished from day.

Above: Midnight sun, North Cape, Mageroya Island, Norway

The spiritual rewards (thawab) of fasting are believed to be multiplied during Ramadan.

Accordingly, Muslims refrain not only from food and drink, but also tobacco products, sexual relations and sinful behaviour, devoting themselves instead to salat (prayer) and recitation of the Qu’ran.

(As long as a man is not arrogant about feasting in the presence of those who fast, it is not expected for a non-Muslim to act like a Muslim – at least in this liberal city of Eskişehir – for the significance of the act of fasting can only appreciated by the practitioner of a religion that requires its faithful to fast.

If at this time a restaurant is open to serve customers, then guilt should not be felt if one acts like a customer.

If there is truly concern over what Muslims think, then do your feasting at home.)

Above: Neysen Tevfik Sokak, Eskişehir, Turkey

(It is odd that while other religions fast, during holy celebrations Christians feast.)

Above: Christmas dinner setting

From Magsie Hamilton Little’s The Thing about Islam: Exposing the Myths, Facts and Controversies:

The acts of prayer and pilgrimage help Muslims to focus on their spirituality, as well as binding them together by allowing them to join in a shared religious experience.

Likewise, fasting performs an equally fundamental role.

It is so important to Islam that the early Muslim theologian al-Ghazzali (1058 – 1111) described it as “one quarter of the Muslim faith“.

As such, the act of fasting is known as the 4th pillar of Islam.

It is not simply a matter of giving up food during the daytime.

It is a symbolic act, enabling Muslims to rid their systems of impurities on all levels and so become closer to God.

Above: Tomb of Imam Al-Ghazzali, Tus, Iran

God’s message to Muhammad was that fasting helps us to learn self-restraint.

It is an example set by the Prophet himself who, according to a famous hadith by Bukhari (810 – 870) that describes the frugality of Muhammad, would break his fast with a sip of water and a date.

To this day, many Muslims do the same.

Through the physical act of fasting, Muslims experience the deprivation that the poor bear throughout the year, thus hopefully becoming more sensitive and responsive to their suffering as a result.

This makes crash-dieting in the West, aimed at dropping a dress size in a few weeks, seem rather shameful.

Above: al-Bukhari Mausoleum, Samarkand, Uzbekistan

Ramadan, the month of the fast, whose name comes from the Arabic root r-m-d, “the great heat“, from the soaring heat in the deserts of Arabia, in the 9th month of the Muslim calendar.

Above: Arabian Desert

It is special for Muslims as it was during the month that Muhammad received the call to be a prophet.

God Himself instructed that it should be the official month of fasting, in a revelation received after the establishment of the community in Medina.

Although no one knows the exact date of this, in the early days of Islam fasting took place on the 10th day of Muharram.

This is still one of a number of days of voluntary fasting, but today Muhammad’s call to be a prophet is celebrated on 27th Ramadan.

This is a particularly significant night.

Many people stay at their local mosque until long into the night, reading the Qu’ran and praying.

It is thought by some that prayer at this time is particularly powerful, awarding more blessings than prayers at other times.

Above: Hira Cave, Jabal al-Nour Mountain, Saudi Arabia, where, according to Muslim belief, Muhammad received his first revelation

Ramadan is about remembering to take nothing for granted.

It is about removing daily distractions so the mind is better able to focus on closeness with Allah.

On a practical level, this means no eating, drinking, smoking or sex from dawn to sunset for the entire month.

In the wider scheme, while fasting it is especially encouraged that the believer avoids sin, such as lying, violence, greed, lust, slander, anger and evil thoughts.

The fact is about self-discipline.

A Muslim is called to make an extra effort to cultivate a more spiritual outlook.

The observance of Ramadan is regarded a source of blessing and not a time of trial.

Muslims generally look forward to this time of bodily and spiritual cleansing.

They do not view it as being arduous or a chore.

They hold it as a special period that brings them back in touch with the values at the heart of their faith.

They see it as a healthy time, during which rich foods are avoided and their digestive systems can be rested and cleansed.

At Ramadan, Muslims are given the opportunity to master all their natural appetites, mental, spiritual and physical.

It also allows them an opportunity to get together with friends and family, to share their food after the hour of sunset.

According to Islamic tradition, during this time the gates of Heaven are opened, the gates of Hell are closed and Satan is put into chains.

Hence fasting during Ramadan is considered 30 times better than at any other time, although many Muslims do fast at other times, some even on a weekly basis.

Ramadan observances do vary slightly from culture to culture, but most Muslims begin the fast, according to the Qu’ran‘s instruction, at the moment when dawn makes it possible to distinguish “a white thread from a black thread“.

They then break the fast as soon as possible at sunset, eating a light meal later in the evening, with perhaps a final light meal in the early pre-dawn hours before the next morning’s fast begins – but all this depends on local custom and personal preference.

The evening is a time of relaxation, of visiting, prayer and Qu’ran recitation.

Printed Qu’rans divide the text into 30 sections to facilitate reading the whole book during Ramadan.

Most Muslims accomplish this.

Sounds of recitation often punctuate the evening air.

Most individuals perform a voluntary salat (prayer) of 20 rak’as, called taraweeh, sometime after the 5th prescribed prayer of the day.

Most go to the mosque during the evening, especially during the last ten days of the month.

Muslims say that Ramadan demands a certain spiritual attitude towards the body.

The hunger, supplemented by the prohibition on perfume and makeup, brings a Muslim back every year to what is regarded as a more natural state.

Whether it be experiencing the hunger of the less fortunate, expiating one’s sins, forgiving others theirs, renewing contact with one’s nearest and dearest, or simply taming one’s passions, a time of fasting is about reflection and contemplation, a return to the core values of Islam and a reassessment of what it means to be a Muslim.

Since fasting can make people feel weary and weak, great care is taken over the type of food eaten during Ramadan.

The consumption of special dishes at this time dates back to the earliest Islamic days, varying according to culture and region.

In medical Islamic recipes harira is sometimes mentioned and described as being made out of milk, flour and fat, rather than being a broth.

Above: Ramadan Harira

Early Muslim scholars, such as Bukhari and ibn Hanbal, talk of harira made of flour with cooked milk and a broth generally made with bran and meat cut into small pieces and boiled in water.

Above: The Musnad of Imam Ahmad is one of the most famous and extensive hadith books.

(Ḥadīth in Islam refers to what the majority of Muslims believe to be a record of the words, actions, and the silent approval of the Prophet Muhammad as transmitted through chains of narrators.

In other words, the ḥadīth are transmitted reports about what Muhammad said and did.)

Above: Imam Nawawi’s 4th Hadith being taught, Sultan Hassan Mosque Madrassa, Cairo, Egypt

In the Muslim East, al-Baghdadi’s Kitab at-Tabikh, written in the 13th century, gives recipes for meat and flour dishes.

Above: Abd al-Latif al-Baghdadi (1162 – 1231)

In the Muslim West, Ibn Razi gives nine recipes for soups and eight for harira, based on bread reduced to fine crumbs or on moistened flour slowly poured and turned into a broth of plain water and salt with oil, egg or chicken, and flavouring ingredients, such as coriander, ginger, cinnamon, onions and garlic.

Above: Statue of Abu Bakr al-Razi, Persian Scholars Pavilion, United Nations Office, Vienna, Austria

Nowadays, other sweet fruits, such as dried figs and halwa, supplement the dates.

Above: Dried figs

Snacks are sometimes eaten between night-time meals, especially biscuits and tea or coffee.

A sign of the approach of Ramadan in the streets of North Africa is the transformation of doughnut merchants’ shops into delicious halwa stores, through home preparation of halwa is still very common.

Halwa consists of wheat flour, eggs, ground sesame, saffron, olive oil, butter, orange-flower water, vinegar, yeast and a pinch of salt.

These ingredients are mixed, energetically kneaded, allowed to rise, shaped, fried in oil and then soaked in honey before being drained and dusted with sesame seeds.

The resulting halwa is served with soup or with dry cakes and tea or coffee, as a snack.

Above: Halwa

In some cultures, such as in Morocco, special foods are prepared, including those of the s’hur, at which different kinds of pancakes are eaten.

Above: Flag of Morocco

Those of the ftur, harira or soups are used to break the fast.

On the eve of Ramadan, people prepare a honey cake to accompany the soup, known as halwa, sellou or zammita – sweet cereals and other dry cakes eaten as after-dinner snacks.

Similarly, in Afghanistan special sweets and pastries are prepared, such as halwa-e swanak, sheer payna and goash-e fil.

Stocks of these sweet foods are replenished during the 3rd or 4th week of the month.

S’hur marks the start of the fast, whereas Iftar ends it.

Above: Flag of Afghanistan

If Muslims follow Muhammad’s example during Ramadan, one would imagine their body weight to show evidence of it during Ramadan, one would imagine their body weight to show evidence of it by the end of the month.

However, the opposite is often the case.

Some Muslims actually put on weight, owing to the increased consumption of sugar in the dates and all the flour.

Forty years ago, the Iftar consisted of a bowl of soup preceded by “a sweet fruit, a small amount of honey or even just a mouthful of water“.

It was thought that that alone gave the strength of a light meal.

Ben Talha, writing in 1950, spoke of Muslims breaking their fast with toast with butter, or bread soaked in beaten eggs and cooked in butter, something like French toast.

Now, in some circles, Ramadan is an excuse to host lavish parties every night and taste exotic foods not sampled since the last Ramadan.

Whatever cultural variances exist between customs at Ramadan, overall the month is seen by Muslims as a very special time.

There is a feeling of camaraderie.

The fast is a great leveller and brings out the best in everyone, whether rich or poor.

I can say, from my extremely limited point-of-view and experience, that Eskişehir is fairly liberal in its observance of Ramadan.

Folks will or will not fast at this time, depending on the depth of their faith.

Those who feast during this time are not condemned.

Those who fast during this time are not ridiculed.

As a non-Muslim, I maintain the same dietary and non-observance of religious rites as I did before Ramadan arrived.

I respect those that do.

No one shows disrespect towards those who do not.

Above: Kanatli shopping centre, Kızılcıklı Sokak, Eskişehir

I was asked by a Turkish student whether or not I had a copy of the Holy Bible as he wished to understand the religion that so many Americans – our school is called Wall Street English after all – profess to practice.

Above: The Malmesbury Bible

(I did not.

My copies remain back in Switzerland.

Above: Flag of Switzerland

Christian copy in Christian countries, Muslim material in Muslim countries.

Not such an intellectual exercise for a man who does not profess to follow any faith, though he respects the rights of those who do.)

Above: Auguste Rodin’s The Thinker, Paris, France

From Andrew Finkel’s Turkey: What Everyone Needs to Know:

Turkey is both a Muslim majority country and an avowed secular state.

Reconciling these two identities has proven complicated.

While Turkey lays claim to serving as a cultural ambassador between faiths in a post 9/11 world, its own domestic political agenda sometimes reflects the emotionally charged debate about the compatibility of Islam with democratic governance.

There is a divide between those who believe Islam is being manipulated by political forces to derail the Western orientation of the Turkish state and those who counter that this Islamic peril is a spectre raised by elements trying to cling to a very undemocratic influence and privilege.

Article 24 of the 1982 Constitution guarantees freedom of religion and conscience, but with the proviso that these freedoms do not threaten the integrity and secular character of the state.

At the same time, the Constitution implicitly recognizes faith as one of the bonds of citizenship by making religious and ethical instruction mandatory during primary and secondary education.

Islam in Turkey remains influenced by the Hanafi School, or what had been Ottoman orthodoxy – the oldest and arguably the most liberal of the four schools of Sunni jurisprudence.

Schools teach the practice rather than comparative religion.

Above: Suleymaniye Mosque, Istanbul, Turkey

Turkey’s secularism is not so much a separation of mosque (Camii) and state as it is the state’s right to assert its primacy over religion.

The government still funds a huge religious establishment, the Presidency of Religious Affairs (DIB), which licences after-school Qu’ran courses, administers Turkey’s allotted pilgrimage quota for the Hadj, publishes books, and makes moral pronouncements.

While it does not build or maintain mosques, it does provide stipends for the nation’s clerics, who, in turn, are expected to preach a prepared message from the Friday pulpit.

Above: Selimiye Mosque, Edirne, Turkey

The DIB is, by its own admission, a much-modified version of the Ottoman religious authority, the Sheikh-ul-Islam.

Yet the Ottoman Empire was far from being a cleric-run theocracy.

Above: The Ottoman Empire at its greatest extent

Clerics were regarded as functionaries rather than divinely inspired.

A state bureaucracy worked to codify laws involving taxation, commerce, the military, agriculture and minority affairs – matters beyond the purview of religious law.

Religious or customary law has no status in the Republic of Turkey, having been replaced by a Swiss-inspired civil code.

However, the DIB can still set itself the ambitious project to codify the hadith, the orally transmitted tradition of the Prophet’s teachings, a project largely intended to confirm Islam’s compatibility with democratic values and universal rights.

Above: Şakirin Mosque, Istanbul, Turkey

Osama bin Laden was among those who put his finger on the resulting anomalies.

In one of his infamous post 9/11 video appearances, he explained that he was out to avenge “eight decades of pain, humiliation and shame“.

Above: Osama bin Laden (1957 – 2011)

The reference, Turks grasped at once, was to the creation of the Republic in 1923 and to the decision of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk to plow salt into the notion of a religiously empowered state.

Above: Mustafa Kemal Atatürk (1881 – 1938)

In Eskişehir and Istanbul, like many who had grown up during the early years of the Republic, there are many people who neither pray or keep a fast.

It is not that they are disrespectful of religion.

They are just indifferent to it.

Like many of their friends and acquaintances they explain their lack of interest for their love for Atatürk and their faith in the secular Republic.

Above: Ulus Monument, representing Mustafa Kemal Atatürk on top, Eskişehir

The 1924 abolition of the Caliphate – the leader of the world Islamic community and a role enjoyed by the Ottoman sultan – was a renunciation of an authority that could transcend the borders of the nation-state.

Moves like the outlawing of the self-governing religious orders were intended to prevent religious institutions and what today would be called “networks” from challenging the new regime.

Above: The last Caliph, Abdulmecid II (1868 – 1944)

The formal adoption of the Gregorian calendar, of Western-style timekeeping in place of “mosque time“, and indeed the whole tenor of Republican reforms were all premised on the view of Islam as an impediment to Turkey’s attempts to catch up with the West.

They were attempts to deconsecrate or secularize the totems of religious life.

Above: Pope Gregory XIII (1502 – 1585)

In 1930, a short-lived uprising led by a cleric in the Western town of Menemen (during which the local military commander’s head was cut off and paraded on a pole) was not a threat to the new regime so much as a challenge to its confidence that the population at large had signed onto its modernization project.

The Menemen Incident, or Kubilay Incident (Turkish: Kubilay Olayı or Menemen Olayı), refers to a chain of events which occurred in Menemen, a small town north of Izmir, on 23 December 1930.

Islamists rebelled against the secularization of Turkey by Atatürk and beheaded Mustafa Fehmi Kubilay, a teacher who was doing his military service and two other watchmen.

Above: Mustafa Fehmi Kubilay (1906 – 1930)

Following the signing of the Treaty of Lausanne in 1923, the Republican People’s Party of Turkey pursued a somewhat liberal policy towards Islam, promoting secularism while not taking a hard line against Islamic institutions and practices, believing that the secularism of their ideology was already taking root.

Above: Borders of Bulgaria, Greece and Turkey set by the Treaty of Lausanne

Above: Palais de Rumine, Lausanne, Switzerland, where the Treaty was settled

This confidence was shaken on 23 December 1930, when Dervish Mehmet Efendi (Cretan Mehmet), a member of the Naqshbandi (Turkish: Nakşibendi) order, created a protest by rallying an armed crowd against the policies of the secular government and calling for the restoration of sharia and the Caliphate.

On the morning of 23 December 1930, six people, four of whom were armed, came to Menemen from Manisa, planted the green banner they had taken from a mosque in the district square after the morning prayer and tried to gather people around them at gunpoint.

With the participation of the public, the rebel group soon grew. 

The activists said that they came to protect religion. 

Mehmet boasted that behind them was the army of the Caliph, 70,000 strong.

Those who did not gather under the banner of sharia before noon would be put to the sword. 

A squad of soldiers from the local garrison was sent to quell the demonstration.

When the incidents were heard by the military unit in the district, the regimental commander sent reserve officer Kubilay to the scene with a squad of soldiers. 

Kublai left the soldiers and met the activists alone and tried to persuade them to surrender. 

One of the armed activists shot and injured Kubilay. Derviş Mehmet, one of the ringleaders, said, “There is no bullet in me.” He tried to convince the people that he had a sacred duty.

Seeing this one of the soldiers fired (using wooden bullets that had no lethal effect) upon the demonstrators and a riot ensued.

Mehmet said:

There is no bullet in me.” 

He tried to convince the people that he had a sacred duty.

Mehmet shouted:

Those who wear hats are kaffirs.

We will return to sharia soon.

Above: Dervish Mehmet Efendi (d. 1931)

Wounded, Kubilay took refuge in the courtyard of the mosque, but Mehmet and his friends followed him. 

Mehmet opened his bag, took out a saw-edged vineyard knife and separated Kubilay’s head from his body, then his severed head was placed on a pole with a green flag and paraded through town.

Above: Martyr Kubilay Memorial in Menemen, İzmir –
The monument of the Menemen Incident features a tall sculpture by Ratip Asir Acudogu which was erected in 1932.
The Kubilay Memorial is a part of Kubilay Barracks, but is open to the public.
The area is landscaped and illuminated at night.
A military honor guard stands continuous watch at the memorial site, which contains the graves of several Turkish soldiers who were killed in the line of duty.
In the aftermath 28 people were hanged by the neck.
It is written on the monument: 
They believed, they fought, they died.
We are the guardians of the trust they left.

Two municipal watchmen, Bekçi Hasan and Bekçi Şevki, were also killed by the demonstrators.

Several rioters were also killed.

Upon hearing Kubilay’s murder by Islamists, Atatürk proclaimed:

Thousands from Menemen didn’t prevent this, instead joined with tekbirs.

Where were these traitors during Greek occupation?”.

The Turkish government expressed their shock over the people of Menemen not reacting to things like the Meneman massacre as harsh as they did to secularization.

The perpetrators of the rebellion including Cretan Mehmet, Cretan Ibrahim, Mehmet of Damascus, Sütçü Mehmet Emin, Nalıncı Hasan and Little Hasan were killed or otherwise punished.

Above: Menemen

The new republican government of Turkey was shocked by the demonstration of religious fervor and by how readily it was embraced by some Turks, as it was completely antithetical to secularism.

A state of emergency was declared and courts-martial were established which meted out sentences ranging from death at the gallows or life imprisonment to one year’s confinement.

There were also several acquittals. 

Sufi members were arrested around the country.

Furthermore, it demonstrated that secularism was taking hold neither as quickly nor as deeply as the government would have liked.

This spurred the government to action.

They began more aggressive secularization reforms in response to the Menemen Incident.

The government carried out this policy by attempting to nationalise Islam through performing the Adhan (Turkish: Ezan)(“call to prayer“), in Turkish rather than Arabic.

The government furthered secularization in schools by having the Quran translated from Arabic into Turkish and read to the people on the radio and in the mosques in Turkish.

These attempts reflected a comprehensive effort by the government to remove Islamic influences and entrench nationality over religion in Turkish culture.

These efforts also showed a larger attempt on the part of the government to consolidate Turkish traditions and promote a Turkish identity to replace a dominantly Muslim one, as in the Ottoman Empire people were identified by the millet system according to their religion rather than ethnicity.

These were done to replace the last vestiges of nostalgia for the abolished Caliphate and the broken-up Ottoman Empire in the aftermath of World War I (1914 – 1918).

Above: Coat of arms of the Ottoman Empire

The Incident helped confirm in the Republican imagination that religion was counter-revolutionary and needed to be monitored and contained.

The 2nd President of Turkey İsmet İnönü said:

Kublai is an example of idealist patriotism that does not calculate power alone for the sake of the revolution, for the sake of patriotism and unity. 

Kubilay is an exceptional monument of the traditional Turkish nature, who is ready to sacrifice his life for the nation at any moment.

Above: İsmet İnönü (1884 – 1973)

7th President Kenan Evren wrote:

The Kublai Incident had a great impact on me and my classmates.

Because the brutal martyrdom of a young officer would of course affect us.

I was under the influence of this for a long time.

They said that the perpetrators of this massacre were caught and they were waiting for the train at the station.

We went to the station.

I saw the traitors who martyred him and Kubilay there.

It left such a deep impression on me that I started painting with a pencil at that time.

I made my first painting with Kubilay’s painting.

I remember it and it was a beautiful painting.

I wish I had kept it.

If only he had stayed with me as a memory.

Above: Kenan Evren (1917 – 2015)

Above: Republic Square, Menemen, Izmir Province, Turkey

Even so, the anticlericalism of the nation’s founders began to soften in the postwar multiparty era as Atatürk’s top-down modernization was replaced with top-down democratization.

In the 1950s there was greater tolerance for Islam – including the reopening of mosques and schools of divinity – and the government allowed mosques to resume the practice of summoning the faithful to prayer in Arabic rather than in Turkish.

Although the core Republic guard saw this as pandering to populist sentiment, later it was the military itself – during the period of martial law (1980 – 1983) – which viewed religion as a force of social cohesion and made religious instruction compulsory.

The rationale for the coup had been the violent street warfare between gangs of left-wing and nationalist youths.

Religious radicalism was regarded as something of a spent force and the military hoped to co-opt Sunni Islam into propping up old-fashioned nationalism.

The result was a worldview known as the “Turkish-Islamic synthesis“.

Above: Kocatepe Mosque, Ankara, Turkey

The success of the overtly Islamist Welfare Party (1983 – 1998) in the 1994 local elections and in general elections the following year obliged the military to doubt the wisdom of their benign view of religion.

Above: Welfare Party logo

This was the election that launched the career of Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who was to prove the military’s most able foe and who was able to maneuver his AK Party into the political mainstream.

The AK Party repackaged its commitment to Islam as a question of private conscience and democratic choice.

Above: Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

Is Turkey in danger of becoming a fundamentalist state?

The question is one often posed by those who fear that Islam is the main obstacle to Turkey’s fuller integration into the West or that it prevents the country from achieving its goal of full democracy.

The more alienating force is a crude nationalism that in the past has served as a cover for government corruption and political/economic isolationism.

Yet many nonetheless fear that Turkish society is becoming a Kulturkampf (cultural battle) between rival secular and Islamic-oriented elites.

Above: Ahmet Hamdi Akseki Mosque, Ankara, Turkey

The most obvious antidote to polarization is the ability of a population to accommodate and thrive from diversity.

Some women wear headscarves, some have piercings, some have both.

In 2012, around 65% of Turks were teetotalers.

Those who indulge can choose from an increasing array of wines from boutique vineyards that have become the passion and playthings of a Western-oriented elite.

Above: Wine-producing regions in Turkey

For example, the residents of the conservative Central Anatolian city of Kayseri joke about those who attend Friday prayers but leave for a weekend at the nearby tourist hotspots of Cappadocia, much in the way the burghers of Philadelphia once made for Atlantic City on a Saturday night to evade the ban of selling alcohol in the early hours of Sunday.

Above: Kayseri beneath Mount Erciyes, Turkey

Above: İbrahimpaşa panorama, Cappadocia, Turkey

Above: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA

Above: Atlantic City, New Jersey, USA

Turkey still regards itself as a home of the world’s revealed religions and actively promotes “faith tourism“, hoping to attract millions of visitors to religious monuments and sites.

Above: Regions in Turkey for religious tourism

The Archbishop of Constantinople (the Ecumenical Patriarch) is the first among equals of the 300 million adherents of the Orthodox faith worldwide.

The title dates back to the 6th century.

The present incumbent still celebrates liturgy in the Church of St. George by the shores of the Golden Horn.

Above: His All Holiness Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I

Above: Church of St. George, Istanbul, Turkey

Castles and churches of the medieval Armenian kingdoms are scattered through eastern Turkey and the seat of the Armenian Patriarchate has, since 1461, been in Istanbul.

Above: Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople, Istanbul, Turkey

The Roman city of Sardis near the Aegean contains the restored remains of a 3rd century synagogue.

Above: Sardis Synagogue

The Arhida Synagogue in Istanbul remains active more than 500 years after it was first built.

Above: Ahrida Synagogue, Istanbul, Turkey

Guidebook in hand, one can visit the basilicas of the Eastern churches, including Chaldean Catholic churches and Assyrian monasteries where the liturgical language is ancient Aramaic.

Above: Mar Petyun Chaldean Catholic Church, Diyarbakir, Turkey

Above: Assyrian Patriarchal Church of Mar Shalita, Qudshanis, Hakkâri Province, Turkey

Though still functioning, these monuments to Anatolia’s multi-confessional past are at best vestigial.

The communities they serve have barely survived a 20th century legacy of nationalist upheavals and subsequent exodus.

Turkish-born non-Muslims now account for less than 1% of the current population.

Above: Hagia Sophia, Istanbul, Turkey

There is a gap between the rhetoric of tolerance and the actual practice.

Opinion surveys commonly report individuals’ reluctance to live next to people of faiths different than their own.

However, there are not that many non-Muslims to put this abstract prejudice to the test.

One might expect, to take a nonreligious example, that there would be much greater tension between Kurdish and non-Kurdish communities, particularly during periods when the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) has been on a violent campaign.

Above: Flag of the PKK

While it would be foolish to deny prejudice exists, dire prophecies of intercommunal tensions between Turk and Kurd simply have not materialized.

Perhaps a common faith remains a unifying force.

To inject a personal note, one of the most attractive features of living in Turkey as a foreigner is the quality of respect and civility that invests the exchanges of everyday life.

It would, therefore, be unwise to see discrimination against non-Muslims as a function of an increasing Islamization of Turkish society or of an ascendancy of the AK Party rather than as a part of the nationalist legacy.

Above: Justice and Development Party (AK) logo

The Greek Orthodox community has also been the victim of tit-for-tat retaliation over the treatment of Turkish communities in Eastern Greece or in Cyprus.

Above: Flag of the Greek Orthodox Church

If anything, religious minorities have benefitted from the greater openness that the AK Party requests on behalf of its own mainstream constituents.

The unease that Turkey feels about allowing full expression of other faiths stems in part from its own insecurities about Islam.

Above: Kocatepe Camii (mosque), Ankara, Turkey

An interesting case is the Orthodox seminary on Heybeli Island off the coast of Istanbul, which served as a private and therefore illegal institution of higher education.

It closed in 1971.

This is of great concern to the Patriarchate, which relies on the institution to train future clergy.

Since then, the door has been opened to private universities albeit under the supervision of the Board of Higher Education – a solution that the Orthodox Church cannot accept.

This has led to an impasse that, in turn, has become a diplomatic embarrassment.

The fate of Halki is often on the agenda when Turkish statesmen travel abroad.

Above: Halki Theological School, Hill of Hope, Heybeli Island, Turkey

It has been the subject of resolutions from both houses of the US Congress.

The real problem is not that the government wants the school to remain shut, but rather that if it allowed priests to be trained to institutions outside its control, it would come under pressure to extend that same right to “unlicensed” courses in Islam.

Above: Emblem of Turkey

Not all Islam in Turkey is mainstream.

Above: Sabanci Merkez Camii, Adana, Turkey

There is a sizeable Alevi community.

Above: Alevis Islam in Turkey

Alevi is a form of Shi’ite Islam, but unlike in Iran, where Shi’ism has reinforced a theocratic orthodoxy, Alevis have been part of a culture of dissent in Turkey.

Above: Flag of Iran

Their faith incorporates elements of mysticism and folk religion and exhibits an indifference to many of the practices associated with mainstream Islam – including obligatory fasting during the month of Ramadan or even the pilgrimage to Mecca.

Above: Hadj pilgrims around the Kaaba, Mecca, Saudi Arabia

Alevis are sometimes regarded as the front line in the defence of Turkish secularism inasmuch as they are treated with condescension or at best are overlooked by the religious establishment.

Many Alevis resent seeing their taxes going to support that establishment or a school system that teaches a variant of a faith very different from what they practice at home.

Indeed, one could argue that they have long been the victim of the intolerance which Turkish secularists fear may one day rebound on themselves.

Above: Haci Bektas Veli (1248 – 1337) was a mystic, humanist and a philosopher who lived in Anatolia (Central-Turkey). His teachings had great impact on the Anatolian cultures. He is known for his humanistic teachings and mystic personality.

At the same time, it would be wrong to gloss over the mutual suspicion between those adopting a pious lifestyle and those who adhere to a more latitudinarian one.

Both have reason to fear the other’s intolerance.

Commentators speak of the informal “neighbourhood pressure” and of an ascendancy forcing people to conform to mores they might not choose themselves.

Turkish secularists wonder whether they will be made to wait on the wrong side of the barriers they themselves erected.

Historically it is the pious who have been excluded from public life.

Above: Sultan Ahmed Mosque, Istanbul, Turkey

The answer to those who worry that the AK Party is a fundamentalist party in liberal clothing is that it has been in office since 2002 and has had ample time to show its hand.

There is evidence that it believes it has the mandate to legislate on issues of private morality and enforce more strictly those laws and ordinances that already exist.

However, it seems unlikely that any Turkish government would make a sudden move that would excite opinion both at home and abroad.

Above: Parliament of Turkey

In 2004, President Erdoğan did propose making adultery a felony.

He backtracked precisely when the ensuing uproar began to affect Turkey’s attempt to get a seat at the EU negotiating table.

Above: Seal of the President of Turkey

In fact, adultery had been illegal in Turkey, but the law governing it was declared unconstitutional in 1996 because it applied a far stricter standard for women (mere infidelity) than for men (taking a mistress).

The never-enacted law apparently was intended not to tame philandering modernists, but to discipline pious men who thought themselves entitled to take on additional partners, sanctioned by Islamic law but not by civil code.

Legislation came into effect in 2011 that has made it more difficult to serve alcohol at some types of events or for alcohol firms to sponsor sporting events.

These restrictions, as well as higher taxes on alcohol, were justified on grounds of public health and not morality.

The AK government is equally anti-smoking.

However, its general disapproval of alcohol is seen by secularists as the not-so-thin edge of the wedge.

The pious may be against the consumption of alcohol, but they show no sign of being against consumption per se.

Turkish sociologists talk about a newly empowered Islamic bourgeoisie.

Islamic (i.e. “non-interest” or “participation“) banking in 2010 accounted for a mere (and static) 4% of total banking assets.

There is scant public discussion concerning the morality of credit cards or bank interest.

One reason to doubt that there will be a sudden “majoritarian” imposition of an Islamic regime is that there is no groundswell of people who see a major incompatibility of their faith and the life they are already living.

(Islamic bankingIslamic finance or Sharia-compliant finance is banking or financing activity that complies with Sharia (Islamic law) and its practical application through the development of Islamic economics.

Some of the modes of Islamic banking/finance include: 

  • Mudarabah (profit-sharing and loss-bearing)
  • Wadiah (safekeeping)
  • Musharaka (joint ventures)
  • Murabahah (profit markup)
  • Ljara (leasing)

Above: Housing Bank, Amman, Jordan

Sharia prohibits riba (usury), interest paid on all loans of money.

Investment in businesses that provide goods or services considered contrary to Islamic principles (e.g. pork or alcohol) is also haram (“sinful and prohibited“).

These prohibitions have been applied historically in varying degrees in Muslim countries/communities to prevent un-Islamic practices.

In the late 20th century, as part of the revival of Islamic identity, a number of Islamic banks formed to apply these principles to private or semi-private commercial institutions within the Muslim community.

Their number and size has grown, so that by 2009, there were over 300 banks and 250 mutual funds around the world complying with Islamic principles, and around $2 trillion was Sharia-compliant by 2014

Sharia-compliant financial institutions represented approximately 1% of total world assets, concentrated in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, Pakistan, Iran and Malaysia. 

Above: Islamic Banking and Finance Institute, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Although Islamic banking still makes up only a fraction of the banking assets of Muslims, since its inception it has been growing faster than banking assets as a whole, and is projected to continue to do so.

The industry has been lauded for returning to the path of “divine guidance” in rejecting the “political and economic dominance” of the West, and noted as the “most visible mark” of Islamic revivalism, its most enthusiastic advocates promise “no inflation, no unemployment, no exploitation and no poverty” once it is fully implemented.

However, it has also been criticized for failing to develop profit and loss sharing or more ethical modes of investment promised by early promoters, and instead selling banking products that “comply with the formal requirements of Islamic law“, but use “ruses and subterfuges to conceal interest“, and entail “higher costs, bigger risks” than conventional (ribawi) banks.)

Above: Saba Islamic Bank, Djibouti City, Djibouti

On the whole, it would be absurd to see mosques as providing an underground network of dissent.

Some women do complain that their religious headscarf subjects them to discrimination.

However, their principal demand – akin to that of the American civil rights movement – is to be accepted into the mainstream rather than to overthrow the existing order.

Women who wear headscarves are often reluctant to see their own fight in the context of a larger battle for human rights – for example, the right to be educated in Kurdish – presumably because this would recast their demands in a far more radical light.

Indeed one could make a convincing argument that religion, far from presenting a threat to the Republic, has proved to be a safety valve and a force of social integration during an intense period of urbanization.

Above: Atatürk and an old woman in chador

This is reflected in the proliferation of mosques, though their construction is not state-funded.

In 1990, well before commentators suspected Turkey of lurching to the religious right, 1,500 mosques were being built every year – at a far brisker rate than new schools.

For the most part these buildings are replicas of 16th century classical architecture, with slender minarets and cascading domes.

In this sense, they parallel the Gothic style churches that were a feature of the post-Industrial Revolution neighbourhoods of Victorian Britain, evoking the sacrament of history to celebrate not just God but the foundation of community.

Above: Wells Cathedral, England

This has particular resonance in Turkey, where communities were often built in defiance of planning procedure and through the quasi-legal occupation of public land.

Mosques were buildings that authorities would think twice about before tearing down.

It is not just the tenacity of religion that has taken secularists by surprise, but its ability to adapt to modernity and itself become a vehicle of change.

Not so far away from Eskişehir, deep in the Western Taurus Mountains of Turkey’s Mediterranean coast, along ancient Roman roads and shepherds’ tracks, live the ghosts of Christianity’s St. Paul and his followers.

Above: Demirkazik Crest, Aladağ Mountains, Niğde Province, Turkey

Between Perge / Aspendos and Antioch lies a wealth of undiscovered, beautiful countryside, with canyons, waterfalls, cedar forests, limestone peaks soaring to almost 3,000 metres, and the exquisitely blue waters of Lake Eğirdir, Turkey’s 4th largest and most beautiful lake.

Above: Eğirdir Lake

Turkey’s tourist image couldn’t be further away from the setting of the St. Paul Walk with its lakes, mountains and canyons.

Above: St. Paul’s Walk

Most holidaymakers coming to Turkey aim for the Aegean and Mediterranean coastlines or for Istanbul.

Above: The “Turkish Riviera” by the Aegean Sea

Above: Istanbul tram

I am a walker who has always been intrigued by the notion of pilgrimages – where the object is not rest and recreation or to get away from it all – that set out to throw down a challenge to everyday life where nothing matters but the adventure.

Where the journey is far more important than the destination.

Where one follows the advice of Confucius to:

  • Practice the arts of attention and listening
  • Practice renewing yourself every day
  • Practice meandering toward the centre of every place
  • Practice the ritual of reading sacred texts
  • Practice gratitude and the singing of praise

Above: The teaching Confucius (551 – 479 BCE)

pilgrimage is a journey, often into an unknown or foreign place, where a person goes in search of new or expanded meaning about their self, others, nature, or a higher good, through the experience.

It can lead to a personal transformation, after which the pilgrim returns to their daily life.

Above: Flemish pilgrim, David Teniers the Younger (1610 – 1690)

God willing and time and money permitting I would love to walk St. Paul’s Trail or follow St. James’ Way to Santiago de Compostela in Spain or hike the Via Francigena all the way to Rome, or visit the Holy Land.

Above: St. James Way

Above: Santiago de Compostela Cathedral, Spain

Above: Pilgrims to Rome, Fidenza Cathedral, Italy

Above: Church of the Holy Sepulchre, Jerusalem, Israel – The purported site of Christ’s resurrection

Above: Dome of the Rock, Jerusalem – Islam’s first direction of prayer before Mecca

Above: Al-Aqsa Mosque, Jerusalem – Purported site of Muhammad’s ascension to Heaven

Above: Temple Mount, Jerusalem – Purported site of Solomon’s Temple

Above: The Wailing (or Western) Wall, Jerusalem – Purported remains of the Holy Temple of Judaism

Though I am remote from ever being labelled one of Christ’s followers or Jehovah’s Chosen People.

Being a non-Muslim I cannot enter the city of Mecca, but I avidly search for accounts of those who have retraced the steps of Muhammed, who have gone on a Hadj.

And pilgrimages are not limited to Abrahamic religions.

Above: Portrait of the Patriarch Abraham, from whom Judaism, Christianity and Islam originate

Sikhs go to Amritsar, Taoists make the Mazu pilgrimage across Taiwan, Zoroastrians visit the fire temples in Iran, Hindus bathe in holy rivers, and Buddhists travel from Buddha’s birthplace in Nepal to his final resting place in India.

Above: Sikh pilgrim at the Golden Temple, Amritsar, India

Above: Mazu Pilgrim Path, Taiwan

Above: Yazd Atash Behram, Iran (Zoroastrian fire temple)

Above: Hindu pilgrims along the Ganges River, India

Above: World Peace Pagoda, Lumbini, Nepal

We grant a divine meaning to this ordinary Earth and seek the meaning of life beyond our understanding.

I would be content as a heathen to understand how faith fuels the fervor of so many around the globe.

Islam is the largest religion in Turkey according to the state, with 99% of the population being initially registered by the state as Muslim, for anyone whose parents are not of any other officially recognised religion and the remaining 0.1% are Christians or adherents of other officially recognised religions like Judaism.

Due to the nature of this method, the official number of Muslims includes people with no religion, as well as converted people and anyone who is of a different religion from their Muslim parents, but has not applied for a change of their individual records.

(By this definition, technically I am Muslim?)

The records can be changed or even blanked on the request of citizen, by filing an e-government application since May 2020, using a valid electronic signature to sign the electronic application. 

Any change in religion records additionally results in a new ID card being issued.

Any change in religion record also leaves a permanent trail in the census record, however, record of change of religion is not accessible except for the citizen in question, next-of-kin of the citizen in question, the citizenship administration and the courts.

Turkey is officially a secular country with no official religion since the constitutional amendment in 1928 and later strengthened by Atatürk’s reforms and the appliance of laicism (which prohibits government influence in the determination of religion) by the country’s founder and first president Mustafa Kemal Atatürk on 5 February 1937.

Above: Mustafa Kemal Atatürk

However, currently all primary and secondary schools hold mandatory religion classes which mostly focus on the Sunni sect of Islam, though other religions are also covered briefly.

In these classes, children are required to learn prayers and other religious practices which belong specifically to Sunnism.

Above: Muslim denominations

Thus, although Turkey is officially a secular state, the teaching of religious practices in public grade schools has been controversial.

Its application to join the European Union (EU) divided existing members, some of which questioned whether a Muslim country could fit in.

Turkish politicians have accused the country’s EU opponents of favoring a “Christian club“.

Above: European Union flag

Above: (in green) The European Union

Beginning in the 1980s, the role of religion in the state has been a divisive issue, as influential religious factions challenged the complete secularization called for by Kemalism and the observance of Islamic practices experienced a substantial revival.

In the early 2000s, Islamic groups challenged the concept of a secular state with increasing vigor after Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s Islamist-rooted Justice and Development Party (AKP) came into power in 2002.

Above: Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

(Kemalism is sweeping political, social, cultural and religious reforms designed to separate the new Turkish state from its Ottoman predecessor and embrace a Western-style modernized lifestyle, including the establishment of secularism / laicism, state support of the sciences, free education, and many more.

Most of these reforms were first introduced to, and implemented in Turkey during Atatürk’s presidency.)

Above: Flag of the Republican People’s Party, showing the Six Arrows of Kemalism

It has been fervor of faith that has transformed the politics of Turkey since Andrew Finkel’s abovementioned 2012 book was published.

One of the most prominent faith movements existent in 2012 was founded by the charismatic preacher Fetullah Gülen.

Above: Fetullah Gülen, 2016

The movement – now designated a terrorist organization by Turkey, Pakistan and the Gulf States – that bears Gülen’s name managed to prosper less through sermons in the mosque and more through the media, think tanks and NGOs, financial services, commercial enterprises, and even universities.

The Gülen Movement created a huge network of nonreligious private and charter schools in Turkey as well as in over 100 other countries.

These schools were far more emissaries of Turkish culture – a privately financed form of public diplomacy – than centres of Islam.

In this they were the mirror image of elite foreign language high schools (German, French, Italian and English) in Turkey itself and have become vehicles for Turkish commercial penetration into parts of the world once beyond its reach.

The schools provided a high standard of education and were particularly popular in the former Soviet Union because of their discipline and teetotaling teachers.

Preaching, where it existed, was very much an afterschool activity.

Gülen himself advocated an “alternative” modernity that involved a very explicit rejection of the proposition that Islam is incompatible with contemporary life.

His Islam, though culturally conservative, had an emotional appeal as well as a mystic component that made it different from a fundamentalist state religion.

Gülen-associated institutions were active participants in interfaith dialogue.

Above: Fetullah Gülen

In 2012 the size of Gülen’s following was difficult to estimate.

Three million was a frequently cited figure.

Time magazine put the figure as high as 6 million.

The Movement had huge influence.

Zaman, the house newspaper of the Movement, was among Turkey’s largest circulating dailies and actively supported the AK Party government.

Above: Typical front page of Zaman (1986 – 2016)

By contrast, it did not back its predecessor, the Welfare Party, which had a much narrower, anti-Western and Muslim Brotherhood feel.

Above: Flag of the Muslim Brotherhood, whose aim is the establishment of a Sharia-based state

Some saw the Gülen Movement as the Islamic incarnation of Calvinism – a belief system that embodies the spirit of capitalism and legitimizes itself through the worldly success of its adherents.

Above: Jean Cauvin (aka John Calvin) (1509 – 1564)

Others believed that Gülen and those who sheltered under his banner tried to create “sleeper cells” within the bureaucracy and particularly within the police.

That the “Master Teacher” (Hoca Efendi), as Gülen has been respectfully called, has spent more than two decades in exile on an estate in Pennsylvania has only made him a more shadowy and sinister figure.

The suspicion is that he owes his allegiance not to where he grew up but where he eats.

Above: Fetullah Gülen

(Ergenekon was the name given to an alleged clandestine, secular ultra-nationalist organization in Turkey with possible ties to members of the country’s military and security forces. 

The would-be group, named after Ergenekon, a mythical place located in the inaccessible valleys of the Altay Mountains, was accused of terrorism in Turkey.

Ergenekon was by some believed to be part of the “deep state“.

The existence of the “deep state” was affirmed in Turkish opinion after the Susurluk Scandal in 1996.)

(The Susurluk Scandal (Susurluk kazası) was a scandal involving the close relationship among the deep state in Turkey (an alleged group of influential anti-democratic coalitions within the politics of Turkey composed of high-level elements within the intelligence services (domestic and foreign), the Turkish military, security agencies, the judiciary and mafia), the Grey Wolves (a Turkish far right organization and movement commonly described as ultra-nationalistic, Islamic fundamentalist extreme and neo-fascist youth organization which claims to be a cultural and educational foundation) and the Turkish mafia (the general term for criminal organizations based in Turkey and/or composed of (former) Turkish citizens).

Above: Logo of the Grey Wolves

It took place during the peak of the Kurdish-Turkish conflict, in the mid-1990s.

The relationship came into existence after the National Security Council (NSC) posited the need for the marshaling of the state’s resources to combat the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK).

Above: Headquarters of the National Security Council, Ankara, Turkey

The scandal surfaced with a car – truck collision on 3 November 1996, near Susurluk, in the province of Balikesir.

Above: Scene of the Susurluk car crash

The victims included the deputy chief of the Istanbul Police Department Huseyin Kocadağ, Member of Parliament Sedat Bucak, and Abdullah Çatli, the leader of the Grey Wolves and a contract killer for the National Intelligence Organization (Turkey’s equivalent to the CIA)(MİT), who was on Interpol’s red list at the time of his death.

The Susurluk car crash took place on 3 November 1996.

It resulted in the death of three of the passengers: 

  • Abdullah Çatli, a former ultra-rightist militant wanted by police for multiple murders and drug trafficking 
  • Huseyin Kocadağ, a senior police official
  • beauty queen Gonca Uş (Çatlı’s girlfriend)

MP Sedat Bucak escaped with a broken leg and fractured skull.

The peculiar associations of the crash victims and their links with Interior Minister Mehmet Agar led to a number of investigations, including a parliamentary investigation, of what became known as the Susurluk scandal.

Above: Mehmet Ağar

The state had been engaged in an escalating low intensity conflict with the PKK since 1984.

The conflict escalated in the early 1990s.

Towards the end of 1992, a furious debate in the NSC about how to proceed was taking place.

Moderates, like President Turgut Özal and General Eşref Bitlis, favoured a non-military solution.

However, both died in 1993.

Above: Turgut Özal (1927 – 1993)

The death of Bitlis (the General Commander of the Turkish Gendarmerie at the time) in a plane crash remains controversial.

Above: Eşref Bitlis (1933 – 1993)

The same year, the NSC ordered a co-ordinated black operations campaign using special forces. 

Then-Deputy Prime Minister Tansu Çiller tasked the police force, then under the leadership of Mehmet Ağar, with crippling the PKK and assassinating its leader, Abdullah Öcalan.

Above: Tansu Çiller

Above: Abdullah Öcalan

Turkish authorities had claimed that security officers, politicians and other authorities who had been involved in drug trafficking were initially tasked with preventing the Turkish mafia and the PKK from profiting from illegal activities, but that these officials then captured the business and fought over who would control it.

Intelligence expert Mahir Kaynak described the police camp as “pro-European“, and the MİT camp as “pro-American“.

Above: Seal of the Turkish National Intelligence Organization (MIT)

The authorities pocketed billions of dollars in profits from the drug smuggling.

This illegal activity on the state’s part was partly motivated, or at least justified as such, by the tens of billions of dollars in loss of trade with Iraq due to the Gulf War.

Above: Gulf War (1990 – 1991) images

To put this into perspective, the Turkish heroin trade, then worth $50 billion, exceeded the state budget of $48 billion.

(Other sources quote the 1998 budget as $62 billion and the drug market as $70 billion, though only a fraction of this was tapped as commission.)

Above: Black tar heroin

Although Ağar and Çiller resigned after the scandal, no one received any punitive sentences.

Ağar was eventually re-elected to Parliament (as a leader of the True Path Party, DYP), and the sole survivor of the crash, chieftain Sedat Bucak, was released.

Above: Logo of the True Path Party (1983 – 2007)

Some reforms were made:

The intelligence agency was restructured to end infighting.

Some hold that the scandal was made possible by the wresting of control of the MİT away from the Turkish military in 1992.)

Above: Emblem of the Turkish Armed Forces

(Alleged members of Ergenekon had been indicted on charges of plotting to foment unrest, among other things by assassinating intellectuals, politicians, judges, military staff, and religious leaders, with the ultimate goal of toppling the incumbent government.

By April 2011, over 500 people had been taken into custody and nearly 300 formally charged with membership of what prosecutors described as “the Ergenekon terrorist organization“, which they claimed had been responsible for virtually every act of political violence — and controlled every militant group —in Turkey over the last 30 years.

As of 2015 most of the people accused of such crimes were acquitted, forensic experts concluded the documents for supposed plots were fake and some of the executors of trials proved to be linked to the Gülen Movement and were charged with plotting against the Turkish Army.)

The Gülen Movement states that it is based on moral values and advocacy of universal access to education, civil society, tolerance and peace.

The emphasis among participants is to perform “service” (hizmet) as arising from individuals’ personal commitments to righteous imperatives.

Along with hizmet, the movement, which has no official name, is termed the Gülen Movement or cemaat (“congregation“, “community” or “assembly“).

The movement has been characterized as a “moderate blend of Islam“. 

Gülen and the Gülen Movement are technology-friendly, work within current market and commerce structures, and are savvy users of modern communications and public relations.

In 2008, Gülen was described as “the modern face of the Sufi Ottoman tradition“, who reassures his followers, including many members of “Turkey’s aspirational middle class“, that “they can combine the statist-nationalist beliefs of Atatürk’s republic with a traditional but flexible Islamic faith” and “Ottoman traditions that had been caricatured as theocratic by Atatürk and his ‘Kemalist’ heirs“.

Above: Fetullah Gülen

In the early 2000s, the Gülen Movement was seen as keeping a distance from established Islamic political parties.

Sources state that the Gülen Movement is vying to be recognized as the world’s leading Muslim network, one that is more reasonable than many of its rivals.

The movement builds on the activities of Gülen, who has won praise from non-Muslim quarters for his advocacy of science, interfaith dialogue, and multi-party democracy.

It has earned praise as “the world’s most global movement“.

It is impossible to calculate the size of the Gülen Movement” since the movement is not a centralized or formal organization with membership rosters, but rather a set of numerous, loosely organized networks of people inspired by Gülen.

Estimates of the size of the Movement vary, with one source stating that between 200,000 supporters and 4 million people are influenced by Gülen’s ideas (1997 Tempo estimate), and another stating that Gülen has “hundreds of thousands of supporters“.

The membership of the movement consists primarily of students, teachers, businessmen, academics, journalists and other professionals. 

Its members have founded schools, universities, an employers’ association, charities, real estate trusts, student organizations, radio and television stations, and newspapers.

The movement’s structure has been described as a flexible organizational network. 

Movement schools and businesses organize locally and link themselves into informal networks. 

Akin to Turkey’s Sufi tariqas (lay religious orders), Movement schools were banned in Turkey in 1925.

The Movement skirted Kemalist Turkey’s prohibitions against assembling in non-state sponsored religious meetings.

(As a young man, future President of Turkey Recep Tayyip Erdoğan belonged to the Naqshbandi tariqa, then technically banned in Turkey.)

Above: An election campaign poster featuring Erdoğan: “Istanbul is Ready, Target 2023“, Taksim Square, Istanbul

Each local Gülen movement school and community has a person designated its “informal” (in the sense of not being Turkish state-sponsored) prayer leader (imam).

In the Gülen Movement, this individual is a layman who serves for a stint within this voluntary position.

His identity is kept confidential, generally only purposely made known to those with close connections to those participating in decision-making and coordinating councils within the local group.

Above a grouping of such “secret” (not-publicly-acknowledged) imams is another such volunteer leader.

This relationship tree continues on up the ladder to the nation-level imam and to individuals who consult with Gülen himself.

(These individuals closest to Gülen, having degrees from theology schools, are offhandedly referred to within the movement as mullahs.)

Gülen’s position is analogous to that of a shaykh (master) of a Sufi tariqa.

Unlike with traditional tariqas, no one makes pledges of any sort, upon joining the Gülen Movement.

A person becomes a Movement participant simply by working with others to promote and effect the Movement’s objectives of education and service.

The Gülen Movement works within the given structures of modern secular states.

It encourages affiliated members to maximize the opportunities those countries afford rather than engaging in subversive activities.

In the words of Gülen himself, it promotes “an Ottoman Empire of the mind“.

Detractors of the Movement “have labeled Gülen community members as secretive missionaries, while those in the Movement and sympathetic observers class it as a civil society organization“.

Critics have complained that members of the Gülen movement are overly compliant to the directions from its leaders.

Gülen’s Movement “is generally perceived by its critics as a religio-political cult“.

Above: Fetullah Gülen

The Guardian editorial board described the Movement in 2013 as having “some of the characteristics of a cult or of an Islamic Opus Dei“.

(Opus Dei is an organization within the Catholic Church.)

Above: Opus Dei logo – “A cross embracing the world

Scholars such as Simon Robinson disagree with the characterization, writing that although “there is no doubt that Gülen remains a charismatic leader and that members of the movement hold him in the highest respect“, the Movement “differs markedly from a cult in several ways“, with Gülen stressing “the primacy of the scriptures” and “the imperative of service” and consistently avoiding “attempts to institutionalize power, to perceive him as the source of all truth, or to view him as taking responsibility for the Movement“.

Zeki Saritoprak says that the view of Gülen as “a cult leader or a man with ambitions” is mistaken, and contends that Gülen should be viewed in the context of a long line of Sufi masters who have long been a centre of attention “for their admirers and followers, both historically and currently“.

Above: Zeki Sartoprak

Beginning in 2008, the Dutch government investigated the Movement’s activities in the Netherlands in response to questions from Parliament.

The first two investigations concluded that the movement did not form a breeding ground for radicalism and found no indications that the movement worked against integration or that it was involved in terrorism or religious radicalization.

A further academic study sketched a portrait of a socially conservative, inwardly directed movement with an opaque organizational structure, but said that its members tend to be highly successful in society and thus form no threat to integration.

Above: Flag of the Netherlands

Hizmet-affiliated foundations and businesses were estimated as worth $20-to-$50 billion in 2015.

Fethullah Gülen’s and the Gülen Movement’s views and practices have been discussed in international conferences.

In October 2007 in London a conference was sponsored by the University of Birmingham, the Dialogue Society, the Irish School of Ecumenics, Leeds Metropolitan University, the London Middle East Institute, the Middle East Institute and the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London.

Above: London, England

The Niagara Foundation of Chicago, together with several academic institutions, organized “The Gülen Movement: Paradigms, Projects and Aspirations” conference, which was held at the University of Chicago on 11–13 November 2010.

Above: Logo of the University of Chicago

In 2017 the German magazine Der Spiegel called the Movement a “secretive and dangerous cult” while calling Gülen a suspicious individual, saying:

The movement calls itself a tolerant service movement, while those who have left the movement call it a secretive Islamist organization with Fethullah Gülen as its leader“.

The article said pupils attending the “cult” schools in Germany were under immense pressure from their abis (tutors) telling them which books to read, which movies to watch, which friends to meet and whether to see their families or not, while the abis were keeping a protocol of all those staying in the cult’s dormitories.

Der Spiegel also criticized the movement regarding its activities towards freedom of the press.

Arguing, despite Gülen emphasizing how much he cares of the freedom of the press in interviews, the Movement launched a campaign towards the newspaper in 2012 after an article was written regarding the “cult“.

During which 2,000 readers sent by the cult wrote letters of complaint to the Press Council.

All of which were rejected by the Council. 

Der Spiegel said the Movement distorted events and threatened those who spoke against it and accused Der Spiegel of having ties to the Turkish mafia.

Above: Logo of Der Spiegel (The Mirror)

Gareth Jenkins of the Sunday Times said, despite portraying itself as a peaceful educational movement, the Gülen organization never hesitates using anti-democratic and anti-liberal methods.

The Süddeutsche Zeitung called the organization as “more dangerous than the Illuminati” and “not transparent as opposed to the claims“, and reported that the organization tried to reorganize in the Swabia region of Germany.

(Illuminati is a name given to several groups, both real and fictitious whose goals were to oppose superstition, obscurantism, religious influence over public life, and abuses of state power.

Historically, the name usually refers to the Bavarian Illuminati, an Enlightenment-era secret society founded on 1 May 1776 in Bavaria, today part of Germany.

The order of the day“, they wrote in their general statutes, “is to put an end to the machinations of the purveyors of injustice, to control them without dominating them.”

Above: Adam Weishaupt (1748–1830), founder of the Illuminati

The Illuminati — along with Freemasonry and other secret societies — were outlawed with the encouragement of the Catholic Church.

The group was generally vilified by conservative and religious critics who claimed that the Illuminati continued underground and were responsible for the French Revolution.

Many influential intellectuals and progressive politicians counted themselves as members.

It attracted literary men.

Above: Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749 – 1832), a member of the Illuminati

Illuminati” has referred to various organisations which have claimed, or have been claimed to be, connected to the original Bavarian Illuminati or similar secret societies, though these links have been unsubstantiated.

These organisations have often been alleged to conspire to control world affairs, by masterminding events and planting agents in government and corporations, in order to gain political power and influence and to establish a New World Order.

Central to some of the more widely known and elaborate conspiracy theories, the Illuminati have been depicted as lurking in the shadows and pulling the strings and levers of power in dozens of novels, films, television shows, comics, video games, and music videos.)

On 9 November 2005, a bookstore was bombed in Şemdinli.

The Şemdinli incident occurred on 9 November 2005 when a bookshop in Şemdinli, Hakkari Province, Turkey was attacked with grenades.

One person died and several were injured in the attack on the Umut bookshop.

The attack was carried out by Turkish Gendarmerie personnel, who were caught in the act by local residents.

The men are said to have worked for the Gendarmerie’s JITEM intelligence unit.

Two hand grenades were thrown, and a further two retrieved from the car of Kaya and İldeniz, which was registered to the local Gendarmerie.

Above: Emblem of the Turkish Gendarmerie

In 2010 grenades with the same serial number were found in a house in Erzincan as part of the Ergenekon investigation.

The incident has been compared with the Susurluk scandal for the light it casts on the Turkish “deep state“.

Above: Aftermath of the 9 November 2005 bookstore bombing

The prosecutor of the case, Ferhat Sarıkaya, prepared a criminal indictment in which Turkey’s Commander of Land Forces Yasar Büyükanit was accused of forming a gang and plotting the bombing.

A decade later, prosecutor Sarıkaya confessed that he was ordered by Gülenists to include General Yaşar Büyükanıt into the criminal indictment, in order to prevent his promotion in the army (Chief of General Staff) and to ease the grip on Gülenist structures within the army.

Above: Yaşar Büyükanıt (1940 – 2019)

The prominent Turkish – Armenian journalist Hrant Dink was assassinated in Istanbul on 19 January 2007.

Dink was a newspaper editor who had written and spoken about the Armenian genocide, and was well known for his efforts for reconciliation between Turks and Armenians and his advocacy of human and minority rights in Turkey.

At the time of his death, he was on trial for violating Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code and “denigrating Turkishness“.

Above: Hrant Dink

Above: Hrant Dink was assassinated in Istanbul around 12:00 GMT on 19 January 2007, as he returned to the offices of Agos.

His murder sparked both massive national protests in Turkey itself as well as widespread international outrage.

Above: A panorama from Halaskargazi Boulevard in the Sisli district of Istanbul.
One hundred thousand mourners marched in Dink’s funeral, protesting his assassination.

Hakan Bakırcıoglu, one of Hrant Dink’s lawyers, said in an interview with Deutsche Welle that the underaged perpetrator, Ogün Samast, had help from third parties, including people connected to the Istanbul and Trabzon police forces.

Four prosecutors in the trial have been dismissed from their posts due to their ties with the Movement, and for failing to make progress with the case.

Furthermore, police commissioners Ramazan Akyürek and Ali Fuat Yılmazer were accused of not sharing their foreknowledge of the attack with the prosecutors, gendarmarie, or the intelligence services despite being briefed of a planned assassination several times.

A Turkish court also said that 18 suspects in the case, among them 13 government officials were using the application ByLock on their phones, which the Turkish government claims are the communication tool of Gülen movement followers.

According to investigative journalist Nedim Şener, the Gülen movement used the assassination of Hrant Dink, the assassination of priest Andrea Santoro, the Zirve Publishing House murders, as well as other events, to create an atmosphere and illusion of a clandestine Kemalist ultra-nationalist organization holding responsible for these misdeeds.

Above: Nedim Şener

(Andrea Santoro (1945 – 2006) was a Roman Catholic priest in Turkey, murdered in the Santa Maria Church in Trabzon where he served as a member of the Catholic Church’s Fidei Donum missionary program. 

He was shot dead from behind while kneeling in prayer in the church.

The motive of the attack is not known.)

Above: Andrea Santoro (1945 – 2006)

(The Zirve Publishing House murders, called the missionary massacres by Turkish media, took place on 18 April 2007, in Zirve Publishing House, Malatya, Turkey.

Three employees of the Bible publishing house were attacked, tortured, and murdered by five Muslim assailants.

Two of the victims, Necati Aydın (36) and Uğur Yüksel (32) were Turkish converts from Islam.

The third man, Tilmann Geske (45) was a German citizen.

Necati Aydın was an actor who played the role of Jesus Christ in a theatre production that the TURK-7 network aired over the Easter holidays.

Aydın is survived by his wife, Şemse, and a son and daughter, both pre-school age.

Geske is survived by his wife Susanne and three children aged 8 to 13.

Yüksel was engaged.

Necati Aydin was a graduate of the Martin Bucer Seminary, whose president Thomas Schirrmacher said he simply cried when he learned of the deaths.)

With the start of the Ergenekon trials, this alleged Kemalist organization was called an “Ergenekon terrorist organization“.

The Gülenist media were instrumental in shaping public opinion during these operations.

In these court cases, military officials, parliamentarians and journalists were accused of plotting a violent coup to oust the government.

It later turned out that these cases were based on fabricated evidence, and that most such fabrications were produced by the Gülenists in the police.

In 2011, Nedim Şener was accused in the Ergenekon trials of being a member of Ergenekon and subsequently was arrested and held in pre-trial detention.

In 2010, the exam questions and answer keys of the Public Personnel Selection Examination (KPSS) were stolen and handed out to certain Gülenist members.

The members with high scores were placed strategically in the critical state bodies.

Above: Logo of the KPSS test

Members of the Gülen movement inside the intelligence agency were accused of reshaping Turkish politics to a more “workable form” by leaking secretly filmed sex tapes and corruption tapes of both government members and opposition members, with the resignation of main opposition leader Deniz Baykal in 2010 as one of the most notable examples.

Above: Deniz Baykal

(An alleged video-tape showing Baykal in bed with his former secretary, Member of Parliament Nesrin Baytok, was leaked to the media.)

Above: Nesrin Baytok

Politicians with no recorded scandalous behavior are believed to have been killed, like Great Unity Party leader Muhsin Yazicioğlu, who died in a helicopter crash in 2009.

Above: Muhsin Yazicioğlu

(Muhsin Yazıcıoğlu (1954 – 2009) was a Turkish politician and member of the Parliament of Turkey.

He was the leader and founder of the Great Unity Party (BBP), a right-wing, nationalist-Islamist political party.

Above: Logo of the Great Unity Party

Yazıcıoğlu died on 25 March 2009, in a helicopter crash in the southern Turkish province of Kahramanmaras, after a political rally there on the way to the next rally in Yozgat just four days before the local elections.

Above: The helicopter crash site

After the helicopter crash, journalist Ismail Güneş who was one of the passengers, called the Turkish emergency service number 112 and was able to talk to the dispatcher clearly.

He explained how the helicopter fell in a way which made some people believe that the crash was more of an assassination than an accident.

According to Ismail Güneş’s autopsy his chin was broken after the crash, suggesting he wouldn’t have been able to talk to the dispatcher.

Above: Ismail Güneş

Locals and soldiers searched for 48 hours until the bodies were found.

The Turkish magazine Aksiyon published a special file on the blood of the deceased.

It contained carbon monoxide before the helicopter fell.

According to Köksal Akpınar, it was proven that the carbon monoxide values in the blood of pilot Kaya İstekte and journalist İsmail Güneş were much higher when the helicopter was falling.

Above: Aksiyon (Action) logo

There is a tape illustrating Sergeant Aydın Özsıcak dismantling the GPS of the helicopter.

This tape was denied by the then-Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan.

However, after the failed military coup in 2016, President Erdoğan published the video since Aydın Özsıcak was one of the sergeants who tried to overthrow Erdoğan during the coup.

Today, the reason for the accident still remains a mystery.)

Above: (foreground) Aydin Özsicak

Turkish and Russian officials declared the Gülen Movement to be responsible for the assassination of Russian ambassador Andrei Karlov and accused the Movement of aiming to damage Russia-Turkey relations that had been normalizing since the 2016 coup d’état attempt.

Above: Andrei Karlov (1954 – 2016)

(Andrei Karlov was assassinated by Mevlüt Mert Altıntaş, an off-duty Turkish police officer, at an art exhibition in Ankara on the evening of 19 December 2016.

The assassination took place after several days of protests in Turkey over Russian involvement in the Syrian Civil War and the battle over Aleppo.

Karlov, the Russian Ambassador to Turkey, had been invited to deliver a speech at the opening of an exhibition of Turkish photography of the Russian countryside.

The exhibition, “Russia through Turks’ eyes“, was being held at the municipality owned Cagdas Sanat Merkezi Centre for Modern Arts in Ankara’s Cankaya district.

Above: Cagdas Sanat Merkezi Centre for Modern Arts, Ankara

Mevlüt Altıntaş entered the hall using his police identification, leading gallery security and attendees to believe he was one of Karlov’s personal bodyguards.

Karlov had begun his speech when Altıntaş suddenly fired several shots at the Russian ambassador from the back, fatally wounding him and injuring several other people.

Above: Mevlüt Mert Altıntaş

After shooting Karlov, Altıntaş circled the room, smashing pictures that were on display and shouting in Arabic and Turkish:

Allahu Akbar (God is the greatest).

We are the descendants of those who supported the Prophet Muhammad, for jihad.

Do not forget Aleppo, do not forget Syria.

We die in Aleppo, you die here.”

Shortly after, Altıntaş was fatally shot by Turkish security forces.

Karlov was taken to the hospital, but died from his injuries.)

Above: Russian commemorative stamp

Since 2013 the Gülen Movement has been accused by the Turkish government of collaborating with the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK).

In 2014 the Movement reportedly conducted several meeting with the PKK, in parts of Northern Iraq under PKK control.

In 2015, the Turkish government said the movement had leaked the identity of 329 Turkish Gendermarie informants to the PKK, who were then executed.

On 15 April 2016, during the Kurdish-Turkish conflict Gülen movement member Brigadier General Ali Osman Gürcan deliberately sent 17 soldiers to a house that was packed with IEDs (improvised explosive devices), according to the testimony of his companions, which led to the death of a police officer and wounding of eight soldiers.

The house was marked on a map with the code ‘P368‘ for IED’s, which Gürcan erased from the map, leading to a brawl that led to his companions calling him a “traitor“. 

Gürcan later participated in the 2016 Turkish coup d’état attempt under the Peace at Home Council.

He was arrested after the coup’s failure and sentenced to life imprisonment.

Above: Ali Osman Gürcan

(The Council for Peace at Home (Yurtta Sulh Konseyi), alternatively called the Peace Council, claimed to be an executive body that led a coup attempt in Turkey (15-16 July 2016).

The name was made public in a statement read on air during the 15 July 2016 temporary takeover by soldiers of the headquarters of Turkish state broadcaster TRT.

It is the wish and order of the Turkish Armed Forces for this statement to be broadcast on all channels of the Turkish Republic.

The valuable citizens of the Turkish Republic have systematically been subject to constitutional and legal infringements threatening the basic characteristics and vital institutions of the state, while all state institutions including the Turkish Armed Forces have undergone attempts to be redesigned based on ideological motives, rendering them unfit for purpose.

Fundamental rights and freedoms as well as the secular democratic legal structure based on the separation of powers have been abolished by the heedless, misguided and even treacherous President and government officials.

Our state has lost its rightful international reputation and has become a country governed by an autocracy based on fear and where fundamental human rights are overlooked.

The wrong decisions taken by the political elite have resulted in the failure to combat growing terrorism, which has claimed the lives of several innocent citizens and security forces who have been fighting against terror.

The corruption and pilferage within the bureaucracy have reached serious levels, while the judicial system throughout the country has become unfit for purpose.

In these circumstances, the Turkish Armed Forces, that founded and has guarded to this day the Turkish Republic under extraordinary sacrifices, established under the leadership of the great Atatürk, has in order to continue the country’s indivisible unity in the wake of the Peace at Home, Peace in the World ideal, to safeguard the survival of the nation and the state, to eliminate the threats our Republic’s victories face, to eliminate the de facto obstructions to our justice system, to stop corruption that has become a national security threat, to allow efficient operations against all forms of terrorism, to bring forward fundamental and universal human rights to all our citizens regardless of race or ethnicity and to re-establish the constitutionally enshrined values of a secular democratic social and legal state, to regain our nation’s lost international reputation and to establish stronger relations and co-operate for international peace, stability and serenity, taken over administration.

The governance of the State will be undertaken by the established Peace at Home Council.

The Peace at Home Council has taken every action to ensure that it fulfils the obligations set by all international institutions, including the United Nations and NATO.

The government, which has lost all its legitimacy, has been dismissed from office.”

Above: The General Directorate of Police (EGM) bombing on 15 July 2016

The group was supposedly formed within the Turkish Armed Forces clandestinely.

It was declared to be the governing council of Turkey during the coup attempt.

The existence of the Council was firstly announced by Tijen Karaş, a news anchor at the state-owned TRT news channel, allegedly at gunpoint.

Above: Tijen Karaş

The name “Peace at Home Council” is derived from ‘Peace at Home, Peace in the World’, which is a famous quote of Atatürk.

Although it was self-declared as the successor to the incumbent 65th government of Turkey, the citizens taking to the streets failed the coup attempt meant that the Council took neither de facto nor de jure power in the country.

BBC article by Ezgi Başaran said that:

The statement of the junta, that was read on government TV as the coup got under way, bore a strong resemblance to Mustafa Kemal Atatürk’s famous address to the Turkish Youth.

On the other hand, given that these references are too obvious, they may have been intentionally included to insinuate a Kemalist junta rather than a Gülenist one.”

In the aftermath of the coup attempt, commentators on social media alleged that the creation of the council had been staged to invoke greater support for the governing Justice and Development Party (AKP), with some sceptics citing the lack of any solid information on the Council’s actual composition as evidence that the entire ordeal had been faked by the government.

No official statement regarding the composition of the Council was ever given.

According to the state-run Anadolu News Agency, subsequent investigations and allegations pointed to the leader being former Colonel Muharrem Köse, who had been dismissed earlier in 2016 from his role as legal advisor to the Chief of Staff due to his apparent links with Fethullah Gülen.

Above: Muharrem Köse

On 15 July 2016, as reported just before 23:00, military jets were witnessed flying over Ankara, and both the Fatih Sultan Mehmet and Bosphorus Bridges in Istanbul were closed.

Above: Ankara

Above: Fatih Sultan Mehmet Bridge, Istanbul

Above: The Bosphorus Bridge (now called the 15 July Martyrs Bridge), Istanbul

Turkish Prime Minister Binali Yildirim said military action was being “taken outside the chain of command” and it was an “illegal attempt” to seize power by “part of the military“.

He further said that those involved “will pay the highest price“.

Above: Binali Yildirim

Local media also reported tanks in Istanbul’s Atatürk Airport.

Above: Atatürk Airport, Istanbul

It was reported that Internet users within Turkey were blocked from accessing Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube.

Twitter later stated that it had “no reason to think we’ve been fully blocked“. 

Above: Logo of Twitter

Some hostages were taken at military headquarters, including the Turkish Chief of the General Staff Hulusi Akar.

Above: Hulusi Akar

At around 21:00, the coup had invited Salih Zeki Çolak, the commander of the Turkish Land Forces to the military headquarters. When he arrived, he was immediately apprehended.

Above: Salih Zeki Çolak

Abidan Ünal, head of the Turkish Air Force, who had been attending a wedding in Istanbul, was abducted from there by soldiers who descended from a helicopter.

The coup then tried to force Akar to sign the coup declaration, almost strangling him using a belt in the process.

He refused and was then taken to the Akinci Air Base and other commanders at the headquarters.

Above: Abidin Ünal

 

The military also entered the Justice and Development Party’s (AKP) offices in Istanbul and asked people to leave.

Early reports said President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was safe in Marmaris, southwest Turkey, where he had been on holiday.

Above: Marmaris

From around 23:00 to midnight, helicopters bombed the police special forces headquarters and police air force headquarters in Gölbasi, just outside of Ankara.

The attacks left 42 dead and 43 injured. 

Above: General Directorate of Security logo

Türksat headquarters in Gölbaşı was also attacked, killing two security personnel.

At around 23:50, soldiers occupied Taksim Square in central Istanbul.

Above: Taksim Square, Istanbul, 15 July 2016

At 00:02, it was reported by Reuters that soldiers were inside the buildings of the state broadcaster, the Turkish Radio and Television Corporation (TRT), in Ankara.

During the coup attempt, soldiers forced anchor Tijen Karaş to read out a statement saying that “the democratic and secular rule of law has been eroded by the current government” and that Turkey was now led by the Peace at Home Council who would “ensure the safety of the population“. 

The statement read in part:

Turkish Armed Forces have completely taken over the administration of the country to reinstate constitutional order, human rights and freedoms, the rule of law and general security that was damaged.

All international agreements are still valid.

We hope that all of our good relationships with all countries will continue.

The plotters said they had “done so to preserve democratic order, and that the rule of law must remain a priority“.

The statement also ordered temporary martial rule, and said a new constitution would be prepared “as soon as possible“.

TRT was then taken off air.

Above: Tijen Karaş

Reuters reported on 15 July that an EU source described the coup as “well orchestrated” and predicted that “given the scale of the operation, it is difficult to imagine they will stop short of prevailing.”

Another EU diplomat said that the Turkish ambassador in his capital was shocked and “taking it very seriously”.

Above: Member states of the European Union

The Turkish Presidential office said President Erdoğan was on holiday inside Turkey and safe and condemned the coup attempt to attack democracy.

A presidential source also said Erdoğan and his government were still in power.

The first messages from Erdoğan were transmitted at around 00:23. 

At about 01:00, Erdoğan did a FaceTime interview with CNN Türk, in which he called upon his supporters to take to the streets in defiance of the military-imposed curfew, saying:

There is no power higher than the power of the people.

Let them do what they will at public squares and airports.”

Above: Logo of FaceTime

Deputy Prime Minister Numan Kurtulmuş appeared on live television, saying Turkey’s ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) is still in charge of the government.

Above: Numan Kurtulmuş

The mayor of Ankara, Melih Gökçek of the AKP, encouraged people to go out to the city’s streets in defiance, despite a curfew imposed by the military.

Above: Melih Gökçek

Erdoğan’s plane took off from Dalaman Airport near Marmaris at 23:47, but had to wait in the air south of Atatürk for the airport to be secured.

His plane landed at 02:50.

Above: Dalaman Airport

The First Army General Command in Istanbul stated in a news conference that the TSK did not support the coup and the perpetrators represented a tiny faction that were on the verge of being brought under control. 

Above: Logo of the First Army

Istanbul Atäturk Airport was closed.

All flights from the airport were cancelled.

Above: Istanbul Atatürk Airport, 2016 coup

There was an explosion in the TRT broadcasting headquarters and gunfire was reported in Ankara.

Soon after, it was stormed by a crowd of civilians and police, with four soldiers inside reportedly being “neutralized“.

The channel went back on air and Karaş, who had previously announced the coup, said live that she had been held hostage and forced to read the declaration of the coup at gunpoint.

By 01:00, it was reported that the military had pulled its forces from the Atatürk airport and people were coming inside, but by 01:13, it was reported that tanks were inside the airport and gunfire was heard.

Above: Istanbul Atatürk Airport, 2016 coup

Tanks opened fire near the Turkish Parliament Building

The parliamentary building was also hit from the air. 

Above: Parliament Building aftermath of 2016 coup

Injuries were reported among protesters following gunfire on Bosphorus Bridge.

Above: Bosphorous Bridge, 2016 coup

A helicopter belonging to the pro-coup forces was shot down by a Turkish military F-16 fighter jet.

There were also reports of pro-state jets flying over Ankara to “neutralize” helicopters used by those behind the coup.

At 03:08, a military helicopter opened fire on the Turkish parliament.

Above: Parliament Building, aftermath of 2016 coup

At 03:10, Turkish Armed Forces stated on their website that they had complete control over the country.

However, at 03:12, Yıldırım made a statement saying that the situation was under control and that a no-fly zone was declared over Ankara and that military planes that still flew would be shot down.

Above: Command Centre of the Turkish Armed Forces, Ankara

It was reported that the Turkish parliament had been bombed again at 03:23 and 03:33.

A helicopter belonging to the pro-coup forces was also seen flying by it.

Above: Aftermath of Turkish Parliament bombings, 2016 coup

Half an hour following the report of 12 deaths and 2 injuries in the parliament, soldiers entered CNN Türk’s headquarters and forced the studio to go off air.

After an hour of interruption by the pro-coup soldiers, CNN Türk resumed its broadcast.

Later, Ismail Kahraman said a bomb exploded at a corner of the public relations building inside the parliament, with no deaths but several injuries among police officers.

Above: İsmail Kahraman

At around 04:00 two or three helicopters attacked Erdogan’s hotel.

According to eyewitness accounts, ten to fifteen heavily armed men landed and started firing.

In the ensuing conflict, two policemen were killed and eight were injured.

Above: The team, consisting of Turkish SAT Commandos and Combat Search and Rescue (MAK) troops, attacked the hotel where President Erdoğan stayed.

The Doğan News Agency (DHA) reported that in Istanbul several individuals were injured after soldiers fired on a group of people attempting to cross the Bosphorus Bridge in protest of the attempted coup.

The Peace Council was eventually unable to take power after pro-coup forces were defeated and the incumbent AKP government retained control. 

Mass arrests were later made, targeting over 2,000 soldiers, including senior officers and generals.

Speculation emerged that former Turkish Air Force Commander Akin Öztürk had been in charge of the coup attempt.)

Above: Akin Öztürk

After Erdoğan flew into Istanbul, he made a televised speech inside the airport at around 04:00, whilst thousands gathered outside.

He addressed a crowd of supporters in the airport, at about 06:30.

He said:

In Turkey, armed forces are not governing the state or leading the state.

They cannot.

He blamed “those in Pennsylvania” (a reference to Fetullah Gülen, who lives in Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania, and his Hizmet Movement) for the coup attempt.

Erdoğan also said he had plans to “clean up” the army, saying that:

This uprising is a gift from God to us.

Above: President Erdoğan addresses the crowd

State-run Anadolu Agency named former Colonel Muharrem Köse, who in March 2016 was dishonorably discharged for reported association with Gülen, as the suspected leader of the coup. 

However, the Alliance for Shared Values, a non-profit organization associated with Gülen, released a statement reiterating that it condemns any military intervention in domestic politics, and saying Erdoğan’s allegations against the movement were “highly irresponsible“. 

Gülen himself said in a brief statement just before midnight:

As someone who suffered under multiple military coups during the past five decades, it is especially insulting to be accused of having any link to such an attempt.

I categorically deny such accusations.

Above: Fetullah Gülen

Reuters reported that in early hours of 16 July, the coup appeared to have “crumbled” as crowds defied pro-coup military orders and gathered in major squares of Istanbul and Ankara to oppose it. 

Reuters also reported pro-coup soldiers surrendering to the police in Taksim Square, Istanbul.

It was reported that by 05:18, Atatürk Airport had completely been recaptured by the government whilst the police had surrounded the coup inside the Turkish army headquarters, calling for them to surrender.

Between 06:00 and 08:00 a skirmish took place there.

In Akar’s absence, Ümit Dündar, head of the First Army, was appointed Acting Chief of Staff.

In the early hours of the morning of 16 July, soldiers blocking the Bosphorus Bridge surrendered to the police.

According to the government-run Anadolu Agency, this consisted of a group of 50 soldiers.

Some of these soldiers were lynched by civilians despite the police’s efforts, who fired into the air to protect the surrendering soldiers.

Meanwhile, in the headquarters of the Turkish Army, 700 unarmed soldiers surrendered as the police conducted an operation into the building while 150 armed soldiers were kept inside by the police.

The coup in the TRT building in Istanbul surrendered in the early morning as well.

Chief of Staff Akar, held hostage at the Akinci Air Base in Ankara, was also rescued by pro-state forces.

One of the primary reasons that the coup failed was chaos among the plotters’ ranks.

Turkey’s National Intelligence Organization (MİT) head Hakan Fidan discovered the coup plot, and the plotters were forced to execute the coup five hours ahead of schedule.

Above: Hakan Fidan

One of the main organizers, General Semih Terzi, was shot dead by loyalist Sergeant Major Ömer Halisdemir at the onset, demoralizing and disrupting command and control of the rebels.

Above: Semih Terzi (1968 – 2016)

These two incidents resulted in the coup being carried out in an uncoordinated manner. 

The highest ranking staff officers opposed the coup and publicly ordered all personnel to return to their barracks.

Acting outside the military chain of command, the rebels lacked the coordination and resources to achieve their goals.

The conscripted soldiers that the rebels mobilized were uninformed of their mission’s true purpose and became demoralized.

Many surrendered rather than shoot demonstrators.

The commander of the First Army in Istanbul, General Ümit Dündar, personally called Erdoğan to warn him of the plot, persuading him to evacuate his hotel ahead of the plotters, and helped to secure Istanbul for Erdoğan to land.

The MİT also mobilized its anti-aircraft guns, which the plotters were unaware existed, deterring rebel jets and commando teams.

Above: Ümit Dündar

Equally important to the coup’s failure, according to military strategist Edward N. Luttwak, was the inability of the rebels to neutralize Erdoğan and other high ranking government officials, either by killing or detaining them.

Above: Edward Luttwak

A unit of special forces was sent via helicopter to kill or capture the President, but missed because he had been evacuated by his security detail just minutes before.

Once Erdoğan landed at Atatürk Airport (which had been recaptured from the rebels by his supporters), the coup was doomed.

Above: Shoulder badge of the Turkish Special Forces

According to a military source, several rebel F-16s targeted Erdoğan’s presidential jet en route to Istanbul, but they did not fire.

A senior Turkish counter-terrorism official later stated that the jets did not fire because the fighter jet pilots were told by President Erdoğan’s pilot over the radio that the flight of the Gulfstream IV was a Turkish Airlines flight.

Above: An example of a Gulfstream IV

According to Naunihal Singh, author of Seizing Power, the coup attempt also failed because the plotters failed to secure control of the media and shape the narrative.

Successful coups require that the rebels control the mass media. 

This allows even small rebel contingents to portray themselves as fully in control, and their victory as inevitable.

Consequently, they convince the public, along with neutral and even loyalist soldiers, to defect to them or not resist.

The rebels failed to properly broadcast their messages effectively across the media that they controlled.

They failed to capture Türksat, Turkey’s main cable and satellite communications company, and failed to gain control of the country’s television and mobile phone networks.

This allowed Erdoğan to make his Facetime call, and to speak on television.

Other scholars of civil-military relations, like Drew H. Kinney, have said reports like Luttwak and Singh’s miss the point of their own analysis:

Civil resistance thwarted the coup.

Luttwak argues that wayward elements of the Turkish armed forces could not silence Erdoğan.

Singh says that the rebels could not project success because they couldn’t control the message.

Kinney states that neither of these reasons on their own matter, but rather it’s their effect — civil disobedience — that is important.

We might find that “Gülen’s movement might have had nothing to do with the attempted takeover in July, but civilians nevertheless definitely played a role in thwarting the coup,” writes Kinney.

An unhappy civilian populace mobilized to face down the military.

Above: Drew Holland Kinney

Erdoğan wasn’t censored (Luttwak’s point) and was therefore able to use FaceTime to mobilize resistance, which in turn hindered the conspirators’ ability to project success (Singh’s point).

The result is civilian resistance to soldiers, i.e., people power.

The reason Singh, Luttwak and other scholars of civil-military relations miss this is, according to Kinney, because they “usually do not study extra-military reasons for coup failures/successes“, but rather put a premium on “the inner workings of the military operation“.

In short, they blame the military for its failure rather than acknowledge the power of the masses and their successes.

Pro-state forces sent text messages to every Turkish citizen calling for them to protest against the coup attempt.

Throughout the night sela prayers were repeatedly called from mosque minarets across the country to encourage people to resist the coup plotters.

While the sela is usually called from minarets to inform the public of a funeral, they are also traditionally performed to notify of a significant event, in this case “to rally people“.

The coup plotters initiated their operation hours ahead of the planned time when they understood that their plans had been compromised.

Had the coup been launched at its original time, the middle of the night, much of the population would have been asleep.

The streets would have been mostly empty.

Reports have emerged, neither confirmed nor denied by Russia or Turkey that the Russian Main Intelligence Directorate (GRU) intercepted signals on an imminent coup passed on to loyal Turkish operatives.

The intercepted plans revealed several helicopters with commandos were on the way to Marmaris’s coastal resort, where Erdoğan stayed, capturing or killing him.

Pre-warned, Erdoğan left quickly to avoid them.

Above: Emblem of the GRU

Fethullah Gülen, whom President Erdoğan said as one of the principal conspirators, condemned the coup attempt and denied any role in it.

I condemn, in the strongest terms, the attempted military coup in Turkey,” he said in an emailed statement reported by The New York Times.

Government should be won through a process of free and fair elections, not force.

I pray to God for Turkey, Turkish citizens, and all those currently in Turkey that this situation is resolved peacefully and quickly.

As someone who suffered under multiple military coups during the past five decades, it is especially insulting to be accused of having any link to such an attempt.

I categorically deny such accusations.

President Erdoğan asked the United States to extradite Gülen:

I call on you again, after there was a coup attempt.

Extradite this man in Pennsylvania to Turkey!

If we are strategic partners or model partners, do what is necessary.”

Above: Fetullah Gülen

Prime Minister Yildirim has threatened war against any country that would support Gülen.

Above: Binali Yildirim

Turkish Labor Minister Süleyman Soylu said that “America is behind the coup“.

Above: Süleyman Soylu

Regarding the AKP’s statement against Gülen, Secretary of State John Kerry invited the Turkish government “to present us with any legitimate evidence that withstands scrutiny“, before they would accept an extradition request.

Above: John Kerry

On 15 August 2016, former United States diplomat James Jeffrey, who was the US Ambassador to Turkey from 2008 until 2010 made the following remarks:

The Gülen movement has some infiltration at the least in the military that I am aware of.

They of course had extreme infiltration into the police and judiciary earlier.

I saw that when I was in Turkey previously, particularly in the Sledgehammer case, Hakan Fidan case, and the corruption cases in 2013.

Obviously, significant segment of Turkey’s bureaucracy was infiltrated and had their allegiance to a movement.

That of course is absolutely unacceptable and extremely dangerous. It likely led to the coup attempt.

Above: James Jeffrey

Outside Turkey, in Beringen, Belgium, anti-coup protesters attempted to attack a building owned by the pro-Gülen movement group ‘Vuslat‘.

The police brought in a water cannon to keep the attackers at bay.

In news articles it was stated that the police also protected the houses of Gülen supporters.

People advocated on social media to go to Beringen once more, and there was unrest in Heusden-Zolder, elsewhere in Belgium.

Above: The Paalse Poort, gateway on Beringen’s central square

Furthermore, in Somalia the government ordered “the total closure of all activities” of an organization linked to the Gülen movement, and gave its staff seven days to leave the country.

Above: Flag of Somalia

On 2 August 2016, President Erdoğan said Western countries were “supporting terrorism” and the military coup, saying:

I’m calling on the United States:

What kind of strategic partners are we, that you can still host someone whose extradition I have asked for?

Above: Flag of the United States of America

On 31 January 2017, British Minister of State for Europe and the Americas, Alan Duncan said he believed the Gülen movement was responsible for the coup attempt.

Duncan went on saying “the organization which incorporated itself into the state tried to topple the democratic structure in Turkey“.

Above: Alan Duncan

Events surrounding the coup attempt and the purges in its aftermath reflect a complex power struggle between Islamist elites in Turkey.

During the coup attempt, over 300 people were killed and more than 2,100 were injured.

Many government buildings, including the Turkish Parliament and the Presidential Palace, were bombed from the air. 

Above: Presidential Palace

Mass arrests followed, with at least 40,000 detained, including at least 10,000 soldiers and, for reasons that remain unclear, 2,745 judges.

15,000 education staff were also suspended and the licenses of 21,000 teachers working at private institutions were revoked after the government stated they were loyal to Gülen. 

More than 77,000 people have been arrested and over 160,000 fired from their jobs, on reports of connections to Gülen.

Many reactions were against the coup attempt, both domestically and internationally.

The main opposition parties in Turkey condemned the attempt, while several international leaders — such as those of the US, NATO, the EU, and neighboring countries — called for “respect of the democratic institutions in Turkey and its elected officials“.

International organizations expressed themselves against the coup.

The UN Security Council, however, did not denounce the coup after disagreements over the phrasing of a statement.

Above: United Nations Security Council Chamber, UN Headquarters, New York City

Unlike some Middle Eastern governments that supported the coup or others that waited to see the outcome of the coup, Iran initially opposed the coup and advised Erdogan to defeat the coup plotters.

President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said the head of US Central Command General Joseph Votel was “siding with coup plotters“, after Votel criticized the Turkish government for arresting the Pentagon’s contacts in Turkey.

Above: Joseph Votel

In March 2017, Germany’s intelligence chief said Germany was unconvinced by Erdoğan’s statement that Fethullah Gülen was behind the failed coup attempt.

Above: Flag of Germany

The same month, the British Parliament’s Foreign Affairs Select Committee said some Gulenists were involved in the coup d’état attempt but found no hard evidence that Fethullah Gülen masterminded the failed coup and found no evidence to justify the UK designating the Gülen movement as a “terrorist organization“.)

Above: Flag of the United Kingdom

In 2016, the Gülen Movement was designated a terrorist organization.

Above: The “proof” against the Gülen Movement

In 2017, according to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, there was “no evidence to justify the designation of the Gülenists as a terrorist organisation by the UK“.

The same year, Gilles de Kerchove, EU Counter Terrorism Coordinator, said that the EU didn’t see the Gülen movement as a terrorist organisation and that the EU would need “substantive” evidence to change its stance.

Above: Gilles de Kerchove

In 2018, in a conference with Turkish President Erdogan, German Chancellor Angela Merkel said that Germany needed more evidence to classify the Gülen movement as a terrorist organization.

Above: Angela Merkel

According to academic researcher Svante E. Cornell, director of the Central Asia – Caucasus Institute and Silk Road Studies Center:

With only slight exaggeration, the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) as well as the government it has led could be termed a coalition of religious orders.”

The Gülen Movement stayed away from electoral politics, focusing instead on increasing its presence in the state bureaucracy.

The Hizmet Movement’s stated success in this regard would initially make it Erdoğan’s main partner, but also his eventual nemesis.

Above: Svante E. Cornell

From 2002 to 2013, the Gülen movement comprehensively collaborated with the AKP and Erdoğan in obtaining political power in Turkey.

Questions have arisen about the Gülen Movement’s possible involvement in the ongoing Ergenekon investigation, which critics have characterized as “a pretext” by the government “to neutralize dissidents” in Turkey.

Despite Gülen’s and his followers’ statements that the organization is non-political in nature, analysts believed that a number of corruption-related arrests made against allies of Erdoğan reflect a growing political power struggle between Gülen and Erdoğan.

Above: Gülen and Erdoğan

These arrests led to the 2013 corruption scandal in Turkey, which the ruling Justice and Development Party’s supporters (along with Erdoğan himself) and the opposition parties alike have said were choreographed by Gülen after Erdoğan’s government came to the decision early in December 2013 to shut down many of his movement’s private pre-university schools in Turkey.

The Erdoğan government has said that the corruption investigation and comments by Gülen are the long term political agenda of Gülen’s movement to infiltrate security, intelligence, and justice institutions of the Turkish state, a charge almost identical to the charges against Gülen by the Chief Prosecutor of Turkey in his trial in 2000 before Erdoğan’s party had come into power.

Gülen had previously been tried in absentia in 2000, and acquitted of these charges in 2008 under Erdoğan’s AKP government.

Above: Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

The 2013 corruption scandal in Turkey or 17-25 December Corruption and Bribery Operation was a criminal investigation that involved several key people in the Turkish government.

All of the 52 people detained on 17 December were connected in various ways with the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP).

Prosecutors accused 14 people – including Suleyman Aslan, the director of state-owned Halkbank, Iranian businessman Reza Zarrab, and several family members of cabinet ministers – of bribery, corruption, fraud, money laundering and gold smuggling.

At the heart of the scandal was an alleged “gas for gold” scheme with Iran involving Aslan, who had US$4.5 million in cash stored in shoeboxes in his home, and Zarrab, who was involved in about US$9.6 billion of gold trading in 2012.

Both men were arrested.

Above: Suleyman Aslan

Above: Reza Zarrab

The scheme started after Turkish government officials found a loophole in the US sanctions against Iran that allowed them to access Iranian oil and gas.

The Turks exported some US$13 billion of gold to Iran directly, or through the United Arab Emirates (UAE), between March 2012 and July 2013.

In return, the Turks received Iranian natural gas and oil.

Above: Flag of Iran

The transactions were carried out through the Turkish state-owned bank, Halkbank.

In January 2013, the Obama Administration decided to close this loophole but instead of immediately charging Halkbank, the US government allowed its gold trading activities to continue until July 2013, because Turkey was an important ally regarding the American-led intervention in the Syrian Civil War, and the US had been working on a nuclear deal with Iran.

Above: Barrack Obama

In emailed comments to the Wall Street Journal in January 2014, Gülen said that “Turkish people are upset that in the last two years democratic progress is now being reversed“, but he denied being part of a plot to unseat the government.

Later, in January 2014 in an interview with BBC World, Gülen said:

If I were to say anything to people I may say people should vote for those who are respectful to democracy, rule of law, who get on well with people.

Telling or encouraging people to vote for a party would be an insult to peoples’ intellect.

Everybody very clearly sees what is going on.

According to some commentators, Gülen is to Erdoğan what Trotsky was to Stalin.

Above: Leon Trotsky (1879 – 1940)

Above: Joseph Stalin (1878 – 1953)

Ben Cohen of the Jewish News Syndicate wrote:

“Rather like Leon Trotsky, the founder of the Soviet Red Army who was hounded and chased out of the USSR by Joseph Stalin, Gülen has become an all-encompassing explanation for the existential threats, as Erdoğan perceives them, that are currently plaguing Turkey.

Stalin saw the influence of ‘Trotskyite counter-revolutionaries’ everywhere, and brutally purged every element of the Soviet apparatus.

Erdoğan is now doing much the same with the ‘Gülenist terrorists.'”

In March 2011, seven Turkish journalists were arrested, including Ahmet Şik, who had been writing a book, “Imamin Ordusu” (The Imam’s Army), which states that the Gülen movement has infiltrated the country’s security forces.

As Şık was taken into police custody, he shouted:

Whoever touches it the Movement gets burned!

Upon his arrest, drafts of the book were confiscated and its possession was banned.

Şık has also been charged with being part of the stated Ergenekon plot, despite being an investigator of the plot before his arrest.

Above: Ahmet Şık

In a reply, Abdullah Bozkurt, from the Gülen Movement newspaper Today’s Zaman (2007 – 2016), said Ahmet Şık was not being an investigative journalist conducting “independent research“, but was hatching “a plot designed and put into action by the terrorist network itself“.

According to Gareth H. Jenkins, a Senior Fellow of the Central Asia – Caucasus Institute and Silk Road Studies Joint Center at John Hopkins University:

From the outset, the pro-AKP media, particularly the newspapers and television channels run by the Gülen Movement such as Zaman, Today’s Zaman and Samanyolu TV, have vigorously supported the Ergenekon investigation.

This has included the illegal publication of “evidence” collected by the investigators before it has been presented in court, misrepresentations and distortions of the content of the indictments and smear campaigns against both the accused and anyone who questions the conduct of the investigations.

There have long been allegations that not only the media coverage but also the Ergenekon investigation itself is being run by Gülen’s supporters.

In August 2010, Hanefi Avci, a right-wing police chief who had once been sympathetic to the Gülen Movement, published a book in which he alleged that a network of Gülen’s supporters in the police were manipulating judicial processes and fixing internal appointments and promotions.

On 28 September 2010, two days before he was due to give a press conference to present documentary evidence to support his allegations, Avcı was arrested and charged with membership of an extremist leftist organization.

On 14 March 2011, Avcı was also formally charged with being a member of the alleged Ergenekon gang.

Above: Gareth Jenkins

The Gülen movement has also been implicated in what the opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) – and after 2013 also President Erdoğan – have said were illegal court decisions against members of the Turkish military, including many during the Ergenekon investigation.

On 17 December 2013, an investigation into stated corrupt practices by several bureaucrats, ministers, mayors, and family members of the ruling AKP were uncovered, resulting in widespread protests and calls for the resignation of the government led by Prime Minister Erdoğan.

Due to the high level of political influence by the Gülen movement in Turkey, it is rumored to be facilitated by the movement’s influence on the Turkish police force and the judiciary, the investigation was said to be a result of a break in previously friendly relations between the Islamist-rooted government and the Movement.

President Erdoğan and the AKP have targeted the Movement since December 2013.

Immediately after the corruption statements, the government subjugated the judiciary, media and civil society critical of the government’s authoritarian trend in recent years.

After the corruption statements surfaced, Erdoğan labelled it as a “civilian coup” against his government.

Since then, Erdoğan has shuffled, dismissed or jailed hundreds of police officers, judges, prosecutors and journalists in the name of fighting against a “Parallel State” within the Turkish state.

Above: “Proof” of the “Parallel State

On 14 December 2014, Turkish police arrested more than two dozen senior journalists and media executives connected with the Gülen movement on various charges.

A statement by the US State Department cautioned Turkey not to violate its “own democratic foundations” while drawing attention to raids against media outlets “openly critical of the current Turkish government“.

EU Foreign Affairs chief Federica Mogherini and EU Enlargement Commissioner Johannes Hahn said that the arrests went “against European values” and “are incompatible with the freedom of media, which is a core principle of democracy“.

Above: Flag of the European Union

On 20 January 2015, Turkish police launched raids in Ankara and three other cities, detaining some 20 people suspected of illegally eavesdropping on President Erdoğan and other senior officials.

The suspects are linked to Turkey’s telecommunications authority and to its scientific and technological research centre TÜBITAK.

Local media said the move was aimed at the “parallel structure” — the term Erdogan uses to refer to Gülen’s supporters in the judiciary, police and other institutions.

The Turkish government took over the Gülenist Zaman Daily, on 4 March 2016.

Turkish police entered Zaman headquarters by force and fired tear gas at the protesting journalists and civilians.

Hundreds of protestors were injured.

In his efforts to eradicate the Movement within the country the Turkish National Security Council has identified the movement as the “Gülenist Terror Organization” (“Fethullahçı Terör Örgütü“)(FETÖ). 

The government has also been targeting individuals and businessmen who have supported the movement’s organizations and activities.

As aforementioned, in reaction to the 15 July 2016 coup attempt, led by a military faction operating outside the chain of command, the Turkish government quickly stated the coup’s leader to be Gülen.

In following days and weeks, a massive crackdown affected all entities affiliated to the Gülen Movement, from individuals to businesses, newspapers to schools and universities.

Above: Fetullah Gülen

Following the aforementioned assassination of Andrey Karlov, the Turkish government was reportedly investigating the assassin’s links to the “Gülenist Terrorist Organization” (FETÖ).

In a speech, President Erdogan said that the perpetrator was a member of FETÖ.

Above: Monument to Andrey Karlov on Andrey Karlov Street in Demre, Turkey

Among Turkish citizens within Turkey convicted for alleged memberships in the Gülen movement are Turkey’s honorary president of Amnesty International, Taner Kilic, and Amnesty’s Turkish branch, Idil Eser, in July 2020.

As of 2020, Turkey had successfully pressured a number of countries, especially those in Africa and Russia, to extradite over 80 alleged Gülenists to Turkey.

Above: Flag of Russia

In 2019 it was reported that Interpol had denied Turkey’s appeals of the agency’s rejections of Turkey’s red notice requests regarding 464 fugitives, citing Interpol’s legal definition of the 2016 Turkish coup d’état attempt as not terrorism but a failed military putsch.

In 2018, approximately 25,000 Turkish asylum requests were filed by alleged Gülenists in the European Union (a rise of 50% from 2017), with Germany’s share 10,000 and Greece’s about 5,000.

Above: Flag of Greece

Within the US, according to news reports, a number of Gülenists successfully receiving political asylum status are resettled in New Jersey.

Above: Flag of US state New Jersey

Opinions are like noses – everyone has one.

But there is something not quite right in my mind with the government account of events surrounding the Gülen Movement.

I find myself thinking of Niccolò Machiavelli and the notion that a prince must appear to be indispensable if he wishes to maintain power over his people.

Nothing makes a leader more indispensable than the notion that the nation must be defended against enemies, foreign and domestic.

Thus a nation must always have the perception that it has enemies.

Above: Niccolò Machiavelli (1469 – 1527)

But who shall we choose as our enemy?

Nationalism in Turkey is a powerful force.

Turks have no friends but themselves.” is a nationalist adage.

The nationalist tenets – including the depiction of Kurds as a threat to the unitary state, as well as the belief that Western powers have an ulterior strategy to divide and weaken Turkey – have found a comfortable place in the political mainstream.

Above: (in orange) Kurdistan in Turkey

Playing upon fears of an erosion of secularism, the elimination of democratic rule, and the disregard for human rights that the Islamic faith if unchecked might pose against the power of the state – the very same fears the Council cited as reasons for their attempted 2016 coup – the Gülen Movement has proven to be a very convenient target.

I am not suggesting that the entire Gülen body of believers are not culpable of all they have been accused of, but so many of the accusations cast upon them seem more like allegations rather than actual proofs of criminality.

The same arguments that President Erdoğan uses to defend Islam against those who would label all Muslims as terrorists could also apply to the Gülen Movement.

Just as not all Kurds support the violent acts of the PKK, not all who espouse the Movement’s tenets are guilty of the wrongful acts some Gülenists have been accused of.

It remains a constant in human psychology to label all members of a group by the actions of a few within that group.

Certainly many of us find it easy to condemn an entire nation of people for the ill-advised activities of its government.

Perhaps the tenacity of the Gülen Movement to adapt Islam to modernity, to make the faith of the Prophet a vehicle for social change, has left the powerful of Ankara nervous about the maintenance of their control over the hearts and minds of the Turkish people.

Demarginalize and denigrate the Movement and thus remove its potential to usurp power is the apparent strategy.

The need to diminish divinity and dominate the desires of faith in the name of preserving power seems to be the theme here in Turkey.

Ankara will tolerate religious expression unless it is the expression of dissent.

The power of belief is powerful if harnessed, channeled, controlled, monitored.

But all the edicts from all the governments in the world will never prevent humanity from seeking wisdom and comfort in a faith, regardless of whether religion is sometimes contrary to reason.

All Ankara can do is persuade people that some of the religious are not as good as they claim to be.

Above: Erdoğan vs Gülen

The opposite holds true in Europe.

Above: St. Gallen, Switzerland

A word first on religion in Switzerland, where, through marriage, I maintain a second residency.

Religion in Switzerland is predominantly Christianity, which, according to the national survey of the Swiss Federal Statistical Office in 2020 was adhered to by 61.2% of the Swiss people, of whom 33.8% were Catholics, 21.8% were Swiss Protestants, and 5.6% were followers of other Christian denominations.

Above: Tower of the Swiss Federal Statistical Office in Neuchâtel

The proportion of Christians has declined significantly since 1980, when they constituted about 94% of the population.

During the same time span, irreligious Swiss have grown from about 4% to 31% of the population, and people professing non-Christian religions have grown from about 1% to 7% of the population.

In 2020, according to church registers, 35.2% of the population were registered members of the country’s Catholic Church, while 23.3% were registered members of the Protestant Church of Switzerland.

Above: Typical large clocks characterising the towers of Swiss Protestant churches: here St. Peter and Fraumünster, Zürich.

Christianity was adopted by the Gaulish (mostly Helvetians) and Germanic (mostly Alemans) ancestors of the modern Swiss respectively between the 4th and 5th century late Roman domination and between the 6th and 7th century Frankish domination, abandoning their indigenous paganisms.

The Old Swiss Confederacy, which began to emerge in the 13th century, remained entirely Catholic until the 16th century, when it became one of the centres of the Protestant Reformation as a majority of the Swiss joined the Protestant movement of Calvinism.

Above: Flag of the Old Swiss Confederacy (1300 – 1798)

Conflicts, and even civil wars, between Protestants and Catholics persisted until the Sonderbund War of 1847, after which freedom of conscience was established by law — only for Christians. 

Legal discrimination against Jews and some restrictions against the Catholic Church persisted until the end of the 20th century. 

In the early 20th century, Switzerland had an absolute majority of Protestants (about 60%) and a large population of Catholics (about 40%).

Since the late 20th century and throughout the 21st century, the religious composition of the country has changed significantly, with a rise of the irreligious population, a sharp decline of Protestantism to about two tenths of the population, and a less sharp decline of Catholicism to about three tenths of the population.

Switzerland has no state religion, though most of its cantons (except for Geneva and Neuchâtel) recognise official churches (Landeskirchen), in all cases Catholic and Swiss Protestant, and in some cantons also the Old Catholic Church and Jewish congregations.

These churches are financed by taxation of their adherents.

In other words, taxpayer funded, albeit voluntarily.

A person can declare oneself to be irreligious and forego this tax payment.

Islam is the second largest religion in Switzerland after Christianity, adhered to by 5.4% of the population in 2020.

Swiss Muslims are mostly of foreign origin (mostly of Arab ancestry in the Gallo-Romance (French/Italian) regions, and mostly of Balkan, Turkish and Iranian ancestry in the Germanic regions), although there is an increasing number of native Swiss converts.

Above: Mosque, Wil, Canton St. Gallen, Switzerland

Religious Jews represented 0.2% of the Swiss population in 2020.

Above: Jewish synagogue, La Chaux de Fonds, Canton Neuchâtel, Switzerland

Other religions present in the country include Hinduism and Buddhism, practised by both local Swiss who have nurtured interest in Eastern doctrines and by immigrants from Asia.

Above: Interior of Sri Sivasubrahmaniar Hindu Temple, Adliswil, Canton Zürich, Switzerland

Above: Der Wat Srinagarindravararam Thai Buddhist Temple, Gretzenbach, Canton Solothurn, Switzerland

There is a Taoist temple, Ming Shan (“Mountain of Light“), located in Bullet, Vaud, and built according to the rules of feng shui.

It is the headquarters of the Swiss Taoist Association and the main centre in Europe of the Taoist tradition of Wujimen (“Gate of Infinity“), which originated in the Min Mountains of Sichuan, China.

Above: Ming Shang Taoist Temple, Bullet, Canton Vaud, Switzerland

In the country there are also various new religious movements, among which one of the most influential has been the theosophy-derived anthroposophy.

Above: Logo for the Theosophical Society

(Theosophy is a commitment “to form a nucleus of the Universal Brotherhood of Humanity without distinction of race, creed, sex, caste or colour“.

Anthroposophy is a movement that postulates the existence of an objective, intellectually comprehensible spiritual world, accessible to human experience.

Followers of anthroposophy aim to engage in spiritual discovery through a mode of thought independent of sensory experience.

They also aim to present their ideas in a manner verifiable by rational discourse and in studying the spiritual world seek comparable precision and clarity to that obtained by scientists investigating the physical world.)

Above: Goetheanum, Dornach, Canton Solothurn, Switzerland

The Anthroposophical Society was established by the Austrian occultist Rudolf Steiner in the 1920s and 1930s in Dornach, Solothurn.

Above: Rudolf Steiner (1861 – 1925)

Some observers have identified persisting discrimination against Jews and Muslims in Switzerland.

While cases of harassment have mostly been verbal, after 2016 there were a few reports of physical assault against Jews.

Muslim cemeteries were targets of vandalism.

In the November 2009 referendum, 57.5% of Swiss voters approved a popular initiative which prohibited the construction of minarets as part of Swiss Islamic mosques (though the four existing minarets of mosques in Zürich, Geneva, Winterthur and Wangen bei Olten were not affected retroactively and have remained in place).

Above: Mahmud Mosque, Zürich

This referendum originates from action on 1 May 2007, when a group of right of centre politicians, mainly from the Swiss People’s Party (SVP) (the ruling party) and the Federal Democratic Union (EDU), the Egerkinger Komittee (“Egerkingen Committee“) launched a federal popular initiative that sought a constitutional ban on minarets.

Above: Logo of the SVP

The minaret at the mosque of the local Turkish cultural association in Wangen bei Olten was the initial motivation for the initiative.

The association applied for a construction permit to erect a 6-metre-high minaret on the roof of its Islamic community centre.

The project faced opposition from surrounding residents, who had formed a group to prevent the tower’s erection.

The Turkish association claimed that the building authorities improperly and arbitrarily delayed its building application.

They also believed that the members of the local opposition group were motivated by religious bias.

The Communal Building and Planning Commission rejected the association’s application.

The applicants appealed to the Building and Justice Department, which reverted the decision and remanded.

As a consequence of that decision, local residents and the commune of Wangen brought the case before the Administrative Court of the Canton of Solothurn, but failed with their claims.

On appeal the Federal Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the lower court.

The 6-metre / 20 foot -high minaret was erected in July 2009.

Above: Mosque, Wangen bei Olten, Canton Solothurn, Switzerland

The Committee opined that the interests of residents, who are disturbed by specific kinds of religious land uses, are to be taken seriously.

Moreover, it argued that Swiss residents should be able to block unwanted and unusual projects such as the erection of Islamic minarets.

The Committee alleged that:

The construction of a minaret has no religious meaning.

Neither in the Qu’ran nor in any other holy scripture of Islam is the minaret expressly mentioned at any point.

The minaret is far more a symbol of a claim of religious-political power.”

Above: Old mill, Egerkingen, Canton Solothurn, Switzerland

The initiators justified their point of view by quoting parts of a speech in 1997 by Recep Tayyip Erdogan (later Prime Minister and President of Turkey), which stated:

Mosques are our barracks, domes our helmets, minarets our bayonets, believers our soldiers.

This holy army guards my religion.”

Ulrich Schluer, one of the Egerkinger Committee’s most prominent spokesmen, stated on that point:

A minaret has nothing to do with religion:

It just symbolises a place where Islamic law is established.

Above: Ulrich Schlüer

The Committee’s campaign featured posters featuring a drawing of a Muslim woman in an abaya and niqab, next to a number of minarets on a Swiss flag pictured in a way “reminiscent of missiles“.

Above: “Stop“, “Yes to the minaret ban“.

The SVP also published a similar poster, with the minarets protruding through the Swiss flag.

A few days before the election, campaigners drove a vehicle near Geneva Mosque in the Le Petit-Saconnex quarter imitating the adhan, the Islamic call to ritual prayer (salat) using loudspeakers.

Above: “Censorship, one more reason to say yes to the minaret ban“.

The British newspaper The Times cited support of the minaret ban from “radical feminists” who opposed the oppression of women in Islamic societies.

Among those named were the notable Dutch feminist and former politician Ayaan Hirso Ali, who gave her support to the ban with an article entitled “Swiss ban on minarets was a vote for tolerance and inclusion“.

Above: Ayaan Hirsi Ali

The Times further reported that in pre-election polling, Swiss women supported the ban by a greater percentage than Swiss men.

Above: Flag of Switzerland

The traditionalist Society of St Pius X (SSPX), which has its headquarters at Ecône in Switzerland, supported the ban on minarets, denouncing opposition to the ban by some Catholic bishops:

The confusion is maintained by certain Vatican II Council authorities between tolerating a person, whatever his religion, and tolerating an ideology that is incompatible with Christian tradition.”

It explained its support of the ban:

The Islamic doctrine cannot be accepted when you know what it is all about.

How can one expect to condone the propagation of an ideology that encourages husbands to beat their wives, the “believer” to murder the “infidel”, a justice that uses body mutilation as punishment, and pushes to reject Jews and Christians?

Above: Logo of the Society of St. Pius X

On 28 August 2008 the Swiss Federal Council opposed a building ban on minarets.

It said that the popular initiative against their construction had been submitted in accordance with the applicable regulations, but infringed guaranteed international human rights and contradicted the core values of the Swiss Federal Constitution.

It believed a ban would endanger peace between religions and would not help to prevent the spread of fundamentalist Islamic beliefs.

In its opinion, the Federal Council therefore recommended the Swiss people to reject the initiative.

Above: Logo of the Swiss Confederation

On 24 October 2008 the Federal Commission against Racism criticized the initiative, claiming that it defamed Muslims and violated religious freedom, which was protected by fundamental human rights and the ban on discrimination.

The Swiss government recommended that the proposed amendment be rejected as inconsistent with the basic principles of the Constitution.

However, after the results were tabulated, the government immediately announced that the ban was in effect.

Above: Results of the Minaret Initiative, 2009

The Society for Minorities in Switzerland called for freedom and equality and started an Internet-based campaign in order to gather as many symbolic signatures as possible against a possible minaret ban.

Amnesty International warned the minaret ban aimed to exploit fears of Muslims and encourage xenophobia for political gains.

This initiative claims to be a defense against rampant Islamification of Switzerland.”, Daniel Bolomey, the head of Amnesty’s Swiss office, said in a statement cited by Agence France-Presse (AFP). “But it seeks to discredit Muslims and defames them, pure and simple.”

Economie Suisse considered that an absolute construction ban would hit Swiss foreign interests negatively, claiming that merely the launch of the initiative had caused turmoil in the Islamic world.

The Swiss-based Unser Recht (“Our Law“) association published a number of articles against the minaret ban.

In autumn 2009, the Swiss Journal of Religious Freedom launched a public campaign for religious harmony, security, and justice in Switzerland, and distributed several thousand stickers in the streets of Zürich in support of the right to religious freedom.

Roman Catholic bishops opposed a minaret ban.

A statement from the Swiss Bishops Conference said that a ban would hinder interreligious dialogue and that the construction and operation of minarets were already regulated by Swiss building codes.

The statement added that:

Our request for the initiative to be rejected is based on our Christian values and the democratic principles in our country.

The official journal of the Roman Catholic Church in Switzerland published a series of articles on the minaret controversy.

Above: Stiftskirche St. Gallen and Othmar, St. Gallen

The Federation of Swiss Protestant Churches held that the federal popular initiative was not about minarets, but was rather an expression of the initiators’ concern and fear of Islam.

It viewed a minaret ban as a wrong approach to express such objections.

Above: Logo of the Federation of Swiss Protestant Churches

The Swiss Federation of Jewish Communities was also against any ban on building minarets.

Dr Herbert Winter, the president of the Federation, said in 2009:

As Jews we have our own experience.

For centuries we were excluded:

We were not allowed to construct synagogues or cupola roofs.

We do not want that kind of exclusion repeated.

Above: Logo of the Swiss Federation of Jewish Communities

Other religious organisations described the idea of a complete minaret ban as lamentable:

  • the Association of Evangelical Free Churches

Above: Logo of the Swiss Association of Evangelical Free Churches

  • the Swiss Evangelical Alliance

  • the Old Catholic Church in Switzerland

Above: Jesuit Church, Luzern

  • the Covenant of Swiss Baptists

  • the Salvation Army

  • the Federation of Evangelical Lutheran Churches in Switzerland

Above: Worship service for the 500th anniversary of the Reformation and 50 years of the Federation of Lutheran Churches in Switzerland and the Principality of Liechtenstein

  • the Orthodox Diocese of the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople

Above: Coat of Arms of the Ecumenical Patriarchate Constantinople

  • the Serbian Orthodox Church in Switzerland

Above: Official coat of arms of Serbian Orthodox Church

  • the Anglican Church in Switzerland

Above: Canterbury Cathedral, England

Marcel Stüssi argued that any ban would be incompatible with articles of international law, to which Switzerland was a signatory.

In any case, cantonal zoning laws already prohibited the construction of buildings that did not match their surroundings.

Right-wing initiatives like the minaret one can misuse the system,” said Stüssi.

He called the initiative “obsolete and unnecessary“, but added that the public discourse on the issue could put Switzerland in a positive light, at least for the majority who at that point opposed a ban.

In July 2008, before the popular initiative, he argued that:

Crisis always creates an opportunity.

A popular vote against a proposed ban would be the highest declaration for the recognition of the Swiss Muslim community.”

It would also be an expressed statement that anybody is equally subject to the law and to the political process,” Stüssi said in an interview with World Radio Switzerland.

Above: Marcel Stüssi, Faculty of Law, University of Luzern

Heinrich Koller stated that:

Switzerland must abide by international law because both systems together form a unity.”

Above: Heinrich Koller, University of Basel

Giusep Nay stated that any state action must be in accordance with fundamental material justice, and applied not only to interpretations of applicable law but also to new law.

Above: Giusep Nay, former President of the Swiss Supreme Court

Erwin Tanner saw the initiative as breaching not only the constitutionally entrenched right to religious freedom, but also the rights to freedom of expression, enjoyment of property, and equality.

Above: Erwin Tanner, director of Missio Switzerland

The editorial board of the Revue de Droit Suisse (Swiss Law Review) called for invalidation of the initiative as “it appears that the material content of popular initiatives is subject to ill-considered draftsmanship because the drafters are affected by particular emotions that merely last for snatches.”

Sami Aldeeb positioned himself for the ban on the erection of minarets in Switzerland, since in his opinion the Constitution allows prayer, but not shouting.

Above: Swiss Palestinian lawyer Sami Aldeeb

An independent study carried out by political scientists Markus Freitag (University of Konstanz), Thomas Milic and Adrian Vatter (University of Bern) noted a good level of knowledge among voters.

Contrary to what had been previously thought, the surveys before the referendum did not influence voters, as it is hard to do so with people who are accustomed to them.

Those who voted did so according to their political convictions, and by taking into account the different arguments.

The study also attributed the result to the fact that supporters of the ban overwhelmingly turned out to vote in the referendum.

In March 2010, the Geneva-based UN Human Rights Council (UNHRC) narrowly passed a resolution condemning “defamation of religion“, which included reference to “Islamophobic” bans on building new minarets on mosques.

Above: Logo for the United Nations Human Rights Council

The resolution was proposed by the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC).

OIC representative Babacar Ba said that the resolution was a “way to reaffirm once again our condemnation of the decision to ban construction of minarets in Switzerland.”

Above: Logo of the OIC

The resolution was opposed, mostly by Western nations, but it gained a majority due to the votes of Muslim nations, in addition to the support of other countries such as Cuba and China.

Eight states abstained.

Above: Flag of the United Nations

US Ambassador Eileen Donahoe criticized the resolution as an “instrument of division” and an “ineffective way to address” concerns about discrimination.

Above: Ambassador Eileen Donahue

The ban was also mentioned in the UNHRC special rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance in his 2010 report to the UN General Assembly.

Above: UN General Assembly Hall, UN Headquarters, New York City

French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner condemned the ban, calling it “an expression of intolerance“, and said it amounted to “religious oppression“, hoping Switzerland would reverse its decision.

Above: Bernard Kouchner

Sweden condemned the ban, with Foreign Minister Carl Bildt stating that:

It’s an expression of quite a bit of prejudice and maybe even fear, but it is clear that it is a negative signal in every way, there’s no doubt about it“.

He also stated that:

Normally Sweden and other countries have city planners that decide this kind of issue.

To decide this kind of issue in a referendum seems very strange to me.”

Above: Carl Bildt

Then-Turkish President Abdullah Gül called the ban “shameful“.

Above: Abdullah Gül

Iranian Foreign Minister Manoucher Mottaki phoned his Swiss counterpart, and stated that the ban went “against the prestige of a country which claims to be an advocate of democracy and human rights“, and that it would “damage Switzerland’s image as a pioneer of respecting human rights among the Muslims’ public opinion“.

He also claimed that “values such as tolerance, dialogue, and respecting others’ religions should never be put to referendum“, and warned Switzerland of the “consequences of anti-Islamic acts“, and expressed hopes that the Swiss government would “take necessary steps and find a constitutional way to prevent the imposition of this ban“.

Above: Manouchehr Mottaki

Switzerland’s Ambassador to Iran was summoned before the Foreign Ministry, which protested against the ban.

Above: Logo of the Iranian Ministry of Foreign Affairs

Then-Libyan leader Muammar al-Gaddafi cited the minaret ban as grounds for his call for a jihad against Switzerland in a speech held in Benghazi on the occasion of Mawlid, four months after the vote.

Gaddafi also called on Muslims around the world to boycott Switzerland, and stated that:

Any Muslim in any part of the world that works with Switzerland is an apostate, is against Muhammad, Allah, and the Koran“.

Gaddafi called Switzerland an “infidel, obscene state which is destroying mosques“.

Above: Muammar al Gaddafi (1942 – 2011)

Libyan government spokesperson Mohammed Baayou announced that Libya had imposed an embargo on all economic and commercial exchanges with Switzerland.

Above: Flag of Libya

The Swiss referendum was welcomed by several European far right parties.

Above: Logo of the Alliance for the Future of Austria

Above: Logo of the Freedom Party of Austria

Above: Logo of the Danish People’s Party

Above: Logo of the Front National, France

Above: Logo of the Dutch Party for Freedom

Above: Logo of Italy’s Northern League

To my knowledge, the ban has never been reversed.

Above: On 8 December 2009, a mock minaret was erected over an industrial storage facility in Bussigny, Canton Vaud, Switzerland, in protest against the referendum outcome.

I must confess I am weary of Islamophobia, not because I am necessarily biased towards Islam as I now live in a predominantly Muslim nation, but because I have seen too many examples in religion and politics of entire groups being accused of the wrongdoing of a few within these groups.

We are not all the same.

We were born as individuals.

We live our lives as individuals.

We make individual decisions as to what we choose to believe, choose to think, choose to be.

The problem with religion is not with the faith itself, but rather with those who claim to follow that faith.

Above: Praying Hands, Albrecht Dürer

How many Muslims actually follow the teachings of Muhammad in the manner in which he intended?

Above: Al-Masjid an-Nabawi (“the Prophet’s mosque“) in Medina, Saudi Arabia, with the Green Dome built over Muhammad’s tomb in the centre

How many Christians actually act Christ-like?

Above: Christ the Saviour (Pantokrator), a 6th-century icon from Saint Catherine’s Monastery, Mount Sinai

How many Buddhists view the Buddha in the manner in which he wished to be viewed?

Above: Seated Buddha, Sarnath Museum, India

The same questioning can be extended to not only other religions but as well to the realms of philosophy and politics.

For example, how would Abraham Lincoln view the American Republican Party of today?

Above: Abraham Lincoln (1809 – 1865)

Above: Logo of the Republican Party

There are those who claim to represent Islam and do acts that run contrary to the sacred text of the Qu’ran.

Let us not paint the acts of a few as representative of the will of the majority.

Above: Muslim men at prayer, Umayyad Mosque, Damascus, Syria

No Muslim resident in Switzerland expects the adhan to be broadcast over Basel, just as no Christian in Turkey expects to hear church bells pealing in the streets of Konya.

Above: Images of Basel, Switzerland

Above: Konya, Turkey

Certainly it would be a fine thing to find minarets in Montreux or steeples in Izmir, but to assume that giving a minority the right to practice their faith will lead to that minority seeking to impose their faith upon the majority that surrounds them presupposes that every believer is infused with the zeal to become a missionary hellbent on converting the locals.

Above: Montreux, Switzerland

Above: Izmir, Turkey

That notion is as ridiculous as this Canadian blogger expecting everyone in Eskisehir to fly the maple leaf standard, subscribe to a sports channel that shows curling and ice hockey, and to demand poutine be served in all city restaurants.

Above: Flag of Canada

Above: Curling

Above: Ice hockey

Above: Poutine, Montréal, Québec, Canada

I did not come to Turkey expecting to make Canadians out of Turks.

Neither am I afraid of losing my Canadian identity to the Turkish environment that surrounds me.

I adapt insofar as I need to be respectful of the customs of the country wherein I find myself, but I will never become Turkish.

Because this is both impossible and undesirable.

My homeland is a part of who I am and though I may be distant from it Canada has defined who I am.

I will gladly try the local cuisine, try to learn the language, try to understand how the locals think.

But this is not to say I would prefer the fare of Trabzon to the cuisine of Toronto.

Above: Trabzon, Turkey

Above: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

This is not to say I will ever feel more comfortable speaking Turkish than my mother tongue of English.

This is not to say that an understanding of how the locals think will mean an automatic agreement with all that they think.

In Turkey, politics clashes with religion where the former feels threatened by the latter.

In Switzerland, politics attempts to use fear of unfamiliar faiths to exercise control over its native population.

In both nations, and perhaps universally around the globe, the reality of the conflict is never about morality.

It has been and always will be about wealth and power.

Religion may be the excuse, but it is never the real reason.

Religion should not involve itself in politics nor government regulate faith.

But what should be rarely is.

Please don’t tell me what to believe.

Please don’t tell me how to believe.

When I consider the gates of Heaven I find myself wondering:

Can we get there from here?

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Andrew Finkel, Turkey: What Everyone Needs to Know / Magsie Hamilton Little, The Thing about Islam: Exposing the Myths, Facts and Controversies / Orhan Pamuk, The Museum of Innocence

Tick tock, Tik Tok (or the opium of ambition)

Eskişehir, Turkey, Thursday, St. Patrick’s Day 2022

My friends Momo and Volkan do it.

Though not together.

They post videos of themselves online.

Above: Volkan Tanner

Above: Mauritz “Momo” Wallenstein

An article I read on the day I returned to work (Tuesday 1 March 2022) has suggested to me that maybe I could do it, should do it, too.

Hürriyet Daily News, Tuesday 1 March 2022

A Zambian student has won hearts in the Aegean province of Afyon as she promotes the city of Afyonkarahisar with YouTube videos she makes to earn a living.

Above: Chimwemwe Chita

(Hold the phone….

People earn a living from this?)

My real name is Chimwemwe Chita, but everybody calls me ‘çhita’.

Many tourists come to visit Afyonkarahisar after watching my videos.”, the 22-year-old woman told the daily Hürriyet.

Above: Chimwemwe Chita

(Afyonkarahisar (Turkish: afyon “poppy, opium“, kara “black“, hisar “fortress“) is a city in western Turkey, the capital of Afyon Province.

Afyon is in the mountainous countryside inland from the Aegean coast, 250 km (155 miles) southwest of Ankara along the Akarçay River.

In Turkey, Afyonkarahisar stands out as a capital city of hot springs and spas, an important junction of railway, highway and air traffic in West Turkey, and the place where independence was won.

Above: Afyonkarahisar Kalesi (castle)

The top of the rock in Afyon has been fortified for a long time.

Above: Afyon Castle

It was known to the Hittites as Hapanuwa, and was later occupied by Phrygians, Lydians and Achaemenid Persians until it was conquered by Alexander the Great (356 – 323 BCE).

Above: Map of the Hittite Empire at its greatest extent, with Hittite rule (c. 1350–1300 BCE) represented by the green line

Above: Phrygians

Above: Map of the Lydian Empire in its final period of sovereignty under Croesus(r. 585 – 546 BCE).
(7th century BCE boundary in red)

Above: Achaemenid Empire at its greatest territorial extent, under the rule of Darius I (522 to 486 BCE)

Above: Alexander on a mosaic from Pompeii, 4th century BCE

After the death of Alexander, the city (now known as Akroinοn (Ακροϊνόν) or Nikopolis (Νικόπολις) in Ancient Greek), was ruled by the Seleucids and the kings of Pergamon, then Rome and Byzantium.

Above: The Kingdom of Pergamon at its greatest extent, 188 BCE

Above: The Roman Empire at its greatest extent, 117 CE

Above: The Byzantine Empire at its greatest extent since the fall of the Western Roman Empire, 555 CE

The Byzantine Emperor Leo III (685 – 741) after his victory over Arab besiegers in 740 renamed the city Nicopolis (Greek for “city of victory“).

Above: Coin bearing the image of Leo III

The Seljuq Turks then arrived in 1071 and changed its name to Kara Hissar (“black castle“) after the ancient fortress situated upon a volcanic rock 201 meters above the town.

Above: The Seljuq Empire at its greatest extent, 1092 CE

Following the dispersal of the Seljuqs the town was occupied by the Sâhib Ata (r. 1260 – 1277)(Sultanate of Rum) and then the Germiyanids.

Above: The Sultanate of Rum (1100 – 1240)

Above: Location of Germiyan Kingdom

The castle was much fought over during the Crusades and was finally conquered by the Ottoman Sultan Beyazid I (1360 – 1403) in 1392, but was lost after the invasion of Timur Lenk (1336 – 1405) in 1402.

Above: Beyazid I

Above: Timur Lenk

It was recaptured in 1429.

The area thrived during the Ottoman Empire, as the centre of opium production and Afyon became a wealthy city.

In 1902, a fire burning for 32 hours destroyed parts of the city.

During the First World War British prisoners of war who had been captured at Gallipoli were housed here in an empty Armenian church at the foot of the rock.

Above: Landing at Gallipoli, April 1915

During the Greco-Turkish War (1919 – 1922) campaign (part of the Turkish War of Independence: 1919 – 1923) Afyon and the surrounding hills were occupied by Greek forces.

However, it was recovered on 27 August 1922, a key moment in the Turkish counterattack in the Aegean region.

After 1923 Afyon became a part of the Republic of Turkey.

Above: Flag of the Republic of Turkey

The region was a major producer of raw opium (hence the name Afyon) until the late 1960s when under international pressure, from the US in particular, the fields were burnt and production ceased.

Now poppies are grown under a strict licensing regime.

They do not produce raw opium any more but derive morphine and other opiates using the poppy straw method of extraction.

Above: Seed head of opium poppy with white latex

Afyon was depicted on the reverse of the Turkish 50 lira banknote of 1927 – 1938.

Today, Afyonkarahisar is one of the top leading provinces in agriculture, globally renowned for its marble and is the world’s largest producer of pharmaceutical opium.

Almost a third of all the morphine produced in the world derives from alkaloids factory in Afyon, named as “Afyon Alkaloids“.

This large capacity is the byproduct of Afyon’s poppy plantations.

The pharmaceuticals derive from the opium of the poppy capsules.

The “Afyon Alkaloids” factory is the largest of its kind in the world, with high capacity processing ability and modern laboratories.

The raw opium is put through a chain of biochemical processes, resulting into several types of morphine.

In the alkaloid extraction unit only base morphine is produced.

In the adjacent derivatives unit, half of the morphine extracted is converted to morphine hydrochloride, codeine, codeine phosphate, codeine sulphate, codeine hydrochloride, morphine sulphate, and ethyl morphine hydrochloride.)

Above: Opium poppy crop

Chita’s bond to Afyonkarahisar dated back to 2017 when Kocatepe University, one of the 12 Turkish universities she had applied to, accepted her application to study veterinary medicine.

Now I am in my 4th year.

I have one more year to study.”, she said.

But I won’t leave Afyonkarahisar after my graduation.

I want to stay here.

I love it here.

Her dream is to work in a veterinary clinic, especially to take care of horses.

Above: Chimwemwe Chita

(Afyon Kocatepe University (PIL) was founded in 1974 under Anadolu University and became a university in Afyonkarahisar in 1992.

It is a public university.

As of January 2012, the university has 1,078 academic staff, including 61 professors, 128 associate professors, 259 assistant professors, 255 lecturers, 56 lecturers, 294 research assistants, 25 experts and one education planner.

The number of administrative staff is 846. 

The total number of students is 33,000.

As a result of the establishment of Afyonkarahisar University of Health Sciences with health themes in Afyonkarahisar, faculties and colleges providing health education were transferred to AFSU.)

Above: Logo of Afyon Kocatepe University

However, after graduation, Chita has a plan in mind “to travel all around Anatolia“.

Above: Anatolia

The very first place to visit will be Cappadoccia, the picturesque historical region famous for its chimneys in Central Anatolia.

I want to fly with a hot air balloon over Cappadoccia.”

Above: Balloons over Cappadocia

(Cappadocia (Turkish: Kapadokya) is a historical region in Central Anatolia, largely in the Nevsehir, Kayseri, Akasaray, Kirsehir, Sivas and Nigde provinces in Turkey.

Since the late 300s BCE the name Cappadocia came to be restricted to the inland province (sometimes called Great Cappadocia), Upper Cappadocia.

According to Herodotus (484 – 425 BCE), at the time of the Ionian Revolt (499 BCE), the Cappadocians were reported as occupying a region from Mount Taurus to the vicinity of the Euxine (Black Sea).

Above: Bust of Herodotus

Cappadocia, in this sense, was bounded in the south by the chain of the Taurus Mountains that separate it from Cilicia, to the east by the upper Euphrates, to the north by Pontus, and to the west by Lycaonia, and eastern Galatia.

The name, traditionally used in Christian sources throughout history, continues in use as an international tourism concept to define a region of exceptional natural wonders, in particular characterized by fairy chimneys and a unique historical and cultural heritage.)

Above: Cappadocian landscape

When asked how she started making videos for YouTube, Chita pointed out a local media company called “Afyon Postasi“.

One day, a friend in the dormitory said officials of Afyon Postasi wanted to work with me and get benefit from my perspective while promoting the city.“, she said.

The first video she filmed was about her visit to the village of Ayazini.

More than 50,000 liked the video.

It was a good start.

And then came the other videos.

(Ayazini is a village in the District of Ihsaniye, Afyon Province, Turkey.

It is a historical place settled by Phrygians, Ancient Romans, Byzantines and Seljuks.

There are dwellings, churches and tomb chambers in rock-cut architecture  at the archaeological site.

The location has been used as a settlement since the Phrygian period.

Above: Byzantine church carved into rock in Ayazini

There are family and single-person rock tomb chambers with lion figures and columns from Roman and Byzantine times, churches and rock dwellings from the Byzantine period, thanks to carving-suitable rocks.

In addition, there is the Avdalaz Castle with a cistern carved into massive rock.

After the Byzantine era, the site was settled by the Seljuks.

It was reported that there are more than 300 caves in various size used as dwelling and 35 churches and chapels.

Rock dwellings from the early Byzantine period are found in the entrance and inside the village.

The dwellings have single rooms, rooms grouped side by side or one over the other.

Some are accessible by steps or by tunnel-shaped passages from other rooms.

In some rooms, there are benches and niches of various size for storing objects and candles or oil lamps.

The rock dwellings on both sides of the entrance to Avdalaz Valley are large.

The dwellings on one side are in multi-story form.

On the inside, there are deep pits used as a hearth and warehouse.

A circular room featuring seats side by side around the walls is accessible by an inclined tunnel.

Next to this section, a slightly-elevated toilet room is carved into rock.

There are multi-story dwellings resembling modern apartments in the rock-carved castle at the upper end of the Avdalaz Valley.

A cistern is carved on the castle’s ground.

A church structure carved into steep tuff rock is situated at the entrance to Ayazini.

It has an apse and a dome.

Built in the 1000s, it has a monastery structure with the adjacent rock chambers.

The facade of the rock-carved tombs are in the form of columned openings arched with a figure of Medusa.

Some tombs are decorated with lion figure reliefs.

On one tomb, the occupant couple is depicted.)

Above: Rock-carved Ancient Roman tomb with Medusa relief, Ayazini, Afyon Province

(Afyon is the centre of an agricultural area and the city has a country town feel to it.

Above: Afyon

Afyon breeds a large amount of livestocks, its landscape and demography is suitable for this field.

As such it ranks in the top 10 within Turkey in terms of amounts of sheep and cattle it has.

As a result of being an important source of livestock, related sectors such as meat and meat products are also very productive in Afyon.

Its one of the leading provinces in red meat production and has very prestigious brand marks of sausages, such as “Cumhuriyet Sausages“.

Afyon is the sole leader in egg production within Turkey.

It has the largest amount of laying hens, with a figure of 12,7 million. 

Afyon produces a record amount of 6 million eggs per day.

Sour cherries are cultivated in Afyon in very large numbers, so much so that it became very iconic to Afyon.

Every year, a sour cherry festival takes place in the Cay district.

It is the largest producer of sour cherries in Turkey. 

The sour cherries grown in Afyon are of excellent quality because of the ideal climate they are grown in.

Top quality cherries known as “Napolyon Cherries” are grown in abundance.

One of the iconic agricultural practices of Afyon is the cultivation of poppy.

Afyon’s climate is ideal for the cultivation of this plant, hence a large amount of poppy plantation occurs in this region.

Though, a strong limitation came some decades ago from international laws, nevertheless, Afyon is the largest producer of poppies in Turkey and accounts for a large amount of global production.

Afyon has a durable reputation in potato production.

It produces around 8% of Turkish potato needs.

Afyon ranks in the top five in potato, sugar-beets, cucumber and barley production.

There is little in the way of bars, cafes, live music or other cultural amenities, and the standards of education are low for a city in the west of Turkey, with the exception of Afyon Kocatepe University.

Afyon is known for its marble (in 2005 there were 355 marble quarries in the province of Afyon producing high quality white stone), its sucuk (spiced sausages), its kaymak (meaning either cream or a white Turkish Delight), and various handmade weavings.

Above: Afyon marble quarry

Above: Afyonkarahisar sucuk

Above: Kamak lokum, Turkish delight of cream, a speciality of Afyonkarahisar

Above: Afyonkarahisar weaving

There is also a large cement factory.

Above: Cement factory, Afyonkarahisar

Afyon is a natural crossroads, the routes from Ankara to Izmir and from Istanbul to Antalya intersect here and thus is a popular stopping-place on these journeys.

Above: Afyonkarahisar Station

There are a number of well-established roadside restaurants for travellers to breakfast on the local cuisine.

Some of these places are modern well-equipped hotels and spas – the mineral waters of Afyon are renowned for their healing qualities.

There is also a long string of roadside kiosks selling the local Turkish delight.)

Chita’s favourite local food is soufflé with hash.

People need to come to Afyonkarahisar and taste all the local foods.

They are delicious.“, she recommends.

Above: Afyonkarahisar soufflé with hash

(Turkish cuisine (Turkish: Türk mutfağı) is largely the heritage of Ottoman cuisine, which can be described as a fusion and refinement of Mediterranean, Balkan, Middle Eastern, Central Asian, Eastern European, Armenian and Georgian cuisines.

Turkish cuisine has in turn influenced those and other neighbouring cuisines, including those of Southeast Europe (Balkans), Central Europe and Western Europe.

The Ottomans fused various culinary traditions of their realm with influences from Mesopotamian cuisine, Greek cuisine, Levantine cuisine, Egyptian cuisine, Balkan cuisine, along with traditional Turkic elements from Central Asia (such as ayran and kaymak), creating a vast array of specialities.)

(Ayrandooghdhallëdaw or tan is a cold savory yogurt-based beverage of Turkic origin, popular across Western Asia, Central Asia, South Asia, Southeastern Europe and Eastern Europe.

The principal ingredients are yogurt, water and salt.

Herbs, such as mint, may be optionally added.

Some varieties are carbonated.)

Above: Ayran

(KaymakSarshir, or Qashta/Ashta is a creamy dairy food similar to clotted cream, made from the milk of water buffalo, cows, sheep or goats in Central Asia, some Balkan countries, some Caucasus countries, the countries of the Levant, Turkic regions, Iran and Iraq.

In Poland, the name kajmak refers to a confection similar to dulce de leche instead.

The traditional method of making kaymak is to boil the raw milk slowly, then simmer it for two hours over a very low heat.

After the heat source is shut off, the cream is skimmed and left to chill (and mildly ferment) for several hours or days.

Kaymak has a high percentage of milk fat, typically about 60%.

It has a thick, creamy consistency (not entirely compact, because of milk protein fibers) and a rich taste.)

Above: Kaymak

(Turkish cuisine varies across the country.

The cooking of Istanbul, Bursa, Izmir, and the rest of the Asia Minor region inherits many elements of Ottoman court cuisine, including a moderate use of spices, a preference for rice over bulgar (a type of wheat), koftes (a type of meatball), and a wider availability of vegetable stews (türlü), eggplant, stuffed dolmas (vegetables) and fish.

Above: Istanbul

Above: Bursa

Above: Izmir

Above: Bulgar

Above: Turkish köfte on pilaf (rice) with orzo (tomato) (“şehriyeli pilav“)

Above: Türlü

The cuisine of the Black Sea region uses fish extensively, especially the Black Sea anchovy (hamsi) and includes maize (corn) dishes.

Above: Anchovy

The cuisine of the southeast (e.g. Urfa, Gaziantep, Adiyaman and Adana) is famous for its variety of kebabs (souvlaki / gyros), mezes (appetizers) and dough-based desserts, such as baklava (a layered pastry dessert made of filo pastry, filled with chopped nuts, and sweetened with syrup or honey), söbiyet (A Turkish dessert similar to baklava, it is stuffed with a cream, made from milk and semolina, and nuts (walnuts or pistachios. It has a soft but crusty outside and creamy inside.), kadayif (a traditional Middle Eastern dessert made with spun pastry (kataifi), soaked in a sweet, sugar-based syrup (attar), and typically layered with cheese or with other ingredients, such as clotted cream, pistachio or nuts, depending on the region.) and künefe (a variant of kadayif).

Above: Urfa

Above: Gaziantep Castle

Above: Adiyaman

Above: Adana

Above: Kebab

Above: Meze platter

Above: Pistachio baklava

Above: Şöbiyet with Maraş ice cream (dondurması)

Above: Kadayif

Above: Turkish künefe and Turkish tea

Especially in the western parts of Turkey, where olive trees grow abundantly, olive oil is the major type of oil used for cooking.

Above: Olive oil

The cuisines of the Aegean, Marmara and Mediterranean regions are rich in vegetables, herbs, and fish. 

Central Anatolia has many famous specialties, such as keşkek (a sort of ceremonial meat or chicken, wheat or barley stew found in Turkish, Iranian, Greek and Balkan cuisine), manti (a type of dumpling, especially from Kayseri) and gözleme.

Above: Keşkek meal

Above: Kayseri manti

(Gözleme is a savory stuffed turnover, usually made from unleavened dough (of flour, salt and water), lightly brushed with butter or oil, rolled thin, then filled with various toppings, sealed, and cooked over a griddle.

Fillings for gözleme are numerous and vary by region and personal preference, and include a variety of meats (minced beef, chopped lamb, fresh or smoked seafood, sujuk (a dry, spicy fermented sausage), pastirma (a highly seasoned, air-dried cured beef)), vegetables (spinach, zucchini, eggplant, leek, chard, various peppers, onion, scallion, shallot, garlic), mushrooms (porcino, chanterelle, truffle), tubers (potatoes, yams, radish), cheeses (feta, Turkish white cheese, lavaş (a distinctive variety of cheese traditionally produced in Karacadağ, in the vicinity of Diyarbakir in eastern Turkey, generally made from sheep’s milk), Beyaz peynir (a brine cheese produced from unpasteurized sheep, cow or goat milk), çökelek (a fermented, coagulated fresh cheese similar to cottage cheese), Kasseri (a medium-hard or hard pale yellow cheese made from pasteurised or unpasteurised sheep milk and, at most, 20% goat’s milk) and Kashkaval (a type of yellow cheese made from cow’s milk, sheep’s milk or both)), as well as eggs, seasonal herbs and spices.)

Above: Gözleme

Food names directly cognate with mantı are also found in Chinese (mantou: steamed bun) and Korean cuisine (mandu) and it is generally considered to have originated in Mongolia during the 13th century.

Above: Chinese mantou

Above: Korean mandu

Specialties are often named for places, and may refer to different styles of preparation.

For example, Urfa kebab is less spicy and thicker than Adana kebab.

Although meat-based foods, such as kebabs, are common in Turkish cuisine abroad, meals in Turkey largely center around rice, vegetables and bread.)

Above: Urfa kebab

Above: Adana kebab

Apart from the money Chita earns from the local media company, she makes a living in the city by tutoring English lessons and sewing dresses.

She may be homesick, missing her family who reside in her mother country, but she has become an “Afyon local“, with even her music taste converting into “Turkish“.

I love listening to Baris Manço, Sezen Aksu, Murat Boz and Hadise.”, she listed.

Above: Chimwemwe Chita

(Barış Manço (1943 – 1999) was a Turkish artist, arranger, singer, composer, songwriter, TV show producer and presenter, columnist, State Artist and cultural ambassador. 

He was considered one of the pioneers of rock music in Turkey and one of the founders of the Anatolian Rock genre.

His more than 200 songs earned him twelve gold and a platinum album and cassette award. [

Some of his songs were later interpreted in Arabic, Bulgarian, Dutch, English, German, Greek, Hebrew and Japanese.

He went to many countries of the world with his television program and was therefore called “Peace Çelebi“. 

In 1991, he was awarded the title of State Artist of the Republic of Turkey.

Above: Barış Manço

Sezen Aksu (born 1954) is a Turkish singer-songwriter and producer.

Since her debut in the mid-1970s, she has become an influential figure with her songs of Turkish pop music.

In addition to her singing, she also frequently came to prominence as a songwriter and composer thanks to the songs she wrote and composed for others.

She has supported many of the people who were her backing vocalists and produced their albums.

In this way, she helped to promote various names throughout the 1990s and early 2000s and influenced them.

Aksu, who is often referred to the media as Little Sparrow.

She was born in Sarayköy, Denizli.

When she was three years old, her family moved to Izmir.

After completing Izmir Girls High School, she attended Ege University Faculty of Agriculture, but dropped out of school in her second year.

In 1974, she moved to Istanbul and a year later she released her first 45 record as Sezen Seley.

In 1977, she released her first studio album, Allahaismared (Goodbye). 

She then released dozens of albums, including Sparrow (Serçe) (1978), Firuze (Turquoise) (1982), Don’t You Cry (Sen Ağlama)(1984), Git (Go)(1986), Sezen Aksu Sings (Sezen Aksu Söylüyor)(1989), Smile (Gülumse) (1991), The Song of the Crazy Girl (Deli kizin türküsü)(1993), and Dream Gardens (Duş bahçeleri)(1996).

Smile became one of the best-selling albums of all time in Turkey.

Aksu has sold more than 40 million albums worldwide to date.

Murat Boz (born 1980) is a Turkish singer-songwriter and actor.

After completing his primary and secondary education in his birthplace of Karadeniz Eregli, Zonguldak Province, he settled in Istanbul.

He studied at Istanbul Bilgi University and Istanbul Technical University.

During these years he was a vocalist for many singers, especially Tarkan.

Boz embarked on his solo career with the single “I Can’t Find Love” (Aşki Bulaman Benim), released in 2006.

The following year, he released his first studio album Maximum which won numerous awards praising his debut.

He then continued his career with the albums Luck (şans)(2009), My Loves Are Bigger Than Me (Aşklarium Büyük Benden) (2011) and Janti (Rim)(2016).

The songs “Maximum“, “Cliff” (Uçurum), “No Money” (Para Yok), “I Miss You” (Özledim), “Sallana Sallana” and “Let Who Knows Your Name Write” (Adini Bilen Yazsin) have reached the top five of the Official List of Turkey.

Maybe Turn Back” (Geri Dönüş Olsa), “I Can’t Stay Friends” (Kalamam Arkadaş) and “Janti” reached the top of the Official List of Turkey.

In addition to his musical career, he has focused on his acting career since 2014, starring in Let’s Hope (Hadi Inşallah)(2014), My Brother (Kardeşim Benim) (2016), If She Returns She Is Yours (Dönerse Senindir) (2016) and Kill Me, Darling (Öldür Beni Sevgilim)(2019).

Murat Boz, who can play piano, violin, drums and ney (a type of Persian flute), is the advertising face of various companies.

Above: Ney

He is one of the four judges of Voice of Turkey.

Above: Murat Boz

Hadise Açgöz (born 1985) is a Belgian-Turkish singer. 

She was born and raised in Belgium.

Above: Hadise Açgöz

After participating in the 2003 Idol competition, she began preparations for her first album.

She became popular in Belgium and Turkey for her song “Stir Me Up“, which appeared on her first studio album Sweat, released in 2005.

After the Turkish press took notice of her, she moved her career to Turkey.

In 2008, she released her second studio album, Hadise.

The song “Mad Boy“, which was included in the album consisting of English and Turkish songs, became a hit in Turkey.

The following year, she came fourth in the 2009 Eurovision Song Contest, representing Turkey with “Düm Tek Tek“(The Rhythm of My Heart).

Thanks to this competition, she has increased in popularity.

In the same year, she released her albums Fast Life and Hero (Kahraman). 

Kahraman‘s debut song, “We Must Get Married“, performed well on the charts.

In 2011, her fifth studio album, “Love Wore What Size?” (Aşk Kaç Beden Giyer) was released.

She recorded music videos for “Superman“, “How Many Sizes Does Love Wear?” and “He Got My Message“.

She released the album Advice in 2014 and Champion in 2017.

She said she was inspired by Christina Aguilera, Brandy Norwood and Beyoncé. 

She has been a judge on the Voice of Turkey competition since 2011.)

Above: Logo of The Voice of Turkey

Chita also said that it was easy for her to adapt to Turkish society as the social orders of the two countries, Turkey and Zambia, are similar.

People of the two countries are both helpful and friendly.

Even the salutation styles are the same.“, she said.

The only difference, I may say, is that Zambian food is spicier.

We do not have as many kinds of desserts as Turks do.“, she underlined.

Above: Flag of Zambia

Blogging, frequently seen as a hobby, an obsession, or a duty imposed on you by your company, your publisher, or your social media consultant, has continued to grow.

Where bloggers in earlier days were often treated as the illegitimate offspring of “real” media, the attractions of blogging remain strong, because blogging may be the most democratic form of self-expression ever invented.

Plenty of pundits have predicted the “death of blogging, because they were so many millions of people starting blogs it became impossible to catalog or even count them.

But blogging continues to morph into new forms, incorporating multimedia, penetrating social media platforms, and claiming a seat at the table.

It has become commonplace to see bloggers sitting on panels on broadcast news and they are quoted everywhere.

Blogs may be, in fact, the most trusted source of information for many consumers.

Even people who profess to not read blogs are probably reading plenty of them.

They just don’t know that they are.

They are likely reading online articles on blog sites that don’t even call themselves “blogs” any more.

We now get much of our information from blogs calling themselves “resource centres” or “information archives” or any number of other labels.

Bloggers know they can build a community of interest around their topic, network with other bigger bloggers, and eventually find some way to monetize all this activity.

The ability to use blogging as a way to build authority, gather a community of interested readers, and cultivate a cadre of committed fans is beginning to show writers how to use this platform to create the literature they have always wanted to write, because blogging provides a kind of high-energy promotion.

I have begun to understand that in this digital age every writer is a start-up business trying to find room in a crowded marketplace.

An increasingly popular way to drive traffic to blogs involves video.

As of 2015, statistics on the YouTube site stated that more than 1 billion unique users visit the site each month.

Over 6 billion hours of video are watched each month on YouTube.

This is almost an hour for every person on the planet.

Additionally, 100 hours of video are uploaded to YouTube every minute.

YouTube videos have become an ever more popular form of Internet information and entertainment.

Bloggers can and should use these videos to drive traffic to their sites.

Since YouTube constitutes the 3rd most popular website on the Internet today, you want to have a presence there.

If you have a YouTube channel, you can post videos related to your blog to YouTube.

You can share this link via your social networks and, if you have included a link to your blog somewhere in the video description, viewers can find your blog.

As well, all blogging software has a function whereby you can add video right into your blog posts.

These days, most computers have video capacity.

Digital video cameras are pretty inexpensive and easy to use.

Your cellphone likely has video capacity as well.

Once you have figured out how to videotape yourself, you can upload that video to YouTube.

What can you record?

  • A blog post
  • Information about your blog
  • Your mission statement
  • The benefits of reading your writing
  • Tips from your blog
  • A trailer about your writing
  • A report on your writing or blogging process

Be creative.

Have fun.

Record whatever you think might be fun for you to talk about or interesting for viewers to watch and hear.

Share it wherever you can.

On all your social networks.

Which brings me to the topic of the title above…..

It all began with Plato.

In 1973, the PLATO system (developed at the University of Illinois and subsequently commercially marketed by Control Data Corporation) offered early forms of social media with:

  • Notes, PLATO’s message-forum application
  • TERM-talk, its instant-messaging feature
  • Talkomatic, perhaps the first online chat room
  • News Report, a crowd-sourced online newspaper and blog
  • Access Lists, enabling the owner of a notes file or other application to limit access to a certain set of users, for example, only friends, classmates, or co-workers. 

Above: PLATO running a fractional distillation simulation

Tom Truscott and Jim Ellis conceived the idea of Usenet in 1979 at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and Duke University.

It was established in 1980.

Above: A diagram of Usenet servers and clients.
The blue, green, and red dots on the servers represent the groups they carry.
Arrows between servers indicate newsgroup group exchanges (feeds).
Arrows between clients and servers indicate that a user is subscribed to a certain group and reads or submits articles.

As operating systems with a graphical user interface, such as Windows and Mac OS, began to emerge and gain popularity, this created an environment that allowed for early social media platforms to thrive and exist.

Above: The original Apple Macintosh Desktop

Bulletin Board Systems (BBS)(1980) and Internet Relay Chat (IRC)(1988) were popular during this time period.

Above: A welcome screen for the Freenet bulletin board, 1994

IRC is still widely used today. 

Above: The first IRC server, the Tolsun 2, University of Oulu, Finland

FidoNet formed in 1984, as BBSs start to exchange email in North America and later internationally.

The WELL, established in 1985, is one of the oldest still-operating online communities.

Its name is an acronym for “Whole Earth ‘Lectronic Link“, coined by Stewart Brand, creator of the Whole Earth Catalog.

Various notable social media platforms, such as Myspace and Facebook, are developed and released.

Classmates.com originally launched as a list of school affiliations, is launched in December 1995.

The site, founded by Randy Conrads, later incorporated features to help former and current classmates find and contact each other online.

The Swedish social networking website LunarStorm, originally called Stajlplejs, is launched in 1996.

The site, founded by Rickard Eriksson, was renamed LunarStorm in 2000 and has been described as “the world’s first social media on the Internet” by the founder.

In 1996, ICQ (“I seek you“) is released by Israeli company Mirabilis.

Above: Logo of ICQ

That same year, Bolt.com was started as the first social networking and video website.

In 1997, the social networking website SixDegrees.com (1997 – 2001) was created.

In 1998, Open Diary launched the first social blogging network, inventing the reader comment and friends-only content.

In 1999, LiveJournal, an early blogging platform and social network, was launched.

Blogging began to gain popularity. 

Above: Logo of LiveJournal

Instant messaging platforms such as AOL (America Online) Instant Messenger (AIM)(1997), Yahoo! Messenger (1998 – 2018) and Windows Live Messenger (1999) also became increasingly popular.

Above: Logo of Windows Live Messenger

In 2000, Habbo, a game-based social networking site, was launched.

Wikipedia was launched in 2001.

Above: Logo of Wikipedia

In 2002, social networking and gaming site Friendster (2002 – 2014) was launched.

The service would be popular in Asia and the Pacific Islands.

Many social media platforms that have remained are now thriving, and new ones are appearing sporadically.

This includes popular blogs, instant messaging servers, and various social networking platforms, such as:

  • Skype (2003)

Above: Logo of Skype

  • LinkedIn (2003)

  • Hi5 (2003)

  • Facebook (2004)

Above: Logo of Facebook

  • Flickr (2004)

  • Orkut (2004 – 2014)

  • Tagged (2004)

  • XING (2005)

  • MySpace (2005)

  • Bebo (2005)

  • Qzone (2005)

  • Reddit (2005)

  • Renren (2005)

  • Twitter (2006)

Above: Logo of Twitter

  • FriendFeed (2007)

  • Justin.tv (2007 – 2014)

  • Sina Weibo (2009)

Above: Logo for Sina Weibo

  • Pinterest (2010)

  • Instagram (2010)

Above: Logo of Instagram

  • Path (2010 – 2018)

  • Quora (2010)

  • Snapchat (2011)

Above: Logo of Snapchat

  • Google+ (2011 – 2019)

  • Keek (2011)

  • Twitch (2011)

  • Tinder (2012)

  • ByteDance (2012)

  • Vine (2013 – 2016)

  • Google Hangouts (2013)

Above: Logo for Google Hangouts

  • Musical.ly (2014 – 2018)

Above: Logo for Musical.ly

  • Periscope (2015)

Above: Logo for Periscope

  • Berne (2015 – 2017)

Above: Logo of Berne

  • Discord (2015)

  • Meerkat (2015)

Above: Logo of Meerkat

  • Triller (2016)

  • TikTok (2017)

Above: TikTok Logo in Chinese



  • Co-Star (2017)

  • Parler (2018 – 2020)

  • Clubhouse (2020)

Above: Logo for Clubhouse

With advances in smartphone technology, almost all social media services now have their own mobile apps.

What follows is a story about one app and how its gain and loss has affected a person and a nation….

Two years ago, Sangita Gaikwad’s teenage daughter Mona introduced her to TikTok.

Like many first-time users of the video-sharing app, Gaikwad, a homemaker in a farming village in western India, was baffled.

What would she want with an infinite stream of 15-stream clips showing strangers dancing, lip-synching, and reenacting memes on their phones?

But when Mona insisted, Gaikwad, a wise-cracking (then) 35-year-old who once dreamed of becoming a TV actress, started uploading her own short videos.

One day she posted a lighthearted clip of herself as she was heading to the market to buy mutton.

The video was viewed 100,000 times.

Gaikwad did not understand it, but she was on her way to becoming another unlikely star in the huge, highly addicting, and often mystifying universe of TikTok, the Chinese-made app whose popularity has skyrocketed worldwide.

Above: Sangita Gaikwad

Nowhere is this truer than in India, TikTok’s biggest international market, where its 200 million users include many villagers, LGBTQ Indians, and others from marginalized backgrounds for whom the app was a source of joy, self-respect, income – and even a measure of fame.

Above: India

Now these Indians’ social media habits have become enmeshed in a geopolitical clash between the world’s two populous countries.

India, in the last week of September 2020, banned TikTok and 58 other apps developed by Chinese companies, labeling them threats to national security, in apparent retaliation for the deaths of 20 Indian soldiers in a melee with Chinese troops on the countries’ disputed Himalayan border two weeks previously.

The announcement dealt a blow to China, whose tech industry is a source of national pride and a key competitor in an emergent Cold War with the US.

But it also illustrated how ubiquitous and influential Chinese apps and other digital products have become around the world, transforming lives even as rival governments worry about their potential for harm.

The success of China’s slick, low-cost smartphones and software has prompted warnings from the US and others who believe they are illegally mining data and could be used to spy for the Chinese Communist Partry.

China and the companies have denied the allegations.

Above: Flag of China

With its 635 million Internet connections and a fast-growing, $3.7 billion digital advertising market, India represents one of the most important countries for China’s tech start-ups.

In 2019, India was the only major developing economy where Chinese apps had a greater market share than American competitors, according to an analysis by MacroPolo, a think tank based at the Paulson Institute in Chicago.

Although 90% of TikTok’s revenues come from China, its parent company, ByteDance, had hired 2,000 employees in India and had planned to invest $1 billion in the market over the next three years.

In April, TikTok said it had donated about $40 million to PM Cares, a fund established by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s office to fight COVID-19.

The company quickly moved to demonstrate compliance with the ban, pulling TikTok from app stores in India and saying it was “committed to working with the government to demonstrate our dedication to user security until our commitment to the country overall“.

India’s TikTok nation has felt the sting.

Above: Tik Tok India logo

I am so dejected.“, Gaikwad said.

By Monday 27 September 2020, the day the ban was announced, her account had amassed nearly half a million followers.

That night, she barely slept.

She was mourning the loss of not just a favourite “timepass” – Indian parlance for a frivolous activity – but of a new way of seeing herself.

Celebrity isn’t something Gaikwad expected, growing up poor in Maharashtra state and raising four children with her husband Ankush, who earns $120 a month as a local government employee.

When she goes to the market now, she said, people stop her for selfies.

Strangers ask to shoot videos with her.

Some even come to her house.

I never got into TikTok for money.“, she said.

But I got respect, legitimacy, and confidence.

We are poor people.

We have never received any attention in life.

All we have gotten is disdain and scorn.

TikTok turned it around.

Above: Sangita Gaikwad

Nikhil Pahwa, founder of Medianama, a website that covers the Indian digital industry, said that TikTok’s intuitive, full-screen design and emphasis on music made it a hit with rural Indians who found American apps too text-heavy or clunky.

TikTok specialized in being a platform that is accessible irrespective of socioeconomic class.“, Pahwa said.

That’s why it has become a hub of creative activity from places that we did not expect.

Even among ardent TikTok users, there has been little pushback to the ban, widely seen as a necessary response by Modi’s Hindu nationalist party to Chinese aggression.

India has also reportedly delayed customs clearance for some Chinese imports, signaling that the trade dispute could widen.

Above: Logo of the Bharatiya Janata Party (the Indian People’s Party)

Given that soldiers have been killed and sentiments are running high, banning Chinese apps is going to be a popular move.“, Pahwa said.

What we see are people looking for alternatives.

If the situation doesn’t get resolved over the next month, creators will have to find other platforms to migrate to.

TikTok hosts a variety of short-form user videos, from genres like pranks, stunts, tricks, jokes, dance, and entertainment with durations from 15 seconds to three minutes.

TikTok is an international version of Douyin, which was originally released in the Chinese market in September 2016.

TikTok was launched in 2017 for iOS and Android in most markets outside of mainland China.

However, it became available worldwide only after merging with another Chinese social media service, Musical.ly, on 2 August 2018.

Above: Location of China (in green)

As of October 2020, TikTok surpassed over 2 billion mobile downloads worldwide.

TikTok has been downloaded more than 130 million times in the United States, and has reached 2 billion downloads worldwide, according to data from mobile research firm Sensor Tower (those numbers exclude Android users in China).

In the United States, celebrities, including Jimmy Fallon and Tony Hawk, began using the app in 2018.

Other celebrities, including Jennifer Lopez, Jessica Alba, Will Smith and Justin Bieber joined TikTok as well and many other celebrities have followed.

Above: Flag of the United States of America

On 3 September 2019, TikTok and the US National Football League (NFL) announced a multi-year partnership.

The agreement occurred just two days before the NFL’s 100th season kick-off at Soldier Field, where TikTok hosted activities for fans in honor of the deal.

The partnership entails the launch of an official NFL TikTok account, which is to bring about new marketing opportunities such as sponsored videos and hashtag challenges.

Above: Logo of the National Football League

In July 2020, TikTok, excluding Douyin, reported close to 800 million monthly active users worldwide after less than four years of existence.

Above: “The Blue Marble” – Full disk view of the Earth taken on 7 December 1972, by the crew of the Apollo 17 spacecraft en route to the Moon at a distance of about 29,000 kilometres (18,000 miles)

On 3 August 2020, US President Donald Trump threatened to ban TikTok in the United States on 15 September if negotiations for the company to be bought by Microsoft or a different “very American” company failed.

On 6 August, Trump signed two executive orders banning US “transactions” with TikTok and WeChat to its respective parent companies ByteDance and Tencent, set to take effect 45 days after the signing. 

A planned ban of the app on 20 September 2020 was postponed by a week and then blocked by a federal judge.

Above: Former US President Donald J. Trump

President Biden revoked the ban in a new executive order in June 2021.

Above: Current US President Joe Biden

The app has been banned by the government of India since June 2020 along with 223 other Chinese apps in view of privacy concerns.

Pakistan banned TikTok citing “immoral” and “indecent” videos on 9 October 2020 but reversed its ban ten days later.

In March 2021, a Pakistani court ordered a new TikTok ban due to complaints over “indecent” content.

Above: Flag of Pakistan

In May 2021, TikTok appointed Shou Zi Chew as their new CEO who assumed the position from interim CEO Vanessa Pappas, following the resignation of Kevin A. Mayer on 27 August 2020.

Above: Shou Zi Chew

In September 2021, TikTok reported that it had reached 1 billion users.

The TikTok mobile app allows users to create short videos, which often feature music in the background and can be sped up, slowed down, or edited with a filter.

They can also add their own sound on top of the background music.

To create a music video with the app, users can choose background music from a wide variety of music genres, edit with a filter and record a 15-second video with speed adjustments before uploading it to share with others on TikTok or other social platforms.

They can also film short lip-sync videos to popular songs.

The “For You” page on TikTok is a feed of videos that are recommended to users based on their activity on the app.

Content is generated by TikTok’s artificial intelligence (AI) depending on the content a user liked, interacted with, or searched.

Users can also choose to add to favorites or select “not interested” on videos for their page.

TikTok combines the user’s enjoyed content to provide videos that they would also enjoy.

Users and their content can only be featured on the “for you” page if they are 16 or over as per TikTok policy.

Users under 16 will not show up under the “for you” page, the sounds page, or under any hashtags.

The app’s “react” feature allows users to film their reaction to a specific video, over which it is placed in a small window that is movable around the screen.

Its “duet” feature allows users to film a video aside another video.

The “duet” feature was another trademark of Musical.ly.

The duet feature is also only able to be used if both parties adjust the privacy settings.

Videos that users do not want to post yet can be stored in their “drafts“.

The user is allowed to see their “drafts” and post when they find it fitting.

The app allows users to set their accounts as “private“.

When first downloading the app, the user’s account is public by default.

The user can change to private in their settings.

Private content remains visible to TikTok, but is blocked from TikTok users who the account holder has not authorized to view their content.

Users can choose whether any other user, or only their “friends“, may interact with them through the app via comments, messages, or “react” or “duet” videos.

Users also can set specific videos to either “public“, “friends only“, or “private” regardless if the account is private or not.

Users are also allowed to report accounts depending on the account’s content, either being spam or inappropriate.

In TikTok’s support center under “For Parents“, they reassure the parents that inappropriate content for their children can be blocked and reported.

When users follow other users, a “following” page is located on the left of the “for you” page.

This is a page only to see the videos from the accounts a user follows.

Users can also add videos, hashtags, filters, and sounds to their “saved” section.

When creating a video, they can refer to their saved section, or create a video straight from it.

This section is visible only to the user on their profile allowing them to refer to any video, hashtag, filter, or sound they’ve previously saved.

Users can also send their friends videos, emojis, and messages with direct messaging.

TikTok has also included a feature to create a video based on the user’s comments.

Influencers often use the “live” feature.

This feature is only available for those who have at least 1,000 followers and are over 16 years old.

If over 18, the user’s followers can send virtual “gifts” that can be later exchanged for money.

One of the newest features as of 2020 is the “Virtual Items” of “Small Gestures” feature.

This is based on China’s big practice of social gifting.

Since this feature was added, many beauty companies and brands created a TikTok account to participate and advertise this feature.

With quarantine in the United States, social gifting grew in popularity.

According to a TikTok representative, the campaign was launched as a result of the lockdown, “to build a sense of support and encouragement with the TikTok community during these tough times.”

TikTok announced a “family safety mode” in February 2020 for parents to be able to control their children’s digital well-being.

There is a screen time management option, restricted mode, and can put a limit on direct messages.

The app expanded its parental controls feature called “Family Pairing” in September 2020 to provide parents and guardians with educational resources to understand what children on TikTok are exposed to.

Content for the feature was created in partnership with online safety nonprofit, Internet Matters.

In October 2021, TikTok launched a test feature that allows users to directly tip certain creators.

Accounts of users that are of age, have at least 100,000 followers and agree to the terms can activate a “Tip” button on their profile, which allows followers to tip any amount, starting from $1.

In December 2021, TikTok started beta-testing Live Studio, a streaming software that would let users broadcast applications open on their computers, including games.

The software also launched with support for mobile and PC streaming.

However, a few days later, users on Twitter discovered that the software allegedly uses code from the open-source OBS Studio.

OBS made a statement saying that, under the GNU GPL version 2, TikTok has to make the code of Live Studio publicly available if it wants to use any code from OBS.

Above: Logo of OBS Studio

A variety of trends have risen within TikTok, including memes, lip-synched songs, and comedy videos.

Duets, a feature that allows users to add their own video to an existing video with the original content’s audio, have sparked many of these trends.

Trends are shown on TikTok’s explore page or the page with the search logo.

The page enlists the trending hashtags and challenges among the app.

Some include #posechallenge, #filterswitch, #dontjudgemechallenge, #homedecor, #hitormiss, #bottlecapchallenge and more.

In June 2019, the company introduced the hashtag #EduTok which received 37 billion views.

Following this development, the company initiated partnerships with edtech startups to create educational content on the platform.

The app has spawned numerous viral trends, Internet celebrities, and music trends around the world.

 

Many stars got their start on Musical.ly, which merged with TikTok on 2 August 2018.

These users include Loren Gray, Baby Ariel, Kristen Hancher, Zach King, Lisa and Lena, Jacob Sartorius, and many others.

Loren Gray remained the most-followed individual on TikTok until Charli D’Amelio surpassed her on 25 March 2020.

Gray’s was the first TikTok account to reach 40 million followers on the platform.

She was surpassed with 41.3 million followers.

Above: Loren Gray

D’Amelio was the first to ever reach 50, 60, and 70 million followers.

Until now Charli D’Amelio remains the most-followed individual on the platform.

Above: Charli D’Amelio

Other creators rose to fame after the platform merged with Musical.ly on 2 August 2018.

One notable TikTok trend is the “hit or miss” meme, which began from a snippet of iLOVEFRiDAY’s song “Mia Khalifa“.

The song has been used in over four million TikTok videos and helped introduce the app to a larger Western audience.

TikTok also played a major part in making “Old Town Road” by Lil Nas X one of the biggest songs of 2019 and the longest running number-one song in the history of the Billboard Hot 100.

Above: Montero Lamar Hill (aka Lil Nas X)


TikTok has allowed many other bands to gain a wider audience, often including foreign fans.

For example, despite never having toured in Asia, the band Fitz and the Tantrums developed a large following in South Korea following the widespread popularity of their song “HandClap” on the platform.

Above: Fitz and the Tantrums

Any Song” by R&B and rap artist Zico became number one on the Korean music charts due to the popularity of the #anysongchallenge, where users dance the choreography of “Any Song“. 

Above: Zico

The platform has received some criticism for not paying royalties to artists whose music is used on their platform.

In 2020, more than 176 different songs surpassed 1 billion video views on TikTok.

In June 2020, TikTok users and K-pop fans “claimed to have registered potentially hundreds of thousands of tickets” for President Trump’s campaign rally in Tulsa through communication on TikTok, contributing to “rows of empty seats” at the event.

Above: Trump rally, Tulsa, Oklahoma, 19 June 2020

TikTok has banned Holocaust denial, but other conspiracy theories have become popular on the platform, such as Pizzagate and QAnon (two conspiracy theories popular among the US alt-right) whose hashtags reached almost 80 million views and 50 million views respectively by June 2020.

Above: Proponents of Pizzagate connected Comet Ping Pong (pictured) to a fictitious child sex trafficking ring

(“Pizzagate” is a debunked conspiracy theory that went viral during the 2016 US presidential election cycle.

It has been extensively discredited by a wide range of organizations, including the Washington DC police.

In March 2016, the personal email account of John Podesta, presidential candidate Hillary Clinton’s campaign chair, was hacked in a spear-phishing ( the creation and sending of emails to a particular person to make the person think the email is legitimate) attack. 

WikiLeaks published Podesta’s emails in November 2016.

Above: John Podesta

Proponents of the Pizzagate conspiracy theory falsely claimed the emails contained coded messages that connected several high-ranking Democratic Party officials and US restaurants with an alleged child sex trafficking ring.

One of the establishments allegedly involved was the Comet Ping Pong pizzeria in Washington DC.)

Above: Democratic Party donkey logo

QAnon is a political conspiracy theory that later evolved into a political movement.

It originated in the American far right political sphere.

QAnon centres on false claims made by an anonymous individual or individuals known as “Q“.

They claim that a cabal of Satanic, cannibalistic sexual abusers of children operating a global child sex trafficking ring conspired against former US President Donald Trump during his term in office.

Some experts have described QAnon as a cult.

Above: QAnon flag featuring the Q logo and the movement’s prominent slogan “Where we go one, we go all”, at a rally in Richmond, Virginia, in 2020

Followers of the conspiracy theory say that Trump was planning mass arrests and executions of thousands of cabal members on a day known as “the Storm” or “the Event“.

QAnon supporters have named Democratic politicians, Hollywood actors, high-ranking government officials, business tycoons, and medical experts as members of the cabal.

QAnon has also claimed that Trump stimulated the conspiracy of Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential election to enlist Robert Mueller to join him in exposing the sex trafficking ring, and to prevent a coup d’état by Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and George Soros.

Above: Robert Mueller

QAnon is described as antisemetic, due to its fixation on Jewish financier George Soros and conspiracy theories about the Rothschild family, a frequent target of antisemites.

Above: George Soros

It also has roots in the Internet conspiracy theory, Pizzagate.

QAnon’s conspiracy theories have been amplified by Russian and Chinese state-backed media companies, social media troll accounts, and the far-right Epoch Media Group.)

The platform has also been used to spread misinformation about the COVID-19 pandemic, such as clips from Plandemic.

TikTok removed some of these videos, and has generally added links to accurate COVID-19 information on videos with tags related to the pandemic.

On 10 August 2020, Emily Jacobssen wrote and sang “Ode To Remy“, a song praising the protagonist from Pixar’s 2007 computer-animated film Ratatouille.

The song rose to popularity when musician Daniel Mertzlufft composed a backing track to the song.

In response, a “crowdsourced” project called Ratatouille the Musical was begun.

Since Mertzlufft’s video, many new elements including costume design, additional songs, and a playbill have been created.

The trend has been even been noticed by Lou Romano (who voiced Alfredo Linguini in the original film), Broadway performer Kevin Chamberlin, and Disney Channel actor Milo Manheim.

On 1 January 2021, a full one-hour virtual presentation of Ratatouille the Musical premiered on the Today Tix.

The production featured elements created via TikTok.

It starred Titus Burgess as Remy, Wayne Brady as Django, Adam Lambert as Emile, Chamberlin as Gusteau, Andrew Barth Feldman as Linguini, Ashley Park as Colette, Priscilla Lopez as Mabel, Mary Testa as Skinner, and André de Shields as Ego.

Several food trends have emerged on the platform, such as Dalgona coffee.

Above: Homemade Dalgona coffee

(Dalgona coffee is a beverage made by whipping equal parts instant coffee powder, sugar, and hot water until it becomes creamy and then adding it to cold or hot milk.

Occasionally, it is topped with coffee powder, cocoa, crumbled biscuits, or honey.

It was popularized on social media during the COVID-19 pandemic, when people refraining from going out started making videos of whipping the coffee at home, by hand without using electrical mixers. 

The name is derived from dalgona, a Korean sugar candy, due to the resemblance in taste and appearance, though most dalgona coffee doesn’t actually contain dalgona.)

Above: Dalgona – Korean sugar candy

Another TikTok usage that corresponds with engagement and bonds people in society is the use of “challenges“.

These could be on any related topic such as dances or cooking certain meals.

People see other people doing something that is trending and then it continues to spread until it is a viral trend which connects people from all over.

While TikTok has primarily been used for entertainment purposes, TikTok may soon have another use, that of a job resource with the idea that prospective employment seekers would send in videos rather than traditional resumes.

The form would most likely be a job search add-on.

TikTok has had favorable results in the past with people using the site to find jobs and may be expanding that need especially in the newer generations.

However, employers need to take care when viewing TikTok resumes that they are not being influenced by biases.

Employers can see people’s faces and physical traits which could potentially create diversity, equity and inclusion issues.

TikTok has provided a platform for users to create content not only for fun, but also for money.

As the platform has grown significantly over the past few years, it has allowed companies to advertise and rapidly reach their intended demographic through influencer marketing.

The platform’s AI algorithm also contributes to the influencer marketing potential, as it picks out content according to the user’s preference. 

Sponsored content is not as prevalent on the platform as it is on other social media apps, but brands and influencers still can make as much as they would if not more in comparison to other platforms.

Influencers on the platform who earn money through engagement, such as likes and comments, are referred to as “meme machines“.

In 2021, the New York Times reported that viral TikTok videos by young people relating the emotional impact of books on them, tagged with the label “BookTok” significantly drove sales of literature.

Publishers were increasingly using the platform as a venue for influencer marketing.

Z generation are more willing to spend their time on TikTok.

TikTok tends to appeal to younger users, as 41% of its users are between the ages of 16 and 24.

Among these TikTok users, 90% say they use the app daily.

TikTok’s geographical use has shown that 43% of new users are from India.

As of July 2020, there were over 90 million monthly active users in the United States alone.

In October 2020, the ecommerce platform Shopify added TikTok to its portfolio of social media platforms, allowing online merchants to sell their products directly to consumers on TikTok.

Some small businesses have used TikTok to advertise and to reach an audience wider than the geographical region they would normally serve.

The viral response to many small business TikTok videos has been attributed to TikTok’s algorithm, which shows content that viewers at large are drawn to, but which they are unlikely to actively search for (such as videos on unconventional types of businesses, like beekeeping and logging).

In 2020, digital media companies, such as Group Nine Media and CDS Global, used TikTok increasingly, focusing on tactics such as brokering partnerships with TikTok influencers and developing branded content campaigns.

Above: Logo of Group Nine Media

Notable collaborations between larger brands and top TikTok influencers have included Chipotle’s partnership with David Dobrik in May 2019 and Dunkin’ Donuts’ partnership with Charli D’Amelio in September 2020.

Above: David Dobrik

Popular TikTok users have lived collectively in collab houses, predominately in the Los Angeles area.

Some users may find it hard to stop using TikTok.

In April 2018, an addiction-reduction feature was added to Douyin.

This encouraged users to take a break every 90 minutes.

Later in 2018, the feature was rolled out to the TikTok app.

TikTok uses some top influencers, such as Gabe Erwin, Alan Chikin Chow, James Henry, and Cosette Rinab, to encourage viewers to stop using the app and take a break.

Above: Gabe Erwin

Many were also concerned with users’ attention spans with these videos.

Users watch short 15-second clips repeatedly and studies say that this could result in a decreased attention span.

This is a concern as many of TikTok’s audience are younger children, whose brains are still developing.

Some countries have shown concerns regarding the content on TikTok, as their cultures views it as obscene, immoral, vulgar, and encouraging pornography.

There have been temporary blocks and warnings issued by countries including Indonesia, Bangladesh, India and Pakistan over the content concerns.

In 2018, Douyin was reprimanded by Chinese media watchdogs for showing “unacceptable” content.

On 27 July 2020, Egypt sentenced five women to two years in prison over TikTok videos.

One of the women had encouraged other women to try and earn money on the platform, another woman was sent to prison for dancing.

The court also imposed a fine of 300,000 Egyptian pounds (UK£14,600) on each defendant.

Above: Flag of Egypt

Concerns have been voiced regarding content relating to, and the promotion and spreading of, hateful words and far-right extremism, such as anti-semitism, racism, and xenophobia.

Some videos were shown to expressly deny the existence of the Holocaust and told viewers to take up arms and fight in the name of white supremacy and the swastika.

Above: Scene from the Holocaust (1941 – 1945) – Selection on the ramp at Auschwitz, May 1944

As TikTok has gained popularity among young children, and the popularity of extremist and hateful content is growing, calls for tighter restrictions on their flexible boundaries have been made.

TikTok have since released tougher parental controls to filter out inappropriate content and to ensure they can provide sufficient protection and security.

A viral TikTok trend known as “devious licks” involves students vandalizing or stealing school property and posting the videos of the action on the platform.

The trend has led to increasing school vandalism and subsequent measures taken by some schools to prevent damage.

Some students have been arrested for participating in the trend. 

TikTok has taken measures to remove and prevent access to content displaying the trend.

The Wall Street Journal has reported that doctors experienced a surge in reported cases of tics, tied to an increasing number of TikTok videos from content creators with Tourette syndrome.

Doctors suggested that the cause may be a social one as users who consumed content showcasing various tics would sometimes develop tics of their own.

In January 2020, Media Matters for America said that TikTok hosted misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic despite a recent policy against misinformation.

In April 2020, the government of India asked TikTok to remove users posting misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic.

There were also multiple conspiracy theories that the government is involved with the spread of the pandemic.

As a response to this, TikTok launched a feature to report content for misinformation.

TikTok’s censorship policy has been criticized as non-transparent. 

Criticism of leaders, such as Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump, Barack Obama, Mahatma Gandhi and Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, has been suppressed by the platform, as well as information relating to the Xinjiang internment camps and the abuse of Uyghurs in the region. 

Above: Xinjiang Re-education Camp

Internal documents have revealed that moderators suppress posts created by users deemed “too ugly, poor, or disabled” for the platform, and censor political speech in livestreams.

TikTok moderators have also blocked content that could be perceived as being positive towards LGBT people.

Above: Rainbow flag of the LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender) community

In October 2019, TikTok removed about two dozen accounts that were responsible for posting ISIS propaganda on the app.

Above: Islamic State (ISIS / ISIL / Daesh) flag

Privacy concerns have also been brought up regarding the app.

In its privacy policy, TikTok lists that it collects usage information, IP addresses, a user’s mobile carrier, unique device identifiers, keystroke patterns, and location data, among other data.

Web developers Talal Haj Bakry and Tommy Mysk said that allowing videos and other content being shared by the app’s users through HTTP puts the users’ data privacy at risk.

Above: The Internet Messenger, Holon, Israel

In January 2020, Check Point Research discovered a security flaw in TikTok which could have allowed hackers access to user accounts using SMS.

In February, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman criticized the app, calling it “spyware” and stating:

I look at that app as so fundamentally parasitic, that it’s always listening, the fingerprinting technology they use is truly terrifying, and I could not bring myself to install an app like that on my phone.

Responding to Huffman’s comments, TikTok stated:

These are baseless accusations made without a shred of evidence.” 

Above: Steve Huffmann

American multinational financial services company Wells Fargo banned the app from its devices due to privacy and security concerns.

In May 2020, the Dutch Data Protection Authority announced an investigation into TikTok in relation to privacy protections for children.

In June 2020, the European Data Protection Board announced that it would assemble a task force to examine TikTok’s user privacy and security practices.

In August 2020, the Wall Street Journal reported that TikTok tracked Android user data, including MAC addresses and IMEIs, with a tactic in violation of Google’s policies.

The report sparked calls in the US Senate for the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to launch an investigation.

In June 2021, TikTok updated its privacy policy to include collection of biometric data, including “faceprints and voiceprints“.

Some experts reacted by calling the terms of collection and data use “vague” and “highly problematic“.

The same month, CNBC reported that former employees had stated that “the boundaries between TikTok and ByteDance were so blurry as to be almost non-existent” and that “ByteDance employees are able to access US user data” on TikTok.

In October 2021, following the Facebook Files and controversies about social media ethics, a bipartisan group of lawmakers also pressed TikTok, YouTube, and Snapchat on questions of data privacy and moderation for age appropriate content.

(In 2021, an internal document leak from the company then known as Facebook (now Meta Platforms, or Meta) showed it was aware of harmful societal effects from its platforms.

The leak, released by whistleblower Frances Haugen, resulted in reporting from The Wall Street Journal in September, as The Facebook Files series, as well as the Facebook Papers, by a consortium of news outlets the next month.

Primarily, the reports proved that based on internally commissioned studies, the company was fully aware of negative impact on teenage users of Instagram, and the contribution of Facebook activity to violence in developing countries.

Other takeaways of the leak include the impact of the company’s platforms on spreading false information and promoting anger-provoking posts.

Furthermore, harmful content had be known to be pushed through Facebook algorithms reaching young users.

The type of content included anorexia posts and self harm photos.)

Above: Frances Haugen

The New York Times reported:

Lawmakers also hammered the head of US policy at TikTok, Mr. Beckerman, about whether TikTok’s Chinese ownership could expose consumer data to Beijing,”

stating that:

Critics have long argued that the company would be obligated to turn Americans’ data over to the Chinese government if asked.”

TikTok told US lawmakers it does not give information to China’s government.

TikTok’s representative stated that TikTok’s data is stored in the US with backups in Singapore.

According to the company’s representative, TikTok had ‘no affiliation‘ with the subsidiary Beijing ByteDance Technology, in which the Chinese government has a minority stake and board seat.

Above: National emblem of China

As with other platforms, journalists in several countries have raised privacy concerns about the app, because it is popular with children and has the potential to be used by sexual predators.

Several users have reported endemic cyberbullying on TikTok, including racism and ableism. 

In December 2019, following a report by German digital rights group Netzpolitik.org, TikTok admitted that it had suppressed videos by disabled users as well as LGBTQ+ users in a purported effort to limit cyberbullying.

TikTok’s moderators were also told to suppress users with “abnormal body shape“, “ugly facial looks“, “too many wrinkles“, or in “slums, rural fields” and “dilapidated housing” to prevent bullying.

In 2021 the platform revealed that it will be introducing a feature that will prevent teenagers from receiving notifications past their bedtime.

The company will no longer send push notifications after 9 pm to users aged between 13 and 15.

For 16-year-olds and those aged 17 notifications will not be sent after 10 pm.

TikTok has received criticism for enabling children to spend large sums of money purchasing coins to send to other users.

TikTok, as with anything else, has its angels and demons, its opportunities and its threats.

Am I cozy with the notion of creating more of a digital presence for myself?

Not yet.

But I have come to realize that a silent voice in a digital age does not get the attention it might deserve.

If I want people to recognize my talents I need to shine a spotlight upon them.

I am not seeking fame, but I am seeking respectful recognition.

TikTok and YouTube attract attention.

The latter seems more of a comfortable fit for me than the former.

For now.

Above: John C. Reilly, “Mr. Cellophane“, Chicago

The blog will eventually lead to the video.

The video will lead back to the blog.

Blogs began as diary entries about people’s personal experiences and/or hobbies.

This is the stage where I am at.

Now, blogs feature content targeted to particular audiences and focused on specific subjects.

Bloggers pick a topic, often in a niche, about which to write.

While bloggers may write about personal experiences, business, news, politics, hobbies, sports, health, opinions, or just about anything else, blogs are anything but personal in the sense that bloggers publish them in cyberspace for anyone and everyone to read.

Writing a blog is about as public as you can get.

You may choose to write about a personal topic, but you will do it publicly on the Internet.

Many blogs offer commentary on a particular subject, cover various aspects of the news, or offer expert advice on a specific topic.

Blogs often combine text with images, include audio and video, and provide links to other similar blogs, websites and online resources.

Readers can comment on posts, making blogs interactive.

A blog is a type of website.

It provides an online presence manageable by even the least tech-savvy person – a website solution for the technologically challenged.

Above: Chris O’Dowd (Roy Trenneman), Scene from The IT Crowd

Anyone who can write – and whose writing is worth reading – can blog.

(Actually lots of people who have scant writing ability and no worth reading have blogs, write and publish posts, call themselves bloggers.)

According to http://www.WPVirtuoso.com, in 2013 there were approximately 152 million blogs on the Internet, with more added every minute.

In fact, at the time of this report, the site claimed that 172,800 blogs were being added to the Internet every day.

That is about 40 new blogs per minute or 2,395 per hour.

As of 2013, 22% (or 2,200,000) of the top 10 million websites ran on WordPress.

That same year, WordPress.com reported having 63 million + websites.

What is the point?

Each one of these blogs represents a subject.

You can blog about nearly anything.

And most importantly…..

A blog allows you to publish as you write.

I humbly believe that I can write.

But I need to occasionally be changing my thinking cap from the hat of a writer to that of a business person.

Do I have the instinct, the insight, the imagination and enthusiasm to be a travel writer?

A travel blogger?

Can I cultivate the ability to not only ask what can be seen, but as well the courage to ask who, how and why?

I believe every place, every person, has a story to tell.

But do I have the necessary perception needed to delve more deeply, to observe more carefully, to focus more clearly to find the humanity of the places of which I wish to write?

Do I have the instinct?

Do I have the impulse that moves a man to the right place at the right time?

Do I have the insight, that quality of discernment that apprehends the inner nature of things?

Do I have imagination, the creative ability to visualise something not currently in view?

Do I have enthusiasm, the force that propels a person forwsrd and ferries the reader forwards?

Do I have the curiosity, the inquisitiveness, the readiness to “read the room”, to look through the looking glass, the drive to discover what is waiting around the bend in the road?

Ultimately I need faith in myself.

I need to be organized.

I need to look at a bigger picture, a bigger audience.

Challenge accepted.

Above: Neil Patrick Harris (Barney Stinson), How I Met Your Mother

Let me do that most democratic of actions while I still can.

Speak.

While there is still time…..

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Facebook / “Zambian promoting Aegean city with videos“, Hürriyet Daily News, 1 March 2022 / Lonely Planet, The Digital Nomad Handbook / Nina Amir, How to Blog a Book / Shashank Bengali and Parth M.N., “TikTok made stars of out of villagers in India, then it was banned“, Los Angeles Times, 19 May 2020 / Mark Harnett, A Quick Guide to Podcasting / Louise Purwin Zobel, The Travel Writer’s Handbook

Portrait of the artist

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Monday 24 January 2022

I read of Turkey and marvel.

Europe’s busiest airport shut down in Istanbul while schools and vaccination centres closed in Athens as a rare snowstorm blanketed swathes of the eastern Mediterranean region, causing blackouts and traffic havoc.

The work to clean the runway and taxiways continues at Istanbul Airport, where all flights were stopped until 18.00 due to heavy snowfall in Istanbul, Turkey

The closure of Istanbul Airport, where the roof of one of the cargo terminals collapsed under the heavy snow, causing no injuries, grounded flights stretching from the Middle East and Africa to Europe and Asia on Monday.

The work to clean the runway and taxiways continues, at Istanbul Airport, where all flights were stopped until 18.00 due to heavy snowfall in Istanbul, Turkiye

Travel officials told AFP news agency it marked the gleaming glass-and-steel structure’s first shutdown since it replaced Istanbul’s old Atatürk Airport as the new hub for Turkish Airlines in 2019.

Agence France-Presse Logo.svg
Above: Agence France Presse logo

Due to adverse conditions, all flights at Istanbul Airport have been temporarily stopped for flight safety,” the airport said in a statement on Twitter.

Twitter-logo.svg
Above: Twitter logo

The shutdown dealt a major headache to the 16 million residents of Turkey’s largest city, where cars ploughed into each other skidding down steep, sleet-covered streets and highways turned into parking lots.

The Istanbul governor’s office warned drivers they would not be able to enter the city from Thrace, a region stretching across the European part of Turkey to its western border with Bulgaria and Greece.

Shopping malls closed early, food delivery services shut down and the city’s iconic “simit” bagel stalls stood empty because suppliers could not make their way through the snow.

Snowstorm brings much of Turkey and Greece to a halt | News | DW |  24.01.2022

Traffic officials also closed major roads across large parts of central and southeastern Turkey, a mountainous region first hit by a snowstorm last week.

Snowfall, blizzards bear down on Turkey, shut down roads | Daily Sabah

Istanbul Airport serviced more than 37 million passengers last year, becoming one of the word’s most important air hubs.

But critics of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan had long questioned his decision to place the airport on a remote patch along the Black Sea coast that is often covered with fog in the winter.

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan 2021.jpg
Above: Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

Turkish Airlines said it was suspending all Istanbul Airport flights until at least 4am (01:00 GMT) on Tuesday.

Turkey: Airport warehouse roof collapses in snowstorm - BBC News

A few light taps upon the pane made him turn to the window.

It had begun to snow again.

He watched sleepily the flakes, silver and dark, falling obliquely against the lamplight.

The time had come for him to set out on his journey westward.

Yes, the newspapers were right:

Snow was general all over Ireland.

It was falling on every part of the dark central plain, on the treeless hills, falling softly upon the Bog of Allen and, farther westward, softly falling into the dark mutinous Shannon waves.

It was falling, too, upon every part of the lonely churchyard on the hill where Michael Furey lay buried.

It lay thickly drifted on the crooked crosses and headstones, on the spears of the little gate, on the barren thorns.

His soul swooned slowly as he heard the snow falling faintly through the universe and faintly falling, like the descent of their last end, upon all the living and the dead.

James Joyce, Dubliners

Joyce - Dubliners, 1914 - 3690390 F.jpg

Five times since my return to Switzerland have I travelled to St. Gallen and once more I anticipate visiting this city before I leave, God willing, on 15 February.

I have seen colleagues from my Starbucks days and it was good, but there is within me a sense of apartness, of alienation.

A view of St. Gallen
Above: St. Gallen, Switzerland

Stephen watched the three glasses being raised from the counter as his father and his two cronies drank to the memory of their past.

An abyss of fortune or of temperament sundered him from them. 

His mind seemed older than theirs:

It shone coldly on their strifes and happiness and regrets like a moon upon a younger Earth.

No life or youth stirred in him as it had stirred in them.

He had known neither the pleasure of companionship with others nor the vigour of rude male health nor filial piety.

Nothing stirred within his soul but a cold and cruel and loveless lust.

His childhood was dead or lost and with it his soul capable of simple joys.

He was drifting amid life like the barren shell of the Moon.

Art thou pale for weariness
Of climbing Heaven and gazing on the Earth,
Wandering companionless…?

He repeated to himself the lines of Shelley’s fragment.

Its alternation of sad human ineffectiveness with vast inhuman cycles of activity chilled him, and he forgot his own human and ineffectual grieving…..

To merge his life in the common tide of other lives was harder for him than any fasting or prayer, and it was his constant failure to do this to his own satisfaction which caused in his soul at last a sensation of spiritual dryness together with a growth of doubts and scruples….

It wounded him to think that he would never be but a shy guest at the feast of the world’s culture and that the monkish learning, in terms of which he was striving to forge out an esthetic philosophy, was held no higher by the age he lived in than the subtle and curious jargons of heraldry and falconry…..

I will tell you what I will do and what I will not do.

I will not serve that in which I no longer believe, whether it call itself my home, my fatherland, or my church:

And I will try to express myself in some mode of life or art as freely as I can and as wholly as I can, using for my defence the only arms I allow myself to use — silence, exile and cunning.

James Joyce, Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man

A book cover. It is entirely blue, and has "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man ~ James Joyce" embossed on it.

Joyce eloped from Ireland in borrowed boots in 1904.

He fled both world wars to the safety of Zürich.

Zürich.jpg
Above: Zürich, Switzerland

Think you are escaping and run into yourself.

Longest way round is the shortest way home.

James Joyce

TakeTheLongWayHome.jpg

We did not elope, my wife and I.

We met one another in Stratford-upon-Avon, England, when she was a 19-year-old medical student serving as an apprentice at a Liverpool hospital while I was a 30-year-old traveller working in Leicester.

Stratford-upon-Avon - panoramio (4).jpg
Above: Stratford-upon-Avon, England

I followed her to Freiburg im Breisgau, settling there in 2001, marrying there in 2005, leaving there that same year for Brombach (Lörrach) near the German-Swiss border at Basel, then moving again in 2008 to Osnabrück, and finally here to Landschlacht since 2010.

View over Freiburg
Above: Freiburg im Breisgau, Germany

Above: Brombach, Germany

City centre of Osnabrück
Above: Osnabrück, Germany

Above: Landschlacht, Switzerland

I have officially been living in both Eskişehir, Turkey, and Landschlacht, since 1 March 2021.

Above: Eskişehir, Turkey

Has escaping from Switzerland to Turkey made me feel like Switzerland is “home“?

Flag of Switzerland
Above: Flag of Switzerland

When the short days of winter came, dusk fell before we had well eaten our dinners.

When we met in the street the houses had grown sombre.

The space of sky above us was the colour of ever-changing violet and towards it the lamps of the street lifted their feeble lanterns.

The cold air stung us and we played till our bodies glowed.

Our shouts echoed in the silent street.

James Joyce, Dubliners

Portrait of James Joyce
Above: James Joyce (1882 – 1941)

Eloping from Ireland, via Paris, James Joyce and Nora Barnacle took a room in the Gasthaus Hoffnung (Hope) at 16 Reitergasse in Zürich.

This was where they consummated their union.

Hope often proved elusive during the decades ahead, but they were to stick by each other through poverty, two world wars, family crisis and literary fame.

They were to find themselves back in Zürich again and again, always by the skin of their teeth.

11 – 19 Oct 1904 & June/July 1915 | ZURICH JAMES JOYCE FOUNDATION
Above: Gasthaus Hoffnung, Zürich

My wife is a doctor and I am, at best, a freelance teacher of English-as-a-second-language.

She has had great success at the hospital near to our apartment.

Projekte Detailansicht
Above: Spital Thurgau, Münsterlingen

But for me Switzerland proved to be a reversal of fortunes.

Prior to the pandemic I who had once taught as many as 60 hours a week in Germany was reduced to teaching 3 hours a month.

The shortage of teaching hours compelled me to work at Starbucks in St. Gallen for five years.

Stadt St.Gallen | Starbucks Coffee Marktgasse

The resulting dissatisfaction compelled me to seek work away from Switzerland.

Through the help of a Starbucks colleague’s father I got the position at Wall Street Eskişehir, to which I shall soon return to.

We did not run from poverty, though we ran to the promise of profit.

Above: Wall Street English, Eskişehir

Switzerland has been neutral since the days of Napoleon.

Coat of arms of Switzerland
Above: Coat of arms of Switzerland

Fortunately neither my bride nor I have ever witnessed war directly, though I have a friend who once served in both Afghanistan and Iraq in a civilian capacity and my wife has a friend who for a time was a missionary in Afghanistan.

Flag of Afghanistan
Above: Flag of Afghanistan

Flag of Iraq
Above: Flag of Iraq

As for familial problems, well, who can say anyone has a choice in the families from whence they sprung?

Above: Clan tartan

As for literary fame, a writer needs literary product.

I am reminded of Stephen Leacock:

Mallory Tompkins had read all sorts of things and had half a mind to write a novel himself – either that or a play.

All he needed, he said, was to have a chance to get away somewhere by himself and think.

Every time he went away to the city Pipken expected that Mallory might return with the novel all finished, but though he often came back with his eyes red from thinking, the novel as yet remained incomplete.

The proprietor of the guesthouse behind the station was called Döblin.

Under the impression a job was waiting for him at the Berlitz School, Joyce next morning discovered to his dismay there was no such thing.

Zürich Switzerland-Münsterbrücke-and-Fraumünster-01.jpg
Above: Zürich

That situation I know only too well.

No photo description available.
Above: Photo of the blogger as a young man

Oxford, England, Thursday 21 October 1996

A day of betrayal and hope.

The Thames Valley Police (TVP) suggested that my poverty would be alleviated easier by charitable organizations if I received a police report about the Ramsgate robbery from the Kent County Constabulary.

The Margate crime desk quickly faxed a copy to the TVP.

The Salvation Army Majors Green provided payment for last night’s stay at the Oxford Backpackers Hostel, a bag of groceries, and a cap.

Met the sister of J, 24-year-old R.

She informed me that their mother is terminally ill with leukemia, that J got terminated from Argos, and that J doesn’t give a damn about how I am.

I start work tomorrow distributing handbills for a men’s fashion store.

From top left to bottom right: Oxford skyline panorama from St Mary's Church; Radcliffe Camera; High Street from above looking east; University College, main quadrangle; High Street by night; Natural History Museum and Pitt Rivers Museum
Above: Images of Oxford, England

The Director did his best to find the penniless Irish graduate a teaching position in Switzerland, but without success.

Writing to his brother Stanislaus, Joyce emphasized shortage of funds and the secrecy surrounding his elopement:

Go about the highways of the city but not to any of my touched friends and make up one pound before Saturday which send me on that day without fail.”

New Directions Publishing | Stanislaus Joyce
Above: Stanislaus Joyce (1884 – 1955)

In England I tried getting money from Canada but my request was refused.

I never asked again.

I would later find work in Oxford, Leicester, Nottingham, Cardiff, and Luxembourg-Ville, before returning back to Canada on 1 November 1997, have met my wife-to-be on 27 July 1997 as aforementioned.

Leicester landmarks: (clockwise from top-left) Jewry Wall, National Space Centre, Arch of Remembrance, Central Leicester, Curve theatre, Leicester Cathedral and Guildhall, Welford Road Stadium, Leicester Market
Above: Images of Leicester, England

Nottingham skyline (top), then beneath from top left: Robin Hood statue, Council House, NET tram, Trent Bridge, Castle Gate House, Wollaton Hall, Ye Olde Trip to Jerusalem, Nottingham Forest's City Ground
Above: Images of Nottingham, England

Clockwise from top left: The Senedd building, Principality Stadium, Cardiff Castle,[1] Cardiff Bay, Cardiff City Centre, City Hall clock tower, Welsh National War Memorial
Above: Images of Cardiff (Caerdydd), Wales (Cymru)

Skyline of Luxembourg City viewed over Grund and the Alzette
Above: Luxembourg-Ville, Luxembourg

A vertical triband design (red, white, red) with a red maple leaf in the center.
Above: Flag of Canada

The 22-year-old could not resist a laddish boast:

Finalement, elle n’est pas encore vièrge.

Elle est touchée.”

(Finally, she is no longer a virgin, she has been touched.)

The lovers spent a week in Zürich, kicking their heels.

Above: Zürich

I am not Joyce.

I do not believe in either bragging (or complaining) about my intimate (or inanimate) private life, real (or imagined).

Harry Styles Quote: “A gentleman doesn't kiss and tell.”

My baby makes me proud
Lord, don’t she make me proud
She never makes a scene
By hangin’ all over me in a crowd

‘Cause people like to talk
Lord, don’t they love to talk
But when they turn out the lights
I know she’ll be leavin’ with me

And when we get behind closed doors
Then she lets her hair hang down
And she makes me glad that I’m a man
Oh, no one knows what goes on behind closed doors

My baby makes me smile
Lord, don’t she make me smile
She’s never far away
Or too tired to say “I want you”

She’s always a lady
Just like a lady should be
But when they turn out the lights
She’s still a baby to me

‘Cause when we get behind closed doors
Then she lets her hair hang down
And she makes me glad I’m a man
Oh, no one knows what goes on behind closed doors
Behind closed doors.

Cover of the Behind Closed Doors album with the singer Charlie Rich in a cowboy hat.

Eventually a vacancy turned up in Trieste on the Adriatic.

They were off again.

That vacancy too proved as elusive as the Swiss one and they continued down the coast to Pola.

It was to be a vagabond life.

Above: Trieste, Italy

It has been suggested to me that a position might be waiting for me in Trieste after Eskişehir.

I am tempted.

Wall Street English logo.png

A decade later, in July 1914, Austria declared war on Serbia.

In August, Great Britain entered the war.

As holders of British passports, the Joyces in Austro-Hungarian Trieste grew worried.

Joyce’s brother was interned as an enemy alien in January 1915.

In May of that year, Italy mobilized its army, prompting anti-Italian demonstrations in Trieste.

Medium coat of arms (1867–1915) (see also Flags of Austria-Hungary) of Austria–Hungary
Above: Coat of arms of the Austro-Hungarian Empire (1867 – 1915)

Could war come again to Europe?

Europe orthographic Caucasus Urals boundary (with borders).svg
Above: Europe (in green)

The world wars ended the pre-eminent position of Britain, France and Germany in Europe and the world.

At the Yalta Conference, Europe was divided into spheres of influence between the victors of World War II, and soon became the principal zone of contention in the Cold War between the two power blocs, the Western countries and the Communist bloc.

Yalta Conference (Churchill, Roosevelt, Stalin) (B&W).jpg
Above: Yalta Conference: Winston Churchill, Franklin Delano Roosevelt and Joseph Stalin, February 1945

The United States and the majority of European liberal democracies at the time (United Kingdom, France, Italy, Netherlands, West Germany, etc.) established the NATO military alliance.

NATO OTAN landscape logo.svg
Above: Flag of NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization)

Later, the Soviet Union and its satellites (Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, East Germany, Hungary, Poland, and Romania) in 1955 established the Warsaw Pact as a counterpoint to NATO.

Warsaw Pact Logo.svg
Above: Logo of the Warsaw Pact

The Warsaw Pact had a much larger ground force, but the American-French-British nuclear umbrellas protected NATO.

North Atlantic Treaty Organization (orthographic projection).svg
Above: NATO members

Communist states were imposed by the Red Army in the East, while parliamentary democracy became the dominant form of government in the West.

Warsaw Pact in 1990 (orthographic projection).svg
Above: Warsaw Pact nations, 1990

Most historians point to its success as the product of exhaustion with war and dictatorship, and the promise of continued economic prosperity.

They also add that an important impetus came from the anti-Nazi wartime political coalitions.

The end of the Cold War came in a series of events from 1979 to 1991, mainly in Eastern Europe.

NATO vs. Warsaw (1949-1990).png
Above: NATO (blue) versus the Warsaw Pact (red)

In the end, these brought the fall of the Iron Curtain, German reunification and the end of Soviet control over their Eastern European satellites and their worldwide network of Communist parties in a friendly chain reaction from the Pan-European Picnic in 1989.

The finals brought the division of the Soviet Union into 15 non-Communist states in 1991.

White stone memorial, with steps and people escaping
Above: Pan-European Picnic Monument, Berlin, Germany

Observers at the time emphasized that:

The systemic and ideological confrontation between capitalism and communism had faded away.

The geopolitical partition of Europe was no more.

Nuclear deterrence was morphing into a less armed, almost hypothetical version of its previous self.

Superpower rivalry was rapidly wound up with cascading effects in various areas of the world.

Capitalism vs. Communism: Pros and Cons - Soapboxie
Above: Capitalism vs Communism

Following the end of the Cold War, the European Economic Community (EEC) pushed for closer integration, co-operation in foreign and home affairs, and started to increase its membership into the neutral and former Communist countries.

Flag of EEC/ECM
Above: Flag of the European Union

In 1993, the Maastricht Treaty established the European Union (EU), succeeding the EEC and furthering political co-operation.

The neutral countries of Austria, Finland and Sweden acceded to the EU, and those that didn’t join were tied into the EU’s economic market via the European Economic Area.

These countries also entered the Schengen Agreement which lifted border controls between member states.

The Maastricht Treaty created a single currency for most EU members.

The Euro was created in 1999 and replaced all previous currencies in participating states in 2002.

The most notable exception to the currency union, or Eurozone, was the United Kingdom, which also did not sign the Schengen Agreement.

Global European Union.svg
Above: The European Union

The EU did not participate in the Yugoslav Wars (1991 – 2001) and was divided on supporting the United States in the Iraq War (2003 – 2011).

Collage Yugoslav wars.jpg
Above: Images of the Yugoslav Wars

Iraq War montage.png
Above: Images of the Iraq War

NATO has been part of the war in Afghanistan (2001 – 2021), but at a much lower level of involvement than the United States.

Collage of the War in Afghanistan (2001-2021).png
Above: Images of the War in Afghanistan

In 2004, the EU gained ten new members:

(Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania (which had been part of the Soviet Union), the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia (five former Communist countries), Malta, and the divided island of Cyprus.)

Flag of Estonia
Above: Flag of Estonia

Flag of Latvia
Above: Flag of Latvia

Flag of Lithuania
Above: Flag of Lithuania

Flag of the Czech Republic
Above: Flag of the Czech Republic

Flag of Hungary
Above: Flag of Hungary

Flag of Poland
Above: Flag of Poland

Flag of Slovakia
Above: Flag of Slovakia

Flag of Slovenia
Above: Flag of Slovenia

Flag of Malta
Above: Flag of Malta

Flag of Cyprus
Above: Flag of Cyprus

These were followed by Bulgaria and Romania in 2007.

Flag of Bulgaria
Above: Flag of Bulgaria

Flag of Romania
Above: Flag of Romania

Russia’s regime had interpreted these expansions as violations against NATO’s promise to not expand “one inch to the east” in 1990. 

File:Flag of Russia.svg
Above: Flag of Russia

Russia engaged in a number of bilateral disputes about gas supplies with Belarus and Ukraine which endangered gas supplies to Europe.

Flag of Belarus
Above: Flag of Belarus

File:Flag of Ukraine.svg
Above: Flag of Ukraine

Russia also engaged in a minor war with Georgia in 2008.

Flag of Georgia
Above: Flag of Georgia

Supported by the United States and some European countries, Kosovo’s government unilaterally declared independence from Serbia on 17 February 2008.

Flag of Kosovo
Above: Flag of Kosovo

Public opinion in the EU turned against enlargement, partially due to what was seen as over-eager expansion including Turkey gaining candidate status.

Flag of Turkey
Above: Flag of Turkey

The European Constitution was rejected in France and the Netherlands, and then (as the Treaty of Lisbon) in Ireland, although a second vote passed in Ireland in 2009.

Flag of Ireland
Above: Flag of Ireland

The financial crisis of 2007 – 2008 affected Europe, and government responded with austerity measures.

Limited ability of the smaller EU nations (most notably Greece) to handle their debts led to social unrest, government liquidation, and financial insolvency.

Flag of Greece
Above: Flag of Greece

In May 2010, the German parliament agreed to loan €22.4 billion to Greece over three years, with the stipulation that Greece follow strict austerity measures.

Flag of Germany
Above: Flag of Germany

Beginning in 2014, Ukraine has been in a state of revolution and unrest with two breakaway regions (Donetsk and Lugansk) attempting to join Russia as full federal subjects.

Europe-Ukraine (и не контролируемые).png
Above: Ukraine (in green) / disputed territories (light green)

On 16 March, a referendum was held in Crimea leading to the de facto secession of Crimea and its largely internationally unrecognized annexation to the Russian Federation as the Republic of Crimea.

Above: Flag of Crimea

In June 2016, in a referendum in the United Kingdom on the country’s membership in the EU, 52% of voters voted to leave the EU, leading to the complex Brexit separation process and negotiations, which led to political and economic changes for both the UK and the remaining EU countries.

A flag composed of a red cross edged in white and superimposed on a red saltire, also edged in white, superimposed on a white saltire on a blue background
Above: Flag of the United Kingdom

The UK left the EU on 31 January 2020.

EU-Austritt (47521165961).svg
Above: Brexit flag

Later that year, Europe was affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Scientifically accurate atomic model of the external structure of SARS-CoV-2. Each "ball" is an atom.

According to the Wall Street Journal in 2021 as Angela Merkel stepped down as the highly popular Chancellort of Germany after 16 years:

Ms. Merkel leaves in her wake a weakened Europe, a region whose aspirations to act as a third superpower have come to seem ever more unrealistic.

When she became chancellor in 2005, the EU was at a high point:

It had adopted the euro, which was meant to rival the dollar as a global currency, and had just expanded by absorbing former members of the Soviet bloc.

Today’s EU, by contrast, is geographically and economically diminished.

Having lost the UK because of Brexit, it faces deep political and cultural divisions, lags behind in the global race for innovation and technology and is increasingly squeezed by the mounting US – China strategic rivalry.

Europe has endured thanks in part to Ms. Merkel’s pragmatic stewardship, but it has been battered by crises during her entire time in office.

Angela Merkel 2019 cropped.jpg
Above: Angela Merkel

Are Russian forces getting ready for war in Ukraine?

Russian TV shows tank exercises close to the border with Ukraine on 14 Jan 2022

US President Joe Biden is certainly expecting some kind of military move.

Russia wants the West to promise that Ukraine will not join its NATO defensive alliance, and although the two sides are negotiating, that is not going to happen.

What happens next could jeopardise Europe’s entire security structure.

Joe Biden presidential portrait.jpg
Above: US President Joe Biden

Russia denies it is planning any invasion, but it has seized Ukrainian territory before and it has an estimated 100,000 troops deployed near its borders.

Russia has long resisted Ukraine’s move towards European institutions, and NATO in particular.

Graphic showing positioning of Russian troops..

Ukraine shares borders with both the EU and Russia, but as a former Soviet republic it has deep social and cultural ties with Russia, and Russian is widely spoken there.

When Ukrainians deposed their pro-Russian president in early 2014, Russia annexed Ukraine’s southern Crimean peninsula and backed separatists who captured large swathes of eastern Ukraine.

The rebels have fought the Ukrainian military ever since in a conflict that has claimed more than 14,000 lives.

Coat of arms of Ukraine
Above: Coat of arms of Ukraine

Russia says it has no plans to attack Ukraine:

Armed forces chief Valery Gerasimov even denounced reports of an impending invasion as a lie.

Valery Gerasimov official photo version 2017-07-11.jpg
Above: Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, First Deputy Minister of Defence of the Russian Federation, General of the Army Valery Gerasimov

But tensions are high and President Vladimir Putin has threatened “appropriate retaliatory military-technical measures” if what he calls the West’s aggressive approach continues.

Vladimir Putin (2018-03-01) 03 (cropped).jpg
Above: Russian President Vladimir Putin

NATO’s secretary general warns the risk of conflict is real and President Biden says his guess is that Russia will move in.

The US says it knows of Russian plans to boost its forces near Ukraine “on very short notice“.

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg.jpg
Above: NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg

The US says Russia has offered no explanation for the troops posted close to Ukraine – and Russian troops and tanks have headed to Belarus for exercises.

Russia on the globe, with unrecognised territory shown in light green.[a]
Above: Russia (green) / disputed territory (light green)

Russia’s deputy foreign minister compared the current situation to the 1962 Cuban missile crisis, when the US and Soviet Union came close to nuclear conflict.

Soviet-R-12-nuclear-ballistic missile.jpg
Above: Soviet R12 nuclear ballistic missile

Western intelligence suggests a Russian incursion or invasion could happen some time in early 2022.

Spy vs. Spy Logotipe.png

Russia has spoken of a “moment of truth” in recasting its relationship with NATO:

For us it’s absolutely mandatory to ensure Ukraine never, ever becomes a member of NATO,” said Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov.

Moscow accuses NATO countries of “pumping” Ukraine with weapons and the US of stoking tensions.

President Putin has complained Russia has “nowhere further to retreat todo they think we’ll just sit idly by?

Sergei Ryabkov.jpg
Above: Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov

In reality, Russia wants NATO to return to its pre-1997 borders.

It demands no more eastward expansion and an end to NATO military activity in Eastern Europe.

That would mean combat units being pulled out of Poland and the Baltic republics of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, and no missiles deployed in countries such as Poland and Romania.

A graphic showing Nato's expansion since 1997

Map indicating locations of NATO and Russia
Above: NATO (green) / Russia (orange)

Russia has also proposed a treaty with the US barring nuclear weapons from being deployed beyond their national territories.

World War 3: Russia and UK's relationship eerily similar to historic NATO  war game | World | News | Express.co.uk

Russia seized Crimea in 2014 arguing it had a historic claim to it.

Ukraine was part of the Soviet Union, which collapsed in December 1991.

Putin said it was the “disintegration of historical Russia“.

A clue to President Putin’s thinking on Ukraine came in a lengthy piece last year when he called Russians and Ukrainians “one nation“.

He labelled Ukraine’s current leaders as running an “anti-Russian project“.

Flag of the Soviet Union
Above: Flag of the former Soviet Union (1922 – 1981)

Russia has also become frustrated that a 2015 Minsk peace deal for eastern Ukraine is far from being fulfilled.

There are still no arrangements for independently monitored elections in the separatist regions.

Russia denies accusations that it is part of the lingering conflict.

Minsk Protocol.svg
Above: A map of the buffer zone established by the Minsk Protocol

President Vladimir Putin has spoken several times to Biden and high level talks continue, but Russian officials have warned that Western rejection of their key demands are leading to a “dead end“.

The question is how far Russia will go.

Analysis: Joe Biden cranks up pressure as Vladimir Putin mulls Ukraine  invastion - CNNPolitics
Above: Joe Biden and Vladimir Putin

President Biden has warned that a full-scale invasion would be a disaster for Russia.

But if it was a minor incursion, he said controversially that the West would “end up having to fight about what to do“.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky visiting positions on the frontline with pro-Russian militants in the Donetsk region, Ukraine, 06 December 2021
Above: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on the front line on 6 December 2021

The White House has stressed any move across the border constitutes a renewed invasion – but points out Russia has other weapons, including cyber-attacks and paramilitary tactics.

The Pentagon has accused Russia of preparing a so-called false-flag operation, with operatives ready to carry out acts of sabotage against Russian-backed rebels, to provide a pretext for invasion. Russia has denied it.

The Pentagon, cropped square.png
Above: The Pentagon, HQ of the US Department of Defense, Arlington, Virginia

Russia has also handed out 500,000 passports in rebel-run areas, so if it does not get what it wants then it could justify any action as protecting its own citizens.

Map of eastern Ukraine

However, if Russia’s only aim is to force NATO away from its backyard, there is no sign of it succeeding.

NATO’s 30 members have turned down flat any attempt to tie their hands for the future.

We will not allow anyone to slam closed Nato’s open-door policy,” said US Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman.

Ukraine is looking for a clear timeline to join and NATO says Russia has “no veto, no right to interfere in that process”.

Deputy Secretary Sherman's Official Photo (51142275093).jpg
Above: US Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman

Non-NATO members Sweden and Finland have also rejected Russia’s attempt to stop them beefing up their ties with the alliance.

Flag of Sweden
Above: Flag of Sweden

Flag of Finland
Above: Flag of Finland

We will not let go of our room for manoeuvre,” said Finland’s prime minister.

Marin lapsen oikeuksien juhla
Above: Finnish Prime Minister Sanna Marin

The US has made clear it has no plans to send combat troops, while being committed to helping Ukraine defend its “sovereign territory“.

The main tools in the West’s armoury appears to be sanctions and military aid in the form of advisers and weapons.

Military strengths graphic

President Biden has threatened Russia’s leader with measures “like none he’s ever seen” if Ukraine is attacked.

So what would they involve?

The ultimate economic hit would be to disconnect Russia’s banking system from the international Swift payment system.

That has always been seen very much as a last resort, but Latvia has said it would send a strong message to Moscow.

SWIFT Logo
Above: Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunications logo

Another key threat is to prevent the opening of Russia’s Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline in Germany, and approval for that is currently being decided by Germany’s energy regulator.

Location of Nord Stream 1

There could also be measures targeting Russia’s RDIF sovereign wealth fund or restrictions on banks converting roubles into foreign currency.

RDIF.svg

Washington has said it is committed to “working in lockstep” with its allies, but there are divisions between the US and Europe.

European leaders are adamant that Russia cannot just decide on the future with the US.

France has even proposed that Europeans work together with NATO and then conduct their own dialogue with Russia.

File:Flag of France (1794–1815, 1830–1974, 2020–present).svg
Above: Flag of France

Ukraine’s president wants an international summit to resolve the conflict, involving France and Germany along with Russia.

Volodymyr Zelensky Official portrait.jpg
Above: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky

Another World War?

Unlikely.

A war over Ukraine similar to past conflicts over the Korean Peninsula and Indochina?

Maybe.

Korean War Montage 2.png
Above: Images of the Korean War (1950 – 1953)

VNWarMontage.png
Above: Images of the Vietnam War (1955 – 1975)

Switzerland again a sanctuary from war?

Above: Map of Switzerland (German language)

There has been significant immigration to Switzerland since the 1960s.

By contrast, during the 19th century, emigration from Switzerland was more common, as Switzerland was economically a poor country where a large fraction of the population survived on subsistence farming.

The largest immigrant groups in Switzerland are those from Italy, Germany, the former Yugoslavia, Albania, Portugal and Turkey (Turks and Kurds).

Between them, these six groups account for about 1.5 million people, 60% of the Swiss population with immigrant background, or close to 20% of total Swiss population.

How many migrants settle in Switzerland? | nccr – on the move

The current federal law of 16 December 2005, on foreigners (the Foreign Nationals Act) came into force on 1 January 2008, replacing the Federal Act on the Residence and Establishment of Foreigners of 1931.

Swizerland and Australia, with about a quarter of their population born outside the country, are the two countries with the highest proportion of immigrants in the western world, although who counts as an immigrant varies from country to country, and even between agencies within countries.

A blue field with the Union Flag in the upper hoist quarter, a large white seven-pointed star in the lower hoist quarter, and constellation of five white stars in the fly – one small five-pointed star and four, larger, seven-pointed stars.
Above: Flag of Australia

Some countries naturalise immigrants easily, while others make it much more difficult, which means that such comparisons ought to be treated with caution.

Switzerland also has the highest Potential Net Migration Index of any European country by a large margin, at +150% (followed by Sweden at +78%) according to a 2010 Gallup study:

This means that out of an estimated 700 million potential migrants worldwide, about 12 million (150% of Swiss resident population) would name Switzerland as their most desired country of residence. 

Residents with migration background are twice as likely to be unemployed.

Logo Gallup.svg

Switzerland doesn’t have much in common with Mars, but that doesn’t stop a foreigner from feeling like they have landed on another planet upon arrival.

They call people living in a country without holding its citizenship “resident aliens” and it is not without reason.

For even though Swiss trains are efficient (at least according to the lore), Swiss bureaucracy is not.

It is a new place.

You cannot just stand there and stare at it.

You have got to listen to what it is trying to tell you.

But there is much difficulty doing even the simple things.

It is not supposed to be a land of hardship.

It is supposed to be a land of cheese, chocolate and tax evaders.

Things are supposed to be both delicious and easy.

Delicious?

Yes.

Easy?

Absolutely not.

What can an immigrant do?

Give up?

It is tempting.

It is said that people who live abroad are more creative than people who do not.

Perhaps this has more to do with desperation than with inspiration.

Panozzo Chantal-999 Ways To Travel Switzerland BOOK NEW 9780990315537 | eBay

Though I had not given up my career, my career seemed to have given up on me after I moved to Switzerland so my wife could advance hers.

I came to realize that outside of institutions like school and work or outside of my mother tongue of English, I had come to rely on these to make friends.

I never considered how lonely life can be in Switzerland, wife notwithstanding.

As hard as it is to find permanent full-time employment as an ESL teacher in Switzerland, I found myself not at peace with my place as the trailing spouse and being asked to accept my fate accordingly.

I tried – for a decade – but a temp job at Starbucks that lasted five years but offered neither job security nor any incentive to seek promotion….

I seized an opportunity.

Out.

Turkish Airlines logo 2019 compact.svg

Despite the encroaching debacle, Joyce was gestating the novel that would make his name and send his own salvoes across the literary landscape.

In a letter to Ezra Pound, Joyce informed the poet that he had already completed the first two episodes of Ulysses:

And so, on 28 June 1915, leaving behind all their furniture and belongings, the Joyce family were able to leave for Zürich from the Southern Railway Station.

Weighed down with suitcases, which fortunately were not checked by the Austrian police at the border, they took a train bound for Innsbruck through the Brenner Pass.

They were to come back for less than nine months at the end of the war after Trieste had become Italian, but only to depart once more, in 1920, for Paris.

Never to return.

James Joyce Ulysses 1st Edition 1922 GB.jpg

I confess I hate the words “never to return” or “burning bridges behind“, but as much as I valued my time at Starbucks, I hope I never return to work there again.

Starbucks Corporation Logo 2011.svg
Above: Starbucks logo

Their train was detained at Innsbruck to allow the Emperor’s train to pass.

Logo ÖBB.svg
Above: Austrian Federal Railways (Österreichische Bundesbahnen) logo

Innsbruck, Austria, 19 October 1997

Sprawling beneath the mountain ridge of the Nordkette, Innsbruck is the only major urban centre in Austria with an array of high Alps on its own doorstep.

The visitor can visit museums in the morning, walk up mountains in the afternoon and bar-hop well into the early hours.

With the Tyrol’s largest concentration of mountain resorts in such close proximity, skiing is obviously big news here.

Panorama insbruck4.jpg
Above: Innsbruck, Austria

Hosting the Winter Olympics in 1964 and 1976 provided the city with a wealth of sporting and tourist facilities to call its own.

1964 Winter Olympics logo.svg

1976 Winter Olympics logo.svg

For those who just want a taste of history, Innsbruck’s compact centre – a classic Austrian hybrid of the Gothic and Baroque – invites aimless strolling.

It is also a thriving commercial centre that depends on more than just tourism for its living.

Innsbruck - Altes Landhaus (Tiroler Landtag)1 (cropped).jpg
Above: Altes Landhaus, Innsbruck

Innsbruck has a down-to-earth unpretentious air quite different to that of western Austria’s other main urban centre, self-possessed Salzburg.

Salzburg (48489551981).jpg
Above: Salzburg, Austria

Innsbruck is the nation’s 3rd biggest university city after Vienna and Graz, its sizable student population helping to support a range of cultural and nightlife options wide enough to suit most tastes.

Above: Wien (Vienna), Österreich (Austria)

19-06-14-Graz-Murinsel-Schloßberg-RalfR.jpg
Above: Graz, Austria

It is an easy city to explore, with many of its tourist attractions only a few paces apart.

A great deal of sightseeing can be achieved in the space of a day.

And I did my best to see everything in a day:

  • the Golden Roof of the Maximilianeum Museum

Above: Goldenes Dach (Golden Roof), Innsbruck

  • the Helblinghaus

Above: Helblinghaus (Sebastian Helbling House), Innsbruck

  • the Stadtturm

Stadtturm (Innsbruck) – Wikipedia
Above: Stadtturm (City Tower), Innsbruck

  • the Domkirche St. Jakob

Cathedral of St. James Facade 1.jpg
Above: Innsbruck Cathedral

  • the Hofburg

Above: Hofburg (Court Castle / Imperial Palace), Innsbruck

  • the Hofkirche

Innsbruck, die Hofkirche Dm64204 poging2 foto7 2017-07-30 13.39.jpg
Above: Hofkirche (Court Church), Innsbruck

  • the Cenotaph of Emperor Maximilian I (1459 – 1519)

Above: Cenotaph of Emperor Maximilian I, Hofkirche, Innsbruck

  • the Tiroler Volkskunstmuseum

Above: Tiroler Volkskunstmuseum (Tyrolean Folk Art Museum), Innsbruck

  • Tiroler Landesmuseum Ferdinandeum

Above: Ferdinandeum (Tyrolean State Museum), Innsbruck

  • the Zeughaus

Above: Zeughaus (Armoury), Innsbruck

  • the Annasäule

Innsbruck Annasäule from c.N.jpg
Above: Annasäule (St. Anne’s Column), Innsbruck

  • the Alpenverein Museum

Above: Hofburg, which houses the Alpenverein Museum (Alpine Club Museum), Innsbruck

  • the Galerie Taxispalais

Portal Taxispalais.jpg
Above: Taxispalais (Taxis Palace)

  • the Triumphpforte….

Above: Triumphpforte (Arch of Triumph), Innsbruck

But I was, for once, not in Innsbruck to play tourist.

Coat of arms of Innsbruck
Above: Coat of arms of Innsbruck

I was there for a woman.

I had met O at the sunset of a relationship and prior to the sunrise of the relationship in which I have since remained for a quarter of a century.

Histoire d o.jpg

W was Welsh and was most determined to show me Wales.

And show me Wales, she did.

Flag of Wales
Above: Flag of Wales

  • Borth
  • Cardigan Bay

Borth - 2008-03-01.jpg
Above: Borth and Cardigan Bay, Wales

  • Machynlleth

Central Machynlleth, June 2016.jpg
Above: Machynlleth, Wales

  • Porthmadog

Porthmadog - Harbour.JPG
Above: Porthmadog, Wales

  • the Ffestiniog Railway

Above: Ffestiniog Railway train leaves Porthmadog and heads towards Blaenau Ffestiniog along the Cob, Wales

  • Harlech

Harlech Castle - Cadw photograph.jpg
Above: Harlech Castle, Harlech, Wales

  • Barmouth

Barmouth.jpg
Above: Barmouth, Wales

  • Bala

Welcome to Visit Bala | Visit Bala | Visit Bala
Above: High Street, Bala, Wales

  • Llanuwchllyn

Llanuwchllyn.jpg
Above. High Street, Llanuwchllyn, Wales

  • the Bala Lake Railway

Bala Lake Railway - 2004-07-18.jpg
Above: The Alice, Llanuwchllyn, Bala Lake Railway, Wales

  • Llangollen

Llangollen Church.jpg
Above: Llangollen, Wales

  • Dolgellau

Above: Dolgellau, Wales

  • Betws-Y-Coed

Betws-y-Coed - geograph.org.uk - 1917328.jpg
Above: Betws-y-Coed, Wales

  • Conwy

Conwy Castle and Bridges.jpg
Above: Conwy, Wales

  • Beaumaris

Beaumaris Castle (8074243202).jpg
Above: Beaumaris Castle, Beaumaris, Wales

  • Bangor

Above: Bangor, Wales

  • and back in England (but feeling Welsh), Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury panorama.jpeg
Above: Shrewsbury, England

In Bangor, W and I stayed at the Tan-y-Bryn Youth Hostel.

Tan-y-bryn | Coflein

After a long day wherein we saw the Bangor Theatre, the Menai Straits and Pier, Bangor Cathedral and Bangor University and Penrhyn Castle, ate Chinese food, and drank Dogbolters at the Ffesant and Firkin Brewery Pub, we found ourselves chatting in the common room of the Hostel – W and I, O of Innsbruck and S of Ljubjana.

Theatr Gwynedd in Bangor, GB - Cinema Treasures
Above: Theatr Gwynedd, Bangor, Wales

Menai Straights.jpg
Above: Aerial view of the Menai Straits

Bangor Pier - geograph.org.uk - 1287040.jpg
Above: Garth Pier, Bangor, Wales

Bangor Cathedral from Bangor Mountain.jpg
Above: Bangor Cathedral

Bangor University.svg

Penrhyn Castle Wales 015.jpg
Above. Penrhyn Castle, Wales

Coc Y Gath! Too Much Burton Snatch For Me.
Above: Former location of the FFesant and Firkin pub, Bangor, Wales

YHA logo (green triangle with initials YHA)
Above: Youth Hostels Association (England and Wales) logo

S excused himself as did W excuse herself, surrendering to fatigue.

O and I spoke for hours more.

O and I kept up intimate correspondence before Innsbruck and for a short time afterwards.

I read the situation wrong and thought there was a connection between us.

I was wrong.

Innsbruck remains tainted.

View of Innsbruck by Albrecht Dürer, 1495 

Joyce had declared earlier in Trieste:

Kings are mountebanks.

(A mountebank is a person who deceives others, especially in order to trick them out of their money, a charlatan.)

(Yes, I had to look this up.)

Emperor Charles I of Austria.jpg
Above: Emperor Charles I of Austria (1887 – 1922)(r. 1916 – 1918)

Republics are slippers for everyone’s feet.”

May be an image of footwear and text that says 'Do these look like they're Laughing or Have i gone crazy?'

I am certain that his friend Ezra Pound would have approved.

photograph of Ezra H. Pound
Above: Ezra Pound, 1913

Ezra Pound (1885 – 1972) was an expatriate American poet and critic, a major figure in the early modernist poetry movement, and a fascist collaborator in Italy during World War II.

His works include Ripostes (1912), Hugh Selwyn Mauberley (1920), and his 800-page epic poem, The Cantos (1917 – 1962).

EzraPound Ripostes.png

Pound’s contribution to poetry began in the early 20th century with his role in developing imagism, a movement stressing precision and economy of language.

Working in London as foreign editor of several American literary magazines, he helped discover and shape the work of contemporaries such as T.S. Eliot, Ernest Hemingway, and James Joyce.

Eliot in 1934 by Lady Ottoline Morrell
Above: Thomas Stearns Eliot (1888 – 1965)

He was responsible for the 1914 serialization of Joyce’s A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, the 1915 publication of Eliot’s “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock“, and the serialization from 1918 of Joyce’s Ulysses.

Hemingway wrote in 1932 that, for poets born in the late 19th or early 20th century, not to be influenced by Pound would be “like passing through a great blizzard and not feeling its cold.”

Dark-haired man in light colored short-sleeved shirt working on a typewriter at a table on which sits an open book
Above: Ernest Hemingway (1899 – 1961)

Angered by the carnage of World War I, Pound blamed the war on finance capitalism, which he called “usury” (the practice of making unethical or immoral monetary loans that unfairly enrich the lender).

WWImontage.jpg
Above: Images of World War I (1914 – 1918)

Pound moved to Italy in 1924 and through the 1930s and 1940s promoted an economic theory known as social credit, wrote for publications owned by the British fascist Sir Oswald Mosley, embraced Benito Mussolini’s fascism, and expressed support for Adolf Hitler.

Oswald mosley MP.jpg
Above: Oswald Mosley (1896 – 1980)

Mussolini biografia.jpg
Above: Benito Mussolini (1883 – 1945)

Portrait of Adolf Hitler, 1938
Above: Adolf Hitler (1889 – 1945)

During World War II and the Holocaust in Italy, Pound made hundreds of paid radio broadcasts for the Italian government, including in German-occupied Italy, attacking the United States, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Great Britain, international finance, munitions makers and mongers, and Jews, among others, as causes, abettors and prolongers of the world war.

Above: Ezra Pound, 1920

FDR 1944 Color Portrait.jpg
Above: Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1882 – 1945)

As a result of which Pound was arrested in 1945 by American forces in Italy on charges of treason.

Photograph of a man

He spent months in a US military camp in Pisa, including three weeks in an outdoor steel cage.

Photograph of steel cages
Above: Pound spent three weeks in the reinforced cage on the far left.

Deemed unfit to stand trial, he was incarcerated in St. Elizabeths Psychiatric Hospital in Washington DC, for over 12 years.

photograph
Above: St. Elizabeth’s Psychiatric Hospital, Washington DC

While in custody in Italy, Pound began work on sections of The Cantos that were published as The Pisan Cantos (1948), for which he was awarded the Bollingen Prize for Poetry in 1949 by the Library of Congress, causing enormous controversy.

After a campaign by his fellow writers, he was released from St. Elizabeths in 1958 and lived in Italy until his death in 1972.

His economic and political views have ensured that his life and work remain controversial.

The Cantos by Ezra Pound - Paperback - 3rd - 1996 - from Philosophia &  Litterae (SKU: 022)

Sometimes I wonder if, in the eyes of some still, whether an American reading Pound is akin to a German buying art from Hitler’s Viennese period.

Above: Der Alte Hof in München, Adolf Hitler, 1914

Nonetheless, Joyce’s 11 years in Trieste under Austro-Hungarian rule -“Each archduke proud, the whole jimbang crowd” – had been benign.

When 23 year-old Joyce first moved to Trieste in March 1905, he immediately started teaching English at the Berlitz school.

By June, Joyce felt financially secure enough to have his satirical poem “Holy Office” printed and asked for copies to be distributed to his former associates in Dublin.

Photograph of Trieste filled with ships around 1907 viewing the city from out in the harbor
Above: Trieste, 1907

Trieste (Triest in German, Trst in Slovenian and Croatian) is a city in Northeast Italy that was once a very influential and powerful centre of politics, literature, music, art and culture under Austrian-Hungarian dominion.

Today, Trieste is often forgotten as tourists head off to bigger Italian cities like Roma (Rome), Milano (Milan), and Trieste’s ancient archrival Venezia (Venice).

But those tourists miss out on a very charming and underestimated city, with a quiet and lovely almost Eastern European atmosphere, several pubs and cafes, some stunning architecture and a beautiful sea view.

It was also, for a while, the residence of the famous Irish writer, James Joyce.

Above: Trieste, Italy

Joyce kept writing despite all these changes.

He completed 24 chapters of Stephen Hero and all but the final story of Dubliners.

But he was unable to get Dubliners in press.

Though the London publisher Grant Richards had contracted with Joyce to publish it, the printers were unwilling to print passages they found controversial because English law could hold them liable if they were brought to court for indecent language.

Richards and Joyce went back and forth trying to find a solution where the book could avoid legal liability while preserving Joyce’s sense of artistic integrity.

As they continued to negotiate, Richards began to scrutinise the stories more carefully.

He became concerned that the book might damage his publishing house’s reputation and eventually backed down from his agreement.

Grant Richards, British publisher and writer, in 1909.png
Above: Grant Richards (1872 – 1948)

Getting a book published should be easy:

  1. Edit and proofread.
  2. Identify a target audience for your book.
  3. Identify potential agents.
  4. Submit your book proposal directly to a publisher.

How to Write Your First Novel: The Stress-Free Guide to Writing Fiction for  Beginners by M.L. Ronn

Trieste was Joyce’s main residence until 1920.

Although he would temporarily leave the city — briefly staying in Rome, travelling to Dublin and emigrating to Zürich during World War I — it became a second Dublin for him and played an important role in his development as a writer.

Dubliners eBook by James Joyce - 1230003633175 | Rakuten Kobo Greece

He completed Dubliners, reworked Stephen Hero into Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, wrote his only published play Exiles, and decided to make Ulysses a full-length novel as he created his notes and jottings for the work.

Exiles | James JOYCE

He worked out the characters of Leopold and Molly Bloom in Trieste.

Ulysses eBook by James Joyce - 1230002430188 | Rakuten Kobo Greece

Many of the novel’s details were taken from Joyce’s observation of the city and its people, and some of its stylistic innovations appear to have been influenced by Futurism – (an artistic and social movement that originated in Italy in the early 20th century and also developed in Russia, it emphasized dynamism, speed, technology, youth, violence, and objects such as the car, the airplane, and the industrial city).

Above: Dynamic Hieroglyphic of the Bal Tabarin, Gino Severini, 1912

There are even words of the Triestine dialect in Finnegans Wake.

Simple book cover, unadorned

Trieste is at the crossroads of several commercial and cultural flows: German-speaking Central Europe to the north, Slavic masses and the Balkans to the east, Italy and Latin countries to the west and the Mediterranean Sea to the south.

Its artistic and cultural heritage is linked to its singular “border town” location.

You can find some old Roman architecture (a small theatre near the sea, a nice arch into old city and an interesting Roman museum), Austrian Empire architecture across the city centre (similar to stuff you can find in Vienna) and a nice atmosphere of metissage of Mediterranean styles, as Trieste was a very important port during the 18th century.

Above: Trieste

In late May 1906, the head of the Berlitz school ran away after embezzling its funds.

Artifoni took over the school but let Joyce know that he could only afford to keep one brother on. 

The Berlitz School | Lo chiamavano Zois…

Berlitz Corporation is a Japanese-owned language education and leadership training company based in Princeton, New Jersey.

The company was founded in 1878 by Maximilian Berlitz in Providence, Rhode Island in the United States.

Berlitz Corporation is now a member of the Benesse Group, a Japanese company, with more than 547 company-owned and franchised locations in more than 70 countries.

Berlitz Sprachschulen logo.svg

Berlitz started in 1878, when Maximilian Berlitz was in need of an assistant French instructor.

He employed a Frenchman by the name of Nicholas Joly, only soon to discover that Joly barely spoke English, and was hired to teach French to English speakers in their native language.

The first Berlitz language school opened in Providence, Rhode Island, in July 1878.

A decade later, Berlitz moved to Boston, Massachusetts, and opened additional schools.

Soon after, he opened schools in New York and New Jersey.

In 1886, he moved the headquarters and his personal residence to New York City.

In 1895, a children’s language learning book was published by Maximilian Berlitz. 

By 1914, there were about 200 Berlitz schools, including 63 Berlitz schools in Germany and 27 in Britain.

By the time of the start of World War I in 1914, there were over 200 Berlitz Schools worldwide.

Maximilian Berlitz died in 1921.

Portrait of Maximilian Berlitz
Above: Maximilian Berlitz (1852 – 1921)

His son-in-law and associate, Victor Harrison-Berlitz, assumed leadership of the business.

Harrison died in 1932, and control passed briefly to his son, Victor Harrison-Berlitz Jr.

The control of the company was thereafter passed to Jacques Strumpen-Darrie.

Jacques’ son Robert succeeded his father as president in 1953.

Above: The first Berlitz Language School in Providence, Rhode Island (1878)

In the 1950s, Berlitz opened its first Latin American language center in Mexico, followed by locations in Brazil, Venezuela, Argentina, Colombia, Chile, and Peru.

Flag of Mexico
Above: Flag of Mexico

In 1966, Berlitz reached Asia, starting with a language center in Tokyo.

Today, there are more than 90 Berlitz centres in Asia.

Berlitz has 547 locations in more than 70 countries.

Locations | Berlitz Language Training Canada
Above: Berlitz Language Training Centres Worldwide

The Berlitz Method” uses the direct method and focuses on using language as a tool for communication.

The direct method, as opposed to the traditional grammar translation method, advocates teaching through the target language only, the rationale being that students will be able to work out grammatical rules from the input language provided, without necessarily being able to explain the rules overtly.

Today, there are a variety of derivative methods and theories that find their beginnings in the natural and communicative elements that were pioneered by Berlitz.

The tried-and-tested Berlitz Method®

While the situation at Berlitz is different from country to country, in Japan there has been substantial industrial action, including the 2007 – 2008 Berlitz Japan strike, which grew into the longest and largest sustained strike among language teachers in Japan.

Berlitz filed suit against the teachers’ union for damages it says it suffered during the strike, but the claim was rejected by the Tokyo District Court on 27 February 2012. 

Within a week Berlitz appealed the ruling to the High Court, with the first court date on 28 May 2012.

The final hearing was held on 27 December 2012, when an agreement was struck between Berlitz and the union.

Berlitz withdrew their High Court lawsuit and new rules for collective bargaining were also established.

They will again be conducted in English, after the language was changed to Japanese previously.

Berlitz also promised to disclose more financial information to the union.

The company also agreed to pay a base-up raise to current union members plus a lump sum bonus to the union.

Berlitz court ruling unequivocal on basic right to strike | The Japan Times
Above: Berlitz Japan strike

In 2010, employees of Berlitz language centers in Germany experienced a major labor conflict, as management planned to lay off nearly 70 contract teachers in order to economize with a staff of freelancers.

Berlitz Deutschland GmbH - 3 Bewertungen - München Altstadt - Weinstr. |  golocal
Above: Berlitz Sprachschule (Language School), München (Munich), Deutschland (Germany)

My own personal experience with Berlitz was in Freiburg im Breisgau, Germany.

I applied for work there to discover that not only was that school the least lucrative of schools in the city at that time, that I would not be paid during the training period that was not held there but in a different city, but as well I would be forbidden to work for other schools while working for Berlitz.

Sprachtraining und BAMF-Kurse in Freiburg | Berlitz
Above: Freiburg im Breisgau, Germany

Wall Street English (formerly Wall Street Institute) is among the largest providers of English language education for adults around the world.

Wall Street English was established in 1972 in Italy by Italian Luigi Tiziano Peccenini. 

Pecce, Luigi Tiziano Peccenini.jpg
Above: Luigi Tiziano Peccenini

The first Wall Street Institute centres opened in Italy in 1972, and within two years 24 new centres opened across Italy.

In 1983, Wall Street Institute expanded outside of Italy, and by the late 1980s Wall Street Institute was well established across Europe.

Expansion continued through the early 1990s, when centres were opened in Mexico, Chile and Venezuela.

Beginning in the late 1990s, Wall Street Institute expanded into the Middle East and then to Asia, which has grown to be a significant part of its business.

The company has over three million alumni with a current enrolment of 180,000 students.

Using a franchise model, they currently operate over 450 centers in 28 countries in North Africa, East Asia, Southeast Asia, Europe, Latin America, and the Middle East. 

Its international offices are in Hong Kong and in Barcelona, Spain.

In 2013, Wall Street Institute launched a company-wide rebranding, changing its name and identity.

The company now operates as Wall Street English.

We are Wall Street English

The Wall Street English program is designed for all levels of learners.

They have 20 different levels of English language courses ranging from beginner to advanced.

Their program includes an English-only environment in their centers, native English-speaking teachers, social activities that allow students to practice English in a social, non-threatening environment, and a global online student community.

The Wall Street English Blended Learning Method, created by Luigi Tiziano Peccenini and Luciano Biondo, combines different education methods of acquiring a language into one study cycle.

The Blended Learning Method includes self-study, small teacher-led classes, and practice time.

Students listen, read, write, speak, and practice English to gain a deep understanding of the language.

Wall Street English has been teaching English since 1972.

Our Method - Wall Street English

Their curriculum is aligned to the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR), according to a study undertaken with the support of the University of Cambridge English for Speakers of Other Languages Examination group (ESOL).

In plain English ...: THE COMMON EUROPEAN FRAMEWORK OF REFERENCE FOR  LANGUAGES

Wall Street English was acquired by Pearson plc from an affiliate of the Carlyle Group and Citic Private Equity for $92 million in cash in 2010. 

Pearson logo.svg

In 2017, Pearson sold it to Baring Private Equity Asia and CITIC Capital for around $300 million.

Baring Private Equity Asia Logo.png

There are eight Wall Street English centers in Switzerland: Biel/Bienne, Fribourg/Freiburg, Geneva, La Chaux-de-Fonds, Lausanne, Lugano, Montreux and Neuchâtel.

Eskişehir is not my first experience with Wall Street.

Once upon a time, back in 2012 – 2013, I worked at a Wall Street branch in St. Gallen.

I enjoyed teaching there, but I found management difficult to work with.

With the closing of that branch in 2014, there are no longer branches in the German-speaking regions of Switzerland.

Above: Languages of Switzerland – German (orange) / French (purple) / Italian (green) / Romansh (yellow)

There are 16 centres in Turkey: six in Istanbul (at Bakirköy, Caddebostan, Sisli, Erenköy, Taksim and Beylikdüzü), three centres in Ankara (Kizilay, Cayyolu and Ostim), Izmit, Bursa, Eskişehir, Izmir, Antalya, Gaziantep and Konya.

Franciza Wall Street English | Franciza.ro

Tired of Trieste and discouraged that he could not get a publisher for Dubliners, Joyce found an advertisement for a correspondence clerk in a Roman bank that paid twice his current salary. 

He was hired for the position, and went to Rome at the end of July.

James Joyce and His Time in Rome - Walks in Rome (Est. 2001)

Above: James Joyce Plaque, Rome

Their first address was a rooming house at Via Frattina 52, off the Corso.

A memorial tablet now graces the building:

Where he lived from August to December 1906 / James Joyce / A voluntary exile evoked the story of Ulysses / Making of his Dublin our Universe.”

Their lodgings were two blocks from the bank where Joyce worked at Via S. Claudio 87.

Rome was rather tense in 1906.

Pope Pius X, still smarting from his loss of the Papal States some 30 years earlier, refused to move beyond the sanctuary of St Peter’s while the Savoy family, his rivals and Italy’s new monarchs, built rather grand monuments, empty gestures of grandeur.

Pius X, by Ernest Walter Histed (retouched).jpg
Above: Pope Pius X ( Giuseppe Melchiorre Sarto) (1835 – 1914)

Into this tension walked 24-year-old James Joyce:

A man desperately trying to escape tensions of his own.

Since leaving Dublin, Joyce had been living in the Adriatic coastal town of Trieste, in northeast Italy.

He had made quite an impact on the expatriate community and their hangers-on.

Many people befriended Joyce and seemed endlessly willing to help him and his wife as they struggled to come to terms with the realities of raising a young family.

Datei:James Joyce Statue Triest 08-2016 300dpi.jpg – Wikipedia
Above: James Joyce Statue, Trieste

But Joyce was a restless and flamboyant character whose fondness for alcohol worried his wife and riled his English school employers.

Joyce even lured his brother Stanislaus to Trieste, knowing full well the extra income would help maintain his indulgent lifestyle.

To make matters worse, the school director absconded, leaving the school in disarray and Joyce without a regular income.

There was always trouble in Trieste.

New Directions Publishing | Stanislaus Joyce
Above: Stanislaus Joyce (1884 – 1955)

Perhaps Rome, with all its mysterious splendour and history, could inspire him to greatness.

Destiny and fame surely awaited him.

This was the city of the Caesars.

Rome Montage 2017.png
Above: Images of Roma (Rome), Italia (Italy)

It was where Keats (1795 – 1821) died, where Goethe (1749 – 1832) had roamed the Forum, and Joyce’s great hero Henrik Ibsen (1828 – 1906) spent many happy months.

Above: John Keats Tombstone, Rome

 - Goethe in the Roman Campagna - Google Art Project.jpg
Above: Goethe in the Roman Campagna, Johann Heinrich Wilhelm Tischbein, 1786

Above: Henrik Ibsen (far left) with friends in Rome, 1867

Joyce fixed his mind on the Eternal City and went about securing a job for himself with little difficulty.

Aided by a letter of recommendation from a former lord mayor of Dublin, Timothy Harrington, Joyce was offered a temporary post in the bank of Nast, Kolb and Schumacher, which stood at the corner of Via del Corso and Via S. Claudio, today the site of a large department store.

Above: Timothy Harrington (1851 – 1910)

Arriving in Rome on 31 July 1906, the Joyce family took lodgings on the third floor of a house at 52 Via Frattina, where today a plaque commemorates his stay.

The accommodation was small but close to his work and the bars and cafés around the Spanish Steps.

From the very beginning, however, his letters to Stanislaus speak negatively of the city and its people.

According to Joyce, the area around the Colosseum was simply “like an old cemetery with broken columns of temples and slabs.”

In a letter to his brother, he wrote:

Rome reminds me of a man who lives by exhibiting to travellers his grandmother’s corpse.

It’s clear that the city’s former glories did nothing for such a modern man.

But he clearly admits his own shortcomings and demonstrates his indignation in another letter to Stanislaus, lamenting:

I wish I knew something of Latin or Roman history.

But it’s not worthwhile beginning now.

So let the ruins rot.”

Colosseo 2020.jpg
Above: The Colosseum, Rome

His work in the bank was soul-destroying.

He often had to work 12 hours a day, copying up to 200 letters in an office where he had no interaction with the public.

He had nothing but contempt for his colleagues who spoke endlessly of their ailments.

His brother received constant updates on how difficult life in Rome was.

And although Joyce was earning more money in the bank, he frequently begged his brother to send more cash.

We want somebody completely dedicated to our firm, so you must not ask for a timetable that allows for extra jobs.

Thus the private bank of Nast-Kolb and Schumacher in Rome sought to put the screws on its prospective employee, the 25-year-old Irish writer James Joyce.

Outwardly, Joyce was completely dedicated to the firm.

His hours were long:

08.30-12.00, 14.00-19.30.

After that there were the little English language teaching jobs, guaranteed to shrink the mind and to round out the ends of the months.

Like many before and after, Joyce quickly found his salary (L.250 a month) inadequate and Rome expensive:

Rome certainly is not cheap, a lira goes a very short way here.”

With his linguistic skills, he was employed initially in the correspondence office of the bank.

While in Rome he took Danish lessons from a man named Petersen.

He was already fluent in French and Italian, and had taught himself Norwegian in order to read Ibsen in the original.

This multilingual clerk had a jaundiced view of his colleagues:

This morning in the bank that German clerk informed us what his wife should be:

She should be able to cook well, to sew, to housekeep, and to play at least one musical instrument.

I suppose they’re all like that in Deutschland.

I am dead tired of their bello and bellezza.

A clerk here is named (he is round, bald, fat, voiceless) Bartoluzzi.

You pronounce it by inflating both cheeks and prolonging the u.

Every time I pass him I repeat the name to myself and translate ‘Good day, little bits of Barto.’

Another is named Simonetti:

They are all little bits of something or other, I think.

This is my first experience of clerks:

Do they all talk for five minutes about the position of a pen wiper?”

r3rhm02sx
Above: James Joyce

Joyce had other ideas: “I hope to find time to finish my novel in Rome within the year.”

But he had packed and gone before the year was out, having written nothing of consequence bar letters to his brother Stanislaus in Trieste.

Together with Nora Barnacle, his companion of two years, and their son Giorgio, he had spent a total of seven months and seven days in Rome, and hated the place.

James Joyce
Above: James Joyce

By November, Joyce’s landlady was tiring of his excessive alcohol abuse and requested that he leave the accommodation on Via Frattina.

Joyce expected to charm his way out of the tight spot but the Signora stuck firmly to her guns and Joyce found himself homeless with his young family.

After four days spent searching, the young writer moved into Via Monte Brianzo 51, near Piazza Navona.

By Christmas, Joyce was forced to take another job as a teacher, but it wasn’t enough and the family dined on pasta on a thoroughly depressing Christmas Day.

While he struggled to make ends meet in Rome nothing came from his pen.

He found no time to write and no immediate inspiration.

The Roman ruins compounded his misery.

He complained of nightmares involving “death, corpses, assassinations, in which I take an unpleasantly prominent part.”

Above: The Death of Caesar, Jean-Léon Gérôme, 1867

The intrigues and gore of ancient Rome infiltrated his psyche and it seems he began to develop a strange appreciation of his native Dublin, something not so keenly felt since his departure.

Irritations can create pearls.

The pearls in this case are Joyce’s two masterpieces, the short story “The Dead” and the novel Ulysses.

The seeds for both were sown in Rome.

Joyce’s letters from this period are filled with parallels between Rome and Dublin.

Samuel Beckett Bridge At Sunset Dublin Ireland (97037639) (cropped).jpeg
Above: Samuel Beckett Bridge, Dublin, Ireland

Photo of the Ponte Sant'Angelo bridge
Above: Ponte Sant’Angelo, Rome

The figure of the Jew, Leopold Bloom, in Ulysses, wandering the streets of a provincial capital, echoes Joyce’s position as a friendless expatriate bank clerk.

Poldy.png
Above: Drawing of Leopold Bloom by Joyce

Bloom’s facile, wide-ranging, restless mentality is that of the Roman flâneur.

Above: Le Flâneur, Paul Gavarni, 1842

(Flâneur is a French noun referring to a person, literally meaning “stroller“, “lounger“, “saunterer“, or “loafer“, but with some nuanced additional meanings. 

Flânerie is the act of strolling, with all of its accompanying associations.

A near-synonym of the noun is boulevardier.

Traditionally depicted as male, a flâneur is an ambivalent figure of urban affluence and modernity, representing the ability to wander detached from society with no other purpose than to be an acute observer of industrialized, contemporary life.

The flâneur was, first of all, a literary type from 19th century France, essential to any picture of the streets of Paris.

The word carried a set of rich associations: the man of leisure, the idler, the urban explorer, the connoisseur of the street.)

Something too of the tessellated sense of history, which Rome epitomises, has gone into Ulysses.

It was at this time that the ideas for his wonderful short story, The Dead, began their gestation.

Perhaps the simple Christmas lunch and Signora Dufour’s apparently barbarous treatment of his family led to dreams of more lavish feasts and what the story’s hero Gabriel Conroy refers to as unique Irish hospitality.

In the same breath Joyce, through Gabriel, a character all the while fixated on the attractions and trappings of continental Europe, acknowledges those things that Ireland has to offer the world by way of this tradition.

Rome’s somewhat crude irreverence for the dead who are constantly on display, whether through imperial Rome’s whimsical Caesars or greedy popes, is in sharp contrast to the quiet, melancholy image of Dublin covered in snow.

The romance and bombast of Michelangelo, Bernini and Borromini contrasts with the humble but no less passionate Michael Furey in The Dead who, we find out, courted Gabriel’s wife Gretta and died of consumption but may, as Gretta reveals, have “died for me”.

Eventually, Joyce had had enough and he decided to leave Rome.

The Dead by James Joyce | 9780979660795 | Paperback | Barnes & Noble®

The day before leaving he was given his last pay cheque from his bank job, and splashed out on a few farewell drinks.

As he drank, two men managed to get a look inside his wallet and when Joyce left the café they attacked and robbed him.

Luckily, he had left some of his pay at his lodgings and with it he packed his son and his wife onto a train for Trieste and left Rome.

He never returned.

Arrivederci Professore: Amazon.de: DVD & Blu-ray

Joyce felt he accomplished very little during his brief stay in Rome, but it had a large impact on his writing.

Though his new job took up most of his time, he revised Dubliners and worked on Stephen Hero.

Rome was the birthplace of the idea for “The Dead“, which would become the final story of Dubliners, and for Ulysses, which was originally conceived as a short story. 

His stay in the city was one of his inspirations for Exiles.

Exiles by James Joyce, New Directions, 1947 | Alvin lustig, Amazing book  covers, History design

Exiles is James Joyce’s only extant play and draws on the story of “The Dead“, the final short story in Joyce’s story collection Dubliners.

The play was rejected by W.B. Yeats for production by the Abbey Theatre.

Above: William Butler Yeats (1865 – 1939)

Its first major London performance was in 1970, when Harold Pinter directed it at the Mermaid Theatre.

Above: Harold Pinter (1930 – 2008)

In terms of both its critical and popular reception, Exiles has proven the least successful of all of Joyce’s published works.

In making his case for the defence of the play, Padraic Colum conceded:

Critics have recorded their feeling that Exiles has not the enchantment of Portrait of the Artist nor the richness of Ulysses.

They have noted that Exiles has the shape of an Ibsen play and have discounted it as being the derivative work of a young admirer of the great Scandinavian dramatist.”

Photographed by Carl Van Vechten, 1959.
Above: Padraic Colum (1881 – 1972)

The play follows four players and two couples, Richard Rowan, a writer and his “common-law wifeBertha, and Robert Hand with his cousin and previous lover Beatrice, both old friends of the previous couple.

The plot is deceptively simple:

Richard, a writer, returns to Ireland from Rome with Bertha, the mother of his illegitimate son, Archie.

While there, he meets his former lover and correspondent Beatrice Justice and former drinking partner and now successful journalist Robert Hand.

Robert was also Beatrice’s lover, and here the complications begin.

As jealousy develops throughout the relationships the action meditates mostly in a budding relationship between Hand and Bertha and thus in Hand‘s attempts at seduction with the lover of his friend.

Exiles eBook by James Joyce - 1230000190742 | Rakuten Kobo Greece

The first act takes place at Rowan‘s house where Hand makes his first advance at Bertha.

After kissing her “with passion” several times Hand requests she join him in his home for a second meeting later that evening.

Bertha in turn confides in Rowan and questions whether or not to accept his invitation.

To this, Rowan retorts she must do whatever she pleases.

Joyce, J: Exiles: A Critical Edition (Florida James Joyce) : Fargnoli, A.  Nicholas, Gillespie, Michael Patrick, Joyce, James: Amazon.de: Books

In the second act, Hand waits, expecting Bertha at the appointed hour but instead is surprised when Rowan appears.

Calmly, Rowan explains his knowledge of Hand‘s attempts at wooing Bertha but is interrupted when Bertha herself knocks at the door.

Rowan returns home, leaving his wife alone with Hand who continues his advances toward Bertha.

The act ends inconclusively, with Hand asking if Bertha loves him, and Bertha explaining:

I like you, Robert.

I think you are good.

Are you satisfied?”

Exiles - Hörbuch Download | James Joyce | Audible.de: Gelesen von Lance  Rasmussen, Jo Palfi, Elizabeth Klett, Graham Scott, Linda Barrans, Leanne  Yau

The third act returns to Rowan‘s home at seven o’clock the following morning.

Bertha‘s maid informs her of Rowan‘s departure from the home an hour earlier, as he left for a walk on the strand.

Printed in the morning newspapers is a favourable article written about Rowan, written the previous evening by Hand himself.

The events of the previous night between Bertha and Hand are unclear, as both parties agree it was a “dream“.

But appearances demonstrate Hand and Bertha shared “a sacred night of love“.

Hand reports to Rowan, assuring him Bertha in fact did not stay the night but instead Hand spent the night alone.

Claiming to have visited the Vice-Chancellor’s lodge, returned home to write the newspaper article, then gone to a nightclub where he picked up a divorcée and had sex with her (“what the subtle Duns Scotus calls ‘a death of the spirit’ took place“) in the cab on the way home.

JohnDunsScotus - full.jpg
Above: John Duns Scotus (1265 – 1308)

Following this conversation, Hand leaves for his cousin’s house in Surrey while Rowan and Bertha are reconciled.

Bertha admits that she longs to meet her lover, but asserts that the lover is Rowan himself.

The resolution of the play lies precisely in the sense of doubt about what occurred between Hand and Bertha between Acts Two and Three.

Rowan is wounded by the sense of doubt that he admits he longed for.

Indeed, he sees this sense of doubt as what enables him “to be united with Bertha in body and soul in utter nakedness”.

Exiles : James Joyce : 9780198800064

There are obvious parallels to be drawn with Joyce’s own life – Joyce and Nora Barnacle lived, unmarried, in Trieste, during the years the fictional Rowans were living in Rome.

During this time, Joyce and his lover considered themselves to be living in exile, directly mirroring the setting of Exiles.

Robert Hand too, draws a connection to Joyce’s personal life as he resembles two friends of Joyce’s, Oliver St. John Gogarty and Vincent Cosgrave, and even shares a few defining characteristics with them both.

Similarly, the character of Beatrice Justice has been said to reflect a cousin of Joyce’s, Elizabeth Justice, who died in 1912.

However, Exiles is by no means straightforwardly autobiographical.

The great question which Joyce sought to use as the basis for a drama was that of human freedom and human dignity.

It is exposed and focused in terms of love and sexual relationships.”

Exiles : James Joyce : 9798686447462

While in Rome, Joyce read the socialist historian Guglielmo Ferrero in depth.

Ferraro’s anti-heroic interpretations of history, arguments against militarism, and conflicted attitudes toward Jews would find their way into Ulysses, particularly in the character of Leopold Bloom

Guglielmo Ferrero.jpg
Above: Guglielmo Ferrero

Guglielmo Ferrero (1871 — 1942) was an Italian historian, journalist and novelist, author of the five-volume Greatness and Decline of Rome (published in English in 1909).

Ferrero devoted his writings to classical liberalism.

He opposed any kind of dictatorship and unlimited government.

He was nominated for the Nobel Prize in Literature twenty times in six years.

Guglielmo Ferrero - Grandeur et décadence de Rome - - Catawiki

Born in Portici, near Napoli (Naples), Ferrero studied law in Pisa, Bologna and Torino (Turin).

Soon afterward he married Gina Lombroso, a daughter of Cesare Lombroso, the criminologist and psychiatrist with whom he wrote The Female OffenderThe Prostitute and The Normal Woman.

Above: Gina Lombroso (1872 – 1944)

From 1891 to 1894 Ferrero traveled extensively in Europe and in 1897 wrote The Young Europe, a book which had a strong influence over James Joyce.

Above: Monument to Giordano Bruno, Campo de’ Fiori, Rome

Joyce admired Bruno and attended the procession in his honour while in Rome.

(In The Young Europe, Ferrero, according to a radical-democratic political perspective and sociology, noted that in Latin countries, such as Italy, society was “governed by classes that do not represent productive work” and expressed a government that is ” thief and patron at the same time, stripper and almsgiver “, dominating an authoritarian and Caesarist state, which presented itself to the agricultural plebs essentially in the form of “gendarme and tax collector“, while in the societies of Northern Europe, where modern industrial capitalism, the enemy of aristocracies, was in full development, “all men, even the humblest, are collaborators of the universe of common work and therefore necessary elements of the whole“, because of a “fruitful and living justice in relations between men“. )

Above: Europa, Palazzio Ferreria, Valetta, Malta

After studying the history of Rome, Ferrero turned to political essays and novels (Between Two Worlds in 1913, Speeches to the Deaf in 1925 and The Two Truths in 1939).

When the fascist reign of the Black Shirts forced liberal intellectuals to leave Italy in 1925, Ferrero refused and was placed under house arrest.

Above: Blackshirts, Piazza di Siena, Rome, 1936

In 1929 Ferrero accepted a professorship at the Graduate Institute of International Studies in Geneva.

IHEID Logo 2013.tif

His last works (AdventureBonaparte in ItalyThe Reconstruction of EuropeThe Principles of Power and The Two French Revolutions) were dedicated to the French Revolution (1789 – 1799) and Napoleon Bonaparte (1769 – 1821).

Portrait of Napoleon in his late thirties, in high-ranking white and dark blue military dress uniform. In the original image he stands amid rich 18th-century furniture laden with papers, and gazes at the viewer. His hair is Brutus style, cropped close but with a short fringe in front, and his right hand is tucked in his waistcoat.
Above: The Emperor Napoleon in His Study at the Tuileries, Jacques-Louis David, 1812

Ferrero was invited to the White House in 1908 by Theodore Roosevelt, who had read The Greatness and Decline of Rome.

Ferrero gave lectures in the northeast of the USA which were collected and published in 1909 as Characters and Events of Roman History.

President Roosevelt - Pach Bros (cropped).jpg
Above: Theodore Roosevelt (1858 – 1919)

Ferrero died in 1942 at Mont Pèlerin, Switzerland.

MontPelerinFromMontreux.JPG
Above: Mont Pèlerin, France

In London, Elkin Mathews published Joyce’s Chamber Music on the recommendation of the British poet Arthur Symons.

Above: Arthur Symons (1865 – 1945)

Chamber Music is a collection of poems by James Joyce, published in May 1907.

The collection originally comprised 34 love poems, but two further poems were added before publication (“All day I hear the noise of waters” and “I hear an army charging upon the land“).

Although it is widely reported that the title refers to the sound of urine tinkling in a chamber pot, this is a later Joycean embellishment, lending an earthiness to a title first suggested by his brother Stanislaus and which Joyce (by the time of publication) had come to dislike:

The reason I dislike Chamber Music as a title is that it is too complacent“, he admitted to Arthur Symons in 1906.

I should prefer a title which repudiated the book without altogether disparaging it.”

ChamberMusicJoyce.jpg

Richard Ellmann reports (from a 1949 conversation with Eva Joyce) that the chamberpot connotation has its origin in a visit he made, accompanied by Oliver Gogarty, to a young widow named Jenny in May 1904.

Richard Ellmann.jpg
Above: Richard Ellmann (1918 – 1987)

The three of them drank porter while Joyce read manuscript versions of the poems aloud – and, at one point, Jenny retreated behind a screen to make use of a chamber pot.

Gogarty commented:

There’s a critic for you!“.

When Joyce later told this story to Stanislaus, his brother agreed that it was a “favourable omen“.

In Ulysses, Leopold Bloom reflects:

Chamber music.

Could make a pun on that.

In fact, the poetry of Chamber Music is not in the least bawdy, nor reminiscent of the sound of tinkling urine.

Although the poems did not sell well (fewer than half of the original print run of 500 had been sold in the first year), they received some critical acclaim. 

Ezra Pound admired the “delicate temperament” of these early poems, while Yeats described “I hear an army charging upon the land” as “a technical and emotional masterpiece“.

In 1909, Joyce wrote to his wife:

When I wrote Chamber Music, I was a lonely boy, walking about by myself at night and thinking that one day a girl would love me.”

James Joyce at six in 1888 in sailor suit with hands in pocket, facing the camera
Above: James Joyce, age 6, 1888

Nonetheless, Joyce was dissatisfied with his job, had exhausted his finances, and realised he’d need additional support when he learned Nora was pregnant again.

He left Rome after only seven months.

Arrivederci, Baby! (1966) - IMDb

Roma (Rome), the ‘Eternal City‘, is the capital and largest city of Italy and of the Lazio (Latium) region.

It is the famed city of the Roman Empire, the Seven Hills, La Dolce Vita (the sweet life), Vatican City and Three Coins in the Fountain.

Flag of Vatican City
Above: Flag of Vatican City

Rome, as a millennium-long centre of power, culture and religion, having been the centre of one of the globe’s greatest civilizations ever, has exerted a huge influence over the world in its 2,500 years of existence.

The historic centre of the city is a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

UNESCO logo English.svg

With wonderful palaces, millennium-old churches and basilicas, grand romantic ruins, opulent monuments, ornate statues and graceful fountains, Rome has an immensely rich historical heritage and cosmopolitan atmosphere, making it one of Europe’s and the world’s most visited, famous, influential and beautiful capitals.

The Roman Empire in AD 117 at its greatest extent, at the time of Trajan's death (with its vassals in pink)[3]
Above: The Roman Empire at its greatest extent

Today, Rome has a growing nightlife scene and is also seen as a shopping heaven, being regarded as one of the fashion capitals of the world (some of Italy’s oldest jewellery and clothing establishments were founded in the city).

Three coins.jpg

With so many sights and things to do, Rome can truly be classified a “global city“.

La Dolce Vita (1960 film) coverart.jpg

Ute (the wife) and I visited Rome for three days in April 2004.

I enjoyed playing tourist in Rome, but like Istanbul or Paris or New York, it is a metropolis too crowded and too expensive for me to ever consider my wanting to live there.

I have few memories of Rome.

Above: Trajan’s Market, Rome

I read your book
And I find it strange
That I know that girl

And I know her world
A little too well

I didn’t know
By giving my hand
That I would be written down, sliced around, passed down
Among strangers’ hands

Three days in Rome
Where do we go?
I’ll always remember
Three days in Rome

Never again
Would I see your face
You carry a pen and a paper,

And no time and no words you waste


Oh, you’re a voyeur

The worst kind of thief
To take what happened to us
To write down everything that went on between you and me

Three days in Rome
And I stand alone
I’ll always remember
Three days in Rome

And what do I get?
Do I get revenge?
While you lay it all out
Without any doubt

Of how this would end


Sometimes it goes
Sometimes we come
To learn by mistake that the love you once made
Can’t be undone

Three days in Rome
I laid my heart out
I laid my soul down
I’ll always remember

Three days in Rome.

45cat - Sheryl Crow - Tomorrow Never Dies (Full Length Version) / The Book  - A&M - UK - 582 456-7

I remember the Torre Argentina Cat Sanctuary….

1929 was the year the sacred area of Torre Argentina was excavated.

This was also the year the history of the cats’ residency began.

Stray and abandoned felines took refuge in the protected area below stree​t level.

From 19​​29 until 1993, the cats were more or less regulary fed by a succession of cat ladies or “gattare“.

One of the most famous of these cat lovers was the great Italian filmstar Anna Magnani.

While working at Teatro Argentina which borders the ruins, Ms. Magnani would spend her breaks feeding her four legged friends.

This film legend, famous for her heart-tugging performances, died in the 1960s.

Above: Anna Magnani (1908 – 1973)

Lia and Silvia started working with the cats in 1993 when they began helping a woman who was running the show alone: feeding, spaying and neutering all the cats.

Her generous efforts put her on the verge of an economic and emotional collapse.

Soon Lia and Silvia realised there was a lot more work than the three women could manage.

In that year the cat population was 90 and growing due to the irresponsibility of people abandoning their cats and kittens, perhaps to go on vacation.

And so, Torre Argentina Cat Sanctuary was born.

Above: Lia and Silvia

Working conditions were primitive to say the least.

A cave like area under the street had been unwittingly created by the construction of the street and the pillars that sustain it long before the cat shelter began.

It had a floor space of about 100 square meters and it began as a night shelter for the cats and as a storage place for cat food.

It was a difficult and frustrating job.

Caring for more than 90 cats in a damp underground space, in many places so low that one cannot stand up and no electricity or running water.

For almost a year and a half Silvia and Lia worked under these conditions, hoping for a breakthrough or a guide through this dark period.

Their prayers were answered in 1995 when a savior arrived:

An English woman named Molga Salvalaggio.

She told Silvia and Lia about the wonderful achievements of certain English organizations who worked in animal protection and she put them in contact with the A.I.S.P.A. (Anglo-Italian Society for the Protection of Animals).

The A.I.S.P.A. was the first organisation to give material as well as moral support.

In addition, they introduced Silvia and Lia to English resources concerning stray cats and solutions to frequent problems who studied this invaluable information and began the slow process of imitating English role models.

The first job was to raise desperately needed funds.

The primitive location had one great advantage:

It was a tourist attraction because of the historical and archaeological significance of the ruins.

Painfully swallowing pride and embarrassment Silvia and Lia started approaching tourists who seemed more interested in the cats than the ruins and asked for donations.

Unbelievably, it worked!

Not only did they collect needed cash, they also managed to attract a certain number of volunteers:

Mostly women of many different nationalities, Italian, French, German, American, English, Brazilian and Dutch.

Torre Argentina became a sort of United Nations for cats.

To raise more money they started organizing fundraising dinners, raffles and flea market sales.​

In September 1998, US Navy Captain John Henriksen and his wife Cheryl generously opened their home to 120 people for a dinner, auction and raffle, the first Gala.

Later, Alexandra Richardson, wife to the British Ambassador allowed volunteers to hold a fundraiser/gala at her residence.

Several more galas followed the following years and provided badly needed funds.

With the newly found income, TA could afford cat food of better quality and the new burst of enthusiasm also motivated Silvia, Lia and their team of volunteers to become more professional and organized in daily operations.

When feeding, spaying, and veterinary care for the TA cats had become an affordable routine, TA started sharing funds also with the poorer sanctuaries around Rome, but with the emphasis on spaying and neutering.

They were, and still are, priorities.

Nelson, a one-eyed Torre Argentina cat was the main character in an award winning book by volunteer, Deborah D’Alessandro.

It was published in 1999 and soon became a bestseller at the shelter drawing attention to the plight of abandoned cats.

9788886061667: Nelson. The one-eyed king - Il re senza un occhio - AbeBooks  - Deborah D'Alessandro: 8886061668

At around the same time, Barbara Palmer published  “Cat Tales”:

Both books contributed to the growing reputation of the shelter.

Cat tales: Roma, Torre argentina - Praha - Sbazar.cz

In 2000, the Sanctuary entered a new era when we were given international exposure with the gift of a website, http://www.romancats.com from Dutch animal rescuers and professional web designers, Micha Postma and Christiaan Schipper.

On the home front, in 2001, the cats of Rome became a “bio-cultural heritage” by special proclamation of the city council.

Things were moving in the right direction:

As the Sanctuary grew, there was also a growing awareness  suffering of the stray animals and their need for protection.

The time was ripe for a public statement:

In 2003, Torre Argentina Sanctuary (TA) was instrumental in the organization of a demonstration march, Cat Pride, that had several thousand participants demanding protection and funding for Rome’s strays.

In 2004, the production of the DVD Cats of Rome  by Michael Hunt, contributed to a further diffusion of TA’s work and goals.

Amazon.com: Cats Of Rome : Narrated by Keith Burberry, Michael W. Hunt:  Movies & TV

I remember also, with as much great fondness as Torre Argentina, the Anglo-American Bookshop.

The Anglo American Bookshop - Wanted in Rome

The bookshop was founded in 1953 under the name of Interbook by an Englishman named Patrick Searle.

Later it was divided into two: Interbook and the Anglo-American Book Company.

The owner of the latter was General Edward Rush Duer Jr.

This choice was very courageous as the English language was not yet considered a language recognized worldwide for any type of exchange (economic, cultural, tourist, etc.).

The initial location was in the centre of Rome, on Via Firenze at the corner of Via Nazionale and later in Via del Boschetto where Arminio Lucchesi (45 years old) and Dino Donati (24 years old) worked, two young booksellers full of desire to do well and resourcefulness who came from previous book experiences.

The first had been in charge of the international department of the historic Bocca bookshop (in Piazza di Spagna, which unfortunately closed in the 90s to make way for a tour operator) and the second had been a willing salesman at the Modernissima bookshop (in via della Mercede, also closed in the 90s to make way for a pizzeria).

A few years later Donati found a shop in Via della Vite 57 (excellent for access to the public) and in company with Lucchesi and Mrs. Nadia Likatcheff Deur moved the business to these new premises where it has remained for over 40 years.

Anglo American Bookshop | Rome, Italy Shopping - Lonely Planet

The street was in the center of the capital but was in a location with little passage, the “neighbours” of the shop were a deposit of mineral water, a charcoal burner, a “sandwich shop” (which over time became the renowned Tuscan restaurant Mario).

At first, times were very difficult, the Second World War had just ended and illiteracy was still a problem felt in Italy.


At the beginning the sales situation was not at all rosy, but the situation improved day by day, Lucchesi was in charge of the internal management of the bookshop and Donati for the promotion and dissemination throughout Italy.

Soon the place became too small to manage the volume of books that arrived for the bookstore and those that were commissioned by customers, institutions or companies, and so they decided to rent an apartment in Via della Vite 68, in order to better manage the part of the commission that was getting bigger.

Anglo American Bookshop - Colonna - 3 tips from 98 visitors


In 1960 Mrs. Deur left for the US and, after a few months, her share was taken over by Donati and Lucchesi.

The bookshop and commission was now underway and the first profits and satisfactions had already arrived.

Luck was on their side, English had become the language of the future and interest grew more and more.

In 1972, part of the commission was transferred from Via della Vite 68 to Via della Vite 27 where the Technical and Scientific Department was located and established for reasons of space.

Otherwise Bookshop in Rome - An American in Rome


The next important step was the creation of the subscription service, one of the first in Italy and Europe.

The aim was to act as an intermediary between a multiplicity of publishers and large customers who needed to receive subscription journals to keep the current value of their studies or ongoing research very high.

The largest customers were, and are, universities, research institutions and medium-large companies engaged in long-term technological research.

At the end of the 70s there was the real explosion of activity and traffic.

The employees were more and more, the space was less and less, and the books and magazines published grew exponentially.


In 1978, Dino Donati took over his share from Arminio Lucchesi and distributed the company shares with his wife Carla and their children, Daniele and Cristina.

At the beginning of the 80s to meet further requests, two more apartments were rented in the same building in Via della Vite 27 outlining the following arrangement that still exists:

  • First and second floors: technical, scientific and commission department
  • Third floor: administration and management
  • Fourth floor: subscription service and data processing centre

To make the best use of the spaces of the small library, two architects were commissioned to renovate the library making it more welcoming and at the same time obtain useful spaces even in the smallest slot.

In 1981, the purchase of their first computer gave the start to the computerization of the entire society.

In 1986, the first XENIX multi-user system connected all the library departments.

The world’s first CD-ROM databases peeped out the door and the A-AB were among the first to consider and massively use them.

This was the beginning of the information and organizational revolution that has followed to this day.

English language bookshops in Rome - Wanted in Rome

At the end of the 80s the books in the library constantly present in stock had become over 80,000 and the small bookstore was bursting, so the sales staff were forced to invent unlikely positions to make sure that the books found a place.

In 1993, with considerable economic commitment, the library was moved from number 57 (about 40 square meters) to number 102 (about 180 square meters) always in Via della Vite where it is currently located.


Books finally breathe, customers too.

You don’t have to crowd to browse and evaluate a book before buying.

The books always on the shelves have reached over 150,000.


The 90s also brought the subscription service to the point of its maximum expansion with the Total service: a reception and delivery service designed for large companies and the most demanding libraries.

This led to the establishment of a company in New York the AABOOK Corp. where all US subscriptions are centralized and subsequently sent by express courier to Rome.

1997 was the year of the launch of the website and the beginning of e-commerce.

English language bookshops in Rome - Wanted in Rome

It was here I bought an English translation of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s Italian Journey, which in turn would inspire us to visit Casa di Goethe and the Keats-Shelley Memorial House.

It was here also I discovered the magazine Wanted in Rome:

Wanted in Rome | LinkedIn

Wanted in Rome is a monthly magazine in English for expatriates in Rome established in 1982.

The magazine covers Roman news stories that may be of interest to English and Italian speaking residents, and tourists as well.

The publication also offers classifieds, photos, information on events, museums, churches, galleries, exhibits, fashion, food, and local travel.

Wanted in Rome was founded in 1982 by two expats who identified the need of an aggregation magazine for the English-speaking community.

In 1997 it launched its website.

Wanted in Rome - June 2020 - Wanted in Rome

The Casa di Goethe is a museum in Rome, at Via del Corso 18, dedicated to Goethe, his Italian journey and his life at Rome in the years from 1786 through 1788.

During his journey Goethe wrote a journal and also many letters which would be published in 1817 as the Italian Journey.

House of goethe fassade.JPG

The Museum is located in the house and in the same rooms in which Goethe lived with his friend the German painter Johann Wilhelm Tischbein during his stay in Rome.

Above: Self Portrait, Johann Wilhelm Tischbein (1751 – 1829)

The permanent exhibition covers his life in Italy, his work and writing, and also about his private life and shows original documents concerning his life.

The second exhibition, which is always a temporary exhibition, often refers to arguments and themes which connect somehow the Italian and German cultures or talks about artists like:

  • Max Beckmann

Max Beckmann, photograph by Hans Möller,1922.jpg
Above: Max Beckmann (1884 – 1950)

  • Heinrich Mann

Heinrich Mann, 1906
Above: Heinrich Mann (1871 – 1950)

  • Thomas Mann

Thomas Mann in 1929
Above: Thomas Mann (1875 – 1955)

  • Andreu Alfaro

Andreu #Alfaro #artist | Escultura abstrata, Arte em cerâmica, Esculturas
Above: Andreu Alfaro (1929 – 2012)

  • Günter Grass

Grass in 2006
Above: Günter Grass (1927 – 2015)

  • Johann Gottfried Schadow (just to name a few) 

Above: Johann Gottfried Schadow (1764 – 1850)

  • Their experiences in Italy as well as their examinations of Goethe

Flag of Italy
Above: Flag of Italy

The Museum owns a library, which includes also the collection of Richard W. Dorn.

The Casa di Goethe, opened in 1997 and is administrated by the Association of Independent Cultural Institutes (AsKI) and directed by Ursula Bongaerts.

Casa di Goethe (@CasadiGoethe) / Twitter

The Keats–Shelley Memorial House is a writer’s house museum in Rome, commemorating the Romantic poets John Keats and Percy Bysshe Shelley.

The museum houses one of the world’s most extensive collections of memorabilia, letters, manuscripts, and paintings relating to Keats and Shelley, as well as Byron, Wordsworth, Robert Browning, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Oscar Wilde, and others.

It is located on the second floor of the building situated just to the south of the base of the Spanish Steps and east of the Piazza do Spagna.

Keats-Shelley House.jpg
Above: Keats – Shelly House, beside the Spanish Steps, Rome

In November 1820, the English poet John Keats, who was dying of tuberculosis, came to Rome at the urging of friends and doctors who hoped that the warmer climate might improve his health.

Posthumous portrait of Keats by William Hilton, National Portrait Gallery, London (c. 1822)
Above: John Keats (1795 – 1821)

He was accompanied by an acquaintance, the artist Joseph Severn, who nursed and looked after Keats until his death, at age 25, on 23 February 1821, in this house. 

Visitors today can enter the second-floor bedroom in which the poet died in terrible agony, his devoted friend Joseph Severn at his side.

Above: Self Portrait, Joseph Severn (1793 – 1879)

Keats is buried in the city’s Non-Catholic Cemetery where his tomb – dedicated simply to a “young English poet” – continues to draw pilgrims almost two centuries after his death. 

Cimitero Acattolico Roma.jpg
Above: Cimitero Acattolico (Non-Catholic Cemetery), Rome

The walls were initially scraped and all things remaining in the room immediately burned (in accordance with the health laws of 19th century Rome) following the poet’s death.

The effort to purchase and restore the two-room apartment in which Keats spent his final days began in 1903 at the instigation of the American poet Robert Underwood Johnson. 

Robert Underwood Johnson in 1920.jpg
Above: Robert Underwood Johnson (1853 – 1937)

Assisted by interested parties representing America, England, and Italy, the house was purchased late in 1906 and dedicated in April 1909 for use by the Keats–Shelley Memorial Association.

The rooms then became known as the Keats–Shelley House.

During World War II, the Keats–Shelley House went “underground“, especially after 1943, in order to preserve its invaluable contents from falling into the hands of, and most likely being deliberately destroyed by, Nazi Germany.

External markings relating to the museum were removed from the building.

The Keats - Shelley House in Rome - Memorial House

Although the library’s 10,000 volumes were not removed, two boxes of artifacts were sent to the Abbey of Monte Cassino in December 1942 for safekeeping.

In October 1943, the Abbey’s archivist placed the two unlabelled boxes of Keats–Shelley memorabilia with his personal possessions so that they could be removed during the Abbey’s evacuation and not fall into German hands.

The items were reclaimed by the museum’s curator and returned to the Keats–Shelley House, where the boxes were reopened in June 1944 upon the arrival of the Allied forces in Rome.

Monte Cassino Opactwo 1.JPG
Above: Abbey of Monte Cassino, Italy

Rome’s Keats-Shelley House hosts a mysterious watercolour map on its steep, narrow stairwell where it is believed to have rested since the museum’s opening in 1909.

Painted by an unknown artist, the map depicts the area surrounding Piazza di Spagna, using blue motifs with calligraphy to indicate where visiting British and American writers and artists stayed during the 19th century.

By this time the network of streets around the Spanish Steps was already known as the “English ghetto” due to its popularity among wealthy British travellers who would conclude their grand tours of Europe in Rome.

The map contains around two dozen names – many of whose paths crossed – with several buildings hosting plaques boasting of their illustrious former residents.

Based on the information recorded in the map, which can also be viewed on the Keats-Shelley House website, it is possible to trace a roughly clockwise trail around the Tridente, a trident-shaped area of the centro storico fanning out from Porta del Popolo, once the main gateway to the city.

The walking tour spans nine decades, from 1817 to 1895, and takes a couple of hours at a leisurely pace. 

Tracing the footsteps of Rome's foreign writers and artists

1819 saw the arrival of English Romantic painter J. M. W. Turner (1775 – 1851).

It is not known where he stayed – perhaps at Palazzo Poli near the Trevi Fountain from which his one surviving letter was written.

However we know that on his return trip in August 1828 he took lodgings at Piazza Mignanelli 12, a stone’s throw from what is now the Keats-Shelley House.

Turner’s exhibition in December 1828 at Palazzo Trulli (demolished half a century later to make way for Corso Vittorio Emanuele II) was attended by over a thousand visitors.

However, the works received a predominantly unfavourable response, according to Turner expert David Blayney Brown.

On 3 January 1829 Turner departed Rome for the last time, although the city’s ruins were to feature prominently in his future work.

Joseph Mallord William Turner Self Portrait 1799.jpg
Above: Joseph Mallord William Turner (1775 – 1851)

Oh, Rome!

My country!

City of the soul!

The Romantic poet Lord Byron (1788 – 1824) is undoubtedly a most colourful character.

Fleeing debts and a desperate personal situation, Byron left England in 1816, never to return, living mainly in Italy until his death in modern-day Greece aged 36.

Byron befriended the Shelleys at Lake Geneva before travelling to Italy, where he was to spend seven years, predominantly in Venice, Pisa and Ravenna.

According to popular myth, he lodged at Piazza di Spagna 66, opposite the Keats-Shelley House, in 1817.

On his return to Ravenna he wrote the 4th canto of his epic narrative poem Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage, about half of which relates to Rome. 

Portrait of Byron
Above: Lord George Gordon Byron (1788 – 1824)

The map features a couple of names who fit into neither painter nor writer category.

One of these figures is James Clark (1788 – 1870), a Scottish doctor who operated a thriving medical practice in Piazza di Spagna from 1819 until 1826, during which time poor Keats was one of his patients.

Despite rising to become physician to Queen Victoria, recent research suggests that Clark misdiagnosed Keats’ illness, compounding the poet’s final months of agony by enforcing starvation and blood lettings.

The doctor’s exact address is unknown but, according to the American author John Evangelist Walsh in his book In Darkling I Listen: The Last Days and Death of John Keats, Clark lived “across the steps” from the Keats – Shelley House. 

Sir-James-Clark-1788-1870.jpg
Above> Sir James Clark (1788 – 1870)

Ascending the steps to Trinità dei Monti, the map lists the American landscape painter Thomas Cole (1801 – 1848) as living on Via Sistina, without a street number, but with the vital clue that he was based at a studio once used by Claude Lorrain, from 1831 – 1832 and again in 1841.

According to a drawing in the collection of the British Museum, the location of Lorrain’s former studio corresponds to Via Sistina 66, the building wedged between the start of Via Sistina and Via Gregoriana, opposite today’s Hotel Hassler. 

Thomas Cole.jpg
Above: Thomas Cole (1801 – 1848)

Next door at Via Sistina 64 lived the Irish portrait painter Amelia Curran (1775 – 1847), who moved to Rome in or around 1818, eking out a living painting portraits and copying old Masters.

She is best known for her portrait of her friend Percy Bysshe Shelley, quill in hand, which was presumably painted at this address and is now in the National Portrait Gallery in London.

Above: Portrait of Percy Bysshe Shelley, Amelia Curran

Curran died in 1847, her funeral celebrated at the Franciscan church of St Isidore’s on Via degli Artisti 41.

Here she is commemorated with a memorial featuring palette and brushes, carved by prominent Rome-based Irish sculptor John Hogan (1800 – 1858).

Rome – St Isidore's College – Irish Franciscans
Above: St. Isidore’s, Rome

On 7 May 1819, Percy Bysshe Shelley (1792 – 1822) and his wife Mary Shelley (1797 – 1851), fresh from penning her Gothic masterpiece Frankenstein, left their lodgings at Palazzo Verospi on Via del Corso 374 to move next door to Curran on Via Sistina 65, against the wishes of the family doctor, who advised Shelley to escape the city’s “mal’aria”.

Half-length portrait of a woman wearing a black dress sitting on a red sofa. Her dress is off the shoulder. The brush strokes are broad.
Above: Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley (1797 – 1851)

Although the elevated Via Sistina had the “best air in Rome” according to Shelley, one month after their move the Shelley’s three-year-old son William “Willmouse” died of a fever, most likely malaria.

The heartbroken couple left Rome for the last time on 10 June 1819, after burying the boy, their third child to die, at the Non-Catholic Cemetery.

Three and a half years later Shelley’s ashes would be interred in the same cemetery after his tragic death, aged 29, during a storm off the Tuscan coast near Lerici.

Above: Posthumous Portrait of Shelley Writing “Prometheus Unbound” in Italy, Joseph Severn, 1845

Veering slightly off-course now, turn left half-way down Via Sistina onto Via di Porta Pinciana.

At the top of the street Palazzo Laranzani, number 37, hosted Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804 – 1864) in 1858.

Hawthorne in the 1860s
Above: Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804 – 1864)

Hawthorne overcame his initial misgivings of Rome’s “wicked filth” to become enraptured with the city:

His 1858 Gothic romance The Marble Faun was inspired after seeing a woodland scene of mythological sculpture in Villa Borghese.

Hawthorne was affected profoundly by the tragic tale of Roman noblewoman Beatrice Cenci – who also inspired Shelley’s five-act drama The Cenci – and her portrait attributed to Guido Reni, which can be seen today at Palazzo Barberini. 

The Marble Faun.jpg

Turning back downhill towards Via Sistina, take the last left onto Via degli Artisti.

From 1821 until 1824, when the street was still called Via di S. Isidoro, it hosted the English painter Joseph Severn (1793-1879) who lived in a large apartment at number 18, today the Hotel degli Artisti.

Severn is linked eternally with Keats with whom he travelled to Rome in 1820 and whom he nursed devotedly in his dying days.

Severn would outlive Keats by almost six decades, becoming an accomplished painter and a highly respected figure among Rome’s English-speaking community.

In 1841 Severn moved back to England.

However, 20 years later he returned to Rome as British Consul, a post he held for 11 years.

When he died, aged 81, there was outrage that his resting place at the Non-Catholic Cemetery was not next to Keats.

Several years later, Severn was reinterred beside his old friend.

At the bottom of Via Sistina, cross over Piazza Barberini and up Via delle Quattro Fontane to Palazzo Barberini, home to Italy’s national gallery of ancient art.

The American neoclassical sculptor and art critic William Wetmore Story (1819 – 1895) lived here with his family from 1856, taking studios on nearby Via di S. Niccolò da Tolentino 4.

For the next four decades his apartment on the palace’s piano nobile was a bustling meeting place for distinguished expatriates, from Robert and Elizabeth Barrett Browning to Henry James.

Above: William Wetmore Story

When his wife Emelyn died in 1894, Story carved the poignant Angel of Grief in the Non-Catholic Cemetery.

The much-replicated memorial was Story’s last major work and became the artist’s resting place a year later on his death, aged 78. 

Above: Angel of Grief, Rome

Returning to Piazza Barberini, turn left down Via del Tritone and at Largo del Tritone turn right and then first left onto Via della Mercede.

When the Scottish poet and novelist Sir Walter Scott (1771 – 1832) undertook his Grand Tour of Italy in 1832, he had achieved international acclaim for historical novels including Ivanhoe and Rob Roy and poems such as The Lady of the Lake (some of which inspired well-known Italian operas).

However despite being greeted with much fanfare, Scott was in failing health by the time he reached Rome.

He stayed at Via della Mercede 11 from 16 April until 11 May 1832 in the same palazzo in which Bernini had lived and died two centuries earlier.

The building’s exterior hosts a plaque dedicated to Scott, who died on his return to Scotland several months later.

Portrait of Sir Walter Scott and his deerhound, "Bran" in 1830 by John Watson Gordon
Above: Sir Walter Scott

Continue along Via della Mercede, cross Via del Corso, into Piazza del Parlamento to the rear of today’s chamber of deputies and along Via dei Prefetti to number 17, home to Samuel Morse (1791-1872) from February 1830 to January 1831, as commemorated by a plaque over the door.

This American painter of portraits and historical scenes is best remembered as the inventor of the Morse Code.

An outspoken opponent of “popery”, it is said that while in Rome the staunchly Calvinist Morse caused a stir by refusing to take off his hat in the presence of the pontiff.

Samuel Morse 1840.jpg
Above: Samuel Morse

The next side-street to the right, Vicolo del Divino Amore, meanders to Palazzo Borghese where Lady Gwendoline Talbot (1817 – 1840) moved from her Alton Towers family estate in Staffordshire following her 1835 marriage to Prince Marcantonio Borghese.

Described by King William IV as the “greatest beauty in the realm“, Gwendoline was known in Rome for her tireless charity work and ministry to the sick.

Princess Gwendoline came into her own in the aftermath of the cholera epidemic that ravaged the Eternal City in 1837.

That year 9,752 victims were struck by the disease in Rome with 5,479 deaths, in a city with little more that 150,000 inhabitants.

The epidemic lasted from the end of July until 15 October, when crowds flocked to St. Maria Maggiore to celebrate the end of the pestilence.

It was with great reluctance that the princess withdrew with her family to their home in Frascati, Villa Mondragone, during those summer months to avoid the danger of contagion.

On her return, however, she threw herself immediately into relief work among the survivors, her prime concern being the infants orphaned by the plague.

She engaged the well-off families of Rome to help her and visited the homes of the poor and destitute, bringing food, clothes and medicine to the needy.

She had no qualms about washing, cleaning and feeding them, sometimes slipping out of the Palazzo Borghese in disguise to conceal her movements.

This led to some embarrassing moments.

On one occasion she was followed by a member of the papal bodyguard, intrigued by her gracious but mysterious aura.

Though somewhat abashed by his proposals, the princess nonetheless stood her ground and invited the gallant into the humble dwelling she was visiting.

Taken aback at the sight of the haggard mother and children who warmly greeted the princess as their benefactor, the young dandy was shamed into leaving a generous offering for their upkeep before he hastily withdrew.

She died of scarlet fever aged just 22, and her tomb in the Borghese Chapel at the Basilica of St. Maria di Maggiore carries the inscription “madre dei poverelli”.

Above: Lady Gwendoline is buried in the crypt under the Borghese Chapel in the Basilica di St. Maria Maggiore.

Shortly after her death the couple’s three sons died of measles however their daugher Agnese survived.

Incidentally, three years before her own marriage in Rome, Gwendoline’s elder sister Mary had married Prince Filippo Doria. 

The whole city was plunged into grief at the news of Princess Gwendoline’s death.

On the night of 30 October, the funeral cortege left the Borghese Palace and, followed by massive crowds, made its way along the Corso, Piazza Venezia and the Baths of Trajan before turning left up the slopes of the Quirinal Hill.

The procession halted at the Palazzo Quirinale, where Pope Gregory XVI came to his balcony and blessed the remains.

Declaring that her death was a public calamity, he gave orders that the great portal of St. Maria Maggiore be opened, a privilege reserved for the noblest Roman families.

Gregory XVI.jpg
Above: Pope Gregory XVI (né Bartolomeo Alberto Cappellari) (1765 – 1846)

Bearing the inscription: Qui riposano le ceneri della madre dei poverelli, la Principessa Guendolina Borghese, Nata a Londra, dal conte de Shrewsbury, morta a 22 anni, il 27 ottobre 1840, the Princess’s coffin was interred in the family vault below the altar in the Borghese Chapel in St. Maria Maggiore.

The funeral oration at the solemn obsequies for the princess in the church of St. Carlo al Corso was delivered by the Rev. Charles Michael Baggs, rector of the Venerable English College in Rome.

In the course of his discourse he remarked that the curate of the parish of St. Rocco, near the Mausoleum of Augustus, had claimed that the Princess knew his parishioners better than he did himself, and counselled him thus:

Fear not, lest you should praise her too highly.

Be sure that whatever you may say of her will fall short of her deserts.”

The orator claimed that Gwendoline’s only fault was to have been liberal beyond her ample means and continued as follows:

Her private fortune was entirely devoted to the poor.

And for their sake she sometimes contracted debts, which were generously paid by the Prince her husband, who admired and encouraged her benevolence.

When you next enter the Basilica of St. Maria Maggiore take note of the icon above the high altar, the Salus Populi Romani, an image of the Virgin Mary that was carried through the streets of Rome for the first time in over 200 years during the cholera epidemics of 1835 and 1837.

Roma - 2016-05-23 - Basilica di Santa Maria Maggiore - 2957.jpg
Above: St. Maria Maggiore, Rome

Spare a thought too for the young princess who lies buried in the Borghese crypt below the altar, a lady whose devotion to the survivors of the epidemic was such that she earned the title:

Mother of the poor.

Princess Gwendoline: Rome's Mother of the Poor
Above: Gwendoline Talbot

Follow Via Borghese onto Via di Ripetta which the map lists as the 1859 address of Irish-born art historian Anna Brownell Jameson (1794 – 1860).

According to her biography by niece Gerardine Bate, Jameson occupied a “pleasant apartment close by the Tiber façade of the Palazzo Borghese, looking out over the river at the point known as the Porto di Ripetta.”

Jameson also stayed at an unknown address in Piazza di Spagna in 1847, after  making part of the journey from Paris to Rome with the Brownings – to undertake research for the best-selling work on which her reputation rests: Sacred and Legendary Art.

Jameson died before finishing the final segment of her celebrated series which was completed by Lady Eastlake, wife of English painter Charles Eastlake, as The History of Our Lord in Art

Anna Brownell Jameson 1844.jpg
Above: Anna Brownell Jameson

Follow Via di Ripetta into Piazza del Popolo, turning right past the twin churches onto Via del Babuino.

The first left is Via della Fontanella, where #4 hosted the studios of Welsh sculptor John Gibson (1790-1866) from 1818 until his death four decades later.

Gibson was originally the star pupil of Venetian master Antonio Canova and later Denmark’s Bertel Thorvaldsen before going on to make his fortune from monumental commissions, mainly from patrons in England.

He is buried in the Non-Catholic Cemetery.

John Gibson by Margaret Sarah Carpenter (née Geddes).jpg
Above: John Gibson

Although not listed on the map it is worth mentioning Gibson’s only protégée Harriet Hosmer (1830-1908), who became the most distinguished female sculptor in America in the 19th century.

Hosmer studied under Gibson from 1853 to 1860, during which time she became good friends with the Brownings and the Storys.

In addition to her artistic prowess and ferocious work ethic, the emancipated Hosmer raised eyebrows by riding her horse alone around the city at all times of night, and even rode from Rome to Florence “for a lark”.

Harriet hosmer.jpg
Above: Harriet Hosmer

Contuining down Via del Babuino, past All Saints’ Anglican Church, a bastion of British life in Rome since it opened in 1887, the map lists English author George Eliot (1819 – 1880) as residing at Hotel Amerique in 1860.

The hotel no longer exists but the building can be found at Via del Babuino 79.

While touring Italy Eliot conceived the idea for her historical novel Romola as well as gathering background material for her future masterpiece Middlemarch, completed in 1871.

The story’s central characters Dorothea and Casaubon honeymooned at a “boudoir of a handsome apartment in the Via Sistina.” 

Portrait of George Eliot (Mary Ann Evans) by Francois D'Albert Durade, 1850
Above: Mary Ann Evans (aka George Eliot)

Turn left into Vicolo dell’Orto di Napoli and straight ahead lies Via Margutta, a greenery-draped street long associated with painters and art studios.

According to the map – perhaps incorrectly – Sir Thomas Lawrence (1769 – 1830) stayed at number 53 in 1822.

This leading English portraitist travelled Europe painting foreign sovereigns and diplomats, including Pope Pius VII, and was hosted at the Palazzo del Quirinale from May 1819 until January 1820.

Subsequently, as president of the Royal Academy, Lawrence granted his cautious approval and funding to Rome’s fledgling British Academy of Arts, established in 1821 by a group of artists led by Severn.

This life drawing academy was based initially at Severn’s apartments on Via degli Artisti and then moved to Via Margutta 53b from 1895 until its closure in January 1936.

Self portrait of Sir Thomas Lawrence.jpg
Above: Unfinished self portrait, Sir Thomas Lawrence

Back on Via del Babuino continue towards Piazza di Spagna, taking the second right onto Via Vittoria until the street meets Via Mario de’ Fiori.

The map lists this corner building, Palazzo Rondanini, as hosting the Romantic poet and former banker Samuel Rogers (1763-1855) while he put the final touches to Italy, a sumptuous edition of verse tales illustrated with vignettes by Turner, in 1829.

Less known today, Rogers was highly prominent in his time, penning hugely popular poems such as The Pleasures of Memory.

In 1850, on the death of Wordsworth, he declined the offer of Poet Laureate due to his age.

Rogers first visited Rome in 1815 and again in 1822, when he met Byron and Shelley in Pisa.

Samuel Rogers
Above: Samuel Rogers

Take the next left onto Via Bocca di Leone where, at number 43, the poets Robert Browning (1812 – 1889) and Elizabeth Barrett Browning (1806 – 1861) spent two winters, in 1853 and 1858, commemorated by a plaque in their honour.

They returned to Rome for the winter of 1859, staying at Via del Tritone 28, and spent the following winter at Via Sistina 126.

Less than a month after leaving Rome on 1 June 1861 Elizabeth died in Florence in her husband’s arms, “smilingly, happily, and with a face like a girl’s”.

She is buried in the city’s English Cemetery.

Robert died in Venice in 1889 and is buried in Poets’ Corner at Westminster Abbey.

The Brownings are also remembered with a writers’ museum at their former Casa Guidi residence in Florence.

Above: Portraits of Elizabeth Barrett Browning and Robert Browning

Continuing along Via Bocca di Leone we reach Hotel d’Inghilterra at number 14, where the American novelist Henry James (1843-1916) stayed in 1869, when it was called Hotel d’Angleterre.

From here the author immediately reeled through Rome’s streets “in a fever of enjoyment”.

His arrival coincided with the dying days of papal Rome, an era he was to mourn in subsequent years.

Considered among the greatest novelists in the English language, James was inspired by the social and cultural interplay between Americans, English people and continental Europeans.

His experience of life in Rome is referenced in his novel Portrait of a Lady, whose central character Isabel Archer lived unhappily at the Palazzo Roccanero on an unnamed street off Piazza Farnese.

James in 1913
Above: Henry James

Turning back a few paces, take the first right onto Via dei Condotti which hosted the former Hotel d’Allemagne, owned by the German family of watercolourist Ettore Roesler Franz, whose romantic paintings of Rome and its surroundings are still popular today.

Ettore Roesler Franz.jpg
Above: Ettore Roesler Franz (1845 – 1907)

It was here that the English writer William Makepeace Thackeray (1811 – 1863) stayed on his first visit to Rome during 1844 – 1845.

Thackeray returned to the hotel in 1853 with his daughters Anne Isabella and Jane but soon moved to a large apartment at Palazzo Poniatowski, at nearby Via della Croce 81, on the advice of the Brownings.

Anne Isabella wrote of “feasting on cakes and petits fours” from the Spillmann pastry shop below.

During this period Thackeray wrote and produced illustrations of The Rose and the Ring, a story conceived in the Christmas period of 1853 to entertain the daughters and children of friends, including Pen Browning and Edith Story.

Describing a “gay and pleasant English colony in Rome”, Thackeray wrote in his memoir The Newcomes:

The ancient city of the Cæsars, the august fanes of the popes, with their splendour and ceremony, are all mapped out and arranged for English diversion.”

1855 daguerreotype of William Makepeace Thackeray by Jesse Harrison Whitehurst
Above: William Makepeace Thackeray

On returning full-circle to the foot of the Spanish Steps, how better to conclude the map-inspired tour than taking a coffee or aperitif at the Caffè Greco.

Established in 1760, this venerable institution was frequented by most of the people on this list (although Hawthorne was not a fan), their memories enshrined today with portraits and literary memorabilia throughout the bar.

The Antico Caffè Greco, sometimes simply referred to as Caffè Greco) is a historic landmark café which opened on Via dei Condotti.

It is the oldest bar in Rome and the 2nd oldest in Italy, after Caffè Florian in Venice.

The café was named after its Greek (Greco in Italian) owner, who opened it in 1760. 

Above: Caffè Greco, Ludwig Passini, 1856

Historic figures who have had coffee there include: 

  • Stendhal

Stendhal, by Olof Johan Södermark, 1840
Above: French writer Marie-Henri Beyle (aka Stendhal) (1783 – 1842)

  • Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

Goethe in 1828, by Joseph Karl Stieler
Above: German writer Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749 – 1832)

  • Arthur Schopenhauer

Arthur Schopenhauer by J Schäfer, 1859b.jpg
Above: German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer (1788 – 1860)

  • Bertel Thorvaldsen

Karl Begas 001.jpg
Above: Danish sculptor Bertel Thorvaldsen (1770 – 1844)

  • Mariano Fortuny

Marià Fortuny - Self-portrait - Google Art Project.jpg
Above: Spanish painter Mariano Fortuny (1838 – 1874)

  • Byron

Above: English poet Lord Byron (1788 – 1824)

  • Georges Bizet

Above: French composer Georges Bizet (1838 – 1875)

  • Hector Berlioz

portrait of white man in early middle age, seen in left profile; he has bushy hair and a neckbeard but no moustache.
Above: French composer Louis-Hector Berlioz (1803 – 1869)

  • Johannes Brahms

Above: German composer Johannes Brahms (1833 – 1897)

  • Franz Liszt

Franz Liszt 1858.jpg
Above: Hungarian composer Franz Liszt (1811 – 1886)

  • John Keats

Above: Statue of English poet John Keats (1795 – 1821) , Chichester, England

  • Henrik Ibsen

Above: Norwegian playwright Henrik Ibsen (1828 – 1906)

  • Hans Christian Andersen

Andersen in 1869
Above: Danish author Hans Christian Andersen (1805 – 1875)

  • Felix Mendelssohn

Above: German composer Felix Mendelssohn (1809 – 1847)

  • James Joyce

Picture of James Joyce from 1922 in three-quarters view looking downward
Above: Irish writer James Joyce (1882 – 1941)

  • Gabriele D’Annunzio

Gabriele D'Anunnzio.png
Above: Italian writer Gabriele D’Annunzio (1863 – 1938)

  • François-René de Chateaubriand

Anne-Louis Girodet-Trioson 006.jpg
Above: French writer / diplomat François-René de Chateaubriand (1768 – 1848)

  • Orson Welles

Above: American actor Orson Welles (1915 – 1985) as the octogenarian Captain Shotover, Mercury Theatre production of Heartbreak House, Time, 9 May 1938

  • Mark Twain

Twain in 1907
Above: American writer Samuel Langhorne Clemens (aka Mark Twain) (1835 – 1910)

  • Friedrich Nietzsche

Nietzsche187a.jpg
Above: German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche (1844 – 1900)

  • Thomas Mann

Above: German writer Thomas Mann (1875 – 1955)

  • Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres

Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres.jpg
Above: French painter Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres (1780 – 1867)

  • Nikolai Gogol

Daguerreotype of Gogol taken in 1845 by Sergei Lvovich Levitsky (1819–1898)
Above: Russian writer Nikolai Gogol (1809 – 1852)

  • Edvard Grieg

Edvard Grieg (1888) by Elliot and Fry - 02.jpg
Above: Norwegian composer Edvard Grieg (1843 – 1907)

  • Antonio Canova

Antonio Canova Selfportrait 1792.jpg
Above: Italian sculptor Antonio Canova (1757 – 1822)

  • Giorgio de Chirico

Giorgio de Chirico (portrait).jpg
Above: Italian Giorgio de Chirico (1888 – 1978)

  • Guillaume Apollinaire

Photograph of Guillaume Apollinaire in spring 1916 after a shrapnel wound to his temple
Above: French writer Guillaume Apollinaire (1880 – 1918)

  • Charles Baudelaire

Charles Baudelaire by Étienne Carjat, 1863
Above: French poet Charles Baudelaire (1821 – 1867)

  • Richard Wagner

Above: German composer Richard Wagner (1813 – 1883)

  • Carlo Levi

Carlolevi.jpg
Above: Italian painter / writer Carlo Levi (1902 – 1985)

  • María Zambrano  

María Zambrano ca. 1918.JPG
Above: Spanish writer / philosopher María Zambrano (1904 – 1991)

  • Lawrence Ferlinghetti

Lawrence Ferlinghetti in 1965
Above: American poet Lawrence Ferlinghetti (1919 – 2021)

  • Giacomo Casanova

Casanova ritratto.jpg
Above: Italian adventurer Giacomo Casanova (1725 – 1798)

For more than two centuries and a half, the Caffè Greco has remained a haven for writers, politicians, artists and notable people in Rome.

However, in 2017, the owner of the building asked for a raise of its monthly rent from the current €18,000 to €120,000.

As of 23 October 2019, despite being protected by the Department of Beni Culturali, the café is under the risk of closing due to the expiration of its rental contract.

Above: Caffè Greco, Rome

The map also includes a few rather obscure names at the expense of towering literary figures, such as Charles Dickens (1812 – 1870) who stayed in Rome in early 1845 while gathering material for his book Pictures from Italy, or Thomas Hardy (1840-1928) whose 1887 visit inspired the poem Rome at the Pyramid of Cestius Near the Graves of Shelley and Keats.

Charles Dickens
Above: Charles Dickens

Hardy between about 1910 and 1915
Above: Thomas Hardy

Another glaring omission is Edith Wharton (1862 – 1937), whose regular travels around Italy in the late 19th century resulted in several erudite guides and travel tales, once describing Rome as exciting “a passion of devotion such as no other city can inspire.”

Wharton, c. 1895
Above: Edith Wharton (née Edith Newbold Jones)

Also omitted is the far less than impressed Mark Twain (1835 – 1910), who in 1867 felt that he had been cheated of discovering anything in Rome as it had all been experienced before.

Mark Twain - The Innocents Abroad.jpg

Finally, perhaps due to its timeline or maybe the attendant scandal, the map fails to record the three-month stay at Hotel d’Inghilterra of Oscar Wilde (1854 – 1900), six months before his death in Paris. 

Wilde in 1882
Above: Oscar Wilde

But this is not Keats’ or Severn’s, Turner’s or Clark’s, Byron’s or Shelley’s, Hawthorne’s or Goethe’s, Story’s or Scott’s, Morse’s or Talbot’s, Jameson’s or Gibson’s, Hosmer’s or Eliot’s, Lawrence’s or Rogers’, Thackeray’s or James’, the Brownings’ or Dickens’, Hardy’s or Wharton’s, Wilde’s or Twain’s story.

Nor will we linger in Rome…..

Above: Aerial view of Rome

Joyce returned to Trieste in March 1907, but was unable to find full-time work.

He went back to being an English instructor, working part time for Berlitz and giving private lessons. 

Flag of Trieste
Above: Flag of Trieste

The author Aron Hector (Ettore) Schmitz, better known by pen name Italo Svevo, was one of his students.

Svevo was a Catholic of Jewish origin who became one of the models for Leopold Bloom

Joyce learned much of what knew about Judaism from him.

The two become lasting friends and mutual critics.

Svevo supported Joyce’s identity as an author, helping him work through his writer’s block with Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man.

Svevo.jpg
Above: Aron Hector (Ettore) Schmitz (aka Italo Svevo)





Aron Hector (Ettore) Schmitz (1861 – 1928), better known by the pseudonym Italo Svevo, was an Italian writer, businessman, novelist, playwright and short story writer.

A close friend of Irish novelist and poet James Joyce, Svevo was considered a pioneer of the psychological novel in Italy and is best known for his classic modernist novel Zeno’s Conscience (La coscienza di Zeno) (1923), a work that had a profound effect on the movement.

Above: Italo Svevo

Born in Trieste as Aron Ettore Schmitz to a Jewish German father and an Italian mother, Svevo was one of seven children and grew up enjoying a passion for literature from a young age, reading Goethe, Schiller, Shakespeare, and the classics of French and Russian literature.

Svevo was a citizen of the Austro-Hungarian Empire until the end of the First World War.

He spoke Italian as a second language (as he usually spoke the Triestine dialect).

Due to his Germanophone ancestry through his father, he and his brothers were sent to a boarding school near Würzburg, Germany, where he learnt fluent German.

Marienberg wuerzburg.jpg
Above: Würzburg, Germany

After returning to Trieste in 1880, Svevo continued his studies for a further two years at Istituto Revoltella before being forced to take financial responsibility when his father filed for bankruptcy after his once successful glassware business failed.

This 20-year period as a bank clerk at Unionbank of Vienna served as inspiration for his first novel One Life (Una vita) (1892).

During his time at the bank, Svevo contributed to Italian-language socialist publication L’Indipendente, and began writing plays (which he rarely finished) before beginning work on Una vita in 1887.

Una vita eBook von Italo Svevo – 9788833464756 | Rakuten Kobo Österreich

(The plot of Una vita:

Alfonso Nitti, a shy young intellectual with literary aspirations, leaves his home in the country where his mother lives to go to Trieste – though the city is not named – and work in a white collar job, as a copy clerk in Maller’s bank.

One day, he is invited to the house of his boss and of his daughter Annetta who knows Macario, a young man with whom Alfonso is friends.

Annetta, like Alfonso, is interested in literature, and holds a weekly soiree to which several suitors are invited.

Alfonso joins this, and he and Annetta begin to co-author a novel.

Alfonso accepts this project out of self-interest, having no respect for Annetta‘s literary abilities, but ingratiatingly allows her to control the project so that they can be together in the hope of winning her hand.

He soon convinces himself that he loves her, but realises that at the same time he despises her.

Eventually he seduces Annetta but then, on the verge of marrying her, he flees on the advice of Francesca, her father’s mistress, who warns him that the marriage would be a failure.

She predicts that while he is away Annetta will forget him and marry a rival.

By chance, while he is away, he is delayed by the prolonged illness of his dying mother, and Francesca‘s prediction proves correct.

Meanwhile Annetta has confessed to her father that Alfonso compromised her and, although Alfonso is relieved at not having to keep his promise to Annetta, on his return to the bank he is treated with hostility by his employer.

He decides to live a life of contemplation, away from passions.

But after discovering that Annetta is engaged to his acquaintance Macario, whom he dislikes, he nevertheless feels jealous.

He makes a last-ditch bid to speak to Annetta but is rejected.

He attempts to assuage his conscience by giving a dowry to his landlady’s daughter so that she can marry respectably but, following a demotion at the bank, he accidentally insults Frederico, Annetta’s brother, and is obliged to accept a duel.

Before this can take place, he decides to kill himself, with feelings of calm and relief at ending his maladjusted existence.)

Italo Svevo.jpg
Above: Italo Svevo

Svevo adhered to a humanistic and democratic socialism which predisposed him to pacifism and to advocate a European economic union after the war.

Following the death of his parents, Svevo married his cousin Livia Veneziani in a civil ceremony in 1896.

Soon after, Livia convinced him to convert to Catholicism and take part in a religious wedding (probably after a troublesome pregnancy).

Personally, however, Svevo was an atheist.

He became a partner in his wealthy father-in-law’s paint business that specialized in manufacturing industrial paint that was used on naval warships.

He became successful in growing the business and after trips to France and Germany, set up a branch of the company in England.

Svevo lived for part of his life in Charlton, southeast London, while working for a family firm.

He documented this period in his letters to his wife which highlighted the cultural differences he encountered in Edwardian England.

His old home at 67 Charlton Church Lane now carries a blue plaque.

In 1923, Italo Svevo published the psychological novel La coscienza di Zeno.

The work, showing the author’s interest in the theories of Sigmund Freud, is written in the form of the memoirs of Zeno Cosini, who writes them at the insistence of his psychoanalyst.

Sigmund Freud, by Max Halberstadt (cropped).jpg
Above: Sigmund Freud (1856 – 1939)

Svevo’s novel received almost no attention from Italian readers and critics at the time.

The work might have disappeared altogether if it were not for the efforts of James Joyce.

Joyce had met Svevo in 1907, when Joyce tutored him in English while working for Berlitz in Trieste.

Joyce read Svevo’s earlier novels Una vita and Senilità.

Senilità : Svevo, Italo: Amazon.de: Bücher

(The plot of Senilità:

Emilio, a clerk from an insurance company who is a failed writer, lives a modest life in a shared apartment with his sister Amalia, a spinster who has few relationships with the outside world, whose life consists mainly of taking care of her bachelor brother.

At the start of the novel Emilio meets Angiolina, a vulgar, poor but beautiful woman, and falls in love with her, causing him to neglect his sister and his sculptor friend Stefano Balli.

Balli has managed to balance his moderate artistic recognition with his successes with women, unlike Emilio, who is now eager for a brief amorous relationship himself.

Emilio tries to explain to Angiolina that their relationship will be subordinate to his other duties, such as those with his own family.

In short, he wants to keep the relationship unofficial, and for both parties not to be too committed.

Balli, who does not believe in love, tries to convince Emilio to simply have fun with Angiolina, known throughout Trieste as a loose woman.

Emilio ends up, instead, opening his heart to this woman, and falls deep under her spell, despite knowing that she is at heart promiscuous.

He imagines transforming Angiolina through his education.

Balli is interested in Angiolina as his model for a sculpture, but Emilio keeps imagining the two being unfaithful to him.

Balli tries to warn Emilio from being too committed:

Angiolina, he says, is seen consorting with an umbrella maker and is soon harboring amorous interest for Balli himself.

The revelation pains Emilio.

Ironically since, as indicated at the beginning of the novel, their initial agreement was for Emilio and Angiolina to have a non-committed relationship.

He breaks off with Angiolina briefly, but soon finds himself searching her out for another tryst.

Balli, meanwhile, starts to frequent Emilio‘s house with great regularity.

In another ironic twist, Emilio‘s sister Amalia falls for Balli.

His masculine charm thus draws in both female protagonists.

Emilio, jealous of Balli, becomes progressively estranged from his sculptor friend, and Amalia, knowing that her secret love is hopeless, numbs herself with ether.

She ultimately becomes ill with pneumonia.

The illness leads to her death, but not after triggering the grave remorse of her negligent brother.)

La coscienza di Zeno (eNewton Classici) (Italian Edition) eBook : Svevo,  Italo, M. Lunetta: Amazon.de: Kindle-Shop

Joyce championed Zeno’s Conscience, helping to have it translated into French and then published in Paris, where critics praised it extravagantly.

That led Italian critics to discover it.

Zeno Cosini, the book’s hero and unreliable narrator, mirrored Svevo himself, being a businessman fascinated by Freudian theory.

Svevo was also a model for Leopold Bloom, the protagonist of Joyce’s seminal novel Ulysses.

Ulysses by James Joyce eBook von James Joyce – 9788180320996 | Rakuten Kobo  Deutschland

Zeno’s Conscience never looks outside the narrow confines of Trieste, much like Joyce’s work, which rarely left Dublin in the last years of Ireland’s time as part of the United Kingdom.

Svevo employed often sardonic wit in his observations of Trieste and, in particular, of his hero, an indifferent man who cheats on his wife, lies to his psychoanalyst, and is trying to explain himself to his psychoanalyst by revisiting his memories.

There is a final connection between Svevo and the character Cosini.

Cosini sought psychoanalysis, he said, in order to discover why he was addicted to nicotine.

As he reveals in his memoirs, each time he had given up smoking, with the iron resolve that this would be the “ultima sigaretta!!“, he experienced the exhilarating feeling that he was now beginning life over without the burden of his old habits and mistakes.

That feeling was, however, so strong that he found smoking irresistible, if only so that he could stop smoking again in order to experience that thrill once more.

La coscienza di Zeno: e «continuazioni» (Einaudi tascabili. Classici Vol.  31) (Italian Edition) - Kindle edition by Svevo, Italo, Lavagetto, M..  Literature & Fiction Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

After being involved in a serious car accident, he was brought into hospital at Motta di Livenza, where his health rapidly failed.

As death approached he asked one of his visitors for a cigarette.

It was refused.

Svevo replied:

That would have been my last.”

He died that afternoon.

Piazza luzzatti.jpg
Above: Piazza Luzzati, Motta di Livenza, Italy

Roberto Prezioso, editor of the Italian newspaper Piccolo della Sera, was another of Joyce’s students.

He helped Joyce financially by commissioning him to write for the newspaper.

Joyce quickly produced three articles aimed toward the Italian irredentists in Trieste.

(Irredentism is a political and popular movement whose members claim – usually on behalf of their nation – and seek to occupy territory which they consider “lost” (or “unredeemed“), based on history or legend.)

He indirectly paralleled their desire for independence from Austria-Hungary with the struggle of the Irish from British rule.

Joyce earned additional money by giving a series of lectures on Ireland and the arts at Trieste’s Università Popolare.

University of Trieste logo.jpg

In May, Joyce was struck by an attack of rheumatic fever, which left him incapacitated for weeks.

The illness exacerbated eye problems that plagued him for the rest of his life. 

While Joyce was still recovering from the attack, Lucia was born on 26 July 1907. 

During his convalescence, he was able to finish “The Dead“, the last story of Dubliners.

Although a heavy drinker, Joyce gave up alcohol for a period in 1908.

He reworked Stephen Hero as the more concise and interior A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man.

He completed the third chapter by April and translated John Millington Synge’s Riders to the Sea into Italian with the help of Nicolò Vidacovich.

John Millington Synge.jpg
Above: John Millington Synge (1871 – 1909)

He even took singing lessons. 

Joyce had been looking for an English publisher for Dubliners but was unable to find one, so he submitted it to a Dublin publisher, Maunsel and Company, owned by George Roberts.

In July 1909, Joyce received a year’s advance payment from one of his students and returned to Ireland to introduce Georgio to both sides of the family (his own in Dublin and Nora’s in Galway). 

He unsuccessfully applied for the position of Chair of Italian at his alma mater, which had become University College Dublin.

He met with Roberts, who seemed positive about publishing Dubliners

Dublin in 1909, with trams, horsecarts, and pedestrians
Above: Dublin, 1909

He returned to Trieste in September with his sister Eva, who helped Nora run the home. 

Joyce only stayed in Trieste for a month, as he almost immediately came upon the idea of starting a cinema in Dublin, which unlike Trieste had none.

He quickly got the backing of some Triestine business men and returned to Dublin in October, launching Ireland’s first cinema, the Volta Cinematograph. 

It was initially well-received, but fell apart after Joyce left.

David Cleary в Twitter: "The Volta Electric Theatre, Ireland's first cinema,  founded in December 1909 on Mary Street by James Joyce. Joyce brought cinema  to Ireland. https://t.co/0jgxIhnZpK" / Twitter

He returned to Trieste in January 1910 with another sister, Eileen.

From 1910 to 1912, Joyce still lacked a reliable income.

In 1912, Joyce once more lectured at the Università Popolare on various topics in English literature and applied for a teaching diploma in English at the University of Padua.

He performed very well on the qualification tests, but was denied because Italy did not recognise his Irish degree.

University of Padua seal.svg
Above: Logo of the University of Padua

In 1912, Joyce and his family returned to Dublin briefly in the summer. 

While there, his three year-long struggle with Roberts over the publication of Dubliners came to an end as Roberts refused to publish the book due to concerns of libel.

Roberts had the printed sheets destroyed, though Joyce was able to obtain a copy of the proof sheets.

When Joyce returned to Trieste, he wrote an invective against Roberts, “Gas from a Burner“.

He never went to Dublin again.

The Salvage Press

Joyce’s fortunes changed for the better 1913 when Richards agreed to publish Dubliners.

It was issued on 15 June 1914, eight and a half years since Joyce had first submitted it to him. 

Around the same time, he found an unexpected advocate in Ezra Pound, who was living in London. 

On the advice of Yeats, Pound wrote to Joyce asking if he could include a poem from Chamber Music, “I Hear an Army Charging upon the Land” in the journal Des Imagistes.

Des Imagistes - Trainwreckpress

They struck up a correspondence that lasted until the late 1930s.

Pound became Joyce’s promoter, helping ensure that Joyce’s works were both published and publicized.

After Pound persuaded Dora Marsden to serially publish A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man in the London literary magazine The Egoist, Joyce’s pace of writing increased.

He completed A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by 1914, resumed Exiles, completing it in 1915, started the novelette Giacomo Joyce, which he eventually abandoned, and began drafting Ulysses.

GiacomoJoyce.jpg

In August 1914, World War I broke out.

Although Joyce was a subject of the United Kingdom, which was now at war with Austria-Hungary, he remained in Trieste.

Even when his brother Stanislaus, who had publicly expressed his sympathy for the Triestine irredentists, was interned at the beginning of January 1915, Joyce chose to stay.

In May 1915, Italy declared war on Austria-Hungary, and less than a month later Joyce took his family to Zürich in neutral Switzerland.

Above: Zürich, Switzerland

Joyce arrived in Zürich as a double exile:

He was an Irishman with a British passport and a Triestine on parole from Austria-Hungary. 

To get to Switzerland, he had to promise the Austro-Hungarian officials that he would not help the Allies during the war, and he and his family had to leave almost all of their possessions in Trieste. 

During the war, he was kept under surveillance by both the English and Austro-Hungarian secret service.

Man in suit secret service agent icon Royalty Free Vector

The Joyces returned for a nostalgic stay at Gasthaus Hoffnung before settling into Zürich for the duration of the war.

In the interim two children had been born, Joyce had matured as a writer, and the realities of poverty, drink and prostitutes had strained his and Nora’s relationship.

James Joyce in Zurich | SpringerLink

Love between man and woman is impossible because there must not be sexual intercourse, and friendship between man and woman is impossible because there must be sexual intercourse.

James Joyce, Dubliners

Dubliners (Unabridged) von James Joyce. Hörbuch-Downloads | Orell Füssli

It had been a scramble to get out of Trieste, then the principal port of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.

Sales of Dubliners (1914) stood at 499 copies.

Above: Port of Trieste

I wanted real adventures to happen to myself.

But real adventures, I reflected, do not happen to people who remain at home:

They must be sought abroad.

James Joyce, Dubliners

Dubliners, James Joyce

The manuscript of “Stephen Hero” tinkered with in 1904, had become A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man (1916).

Published serially in The Egoist, it was a succèss d’estime.

Five publishers turned it down and seven printers to set up the type.

Joyce had to wait until the last days of 1916 for book publication.

His novel of growing up in Dublin in the last decades of the 19th century sank virtually unnoticed during the First World War.

The top half of a yellowed page of a periodical entitled "The Egoist" with "An Individualist Review" as the subtitle and "Formerly the New Freewoman" underneath the subtitle.

Shortly after arriving in Zürich, Joyce was awarded 75 pounds from the Royal Literary Fund.

He buttoned his lip as regards mountebanks.

He was granted a Civil List fund in 1916 as well as other monies privately donated to an author who was beginning to attract notice.

In 1904, and on this occasion in 1915, he had arrived in Zürich skint.

By the time he left for Paris in 1920, he had moved from poverty into a qualified bourgeoisie, at home with some but not all of the bürgerlich habits of the banking city.

Ljmmat/Sjhl | Museum für Gestaltung eGuide
Above: James Joyce

Zürich during the First World War was awash with refugees and war profiteers – a vibrant hodgepodge of pacifists, revolutionaries, anarchists and artists who kept the Swiss police in shoe leather.

Lenin arrived in 1916, taking a room 100 yards away from the Cabaret Voltaire where the Dada movement held noisy court.

Cabaret Voltaire
Above: Cabaret Voltaire, Zürich

Switzerland had long been a crucible of Russian revolutionary thought, including such firebrands as Alexander Herzen, Mikhail Bakunin, Piotr Kropotkin, Rosa Luxembourg and Lenin.

Many of them were shielded from Siberian exile by Switzerland’s tolerance and judicial system.

Flag of the Soviet Union
Above: Flag of the Soviet Union (1922 – 1991)

Lenin was a habitué of the Café Odéon and most likely rubbed shoulders with Joyce there.

Musical "Odeon" - Das legendäre Grand Café Odeon erobert die Bühne – und  ein 81-jähriger Geroldswiler spielt mit
Above: Café Odeon, Zürich

The political revolutionary was more outspoken about his hosts than the Irish writer:

Switzerland is the most revolutionary country in the world….

There is only one slogan that you should spread quickly in Switzerland and around all other countries:

Armed insurrection!”

No wonder the Swiss were keen to see him safely across the border.

After the abdication of Tsar Nicholas II in 1917, Lenin boarded a sealed train in Zürich that took him across Germany to the Finland Station.

The rest, as they say, is history.

Vladimir Lenin.jpg
Above: Vladimir Lenin (1870 – 1924)

From a provincial town, Zürich had grown to become the centre of European modernism.

Partly this had to do with the influx of German and other refugees – Joyce, Frank Wedekind, Tristan Tzara, Stefan Zweig, and the painters Wassily Kandinsky and Jean Arp.

Frank Wedekind
Above: German playwright Frank Wedekind (1864 – 1918)

Robert Delaunay's portrait of Tzara, 1923
Above: Romanian artist Tristan Tzara (1896 – 1963)

Stefan Zweig2.png
Above: Austrian writer Stefan Zweig (1881 – 1942)

Vassily-Kandinsky.jpeg
Above: Russian painter Vassily Kandinsky (1866 – 1944)

Hans Arp.JPG
Above: Alsatian painter Jean Arp (1886 – 1966)

Partly too it was because theatres were closed or restricted elsewhere.

Little of this ferment was homegrown.

Hugo Ball and Emmy Hennings, the wild spirits behind Dada, were German pacifists.

Hugoball.jpg
Above: German writer Hugo Ball (1886 – 1927)

Emmy Hennings, Dadaist pioneer | House of Switzerland
Above: German artist Emmy Hennins (1885 – 1948)

Carl Jung’s theories developed from the theories of Viennese Sigmund Freud.

ETH-BIB-Jung, Carl Gustav (1875-1961)-Portrait-Portr 14163 (cropped).tif
Above: Swiss psychologist Carl Jung (1875 – 1961)

The Swiss themselves were suspicious of the backwash of foreigners and showed scant interest in their avant-garde activities.

Police files during these years followed émigré movements, as they did during the Second World War.

Zürich was where Joyce got down to writing Ulysses.

The germ of the idea had come to him during an aborted stay in Rome – and its last line – “Trieste, Zürich, Paris” – is, as Alain de Botton says, “a symbol of the cosmopolitan spirit behind its composition“.

Alain de Botton.jpg
Above: Swiss philosopher Alain de Botton

Leopold Bloom, its urban Jewish protagonist, borrows characteristics from Joyce’s friends and acquaintances in the rump of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.

But Bloom has a bit of Zürich in him too – modernist multi-culti Zürich, the Zürich of the flâneur as well as the banker.

Joyce’s friends in the Swiss city were mostly Jews, Greeks and displaced Austro-Hungarians, as they had benn in Trieste.

Bibliophilia on Twitter | James joyce, Joyce, James joyce poems
Above: James Joyce

Behind him Zürich, suddenly confronted by this and other manifestations of a revolutionary spirit, sat like some austere grandmother long since inured and indifferent to the babbling of unfamiliar progeny.”

Detail

Joyce’s Zürich drinking haunts signal his relative affluence.

Whereas in Trieste he had frequented sailors’s dens in the port, in Zürich a better class of establishment came to the fore, the restaurant Zum Roten Kreuz, the Café Terrasse and the Café Odéon.

Ansichtskarte / Postkarte Fluntern Zürich Stadt Schweiz, | akpool.de
Above: Zum Roten Kreuz, Zürich

In The End of the World News (1982), Anthony Burgess imagines Joyce and Lenin at nearby tables in the Zum Roten Kreuz, both plotting revolutions in two different dimensions.

The End of the World News: An Entertainment - Wikipedia

Together with Joyce’s regular haunt, the Pfauen Café, these locales hosted a medley of polyglot drinking, singing and repartee.

Other Joyce Sites | ZURICH JAMES JOYCE FOUNDATION
Above: Pfauen Café, Zürich

As the Swiss writer Dürrenmatt reminds us, the Hapsburgs originated just outside of town.

Zürich can strike the visitor as the most Western of the Mitteleuropa cities.

Dürrenmatt in 1989
Above: Swiss writer Friedrich Dürrenmatt (1921 – 1990)

Many of Joyce’s hosteleries still flourish a century later.

The Café Odéon reduced to a third its original size, is usually crowded with shoppers and capuccino drinkers – bags and dogs at their feet – rather than the radical loudmouths of the early 20th century.

In the winter there is the smell of wet cashmere.

Gilt mirrors and brassy bar have seen generations come and go through the stained glass doors.

Café Bar Odeon - Zürich - Guidle
Above: Café Odeon, Zürich

Across the road, the Café Terrasse is also crowded.

The pastries are good, the décor a bit doily.

Gone are the newspapers on batons, that quintessential feature of the central European coffeehouse, but laptops are in evidence.

Oompa music on public squares has been replaced by ringtones at tables.

Joyce’s bars have weathered revolutions and wars and come up in the world in the meantime.

TERRASSE, Zürich - Old Town - Menü, Preise & Restaurant Bewertungen -  Tripadvisor
Above: Café Terrasse, Zürich

The Joyce family viewed Zürich as an interlude that stretched to four years, intending to return to furniture and pictures in Trieste as soon as the First World War had ended.

But nobody knew when that would be.

They occupied a number of furnished apartments in the course of their stay, the longest at Universitätsstrasse 29.

Joyce in Zurich | ZURICH JAMES JOYCE FOUNDATION
Above: Universitätsstrasse 29, Zürich

The language at home was a Triestine dialect of Italian, with Slavic undertones.

Giorgio was turning ten when they arrived in Zürich, and Lucia eight.

They were put back two years in school, as they knew no German.

Joyce himself had quite good German – enough to write lovelorn letters to his fancy women – but for Nora the language was a trial.

Above: “A complete word“, Illustration in the essay “The Awful German Language“, A Tramp Abroad, Mark Twain

Market day in Locarno reminded her of Trieste:

It was quite lively to hear the men calling out the prices and making as much noise as they could just like in Trieste.

The markets in Ticino | ticino.ch
Above: Market, Locarno, Ticino, Switzerland

Contact with other languages in the smithy of the Austro-Hungarian Empire made Joyce instantly aware of his own, its registers, dialects, history and slang.

He code shifted from Triestine Italian to Zürich German to Modern Greek.

Ulysses has the cosmopolitan soundscape of the war years, its language a mixing board, its constituent parts broken down, like notes, like an opera.

On any given day in Zürich you never know what languages you might encounter.

Joyce became an auditor of the world’s sounds, at sea in the flotsam of language, adrift from meaning, aware of multiple levels and the interpenetration of words.

A tram bell.

Above: Zürich

A cry in the street.

The murmur along a bar.

Rutting in the next room.

Vision reduced, his ears took up the slack.

Above: Zürich

It was in Zürich that Joyce’s eye troubles turned serious.

His glaucoma required an iridectomy, the first of eleven operations over the next fifteen years.

In 1917 he wrote to Pound:

On Saturday when walking in the street I got suddenly a violent Hexenschuss which incapicated me from moving for about twenty minutes.

I managed to crawl into a tram and get home.

It got better in the evening but the next day I had symptoms of glaucoma again – slightly better today.

Tomorrow morning I am going to the Augenklinik.

This climate is impossible for me so that, operated or not, I want to go away next month.

I am advised to go to Italian Switzerland.

Acute angle closure glaucoma.JPG

Neither Joyce nor Nora adapted to Zürich’s muggy climate after balmy seaside Trieste.

In August 1917, Nora and the children went ahead to Locarno while Joyce remained behind.

On Bahnhofstrasse he suffered the episode of glaucoma described to Pound.

The eye clinic operated successfully and Nora returned to comfort her husband.

In the days following, Joyce wrote one of his more touching poems about the loss of youthful vision and vim,

Bahnhofstrasse is named for Zürich’s main thoroughfare, the most expensive shopping street in the world.

He was only 37.

Bahnhofstrasse Zurich | Shopping in Zurich
Above: Bahnhofstrasse, Zürich

Ah, star of evil! Star of pain!

Highhearted youth comes not again.

Nor old heart’s wisdom yet to know

The signs that mock me as I go.

Should James Joyce's remains leave Switzerland?
Above: James Joyce statue, Zürich

They wintered in Locarno, staying at the Pension Villa Rossa and laster at the Pension Daheim.

Above: Postcard, Pension Villa Rosa, Locarno

The nearby fishing village of Ascona was already an artists’ colony.

Ascona IMG 1646.jpg
Above: Ascona

But Joyce grew bored in Locarno.

He was a city boy at heart.

Despite snow and an earthquake, he was able to complete there the three opening episodes of Ulysses – the manuscript title page bears the inscription “Pension Daheim, Locarno, Switzerland“.

Above: Pension Daheim, Locarno

Nora and the children relaxed into the Italian atmosphere, with its accents of home.

Pizza was on the menu.

Eq it-na pizza-margherita sep2005 sml.jpg

Because of his glaucoma Joyce decided to forgo absinthe, his tipple at the time, for Swiss white wines.

Absinthe-glass.jpg
Above: Absinthe

He settled on Fendant de Sion, comparing its golden hue to an Archduchess’ piss:

For now the wine was known as ‘the Archduchess’ and is so celebrated in ‘Finnegan’s Wake‘.”

Varone Fendant de Sion Soleil du Valais | Vivino

Glaucoma didn’t prevent his other eye from wandering.

Two women took hold of Joyce’s imagination, apart from Nora, during his stay in Switzerland.

Both made their way into Ulysses, forming the composite figure of Gerty McDowell showing her drawers to an admiring Bloom.

Ulysses (English Edition) eBook : James Joyce: Amazon.de: Kindle-Shop

Dr. Gertrude Kaempffer was a 26-year-old recovering from tuberculosis in Orselina above Locarno, where the Madonna del Sasso Basilica commands the valley.

Above: Orselina

When she rebuffed his initial advances, Joyce conducted an erotic correspondence with her from Zürich, using a poste restante address, as Bloom does in Ulysses.

Joyce revealed to her his first sexual experience when he was 14 while walking with the family nanny through fields on the edge of a wood.

The nanny was taken short and asked him to look the other way.

She went off to pee.

He heard the sound of liquid splashing on the ground…..

The sound aroused him:

I jiggled furiously.‘”

exclamation mark - Simple English Wiktionary

This information proved less stimulating to Dr. Kaempffer than to the author of Ulysses and so their correspondence fizzled out.

White Balloon And Deflated Balloon On A White Background High-Res Stock  Photo - Getty Images

The second of Joyce’s dalliances, Marthe Fleischmann, was closer to home.

She lived around the corner from the Joyce flat at 29 Universitätsstrasse, Kitty Corner.

Their windows were in sight of each other and he first spotted her as she was pulling the toilet chain.

Joyce gives to the hero of Finnegans Wake an erotic interest in watching girls pee and the author’s correspondence with his wife Nora confirms this peccadillo.

Marthe was attractive, had notions about herself and walked with a slight limp (as does Gerty in Ulysses).

Joyce cast Marthe as the reincarnation of his youthful muse first spotted on Dublin’s North Strand: girlish, birdlike, ethereal, her skirts hiked up.

He began a correspondence in French with Marthe, deploying his usual Irish blether about Dante, Shakespeare and the Dark Lady of the Sonnets – and, by the way, could we meet?

He shaved two years off his age, continued ogling her through the window and sent her a copy of his wee book of poems, Chamber Music, named in jest for another piddling floozy.

Martha Fleischmann (Aufrichtig) (1901 - c.1942) - Genealogy
Above: Martha Fleischmann (1901 – 1942)

They arranged to meet on his birthday – 2 February, Candlemas Day.

Joyce borrowed his friend Frank Budgen’s flat for the assignation.

Smells and bells, a Hanukkah candelabra (Joyce thought she was of Jewish ancestry), the whole caboodle:

By nightfall everything was ready.

He had lit the candles both because they were romantic and because he wished to see his visitor in a flattering light.

His Pagan Marthe both yielded and withheld.

He confided to Budgen when they met later on that he had ‘explored the coldest and the hottest parts of a woman’s body’.

Hanukkah חג חנוכה.jpg

Marthe was already a kept woman.

She liked her airs and graces, and secreted rosewater hankies in her cleavage.

But she wasn’t adverse to Joyce’s dirty talk about undergarments.

Her paramour (‘Vormund‘) was an engineer named Rudolph Hiltpond, himself putting it about a bit with sundry mistresses, who soon got wind of the peeping Paddy next door.

As Joyce expressed it militarily in a letter to Frank Budgen:

Result, status: Waffenstillstand.” (Armistice)

Women's Fashion During WWI: 1914–1920 - Bellatory

It was with Budgen with whom Joyce made a second trip to Locarno in May 1919.

He was an ex-sailor, a painter and had modelled for the Swiss artist August Suter.

He had an associative, imaginative mind, much like Joyce’s.

The allegorical figure representing Labour, was modelled on Budgen, as was the sailor on a pack of Player’s Navy Cut cigarettes.

Joyce was continuously looking for material to feed his mythopoeic imagination, even manipulating conversations to get it, as August Suter noted:

He imperceptively brought on conversation that he happened to need for his work.”

Above: English artist Frank Budgen (1882 – 1971)

On this second visit to Locarno, Joyce and Budgen encountered the Baroness St. Leger, who lived on the tiny Isola di Brissago on Lago Maggiore.

Joyce was working on the Circe episode of Ulysses.

Circe in Homer is a kind of temptress emasculator, with Odysseus as her captive boy-toy and her island as a dolce far niente.

Joyce thought the Baroness might fit the bill:

She had been thrice married.

He dubbed her “the Siren of Lago Maggiore“.

Isoledibrissago.jpg
Above: Aerial view of the Brissago Isles

A Siren in winter, perhaps.

The Baroness is one of those fascinating figures on the margins of writers’ lives.

She was born in St. Petersburg in 1856 and was rumoured to be the illegitimate daughter of Tsar Alexander II.

Zar Alexander II.jpg (cropped).jpg
Above: Russian Tsar Alexander II (1818 – 1881)

Her birth certificate gives her parents’ names as Nicholas Alexandre and Maryam Meyer.

Antoinetta was pretty and vivacious.

Ein Vorschlag aus dem Tessin: Isole del Brissago - FORUM elle
Above: Baroness St. Leger (1886 – 1948)

Her piano teacher had been Franz Liszt.

Two husbands quickly palled.

Her third husband was the Anglo-Irish Lord Richard Fleming Saint Leger, from Kingstown (Dun Laoghaire), apparently descended from Richard the Lionheart.

They bought the two Brissago islands for CHF 10,000 and the Baroness proceeded to import thousands of plants and turn the hideaway into a botanical paradise befitting the Mediterranean microclimate.

Her other passion, like Circe‘s, was for young men.

Husband #3 soon abandoned her in 1897.

Above: Villa Brissago

By the time Joyce pitched up in 1919, she was 63 and as flighty as ever, coming over the water to greet him standing up in her boat.

The poet Rilke, fond of people’s castles as he was, had visited the Baroness the same year, so she had no shortage of scribbling admirers.

Rilke in 1900
Above: German poet Rainer Maria Rilke (1875 – 1926)

She liked to make puppets and had hundreds of them on the island, which may indicate her psychological makeup.

Penniless in 1927, she was forced to sell her islands to the department store magnate Max Emden.

Above: Villa Emden, Brissago Islands

He was German-Jewish and fed up with the retail business.

(He was the founder of the KaDeVe chain, still ringing the tills in Germany.)

On a good day he dressed in a kimono and did his yoga and meditation on the Roman baths he had built on the island.

Curvaceous lovelies kept him company.

There was nude water-skiing and slap and tickle among the guests.

He was a department store Gatsby.

MaxEmden.JPG
Above: Max Emden

Monte Verità art collector Baron Eduard von der Heydt (more of a toga man) was an occasional poolside visitor.

Eduard von der Heydt im Tresor der Von der Heydt‘s Bank AG, Berlin.jpg
Above: Eduard von der Heydt (1882 – 1964)

Emden died in 1940, after fifteen good years in a kimono.

The Baroness outlived him, saw out two world wars as well as the Crimean War and the downfall of the Russian Empire, and died age 92 in 1948 – still penniless, in an old people’s home in Intragna.

ThinkShop: The Baroness on Brissago Islands
Above: Baroness St. Leger

Like many Swiss stories, this one has a sting in the tale.

In 2012, the grandson of Max Emden, a Chilean, claimed ownership of Claude Monet’s “Poppy Fields at Vétheuil“, valued at over €20 million.

The Bührle Foundation in Zürich has the famous painting and is clear about the provenance.

Max Enden’s only son fled Switzerland for Chile at the beginning of the war and the painting was apparently sold to finance his excape from the Nazis.

The German government has not ruled in favour of restitution.

Poppy field near Vétheuil · Claude Monet · Stiftung Sammlung E.G. Bührle
Above: Claude Monet’s Poppy Fiedls at Vétheuil

Other details of Joyce’s Swiss stay make their way into Ulysses.

A visit to the Rhine Falls near Schaffhausen found a faint echo in ‘Circe‘.

SBB RABe 514 DTZ Rheinfall.jpg
Above: Rhine Falls, Schaffhausen, Switzerland

Joyce co-founded an acting company, the English Players, and became its business manager.

The company was pitched to the British government as a contribution to the war effort, and mainly staged works by Irish playwrights, such as Oscar Wilde, George Bernard Shaw and John Millington Synge.

Wilde in 1882
Above: Oscar Wilde (1854 – 1900)

Middle-aged man with greying hair and full beard
Above: George Bernard Shaw (1856 – 1950)

For Synge’s Riders to the Sea, Nora played a principal role and Joyce sang offstage, which he did again when Robert Browning’s In a Balcony was staged.

He hoped the company would eventually stage his play, Exiles, but his participation in the English Players declined in the wake of the Great Influenza Epidemic of 1918, though the company continued until 1920.

The Pfauen complex, a large stone building. Theatre is in the center. Cafe used to be right of theatre
Above: The Pfauen in Zürich. Joyce’s preferred hangout was the cafe, which used to be on the right corner. The theatre staged the English Players.

Joyce’s work with the English Players involved him in a lawsuit. 

Henry Wilfred Carr (1894 – 1962), a wounded war veteran and British consul, accused Joyce of underpaying him for his role in The Importance of Being Earnest.

Carr sued for compensation.

Joyce countersued for libel.

When the cases were settled in 1919, Joyce won the compensation case but lost the one for libel.

The incident ended up creating acrimony between the British consulate and Joyce for the rest of his time in Zürich.

Clean-shaven young white man in Scottish military dress uniform, with kilt and bearskin
Above: Henry Carr in Canadian Black Watch uniform, 1917

Up to rheumy Zürich town came an Irish man one day,

And as the place was rather dull he thought he’d give a play,

So that the German propagandists might be rightly riled,

But the bully British Philistine once more drove Oscar Wilde.”

Joyce, James Augustine Aloysius (1882–1941), writer | Oxford Dictionary of  National Biography
Above: James Joyce

Fritz Senn, the keeper of the flame at the James Joyce Foundation in Zürich, has uncovered numerous references to his city in Ulysses and Finnegans Wake.

Zürich served as a refuge from the war and provided Joyce with an atmosphere, an urban vibe and a cacophony of friends who fuelled his masterpiece.

UZH - The Swiss Centre of Irish Studies @ the Zurich James Joyce Foundation  - About Us

When the Joyce family returned to Trieste in 1919, it was not for long.

It had become a backwater.

By 1919, Joyce was in financial straits again.

Zürich had become expensive to live in after the war.

Furthermore, he was becoming isolated as the city’s emigres returned home.

In October 1919, Joyce’s family moved back to Trieste, but it had changed.

The Austro-Hungarian empire had ceased to exist.

Trieste was now an Italian city in post-war recovery.

Eight months after his return, Joyce went to Sirmione, Italy, to meet Pound, who made arrangements for him to move to Paris.

The castle at the entrance of the old town
Above: Sirmione, Italy

Joyce and his family packed their belongings and headed for Paris in June 1920.

Paris was the happening place and Zürich had whetted Joyce’s appetite for it.

File:La Tour Eiffel vue de la Tour Saint-Jacques, Paris août 2014 (2).jpg
Above: Paris, France

Joyce was almost blind in the last months of 1940.

He and his family were on the run from yet another war.

The Swiss Federal Aliens’ Police rejected Joyce’s initial application for visas on the supposition that he and his family were Jews.

The Swiss writer Jacques Mercanton put the authorities right on this point.

Joyce himself privately declared that he “was not a Jew from Judea but an Aryan from Erin“.

The mayor of Zürich, the rector of its university, the Swiss Society of Authors, and other notables vouched for him.

Mercanton, Jacques | Lenos Verlag
Above: Jacques Mercanton (1909 – 1997)

(Up in the University Library, Joyce researched Ulysses.)

University of Zurich seal.svg
Above: Logo of the University of Zürich

Cantonal authorities wanted a guarantee of CHF 50,000, later reduced to CHF 20,000.

The Joyce family eventually succeeded in getting entry permits.

In December 1940 they came into Switzerland by way of Geneva, where Stephen Joyce, the writer’s eight-year-old grandson, had his bicycle impounded at the border because of inability to pay import duties.

A view over Geneva and the lake
Above: Genève (Geneva), Switzerland

They spent the night of 14 December 1940 at the Richemonde Hotel, before moving on to Lausanne.

Hotel Richemond Geneva - Jep Cary
Above: Hotel Richemond, Geneva

Seán Lester, acting general secretary of the League of Nations and a Belfast man, had tea with the Joyce family on the Sunday afternoon, in the marble and ormolu salon of their hotel:

SeanLester.jpg
Above: Seán Lester (1888 – 1959)

Flag of League of Nations
Above: Flag of the League of Nations

The famous Joyce is tall, slight, in the fifties, blue eyes and a good thatch of hair.

No one would hesitate in looking at him to recognize his nationality and accent as Dublin as when he left it over thirty years ago.

seated portrait of James Joyce in a suit. He is in three-quarters view looking left, wearing a suit. Table with books is in background on the right.
Above: James Joyce

His eyesight is very bad and he told me it had been some years ago by the famous Vogt of Zürich, who had also operated on de Valera (President of Ireland and statesman).

Alfred Vogt.jpg
Above: Swiss ophthalmologist Alfred Vogt (1879 – 1943)

Éamon de Valera.jpg
Above: Éamon de Valera (1882 – 1975)

His son, seemingly in his late twenties, came in first.

A fine, well-built fellow, with a peculiar hybrid accent in English.

He told me he is a singer and has sung in Paris and New York.

James Joyce and his wife Nora with their son Giorgio, daughter-in-law Helen and two-year-old grandson Stephen James Joyce in Paris in 1934. Photo: Bettmann Archive
Above: James Joyce and his wife Nora with their son Giorgio, daughter-in-law Helen and two-year-old grandson Stephen James Joyce in Paris in 1934.

The Richemonde sits one block back from the more illustrious Hotel Beau Rivage on Geneva’s lakeshore.

The Beau Rivage is where royalty stayed, where Empress Sisi of Austria-Hungary died from a madman’s stiletto, where Somerset Maugham and other international spies kept their ears open.

Hotel Beau Rivage Geneva | Geneva.info
Above: Hotel Beau Rivage, Geneva

Isabel da Áustria 1867.jpg
Above: Austrian Empress Elisabeth (“Sisi“) (1837 – 1898)

Above: An artist’s rendition of the stabbing of Elisabeth by the Italian anarchist Luigi Lucheni in Geneva, 10 September 1898

Maugham photographed by Carl Van Vechten in 1934
Above: William Somerset Maugham (1874 – 1965)

The Richemonde is equally glitzy:

Charlie Chaplin, Sophia Loren and Michael Jackson found rooms with a view there.

Above: Poster of Charlie Chaplin (1889 – 1977)

Sophia Loren - 1959.jpg
Above: Sophie Loren (née Sofia Costanza Brigida Villani Scicolone)

A photograph of Michael Jackson singing into a microphone
Above: Michael Jackson (1958 – 2009)

It is a historic corner overlooking Brunswick Monument – a history not lost on James Joyce.

Brunswick Monument - Wikipedia
Above: Brunswick Monument, Geneva

As a boy he had lived on Dublin’s North Richmond Street.

Pillar to Post: SUNDAY REVIEW /ARABY /SHORT STORY BY JAMES JOYCE
Above: North Richmond Street, Dublin, Ireland

Great Brunswick Street was where he sang in the Antient Concert Rooms at the beginning of the century.

A Night at the Ancient Concert Rooms
Above: Antient Concert Rooms, Dublin, Ireland

The Joyce family might have felt that they were once again at history’s mercy.

Above: History, Frederick Dielman (1896)

Finnegans Wake (1939), 17 years in the writing, had received a puzzled reception the previous year.

Needing two magnifying glasses to read and write, Joyce was addicted to Radio Éireann.

Since 1920, he, Nora and their two children had been living in Paris, where the writer had achieved fame and squandered some fortune.

Now Paris was occupied and they were on the move once more.

In the late 1930s, Joyce became increasingly concerned about the rise of fascism and antisemitism. 

As early as 1938, Joyce was involved in helping a number Jews escape Nazi persecution.

After the defeat of France in World War II, Joyce and his family fled from Nazi occupation, returning to Zürich a final time.

They were going to settle in Zürich, where they had some good friends.

I said I thought it was an unusual place for him to choose and asked, ‘What about Suisse Romande?’.

His wife then intervened and said that Zürich had always been associated with certain crises in their lives.

They had rushed from Austria at the beginning of the last war and had lived in Zürich very comfortably.

They had spent their honeymoon there.

It was there that Joyce’s eyesight had been saved and now they were going back in another crisis.

They liked the solid virtues of the people.

James Joyce: Irish writer died in Switzerland on Jan 13 1941
Above: James Joyce

It was these solid Swiss virtues that supported them as the world turned once more to war.

When they returned to Zürich in December 1940, it musr have seemed like déjà vu.

Not more bloody Swiss German, Nora must have thought – it was her 4th language.

Friends met them at the Hauptbahnhof.

Above: Hauptbahnhof (Grand Central Station), Zürich

Staying at the Hotel Pension Delphin on Muhlebachstrasse, Joyce wrote to the Mayor of Zürich to thank him:

The connection between me and your hospitable city extends over a period of nearly forty years and in these painful times I feel honoured that I should owe my presence here in large part to the personal guaranty of Zürich’s first citizen.

Quartierverein - Zürich Fluntern

The Joyce family celebrated Christmas with friends.

He walked out in the snow in the afternoons with his grandson Stephen, to the confluence of the Sihl and Limmat Rivers, where today the spot has an inscription from Finnegans Wake:

Yssel that the Limmat?” and “legging a jig or so on the Sihl“.

File:Limmat & Sihl - James-Joyce-Kanzel 2011-08-20 15-47-00.JPG - Wikimedia  Commons
Above: Where the Limmat and Sihl Rivers meet, Zürich

At the Kronenhalle, Joyce ate his last dinner.

The bistro has priceless art on the walls and has been feeding artists from Joyce to Picasso to Dürrenmatt and Frisch for over a century.

Restaurant Kronenhalle Zürich | Schönste Zeit Magazin
Above: Restaurant Kronenhalle, Zürich

On 11 January 1941, Joyce underwent surgery in Zürich for a perforated duodenal ulcer.

He fell into a coma the following day.

He awoke at 2 am on 13 January 1941, and asked a nurse to call his wife and son.

They were en route when he died 15 minutes later, less than a month before his 59th birthday.

His body was buried in the Fluntern Cemetery in Zürich.

Swiss tenor Max Meili sang “Addio terra, addio cielo” from Monteverdi’s L’Orfeo at the burial service.

FORGOTTEN OPERA SINGERS : Max Meili (Tenor) (Winterthur, Switzerland 11  December 1899 - Zürich, Switzerland 17 March 1970)
Above: Max Meili (1899 – 1970)

Joyce had been a subject of the United Kingdom all his life and only the British consul attended the funeral.

Although two senior Irish diplomats were in Switzerland at the time, neither attended Joyce’s funeral.

When Joseph Walshe, secretary at the Department of External Affairs in Dublin, was informed of Joyce’s death by Frank Cremins, chargé d’affaires at Bern, Walshe responded:

Please wire details of Joyce’s death.

If possible find out did he die a Catholic?

Express sympathy with Mrs Joyce and explain inability to attend funeral.”

Ireland and the Nazis: a troubled history

Above: Joseph Walshe (1886 – 1956)

Buried originally in an ordinary grave, Joyce was moved in 1966 to a more prominent “honour grave“, with a seated portrait statue by American artist Milton Hebald nearby.

Nora, whom he had married in 1931, survived him by 10 years.

She is buried by his side, as is their son Giorgio, who died in 1976.

Horizontal gravestone saying "JAMES JOYCE", "NORA BARNACLE JOYCE", GEORGE JOYCE", and "...ASTA OSTERWALDER JO...", all with dates. Behind the stone is a green hedge and a seated statue of Joyce holding a book and pondering.
Above: James Joyce Grave, Flautern Cemetery, Zürich

After Joyce’s death, the Irish government declined Nora’s request to permit the repatriation of Joyce’s remains, despite being persistently lobbied by the American diplomat John J. Slocum.

In October 2019, a motion was put to Dublin City Council to plan and budget for the costs of the exhumations and reburials of Joyce and his family somewhere in Dublin, subject to his family’s wishes.

Logo

The proposal immediately became controversial, with the Irish Times commenting:

“It is hard not to suspect that there is a calculating, even mercantile, aspect to contemporary Ireland’s relationship to its great writers, whom we are often more keen to ‘celebrate’, and if possible monetise, than read.”

The Irish Times logo.svg

The Pfauen has shut, but the Schauspielhaus right next door, where Brecht’s Mother Courage got its premiere, is still packing them in.

Brecht in 1954
Above: Bertolt Brecht (1898 – 1956)

One of Joyce’s old apartments is gone, bulldozed by the developers.

Under the Uraniabrücke, gaze up at Frank Budgen, Joyce’s model friend, in the stony buff.

Imagine having to go past yourself like that every day.

Other Joyce Sites | ZURICH JAMES JOYCE FOUNDATION
Above: Statue of Frank Budgen

Together with Thomas Mann and Vladimir Nabokov, Joyce is one of the 20th century’s literary greats.

All three were marked by history.

As Joyce fled Vichy France for Zürich, Nabokov boarded the boat for America and Mann took refuge in California.

They all eventually found peace and quiet to write in Switzerland, sometimes engaging but more often disengaging from the conflicts that surrounded them.

Nabokov’s final resting place is at Clarens above Lac Léman (Lake Geneva).

Above: Vladimir and Vera Nabokov gravesite, Cimetière de Clarens, near Montreux, Switzerland

Mann is buried at Kilchberg across the Lake (Zürichsee) from Joyce, who died on 13 January 1941, age 59.

Above: The grave of Thomas, Katia, Erika, Monika, Michael and Elisabeth Mann, Kilchberg, Switzerland

The great modernist is buried next to Nora in Zürich’s Flauntern Cemetery, within a lion’s roar of the Zoo.

trumb
Above: Friedhof Flauntern, Zürich

He watched the scene and thought of life; and (as always happened when he thought of life) he became sad.

A gentle melancholy took possession of him.

He felt how useless it was to struggle against fortune, this being the burden of wisdom which the ages had bequeathed him.

James Joyce, Dubliners

Dubliners by James Joyce: 9780812983012 | PenguinRandomHouse.com: Books

I have often told my wife – and anyone who has cared to listen – that I was willing to live in Switzerland, but that, given a choice, I would not choose to die in Switzerland.

Joyce chose Zürich as his final choice of exile.

Though I resided in Landschlacht, I “lived” in St. Gallen, for it was in the latter where most of the work I did and most of the friends I had were.

Above: Old houses, St. Gallen, Switzerland

On Wednesday, I will visit St. Gallen again.

There are tales to be told.

Some of them may sting…..

Above: Abbey Library, St. Gallen

(To be continued…..)

Sources: Wikipedia / Wikivoyage / Google / Personal journals / “Heavy snowfall in Turkey forces Istanbul Airport to close“, Al Jazeera, 24 January 2022 / Sheryl Crow, “The Book” / James Joyce: Chamber Music/Dubliners/Exiles/Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man / Paul Kirby, “Is Russia preparing to invade Ukraine?“, BBC News, 26 January 2022 / Stephen Leacock, Sunshine Sketches of a Little Town / Mícheál MacCraith, “Princess Gwendoline: Rome’s Mother of the Poor“, Wanted in Rome, January 2020 / Chantal Panozzo, Swiss Life: 30 Things I Wish I’d Known / Charlie Rich, “Behind Closed Doors” / Padraig Rooney, The Gilded Chalet: Off-piste in Literary Switzerland / Wanted in Rome, “James Joyce in Rome“, 16 June 2021 / Wanted in Rome, “Tracing the footsteps of Rome’s foreign writers and artists“, 2 November 2018 / http://www.aab.it (Anglo-American Bookshop) / http://www.gattidiroma.net (Cats of Rome)

T minus zero

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Monday 17 January 2022

T minus zero” means “out of time“.

This comes from a countdown convention used in by both the American military and NASA.

Generally, it is used when counting down to a major event that will happen at a specific time.

Mathematically, T is time, minus whatever amount of time is left until the event happens.

If the New Year’s ball is dropping in ten minutes, one could say “The ball is dropping in T minus 10 minutes and counting!”

Therefore, “T minus zero” means that there is no time left.

T-Minus Zero. In our busy days, time runs out faster… | by Andrew Lee |  Medium

Tolerate what is created because of the Creator.”

(Yunus Emre)

Yunus Emre Gedenkstätte in Ortschaft Haci Bektas bei Nevsehir TR.jpg
Above: Statue of Yunus Emre (1238 – 1328) in Hacibektaş, Turkey

The past is a foreign country.

They do things differently there.

L.P. Hartley, The Go-Between (1953)

The Go-Between by L.P. Hartley
Above: L.P. (Leslie Poles) Hartley (1895 – 1972)

This evening I find myself thinking a lot about the past and not the future.

Of at least the past as it pertains to the future.

In the short time I am in the area, when my time and attention is not required by the wife, it is a question of when and where I can meet friends from my Starbucks days.

Starbucks Corporation Logo 2011.svg
Above: Starbucks logo

So far, I have met Nesha (of Serbia) and Volkan (of Turkey), and my former students at Dimetix in Herisau, Naomi and Alanna of Canada, and Augustin from…..

Everywhere.

I am still hoping to see Sinan of Amriswil, Katja and Michael of St. Gallen, Sonja of Luzern, and whomever I can arrange time with, next week.

Personal Organizer Stock Illustration - Download Image Now - iStock

The dilemma I am presented with in all of these reunions lies in the explanation of where I have been and what have I done since I left Switzerland on 1 March 2021.

What have I seen in Turkey?

How is teaching in Eskişehir?

What was my life like?

And the problem is I am not really sure what it is I should tell them and, more importantly, what it is they want to hear.

Flag of Turkey
Above: Flag of Turkey

I have been to faraway places with strange-sounding names as distant in their imagination as Hogwarts or Oz is in mine.

Hogwarts model studio tour.jpg
Above: Model of Hogwarts

Oz flag.svg
Above: Flag of Oz, L. Frank Baum (1856 – 1919)

Far away places with strange sounding names
Far away over the sea
Those far away places with the strange sounding names are
Calling
Calling me
Goin’ to China or maybe Siam
I wanna see for myself
Those far away places I’ve been reading about in a
Book that I took from a shelf
I start getting’ restless whenever I hear the whistle of a train
I pray for the day I can get underway
And look for those castles in Spain
They call me a dreamer
Well maybe I am
But I know that I’m burning to see those
Far away places with the strange sounding names
Calling, calling me
Me.

sheet music far away places - bing crosby: Amazon.co.uk: joan whitney -  alex kramer: Books

I search for words that can transport them from the reality they know to the reality I have experienced, but perhaps this is as impossible as describing an experiment with LSD to someone who has always been clean and sober.

Above: Square blotters of the drug LSD

It is akin to showing a postcard of the Colosseum and hoping that you can recreate in them the sensation of running your fingers lightly across the centuries-worn marble blocks, trying to visualize those whose hands carefully shaped and placed each one.

Photographs are never the same as memories.

Colosseo 2020.jpg
Above: The Flavian Amphitheatre / Colosseum, Rome, Italy

To feel the dusty, stony streets of Pompeii beneath travel-sore feet on a blazing summer day with the crater of Vesuvius looming over you.

It changes the way you think about what happened there 2,000 years ago.

I couldn’t tear my gaze from the preserved figures showing the bodies of human beings and animals contorted in fear and torment, ghosts winding their ethereal and melancholy way through the empty doorways and windows of every domus.

I felt ashamed in looking on their suffering as a mere spectator.

I could hardly bear to look and taking photos felt like sacrilege, but I couldn’t stand not to lock each one in my memory.

Theathres of Pompeii.jpg
Above: Pompeii and Mount Vesuvius, Italy

Do I bother speaking about Wall Street English Eskisehir?

Its cast of characters – staff and students?

Do I bother mentioning our jargon – Encounters, Complimentary Classes, Social Clubs – or do I remain silent and save myself many explanations?

Wall Street English logo.png

Do I speak of what is Western about Eskişehir (for example, the traffic, the ES Park shopping mall, my fitness centre in a three-star hotel, the city’s energetic mayor Yilmaz Büyükersen, the high speed trains to Ankara and Istanbul, the flashy tram system, the city’s three universities, the nachos and rum Sunday evening feasts with my colleague Rasool) or would they be more enchanted by descriptions of meerschaum trinkets, the appealing crop of Ottoman houses in the Odunpazari district, the fairytale castle, the beauty of Parisian bridges and Venetian-style boats of the Porsuk River, the tranquillity of Sazova Park, and the poetry of native son Yunus Emre?

Above: The first Turkish car Devrim, Eskişehir, Turkey

The waters always flowed, dried up, passed the time, many sultans left the throne, the world is a window, and everyone looked.

(Yunus Emre)

Let’s meet, let’s make it easy.

Let’s love, let’s be loved, the world is left to no one.

Ingenuity is to be able to see beauty, to have the secret of loving.

I have read and collected the meaning of four books.

As for love, I saw it was a long syllable.

I am a bunch of dirt and a little bit of water and that’s what I am proud of.

If I don’t say I love you, it is because I am choked by love.

My job is for love, the place of love is hearts, and I have come to make hearts.

(Yunus Emre)

Above: A statue and representative bust of Yunus Emre in Istanbul

Of what shall I speak?

What can I say?

Shall I speak the truth?

Do I know what the truth is?

Little Lies.jpg

I think again of the airport from whence I flew back to Switzerland.

Sabiha Gökçen International Airport logo.svg

Sabiha Gökçen Airport, Pendik, Istanbul, Turkey, Monday 27 December 2021

The airport is named after Sabiha Gökçen, adoptive daughter of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk and the first female fighter pilot in the world.

She is commemorated by an airport, but how should she be seen?

Sabiha Gökçen Airport.JPG
Above: Sabiha Gökçen Airport, Istanbul, Turkey

According to official Turkish sources and interviews with Sabiha Gökçen, she was the daughter of Mustafa Izzet Bey and Hayriye Hanım, both of whom were of Bosniak ancestry. 

Sabiha gokcen3.jpg
Above: Sabiha Gökçen (1913 – 2001)

During Atatürk’s visit to Bursa in 1925, Sabiha, who was only 12 years old, asked for permission to talk with Atatürk and expressed her wish to study at a boarding school.

After learning her story and about her miserable living conditions, Atatürk decided to adopt her and asked Sabiha’s brother for permission to take her to the Çankaya Presidential Residence in Ankara, where Sabiha would live with Atatürk’s other adoptive daughters, Zehra, Afet and Rukiye.

Ataturk1930s.jpg
Above: Mustafa Kemal Atatürk (1881 – 1934)

Above: Daughters of Mustafa Kemal; left to right: Zehra Aylin, Rukiye (Erkin) and Sabiha (Gökçen).

Turkey. Ankara. Palace of Attaturk (i.e., Ataturk) LOC matpc.16728 (cropped).jpg
Above: Palace of Atatürk

Sabiha attended the Çankaya Primary School in Ankara and the Üsküdar American Academy in Istanbul.

UskudarAmericanAcademyLogo.png
Above: Logo of the American Academy

After the introduction of the Surname Law, Atatürk gave her the family name Gökçen on 19 December 1934.

Gök‘ means sky in Turkish and Gökçen means ‘belonging or relating to the sky‘.

However, she was not an aviator at that time, and it was only six months later that Sabiha developed a passion for flying.

Atatürk attached great importance to aviation and for that purpose oversaw the foundation of the Turkish Aeronautical Association in 1925.

TurkishAeronauticalAssociationLogo.png
Above: Logo of the Turkish Aeronautical Association

He took Sabiha along with him to the opening ceremony of Türkkuşu (Turkish bird) Flight School on 5 May 1935.

During the airshow of gliders and parachutists invited from foreign countries, she got very excited.

As Atatürk asked her whether she would also want to become a skydiver, she nodded:

Yes indeed, I am ready right now“.

Above: Bust of Sabiha Gökçen at the Istanbul Aviation Museum

Atatürk instructed Fuat Bulca, the head of the school, to enroll her as the first female trainee.

She was meant to become a skydiver, but she was much more interested in flying, so she earned her pilot’s licence.

Gökçen was sent to Russia, together with seven male students, for an advanced course in glider and powered aircraft piloting.

Above: Sabiha Gökçen poses with her Breguet 19

However, when she was in Moscow, she learned the news that her sister Zehra had died, and with collapsed morale, she immediately returned to Turkey, isolating herself from social activities for some time.

After a while, with Atatürk’s insistence, Sabiha began working again.

Above: Sabiha Gökçen reviews her Breguet 19

At Eskişehir Aviation School, she received special flight training from Savmi Uçan and Muhittin Bey.

She began flying a motorized aircraft for the first time on 25 February 1936.

Gökçen, due to the success in flight training, Ataturk himself said:  

You’ve made me very happy.

Now I can explain what I have planned for you.

Perhaps you’ll be the first military woman pilot in the world, the world’s first military woman pilot to be from Turkish descent is a proud event, you can imagine, right?

Now I will act immediately and send you to Tayyare School in Eskişehir.

You will receive a special education there.”

As girls were not being accepted by the Turkish War Academies in those years, Sabiha Gökçen was provided, on Atatürk’s orders, with a personalized uniform, and attended a special education programme of eleven months at the Tayyare Mektebi (Aviation School) in Eskisehir in the academic year of 1936-1937.

Turkish War Academies logo.jpg
Above: Logo of the Turkish War Academies

After receiving her flight patents (diploma) she trained to become a war pilot at the 1st Airplane Regiment in Eskişehir for six months.

She improved her skills by flying bomber and fighter planes at the 1st Aircraft Regiment in Eskişehir Airbase and gained experience after participating in the Aegean and Thrace exercises in 1937.

In that same year, she took part in military operations at the Dersim rebellion and became the first Turkish female air force combat pilot.

Turkish soldiers and local people of Dersim region.jpg
Above: Turkish soldiers and local people of Dersim region. They were exiled to other parts of Turkey, 1938.

She stated later in her life in an interview regarding her bombing and killing of tens of thousands of Kurdish civilians that:

I saw them as animals when I bombed them, not as humans.”

A report of the General Staff mentioned the “serious damage” that had been caused by her 50 kg bomb to a group of 50 fleeing Kurds. 

She was awarded with a takdirname (letter of appreciation).

She was also awarded the Turkish Aeronautical Association’s first Murassa (jeweled) Medal for her superior performance in this operation.

In 1938, she carried out a five-day flight around the Balkan countries to great acclaim.

In the same year, she was appointed chief trainer of the Türkkusu Flight School of the Turkish Aeronautical Association, where she served until 1954 as a flight instructor and became a member of the association’s executive board.

She trained four female aviators, Edibe Subaşı, Yıldız Uçman, Sahavet Karapas and Nezihe Viranyali.

Sabiha Gökçen flew around the world for a period of 28 years until 1964.

Her book entitled A Life Along the Path of Atatürk was published in 1981 by the Turkish Aeronautical Association to commemorate Atatürk’s 100th birthday.

Above: Sabiha Gökçen in Athens, during her 1938 Balkan tour

Gökçen made headlines and sparked controversy, in 2004, when Hrant Dink, a journalist of Turkish-Armenian descent, published an interview with a person claiming to be Sabiha’s niece that claimed that she was of Armenian origin.

Many contested the matter, including her adopted sister and the last living daughter of Atatürk, Ülkü Adatepe, disputing this during an interview and stating that Sabiha was of Bosniak ancestry.

According to Adatepe, Sabiha’s mother Hayriye and father Mustafa İzzet were ethnic Bosniaks.

Hrant Dink.jpg
Above: Hrant Dink (1954 – 2007)

The notion that Gökçen could have been Armenian caused controversy in the country.

The Turkish General Staff said the debate “mocked national values” and was “not conducive to social peace“.

Hrant Dink, the journalist who wrote the article, came under criticism, most notably from newspaper columnists and Turkish nationalist groups.

A US consul dispatch leaked by WikiLeaks and penned by an official from the consulate in Istanbul observed that the entire affair “exposed an ugly streak of racism in Turkish society.” 

It is also believed that the affair was one of the reasons that led to Hrant Dink’s assassination in Istanbul in January 2007.

Above: A panorama from Halaskargazi Boulevard in the Sisli district of Istanbul. Over 100,000 mourners marched in Dink’s funeral, protesting his assassination. The office of the Agos newspaper, where Dink was gunned down, is near the right edge of the image: It is the first building to the right of the one with the large black banner.

Sabiha Gökçen died of heart failure at the age of 88 at Gülhane Military Medical Academy on 22 March 2001.

Istanbul asv2020-02 img76 Imperial Medical College.jpg
Above: Imperial Medical College, Istanbul

It is sad to think that there was less controversy about her being the adopted daughter of a leader some view as a dictator and her view of Kurds as animals than there was over the possibility that she was descended from Armenia.

Certainly I can respect the first woman entering any formerly male-exclusive profession.

Frankly, the only criteria we should judge a person on is their character and their capabilities.

I don’t care what the name of an airport is as long as it effectively does what it should: facilitates travelling.

My point of mentioning the airport’s name at all is to wonder whether history is truly fact or whether it is truly a story to explain events that we ourselves were not there to witness or could fully understand.

Above: Check-in area, Sabiha Gökçen Airport, Istanbul

It is said that opinions are a lot like noses, in that everyone has one.

By virtue of each person’s individuality opinions between people will consequently vary.

3D medical animation still shot depicting a human nose

I try to follow the François Hemsterhuis view:

Beautiful is that which gives us the greatest number of ideas in the shortest space of time.

I seek a view of history which is by this definition –

Beautiful.

But can we see history beyond our own blinders?

Frans Hemsterhuis (1721-1790), filosoof, Bestanddeelnr 935-0855.jpg
Above. François Hemsterhuis (1721 – 1790)

This world is a child’s playground for me
A spectacle unfolds day and night before me.

How can Sahbai be a poet?

He has never tasted the wine, nor has he ever gambled.

He has not been beaten with slippers by lovers,

Nor has he ever seen the inside of a jail.

It is not praised if you are the only one to understand what you speak
Interesting is the situation when you speak and the others understand.

I don’t need appreciation neither do I need any return
Let not be if there is no meaning in my couplets.

The eye began to see, the arm found strength
That which was wrapped in ancient clothes,
Now put on a new dress.

It should be said, it’s an excellent inventory
So what’s there to see that’s worth seeing? 

And if you talk with me of Laws and Rules
Open your eyes, and in this ancient halting-place

Before the Laws and Rules that the times now have
All others have become things of yesteryears

If what the eye sees does not rankle in the heart

Sweet is the flow of life in travel spent.

Indian poet Ghalib

Mirza Ghalib photograph 3.jpg
Above: Mirza Ghalib (1797 – 1869)

Truth may be found in the heart of a philosopher, but seldom in the figures of a statistician.

It is far too delicate a thing to be pinned down to columns of numbers on ruled paper.

Much of the material is controversial, but if controversy means the stimulation of thought and ideas, so much the better. 

It is only thus that the citizens of a republic may protect themselves from the evils threatening them from within their borders as well as those which threaten from beyond.

American writer Louis Bromfield

Louis-Bromfield-1933.jpg
Above: Louis Bromfield (1896 – 1956)

Not one death but many,
not accumulation but
 change
,

The feedback proves, the feedback is
the law

Into the same river no man steps twice


No one remains, nor is, one

Around an appearance, one common model, we grow up
many.

Else how is it,
if we remain the same,
we take pleasure now
in what we did not take pleasure before?

Love?
Contrary objects?

Admire and / or find fault?

Use other words, feel other passions,

Have nor figure,

appearance, disposition, tissue
the same?

To be in different states without a change
is not a possibility
.

American poet Charles Olson

Charles Olson.jpg
Above: Charles Olson (1910 – 1970)

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Tuesday 28 December 2021

Perhaps one needs to be medicated to appreciate yesterday’s poetry.

And medicated I surely am.

I have consumed, upon arrival back home from Zürich Airport and Konstanz, NeoCitron (a lemon concoction), MediNacht (an absinthe-looking vile liquid that knocks you out for the night), aspirin and Tiger Balm (for my headache that will not leave) and Wicks vapo-rub (for the cough that will not die).

German Logo of Zurich Airport

Zurich airport img 3324.jpg
Above: Zürich Airport, Switzerland

Rheintorturm, a section of the former city wall of Konstanz at Lake Constance
Above: Rheintorturm (Rhine Gate Tower), Konstanz (Constance)

I have a man-cold.

I am not happy.

I think of the apartment wherein I have lived in for a decade.

I have been absent for ten months and much has changed.

My clutter from common areas has been piled into my bedroom, the kitchen has been renovated into a postmodern wonder I no longer recognize, there are new windows around the apartment, new light switches on the walls, new faucets in the sink.

Of course, traces of the familiar remain: same furniture, same posters on the walls, same magnets on the metallic door frames, same clothes in the closets and on the coat racks, same books on the shelves, same sentiments between man and wife.

But am I the same?

Is she?

Above: Klöster Münsterlingen, 1854

In all my travelling today there was no chance to pick up a New York Times, so to aid sleep – for I am restless despite all the stuff in and on my person – I am left with the English language newspapers I picked up at the airport earlier today: the Daily Sabah and the Hürriyet Daily News.

NewYorkTimes.svg

What awaits me upon my return to Eskisehir is a pile of these Turkish papers yet to be read and written about, for there is within me the desire to show the world the places I visit from the perspective of the places themselves.

Daily Sabah logo.svg

Istanbul -Hürriyet- 2000 by RaBoe 02.jpg

Travelling adds something powerful and vital to the experience of studying history.

Whenever I have travelled to a location hitherto known to me only in the pages of a book, I have been overcome by awe and wonder.

But might such experiences lead to exactly the kinds of distortion that the modern profession of history exists to straighten out?

Turkish Airlines logo 2019 compact.svg

One remarkable aspect of Turkey is the veracity of the slogan:

Turkey: the world’s largest museum.

The slogan is the theme of a project, initiated jointly by the Culture and Tourism Ministry, the Turkish Travel Agencies Union (TÜRSAB) Museums Initiatives, and the Bilkent Cultural Initiatives, to promote Turkey’s historical heritage in an active way, to be helpful in the field of the history of civilizations.

There are museums and ancient sites all around Turkey, each with their own impressive stories, that reveal the importance of the history of humanity in the Republic, a cultural and historical heritage from the Paleolithic age to the Hittite, Seljuk, Byzantine, Ottoman and Republican eras.

I am a mere speck of dust lost in the winds of change.

The Daily Sabah, for all its quality, speaks little of the heritage of this land.

But regularly the Hürriyet Daily News seeks to educate the reader about the heritage that is their home.

For me, it is in moments of travelling to the places that history books and travel guides reveal that I discover the concrete reality of what has up until then only been described to me.

Any lingering assumptions or biases about an ancient people due to my own modern standards or expectations begin to melt away.

To the extent this is possible, I leave my own time and culture that much further behind as I become more fully immersed in another ‘when’ as well as another ‘where’.

Evoked by the right ancient and modern authors, my imagination, as well as analytical understanding, is shaped and magnified by standing in the places where history (even ostensibly or at least reasonably enough) occurred.

Visiting a remnant of the past reaffirms my connection as a concrete human being in his complexity and ambiguity, rather than simply a notetaker of an abstract or legendary historical figure who functions as a mere symbol for something else.

Travelling has the ability to de-mythologize history, while at the same time to experience that a mystical sense of awe and wonder by seeing and touching the locations and artefacts of history.

International travel with its requisite cultural sensitivity and flexibility easily translates to helping me seek (to the extent it is possible) to understand other times and places on their own terms rather than according to my own standards or assumptions.

All of this is true for me regardless of the location or its particular historical associations.

Location of Turkey
Above: Location of Turkey (green)

The past is so different from the present, just as visiting a foreign country for the uninitiated is such a different experience from living at home.

However faithfully we preserve, however authentically we restore, however deeply we immerse ourselves in bygone times, life back then was based on ways of being and believing incommensurable with our own.

The past’s difference is, indeed, one of its charms:

No one would yearn for it if it merely replicated the present.

But we cannot help but view and celebrate it (except) through present-day lenses.

People did do things differently back then.

So, the problem for the student of history is to try to figure out what they did, what they thought, how they lived and then to make some sense of all that for ourselves, for our own situations.

Making a connection with the past is sometimes hard, sometimes easy.

But sometimes, students of history must simply admit that we just do not know, that we just cannot understand fully, how folks lived in the past.

Turkey in Asia Minor and Transcaucasia, 1921
Above: Turkey, 1921

In The Everlasting Man, G. K. Chesterton wrote eloquently about the limits of doing history.

The other day, a scientific summary of the state of a prehistoric tribe began confidently with the words: ‘They wore no clothes.’

Not one reader in a hundred probably stopped to ask himself how we should come to know whether clothes had once been worn by people of whom everything has perished except a few chips of bone and stone.

It was doubtless hoped that we should find a stone hat as well as a stone hatchet.”

It is not contended here that these primitive men did wear clothes any more than they did weave rushes, but merely that we have not enough evidence to know whether they did or not.”

G. K. Chesterton at work.jpg
Above: G.K. (Gilbert Keith) Chesterton (1874 – 1936)

Sometimes, we have to admit that we just don’t know.

The Unknown Unknown: Bookshops and the delight of not getting what you  wanted: Amazon.co.uk: Forsyth, Mark: 9781848317840: Books

To look backward for a while is to refresh the eye, to restore it and to render it the more fit for its prime function of looking forward.

This is why I keep a journal.

This is why I read newspapers and history books.

This is why I write.

How to Read a Book: The Classic Guide to Intelligent Reading by Mortimer J.  Adler

The mountain-rimmed basin of the Euphrates and Tigris Rivers is perhaps the most exotic part of Turkey, offering travellers a heady mix of atmospheric ancient sites and bustling Middle East style towns.

Forming the northern rim of ancient Mesopotamia (“between two rivers“), the region has been of importance since the Neolithic period.

The eastern boundaries of the Roman and Byzantine empires lay here.

The two rivers were crossed by Arab Muslim invaders from the south and east after the birth of Islam in 632.

Almost everybody of any import in Middle Eastern affairs has passed through this region: Crusaders, Armenians, Selçuks, Turcomans, Mongols, French, Americans…..

Political Map of Turkey - Nations Online Project

Traditionally, smallholding farmers and herdsmen scratched a living from this unrewarding land.

Today, the dams of the Southeastern Anatolia Project (SAP) have dramatically improved the fertility of the area, but population drift to the big cities continues.

Above: Sluice gates, SAP

Close to the border with volatile Syria, Arab influence is strong, but even here Kurds predominate and ethnic Turks are in a distinct minority.

The separate sympathies of some Kurds means that there is often a security presence in the area – particularly around Diyarbakir and the frontier zone south and east of Mardin.

Flag of Kurdistan.svg
Above: Flag of Kurdistan

First stop coming from the west is the city of Gaziantep, booming on its new-found industrial wealth.

Above: Fortress, Gaziantep, Turkey

East of here, the road shoots across the plain to cross the River Euphrates at bleached Birecik before cutting through rocky uplands to the pious town of Sanliurfa, simply called Urfa by the locals.

Mevlid-i Halil Mosque
Above: Mevlid-i-Halil Mosque, Sanliurfa, Turkey

Urfa is a good base for exploring Harran – an evocative village of beehive-shaped houses, the extraordinary Neolithic temple complex of Göbekli Tepe, and the natural gateway to Yuvacali village (near Hilvan) where you can experience a genuine slice of rural life.

Harran beehive houses (2).JPG
Above: Harran, Turkey

Above: Göbekli Tepe, Turkey

Homestay Yuvacali - Picture of Nomad Village Home Stays, Hilvan -  Tripadvisor
Above: Yuvacali, Turkey

Urfa is a place of pilgrimage for many religions and the reputed birthplace of the prophet Abraham.

Its chief attraction is a beautiful mosque complex, reflected in the limpid waters of a sacred pool.

Much of the population is Kurdish, a significant minority Arab.

Here you will find bazaars full of veiled, henna-tattooed women and men wearing baggy trousers and traditional headgear.

This city of the prophets has gained a reputation as a focus for Islamic fundamentalism.

Rizvaniye Mosque
Above: Rizvaniye Mosque, Urfa, Turkey

Although Urfa is one of Turkey’s fastest growing cities, thanks largely to the SAP, it still ranks very low in terms of economic development, a fact that is clear from a walk around its impoverished backstreets and by the number of occasionally annoying ragged urchins working them.

Halfeti
Above: Urfa

The Hurri, members of one of Anatolia’s earliest civilizations, built a fortress on the site of Urfa’s present citadel around 3500 BCE.

Later came the Hittites and Assyrians.

But only after the city was refounded as Edessa, by Seleucus Nicator in 300 BCE, did it eclipse nearby Harran.

Seleuco I 2.JPG
Above: Seleucus I Nicator (358 – 231 BCE) statue

Edessa later became an important eastern outpost for the Romans against Persia.

Urfa man.jpg
Above: Urfa Man

From the 2nd century CE, Edessa was a thriving centre of Christianity.

Abgar V had made it the world’s first Christian kingdom in the 1st century CE.

Above: Abgar V (r. 4 BC – 7 CE / 12 – 50 CE) – on an Armenian banknote

The city changed hands between Byzantine and Arab several times.

View of Urfa
Above: Modern day Urfa

According to Syrian Orthodox legend, it was once ransomed for the Mandalyon, a handkerchief bearing the imprint of Christ.

Turin shroud positive and negative displaying original color information 708 x 465 pixels 94 KB.jpg
Above: The Shroud of Turin

As Byzantine control ebbed, the Arab moved in, staying until the 11th century.

During the First Crusade, French Count Baldwin of Boulogne stopped off en route to Tripoli and the Holy Land to establish the country of Edessa, a short-lived Christian state.

Baldwin 1 of Jerusalem.jpg
Above: Coronation of Baldwin I (1060 – 1118) of Jerusalem

In 1144, the Arabs recaptured Edessa, giving the rulers of Europe a pretext to launch the Second Crusade.

After being sacked by the Mongols in 1260, Edessa never recovered.

The city declined into obscurity and was eventually absorbed as Urfa into the Ottoman Empire in 1637.

Urfa Castle
Above: Urfa Castle

Fifteen kilometres northeast of Urfa, set where the southern foothills of the Toros Mountains fade into the scorching flatlands of upper Mesopotamia, Göbekli Tepe (Hill of the Navel) ranks among Turkey’s most intriguing archaeological sites.

Here, on a hilltop 870 metres above sea level, stands a manmade mound, some 300 metres in diameter and 15 metres high, carbon-dated to between 9500 and 7500 BCE.

The enclosures have burnt lime floors and are lined with stone benches, but most remarkably contain a series of T-shaped monoliths, the tallest of which are 5 metres high.

Clearly anthropomorphic, many of the monoliths are liberally covered with incredible relief carvings of wild animals, from scorpions and snakes to lions and wild boar.

The enclosures were almost certainly used for cult purposes and the site is much hyped as “the world’s first temple“.

Photograph of the main excavation area of Göbekli Tepe, showing the ruins of several prehistoric structures.
Above: Göbekli Tepe

Göbekli Tepe also appears to disprove the theory that only settled societies were capable of producing monumental buildings and sophisticated art.

Most of the work here was done when Man was still in the hunter-gatherer stage of development.

No evidence has been found of human settlement.

An unslightly protective roof was removed in 2011 and a new wooden walkway added, allowing visitors to walk right around the main enclosures.

Göbrkli Tepe is merely one of the many archaeological discoveries made in Anatolia, which has hosted dozens of civilizations due to its geographical location in the middle of three continents, that are being followed with great interest in the world.

Above: Göbekli Tepe

Archaeologist Professor Sengül Aydingün – who introduced to the world the city of Bathonea (located on the Avcilar side of Kücukcekmece Lake) – brought together the most important discoveries and excavations of 2021 by consulting 71 experts in their fields to explain and evaluate Turkey’s historical values for the Turkish daily Milliyet.

International Journal of Environment and Geoinformatics » Dergi Kurulları

Above: Professor Sengül Aydingün

İstanbul'da Bathonea Antik Kenti Çalışmaları Sürüyor - Arkeofili
Above: Bathonea, Turkey

Milliyet logo.svg

They chose the human-headed cult room in Karahan Tepe as the most important discovery of 2021.

Discovery of Turkish 11,400-year-old village challenges ideas of when and  why humans first settled down
Above: Karahan Tepe, Turkey

Some structures of the same period as Göbekli Tepe and a human statue with a leopard on its back were unearthed during the Karahan Tepe excavations.

Discovery of Turkish 11,400-year-old village challenges ideas of when and  why humans first settled down
Above: Karahan Tepe

The interesting Neolithic-era artifacts and sculptures were put on display at the Sanliurfa Archaeology Museum and introduced to the world at a ceremony attended by the Culture and Tourism Minister Mehmet Nuri Ersoy.

Above: Urfa Museum

Mehmetersoy.jpg
Above: Mehmet Ersoy

Excavations at monumental site Karahan Tepe, near the Turkish-Syrian border, suggest that society was established before the dawn of agriculture.

Sacred and secular spaces were built simultaneously at Karahan Tepe despite no remnants of farmed vegetation being found, suggesting that the inhabitants remained hunter-gatherers.

Turkey is hailing the discovery of this 11,400-year-old monumental site as one the world’s oldest villages, challenging the prevailing science on when and why humankind first settled down.

Karahan Tepe, the first of a dozen prehistoric sites to be exacavated by Turkish authorities in the southeastern province of Sanliurfa near the Syrian border, includes homes within a vast ritualistic complex that demonstrates that hunter-gatherers built permanent settlements long before the advent of agriculture 10,000 years ago.

Karahantepe will shed light on the mysteries of the Prehistoric period -  Arkeonews
Above: Karahan Tepe

Now we have a different view on history.”, said Necmi Karul, an associate professor at Istanbul University who is leading the dig at Karahan Tepe, a site carved into the slope of a hill on a high limestone plateau between the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers.

Our findings change the perception, still seen in schoolbooks across the world, that settled life resulted from farming and animal husbandry.“, Karul said at a September 2021 presentation of the site.

This shows that settled life began when humans were still hunter-gatherers and that agriculture is not a cause, but the effect, of settled life.”

Discovery of Turkish 11,400-year-old village challenges ideas of when and  why humans first settled down
Above: Necmi Karul

Sacred and secular spaces were built simultaneously at Karahan Tepe, where humans dwelled year-round about 1,500 years ago, but no remnants of farmed vegetation have been found.

Karahan Tepe is located around 35 kilometres from the UNESCO World Heritage Site of Göbekli Tepe, billed as the home to the world’s oldest temple structures.

UNESCO logo English.svg

Dating to 9600 BCE, Göbekli Tepe reshaped ideas about early civilization when field research led by German archaeologist Klaus Schmidt was published in the mid-2000s.

Previously thought to be a lone destination where nomadic people came to worship, Göbekli Tepe is now considered part of a constellation of contemporaneous settlements that extends over 100 kilometres and includes Karahan Tepe and at least 11 other unexcavated sites.

Recent work has also revealed domestic structures at Göbelki Tepe.

Gobekli Tepe Excavator Klaus Schmidt Dies
Above: Klaus Schmidt

In this region, we encounter monumental structures for the first time in the oldest villages in the world.“, Karul said.

Scientists long believed that the domestication of plants and animals around 10,000 years ago is what compelled humans to adopt a sedentary lifestyle and that the boom in food production allowed them to develop complex societies and lay the foundations of civilization.

But the mounting evidence that Stone Age people built permanent structures for spiritual, rather than strictly essential, pursuits is disrupting conventional thinking that they lacked a large scale society with divisions of labour and shared ritualistic motifs.

Karahan Tepe is Called The 'Sister Site' Of Gobekli Tepe In Turkey (And Is  Just As Old)
Above: Karahan Tepe

It will take time for the scientific community to digest and accept this game-changing research.“, said Mehmet Özdogan, professor emeritus of archaeology at Istanbul University.

We must now rethink what we knew – that civilization emerged from a horizontal society that began rasing wheat because people were hungry – and access this period with its multifaceted society.

The Neolithic era, coinciding with the end of the Ice Age, marks humankind’s dramatic shift from forgaing to farming.

The foundations for today’s civilization, from family law to inheritance to the state and bureaucracy, were all struck in the Neolithic period.”, Özdogan said.

Prof. Dr. Mehmet Özdoğan'dan Göbeklitepe Açıklaması - Arkeofili
Above: Professor Dr. Mehmet Ökdogan

Karahan Tepe’s circular rooms were planned out in advance.

The very skillful processing of bedrock reveals an impressive prehistoric architectural engineering.“, Karul said.

Building multiple structures with different purposes is the reflection of a complicated belief system.

It is not possible to talk about religion in its true sense, but we see a set of distinct limited rituals that are radically set forth.

Karahan Tepe is Older Than Gobekli Tepe (BREAKING DISCOVERY: EARTHS FIRST  VILLAGE) - YouTube

This is manifested in a chamber that contains what Karul called “one of the most monumental and earliest examples of phallic symbolism“:

Eleven giant penises carved from the bedrock and watched over by a bearded head with a serpent’s body that emerges from the wall.

Karul has deduced that the space, which includes a separate entrance and exit and a channel for water, was used for rites of passage.

Almost entirely absent are female figures.

Stone reliefs of wildlife range from insects to mammals, and include attacking beasts gripping men’s heads.

There are more depictions of humans here than in the menagerie found at Göbekli Tepe, which is around 200 years older, indicating that humans had begun to see themselves as distinct from the animal world.

Scores of T-shaped stelae – an abstract rendering of the human form, have been unearthed at Karahan Tepe.

Via agli scavi di Karahan Tepe – C'era una volta un mondo
Above: Karahan Tepe

Archaeologists have unearthed 1% of the 60,000 square metre site since 2019, working in record time as remote university instruction during the extended dig seasons.

While excavations continue, Turkey could open Karahan Tepe to tourists in 2022, according to the culture and tourism minister Mehmet Nuri Ersoy.

The government eventually hopes to attract five million visitors a year to Göbekli Tepe and the string of Neolithic sites, which it has dubbed Taş Tepeler (“stone hills“).

The government is investing around $14 million to expand excavations to as many as 30 sites in the area and to build a Neolithic research centre, Ersoy said in September 2021, although no time scale for the projects has been announced.

Taş Tepeler Tanıtım Toplantısı" 📡📍 Şanlıurfa - YouTube

At the end of Karahan Tepe’s lifespan, its inhabitants painstakingly buried their temples “as you would a person who had died“, Karul said.

He acknowledges the risks of reopening the site now to millions of people, but said:

Everybody has a right to access these archaeological sites.

Early Artistic Skills Amaze at Turkey's Neolithic Karahantepe Site |  Ancient Origins
Above: Karahan Tepe

The excavations have uncovered 250 obelisks featuring animal figures to date.

Advanced Structures at Ancient Site Are Older Than Göbekli Tepe | Gaia
Above: Karahan Tepe

The ancient structures at Karahan Tepe were discovered in 1997 by researchers near the Kargali neighbourhood in Tek Tek Mountains National Park.

Sumatar5.jpg
Above: Sumatar, Tek Tek Mountains National Park

The site is located near Yağmurlu, roughly 35 kilometres east of Göbekli Tepe, which is often referred to as its sister site.

Above. Yağmurlu, Turkey

Karahan Tepe is part of the Göbekli culture and Karahan Tepe excavations project.

The area is known as “Kecili Tepe” by local people.

Last Stand of the Hunter-Gatherers? - Archaeology Magazine
Above: Karahan Tepe

Karul told Anadolu Agency in 2019:

Last year, excavation work restarted in Karahan Tepe and we encountered traces of special structures, obelisks, animal sculptures and depictions as well as similar symbolism.”

The site was filled with dirt and rubble at some point, preserving T-topped columns carved into bedrock, just waiting to be discovered.

Anadolu Agency Logo.jpg

Dirt and rubble and the silence of time conceal secrets.

All that I was will one day be covered by dirt and rubble and the silence of time.

Only the words that survive, somehow, somewhere, for some time, may serve as a record of the spirit of what and who someone was.

Without a record of those who were, their past remains elusive and prone to false interpretation.

Ruins are lifeless clues as to whom they might have been.

Whoever once lived here has long ago been robbed of vitality.

Their spirits are mere pedantic pauses in academic study, hypothetical arguments debated with ignorant sophistication, cold conversations of unsympathetic commentary, as dead as dusty tomes in ancient libraries buried by quakes.

Obscure objects with a voice that only the erudite and creative can hear, that only the educated and learned can read.

Where are its poets to expound on the value of their lives?

How may we consort with their spirits without literature to lead us?

The average man can only stand in awe and wonder, in amazement (and amusement) and ponder the past that is the city of Urfa, and the Tepeler of Göbekli and Karahan.

Via agli scavi di Karahan Tepe – C'era una volta un mondo
Above: Karahan Tepe

In a way, Karahan Tepe reminds me of the need to write, to expound on the value of our lives, to consort with the spirit of our age.

And yet even if my words are written down, there are no guarantees that I will be understood, for the past is another place and yesterday’s man is a far different man than the one who types these words.

The strange face carved into the wall at Karahan Tepe, another Pre-Pottery  Neolithic site near Göbekli Tepe. [1024x683] : r/ArtefactPorn
Above: Karahan Tepe

I have been away from Switzerland for ten months.

Flag of Switzerland
Above: Flag of Switzerland

I have not lived in Canada for over two decades.

A vertical triband design (red, white, red) with a red maple leaf in the center.
Above: Flag of Canada

How can I communicate all that I have learned, all that I have felt, with so much time and distance between us?

A man’s history is written in hieroglyphics only he can write and very few, if anyone at all, can read.

But the words must be written nonetheless.

For whom, it suddenly occurred to him, to wonder, was he writing this diary?

For the future, for the unborn….

How could you communicate with the future?

It was of its nature impossible.

Either the future would resemble the present, in which it would not listen to him.

Or it would be different from it and his predicament would be meaningless….

How could you make appeal to the future when not a trace of you, not even an anonymous word scribbled on a piece of paper, could physically survive?….

He was a lonely ghost uttering a truth that nobody would even hear.

But so long as he uttered it, in some obscure way the continuity was not broken.

It was not by making yourself heard but by staying sane that you carried on the human heritage….

How could you tell how much of it was lies?….

The only evidence to the contrary was the mute protest in your own bones….

It struck him that the truly characteristic thing about modern life was not its cruelty and insecurity, but simply its bareness, its dinginess, its listlessness.

Life, if you looked about you, bore no resemblance to the lies that streamed out of the screens or even the ideals that were trying to be achieved.

Great areas of it were neutral and non-political, a matter of slogging through dreary jobs, fighting for a place….

Day and night, the screens bruised your ears with information.

Not a word of it could ever be proved or disproved…..

It might very be that literally every word in the history books, even the things that one accepted without question, was pure fantasy….

Everything faded into mist.

The past was erased.

The erasure was forgotten.

The lie became truth….

1984first.jpg

Nothing is easier than to falsify the past.

Woodrow Wilson

Thomas Woodrow Wilson, Harris & Ewing bw photo portrait, 1919 (cropped).jpg
Above: Woodrow Wilson (1856 – 1924)

And yet he was in the right!

They were wrong and he was right.

The obvious, the silly and the true have got to be defended.”

Nineteen Eighty Four.jpg

Television, radio, magazines and the Internet are so designed as to make thinking seem unnecessary.

The packaging of intellectual positions and views is one of the most active enterprises of some of the best minds of our day.

The viewer of television, the listener to radio, the reader of magazines, the downloader from the Internet, is presented with a whole complex of elements – all the way from ingenious rhetoric to carefully selected data and statistics – to make it easy for him to “make up his own mind” with the minimum of difficulty and effort.

But the packaging is often done so effectively that the viewer, the listener, the reader or the user does make up his own mind up at all.

Marshall McLuhan.jpg
Above: Marshall McLuhan (1911 – 1980) coined the phrase “The medium is the message.”

Instead, he inserts a packaged opinion into his mind, somewhat like inserting a cassette into a cassette player.

He then pushes a button and “plays back” the opinion whenever it seems appropriate to do so.

He has performed acceptably without having had to think.

Hamilton Buhl Cassette Recorder with 2 Jacks : Amazon.in: Electronics

There is a sense in which we are inundated with facts to the detriment of understanding.

Knowledge must grow in the mind if learning is to take place.

An educated person is one who, through the travail of his own life, has assimilated the ideas that make him representative of his culture.

I want to believe that we live in a marvellous age with numerous freedoms created by a global village that is instantly and effortlessly accessible to all, but villages have always been dominated by conformism, isolation, surveillance, boredom and malice.

What should liberate and unite us is oft-times nothing more than a spectacle of vulgarity.

Global Village | Futurism

My biggest fear for the past is that tourism, human circulation from somewhere else, becomes fundamentally nothing more than the leisure of going to see what has become banal.

The sorrow of ruins, the destruction of history, finds us retreating into remote realms of unverifiable stories, uncheckable statistics, unlikely explanations and untenable reasoning.

PDF) Karahan Tepe | Göbekli Tepe - Academia.edu

My biggest fear for the future is that science will no longer be asked to understand the world or to improve any part of it, but will be asked instead to immediately justify everything that happens, wherein the vast tree of knowledge is cut down in order to make truncheons.

The Tree of Knowledge Painting by David Cannon | Saatchi Art

Smiffys Policeman Truncheon : Smiffys: Amazon.co.uk: Toys & Games

In the conflict between survival of the flesh and dignity of the spirit, if we cower to preserve ourselves, we become mere zombies, despite our trappings of prosperity.

If we stand up for our dignity, we live nobly, no matter how much we risk or suffer.

VIDEO: Respect vs Dignity - Cultures of Dignity

But the ruins of Karahan Tepe remind me that power and money often reign supreme.

Stunning carvings of human figures and heads are uncovered at Karahantepe |  Daily Mail Online
Above: Karahan Tepe

In truth, in too many places, education and ideas count less than the wielding of wealth and the display of domination.

We live in an age where love, truth and sacrifice have been reduced to emojis, while philosophy is encapsulated in a text message, and betrayal and collective amnesia are merely a matter of course.

As it has always been and probably as it will always remain, the individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe.

LordOfTheFliesBookCover.jpg

To be your own man is a hard business.

(Rudyard Kipling)

Kipling in 1895
Above: Rudyard Kipling (1865 – 1936)

The ruins of Karahan Tepe speak of the termination of tribes but not of the inspiration of individuals.

We know nothing about the lives of those who came before us nor that of the lives of those who might come after.

Oh, to be able to find the words of a poet, someone with whom we can feel that we have eaten their bread, savoured their salt, drunken their water or wine, have led their common lives and have died deaths worth mourning.

The sadness of dirt and rubble, the emptiness of eternity reflected in the ruins of yesteryear is nevertheless the dignity of existence that I long to understand.

One day, God willing, I shall stand in chambers old covered by unsettling dust and I shall write what I see and feel.

Perhaps the wind from without shall carry the whispers of the past and inspire from within words that convey the promise of tomorrow.

Perhaps I too, like the dead and disappeared of Karahan Tepe, am merely dust in the wind.

Turkey's Taş Tepeler marks the beginning of civilization - Arkeonews
Above: Karahan Tepe

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / “Karahantepe: Discovery of the Year“, Hürriyet Daily News, 28 December 2021

Dog daze

Kreuzlingen, Switzerland, Wednesday 12 January 2022

However tight I shut my eyes, there will always be a stray dog somewhere in the world who will stop me being happy.

French playwright Jean Anouilh (1910 – 1987), Restless Heart (La Sauvage)

Kreuzlingen is a municipality in the canton of Thurgau in northeastern Switzerland.

It is the second-largest city of the canton, after Frauenfeld, with a population of about 22,000.

Together with the adjoining city of Konstanz (Constance) just across the border in Germany, Kreuzlingen is part of the largest conurbation on Lake Constance (Bodensee) with a population of almost 120,000.

Kreuzlingen in early-October 2009
Above: Kreuzlingen, Switzerland

Since my return to Switzerland (28 December to 15 February) I have visited Kreuzlingen generally as a means to an end:

The end being to cross the border from there to Konstanz, Germany.

I have already visited Kreuzlingen three times in this regard.

Above: The German – Swiss border

The name of the municipality stems from the Augustinian monastery Crucelin, later the Kreuzlingen Abbey. 

It was founded in 1125 by the Bishop of Konstanz, Ulrich I.

Above: Kreuzlingen Abbey (or the Church of St. Ulrich and St. Afra)

In the Swabian War (1499) and the Thirty Years’ War (1618 – 1648) after the siege of Konstanz by Swedish troops, the Augustinian monastery was burned down by the people of Konstanz, who blamed the monks for having supported the enemy.

Battle of Hard.jpg
Above: The Battle of Hard (20 February 1499), one of the battles of the Swabian War, as depicted in the Luzerner Schilling of 1513.

Above: “The Lion of the North“, King Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden (1594 – 1632)

In 1650, the Monastery was rebuilt in its present location.

With secularization in 1848, the buildings became a teachers’ school.

The chapel became a Catholic church.

Above: Interior of St. Ulrich Church, Kreuzlingen

Its very name of Kreuzlingen (village of the cross) suggests that there is more to life than commerce, more to existence than the saving of money by shopping over the border.

Coat of arms of Kreuzlingen
Above: Coat of arms of Kreuzlingen

The area was already settled during the Bronze Age (3300 – 1200 BCE). 

Celtic and Roman coins and artifacts testify of continued settlement.

Above: A Roman coin depicting the profile of Diocletian (242 – 311)

When the wife and I were considering where to live when she accepted her position at the nearby hospital in Münsterlingen, at no time then or since have we desired to live in Kreuzlingen, despite its attractions.

Logo

Kurzrickenbach is first mentioned as Rihinbah in 830, Egelshofen as Eigolteshoven in 1125, and Emmishofen as Eminshoven in 1159.

Hörnliplatz Kurzrickenbach
Above: Hörnliplatz, Kurzrickenbach, Kreuzlingen

Egelshofen
Above: Egelshofen, Kreuzlingen

Emmishofen, im Hintergrund der Bodensee und Hagnau
Above: Emmishofen, Kreuzlingen

The territory of the municipality, except for the Augustinian monastery, belonged to the Bishop of Konstanz.

Wappen Bistum Konstanz.png
Above: Coat of arms of the Bishop of Konstanz

When the Eidgenossen (the Swiss Confederation) conquered Thurgau in 1460 and further with the Reformation (1521 – 1648), the ties to the neighbouring city loosened.

Flag of Thurgau
Above: Flag of Thurgau Canton

Have these ties really loosened?

I wonder.

The Swiss still cross over the border to shop more cheaply in Germany.

Vehicles backed up on a divided roadway seen from above. In the foreground is a traffic signal; there are blue signs in German further down the road as it narrows. In the rear is a developed hillside, partially obscured by bluish haze
Above: Swiss shoppers returning to their home country from Konstanz on weekends

Until the beginning of the 19th century, the present centre of Kreuzlingen was still largely agricultural.

So was the rest of Switzerland for that matter.

Above: Aerial view of Kreuzlingen from 200 m (1919) by Walter Mittelholzer (1894 – 1937)

The wee village of Landschlacht where the wife and I decided to reside is still agricultural in its essence.

Directly across from our apartment block, the adjacent field is still being cultivated.

Above: Landschlacht, Switzerland

The first steamboats began to operate on the Bodensee in 1824.

Above: Map of the Lake of Constance (Bodensee)

The steamboat era is long past, though boats still continue to criss-cross the Bodensee or navigate the Rhine (Rhein) River from Kreuzlingen to Schaffhausen.

Das Teufelsschiff vom Bodensee: Wie die «Zürich» vor 100 Jahren mehrere  Schiffe zum Kentern brachte

The first train line to Romanshorn was finished in 1871, and the second to Etzwilen in 1875.

Hafeneinfahrt Romanshorn 2.JPG
Above: Romanshorn

Etzwilen
Above: Etzwilen

There are still trains that traverse Kreuzlingen: the Wil (SG) – Schaffhausen (SH) line, the Weinfelden – Kreuzlingen line, and Intercity trains to Zürich and Luzern.

Above: Wil

Schaffhausen mit Munot, Rhein & MS Munot 20150419-IMG 0194.JPG
Above: Schaffhausen

Rathausstrasse in Weinfelden
Above: Rathausstrasse, Weinfelden

Altstadt Zürich
Above: Zürich

Reuss, Kapellbrücke mit Wasserturm, Jesuitenkirche, Rathaus und Rathausquai
Above: Luzern (Lucerne)

This brought commerce and industry to the region.

1SwissFranc2001.jpg

I suspect more commerce is still lost to Germany than remains in Kreuzlingen.

Euro symbol.svg

In 1874, the municipality of Egelshofen was renamed Kreuzlingen and became the capital of the district, instead of Gottlieben.

Blick vom gegenüberliegenden Rheinufer auf Gottlieben
Above: Gottlieben

It reached its present size with the incorporation of Kurzrickenbach in 1927 and Emmishofen in 1928.

However, until World War I (1914 – 1918), Kreuzlingen was a kind of suburb of Konstanz.

Vor dem Ersten Weltkrieg spielte die Grenze zwischen Kreuzlingen und  Konstanz keine Rolle
Above: Border crossings between Kreuzlingen and Konstanz

In many ways, Kreuzlingen still is.

And these suburban lines stretch as far as Landschlacht from where Bus 908 can deliver me all the way to my dentist’s office at Zähringerplatz in Konstanz.

Auch Konstanz hat zu viel an Postauto bezahlt - TOP ONLINE

Stadtwerke Konstanz Nr. 8/KN-C 1108 Mercedes Citaro am 15. September 2008  Konstanz, Bahnhof - Bus-bild.de

Most of its industry was in the hands of German firms.

The Second World War made Kreuzlingen more independent.

In 1947 Kreuzlingen passed the mark of 10,000 residents, thus becoming according to Swiss statistical convention a town.

Though these days, Kreuzlingen calls itself a city.

Above: Kreuzlingen Harbour

The Sanatorium of Bellevue (1857 – 1980), which occupied part of the old monastery, played an important role in the history of Kreuzlingen.

In 1842, Ignaz Vanotti from Konstanz bought a large tract of land and built a residential and commercial building in 1843 to house the emigrants of Bellevue, which had previously been located in Römerburg.

In 1857, Ludwig Binswanger, a psychiatrist from Münsterlingen acquired the property and opened a private sanatorium.

Above: Ludwig Binswanger (1820 – 1880)

The clinic was very modern and remained in the control of the Binswanger family for nearly 120 years.

Important psychiatric advances, particularly under the founder’s grandson, also called Ludwig Binswanger (1881 – 1966), especially in the development of existential psychotherapy, were made at the Sanatorium.

Above: Portrait of Ludwig Binswanger II, Ernst Kirchner (1880 – 1938)

However, few of its buildings remain.

Above: Bellevue Sanatorium, Kreuzlingen

In 1840, the Canton of Thurgau opened the Cantonal Hospital in Münsterlingen.

In 1849, Doctor Ludwig Binswanger was entrusted with the treatment of the mentally ill at Münsterlingen.

In 1894, this department received its own buildings on the Bodensee.

Above: Psychiatrische Klinik Münsterlingen

In 1972, the new building of the Münsterlingen Cantonal Hospital was ready for occupancy.

In 1999, the Cantonal Hospital and the Münsterlingen Psychiatric Clinic were integrated into Spital Thurgau AG.

In 2005, this 3rd economic sector of Münsterlingen provided 97% of the Municipality’s jobs, with the Clinic and Hospital alone employing 877 people.

Coat of arms of Münsterlingen
Above: Coat of arms of Münsterlingen

It is my understanding that the psychologically unwell of Kreuzlingen now travel to (or reside in) the Münsterlingen Clinic.

Living in the neighbourhood of a psychiatric clinic means that, from time to time, it is possible to encounter someone unwell in this regard anywhere on the rail route from Romanshorn to Kreuzlingen.

Such was the case (or so I believe) this evening….

Landschlacht TG: Mann (35) auf Perron von Zug erfasst - 20 Minuten
Above: Landschlacht Station

Existential psychotherapy is a form of pschotherapy based on the model of human nature and experience developed by the existential tradition of European philosophy.

It focuses on concepts that are universally applicable to human existence including death, freedom, responsibility, and the meaning of life. 

Instead of regarding human experiences such as anxiety, alienation and depression as implying the presence of mental illness, existential psychotherapy sees these experiences as natural stages in a normal process of human development and maturation.

In facilitating this process of development and maturation, existential psychotherapy involves a philosophical exploration of an individual’s experiences stressing the individual’s freedom and responsibility to facilitate a higher degree of meaning and well-being in their life.

All the signs of anxiety, alienation and depression, whether an implication of mental illness or simply a natural stage of human maturation, were very present and palpable this evening….

What Is Existential Therapy? - TRANSFORMATIVE THERAPY

The Kreuzlingen train station is the largest of four train stations in the City.

Two story building with adjoining single story section
Above: Kreuzlingen Station

It is operated by the SBB (Swiss National Railways) and is served by the SBB, Thurbo S-Bahn and Deutsche Bahn trains.

SBB CFF FFS logo.svg
Above: Swiss National Railways logo

Logo

Logo

The station was opened to traffic on 1 July 1875 as Emmishofen station in the course of the opening of the Etzwilen – Konstanz railway line.

Bahnhof Konstanz – Wikipedia
Above: Konstanz Station

At that time, today’s Kreuzlinger Hafen (harbour) station on the Romanshorn – Konstanz railway line was simply called Kreuzlingen.

The connection between the two stations was opened at the same time.

File:Bahnhof Kreuzlingen-Hafen (April 2011).jpg - Wikimedia Commons
Above: Kreuzlingen Hafen (Harbour) Station

On 18 December 1911, after two years of construction, the Mittelthurgau (Central Thurgau) Railway (MThB) was added, which opened its line from Weinfelden to Emmishofen.

For this step, the station was massively rebuilt.

Mittelthurgaubahn – Wikipedia

With the incorporation of Emmishofen into the City of Kreuzlingen, the Emmishofen train station became the Kreuzlingen train station and the old Kreuzlingen station was now called Kreuzlingen Hafen.

Above: Kreuzlingen Station

In 1996, all routes around the Kreuzlingen train station were transferred to Mittelthurgau Bahn – previously only the Weinfelden – Kreuzlingen route had belonged to it.

The Kreuzlingen – Konstanz route also belonged to the SBB, even if it was only used by the MThB.

With the MThB bankruptcy and the establishment of the Thurbo as a 90% owned subsidiary of the SBB in 2002, Kreuzlingen station went back to the SBB.

Above: Kreuzlingen Station

The station consists of a side platform (Gleis 1) and a central platform (Gleis 2 and 3).

The track plans were created in such a way that two trains per track stop at the same time and can also overtake one another.

Bild: Bahnhof "Kreuzlingen Hafen" • Schienenverkehr-Schweiz.ch
Above: Kreuzlingen Station

The SBB plans to discontinue personal service in 50 to 100 medium-sized stations.

(Not that personal service was remarkable before….)

Verkehrs-Club der Schweiz på Twitter: "Der #SBB Fahrplan 2018 ist ab heute  gültig! ⌚ Wer ist verantwortlich für die Fahrplanerstellung? Warum wechselt  er so oft? Was sind dieses Jahr die wichtigsten Änderungen?
Above: The SBB train network

Then tickets will only be purchased from machines.

(Even more unreliable…..)

How to buy a train ticket in Switzerland - a step by step guide

According to an SBB press release, this would also affect Kreuzlingen.

Bild: Bahnhof "Kreuzlingen" • Schienenverkehr-Schweiz.ch
Above: Kreuzlingen Station

In 2018, the idea of a Kreuzlinger-Konstanzer S-Bahn was discussed.

I am not sure what the results of that discussion were, but I can confirm that it is possible to get a high-speed train from Konstanz to Luzern without much difficulty.

Generally, for train-travelling locals, the journey from Konstanz to anywhere else in Switzerland must involve stopping at Kreuzlingen station and waiting for another train to whisk you away to where you wish to go.

Datei:Flag of Switzerland.svg
Above: Flag of Switzerland

Returning from shopping in Konstanz I find myself, yet again, waiting for a train back to Landschlacht.

The weather is -2°C, but as is often the case of Canadians who wish to brag about their ability to tolerate cold temperatures, I find myself woefully underdressed and so I seek shelter in a glass-enclosed waiting area between the platforms.

Above: Platforms 2 and 3, Kreuzlingen Station

I am alone for a few moments, then I am joined by a younger man, masked against COVID as I am.

He is furiously texting someone and suddenly…..

He is sobbing, his tears dampening the top trim of his mask.

Crying Face Emoji (U+1F622)

Is his relationship with his lover dissipating before his eyes?

Has someone died?

GrahamGreene TheEndOfTheAffair.jpg

I feel I ought to say something, but I am flooded with hesitant thoughts.

How will he react to my involvement?

What if he is not a rational man?

Unwell.jpg

The sense I get from his body language is that tragically someone he has loved has, for one reason or another, denied him the possibility of being loved in return in future.

All of this prompts the thought…..

Is he worthy of being loved?

What will the removal or denial of love do to this young man’s character, to this young man’s life?

His hunched shoulders, his head bent forward over the screen of his phone, his body is a monument to the misery of the moment.

Where Is the Love - Roberta Flack and Donny Hathaway.jpg

I am reminded of repenting dogs, beaten by feelings of guilt and remorse.

And my mind retreats into the past.

Submissive and Excitement Urination

I recall how a woman I once thought I would marry ended our relationship.

By fax.

(Anyone remember faxes?)

How cold, how cruel, how cowardly a way to end an affair!

Hindsight, of course, shows me how unready I was for a relationship in those days and how wise she had been to excuse herself from further intimacy with me.

I no longer have hard feelings towards her.

I no longer feel anything about her.

I am not spiteful.

I wish her well wherever she is, with whomever she is with.

A large heart shaped design is filled with a montage of images. Most are grey, black, and white; the central image includes red colouring. The name Gotye is styled as a signature at bottom right.

I have long since learned that happiness can never be found in the arms of another.

Happiness comes from within, never from without.

Happiness is shared, it is never the result of someone else’s solutions.

Pharrell Williams - Happy.jpg

But I feel that the end of love, whether through the deterioration of a relationship or the demise of a loved one, should, ideally, be a dignified exit.

A text ending an affair, whether by fax or phone, denigrates the importance of the relationship.

Are we unworthy of a face-to-face finale?

Or is the chaos of confrontation too frightening a possibility for some to face?

Is confronting the soon-to-be-jilted lover an open admission that the relationship has failed, that mistakes had been made?

Is the salvation of one ego only possible through the destruction of an other?

Boyz II Men End of the Road USA commercial cassette.jpg

Mind drifts into another time passage, one more recent, a memory a mere two weeks old.

ISG Sabiha Gökçen Airport Hotel, Istanbul – Updated 2022 Prices
Above: Sabiha Gökcen Airport Hotel, Pendik, Istanbul

Hung-up, run-down, low-down, depressed and despairing, the young traveller’s face imprints an image that haunts me, the one that I had seen on the TV of the restaurant of the Airport Hotel in Istanbul where I spent my last morning in Turkey – (For now. I plan to return to Turkey on 15 February, God willing / Inshallah.) – that of an attack by two pit bull terriers on a four-year-old girl captured on CCTV camera.

Asiye Ateş was playing in the garden of the estate where she lived in Gaziantep Beştepe Mahallesi on the evening of 22 December.

She was suddenly attacked by two pit bull dogs on the basketball court.

In those moments when people rushed to help, the dogs did not leave the little girl for a long time.

Pitbull saldırısına uğrayan Asiye Ateş Antalya'ya getirildi! Başkan Erdoğan  bizzat ilgilendi: Asiye'nin tedavisini Prof. Ömer Özkan yapacak - Galeri -  Takvim

Above: Video of the pit bull attack

The child, who was injured in the face and chest, was rescued and handed over to medical teams.

Gaziantep'te pitbull saldırısında ağır yaralanmıştı! Asiye Ateş'in ameliyat  öncesi sorusu yürek yaktı
Above: Asiye Ateş

In a written statement from the Gaziantep Governor’s Office:

Two pitbull dogs belonging to five people living on site injured the child of a site employee in a life-threatening manner in the head and throat area.

The two dogs were delivered to Gaziantep Metropolitan Municipality Animal Shelter and Rehabilitation Centre by the Nature Conservation and National Parks Branch Directorate.

The dog owners and a site security guard were taken into police custody.

The judicial and administrative process is ongoing.

The treatment and rehabilitation of the injured child, provided by the Governor’s Office, is being followed.

Above: Gaziantep Castle, Turkey

I had not known of this attack, for, in truth, my last week in Turkey had been extremely busy and though newspapers were bought throughout the week, none had been read, and, as both a matter of habit and interest, I rarely catch the news on TV or on the Internet, so the screen shot on the restaurant TV was my first exposure to the attack.

What little can be seen in the video clip it appears that the little girl had done nothing to provoke the canine attack.

A dog teaches a boy fidelity, perseverance, and to turn around three times before lying down.

American writer Robert Benchley (1889 – 1945), Artemus Ward, His Book

New dog, old tricks? Untrained stray dogs can understand human cues –  Science & research news | Frontiers

The Green Mile is a 1999 American fantasy drama film written and directed by Frank Darabont and based on Stephen King’s 1996 novel of the same name.

The words Tom Hanks, a prison guard looking to the distance, below the words The Green Mile, in the middle of the words, a small silhouette of a big man and small man walking towards a light.

It stars Tom Hanks as death row prison guard Paul Edgecomb during the Great Depression who witnesses supernatural events following the arrival of an enigmatic convict (Michael Clarke Duncan) at his facility.

Above: Michael Clarke Duncan (1957 – 2012) and Tom Hanks, The Green Mile

At a Louisiana assisted-living home, elderly retiree Paul Edgecomb (Dabbs Greer) becomes emotional while viewing the film Top Hat.

TopHatORGI.jpg

His companion Elaine becomes concerned, and Paul explains to her that the film reminded him of events that he witnessed in 1935 when he was an officer at Cold Mountain Penitentiary’s death row, nicknamed “The Green Mile“.

Above: Dabbs Greer (1917 – 2007), The Green Mile

In 1935, Paul supervises Corrections Officers Brutus “Brutal” Howell (David Morse), Dean Stanton (Barry Pepper), Harry Terwilliger (Jeffrey DeMunn), and Percy Wetmore (Doug Hutchison), reporting to chief warden Hal Moores (James Cromwell).

Brutus "Brutal" Howell - The Green Mile (1999) MBTI - Personality Database  ™️
Above: David Morse, The Green Mile

Dean Stanton - The Green Mile
Above: Barry Pepper, The Green Mile

The Green Mile (1999) - Wild Bill Piss On Harry Terwilliger - YouTube
Above: Jeffrey DeMunn, The Green Mile

TIL Tom Holland played the role for Percy Wetmore in 1999 Green Mile.  decades of time difference, incredibly different roles, yet still the  superb performance 👏 : r/TomHolland
Above: Doug Hutchison, The Green Mile

Hal - The Green Mile photo (25091586) - fanpop
Above: James Cromwell, The Green Mile

Paul is introduced to John Coffey, a physically imposing but mild-mannered black man, who has been sentenced to death after being convicted of raping and murdering two little white girls. 

Paul gradually realizes that John possesses a supernatural ability to heal others.

Above: Michael Clarke Duncan, The Green Mile

Suspecting that John is endowed with the power to perform divine miracles, Paul begins to doubt whether he is truly guilty of his crimes.

He visits the lawyer who defended Coffey, Burt Hammersmith (Gary Sinise), at his farm.

The Green Mile (1999)
Above: Tom Hanks and Gary Sinise, The Green Mile

Edgecomb: He (Coffey) is strange, I admit, but there doesn’t seem to be any real violence in him.

I know violent men, Mr. Hammersmith.

I deal with them, day in and day out.

15 Things You Might Not Know About 'The Green Mile' | Mental Floss
Above: Tom Hanks, The Green Mile

Hammersmith: You didn’t come up here to ask me whether he might have killed before.

You came up to see if I think he did it at all.

Gary Sinise: pointing at his own head | Gary sinise, Gary, Handsome
Above: Gary Sinise, The Green Mile

Edgecomb: Do you?

Fotostrecke: Die TV-Tops und Flops der Woche | BRIGITTE.de
Above: Tom Hanks, The Green Mile

Hammersmith: One rarely sees such an unambiguous case.

He was found with the victims in his arms.

Green Mile Book Club Guide – RADical Projects
Above: Michael Clarke Duncan and Evanne and Bailey Drucker, The Green Mile

Edgecomb: And yet you defended him?

The Green Mile by Stephen King
Above: Michael Clarke Duncan, The Green Mile

Hammersmith: Everyone is entitled to a defense.

I’ll tell you something and you listen close too, because it might be something you need to know.

The Green Mile (1999)
Above: Gary Sinise, The Green Mile

Edgecomb: I’m listening.

The Green Mile (1999)
Above: Gary Sinise and Tom Hanks, The Green Mile

Hammersmith: We had us a dog, just a sweet mongrel, you know the kind.

Well, in many ways, a good mongrel dog is like a Negro.

You get to know it, often you get to love it.

It is of no particular use, but you keep it around because you think it loves you.

If you’re lucky, Mr. Edgecomb, you never have to find out any different.

My wife and I were not so lucky.

The Green Mile | Bild 2 von 20 | Moviepilot.de
Above: The Hammersmith family, The Green Mile

(Hammersmith calls his son Ethan to his side.

We see that the right side of his face is scarred and his right eye is missing.)

The Green Mile (1999)
Above: Gary Sinise, The Green Mile

Hammersmith: He still has the one good eye.

I suppose he’s lucky not to be completely blind.

We get down on our knees and thank God for that much at least.

That dog attacked my boy for no reason.

Just got it in his mind one day.

The same with John Coffey.

He was sorry afterwards.

Of that I have no doubt, but those little girls stayed raped and murdered.

John Coffey the Green Mile by JonathanSlagt on DeviantArt
Above: Michael Clarke Duncan, The Green Mile

Maybe he never done it before.

My dog never bit before.

But I didn’t concern myself with that.

I went out there with my rifle, grabbed his collar and blew his brains out.

Is Coffey guilty?

Yes, he is.

Don’t you doubt it.

And don’t you turn your back on him.

You may get away with it once or even a hundred times, but, in the end, you’ll get bit.

Burt Hammersmith – KingWiki
Above: Gary Sinise, The Green Mile

In order to really enjoy a dog, one doesn’t merely try to train him to be semihuman.

The point of it is to open oneself to the possibility of becoming partly a dog.

American writer Edward Hoagland (b. 1932), “Dogs and the Tug of Life“, Harper’s, February 1975

Stray Dogs - Galleries - Our Stories - FOUR PAWS International

From the Hürriyet Daily News, Tuesday 28 December 2021:

A nationwide debate has sparked over the fate of stray animals, following a gruesome incident in which a four-year-old girl became the victim of a vicious dog attack, setting social media abuzz.

Pitbull'un saldırdığı Asiye Ateş'in doktorundan flaş açıklama: Saçlarına  kavuşacak... - Galeri - Yaşam
Above: Asiye Ateş, before and after the pit bull attack

Asiye Ateş sustained severe injuries when two pit bulls mauled her in the southeastern province of Gaziantep while she was playing in a building complex in the Şahinbey district, severely injuring her from the neck and the head.

Asiye Ateş'in sağlık durumuna ilişkin flaş açıklama « haberciyedi24.com-  Haberler, Son Dakika Haberleri ve Güncel Haberler
Above: Asiye Ateş and the two pit bull terriers

The incident led to an outrage on social media, with a substantial number of people demanding authorities to collect all stray animals and not just breeds deemed dangerous.

Turkey expedites efforts for new social media regulation | Daily Sabah

The call has led to the rise of two schools of thought:

One group standing up for the rights of stray animals, saying that streets belong to these animals, too.

The other group in favor of locking them up in animal shelters after they are neutered, stating it as probably the most reasonable solution for the betterment of these homeless animals.

Istanbul stray dogs get starring roles in new film

While these discussions on social media are yet to go anywhere, some local authorities, agreeing to the calls of collecting stray animals and locking them up in shelters, have begin their operation already.

Stray' documentary about Turkish street dogs streaming today at Ciné

Dozens of municipalities in Istanbul, Afyon and Ankara started to collect animals opportunistically.

Where will a shelter with a capacity of 50 put 1,500 animals?“, asked Nesrin Citirik, the chairperson of HAYKONFED, a federation of animal protection groups.

She said that 1,200 out of 1,389 municipalities still do not have sterilization centres and shelters, even though there has been a law order for it for 17 years in Turkey.

Istanbul's street dogs are the stars of documentary 'Stray' - The  Washington Post

These municipalities, defying the law and the state, collect poor animals in shelters that do not exist now.

Some of these animals will be killed and some will be left in rural areas.“, Citirik said, adding that it was not fair to make stray animals pay for the biting incident of owned animals with death and cruelty against them.

Turkey feeds stray animals during Covid-19 outbreak - BBC News

Meanwhile, a piece of good news about Ateş’ health came from the southern province of Antalya, the city that hosts one of the best organ and tissue transplant centres in the world.

According to a senior official, a three-hour surgery performed at Akdeniz University Hospital on the girl was successful.

Akdeniz University Hospital – Medical Tourism with MediGlobus: The best  treatment around the world
Above: Akdeniz University Hospital, Antalya, Turkey

The first session surgery was performed for the tissue loss in the face and hair areas of Ateş.”, said Professor Yildiray Cete, the chief physician of the university hospital.

Since tissue transplantations are performed by microsurgical method, there are risks related to the tissue in the first few days, but as of now both the transplanted tissues are healthy and the vital signs of the patient are stable.“, he said.

Akdeniz University Hospital – Medical Tourism with MediGlobus: The best  treatment around the world

While discussion about stray animals and dogs of dangerous breeds is picking up momentum and has become a sensitive issue, two citizens in Istanbul and one in Denizli were injured due to a pit bull attack.

Under Turkey’s Animal Protection Act, pit bull terriers and other breeds posing a danger to humans are banned from being bred and sold.

Those violating the laws are given fines.

However, the Internet continues to be a lucrative platform for illegal sellers to sell potentially dangerous canine breeds.

New film 'Stray' chases three stray dogs in Istanbul's streets | Daily Sabah

From the Daily Sabah, Tuesday 28 December 2021:

As a four-year-old girl fights for her life after being mauled by two dogs, the issue of “dangerous canine breeds” is in the spotlight again.

The girl, in intensive care now, was a victim of pit bulls, despite the sale and ownership of the breed being banned in Turkey.

Unfortunately, she was not the latest victim, as three children were injured by pit bulls over the weekend in Istanbul and the western province of Denizli.

Asiye Ateş olayı ile ilgili skandal iddia! Pitbull saldırısı sonrası... -  Gündem Haberleri
Above: One of the pit bull terriers and Asiye Ateş

The attack in the southern province of Gaziantep, in which A.A. suffered injuries to her head and neck, drew widespread condemnation and resulted in six people, including the dogs’ owners being detained.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan called the girl’s family after the incident and pledged to follow up on the process.

The President also repeatedly called upon municipalities to take action to collect stray street animals and ensure them a safe environment in animal shelters.

The President also called on dog owners to restrain their animals.

Recep Tayyip Erdoğan 2021.jpg
Above: Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

Pit bulls are among the breeds banned from ownership and import in Turkey.

However, they are still illegally bred and even sold online.

From 14 January 2022, owners of breeds of dogs deemed dangerous under law are required to have their pets sterilized and microchipped so they can be tracked if they get loose.

Animal rights activists, on the other hand, say that moving dogs that pose a danger to humans to shelters is not a solution, asserting that pit bulls, like other breeds, are not aggressive and rather are trained to attack others by their owners.

Turkey’s leading animal rights organization, the Animal Rights Federation (HAYTAP), in a written statement said that they backed the idea of keeping stray dogs in check, but argued that they should be left alone after sterilization instead of being öocked up in “prison-like” animal shelters.

HAYTAP also called on authorities to stop the sale of dangerous breeds at pet shops and online.

The statement noted that the Federation supported the dog owners in Gaziantep receiving the highest sentence, charges of attempted homicide.

Pit bull sales thrive online despite ban on aggressive breeds in Turkey |  Daily Sabah

Turkey recently passed an animal rights bill after consultations with animal rights groups.

The comprehensive piece of legislation is viewed as a boost to animal rights, long neglected in a country that takes pride in caring for stray animals, whose number proliferate especially in big cities where they freely roam and mingle with people.

TURKEY - Villalobos Rescue Center

From Jennifer Hattam, Washington Post, 18 March 2021:

Forget the majestic mosques and bustling bazaars.

Over the centuries, one of the things that has most consistently captured the imagination of foreign travellers to Istanbul has been…..

The street dogs.

Why are Turkey's dogs committing suicide? - Al-Monitor: The Pulse of the  Middle East

The dogs sleep in the streets, all over the city.

They would not move, though the Sultan himself passed by.”

(Mark Twain, The Innocents Abroad, 1867)

Mark Twain - The Innocents Abroad.jpg

Amply documented in both 19th century lithographs and 21st century viral videos, Istanbul’s street dogs can today be found patiently waiting to cross at green lights, hitching ferry rides across the Bosporus, marching with protesters, and lapping up leftovers and attention outside sidewalk cafés.

Happiest pack of playing Street Dogs Istanbul Turkey - YouTube

Filmmaker Elizabeth Lo, whose documentary Stray had its US streaming release earlier this month, is the latest visitor to fall under the spell of the City’s canine cohort.

Stray (2020) - IMDb

Lo says she was struck by “seeing dogs roaming around freely, living life on their own terms, in this very developed city” and by the relationship she observed between them and Istanbul’s human residents.

People really see a dignity in the dogs, they see them as fellow citizens, as belonging to their streets and communities.”, she says.

Stray dog tours Istanbul using public transportation - Turkey News

Lo’s visually engaging film follows three charismatic canine protagonists, Zeytin, Nazar and Kartal, on their daily rounds through central Istanbul, often at a dog’s eye view that makes even familiar scenes look fresh.

Though scant on narrative or exposition, Stray alludes to the contested history of dogs in Istanbul and the ever-shifting social and urban dynamics that affect the lives of its canine and human citizens alike.

Stray has been heralded as “the ultimate love letter to dogs and a multifaceted moral inquiry into humanity“.

Meet Boji, Istanbul's commuting street dog and newest influencer | Middle  East Eye

Istanbul is home to some 600,000 stray dogs and cats, estimates Ahmet Atalik, who overseas veterinary services for the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality.

His staff puts out food at hundreds of locations around the City, carries out spay-neuter operations, and performs surgeries on injured dogs and cats.

Opinion | A New Deal for Turkey's Homeless Dogs - The New York Times

The origins of Istanbul’s dogs are as tough to pin down as their exact numbers.

One story holds that they entered Constantinople (Istanbul) with the army of Mehmet II, the Ottoman sultan who conquered the City from the Byzantines in 1453.

Gentile Bellini 003.jpg
Above: Sultan Mehmet II (1432 – 1481)

An archaeological dig of the Byzantine-era harbour in the City’s Yenikapi area that unearthed hundreds of dog skulls attests to a much earlier presence.

But their long-standing role in the life of the City is beyond dispute.

Jail time to replace Turkey's animal cruelty penalties

Historical sources from the Ottoman era show that dogs served as guards for neighbourhoods, ate the garbage since there were no municipal sanitation services, and would bark to alert people when there were fires which used to happen a lot.“, says Kimberly Hart, an anthropologist at SUNY Buffalo State College who studies Istanbul’s street animals as part of the City’s intangible cultural heritage.

But it wasn’t just a functional relationship.

It was seen as a good deed to feed and take care of them.

Buffalo State College seal.svg

The bowls of food and water and homemade shelters that modern Istanbul residents place on the streets for the City’s dogs – and its abundant stray cats – hark back to Ottoman times, when mosques had drinking water troughs for animals, charitable foundations were established to feed them, and travellers described seeing “little straw huts” set up for dogs.

Istanbul′s forgotten dogs struggle for survival | Environment | All topics  from climate change to conservation | DW | 08.10.2013

But though dogs have been a resilient presence in Istanbul for centuries, they are also a vulnerable one – as are the homeless Syrian boys who form a pack of sorts with some of the dogs in Lo’s film.

When war first broke out in neighbouring Syria, Turkey welcomed the refugees, but as their numbers swelled past 3.6 million and the conflict dragged on, the climate became less hospitable.

Syrians have been targets of hate speech and even attacks, as have other minority communities, including Armenians, Greeks and Jews.

Syrian children say they feel at home in Turkey - Turkey News

And history shows that dogs can become victims as well.

Attempts have been made to remove or exterminate Istanbul’s dog population since the early 1800s, with periodic mass killings continuing until as recently as the 1990s.

Most haunting is the exile in 1910 of 80,000 dogs to Sivriada, one of the Princes’ Islands off the City’s coast.

With no food or water on the rocky, uninhabited island, the dogs died slowly and painfully, their howls reporting carrying across the Sea of Marmara to the mainland.

Above: Sivriada Island

According to local lore, many saw divine punishment in the devastating fire that swept the City in 1911 and the outbreak of World War I, which culminated in the occupation of Istanbul.

ISTANBUL FIRES DURING THE OTTOMAN PERIOD AND THEIR EFFECT ON THE CITY'S  TOPOGRAPHY | History of Istanbul
Above: Istanbul fire

Above: Occupation of Istanbul

Historians attribute these cruel culling campaigns to late-era Ottoman rulers’s attempts to “Westernize” the City by imposing order and cleanliness on its streets as daily life moved from private homes to public squares.

Some accounts even say that complaints about the dogs from Western diplomats and visitors spurred the killings.

(Other foreigners helped found the City’s first animal societies in the 1910s.)

Coat of arms of the Ottoman Empire (1882–1922).svg
Above: Coat of arms of the Ottoman Empire (1882 – 1922)

The struggle continues to take care of them and keep them in their own neighbourhoods.

In 2012, animal lovers successfully protested en masse against amendments that would have allowed the removal of animals from city centres.

Istanbul's street dogs are the stars of documentary 'Stray' - The  Washington Post

But just as late Ottoman era rulers saw no place for dogs in their “modernizing” City, many worry that the urbanization processes reshaping Istanbul today will leave no room for them either.

Animals had a place in the social fabric of the mahalle (traditional neighbourhood), where there are back streets, butcher shops, people who look after them.“, says Hart, the anthropologist.

That is being destroyed as Istanbul is being re-created as a City where everything is shiny and bright and brand new.

Stray review – exquisite dog's eye view of Istanbul | Movies | The Guardian

And in Lo’s film, the dogs and boys find temporary shelter in a construction site, a symbol of the massive development projects gobbling up many of the City’s old neighbourhoods and green spaces.

Stray sketches: Woman sells art to feed Turkey's street dogs | Daily Sabah

We’ve destroyed the rivers where animals used to drink and cut down the trees that provided shelter for them when it was too hot or too cold.“, says Istanbul native Cem Arslan, who founded the Empathy Association to support street animals and their caretakers on Kinahada, an island neighbouring the infamous Sivriada.

Istanbul, Turkey Kinahada, Island of Proti Sea of Marmara (Photos Prints  Framed...) #11558029

Street animals are also living in the City, and because of rapid urbanization, they require more care and attention.“, agrees Atalik of the Istanbul Municipality.

Perhaps we are the ones occupying ‘their’ space.

Coat of arms of Istanbul
Above: Coat of arms of Istanbul Municipality

free-ranging dog is a dog that is not confined to a yard or house. 

Free-ranging dogs include street dogs, village dogs, stray dogs, and feral dogs, and may be owned or unowned.

The global dog population is estimated to be 900 million, of which around 20% are regarded as owned pets and therefore restrained.

Dogs living with humans is a dynamic relationship, with a large proportion of the dog population losing contact with humans at some stage over time.

This loss of contact first occurred after domestication and has reoccurred throughout history.

The global dog population is estimated to be 900 million and rising.

Although it is said that the “dog is man’s best friend“, for the 17% to 24% of dogs that live as pets in the developed countries, in the developing world pet dogs are uncommon but there are many village, community or feral dogs.

Most of these dogs live out their lives as scavengers and have never been owned by humans, with one study showing their most common response when approached by strangers is to run away (52%) or respond aggressively (11%).

Little is known about these dogs, or the dogs in developed countries that are feral, stray or that are in shelters, as the majority of modern research on dog cognition has focused on pet dogs living in human homes.

There is confusion with the terms used to categorize dogs.

Dogs can be classed by whether they possess an owner or a community of owners, how freely they can move around, and any genetic differences they have from other dog populations due to long-term separation.

Owned dogs are “family” dogs.

They have an identifiable owner, are commonly socialized, and are not allowed to roam.

They are restricted to particular outdoor or indoor areas.

They have little impact on wildlife unless going with humans into natural areas.

A free-ranging dog is a dog that is not confined to a yard or house.

Free-ranging owned dogs are cared for by one owner or a community of owners, and are able to roam freely.

This includes “village dogs“, which live in rural areas and human habitations.

These are not confined.

However, they rarely leave the village vicinity.

This also includes “rural free-ranging dogs“, which also live in rural areas and human habitations.

These are owned or are associated with homes, and they are not confined.

These include farm and pastoral dogs that range over particular areas.

Istanbul′s forgotten dogs struggle for survival | Environment | All topics  from climate change to conservation | DW | 08.10.2013

Free-ranging unowned dogs are stray dogs.

They get their food and shelter from human environments, but they have not been socialized and so they avoid humans as much as possible. 

Free-ranging unowned dogs include “urban free-ranging dogs“, which live in cities and urban areas.

These have no owner but are commensals, subsisting on left over food from human, garbage or other dogs’ food as their primary food sources. 

(Commensalism is a long-term biological interaction (symbiosis) in which members of one species gain benefits while those of the other species neither benefit nor are harmed.

This is in contrast with mutualism (in which both organisms benefit from each other), amensalism (where one is harmed while the other is unaffected), parasitism (where one is harmed and the other benefits), and parasitoidism (which is similar to parasitism but the parasitoid has a free-living state and instead of just harming its host, it eventually ends up killing it).

The commensal (the species that benefits from the association) may obtain nutrients, shelter, support, or locomotion from the host species, which is substantially unaffected.

The commensal relation is often between a larger host and a smaller commensal.

The host organism is unmodified, whereas the commensal species may show great structural adaptation consistent with its habits, as in the remoras that ride attached to sharks and other fish.

Remoras feed on their hosts’ fecal matter, while pilot fish feed on the leftovers of their hosts’ meals.

Above: Spearfish remora

Numerous birds perch on bodies of large mammal herbivores or feed on the insects turned up by grazing mammals.)

Strange Bird in Mahabharata: Bhulinga Bird! | Tamil and Vedas

Free-ranging unowned dogs also include feral dogs.

The term “feral” can be used to describe those animals that have been through the process of domestication but have returned to a wild state.

Domesticated and socialized (tamed) do not mean the same.

It is possible for a domestic form of an animal to be feral and not tame, and it is possible for a wild form of animal to be socialized to live with humans.

Feral Dogs and Shy Dogs | Best Friends Animal Society

Feral dogs differ from other dogs because they did not have close human contact early in their lives (socialization). 

Feral dogs live in a wild state with no food and shelter intentionally provided by humans and show a continuous and strong avoidance of direct human contact.

The distinction between feral, stray, and free ranging dogs is sometimes a matter of degree, and a dog may shift its status throughout its life.

In some unlikely but observed cases, a feral dog that was not born wild but lived with a feral group can become rehabilitated to a domestic dog with an owner.

A dog can become a stray when it escapes human control, by abandonment or being born to a stray mother.

A stray dog can become feral when it is forced out of the human environment or when it is co-opted or socially accepted by a nearby feral group.

Feralization occurs by the development of a fear response to humans.

Feral dogs are not reproductively self-sustaining, suffer from high rates of juvenile mortality, and depend indirectly on humans for their food, their space, and the supply of co-optable individuals.

Feral Dog Foster & Adoption | Best Friends Animal Society

The existence of “wild dogs” is debated.

Some authors propose that this term applies to the Australian dingo and dingo-feral dog hybrids.

They believe that these have a history of independence from humans and should no longer be considered as domesticated.

Others disagree, and propose that the dingo was once domesticated and is now a feral dog.

Dingo walking.jpg

The first British colonists to arrive in Australia established a settlement at Port Jackson in 1788 and recorded dingoes living there with indigenous Australians. 

Although the dingo exists in the wild, it associates with humans, but it has not been selectively bred as have other domesticated animals.

The dingo’s relationship with indigenous Australians can be described as commensalism, in which two organisms live in close association but without depending on each other for survival.

They will both hunt and sleep together.

The dingo is therefore comfortable enough around humans to associate with them, but is still capable of living independently. 

Any free-ranging unowned dog can be socialized to become an owned dog, as some dingoes do when they join human families.

Another point of view regards domestication as a process that is difficult to define.

It regards dogs as being either socialized and able to exist with humans, or unsocialized.

There exist dogs that live with their human families but are unsocialized and will treat strangers aggressively and defensively as might a wild wolf.

There also exists a number of cases where wild wolves have approached people in remote places, attempting to get them to play and to form companionship.

Stray' documentary about Turkish street dogs streaming today at Ciné

In 2011, a media article on the stray dog population by the US National Animal Interest Alliance said that there are 200 million stray dogs worldwide and that a “rabies epidemic” was causing a global public health issue.

About National Animal Interest Alliance, Animal Welfare  OrganizationNational Animal Interest Alliance

In 2013, the World Health Organization (WHO) reported that dogs are responsible for the vast majority of human rabies deaths, contributing up to 99% of all rabies transmissions to humans.

World Health Organization Logo.svg

Rabies causes tens of thousands of deaths every year, mainly in Asia and Africa.

More than 15 million people receive post-bite rabies vaccines to prevent the disease.

Above: Deaths from rabies per million persons in 2012 – The darker the region, the more deaths therein.

Increasing numbers of free-ranging dogs have become a threat to the snow leopard and young brown bears on the Tibetan Plateau because dog packs chase these animals away from food.

Irbis4.JPG
Above: Snow leopard

Above: Grizzly bear sow and cubs

Free-ranging dogs are often vectors of diseases, such as rabies and canine distemper, which can jump into species such as African wild dogs, wolves, lions and tigers.

In addition, they can interbreed with other members of the genus Canis, such as the Ethiopian wolf and the dingo, raising genetic purity concerns.

Ethiopian wolf (Canis simensis citernii).jpg
Above: Ethiopian wolf

Abandoned pets are companion animals that are either inadvertently or deliberately abandoned by their owners, by either dumping the animals on the streets, leaving them alone in a vacant property, or relinquishing them at an animal shelter.

Is COVID-19 just an excuse to abandon pets? - Times of India

Animal welfare laws in many states of the United States make it a crime to abandon a pet.

File:Flag of the United States.svg
Above: Flag of the United States of America

The UK passed the Abandonment of Animals Act of 1960, which describes the offence of cruelty as:

If any person being the owner or having charge or control of any animal shall without reasonable cause or excuse abandon it, whether permanently or not, in circumstances likely to cause the animal any unnecessary suffering, or cause or procure or, being the owner, permit it to be so abandoned.

A flag composed of a red cross edged in white and superimposed on a red saltire, also edged in white, superimposed on a white saltire on a blue background
Above: Flag of the United Kingdom

Often, when abandoned, pets are forced to fend for themselves and become stray or feral. 

Feral cats are said to outnumber feral dogs and can become challenging to handle and socialize enough to be re-introduced to a new human owner.

In general, only some newly abandoned cats and very young feral kittens can be tamed. 

There is a necessity to investigate interventions to prevent companion-animal relinquishment.

Stray animals increase potential exposure to zoonotic diseases like rabies. 

Cat bites or scratches involving stray or feral animals are eight times more common than dog bites.

Some pets relinquished to an animal shelter will be euthanized due to a lack of space or financial resources. 

Millions of companion animals enter animal shelters every year in the United States. 

However, the number of dogs and cats euthanized in US shelters declined from approximately 2.6 million in 2011 to 1.5 million in 2018.

This decline can be partially explained by an increase in the percentage of animals adopted, and an increase in the number of stray animals successfully returned to their owners. 

Studies show that the majority of people who relinquish an animal also report being emotionally attached to the dog.

It has been reported that when forced to abandon their animals in an evacuation, people suffer mental issues, such as grief, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder.

Recognizing the importance of pets to their owners and their role in public health is an essential first step in improving a public health problem that has been seen repeatedly in the past and is unlikely to change in the future.

Alf wight.jpg
Above: James Heriot (1916 – 1995)

Pet abandonment increased during the USA financial crisis of 2007 – 2008.

In early 2009, the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) published advice for people facing foreclosure and the loss of their pets, recommending finding a foster or adoption situation for your pet, being aware of rental property rules for pets, and checking with animal shelters and animal rescue groups.

American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (logo).svg

Eskişehir, Turkey, Friday 24 December 2021

I have tried and have failed miserably at being a dog owner.

No photo description available.
Above: Your humble blogger

During my college years in Québec City I was given a puppy.

I accepted it without giving any forethought that the boarding house wherein I lived might not accept the dog on the premises.

I was forced to give up the puppy within a day of getting it.

From top, left to right: Quebec City from the St. Lawrence River, the Ramparts of Quebec City, waterfront in Old Quebec, skycrapers in Vieux-Québec, Parliament Building, Château Frontenac, Pierre Laporte Bridge
Above: Images of Québec City, Canada

During my time in Suwon, South Korea, I was given another dog to take care of.

A stray dog that my Canadian colleague from Toronto took in, it was given to me when Laura decided to prematurely break her work contract and return back to Canada.

Harubang (Korean for “grandfather“) was not at all a domesticated animal.

Indoors was its fecal depository, outdoors its playground.

Never having toilet trained an animal before I was overwhelmed as to handle Harubang.

I soon gave Harubang away to a Korean colleague and I have never found out the dog’s fate.

Hwaseong Fortress and the skyline of Suwon
Above: Suwon, South Korea

Since Suwon I have found myself living in apartments where the leasing agreements have strictly prohibited pets on the premises, including the old apartment in Eskişehir I would leave in 5 days’ time and the new apartment in Eskişehir I will move into in 55 days’ time.

Above: Eskişehir, Turkey

I have found myself envying St. Gallen friends of mine who are pet owners.

Kasia of Poland has half a dozen cats.

Byron of America has had dogs the entirety of his life.

Naomi of Vancouver adopted two lovely dogs for her home.

A view of St. Gallen
Above: St. Gallen, Switzerland

But Ute (the aforementioned wife) and I don’t have any pets in Landschlacht, as both our lease and our lifestyles deny this destiny.

A pet is a responsibility akin to having a child.

A pet is in so many ways as helpless as a human child.

A pet, an animal, has feelings and deserves to be treated as compassionately and responsibly as any person.

And herein lies the connection between people and pets.

We feel, or at least should feel, compassion for all living beings.

But this need for connectivity contradicts with the burden of duty that compassion demands.

Christmas Eve Day, or Quviasukvik (Inuit New Year’s Day), finds me having to visit Immigration to register the change of apartment addresses, my bank for the proper transferral of funds, and to do the usual hours of work at Wall Street English.

Bridge over the Porsuk River, Eskişehir, Turkey | Steve Hobson | Flickr

As my business with Immigration is completed sooner than I had anticipated, but my bank is closed for lunch, I stroll from the main street of Eskişehir’s shopping district to the Porsuk River bridge that connects to the street where Izmir Sandviç, my regular hangout in my first week in Eskişehir, sits.

Izmirlim Sandviç, Eskişehir - Restoran Yorumları - Tripadvisor

A beautiful Turkish Akbash sheepdog seeks my attention as I ascend the stairs leading up to the bridge.

Soft-hearted man that I am, I pet the dog’s beautiful coat.

In an instant, I love this dog and the dog loves me.

But I have neither the time nor the ability to take care of a creature that clearly needs to be loved.

The dog follows me for a block.

I dare not turn around to look at him or I will be lost in his sorrowful eyes.

I feel terrible, like I am abandoning a helpless creature to a state of loneliness and pain.

But am I ready, able and willing to give it the care it needs?

Sadly, no.

I walk away, spirits heavy, thoughts bleak.

The dog will forget me, but I will not forget the dog for quite some time.

He is both a major and a minor memory in a lifetime of many moments worth remembering.

Above: Turkish Akbash sheepdog

I find myself remembering Mark Twain’s A Dog’s Tale:

Dogstale.jpg

My father was a St. Bernard, my mother was a collie, but I am a Presbyterian.

That is what my mother told me.

I do not know these nice distinctions myself.

To me they are only fine large words meaning nothing.

Hummel Vedor vd Robandahoeve.jpg
Above: A male St. Bernard

My mother had a fondness for such.

She liked to say them and see other dogs look surprised and envious, as wondering how she got so much education.

But indeed it was not real education.

It was only show.

She got the words by listening in the dining room and drawing room when there was company, and by going with the children to Sunday school and listening there.

Whenever she heard a large word she said it over to herself many times, and so was able to keep it until there was a dogmatic gathering in the neighbourhood.

Then she would get it off, and surprise and distress them all, from pocket pup to mastiff, which rewarded her for all her trouble.

If there was a stranger he was nearly sure to be suspicious, and when he got his breath again he would ask her what it meant.

And she always told him.

He was never expecting this, but thought he would catch her.

So when she told him, he was the one that looked ashamed, whereas he had thought it was going to be she.

The others were always waiting for this, and glad of it and proud of her, for they knew what was going to happen, because they had had experience.

Above: A collie

You can see by these things that she was of a rather vain and frivolous character.

Still, she had virtues, and enough to make up, I think.

She had a kind heart and gentle ways.

She never harboured resentments for injuries done her, but put them easily out of her mind and forgot them.

And she taught her children her kindly way.

From her we learned also to be brave and prompt in time of danger and not to run away, but face the peril that threatened friend or stranger, and help him the best we could without stopping to think what the cost might be to us.

She taught us, not by words only, but by example.

And that is the best way and the surest and the most lasting.

Why, the brave things she did, the splendid things!

She was just a soldier, and so modest about it.

Well, you couldn’t help admiring her and you couldn’t help imitating her.

There was more to her than her education.

8 Dogs ideas | dogs, saint bernard, st bernard mix

When I was well grown, at last, I was sold and taken away, and I never saw her again.

She was broken-hearted and so was I and we cried.

But she comforted me as well as she could and said we were sent into this world for a wise and good purpose, and must do our duties without repining.

Take our life as we might find it.

Live it for the best good of others and never mind about the results.

They were not our affair.

She said men who did like this would have a noble and beautiful reward by-and-by in another world.

And although we animals would not go there, to do well and right without reward would give to our brief lives a worthiness and dignity which in itself would be a reward.

18 Saint Bernard Mixes That You Would Find Adorable - TheGoodyPet

So we said our farewells and looked our last upon each other through our tears.

The last thing she said – keeping it for the last to make me remember it the better, I think, was:

In memory of me, when there is a time of danger to another do not think of yourself, think of your mother and do as she would do.

Do you think I could forget that?

No.

Adrian the Saint Bernard Mix | St bernard mix, Puppies, Puppy funny memes

It was such a charming home – my new one.

A fine great house with pictures and delicate decorations and rich furniture and no gloom anywhere.

All the wilderness of dainty colours lit up with flooding sunshine.

And the spacious grounds around it and the great garden – oh, greensward and noble trees and flowers, no end!

What Is A Victorian Style House? - Victorian House Design Style

And I was the same as a member of the family.

And they loved me and petted me.

Mrs. Gray was 30, and so sweet and so lovely, you cannot imagine it.

And Sadie was 10, and just like her mother, just a darling slender little copy of her, with auburn tails down her back, and short frocks.

And the baby was a year old, plump and dimpled and fond of me, and never could get enough of hauling on my tail and hugging me and laughing out loud its innocent happiness.

And Mr. Gray was 38, tall and slender and handsome, a little blad in front, alert, quick in his movements, businesslike, prompt, decided, unsentimental, with that kind of trim-chiselled face that just seems to glint and sparkle with frosty intellectuality!

He was a renowned scientist.

8,945 BEST Family Silhouette With Dog IMAGES, STOCK PHOTOS & VECTORS |  Adobe Stock

The laboratory was not a book or a picture or a place to wash your hands in.

It is filled with jars and bottles and electrics and wires and strange machines.

Every week other scientists came there and sat in the place and used the machines and discussed and made what they called experiments and discoveries.

Often I came too and stood around and listened and tried to learn, for the sake of my mother and in loving memory of her.

Try as I might, I was never able to make anything out of it at all.

ArtStation - Victorian Attic Lab, Ewan Tennent

Other times I lay on the floor in the mistress’ workroom and slept, she gently using me as a footstool, knowing it pleased me, for it was a caress.

Other times I spent an hour in the nursery and well tousled and made happy.

Other times I watched by the crib there, when the baby was sleeping and the nurse out for a few minutes on the baby’s affairs.

Other times I romped and raced through the grounds and the garden with Sadie until we were tired out, then slumbered on the grass in the shade of the tree while she read her book.

Why The Border Collie St Bernard Mix Is A Great Family And Working Dog?

The servants in our house were all kind to me and were fond of me, and so, as you see, mine was a pleasant life.

There could not be a happier dog than I was nor a more grateful one.

I will say this for myself, for it is only the truth:

I tried in all ways to do well and right and honour my mother’s memory and her teachings and earn the happiness that had come to me as best as I could.

8 Dogs ideas | dogs, saint bernard, st bernard mix

By-and-by came my little puppy and then my cup was full.

My happiness was perfect.

It was the dearest little waddling thing, so smooth and soft and velvety and had such cunning little awkward paws.

It made me so proud to see how the children and their mother adored it and fondled it and exclaimed over every little wonderful thing it did.

It did seem to me that life was just too lovely to…..

Moon Pack Dogs | Husky dog pictures, Cute dogs, Unique dog breeds

Then came the winter.

One day I was standing a watch in the nursery.

That is to say, I was asleep on the bed.

The baby was sleep in the crib, which was alongside the bed, on the side next to the fireplace.

It was the kind of crib that has a lofty tent over it made of a gauzy stuff that you can see through it.

The nurse was out and we two sleepers were alone.

Homeless dog rescues abandoned baby (PHOTOS) – Society – World – NOVA News  – Darik.News/en

A spark from the wood fire was shot out and it lit on the slope of the tent.

I suppose a quiet interval followed, then a scream from the baby awoke me.

There was that tent flaming up toward the ceiling!

Before I could think, I sprang to the floor in my fright and in a second was halfway to the door, but in the next half-second my mother’s farewell was sounding in my ears.

I was back on the bed again.

I reached my head through the flames and dragged the baby out by the waistband and tugged it along.

We fell to the floor together in a cloud of smoke.

Nursery Fender Fire Guard | Jamb

I snatched a new hold and dragged the screaming creature along and out at the door and around the bend of the hall and was still tugging away, all excited and happy and proud, when the master’s voice shouted:

Begone, you cursed beast!”

I jumped up to save myself, but he was wonderfully quick and chased me up, striking furiously at me with his cane, I dodging this way and that, in terror.

At last a strong blow fell upon my left foreleg, which made me shriek and fall, for the moment, helpless.

Watch: Drunk man beats a stray dog to death in UP's Ghaziabad

The cane went up for another blow, but never descended, for the nurse’s voice rang wildly out:

The nursery is on fire!

The master rushed away in that direction and my other bones were saved.

Town centre road closed as fire crews tackle blaze in children's nursery -  Stoke-on-Trent Live

The pain was cruel, but, no matter, I must not lose any time.

He might come back at any moment.

So I limped on three legs to the other end of the hall, where there was a dark little stairway leading up into a garret where old boxes and such things were kept, as I had heard say and where people seldom went.

I managed to climb up there, then I searched my way through the dark amongst the pile of things and hid in the most secret place I could find.

It was foolish to be afraid there, yet still I was.

So afraid that I held in and hardly even whimpered, though it would have been a comfort to whimper, because that eases the pain, you know.

But I could lick my leg and that did me some good.

Dog found lying on the street needs leg amputated - Galway Daily

For half an hour there was a commotion downstairs, shouting, and rushing footsteps, and then there was quiet again.

Quiet for some minutes and that was grateful to my spirit, for then my fears began to go down.

Fears are worse than pain – oh, much worse.

Then came a sound that froze me!

They were calling me – calling me by name – hunting for me!

16 Saint Bernard Mixes That Will Melt Your Cold, Unloving Heart - PetPress

It was muffled by distance, but that could not take the terror out of it.

It was the most dreadful sound to me that I had ever heard.

It went all about, everywhere, down there, along the halls, through all the rooms, in both stories, and in the basement and the cellar, then outside, and further and further away – then back, and all about the house again.

I thought it would never, never stop.

But at last it did, hours and hours after the vague twilight of the garret had long ago been blotted out by black darkness.

Top Activities For Border Collie Bernards - Wag!

Then in that blessed stillness my terrors fell little by little away.

I was at peace and slept.

It was a good rest I had, but I woke before the twilight had come again.

I was feeling fairly comfortable and I could think out a plan now.

I made a very good one, which was, to creep down, all the way down the back stairs, and hide behind the cellar door, and slip out and escape when the iceman came at dawn, whilst he was inside filling the refrigerator.

Then I would hide all day and start on my journey when night came.

My journey to –

Well, anywhere they would not know me and betray me to the master.

I was feeling almost cheerful now.

St Bernard Mix Breeds - Different Hybrids of this Big Beautiful Dog

Then suddenly I thought:

Why, what would life be without my puppy?

That was despair.

There was no plan for me.

I saw that I must stay where I was.

Stay and wait and take what might come.

30 Breeds That Are Mixed With Border Collie - PetPress

It was not my affair.

That was what life is.

My mother has said it.

Then –

Well, then the calling began again!

All my sorrows came back.

I said to myself:

The master will never forgive.

I did not know what I had done to make him so bitter and so unforgiving, yet I judged it was something a dog could not understand, but which was clear to a man and dreadful.

SPCA treating St. Bernard mix for gunshot wound | CTV News

They called and called – days and nights, it seemed to me.

So long that the hunger and thirst near drove me mad.

I recognized that I was getting very weak.

When you are this way you sleep a great deal, and I did.

Once I woke in an awful fright – it seemed to me that the calling was right there in the garret!

And so it was.

It was Sadie’s voice and she was crying.

My name was falling from her lips all broken, poor thing.

I could not believe my ears for the joy of it when I heard her say:

Come back to us – oh, come back to us and forgive – it is all so sad without our – “

The Saint Bernard Australian Shepherd Mix: Facts/Information

I broke in with such a grateful little yelp.

The next moment Sadie was plunging and stumbling through the darkness and the lumber and shouting for the family to hear:

She’s found! She’s found!”

Medium shot of a woman calling a dog - Stock Video Footage - Dissolve

The days that followed –

Well, they were wonderful.

The mother and Sadie and the servants – why, they just seemed to worship me.

They couldn’t seem to make me a bed that was fine enough, and as for food, they couldn’t be satisfied with anything but game and delicacies that were out of season.

Every day the friends and neighbours flocked in to hear about my heroism.

A dozen times a day Mrs. Gray and Sadie would tell the tale to newcomers, and say I risked my life to save the baby’s and both of us had burns to prove it.

And then the company would pass me around and pet me and exclaim about me, and you could see the pride in the eyes of Sadie and her mother.

When people wanted to know what made me limp, they looked ashamed and changed the subject.

Sometimes when people hunted them this way and that with questions about it, it looked to me as if they were going to cry.

Timmyfan Whispers: Interesting St. Bernard Mixed Dogs I've Seen On the  Internet

And this was not all the glory.

No, the master’s friends came, a whole twenty of the most distinguished people, and had me in the laboratory, and discussed me as if I was a kind of discovery.

Some of them said it was wonderful in a dumb beast, the finest exhibition of instinct they could call to mind.

But the master said, with vehemence:

It’s far above instinct.

It’s ‘reason’, and many a man, privileged to be saved and go with you and me to a better world by right of its possession, has less of it than this poor silly quadruped that’s foreordained to perish.

And then he laughed and said:

Well, look at me – I’m a sarcasm!

Bless you, with all my grand intelligence, the only thing I inferred was that the dog had gone mad and was destroying the child, whereas but for the beast’s intelligence – its ‘reason’, I tell you! – the child would have perished!

St. Bernard/Border Collie Mix (Archer Barker) - Imgur

They disputed and disputed and I was the very centre and subject of it all.

I wished my mother could know that this great honour had come to me.

It would have made her proud.

Male Border Collie

Then they discussed optics, as they called it, and whether a certain injury to the brain would produce blindness or not, but they could not agree about it.

Next, they discussed plants.

That interested me, because in the summer Sadie and I had planted seeds – I helped her dig the holes, you know – and after days and days a little shrub or a flower came up there.

It was a wonder how that could happen.

But it did.

I wished I could talk.

I would have told those people about it and shown them how much I knew and been all alive with the subject.

Dog helps her human with gardening. Watch adorable video | viral video on  internet today | Bhanu vlg - YouTube

But I didn’t care for the optics.

It was dull and when they came back to it again it bored me and I went to sleep.

Dog-Friendly Garden | Tips for the Perfect Pet-Friendly Green Space

Pretty soon it was spring and sunny and pleasant and lovely.

The sweet mother and the children petted me and the puppy good-bye and went away on a journey and a visit to their kin.

The master wasn’t any company for us, but we played together and had good times.

The servants were kind and friendly, so we got along quite happily and counted the days and waited for the family.

Irwin, PA - St. Bernard. Meet Ziggy a Pet for Adoption - AdoptaPet.com

One day those men came again and said now for the test.

They took the puppy to the laboratory.

I limped three-leggedly along, too, feeling proud, for any attention shown the puppy was a pleasure to me, of course.

They discussed and experimented, and then suddenly the puppy shrieked.

They set him on the floor and he went staggering around, with his head all bloody.

The master clapped his hands and shouted:

There, I’ve won – confess it!

He’s as blind as a bat!”

And they all said:

It’s so – you’ve proved your theory and suffering humanity owes you a great debt from henceforth.”

They crowded around him and wrung his hand cordially and thankfully and praised him.

Doggos! — What would you name her?? 9 week old Saint...

But I hardly saw or heard these things, for I ran at once to my little darling and snuggled close to it where it lay and licked the blood.

It put its head against mine, whimpering softly, and I knew in my heart it was a comfort to it in its pain and trouble to feel its mother’s touch, though it could not see me.

Then it drooped down, presently, and its little velvet nose rested upon the floor.

It was still and did not move any more.

Saint Bernard X Retriver in Balloch on Freeads Classifieds - Mixed Breed  classifieds

Soon the master stopped discussing a moment and rang in the footman and said, “Bury it in the far corner of the garden.“, and then went on with the discussion.

I trotted after the footman, very happy and grateful, for I knew the puppy was out of its pain now, because it was asleep.

We went far down the garden to the furthest end, where the children and the nurse and the puppy and I used to play in the summer in the shade of a great elm.

And there the footman dug a hole and I saw he was going to plant the puppy.

I was glad, because it would grow and become a fine handsome dog and be a beautiful surprise for the family when they came home.

I tried to help him dig, but my lame leg was no good, being stiff, you know, and you have to have two or it is no use.

When the footman had finished and covered little Robin up, he patted my head.

There were tears in his eyes and he said:

Poor little doggie, you SAVED ‘his’ child.

Video of Dog Burying Other Dog May Be a Lot Less Heartwarming Than It  Appears

I have watched two whole weeks and he doesn’t come up.

This last week a fright has been stealing upon me.

I think there is something terrible about this.

I do not know what it is, but the fear makes me sick and I cannot eat, though the servants bring me the best of food.

They pet me and come in the night and cry and say:

Poor doggie – do give it up and come home.

Don’t break our hearts!

And all this terrifies me the more and makes me sure something has happened.

I am so weak.

Since yesterday I cannot stand on my feet any more.

And within this hour the servants, looking toward the sun where it was sinking out of sight and the night chill coming on, said things I could not understand, but they carried something cold to my heart.

Those poor creatures! They do not suspect. They will come home in the morning and eagerly ask for the little doggie that did the brave deed and who of us will be strong enough to say the truth to them?

The humble little friend is gone where go the beasts that perish.

Why you shouldn't bury your pet in the backyard

It is said that dog is man’s best friend.

Sadly, I doubt whether man has been dog’s best friend.

How Did Dogs Evolve to Become Man's Best Friend?

Certainly it is good to see that the Turks provide water and food and shelter to the strays that roam the streets of its cities.

But God’s creatures are not merely receptacles for shelter and nourishment, they feel as much as we do and think as best as they can.

All creatures love and need to be loved.

And the power of love demands great compassion and commitment and responsibility.

And not all of us are capable of the compassion, commitment and resp

Abuse and abandonment: why pets are at risk during this pandemic

Humanity taught the pit bull aggression and the pit bull thus follows what it has been taught.

Which is how and why a child lies in hospital scarred, physically for now, psychologically for some time to come.

The dogs will probably be destroyed.

Many of their canine compatriots will perhaps pay a heavy price for the aggression visited upon one solitary child.

There are too many stray dogs, they say.

No, there are not enough homes.

My thoughts return to the young man sobbing behind his mask, grieving inside this manmade artificial platform shelter.

I curse the fear that keeps me from speaking with him, from asking how he is and if there is anything I could do, that I could say, that might bring him some modicum of comfort.

I remain quiet, distant, uninvolved.

I tell myself that this man’s problems are not my responsibility.

Much like the dog by the Porsuk River is not my responsibility..

Not my circus, not my monkeys, not my problem.

But this is a lie.

We are our brothers’ keepers.

And all humanity, all existence, is our responsibility.

I am honest with myself.

I am selfish and afraid to get involved.

Because life is messy, complicated, complex, and damnedably difficult.

Love ain’t easy.

Perhaps this is why it is such a rare and precious thing.

Rescue me: why Britain's beautiful lockdown pets are being abandoned | Pets  | The Guardian

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / “More pit bull attacks take place amid calls for shelters“, Daily Sabah, 28 December 2021 / Jennifer Hattam, “‘They see them as fellow citizens’: How Istanbul’s street dogs have found a place in society“, Washington Post, 18 March 2021 / “Stray animals under spotlight amid debate“, Hürriyet Daily News, 28 December 2021 / Mark Twain, A Dog’s Tale