Swiss Miss and the Border School of Poetry

Eskişehir, Türkiye, Monday 7 November 2022

Recently, a friend wrote a poem and asked of me an opinion.

Had he written well?

The qualities of a good poem include consistent language which presents the main idea and that emotionally supports that idea.

Poetry is a beautiful form of expression.

It is versatile, giving freedom to writers who want to stretch themselves creatively.

You shouldn’t worry about whether your poetry is good or bad, but how it conveys the topic and emotion you want to share.

Poetry is a classic form of expression.

Many writers got their start crafting poems.

Many who have moved on to other forms of literature still occasionally create poetry.

Nothing quite conveys the complexity of human emotion as this writing style.

Poetry gives both the structure and freedom to present big ideas in bite-sized forms. 

Poetry limits the space we have to write by its very nature, which can seem restrictive but it is an excellent means of following a built-in structure.

That being said, it isn’t so different from other literary forms as you still need a central idea that holds it together

Your focus should always be on that primary concept. 

It can be easy to get off-track and introduce too many ideas that detract from the principal point.

As you are writing, ask yourself if it builds on the initial concept. 

All writing is a form of storytelling, including poetry.

No matter what you are trying to convey, the reader should be able to follow that story as they go.

That doesn’t mean it can’t be abstract or even hard to decipher.

A lot of poems are based on interpretation by the reader, but there should be some story woven throughout the lines. 

Read through your poem as if you didn’t write it.

Do you see the story?

If not, then you might need to revise it.

Emotion is the driving force behind a successful poem.

For instance, in a novel, the reader should be emotionally connected to the characters and what is happening in the plot.

How the reader feels lends context to the story being told and connects them to what has been written. 

There is less time to make that connection in a poem, so it has to be done quickly.

The reader should be hooked from the first line, feeling their way to the end. 

Above: Russian writer Anton Chekhov (1860 – 1904)

Think about “The Raven” by Edgar Allen Poe.

Immediately, we are drawn in by the incessant knocking of some unknown visitor.

But as the poem goes on, it draws us in even more through words like, “filled me with fantastic terrors” and “to still the beating of my heart”.

These words have us on the edge of our seats because they describe basic fears.

When you can write your poem with such vivid words like that, then you can resonate emotionally with your audience.

Above: American writer Edgar Allan Poe (1809 – 1849)

A good poem has visual imagery that paints a picture in the head of the reader.

Descriptive language is critical.

Without it, poetry falls flat and feels one-dimensional, without color or depth.

It is why metaphor is so often found in poems. 

Whatever you are trying to present to the reader, it should always have a strong visual element. 

There is a standard piece of advice in writing that states that you should go back through your work and remove 10% of it.

This can be harder in poetry, where you are already more limited in your verbal space.

But it remains a tried and true way to improve the work. 

Flow is crucial when writing a poem.

It isn’t easy to get a sense of that flow when reading it in your mind.

You should always consider speaking your poetry out loud.

If it is written well, it will feel good to speak out loud. 

Reading aloud is also a great exercise in developing your writing style and confidence, especially when done in front of an audience. 

Is my friend a poet?

Poets and writers see patterns not only in their writing, but in life itself.

A poet sees patterns and rhythm in each line and verse of every poem.

A poet’s personality is the essence of pattern and rhythm.

A poem or verse or poet without pattern is chaos.

They write for themselves, for their own personal reasons.

The best poets and writers are driven/led/guided by their failures/experiences/heartaches.

They want to spread the misery/insights/information to help readers live fulfilling lives.

Trust the process regardless of the progress.

In seeking an answer to my friend’s query I turned to Rainer Maria Rilke’s Letters to a Young Poet.

Letters to a Young Poet could as easily have been called Letters FROM a Young Poet.

Rilke was only 26 years old when Franz Xavier Kappus first wrote to him in 1902.

Above: Austrian writer Franz Xaver Kappus (1883 – 1966)

As the addresses on Rilke’s Letters indicate, he had no settled home.

Three years before these Letters start, Rilke had married the sculptor Clara Westhoff and fathered a child, but they rarely lived together nor did they raise their daughter.

(They left that task to Clara’s parents.)

Above: Portrait of German artist Clara Rilke-Westhoff (1878 – 1954)

Nonetheless, he was not without a sense of family obligation.

The last two years since my marriage I really have tried to earn, continually, day by day.

Not much has come of it.

I am left feeling as if someone had closed the window towards the garden in which my songs live.

I have written twelve books and have received almost nothing from them.

I dream that I might seek rescue in some quiet handicraft.

Above: German poet Rainer Maria Rilke (1875 – 1926)

In August 1902, six months before his Letters began, Rilke travelled to Paris.

He hated it.

He felt invisible and alone, surrounded by men and women driven like machines, people “holding out under the foot of each day that trod on them, like tough beetles.”

Their “burdened lives” threatened to swamp him:

I often had to say aloud to myself that I was not one of them.

And yet, when I noticed how my clothes were becoming worse and heavier from week to week, I was frightened and felt that I would belong irretrievably to the lost if some passer-by merely looked at me and half unconsciously counted me with them.

Above: Paris, France

In the Letters, Rilke hints at his own difficulties as when he says that his “life is full of troubles and sadness.”

Rilke often speaks of being anxious and afraid.

Afraid that he might never become his own person.

Rilke mentions the way in which most people, faced with the difficulties of sexual love, “escape into one of the many conventions which like public shelters are set up along this most dangerous of paths“.

Rilke himself did not wish to take shelter, but the temptation was there – to settle down, to support his wife and daughter, to buy himself a good suit, to follow a path that no one could call imprudent.

He lived in fear of two false fates:

Either he might end up as lost as the ragged poor who had surrounded him in Paris or else that he might succumb to the safe but numbing comforts of convention.

Above: Portrait of Rainer Maria Rilke, Paula Modersohn-Becker (1906)

I wondered if Rilke’s struggle is not so dissimilar to the struggles of my friend and myself.

The fear that we might never become our own persons, driven by the desperate need to express that fear.

Above: Castello di Duino near Trieste, Italy, was where Rilke began writing the Duino Elegies in 1912, recounting that he heard the famous first line as a voice in the wind while walking along the cliffs and that he wrote it quickly in his notebook.

I posted on Facebook the following:

I listen to women and sometimes I think that there are some (perhaps many) who are so wrapped up in themselves that they neither know nor care about the struggles that men must endure.

I am not suggesting that a woman’s life is necessarily a bed of roses, but rather that there are women who cannot understand the way men feel, some that don’t want to know, because knowing may demand changing the focus of entitlement from themselves to those with whom they wish to share a future.

Women of this day and age seem to act from inner feeling and spirit, more and more knowing who they are and what they want.

But I think too many men spend their lives pretending to be happy, not knowing who they are supposed to be nor knowing what it is they should want for themselves.

Men are hurting and in the process they hurt others.

So, instead they plug on, in quiet desperation, not knowing how they should be, for too many men lack the kind of family and friendship networks that seem atypical for women.

Women have had to overcome suppression, but men’s struggles are with isolation.

Too many men are tragically lonely, compulsively competitive and emotionally timid.

Men live fewer years than women.

Men routinely fail at close relationships.

40% of marriages break down.

70% of divorces are initiated by women.

90% of violent acts are committed by men.

67% of their victims are men.

In school, 90% of children with behaviour problems are boys.

80% of children with learning problems are boys.

Men comprise over 90% of inmates in jails.

Men are 75% of the unemployed.

The leading cause of death amongst men between 12 and 60 is self-inflicted.

75% of suicides are men.

And yet this is supposedly a man’s world?

Men are in many countries compelled to do military service.

For women, this is optional.

Men are universally expected to work.

For women, traditionally, this has been an option.

Men consistently lose in divorce settlements and consistently lose access to their children in custody battles.

In our pursuit of women, we are expected to make them happy.

But is not men’s happiness just as crucial as women’s?

The Isle of Man is a geography of solitude.

Solitude is not merely a matter of being alone.

It is a territory to be entered and occupied.

Solitude exists, a lack of connection to other people, a fact we are not eager to seek, acknowledge or welcome.

We are alone in a crowd, unaided even by those in similar straits.

And yet identity cannot be found in a crowd, but must be sought in the silence.

Women are the Earth.

Men are both a part of and apart from the Earth.

Islands unto ourselves, our own teachers, for rare is the boy who is taught to be a man by other men.

I wish I could explain this to women, but first a man must decipher this for himself.

Men do not need make-up.

Our pretense runs deeper than skin surface.

The Isle of Man is a geography of solitude desperate for a bridge.

Some men manage the bridge construction.

Many do not.

Life offers the human being two choices: animal existence and spiritual existence.

I believe that too many women choose the former, opting for physical well-being and an opportunity to indulge in habits.

Men and women have the same potential.

There is no primary difference in intelligence between the sexes, but that potential if neglected will stagnate.

If the capacity is not utilized, it will disintegrate.

Men are compelled by society to develop theirs.

Women have the choice to do so or not.

I believe women can be anything they wish.

If only they would choose to be.

Above: The Isle of Man in the Irish Sea between England and Ireland

My friend (and he is not alone in this respect) has pain seeking release.

I seek to answer him in the manner of Rilke:

You ask whether your verses are good.

You ask me that.

You have asked others before.

You send them to magazines.

You compare them with other poems.

You worry when certain editors turn your efforts down.

Now let me ask you to give up all that.

You are looking to the outside and that above all you should not be doing.

Nobody can advise you and help you.

Nobody.

There is only one way.

Go into yourself.

Examine the reason that bids you to write.

Check whether it reaches its roots into the deepest region of your heart.

Admit to yourself whether you should die if it should be denied you to write.

This above all:

Ask yourself in your night’s quietest hour:

MUST I write?

Dig down into yourself for a deep answer.

It should be affirmative.

A loud and simple “I must”.

Construct your life according to this necessity.

Your life right into its most inconsequential and slightest hour must become a sign and witness of this urge.

Make use of whatever you find about you to express yourself, the images from your dreams and the things in your memory.

If your everyday life seems to lack material, do not blame it.

Blame yourself.

Tell yourself that you are not poet enough to summon up its riches.

For there is no lack for him who creates and no poor trivial place.

Above: Château de Muzot in Veyras, Switzerland, was where Rilke completed writing the Duino Elegies in “a savage creative storm” in February 1922.

Within herself, Heidi Ho sits and ponders.

There is music within that seeks expression.

Does her everyday life in Zürich and St. Gallen seem to lack material to set to music?

Above: Zürich, Switzerland

Perhaps.

Perhaps one needs to have beauty within to see the beauty that surrounds us.

Perhaps this is why she has travelled, why she will continue to travel in future.

A search for self, the soul’s expression, the music of the road.

Above: St. Gallen, Switzerland

Vinh to Huê, Vietnam, Saturday 27 April 2019

It is 2 hours and 28 minutes, should the motorcyclist not become distracted en route by hunger, toilet needs or sites seen, from Ha Tinh to Hoan Lao.

The terrain is flat.

The East Sea is glimpsed in the distance, shimmering, beckoning, whispering:

Linger“.

Above: Flag of Vietnam

Heidi and her travelling companion do not.

They left Vinh this morning.

They hope to reach Hué this evening where their booked rooms await.

Above: Images of Vinh, Vietnam

Above: Imperial City, Hué, Vietnam

The days are warm Swiss summer, the nights are cool Helvetian spring.

The roads are congested.

Full alertness required.

They have been on the road for much of the morning.

Highway 1 rises from the plain of Ha Tinh into and across the Hoann Son Mountains through Ngang Pass, the Jain temple of Dèn thö Bâ chu’a Liêu Hanh marks the border between Ha Tinh and Quang Binh Provinces.

Above: Highway 1A (red line), Vietnam

Above: Ha Tinh Province scene

Above: the Jain temple of Dèn thö Bâ chu’a Liêu Hanh, Vietnam

Ngang Pass was once a major hindrance to land transportation with its winding and steep grade.

A modern tunnel has since bypassed the climb, shortening the driving time through the pass as well as making it safer for drivers.

The serpentine road ascending the pass is now used by sightseers only.

A tunnel through a mountain.

How Swiss!“, Heidi thinks.

Above: Ngang Pass, Vietnam

The Pass is 2,560 m long, ascending to the height of 250 m (750 ft).

It marked the former boundary of Champa and Dai Viet until the 15th century when the Vietnamese pushed south and conquered the Cham lands piecemeal.

Controlling the strategic pass was a priority through the ages as the narrow neck of land could be choked off.

At the summit of Ngang Pass remains the Hoành Sơn Quan (Transverse Mountain Gate), a masonry gateway built by Vietnam’s last dynasty, the Nguyen to regulate the foot traffic across the mountain.

The scenic pass is also well known in Vietnamese literature, its beauty having been sung by many writers, perhaps the most well-known is the poem by Ba Huyen Thanh Quan.

Above: Hoành Son Quan, Ngang Pass, Vietnam

Nguyễn Thị Hinh, popularly known as Bà Huyện Thanh Quan (Lady of the Thanh Quan District Chief) (1805 – 1848) was a Vietnamese female poet.

Most of her Nom poems are descriptions of scenes and confessions, but all of them are good and show that she is a virtuous, ethereal person, an educated person who often thinks about home and country. 

The lyrics are very elegant and skillful.

Ba Huyen Thanh Quan’s poetry is full of poetry. 

Her poetry is skillful, sharpened, and beautiful, like an ancient painting.

Words are used skillfully, selectively, appropriately, with very fine tuning, very sentimental, conspicuous, elaborate, concise, beautiful words, sleek and graceful, elegant and gentle, satire in a scholarly form.

Her poetry often writes about nature, mostly in the afternoon, evoking feelings of silence and sadness. 

The scenes she describes in her poems are like watercolor paintings, dotted.

Moreover, strictly speaking, the scene in her poetry is not actually a scene, but a love. 

Her affection is often a painful nostalgia for the golden past that has gone and never returned. 

Therefore, people call her a nostalgic poet. 

Her poetry is also noted for another reason, it is extremely skillful art. 

The rules and regulations of poetry are strictly followed without causing a feeling of restraint or arrangement. 

Her verse is elegant, her words polished and carefully selected.

Above: Portrait of Nguyễn Thị Hinh, popularly known as Bà Huyện Thanh Quan (1805 – 1848)

Crossing Ngang Pass

Arriving at Ngang Pass at dusk

Grass trees mix with rocks, leaves mix with flowers.

Hunched below the foothills, a handful of woodcutters,

Scattered across the stream, a couple of market stalls.

Missing homeland rends the heart of the quail,

Loving home tires the mouth of the partridge.

Stopping to see, sky, mountains, water,

A private feeling of utter lonesomeness, myself with myself.

Highway 1 crosses the Gianh River over the Cau Gianh bridge.

The Gianh River (Sông Gianh) is a river in Quang Binh Province along Vietnam’s North Central Coast (Bắc Trung Bộ).

The river is 268 kilometres (167 mi) in length.

It was the border between ruling families during the partition of Vietnam following the Trinh-Nguyen War of the 17th century, serving to effectively divide the country between northern and southern regions.

The 17th parallel, used as the border between North Vietnam and South Vietnam from 1954 to 1975 was located just to the south, at the Ben Hai River in Quang Tri Province.

Boats can cross the river downstream, from Cua Gianh to Ba Don 6 km, to Dong Le town, Tuyen Hoa district is 47 km.

The upstream section from Khe Net back to the source is about 70–80 km long, with many waterfalls and rapids in the river bed. 

About 20 km upstream, rocks are scattered in the river bed. 

To Dong Tam, the river bed is about 80 – 90 metres wide, the largest is 110 – 115 metres. 

The section from Phu Hoa and Quang Tien continues to Ba Don town.

Above: Ba Don town market, Quàng Binh Province, Vietnam

The riverbed has five dunes, small islands in the river, of which the longest island is about 3, 8 km, the widest about 0.8 km. 

Right below Ba Don, the river bed is up to 1 km wide.

Above: Gianh River, Vietnam

Gianh River and Ngang Pass are geographical symbols of Quang Binh province. 

The upper part of Gianh River is named Rao Nay, another branch is Rao Son leading to Phong Nha Cave in Phong Nha Ke Bang National Park. 

The river mouth has a seaport called Cang Gianh.

Above: Song River (Rao Song) in front of Phong Nha Cave, Quàng Binh Province, Vietnam

If the Ngang Pass was the boundary between Dai Co Viet and Champa after the Vietnamese gained independence from 939 to 1069, then the Gianh River was the boundary of the Trinh-Nguyen dynasties between Dang Trong and Dang Ngoai (1570 -1786), with armed conflict for nearly half a century (1627 – 1672). 

Above: Gianh River, Vietnam

The main battlefield in the Bo Chinh region, Ngang Pass is associated with the legend of “Hoang Son Nhat Dia, Ten Thousand Dai Dung Body” by Trang Trinh. 

During the Trinh Nguyen war, the Trinh army stayed at the Ngang Pass.

Above: Ngang Pass, Vietnam

But the real boundary separating the North and the South of Vietnam was the Gianh River from 1627 to 1774.

The north bank of the River had Ba Don market where Trinh troops bought food. drink and other goods.

Above: Gianh River, Vietnam

In July 1885, King Ham Nghi (1871 – 1943), who was deposed by the French for lack of cooperation and launched an appeal to the people to revolt, the king’s army (“Help the King“) took refuge in the upper reaches of the River, a wilderness area. mountains and dense forests. 

It was there, in the small village of Ò, that he was arrested on 2 November 1888 and exiled to Algiers, where he died in 1943.

Above: Ham Nghi

Ham Nghi was Nguyen Phuc Ung Lich.

When he ascended the throne, he changed his name to Nguyen Phuc Minh.

After King Tu Duc died in July 1883, although the ministers Nguyen Van Tuong and Ton That Thuy held full power in dethroning one king after another, they were very passive in finding people to take the throne. 

Above: Tu Duc (1829 – 1883)

Before Ham Nghi’s reign, all three kings Duc Duc, Hiep Hoa and Kien Phuc, in turn, went against the path of the warlord faction or were lost early, becoming elements that could not be excluded from the troubled government.

Above: Tomb of Duc Duc (1852 – 1883), Long An Palace, An Lang, Hué Province, Vietnam

Above: Portrait of Hiep Hoa (1847 – 1883)

Above: Painting of Emperor Kien Phuc (1869 – 1884) dressed in military uniform

King Kien Phuc suddenly died while the situation was favorable to the war faction in the Hue court. 

After the King’s death, King Tu Duc’s second adopted son, Nguyen Phuc Ung Ky, should have ascended the throne, but Nguyen Van Tuong and Ton That Thuyet were afraid of establishing an older king who would lose power and the two men firmly advocated a king who supported their stance against the French, so they chose Ung Lich. 

Above: Nguyen Phuc Ung Ky (1864 – 1889)

This was a person qualified in terms of lineage, but who had not been contaminated by the rich life of the capital, contained the spirit of national pride and, most importantly, the two men could orient the King easily.

Ung Lich from a young age lived in poverty, with a rustic life with his biological mother, but was not raised properly like his two biological brothers in the Palace. 

Above: Thai Hoa Palace, Hué, Vietnam

When the messenger came to pick him up, the boy Ung Lich panicked and did not dare to accept the hats and robes offered. 

On the morning of 2 August 1884, Ung Lich was led between two lines of bodyguards, entered Thai Hoa Palace to celebrate the coronation of the Emperor to be named Ham Nghi. 

At that time, Ung Lich was only 13 years old. 

It is said that Ham Nghi ascended to the throne according to the will of the former King Kien Phuc.

However, in fact, Ham Nghi was established by warlords to the throne. 

In July 1884, after King Kien Phuc suddenly died, the court honored Ham Nghi to the throne. 

Above: Ham Nghi

Nuncio Pierre Paul Rheinart saw that Nguyen Van Tuong and Ton That Thuyet freely established themselves as kings, without consulting the French as they had agreed, so they sent troops to Hué to force the Nguyen Dynasty to ask for permission. 

Rheinart sent a note to the Hue court:

If the Southern dynasties establish anyone as King, they have to ask permission from France.”

Above: Flag of France

Nguyen Van Tuong and Ton That Thuyet had to make an application in Nom script, but the Nuncio refused, forcing it to be made in Chinese. 

The two men had to rewrite the application, the new Nuncio accepted and then went to the main door to the Palace to consecrate King Ham Nghi. 

Above: Coronation of King Ham Nghi

The first role that King Ham Nghi had to play, under the guidance of Ton That Thuyet, was to organize the reception of the French delegation from the Nuncio on the south bank of the Perfume River to Thai Hoa Palace to celebrate the King’s enthronement ceremony. 

This is the victory that the warring faction of the Hue court had achieved in defending the throne of Ham Nghi.

As for the French, after their claims and demands failed, they had to make concessions to avoid new troubles by accepting a fact that it had already happened.

At 9:00 a.m. on 17 August 1884 , the French delegation – including Colonel Guerrier, Ambassador Rheinart, Captain Wallarmé and 185 military officers – pulled up to the Imperial Citadel of Hué. 

Guerrier forced the Hué court to let the entire French army enter Ngo Mon by the middle way, which was the only way for the King to go.

Ton That Thuyet definitely refused. 

In the end, only three messengers could enter the main gate, the rest of the members went through the gates on both sides. 

Both the Hue court and the French delegation were in a disagreeable mood, but the ordination ceremony finally ended peacefully. 

When the French delegation left, Ton That Thuyet secretly let the troops close the main door at Ngo Mon, so the French delegation had to use the two side doors to return. 

Above: Ton That Thuyet (1835 – 1913)

Acknowledging this, Marcel Gaultier wrote:

King Ham Nghi has kept the sacredness of his subjects.

Unknowingly, the young King did something that had a resounding effect throughout the country:

With a determined will to be independent, and even though the French were stationed in Hué, the court still displayed a non-cowardly attitude.

The Council was rightly convinced that the people depended on the King’s attitude to follow, seeing it as an unspoken command against the French.

The following year of 1885, General de Courcy was sent by the French Government to Vietnam to assist in the establishment of a protectorate. 

General de Courcy wanted to go in and see King Ham Nghi, but he wanted all his troops, 500 men, to enter the main door, which was reserved for great guests. 

The royal court asked the French soldiers to go through the doors on the sides, that only generals could go through the main door in accordance with royal etiquette, but de Courcy refused.

Above: Henri Roussel de Courcy (1827 – 1887)

On the night of the 5th and 6th of July 1885, Nguyen Van Tuong and Ton That Thuyet, seeing that the French despised their King, decided to take action first:

They took the army and attacked the French camp at Mang Ca Fort.

In the morning, the French counter-attacked, the Nguyen army lost and fled, leaving Hué Citadel. 

Above: Hué Citadel, Vietnam

Ton That Thuyet went to the Palace to report the night battle and implored the young Emperor Ham Nghi and Tam Cung to go. 

Hearing that he had to leave the city, King Ham Nghi was shocked and said:

I didn’t fight anyone but I had to run.”

King Ham Nghi sat in the constantly wobbling palanquin, his head painfully hitting the wall of the palanquin many times.

Finally, the King had to lie down in a hammock for the stretcher soldiers. 

Nguyen Van Tuong sent people to bring King Ham Nghi to Quang Tri Citadel to take refuge. 

On the afternoon of 6 July 1885, the group arrived in Quang Tri. 

Above: Quàng Tri Citadel, Vietnam

Nguyen Van Tuong presented himself to the French army. 

General de Courcy gave Nguyen two months to find a way to bring the King back. 

Nguyen wrote to Quang Tri to ask for the King’s return, but Ton That Thuyet prevented the letter from reaching the King. 

After two months, the whole family of Nguyen Van Tuong was exiled by de Courcy to Con Dao, then taken to Tahiti Island in the Pacific Ocean. 

Some time after Nguyen died, his body was brought back to Vietnam. 

Above: Nguyen Van Tuong (1824 – 1886)

On 9 July 1885, under the pressure of Ton That Thuyet, King Ham Nghi had to go to Tan So.

Ham Nghi lived in Tan So and then retreated to remote communities. 

King Ham Nghi had to endure many hardships because he had to deal with mountains and forests and harsh weather, in the midst of countless deprivations, diseases, hunger and danger to his life. 

At Tan So, King Ham Nghi declared Can Vuong to call on scholars and people to rebel against the French to gain independence. 

The support, protection and enthusiastic participation of local people from Quang Tri to Laos as well as in Ha Tinh and Quang Binh showed Ham Nghi his own strength, so the King no longer felt as coerced as before. 

The King was trained by hardships to be patient and received the ordination with a very calm attitude.” 

Above: Ham Nghi

His uprising was very large, but because it was scattered everywhere, his force was not strong. 

The King twice went down to Can Vuong, including once sending a letter of prayer to Governor Van Quy of the Manchu Dynasty and many other edicts to mandarins and leaders of the anti-French movement. 

His name had become the flag of national independence.

From the North to the South, the people had emerged everywhere at the call of the exalted King.

During the resistance war of King Ham Nghi, King Dong Khanh and the three Empress Dowagers repeatedly sent letters calling for the King to return, but he firmly refused. 

The Governor General of France in Indochina, Paul Bert, also tried to establish Ham Nghi as King of the four provinces of Thanh Nghe Tinh Binh but failed. 

Above: Paul Bert (1833 – 1886)

The King often said that he would rather die in the forest than return to be a King and stay in its embrace

As the base of the Can Vuong movement, King Ham Nghi was sent away for his own protection.

Admiral Le Truc and Nguyen Pham Tuan divided the defense and attacked French forces in the region.

In September 1888, the treacherous Nguyen Dinh Tinh team surrendered to the French at Dong Ca Fort. 

Nguyen Dinh Tinh again lured Truong Quang Ngoc to surrender. 

Then Nguyen Dinh Tinh and Truong Quang Ngoc volunteered with the French to bring troops to round up King Ham Nghi. 

Late at night on 26 September 1888, King Ham Nghi was arrested while sleeping.

Ton That Thiep was stabbed to death. 

At that time, the King was only 17 years old and had been fighting the French for three years. 

The King pointed directly at Truong Quang Ngoc and said:

I would that you had rather killed me than to bring me out and hand me over to the West.”

Above: The arrest of Ham Nghi

From that night at the bank of Ta Bao Creek, Truong Quang Ngoc brought King Ham Nghi to Thuan Bai Fort on the afternoon. of 14 November 1888. 

The French army held a very solemn welcome to the King, but the King did not understand nor recognize himself as Ham Nghi. 

The lieutenant in command of the Bonnefoy army delivered Ton That Dam’s letter to King Ham Nghi, but the King threw the letter on the table and acted as if it had nothing to do with him. 

Admiral Thanh Thuy was sent by the French to visit the King, but the King pretended not to know. 

But when the French brought his former teacher Nguyen Nhuan to him, the King involuntarily stood up and bowed. 

Only then did the French rest assured that it was King Ham Nghi. 

Above: Ham Nghi after he was arrested by the French (1888)

From Thuan Bai, the French moved King Ham Nghi to the gates of Thuan An on 22 November 1888 .

At this time, the Hué court heard that Ham Nghi was arrested.

King Dong Khanh sent the Thua Thien mandarin and infantry to pick the King up and bring him back to Hué, but the French were afraid that the people would be agitated when they saw the face of the resistance king, so they informed the Institute of Secrets that King Ham Nghi had an unusual temper at this time, and there was an inconvenience in the business of transferral at that time. 

In fact, the French made a decisive decision that this resistance King would be exiled to Algeria in North Africa. 

Rheinart had informed him that the Queen Mother was seriously ill, and if the King wanted to visit her, he would send him home to meet her. 

Hearing that, King Ham Nghi replied: 

I am already in prison, the country is lost, I don’t dare to think about my parents and brothers anymore. 

Then he said goodbye to his own room.

After being deposed, the former Emperor was officially known as Duke Ung Lich. 

At 4 a.m. on 25 November 1888, King Ham Nghi was taken off the train at Lang Co.

Before leaving his homeland, the King looked ashore, unable to contain his emotions because of his own feelings and luck, and he burst into tears. 

Above: Lang Co Beach, Hué Province, Vietnam

From Saigon, on 13 December 1888, King Ham Nghi was taken to a ship named “Bien Hoa” across the ocean to North Africa. 

Because he was not used to the sea, the King suffered from constant seasickness but still did not utter a single comment or complaint. 

On Sunday afternoon, 13 January 1889, Ham Nghi arrived in Algiers, the capital of Algeria. 

At this time, he had just turned 18.

Above: Flag of modern Algeria

For the first ten days, Ham Nghi temporarily stayed at L’Hôtel de la Régence (Regent Court). 

After that, he was transferred to Villa des Pins (Pine Wood Villa) in the village of El Biar, 5 kilometers from the capital.

Above: Villa des Pins, El Biar, Algeria

On 24 January 1889, Governor-General Tirman of Algeria received and invited Ham Nghi to have a family meal. 

A few days later, through Governor-General Tirman, the former Emperor received news that his mother, Mrs. Phan Thi Nhan (second wife of King Kien Thai) had died on 21 January 1889 in Hué.

Above: Louis Tirman (1837 – 1899)

For the next ten months, Ham Nghi refused to learn French because he considered it to be the language of the nation that invaded his country.

He still used a scarf and a five-piece robe according to the old habits in his homeland. 

All communication was through an interpreter.

But later, seeing that the French in Algeria were friendly, much different from the French in Vietnam, so from November 1889 he began to learn French. 

A few years later, Ham Nghi could speak and write French very well.

Above: The French language in the world –

  • States where French is the majority native language, an official or administrative language (dark blue)
  • States where it is a minority or secondary language (light blue)
  • States that have a local francophone minority (green)

The following things have been changed since the publication of this map:

  • Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos are no longer colored in light blue, this is because French is not used there very much these days.
  • Mauritania, Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia have been colored light blue, because the French language is widely used.

There are even more French speakers in those countries where French is the official language.

  • The Western Sahara has been colored light blue, due to the increased use of French there.
  • A green square has been added in London to recognize the French-speaking minority there.

Ham Nghi also interacted with famous French intellectuals. 

In 1899, he visited Paris to see an exhibition of the painter Paul Gauguin. 

Above: French painter Paul Gauguin (1848 – 1903)

More than 100 years later, the painting Déclin du jour (Afternoon) of the former Emperor was discovered at an auction in Paris on 24 November 2010.

It was sold for €8,800.

In 1904, Ham Nghi was engaged to Ms. Marcelle Laloe (1884 – 1974), the daughter of the Chief Justice of the High Court of Alger. 

Their wedding was the cultural event of the Alger capital. 

Ham Nghi and Marcelle Laloe had three children:

  • Princess Nhu Mai (1905 – 1999)

Above: Princess Nhu Mai

  • Princess Nhu Luan (1908 – 2005)

Above: Princess Nhu Ly

  • Prince Minh Duc (1910 – 1990)

Above: Prince Minh Duc

On 14 January 1944, Ham Nghi died of stomach cancer at Gia Long Villa in Algiers. 

He was buried in Thonac, Salat-la-Canéda district, Nouvelle Aquitaine region.

He left with an unrelenting sadness in his mind. 

Above: Final resting place of Ham Nghi, Thonac, France

On 25 January 2009, a boat accident took place on the Gianh River, near Quảng Hải Village.

A wooden boat sank 20 meters from the shore in strong currents during windy conditions.

There were reportedly over 80 people on board, yet the boat was capable of carrying only 20.

The accident caused 42 deaths and five people were missing.

Above: Personal effects of some of the victims of the 2009 Gianh River boat accident

The Prime Minister of Vietnam sent his condolences to the victims’ families.

Above: Nguyen Tan Dung (Prime Minister of Vietnam: 2006 – 2016)

The government of Quảng Bình Province decided to cancel the fireworks supposed to take place at midnight the same day, on the eve of Têt, New Year’s Day in Vietnam.

Above: A Vietnamese family is making bánh tét (or bánh đòn, Vietnamese sticky rice cake) on the biggest traditional holiday of Vietnam, Tết, the Vietnamese Lunar New Year.

Bánh tét is a must traditional food that is made and eaten only on Tet holiday by families in the South and the Central of Vietnam.

In the North, they make bánh chưng.

Nowadays, this kind of food is still available sometimes at some shops and markets during the year, especially at markets in small towns.

However, the quality is not as good as the ones that made by families for themselves.

In the past, families usually made bánh tét on the day before Tết.

They cooked it and celebrated the New Year’s Eve at the same time.

Gathering together to make bánh tét is a very beautiful tradition of Vietnam.

It is not only the time to make bánh tét, but also the time for family members to bond and come together by talking, recalling memories, laughing together and celebrating the holiday spirit after a long hard working year that they might even not meet each other.

It is also a special time for the young to learn about Vietnamese traditions and the legend of bánh tét.

This way, historical values are preserved.

As it takes a lot of time and technique to make bánh tét, many families now choose to buy bánh tét instead of making it by themselves.

This somehow makes the beauty of the traditions and customs of Tet holiday in Vietnam not as how it used to be.

There is nothing to make sure that images like this will still available to catch in the future as life has been getting more and more modern and people tend to choose convenient things.

Most of the victims were women and children, including three women who were pregnant.

At least 36 passengers survived, a few by swimming to shore and others being rescued, but several are still missing.

 Above: Tất Niên offering (New Year’s prayer)

According to Luong Ngoc Binh, provincial Communist Party chief:

The waves on the river were big, the wind was strong and it was cold, so it was very difficult for people to survive.

The boat was crowded because people were trying to cross the river to get to the market.

They were rushing to buy things for the Lunar New Year festivities.

The tragedy happened on the eve of the Tet Lunar New Year, the biggest annual festival in Vietnam.

It was supposed to reunite families for celebration meals and to pray for good luck in the year ahead.

Above: Altar to the ancestors

According to Phan Lam Phuong, the governor of Quang Binh:

It’s a tragedy for the province, it should have been time to celebrate the Lunar New Year.

Above: Pham Lam Phuong (1937 – 2020)

The provincial government decided to cancel the Lunar New Year fireworks show.

It was one of the worst ferry accidents in Quang Binh province.

Above: Sinkhole 2 in Son Doong Cave – the world’s largest cave – Phong Nha-Ke Bang National Park, Quang Binh Province, Vietnam 

According to the Vietnamese News Agency, following the event, the Ministry of Transport suggested that the Chairman of Quang Binh region determine who was to blame for the tragedy.

Some families of the victims were upset that the construction of a bridge was supposed to be finished two years before the accident.

The bridge was to be constructed around one kilometer from the accident site and might have prevented the tragedy.

Phan Thanh Ha, the provincial police chief of Quang Binh said:

Authorities will give 10 million dong ($600) to the families of each victim.”

Gianh River is the biggest river in Quang Binh, so the residents call it the Mother River.

Gianh River’s water can be clear and still, but its average steepness is 19.2%.

So, throughout the flood season from September to November, the stream is brutal.

Above: Bridge over the Gianh River

According to the magazine Vietnam Heritage:

Quang Binh people say only those who have witnessed the crest of its floods know its power and ferocity.”

Hoàn Lão is the capital of Bo Trach District, situated in northeastern Quang Binh Province, 13 km north of Dong Hoi.

The township is located about 30 km east of Phong Nha-Kè National Park National Park, a UNESCO Heritage Site.

Hoàn Lão covers 5,70 km² and had a population of 7,372 in 2012.

Above: Hoan Lao (where National Highway 1A passes), Vietnam

Quach Xuan Ky (1926 – 1949) was a soldier of North Vietnam, who fought and died in the Vietnam/American War (1955 – 1975).

Quach Xuan Ky was born in Hoan Lao.

His father was Quach Nguyen Ham, a famous doctor in the region.

Quach Xuan Ky is the 5th child in the family.

From a young age he participated in Viet Minh activities with many peers. 

Quach Xuan Ky was very fond of poetry, especially poetry by Phan Boi Chau and To Huu.

Above: Quach Xuan Ky

Phan Boi Chau (1867 – 1940) was a famous Vietnamese scholar and revolutionary, active during the French colonial period.

In addition to his revolutionary career, he also wrote many books and newspapers, which were widely popularized among the people. 

In the Literary Dictionary, after introducing him and his literary career, it was also concluded that:

In the history of Vietnamese literature, it is not easy to find literature that has the power to move the masses to stand up for the great revolutionary struggle, like that of Phan Boi Chau. 

Today in that literature, in terms of thought and concept, this point or other may no longer be relevant, but the author’s enthusiastic heart is still valid heart.

He is considered to be one of the great writers of Vietnamese literature in the first half of the 20th century.

Above: Phan Boi Chau

To Huu, real name Nguyen Kim Thanh (1920 – 2002) was a poet and politician, who rose to the post of Permanent Deputy Prime Minister of Vietnam (1980 – 1986).

Above: To Huu

In 1969, he was assigned to be the last person to edit the eulogy at the funeral of President Ho Chi Minh. 

To Huu used his pen and enthusiasm to help make the eulogy better and go into people’s hearts:

Dear compatriots and soldiers nationwide, comrades and friends

Our beloved President Ho is no more!

This loss is enormous, this pain is infinite.

The international communist movement, the national liberation movement and the progress of all mankind have lost an outstanding soldier, a resilient and close friend.

Our people, our people, our country’s mountains and rivers gave birth to President Ho, a great hero, and it was he who made our nation radiant, human. our people and the rivers of our country.”

Above: Ho Chi Minh (1890 – 1969)

In To Huu, there is a beautiful unity between the revolutionary life and the poetic life, between the ideal in the heart and the verses on the tip of the pen. 

To Huu’s poetic journey is the historical journey of an entire nation. 

He is considered the flagship of revolutionary and resistance poetry, honored as the poet of the revolution“, “the poet of the people“, “the battle flag of the Vietnamese revolutionary poetry“, “who contributed to the construction of revolutionary poetry in Vietnam“, “a full life with Revolution – Art – Love“, “poet of revolutionary humanism“. 

During the two resistance wars, To Huu composed many poems to encourage the spirit of soldiers and people, associated with the entire history of the resistance. 

To Huu’s poetry is frugal and sweet, penetrating deeply into the souls of all generations, from the one who “fell into the forest of young men” or “who came to his poetry during his childhood“, preserved and promoted as a spiritual strength, a hidden cultural value in the people of the Ho Chi Minh era.

There is something reminiscent about the notion of revolutionary poets that finds me thinking of Yevgeny Zamyatin’s science fiction classic, We:

This is merely a copy, word by word, of what was published this morning in the State newspaper:

In another 120 days the building of the Integral will be completed.

The great historic hour is near, when the first Integral will rise into the limitless space of the universe.

A thousand years ago your heroic ancestors subjected the whole Earth to the power of the United State.

A still more glorious task is before you —the integration of the indefinite equation of the Cosmos by the use of the glass, electric, fire-breathing Integral.

Your mission is to subjugate to the grateful yoke of reason the unknown beings who live on other planets, and who are perhaps still in the primitive state of freedom.

If they will not understand that we are bringing them a mathematically faultless happiness, our duty will be to force them to be happy.

But before we take up arms, we shall try the power of words.

In the name of the Well-Doer, the following is announced herewith to all Numbers of the United State:

Whoever feels capable must consider it his duty to write treatises, poems, manifestoes, odes and other compositions on the greatness and the beauty of the United State.

This will be the first load which the Integral will carry.

Long live the United State!

Long live the Numbers!!

Long live the Well-Doer!!!

I feel my cheeks are burning as I write this.

To integrate the colossal, universal equation!

To unbend the wild curve, to straighten it out to a tangent — to a straight line!

For the United State is a straight line, a great, divine, precise, wise line, the wisest of lines!

I, D-503, the builder of the Integral, I am only one of the many mathematicians of the United State.

My pen, which is accustomed to figures, is unable to express the march and rhythm of consonance.

Therefore, I shall try to record only the things I see, the things I think, or to be more exact, the things we think.

Yes, we;

That is exactly what I mean.

“We” shall, therefore, be the title of my records.

But this will only be a derivative of our life — of our mathematical, perfect life in the United State.

If this be so, will not this derivative be a poem in itself, despite my limitations?

It will.

I believe,

I know it.

I feel my cheeks are burning as I write this.

I feel something similar to what a woman probably feels when for the first time she senses within herself the pulse of a tiny, blind, human being.

It is I, and at the same time it is not I.

And for many long months it will be necessary to feed it with my life, with my blood, and then with a pain at my heart, to tear it from myself and lay it at the feet of the United State.

Yet I am ready, as everyone, or nearly everyone of us, is.

I am ready.

In January 1945, at the age of 19, Quach Xuan Ky was admitted to the Communist Party of Vietnam.

Quach Xuan Ky joined the Viet Minh at a very young age, joined the Bo Trach District Uprising Committee from day one, and quickly became one of the leadership cores of the new government in his homeland after the August Revolution (1945) was successful.

In 1946, he was in charge of intelligence work in Bo Trach district.

In July 1948, Quach Xuan Ky was elected to the Standing Committee of the District Party Committee and then assumed the position of Secretary of the Bo Trach District Party Committee.

In February 1949, Quach Xuan Ky became a member of the Provincial Party Committee, Secretary of the Party Committee of Dong Hoi.

In the same year, he was captured by the French during a sweep. 

In prison, Quach Xuan Ky established and became the Secretary of the prison cell, resolutely resisting pressure from the French government. 

After a long period of torture and imprisonment without success, Quach Xuan Ky was publicly shot on 11 July 1949, at the age of 23.

Above: Images of the First Indochina War (1946 – 1954)

Quach Xuan Ky regularly wrote diaries, describing the process of revolutionary activities, fighting as well as love of life and people.

He had a deep love affair with a Dong Hoi girl named Hue.

His closest combat mate was Phan Khac Hy, a senior officer in the Vietnam People’s Army.

Quach Xuan Ky’s diary lines are still preserved to this day, including the following passages:

It is impossible for Vietnam to be enslaved again, just as the Vietnamese people cannot be oppressed and so why should we be in chains?

Right now, I think about that beautiful tomorrow. 

I believe in that beautiful tomorrow. 

Just as I’m sure I’m alive right now.

A Communist must have two working conditions in order to carry out the program:

1) Russian revolutionary spirit

2) America’s practical mind

Both parts are equally important, one cannot be missing from the other.

Above: Emblem of the Vietnam People’s Army

Quach Xuan Ky is remembered as a loyal soldier, a passionate and profound lover of his homeland.

In 1999, Quach Xuan Ky was posthumously awarded the title of Hero of the People’s Armed Forces by the State of Vietnam.

Today, his name has been given to streets of Dong Hoi, and streets and a secondary school in Hoan Lao.

Above: Dong Hoi, Vietnam

Đồng Hới is the capital city of Quang Binh Province on the north central coast of Vietnam.

The city’s area is 155.71 km2 (60.12 sq mi).

Population as per the 2017 census was 119,222. 

It is served by National Highway 1A, the Dong Hoi railway station and the Dong Hoi airport.

By road, Đồng Hới is 486 kilometres (302 mi) south of Hanoi, 195 kilometres (121 mi) south of Vinh, 160 kilometres (99 mi) north of Hué and 1,204 kilometres (748 mi) north of Ho Chi Minh City. 

Đồng Hới has a 12-km-long coastline with white sand beaches. 

Above: Fishing boats, Dong Hoi, Vietnam

It is the closest city to Phong Nha-Ke Bang National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, 50 km northwest.

Above: Logo of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization

I believe that Heidi did not visit Phong Nha-Ke Bang, even though I think she should have.

But as these are her travels and not mine so I will forego extolling the virtues of the Park and instead speak of Dong Hoi.

Above: View of Phong Nha-Ke Bang National Park, Vietnam

Almost entirely flattened in the Vietnam / American War’s bombing raids, Dong Hoi has risen from its ashes to become a prosperous and orderly provincial capital of over 160,000 people.

Tourists who stay here – Heidi did not – usually use the town as a base for the Phong Nha Caves, though there are plenty of accommodation options in Phong Nha itself.

However, Dong Hoi warrants a visit in itself, if only to step off the beaten track for a bit.

Above: Dong Hoi, Vietnam

Particularly pleasant is the esplanade along the west bank of the Nhat Le River, which leads to the East Sea and an attractive stretch of beach.

The city’s focal point is the remnants of a Nguyen-dynasty citadel – the only notable part is the restored south gate, where a lively riverside market has spring up and in summer vendors sell ice-cold glasses of sweet bean che.

Above: Eastern Gate of Dong Hoi Citadel

Crossing the Nhat Le River, you will find yourself on a small spit of land named My Canh.

This is also the name of the small beach sliding down the eastern edge of the isthmus.

As with sandy beaches up and down the land, My Canh has been developed as a resort area, though it attracts more Vietnamese than foreigners.

There is not much to do in Dong Hoi but relax, enjoy its beaches and drink a beer.

Get there now before the masses do.

Many hotels and tour groups operate tours to these nearby beaches and caves.

There are few tourists in Dong Hoi, so you will be greeted with many hellos.

Nhat Le Beach is nearby, but the focus of the town is very much on the river and canals.

Enjoy a massage by the blind while soft sultry saxophone music echoes in the corridor.

Not all the employees are actually blind, as they sometimes check and write text messages on their phones during the massage, but it has been claimed that they are all legally blind.

Good energetic massage by properly trained people. 

70,000 dong per hour.

Although Nhat Le Beach is nearby, the focus of Dong Hoi is on the River.

Accordingly, you will find the beach to be generally empty and abandoned, with just a few hotels, construction work, and piles of dirt.

The beach is pleasant, but the current is strong and the waves often too powerful for swimming.

Archaeological excavation in this area proved that humans lived in what is now Quảng Bình Province in the Stone Age.

Many artifacts, such as ceramic vases, stone tools, and china, have been unearthed in Quảng Bình.

In 1926, French archaeologist Madeleine Colani (1866 – 1943) discovered and excavated many artifacts in caves and grottoes in west mountainous areas of Quảng Bình.

She concluded that the Hoa Binh culture existed in this region.

Through carbon testing, the artifacts dated back to 10,509 (plus or minus 950) years ago.

Above: Madeleine Colani (1866 – 1943)

The Hum Grotto contains many stone tools and animal stones from an ancient human community.

Inside Khai Grotto, similar artifacts were found, including ceramics from the Dong Son culture.

Additionally, artifacts of the Stone Age were unearthed in grottoes in the Quảng Bình region.

Owners of these artifacts lived in the caves and grottoes and hunted for their food.

Human settlement in Đồng Hới can be traced 5,000 years back.

Many relics and remnants have been found in Bau Tro, a lake in the city, most of which date to the Stone Age.

Above: Bau Tro Lake, Dong Hoi, Vietnam

Around 2880 BCE, the site of modern Đồng Hới was a territory of the Viet Thuong tribe of Van Lang during the reign of King Hùng Virong (c. 2524 BCE).

Above: Vietnam, 500 BCE

Above: Statue of Hùng Vương at Hùng Temple, Tao Đàn, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

The site was a long-disputed territory between the Champa Kingdom and Dai Viet.

Above: Southeast Asia, 1400

It officially became Đại Việt territory in 1069  after Ly Thuong Kiet (1019 – 1105) took victory over Champaas a result of the Đại Việt-Champa War.

Above: Statue of Tuong Ly Thuong Kiet, Dai Nam Quoc Tu, Vietnam

The area ceased to be the southernmost of Đại Việt following the political marriage of the Tran Dynasty Princess Huyen Tran to Champa King Jaya Sinhararman III.

Thanks to this marriage, Đại Việt acquired lands (as dowry) of what is now Quang Tri Province and Thira Thien Hué Province.

Above: Statue of Huyen Tran (1289 – 1340), Hué, Vietnam

Above: Statue of Jaya Simhavarman III (1288 – 1307), Po Klong Garai Temple, Vietnam

During the time of the Trinh – Nguyen War (1558 – 1775), Vietnam was divided into two countries: Dang Trong (South) and Dang Ngoai (North) with the Gianh River as frontier line.

Đồng Hới was an important fortress of the southern Nguyen lords.

The Đồng Hới Wall was considered the barrier that protected the Nguyễn lords from the attack by the northern Trinh family.

Above: Vietnam, 1757

During the First Indochina War (1946 – 1954) (between the French and the Viet Minh), Đồng Hới Airbase was used by the French to attack the Viet Minh in north-central Vietnam and the Laotian Pathet Lao army in central and southern Laos.

Above: Dong Hoi Airport

During the Vietnam / American War (1955 – 1975), Đồng Hới was heavily devastated by bombardments from US B-52 bombers due to its location near the 17th parallel and the DMZ between North and South Vietnam.

Above: 1969 map of the Demilitarized Zone

On 11 February 1965, bombing destroyed much of the city.

Above: B-52 Stratofortress

The Tam Toa Church, a Catholic cathedral, was severely damaged.

Today the bell tower remains near the town center as a monument.

Above: Ruins of Tam Toa Church, Dong Hoi, Vietnam

On 19 April 1972, during a major North Vietnam offensive, a task force of four US ships were sailing off the coast of Vietnam — USS Oklahoma City, USS Sterett, USS Lloyd Thomas and USS Higbee.

They were attacked by three North Vietnamese MiG aircraft in the Battle of Dong Hoi.

In an attempt to surprise the task force, the MiGs came in low, described as “getting their feet wet“.

Despite the official stories, they did not surprise the task force, which had spotted them long before engagement range and were ready to shoot.

Two ships, Oklahoma City and Sterett, had anti-aircraft missiles, while Higbee and Lloyd Thomas were armed with dual purpose 5-inch (127 mm) guns.

All ships were at battle stations.

Above: A preserved Vietnamese MiG-17 used in the “Air Battle of Dong Hoi” on 19 April 1972.

Pilot Nguyen Van Bay B flew this aircraft and bombed the US Navy destroyer USS Higbee.

This city is the narrowest land of Vietnam (around 40 km from the east to the west).

After the fall of Saigon on 30 April 1975, Quảng Bình province was merged into Bình Trị Thiên province.

Above: The CIA helps evacuees up a ladder onto an Air America helicopter on the roof of 22 Gia Long Street, 29 April 1975, shortly before Saigon fell to advancing North Vietnamese troops.

In 1990, Bình Trị Thiên was once again separated into three provinces as it had been before.

Đồng Hới then became the capital of Quảng Bình province.

Above: Dong Hoi seen from the air

Đồng Hới is endowed with beautiful beaches with fine sand and clean water of Nhật Lệ.

Above: Nhat Le River

Da Nhay and Ly Hoa beaches (60 km north of the city) are popular tourist destinations.

Above: Da Nhay Beach

Above: Ly Hoa Beach

Bang Spa (hot mineral spring) is ideal for those who enjoy spa baths.

As previously said, the city is 50 km south of the Phong Nha-Ke Bang National Park, which is ideal for cave and grotto exploration and biological research activities.

Above: Boats for tourists in Phong Nha-Kẻ Bàng National Park

Đồng Hới is included in former battlefield tours where travellers can visit once-dangerous fields along the Annamite Range and the Ho Chi Minh Trail.

Above: Pu Mat National Park, Annamite Range, Vietnam

Đồng Hới is accessible by road, by rail or by air.

Above: National Road 1A

Above: Dong Hoi Railway Station yard

The city provides tourists with 98 hotels and guesthouses from 1 to 3-star hotels.

The cuisine includes seafood, the traditional “hot pot“, Vietnamese and European-style meals.

Above: Hot pot

In 2005, the city welcomed nearly 300,000 visitors.

A complex of ten golf courses, three clubhouses, more than 1,000 villas, a large resort hotel, a commercial village and a convention centre has recently been constructed in the seaside area of Dong Hoi.

Above: Dong Hoi, Vietnam

Đồng Hới Citadel (Thành Đồng Hới) is a citadel in the centre of the city. 

The Citadel is located in the vicinity of Hùng Vương Street.

Today all that remains of the Citadel is one rather unsympathetically restored Quảng Bình Gate (located close to the new museum) and a section of the original wall next to Highway 1.

Above: Dong Hoi Citadel

This is an ancient architecture and a military construction built nearly 200 years ago by order of King Gia Long. 

Above: King Gia Long (1762 – 1820)

The citadel was built of earth, located on an important land on the trans-Vietnam road, and near the sea (about 1,500 metres from Nhat Le Estuary).

Above: Dong Hoi Ancient Citadel (East gate)

By the reign of King Minh Mang, the Citadel was built with bricks and stones. 

Above: Minh Mang (1791 – 1841)

A large part of Dong Hoi Citadel was destroyed during the French colonial period. 

Above: Quang Binh Quan

The remnants of Dong Hoi citadel were destroyed by bombs of the US Air Force (USAF) in the late 1960s during the Vietnam War.

Dong Hoi Citadel still preserves many vestiges of two wars, imprinted with the unyielding will of the army and people of Quang Binh.

Today, the ruins of Dong Hoi citadel are only Quang Binh Quan (newly restored but criticized by public opinion as not the same as the old citadel) and a section of the wall located on National Highway 1 passing through Dong Hoi. 

In August 2005, Quang Binh Province restored the Citadel at a total estimate of 31 billion VND. 

Dong Hoi Citadel is one of 32 works that the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism included in the list of key cultural projects. 

The wall is built of bricks about 6 metres high. 

Now this relic only has a few sporadic sections in Dong Hoi, the most visible from the map is a moat around the citadel according to the ancient citadel architecture.

Above: Dong Hoi Citadel from above

At Bau Tro, relics were found, such as tools made of sea creatures (such as snails and shells) and stone. 

Research shows that they are about 5,000 years old. 

In the summer of 1923, two Frenchmen of the Institute of the Far East of the Ancients, Max and Depiruy, discovered the archaeological site of Bau Tro. 

At the end of the summer of 1923, geologist and archaeologist Etienne Patté organized the excavation of the Bau Tro site and published the research results in a report in the journal Bac Co Far East School titled:

On a site indicating Neolithic prehistory, piles of shells in Bau Tro, Tam Toa near Dong Hoi“. 

The collected artifacts are still stored at the Vietnam History Museum, consisting of:

  • 46 stone axes
  • 140 shards
  • two quartz stones
  • a stone tool used to repair presses
  • 14 bead mills
  • a net lead
  • some ocher
  • vertebrae of a fish
  • shells
  • pieces of pottery.

Above: Bau Tro Lake

Built during the war of Trinh Nguyen, Luy Thay Citadel was built by Lord Nguyen Phuc and ordered by Governor Dao Duy Tu to protect the border at Dang Trong. 

The Citadel is made of earth with a length of 8 km surrounding Dong Hoi Citadel. 

Thay can now be seen from Quach Xuan Ky Street street to the west of Phu Hai Ward.

This part of the dyke is now named Truong Dinh Street.

Above: Dong Hoi Citadel

Tam Toa Church was built in 1886. 

Poet Han Mac Tu was baptized here in 1912 with the holy name Francois Nguyen Trong Tri. 

In the eight years of 1964 to 1972, when the USAF bombed North Vietnam, Tam Toa Church was destroyed, leaving only the bell tower. 

Above: Tam Toa Church, Dong Hoi

Dong Hoi Hospital was donated by the Cuban government in 1975.

Above: Dong Hoi Hospital

Han Mac Tu (né Nguyen Trong Tri)(1912 – 1940) was a Vietnamese poet, the founder of the School of Poetry and a pioneer of Vietnamese modern romantic poetry.

Above: Banner of the Chaos School of Poetry

Han Mac Tu is known as the marshal of the school of chaotic poetry.

Han Mac Tu had a weak physique and a gentle simple personality.

He was studious and liked to make friends in the field of literature and poetry. 

Because his father Nguyen Van Toan worked as an interpreter and scribe, he often moved to many places and had many assignments, so Han Mac Tu attended many different schools.

Above: Han Mac Tu

He had a talent for writing poetry from the early age of 16. 

He decided to go to Saigon to start a business, when he was 21 years old;

Arriving in Saigon, he worked as a reporter in charge of poetry pages for the newspaper Cong Cong

Above: Ho Chi Minh City (formerly Saigon)

At that time, Mong Cam (1917 – 2007) in Phan Thiet also wrote poetry and often sent it to the newspaper. 

The two began to exchange letters.

He decided to go to Phan Thiet to meet Mong Cam. 

A romantic poetic love blossomed between the two.

Above: Han Mac Tu and his lovers in poetry: Thuong Thuong, Kim Cuc, Mong Cam, Ngoc Suong and Mai Dinh

According to Han Mac Tu’s family, around early 1935, they discovered signs of leprosy on his body. 

However, he did not care because he thought it was an insignificant leprosy. 

Until 1936, when he published the book “Country Girl“, Han travelled to Hué, Saigon and Quang Ngai.

When Tan Van newspaper decided to invite Han Mac Tu to be the editor, then he thought about his illness. 

He meant to completely cure a disease of the “itchy” type, so that he could go to Saigon to work as a newspaper without expecting an incurable disease. 

By 1939, Han Mac Tu was in severe pain. 

However, no one heard him groaning. 

He only screamed in his poems. 

Above: Rash on the chest and abdomen due to leprosy

Before Han Mac Tu entered Quy Hoa leprosy camp, Nguyen Ba Tin, the poet’s younger brother, said his brother’s illness was as follows: 

His skin is dry, but a little wrinkled in his hands, because he has to exert strength. strong to pull his fingers when holding a spoon to eat rice. 

Therefore, he looks like he is wearing a raw leather “glove”. 

His whole body is dry.

Nguyen Ba Tin, during a visit to Quy Hoa Hospital, visited Dr. Gour Vile – the director of Quy Nhon Hospital. 

The doctor said: 

Leprosy is difficult to distinguish. 

The medical community (at that time) did not know very well. 

Although the symptoms are the same, there are many things

The doctor insisted that leprosy could not be easily transmitted.

Above: The Wind Tomb, Quy Hoa Leprosy Camp, Quy Nhon, Vietnam

It is said that one day, Han Mac Tu went for a walk with Mong Cam in Phan Thiet, passing a cemetery with a newly buried grave when it rained. 

Suddenly he discovered red spots flying up from the grave. 

He went back to the motel, only to find out early in the morning that he was like that. 

Above: Phan Thiet, Vietnam

At that time, because of the misconception that this was a contagious disease, patients were often rejected, isolated, shunned, and even mistreated. 

Han Mac Tu was no exception. 

At this time, his family had to deal with local authorities because they have learned that he had an infectious disease, demanding that he be isolated from everyone. 

After that, his family had to hide him in many places.

In terms of treatment effectiveness, this was unscientific because he should have been brought to the place with the most adequate treatment conditions at that time, which was Quy Hoa Leprosy Hospital. 

Dr. Gour also said that from experience from leprosy camps, no patient can live after suffering for so many years. 

He blamed Han Mac Tu’s family for not sending the poet to the leper camp early. 

The doctor said that Han Mac Tu died because his internal organs were damaged too quickly because he took too many quack drugs before being hospitalized.

He died at 5:45 a.m. on 11 November 1940 at the age of 28.

Above: Signpost marker to the grave of Han Mac Tu

Above: Grave of Han Mac Tu, Ghenh Rang, Vietnam

Han Mac Tu’s life had a predestined relationship with the word Binh: born in Quang Binh, worked as a newspaper in Tan Binh, had a lover in Binh Thuan and died in Binh Dinh. 

He was known for his many love affairs, with many different women, that have left many marks on his poetry – some he had met, some he only communicated through letters, and others he only knew by their names.

There are many reviews and comments about Han Mac Tu’s poetic talent, here are some evaluations of famous poets and writers:

No one before, no one after, Han Mac Tu is like a comet passing through the sky of Vietnam with its dazzling tail.

I promise you that, in the future, those mediocrity and standards will disappear, and what remains of this period is Han Mac Tu.

(Poet Che Lan Vien)

Above: Ché La Viên (1920 – 1989)

It will not be possible to fully explain the phenomenon of Han Mac Tu if only using the poetic of romanticism and the influence of the Bible.

We need to study more the theory of symbolism and surrealism.

In Han Mac Tu’s surrealist poems, people cannot distinguish between the void and the real, the form and the void, the worldly and the other worldly, the visible and the invisible, the inner and the outer, the subject and the object, the emotional and the non-emotional world.

All the senses are mixed up, all the normal logic in thought and language, in grammar and poetry is suddenly turned upside down.

The poet has made the contrasts and combinations strange, creating a uniqueness full of amazement and horror for the reader.

(Literary critic Phan Cu De)

Above: Phan Cu De (1933 – 2007)

Han Mac Tu has about seven good songs, four of which have reached perfection.

The rest are genius verses.

These verses could not be written by anyone but Han Mac Tu.

(Poet Tran Dang Khoa)

Above: Tran Dang Khoa

In my opinion, there was a lot of poetry left in Han Mac Tu’s life.

He was a very talented person who made a worthy contribution to New Poetry. “

(Poet Huy Can)

Above: Huy Can (1919 – 2005)

A source of strange poetry, a vast and boundless garden from which the further away you go into it, the more chilling you become.

(Literary critic Hoai Thanh)

Above: Hoai Thanh (1909 – 1982)

A person who suffered so much, when we lived we indifferently forgot, now that we are gone, we gather around those who criticize and praise. 

Criticize or praise me, I see nothing cruel.

Above: Han Mac Tu

Many localities in Vietnam use his name to name streets such as:

  • Binh Dinh
  • Vung Tau
  • Da Nang
  • Dak Lak
  • Hué
  • Nghe An
  • Phan Thiet
  • Quang Binh
  • Thanh Hoa
  • Ho Chi Minh City

Above: Han Mac Tu

(A tip to travel writers:

Place names give you the flavour of the community.

California’s San Jose and La Jolla, New Orleans’ Bienville Street, Chartres Street and Beauregard Street, evokes the areas’ origins.

Above: San Jose, California

Above: New Orleans, Louisiana

Notice what they call their plazas and squares and how they name their streets.

Is the town laid out with First Street and Second Street intersecting A and B and C?

Are the streets, the squares, the gates, the areas named for famous people?

What kinds of famous people?

Politicians?

Generals?

Writers?

Artists?

Musicians?

Entertainers?

Millionaires?

Sometimes it is the date that is important – for example, Mexico City’s Avenida 16 de Septiembre (named for the Mexican Independence Day) or Buenos Aires’ Avenida 9 Julio (a crucial day in Argentina’s struggle for liberty). )

Above: Mexico City, Mexico

Above: Buenos Aires, Argentina

With images of inner expression, descriptive writing, delicate language, rich in associations, the poem This is Vi Da village is a beautiful picture of a country’s countryside, the voice of a person’s heart. life, love people.

Vi Da village sparkles with metaphorical colours: 

There is sunshine, there is moon waiting, there is smog has haunted the mind of the talented poet. 

Although he left life in a hurry, Han Mac Tu always loved people, loved life with all his passion, and had a thirst for life.

Vi Da village is the most gentle poem of Han Mac Tu in the collection of Poems Crazy

Because at this time, he was in a period of illness, insane pain both physically and mentally. 

His poetry is always screams of anger, choking.

Vi Da village is so beautiful, so complete, suddenly torn apart by a wind, a cloud, the Moon, the poet released his soul and hugged the shadow of a beautiful woman, and then finally doubted, asked who seems to wonder: “Who knows whose love is rich?”

So, isn’t it a harmonious and beautiful world, but also fragile, perceived by a poet carrying a monstrous disease, at a young age, still too earnest for the world? 

Under his pen, Vi Da became incredibly beautiful and poetic.

Under the eyes of Han Mac Tu, the landscape, no matter how small and insignificant, also became soulful, lively, and great.

The fragrance is magical like a miracle, so beautiful and poetic that everyone wants to visit this Vi Da village, that is full of love, light and whispers.

Love, light and whispers have worked together to create a miracle.

Han Mac Tu’s poetry is a complex phenomenon that is not easily unified in its assessment and interpretation. 

Vi Da village is such a poem.

Overall, the poem has an increasing movement towards the end. 

From the real world to the dream world. 

From the very beginning, the scene and the people of Vi village appear together as a vision in a dream.

The second stanza is full of fantasy.

The third stanza is full of dreams.

Because it is the product of a dream state, it is illogical on the surface, co-occurring and spontaneous, but it has deep logic:

The sound of a desperate, startled and painful love…

In 2001, the publishing house Arfuyen published an anthology of Han Mac Tu’s poetry into French, named Le Hameau des roseaux (Here is Vi Da village) translated by Hélène Péras and Vu Thi Bich.

Above: Han Mac Tu

Many languages have next to nothing translated into our own language.

There are in the world tiny tucked-away places where very little is written down at all.

Some governments don’t like to let works of art leak out to corrupt Westerners.

Most of us barely touch works by foreign language writers even if their works have been translated.

Most of us are literary xenophobes.

Our literary insularity has created within us a narrowness of mind, thought and perspective.

Above: State and University Library, Copenhagen, Denmark

Since Goethe first introduced the term Weltliteratur in the late 1820s, numerous would-be world readers have quailed in the face of the enormity and even ludicrousness of the task.

Above: Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749 – 1832)

What can one make of such an idea!

The sum total of all national literatures?

A wild idea, unattainable in practice, worthy not of an actual reader but of a deluded keeper of archives who is also a multimillionaire.

The most harebrained editor has never aspired to such a thing.“, exclaimed the critic Claudio Guillén in 1993.

Above: Claudio Guillén (1924 – 2007)

Back in 1964, French polyglot René Étiemble, who specialized in Arab and Chinese culture, was thrown into a cold sweat by the notion of trying to tackle all stories written everywhere ever.

I am immediately seized by a kind of panic terror.

What would such theoretical openness of spirit to all literatures, whether present or past, bring us given that any mind, however capacious we may imagine it, is limited by the average length of our lives?“, he confessed in a speech to the Fourth World Congress of the International Comparative Literature Association.

Above: René Étiemble (1909 – 2002)

The idea clearly niggled Étiemble, for he gave it some detailed thought:

Do the sum yourself:

Give yourself 50 years of life without one day of illness or rest, or altogether 18,262 days.

Rigorously take into account periods of sleep, meals, the obligations and pleasures of life and of your profession.

Estimate the time left to you for reading masterpieces with the sole purpose of finding out what precisely IS literature.

As I am extremely generous, I will grant you the privilege of reading every day – good ones as well as bad ones – one very beautiful book of all that are accessible to you in your own language and in the foreign languages you have mastered, in the original or in translation.

You know that it will take you more than one day to read “The Magic Mountain” or the “Arabian Nights”, but I also take into account that with a little bit of luck and zeal you might read in one day the “Hojoki”, the “Romancero gitano”, the “Menexenos” and “The Spirit of Conquest” by Benjamin Constant.

Above: Thomas Mann’s Der Zauberberg (The Magic Mountain)

Above: Benjamin Constant (1767 – 1830)

This will give you the couple of days extra you will need to read “And Quiet Flows the Don”.

Now, when measured against the total number of very beautiful books that exist in the world, what are 18,262 titles?

Sheer misery.

Above: Russian edition of Quiet Flows the Don by Mikhail Sholokhov (1905 – 1984)

One wonders what Étiemble would have made of today’s rate of publication, which, leaving aside the hundreds of thousands of books published every year, sees around 51 million websites added to the Internet annually and 100,000 new tweets going live every minute.

The truth is that the volume of printed words in the world has always been unreadable by a single individual.

By 1500. a mere 50 years after Gutenberg’s first printing press rattled into life in Mainz, some 27,000 titles had been churned out across Europe – considerably more than even Étiemble’s proposed regime could allow getting through in a single lifetime.

With covering all bases definitively off the menu, some element of choice has to come into the equation, which creates a new dilemma:

Because if no individual can have read all the books in the world, how can anyone be in a position to say that one text is more deserving of attention than another?

Above: Johannes Gensfleisch zur Laden zum Gutenberg (1400 – 1468)

The most powerful impression that anyone encountering Goethe’s comments on reading internationally is likely to take away is his impatience with national divisions and distinctions altogether.

Far from developing a concept of reading the world that might involve sampling literature from every country, Goethe was anxious to encourage his contemporaries to work towards “a common world literature transcending national limits“.

This, he thought, could be achieved by and could in turn promote exchanges between “the living, striving men of letters” of the age, such that they “should learn to know each other and through their own inclination and similarity of tastes, find the motive for corporate action“.

It was a conviction that stayed with him throughout his career spanning more than 73 years.

I am more and more convinced that poetry is the universal possession of mankind, revealing itself everywhere and at all times in hundreds and hundreds of men.

I therefore like to look about me in foreign nations and advise everyone to do the same.

National literature is now a rather unmeaning term.

The epoch of world literature is at hand.

Everyone must strive to hasten its approach.“, Goethe said in the final years of his life.

Above: Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

For me, world literature is whatever I can get my hands on, books that have reached me, books I have travelled to and have travelled with.

So, what is it that makes some stories cross national boundaries while others remain shut up in their local markets?

Some commentators have tried to maintain that quality is the key, that the litmus test for texts of any kind is whether they add value to the global community, in that it addresses and enriches all of humanity.

But when you look at which books actually do reach us, the idea that benefit to humanity should be the main criterion when it comes to assessing works from elsewhere is problematic.

Most of what we read does not fit unconditionally into that category of indisputable world greats.

There might be good books, indifferent books and even bad books in our literary diet.

There might be guilty pleasures and indulgences that we have no intention of expanding our souls or advancing world harmony by reading but we nonetheless enjoy all the same.

Indeed, it is estimated that 99.5% of all literature in non-canonical.

Above: Sistine Hall, Vatican Library

A man may protest against using popularity as a yardstick when it comes to defining great literature because the great majority of us are “lethargic, ignorant and of poor judgment“, the truth is that there are many things we want to read for reasons other than their objective excellence.

For better or worse, our imaginary worlds are made up of all manner of books.

Above: Scene from A Knight’s Tale (2001)

The other problem is that most writers don’t write with the aim of addressing the whole world – and if they do, they usually don’t succeed.

For most writers, an attempt to address everyone will usually result in reaching no one.

That which is written directly for the world will hardly be a work of art.

Indeed, it is often the specificity of a book that is the secret of its success.

For example, the beauty of Mongolian writer Galsan Tschinag’s The Blue Sky lies in the author’s ability to inhabit the thoughts of his protagonist, a young shepherd boy in the Altai Mountains and to thereby bring us into his hopes and dreams.

By feeling connected to and invested in Tschinag’s very distinctive creation, we can take the imaginative leap needed to recognise truths about the world, its capacity to connect the specific and the local with the universal.

Connection is the key here.

It is not enough for a book simply to go into the intricacies of a particular culture or situation in great detail.

In order to travel beyond its milieu, a book must have the ability to make its specificities meaningful and engaging to people with little knowledge of them, to “make one little room an everywhere“.

What makes books travel?

They speak at once to where they have come from and where they are going to.

They meld discovery and recognition – enlightening, flattering, challenging and comforting in varying degrees.

It is a stranger trying to communicate with another faraway stranger local truths and distinctions in a manner recognizable to the other.

Above: The bookmobile of the Ottawa Public Library, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

I stumble across books much in the manner of a blind man tripping over cobblestones.

I fall upon a writer’s work and embrace it as my own.

Books drive me to travel and travel drives me to books.

As I travel, I seek out works written by those who were once standing in the spot where I find myself.

For example, this past July, I travelled from Eskişehir to the Black Sea coast, visiting Zonguldak, Safronbolu, Amasra, Kastamonu, Sinop and Samsun.

Prior to packing my bags I read what I could of these places.

He who would bring home the wealth of the Indies must carry the wealth of the Indies with him.

So it is with travel.

A man must carry knowledge with him if he would bring knowledge home.

(Samuel Johnson)

Above: English writer Samuel Johnson (1709 – 1784)

One longs to see Alexandria after reading Lawrence Durrell.

Above: Lawrence Durrell’s The Alexandria Quartet

One promises oneself a trip to Spain after reading Don Quixote, Australia after Colleen McCullough’s The Thorn Birds, New England of Nathaniel Hawthorne, the Hawaii of James Michener.

Above: Flag of Spain

Above: Flag of Australia

Above: American writer Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804 – 1864)

Above: Location of New England (in red) in the United States of America

I longed to visit Kars in winter (and I did last February) just because of my enjoyment of Orhan Pamuk’s Snow.

Above: Turkish edition of Orhan Pamuk’s Snow

Above: Kars, Türkiye

Some of the world’s best travel guides are Charles Dickens and Mark Twain, Ernest Hemingway and Joseph Conrad, Robert Louis Stevenson and Pearl Buck, Somerset Maugham and Charles Darwin, Rudyard Kipling and Jack London, Herman Melville and John Steinbeck, just to name a few.

Above: English writer Charles Dickens (1812 – 1870)

Above: American writer Samuel Clemens (aka Mark Twain) (1835 – 1910)

Above: American author Ernest Hemingway (1899 – 1961)

Above: Polish writer Joseph Conrad (né Józef Teodor Konrad Korzeniowski)(1857 – 1924)

Above: Scottish novelist Robert Louis Stevenson (1850 – 1894)

Above: American writer Pearl Buck (1892 – 1973)

Above: English writer W. Somerset Maugham (1874 – 1965)

Above: English naturalist Charles Darwin (1809 – 1882)

Above: Indian-born English writer Rudyard Kipling (1865 – 1936)

Above: American writer John Chaney (aka Jack London) (1876 – 1916)

Above: American writer Herman Melville (1819 – 1891)

Above: American writer John Steinbeck (1902 – 1968)

My travels to the Black Sea were determined by time and money, but my choices were decided by my reading and research.

I learned that Zonguldak is more than its port and its coal, but is also famous for footballer Ergün Penbe, entertainer Murat Boz and entrepreneur Nilgün Efes.

Above: Zonguldak, Türkiye

Above: Turkish footballer Ergün Penbe

Above: Turkish singer Murat Boz

Above: Turkish entrepreneur Nilgun Efes

Safronbolu is more than Ottoman buildings and saffron trading, it was home to 17th century spiritualist Cinci Hoca – Think of an Ottoman Rasputin. – Grand Vizier Izzet Mehmet Pasha, sports writer and former wrestling association president Ali Gümüş, and film producer Türker İnanoğlu.

Above: Safronbolu, Türkiye

Above: Tomb of Izzet Mehmet Pasha (1743 – 1812), Safronbolu, Türkiye

Above: Turkish film producer Türker İnanoğlu

Above: Turkish journalist Ali Gümüş (1940 – 2015)

Amasra is more than its castle and coal.

Above: Amasra, Türkiye

It was mentioned (as Sesamus) by Homer is his Iliad and was administered by avid letter-writer the Roman Pliny the Younger.

Above: Bust of Greek author Homer (8th century BCE), British Museum, London, England

Above: Statue of Roman writer Pliny the Younger (61 – 113), Cathedral of Santa Maria Maggiore, Como, Italy

Kastamonu is more than Ottoman mansions, rose jam, hot sauce and lamb kebab.

Above: Kastamonu, Türkiye

It was visited by the Berber explorer Ibn Battuta (1304 – 1369) (who travelled more than any other explorer in pre-modern history, totalling around 117,000 km (73,000 mi), surpassing Zheng He’s 50,000 km / 31,000 miles and Marco Polo’s 24,000 km /15,000 miles), noting it as “one of the largest and finest cities, where commodities are abundant and prices low.

He stayed 40 days.

Above: 1878 illustration by Léon Benett from Jules Verne’s book Discovery of the Earth showing Ibn Battuta (right) and his guide in Egypt

Above: Statue of Chinese explorer Zheng He (1371 – 1435), Stadthuys Museum, Malacca City, Malaysia

Above: Italian explorer Marco Polo (1254 – 1324) in Tartar costume

Türkiye’s Dress Code Revolution started on 23 August 1925, when Kemal Atatürk made his historical speech during his visit to Kastamonu.

Above: Mustafa Kemal Atatürk (1881 – 1938)

(Beginning in the fall of 1925, Atatürk encouraged the Turks to wear modern European attire.

He was determined to force the abandonment of the sartorial traditions of the Middle East and finalize a series of dress reforms, which were originally started by Mahmud II (1785 – 1839).

The fez was established by Sultan Mahmud II in 1826 as part of the Ottoman Empire’s modernization effort.

The Hat Law of 1925 introduced the use of Western-style hats instead of the fez.

Atatürk first made the hat compulsory for civil servants. 

The guidelines for the proper dressing of students and state employees were passed during his lifetime.

Many civil servants adopted the hat willingly.

In 1925, Atatürk wore a Panama hat during a public appearance in Kastamonu, one of the most conservative towns in Anatolia, to explain that the hat was the headgear of civilized nations.

The last part of reform on dress emphasized the need to wear modern Western suits with neckties as well as Fedora and Derby-style hats instead of antiquated religion-based clothing such as the veil and turban in the Law Relating to Prohibited Garments of 1934.

Even though he personally promoted modern dress for women, Atatürk never made specific reference to women’s clothing in the law, as he believed that women would adapt to the new clothing styles of their own free will.

He was frequently photographed on public business with his wife Latife Usakligil, who covered her head in accordance with Islamic tradition.

He was also frequently photographed on public business with women wearing modern Western clothes.

But it was Atatürk’s adopted daughters, Sabiha Gökçen and Afet Inan, who provided the real role model for the Turkish women of the future.

He wrote:

The religious covering of women will not cause difficulty.

This simple style of head covering is not in conflict with the morals and manners of our society.”

Above: Atatürk with his Panama hat just after his Kastamonu speech in 1925

Ottoman poet Latifi (1491 – 1582) was born in Kastamonu and is known for his Memoir of the Poets (which narrated the life and work of around 300 poets of the period from 1421 until 1543) and Qualities of Istanbul (which gives a historical overview on the city of Istanbul, intertwined with geographical data, and information on the city’s neighborhoods, architecture, and social life).

Above: Illustration of Latifi

Greek musician Iovan Tsaous (1893 – 1942) was also born here and is particularly noted for the unique instruments he played, that were custom-built for him.

Above: Iovan Tsaous

Oğuz Atay (1934 – 1977) was born nearby in the town of İnebolu and is known as a pioneer of the modern novel in Turkey.

His first novel, The Disconnected, appeared in 1972.

Never reprinted in his lifetime and controversial among critics, it has become a best-seller since a new edition came out in 1984.

It has been described as “probably the most eminent novel of 20th century Turkish literature”.

I have been unable to obtain an English translation, but I nevertheless bought Tutunamayanlar in the original Turkish as its description intrigued me.

The book, rather than presenting a specific event, consists of impressions, associations, satires, details and spiritual analyses.

Learning that his friend Selim Işık committed suicide, the protagonist Turgut Özben tries to trace Selim’s past, whom he thinks he neglected, and to get to know him through people Selim knows. 

The image of Selim, who shows a different side to each person, will become clear to the reader and Turgut as a result of Turgut talking to these people. 

There are many people in the novel, but each of them is actually a person in Selim’s life and all the stories illuminate Selim Işık. 

Selim Işık is the symbol of the thinking and questioning person, and therefore he could not hold on to life and became disconnected, one of those who cannot hold on.

Above: Bust of Oğuz Atay, İnebolu, Türkiye

Sinop is more than just its harbour’s northernmost location on the Black Sea.

Above: Sinop, Türkiye

Named after the mythical Amazon Queen Sinope, she attracted the attention of Zeus who promised her anything she desired in return for her favours.

Her request was for eternal virginity.

Zeus uncharacteristically played the gentleman and complied.

Above: Sinope

Strabo mentioned Sinop and connected its mythical founder with the legendary Jason and the Argonauts.

Above: Greek geographer Strabo (64 BCE – 24 CE)

Above: Poster from the film Jason and the Argonauts (1963)

Julius Caesar established a colony here.

Above: Bust of Julius Caesar (100 – 44 BCE), Archaeological Museum, Torino, Italy

One of the Roman Republic’s fiercest opponents Mithridates VI Eupator was born here.

Above: Bust of Mithridates VI (135 – 63 BCE), Louvre Museum, Paris, France

It was also the birthplace of Diogenes and Diphilus and Marcion.

Above: Greek philosopher Diogenes (in the barrel) (412 – 323 BCE)

Above: Bust of Greek poet Diphilus (342 – 291 BCE)

Above: Illustration of Christian heretic Marcion of Sinope (85 – 160)

Marcion preached that God had sent Jesus Christ, an entirely new alien god, distinct from the vengeful God of Israel who had created the world.

Ibn Battuta visited the city and stayed for 40 days.

He noted it was “a superb city which combines fortification with beautification“.

Above: Sinop, Türkiye

In November 1853, at the start of the Crimean War (1853 – 1856), in the Battle of Sinop, the Russians, under the command of Admiral Nakhimov, destroyed an Ottoman frigate squadron in Sinop, leading Britain and France to declare war on Russia.

Above: Battle of Sinop, 30 November 1853

Sinop hosted a US military radar station that was important for intelligence during the Cold War era.

Ayancik Base was closed in 1992.

Above: Ayancik Radar Station

The list of Sinop’s noteworthy people is long, so I will name only one more.

Among the poets who can be called the last generation of syllabic poetry, Ahmet Muhip Dıranas (1909 – 1980) was a poet who was closest to contemporary Western poetry (Baudelaire, Verlaine) and still has a long-lasting influence on poets a couple of generations after him, even with his small number of poems. 

He wrote little, published sparsely, and published his poems into a book almost fifty years after he started poetry (1974).  

He wrote unforgettable poems with an unconventional pattern of sayings, keeping within the limits of syllabic meter, but changing the places of stop and emphasis, which catches the modernity in tradition.

His writing has high therapeutic (associative) power, for Diranas was at peace with his homeland, people and nature. 

In his poems, love, nature, death, memories are given in a shallow and thought-provoking way.

His Fahriye Abla (Sister Fahriye) poem is one of the most famous poems of Turkish literature, showing the feelings of an adolescent boy towards Fahriye, the beautiful and beloved daughter of the older neighbor, told with details from the neighborhood and Fahriye’s life.

Samsun is more than simply the place where Mustafa Kemal Atatürk began the Turkish War of Independence in 1919.

It is more than its port and its shipbuilding, more than its alleged illegal exporting of Ukrainian coal to Russia, more than its medical devices, furniture, tobacco products, chemicals, automobile spare parts and flour mills.

Above: Images of Samsun, Türkiye

Samsun has as well a long list of notable people who were either born here and/or made their homes here.

I will mention only three names:

A.I. Bezzerides (1908 – 2007), born in Samsun, was an American novelist and screenwriter, best known for writing films noir and action motion pictures, especially several of Warner Brothers’ “social conscience” films of the 1940s.

Above: Albert Isaac “Buzz” Bezzerides

Abdülkadir “Demirkan” Pirhasan (1919 – 2016), known by his pen name as Vedat Türkali, was a Turkish screenwriter, novelist, playwright, intellectual and teacher.

Türkali wrote more than 40 screenplays, four theatre plays and eight novels throughout his career since 1958. 

His novels are prominent literary works in modern Turkish literature.

He is often recognized one of the greatest writers in the history of Turkish literature.

He was detained 51 times over his controversial writings and political movements.

Türkali primarily wrote about different aspects of issues, ethnic and minority groups, including Hamidives, Armenians, Kurds, social issues, Turkish politics and literature.

He covered the Armenian Genocide in his writings, making him the first novelist in the history of Turkish literature who wrote about the conflicts involving Armenians and Turkish.

Above: Vedat Türkali

Xenophon Akoglou (1895 – 1961), born in Samsun, was a Greek folklore writer, known as well by his nickname Xenos Xenitas.

Above: Xenophon Akoglou

The point of my digression from Heidi‘s wild motorcycle ride down the coast of Vietnam to my discoveries along the shore of Türkiye’s Black Sea is to illustrate that a little reading and research brings life to the places which seem to be merely names on a map or fast fading blurs as we speed past them.

A little examination of our own lives creates the need to express ourselves.

I am, at best, a traveller.

Above: Your humble blogger

Heidi is, at present, a travelling student.

Wherein I hone my talents as a wordsmith, Heidi is a musician, studying music in Zürich as I type these words.

As she reads these words, as my poetic friend (aforementioned at the start of this post) reads these words, it is my hope that they construct their lives according to their needs to express themselves: my friend through words, Heidi through her music.

They need to observe nature, both wild and human.

Take refuge and comfort in life.

Seek out the joy, the richness, the incomparable greatness.

View your memories as both blessings and lessons.

What does this day have to teach me?

What does this place have to teach me?

And this above all else:

Live long and prosper.

Above: American actor Leonard Nimoy (1931 – 2015) as Spock, Star Trek (1966 – 1969)

I do not know what my poetic friend will do next.

I do know that Heidi and her travelling companion carried on that day to Hué, which is deserving of a blogpost of its own.

Heidi would then continue travelling down the coast of Vietnam until…..

Well, that is another story for another time.

Suffice to say, that unbeknownst to her the places she sped by were filled with stories and inspiration for many a tune just waiting to be expressed.

It is my wish that she sees the magic of her memories and the beauty of the two Swiss cities wherein she presently lives.

I am optimistic, for I know that this magic and beauty are also part of her.

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Rough Guide to Vietnam / Steve Biddulph, Manhood / Ann Morgan, Reading the World / Rainer Maria Rilke, Letters to a Young Poet / Esther Vilar, The Manipulated Man / Louise Purwin Zobel, The Travel Writer’s Handbook

The still centre

Goodbye, Farewell and Amen, Part Three

Eskişehir, Turkey, Wednesday 23 December 2021

Above: Porsuk River bridge, Eskişehir, Turkey

I have friends and family who occasionally ask me:

Where is the novel we know you can write?

I stutter and stammer my response, for the answer is never as easy to express as the question, so let me begin to explain myself by first referring to other glorious writers who have come before me as I emerge blinking and blind into the light of day.

Get Started in Creative Writing by Stephen May | Goodreads

There are three rules for writing the novel.

Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.

(W. Somerset Maugham)

Maugham photographed by Carl Van Vechten in 1934
Above: William Somerset Maugham (1874 – 1965)

This is true.

For it is not so much as the way a writer writes, for I think I can on occasion string words together as crudely as a garland of popcorn on a Yuletide tree.

How to Make a Popcorn Garland - DIY Old-Fashioned Christmas Garland

What’s writing really about?

It’s about trying to take fuller possession of your life.

(Ted Hughes)

Ted Hughes.jpeg
Above: Ted Hughes (1930 – 1998)

How I write is significant, certainly, but the why I write matters more.

You are miming the real thing until one day the chain draws unexpectedly tight and you have dipped into the waters that will continue to entice you back.

You have broken the skin on the pool of yourself.

(Seamus Heaney)

Heaney in 1982
Above: Seamus Heaney (1939 – 2013)

Writing, for me, is an intimate act, privately created for public perusal.

It is closely intertwined with notions of perception, personality, morality and possibility.

Writing is akin to serendipity.

I never know what wonderful and/or terrible thing I will accidentally discover about myself and the humanity that binds me to others.

The Three Princes of Serendip: New Tellings of Old Tales for Everyone: Al  Galidi, Rodaan, Aalders, Geertje: 9781536214505: Amazon.com: Books

Writing is a choice to examine the choices I have made in my life.

And this revelation leaves me as exposed as a stripper inside a congregation of the righteous.

Upside Down Quasi-Rastafarian Stripper Pole Crucifix at St… | Flickr

But this is an exposure far more intimate than that of an overweight scarred aging man’s body, but rather it is the cross-sectional microscopic examination of the contents of my heart, my mind, my soul.

Compound Microscope (cropped).JPG

There are strange tales told beneath the Arctic sun by the men who moil for gold,

The Arctic trails have their secret tales that would make your blood run cold,

The Northern Lights have seen queer sights but the strangest they ever did see….

(Robert W. Service)

Service c. 1905
Above: Robert William Service (1874 – 1958)

….was the night in the room of shadows of gloom when I revealed the real me.

Dark Room Work In Progress by damenFaltor on DeviantArt

The winds of opinion can be as cold as a “three dog night” in Tuktoyaktuk.

Three Dog Night - Three Dog Night.jpg
Above: Three Dog Night is an American rock band formed in 1967, with founding members consisting of vocalists Danny Hutton, Cory Wells (1941 – 2015), and Chuck Negron. This lineup was soon augmented by Jimmy Greenspoon (1948 – 2015)(keyboards), Joe Schermie (1946 – 2002)(bass), Michael Allsup (guitar), and Floyd Sneed (drums). The band had 21 Billboard Top 40 hits between 1969 and 1975, with three hitting number one. Three Dog Night recorded many songs written by outside songwriters, and they helped to introduce mainstream audiences to writers such as Paul Williams (“An Old Fashioned Love Song“) and Hoyt Axton (1938 – 1999)(“Joy to the World“). The official commentary included in the CD set Celebrate: The Three Dog Night Story, 1965 – 1975 states that vocalist Danny Hutton’s girlfriend, actress June Fairchild (1946 – 2015)(best known as the “Ajax Lady” from the Cheech and Chong movie Up In Smoke) suggested the name after reading a magazine article about Aboriginal Australians, in which it was explained that on cold nights they would customarily sleep in a hole in the ground while embracing a dingo, a native species of wild dog. On colder nights they would sleep with two dogs and, if the night were freezing, it was a “three dog night“.

Above: Trans Canada Trail sign in Tuktoyaktuk, Northwest Territories, Canada

And so an exposed psyche feels hesitant at times.

Sentences sentence me as the testimony of the sum and signature of my person, the deepest reflection of an identity undefined and undefinable crawling haltingly from the cocoon of my consciousness, is read against me.

Each word is made of Roman characters chiselled from the frozen fortress that protects me from myself.

Fortress Around Your Heart Sting UK 12-inch.jpg

My mind is relentless with endless discussion, examination, testing, moulding and learning.

Layers of tone and texture make a man and could, should make a solid story.

What’s going to happen?

To whom?

When?

Where?

Why?

How?

What’s the story?

My novel is much like my life.

Much, God willing, left to be written.

Writing a Novel : Richard Skinner : 9780571340460

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Sunday 28 February 2021

Above: Landschlacht, Switzerland

Reading and writing are two sides of the same coin, but it is not only what you read that is important, it is how you read as well.

As to what I read, this is a combination of serendipity for new literature (at least new for me) and a nostalgic return to old previously read works.

Serendipity poster.jpg

It has been suggested that when starting to read a novel for the first time or re-reading an old favourite that the reading writer should try to view it as an editor would, looking “through” the text in X-ray fashion.

Reading books in this way allows you to examine a narrative closely, locating and identifying dee p structure and embedded themes.

Buy The Original X-ray Spex - Amazing X-ray Vision! [Toy] Online in Turkey.  B001DBEARY

How does the writer bring their themes to life?

What most appealed to you about the story?

How was that dramatized in the narrative?

It has been suggested that we should try to begin reading not just for pleasure, but also for ideas.

Reading in this way can be a great source of inspiration.

You should not hesitate to use all the stimulation and motivation to kickstart your own work.

Reading Like a Writer: A Guide for People Who Love Books and for Those Who  Want to Write Them: Prose, Francine: 9780060777050: Books - Amazon.ca

A work is eternal, not because it imposes a single meaning on different men, but because it suggests different meanings to a single man.”

(Roland Barthes)

Roland Barthes Vertical.jpg
Above: Roland Barthes (1915 – 1980)

It is good to read as widely as possible – especially outside your race, class and gender.

The reading of other writers and noting how they write is one of the least expensive and gentlest schools of learning of all.

Required reading: The books that students read in 28 countries around the  world |

That exploration of extensive reading is done through the search of each calendar date and the subsequent revelation of authors who have lived, published or died on that date.

World Writers Day Literature Holiday Isolated Icon Books Stock Vector -  Illustration of antique, learning: 140479181

Which, on this day of days, has led me to Stephen Spender…..

Spender in 1933
Above: Stephen Spender (1909 – 1995)

History is the ship carrying living memories to the future.

(Stephen Spender)

Above: Bluenose postage stamp of 1929

Stephen Spender was a member of the generation of British poets who came to prominence in the 1930s, a group—sometimes referred to as the Oxford Poets — that included W.H. Auden, Christopher Isherwood, C. Day Lewis, and Louis MacNeice.

From top left to bottom right: Oxford skyline panorama from St Mary's Church; Radcliffe Camera; High Street from above looking east; University College, main quadrangle; High Street by night; Natural History Museum and Pitt Rivers Museum
Above: Images of Oxford, England

In an essay on Spender’s work in Chicago Tribune Book World, Gerald Nicosia wrote:

While preserving a reverence for traditional values and a high standard of craftsmanship, these poets turned away from the esotericism of T.S. Eliot, insisting that the writer stay in touch with the urgent political issues of the day and that he speak in a voice whose clarity can be understood by all.

Logo of the Chicago Tribune

Spender’s numerous books of poetry include: 

  • Dolphins (1994)

Dolphins by Stephen Spender

  • Collected Poems, 1928 – 1985

Collected Poems 1928-1953 | Stephen SPENDER

  • The Generous Days (1971)

The Generous Days | Stephen Spender | Books Tell You Why, Inc

  • Poems of Dedication (1946)

Poems of Dedication by Stephen Spender: Near Fine Hardcover (1947) 1st  Edition, Signed by Author(s) | Sellers & Newel Second-Hand Books

  • The Still Centre (1939)

The Still Centre | Stephen SPENDER

Stephen Spender was born on 28 February 1909 in Kensington, London, to journalist Harold Spender and Violet Hilda Schuster, a painter and poet, of German Jewish heritage.

St Mary Abbots, Kensington High Street, London W8 - geograph.org.uk - 1590248.jpg
Above: St. Mary Abbots, Kensington High Street, London, England

Violet Hilda Schuster Spender (1877-1921) - Find A Grave Memorial

When a child, my dreams rode on your wishes,
I was your son, high on your horse,
My mind a top whipped by the lashes
Of your rhetoric, windy of course.

On his father in “The Public Son of a Public Man“, as quoted in Time magazine, 20 January 1986

Above: Harold Spender (1864 – 1926)

My Parents

My parents kept me from children who were rough
Who threw words like stones and wore torn clothes
Their thighs showed through rags they ran in the street
And climbed cliffs and stripped by the country streams.

I feared more than tigers their muscles like iron
Their jerking hands and their knees tight on my arms
I feared the salt coarse pointing of those boys
Who copied my lisp behind me on the road.

They were lithe they sprang out behind hedges
Like dogs to bark at my world. They threw mud
While I looked the other way, pretending to smile.
I longed to forgive them but they never smiled.

English Literature Summaries: Summary of My Parents by Stephen Spender

He went first to Hall School in Hampstead and then at 13 to Gresham’s School, Holt, and later Charlecote School in Worthing, but he was unhappy there.

Contact Us | The Hall School
Above: Hall School, Hampstead, North London, England

The Old Greshamian Club | Gresham's School – The Old Greshamian Club
Above: Gresham’s School, Holt, Norfolk, England

Readers share memories of former junior school in Worthing | Shoreham Herald
Above: Charlecote Junior School, Worthing, West Sussex, England

An Elementary School Classroom in a Slum

Far far from gusty waves these children’s faces.
Like rootless weeds, the hair torn round their pallor:
The tall girl with her weighed-down head. The paper-
seeming boy, with rat’s eyes. The stunted, unlucky heir
Of twisted bones, reciting a father’s gnarled disease,
His lesson, from his desk. At back of the dim class
One unnoted, sweet and young. His eyes live in a dream
Of squirrel’s game, in tree room, other than this.

On sour cream walls, donations. Shakespeare’s head,
Cloudless at dawn, civilized dome riding all cities.
Belled, flowery, Tyrolese valley. Open-handed map
Awarding the world its world. And yet, for these
Children, these windows, not this map, their world,
Where all their future’s painted with a fog,
A narrow street sealed in with a lead sky
Far far from rivers, capes, and stars of words.

Surely, Shakespeare is wicked, the map a bad example.
With ships and sun and love tempting them to steal —
For lives that slyly turn in their cramped holes
From fog to endless night? On their slag heap, these children
Wear skins peeped through by bones and spectacles of steel
With mended glass, like bottle bits on stones.
All of their time and space are foggy slum.
So blot their maps with slums as big as doom.

Unless, governor, inspector, visitor,
This map becomes their window and these windows
That shut upon their lives like catacombs,
Break O break open till they break the town
And show the children to green fields, and make their world
Run azure on gold sands, and let their tongues
Run naked into books the white and green leaves open
History theirs whose language is the sun.

Primary school classroom | Primary school classroom, Elementary school  classroom, English projects

On the face of it, Stephen’s childhood in Hampstead and Norfolk couldn’t have been more privileged.

His mother, Violet, came from a wealthy Anglo-German Jewish family called Schuster.

Star of David.svg
Above: Star of David, symbol of Judaism

His father, Harold, was a tireless campaigning journalist whose friends numbered Henry James and Lloyd George.

James in 1913
Above: American-British writer Henry James (1843 – 1916)

David Lloyd George.jpg
Above: British Prime Minister David Lloyd George (1863 – 1945)

(Visiting the latter in Downing Street, Harold took so long about it that young Stephen, waiting in a taxi outside, was forced to relieve himself out of the back window).

10 Downing Street. MOD 45155532.jpg
Above: The Prime Minister’s Residence, 10 Downing Street, London, England

Denied contact with poorer children, in case they were carrying diseases, the Spender children were brought up largely by servants – though once a day, tidied up, they would be brought to Violet and allowed to play with her jewel-box.

Italian Leather Wave Jewel Box | Jewelry Case | Leather Accessories | Home  Decor | ScullyandScully.com

The three younger children – Stephen, Humphrey and Christine – lived in the shadow of the oldest, Michael, whose infant beauty prompted a cringe-making poem from Violet (“rosy cheeks, eyes blue and tender! / Neighbours, have you such a one? / All the neighbours answer, ‘None!’“).

Stephen’s allotted family role was that of namby-pamby.

Word For The Weekend: NAMBY-PAMBY - WARM 101.3

Things got worse when he went to boarding school.

As well as being flogged for stupidity and persecuted for his Hunnish origins, he was flung down the kipper hole at the back of the school dining-room, along with meal scraps intended for pigs.

His piano teacher consolingly prophesied that he’d be happy once an adult.

In the shorter term he was rescued by his mother, who died when he was 12, after which he was allowed home again as a day boy.

The death left him guiltily unmoved and “longing to be stricken again in order to prove that next time I would be really tragic“.

On the death of his mother, he was transferred to University College School (Hampstead), which he later described as “that gentlest of schools“.

Above: University College School, Frognal, Hampshire, England

Teen age brought further embarrassments.

The widowed Harold was possessive of his charges and studiously monitored their bowel movements to ensure they “did their little duty“.

The children were also enlisted as canvassers when Harold stood (and lost) as a Liberal MP, which meant being dispatched round the streets of Bath in a cart pulled by a donkey with “VOTE FOR DADDY” round its neck.

Bath, England (38162201235).jpg
Above: Pulteney Bridge, Bath, England

For the hyper-sensitive Stephen, who felt “skewered on the gaze of everyone” even when unobtrusively walking down the street, nothing could have been more humiliating.

I had the most tormented adolescence anyone has ever had in the whole of history,” he later wrote.

Luckily, Harold outlived Violet by less than five years, suffering a heart attack after an operation on his spleen, after which Stephen had “a very happy last year” at school.

Harold Spender - Person - National Portrait Gallery
Above: Harold Spender

Spender left for Nantes and Lausanne and then went up to University College, Oxford. 

(Much later, in 1973, he was made an Honorary Fellow).

Panorama depuis Butte Sainte-Anne.jpg
Above: Nantes, France

View of the city centre of Lausanne
Above: Lausanne, Switzerland

Quad, University College, Oxford University
Above: University College, Oxford University, Oxford, England

Academically, he was still a laggard.

In fact he failed every exam he took apart from his driving test.

(And terrified passengers doubted the wisdom of that result).

Withdrawn] Driving lessons, theory tests and driving tests to restart in  England - GOV.UK

But poetically and politically he had found his niche, and won a place at Oxford, where, after much angling for an introduction, he met Auden, already a legend at 21.

In the many different accounts Spender gave of that meeting, the word “clinical” is unvarying, pinpointing what the master has and what his acolyte lacks.

Auden wields a surgeon’s knife.

Spender is woozier.

Perhaps his closest friend and the man who had the biggest influence on him was W. H. Auden, who introduced him to Christopher Isherwood.

Spender handprinted the earliest version of Auden’s Poems.

AudenVanVechten1939.jpg
Above: Wystan Hugh Auden (1907 – 1973)

But do you really think I’m any good?” a nervous Stephen Spender asked WH Auden, some six weeks after they’d met.

Of course,” Auden said. “Because you are so infinitely capable of being humiliated.

Humiliation was Spender’s lifetime companion.

Few poets have been more savagely reviewed.

And none has nurtured a greater sense of inadequacy.

This is the man who, having dismissed John Lehmann as a potential lover because he was a “failed version of myself“, adds: “but I also regarded myself as a failed version of myself.”

With Spender, self-deprecation reaches comic extremes of self-abasement.

NPG x184157; W.H. Auden; Stephen Spender - Portrait - National Portrait  Gallery
Above: W.H. Auden and Stephen Spender, 22 June 1972

He left Oxford without taking a degree and in 1929 moved to Hamburg.

Alster Hd pano a.jpg
Above: Hamburg, Germany

Isherwood invited him to Berlin.

Siegessaeule Aussicht 10-13 img4 Tiergarten.jpg
Above: Berlin, Germany

Every six months, Spender went back to England.

Christopher Isherwood in 1938
Above: Christopher Isherwood (1904 – 1986)

By now Spender was a strikingly handsome young man.

In the German gay-arcadia of 1930, every Hans, Helmut and Harry was a willing bedfellow.

But it was Tony Hyndman, a sandy-haired Welsh ex-soldier, who consumed Spender’s emotional life for several years.

Tony Hyndman | stuartshieldgardendesign
Above: Tony Hyndman

Few friends saw the point of Tony.

Feckless, drunk and pilfering, he could also be wildly possessive, and in his later career as a stage manager took revenge on his former lover Michael Redgrave by sprinkling tacks on a couch on to which the actor was obliged to throw himself.

Sir Michael Redgrave portrait.jpg
Above: British actor Michael Redgrave (1908 – 1985)

If Spender escaped more lightly, that’s because he remained oddly loyal to Tony.

The embarrassing struggle to extricate him from Spain, where he was fighting for the Republicans, was the extent of Spender’s Spanish Civil War – and the beginning of his disillusion with Communism.

Flag of Spain
Above: Flag of Spain

Spender was acquainted with fellow Auden Group members: 

  • Louis MacNeice

New Catalogue: Papers of Louis MacNeice | Archives and Manuscripts at the  Bodleian Library
Above: Irish poet Louis MacNeice (1907 – 1963)

  • Edward Upward

Upward c. 1938
Above: British writer Edward Upward (1903 – 2009)

  • Cecil Day-Lewis

Cecil Day-Lewis.jpg
Above: Irish-English poet Cecil Day-Lewis (1904 – 1972)

He was friendly with David Jones.

David Jones
Above: English poet David Jones (1895 – 1974)

He later came to know: 

  • William Butler Yeats

Above: Irish writer W.B. Yeats (1865 – 1939)

  • Allen Ginsberg

Ginsberg in 1979
Above: American writer Allen Ginsberg (1926 – 1997)

  • Ted Hughes

Above: English poet Ted Hughes

  • Joseph Brodsky

Brodsky in 1988
Above: Russian-American poet Joseph Brodsky (1940 – 1996)

  • Isaiah Berlin

IsaiahBerlin1983.jpg
Above: Latvian-British philosopher Isaiah Berlin (1909 – 1997)

  • Mary McCarthy

McCarthy in 1963
Above: American writer Mary McCarthy (1912 – 1989)

  • Roy Campbell

The Poet, Roy Campbell | CMOA Collection
Above: South African writer Roy Campbell (1901 – 1957)

  • Raymond Chandler

Man with slicked-back black hair facing left, smoking a pipe
Above: American-British novelist Raymond Chandler (1888 – 1959)

  • Dylan Thomas

A black and white photograph of Thomas wearing a suit with a white spotted bow tie in a book shop in New York.
Above: Welsh writer Dylan Thomas (1914 – 1953)

  • Jean-Paul Sartre

Sartre 1967 crop.jpg
Above: French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre (1905 – 1980)

  • Colin Wilson

Wilson in Cornwall, 1984
Above: English writer Colin Wilson (1931 – 2013)

  • Aleister Crowley

1912 photograph of Aleister Crowley
Above: English occultist Aleister Crowley (1875 – 1947)

  • F. T. Prince

Manuscript Collections: Papers of Frank Templeton Prince | University of  Southampton Special Collections
Above: British poet Frank Templeton Prince (1912 – 2003)

  • T. S. Eliot

Eliot in 1934 by Lady Ottoline Morrell
Above: Thomas Stearns Eliot (1888 – 1965)

  • Virginia Woolf

Photograph of Virginia Woolf in 1902; photograph by George Charles Beresford
Above: English writer Virginia Woolf (1882 – 1941)

Paris Review interview, May 1978:

The Paris Review cover issue 1.jpg

I knew Dylan from very early on.

In fact, I was the first literary person he met in London.

Statue of Thomas in the Maritime Quarter, Swansea
Above: Dylan Thomas statue, Swansea, Wales

Edith Sitwell made the absurd claim that she’d discovered Dylan Thomas, which is rubbish.

All she did was write a favorable review of his first book.

Portrait of Sitwell by Roger Fry, 1915
Above: British poet Edith Sitwell (1887 – 1964)

There was a Sunday newspaper called Reynolds News at that time, and it had a poetry column which was edited by a man called Victor Neuberg.

He would publish poems sent in by readers.

I always read this column, being very sympathetic with the idea of ordinary people writing poetry.

And then in one issue I saw a poem which I thought was absolutely marvelous —

It was about a train going through a valley.

I was very moved by this poem, so I wrote to the writer in care of the column, and the writer wrote back.

WW2 WARTIME NEWSPAPER - REYNOLDS NEWS - MAY 17th 1942 | eBay
Above: Reynolds News, 17 May 1942

It was Dylan Thomas, and in his letter he said first of all that he admired my work, something that he never said again.

Then he said he wanted to come up to London and that he wanted to make money —

He was always rather obsessed by money.

So I invited him to London, and may have sent him his fare.

I felt nervous about meeting him alone, which is what I should have done, so I invited my good friend William Plomer to have lunch with us.

Above: South African-British writer William Plomer (1903 – 1973)

We took him to a restaurant in Soho.

He was very pale and intense and nervous, and Plomer and I talked a lot of London gossip to prevent the meal from going in complete silence.

I think he probably stayed in London —

Soho
Above: A bar in Soho, London, England

He was a friend of Pamela Hansford Johnson, who became Lady Snow.

Pamela Hansford Johnson at her typewriter in the 1930s or 1940s
Above: Pamela Hansford Johnson (1912 – 1981)

Then, right at the end of his life, Dylan wrote me a letter saying he’d never forgotten that I was the first poet of my generation who met him.

He was thanking me for some review I’d written —

This was the most appreciative review he’d had in his life, I think he said, something like that.

Mind you, he probably wrote a dozen letters like that to people every day.

And he certainly said extremely mean things behind my back, of that I’m quite sure.

I don’t hold that against him at all —

It was just his style.

We all enjoy doing things like that.

After those very early days I didn’t see Dylan often.

One reason is that I never get on well with alcoholics.

Also he liked to surround himself with a kind of court that moved from pub to pub.

And Dylan was expected to pay for everyone, which he always did, and he was expected to be “Dylan”.

On the corner of a block is a building with large glass fronts on both sides; a sign displaying the tavern's name shines brightly above in red neon.
Above: White Horse Tavern, New York City, where Dylan Thomas was drinking shortly before his death

Of course when I was at Horizon with Cyril Connolly, Dylan was always coming in, usually to borrow money.

NPG x15334; Cyril Connolly - Portrait - National Portrait Gallery
Above: English writer Cyril Connolly (1903 – 1974)

Richard Burton was funny telling me about Dylan.

He was a young actor and absolutely without money.

He would be playing somewhere and Dylan would turn up to borrow a pound.

When he left, Burton would always hear a taxi carrying the pauper away.

Photo of Richard Burton in The Robe, 1953
Above: English actor Richard Burton (1925 – 1984)

Spender began work on a novel in 1929, which was not published until 1988, under the title The Temple.

The novel is about a young man who travels to Germany and finds a culture at once more open than England’s, particularly about relationships between men, and shows frightening harbingers of Nazism that are confusingly related to the very openness the man admires.

Spender wrote in his 1988 introduction:

In the late Twenties young English writers were more concerned with censorship than with politics…. 1929 was the last year of that strange Indian Summer—the Weimar Republic.

For many of my friends and for myself, Germany seemed a paradise where there was no censorship and young Germans enjoyed extraordinary freedom in their lives.

The Temple is a semi-autobiographical novel written by Stephen Spender, sometimes labelled a Bildungsroman because of its explorations of youth and first love.

It was written after Spender spent his summer vacation in Germany in 1929 and recounts his experiences there.

During the holiday in 1929 on which The Temple is based, Spender formed friendships with Herbert List (photographer) and Ernst Robert Curtius (German critic), the latter of which introduced him to and cultivated his passion for Rilke, Hölderlin, Schiller and Goethe.

Spender had a particularly significant relationship with German culture which he found heavily conflicted with his Jewish roots.

His taste for German society sets him apart from some of his contemporaries.

However, even after contemplating suicide if the Nazis were to invade England due to his abhorrence of their regime, he still maintained a love of Germany, returning to it after the war and writing a book about its ruins.

It was not completed until the early 1930s (after Spender had failed his finals at Oxford University in 1930 and moved to Hamburg).

Because of its frank depictions of homosexuality, it was not published in the UK until 1988.

Flag of Germany
Above: Flag of Germany

(Does a person’s sexual orientation have anyone to do with creativity?

I don’t believe so.

Frankly, what an author’s private life is (or isn’t) should not affect my ability to enjoy their public creations.)

question mark | 3d human with a red question mark | Damián Navas | Flickr

The Temple begins in Oxford, where Paul Schoner meets Simon Wilmot and William Bradshaw, caricatures of the young W. H. Auden and Christopher Isherwood respectively.

Above: Aerial view of Oxford, England

They encourage him to visit Germany, hinting that Paul might prefer Germany to Britain because of Germany’s liberal attitudes towards sex and the body.

During this section, Paul is introduced to Ernst Stockmann, a fan of his poetry who later invites him to visit his family home in Hamburg.

Paul visits Ernst Stockmann, meeting his wealthy mother and friends, Joachim Lenz and Willy Lassel.

During his time at the Stockmann household, Paul experiences the liberality of German youth culture first-hand, attending a party at which he drinks too much and meets Irmi, his later love affair.

Projekt Heißluftballon - Highflyer -IMG-1407.jpg
Above: Hamburg, Germany

Paul, Ernst, Joachim and Willy also visit Hamburg’s notorious quarter Sankt Pauli.

In Sankt Pauli, at a bar named The Three Stars, Paul meets some young male prostitutes who claim to be destitute.

It is on this evening, while he is drunk, that Paul agrees to go on holiday to the Baltic with Ernst despite being uncomfortable in Ernst’s company.

St. Pauli Piers and the port of Hamburg
Above: St. Pauli Pier and the port of Hamburg, Germany

When Paul and Ernst arrive at the hotel by the Baltic where they will be staying, Paul is distressed to find that Ernst has booked them into a shared room.

Paul feels suffocated by Ernst’s clear affection for him and tries to deter Ernst by telling him that he is not interested.

Afterward, Paul ponders Stephen Wilmot’s quasi-Freudian premise that it is kindest to offer love in return to those who love you, especially if you do not find them attractive.

As a result, when Ernst comes on to Paul in the hotel room, Paul accepts his attention and they have an uncomfortable sexual encounter.

In the morning, Paul is keen to escape the hotel room, and runs down to a beach, where he meets Irmi again.

They have a more satisfying sexual experience on the beach.

Map

In the next chapter, Paul goes on a trip with Joachim Lenz to the Rhine.

On this trip, Joachim makes it clear that he intends to fall in love, but there is little indication that he and Paul could be lovers.

Nevertheless, Paul is distressed when Joachim books him an adjacent hotel room so that he can stay with a young man named Heinrich who he had met on the beach.

Flusssystemkarte Rhein 04.jpg

In Part Two, “Towards the Dark“, Paul returns to Germany in the winter of 1932.

Spender admits in his introduction to the 1988 edition that both parts had taken place in 1929 in reality, but that he moved this part forward to winter 1932 to increase the sense of foreboding (as Adolf Hitler came to power in Germany later that winter).

In this section, Paul visits several of his friends again, most notably Willy Lassel, who is now engaged to a Nazi woman, and Joachim Lenz, whose relationship with Heinrich is struggling.

Heinrich has made friends with Erich, a fascist man.

Paul meets him and is disgusted and disturbed by his ideology.

Soon after, Paul visits Joachim again and finds him with a cut on his face, staying in a trashed flat.

Joachim tells Paul how one of Heinrich’s Nazi friends had threatened him and destroyed his possessions after Joachim defiled a Nazi party uniform belonging to Heinrich.

This discussion about their former acquaintances is the end of the novel.

Flag of Nazi Germany
Above: Flag of Nazi Germany (1935 – 1945)

Spender was discovered by T. S. Eliot, an editor at Faber & Faber, in 1933.

His early poetry, notably Poems (1933), was often inspired by social protest.

Poems by Stephen Spender by Stephen Spender

Living in Vienna, he further expressed his convictions in Forward from Liberalism, in Vienna (1934), a long poem in praise of the 1934 uprising of Austrian socialists, and in Trial of a Judge (1938), an antifascist drama in verse.

Forward from Liberalism: Spender, Stephen: 9781125852484: Amazon.com: Books

The 1930s were marked by turbulent events that would shape the course of history: the worldwide economic depression, the Spanish Civil War, and the beginnings of World War II.

Above: Dorothea Lange’s (1895 – 1965) Migrant Mother depicts destitute pea pickers in California, centering on Florence Owens Thompson (1903 – 1983), age 32, a mother of seven children, in Nipomo, California, March 1936

Collage guerra civile spagnola.png
Above: Images of the Spanish Civil War (1936 – 1939)

World War II: Summary, Combatants & Facts - HISTORY
Above: Soldier, World War II (1939 – 1945)

Seeing the established world crumbling around them, the writers of the period sought to create a new reality to replace the old, which, in their minds, had become obsolete.

For a time, Spender, like many young intellectuals of the era, was a member of the Communist Party.

CPGB2.png

Spender believed that Communism offered the only workable analysis and solution of complex world problems, that it was sure eventually to win, and that for significance and relevance the artist must somehow link his art to the Communist diagnosis.

Spender’s poem, “The Funeral” (included in Collected Poems: 1928 – 1953, published in 1955, but omitted from the 1985 revision of the same work), has been described as “a Communist elegy”.

37,263 Communism Stock Photos, Pictures & Royalty-Free Images - iStock
Above: Communist flag

Auden’s Funeral

One among friends who stood above your grave
I cast a clod of earth from those heaped there
Down on the great brass-handled coffin lid.
It rattled on the oak like a door knocker
And at that sound I saw your face beneath
Wedged in an oblong shadow under ground.
Flesh creased, eyes shut, jaw jutting
And on the mouth a grin: triumph of one
Who has escaped from life-long colleagues roaring
For him to join their throng. He’s still half with us
Conniving slyly, yet he knows he’s gone
Into that cellar where they’ll never find him,
Happy to be alone, his last work done,
Word freed from world, into a different wood.

But we, with feet on grass, feeling the wind
Whip blood up in our cheeks, walk back along
The hillside road we earlier climbed today
Following the hearse and tinkling village band.
The white October sun circles Kirchstetten
With colours of chrysanthemums in gardens,
And bronze and golden under wiry boughs,
A few last apples gleam like jewels.
Back in the village inn, we sit on benches
For the last toast to you, the honoured ghost
Whose absence now becomes incarnate in us.
Tasting the meats, we imitate your voice
Speaking in flat benign objective tones
The night before you died. In the packed hall
You are your words. Your listeners see
Written on your face the poems they hear
Like letters carved in a tree’s bark
The sight and sound of solitudes endured.
And looking down on them, you see
Your image echoed in their eyes
Enchanted by your language to be theirs.
And then, your last word said, halloing hands
Hold up above their heads your farewell bow.
Then many stomp the platform, entreating
Each for his horde, your still warm signing hand.
But you have hidden away in your hotel
And locked the door and lain down on the bed
And fallen from their praise, dead on the floor.

(Ghost of a ghost, of you when young, you waken
In me my ghost when young, us both at Oxford.
You, the tow-haired undergraduate
With jaunty liftings of the head.
Angular forward stride, cross-questioning glance,
A Buster Keaton-faced pale gravitas.
Saying aloud your poems whose letters bit
Ink-deep into my fingers when I set
Them up upon my five-pound printing press:

‘An evening like a coloured photograph

A music stultified across the water

The heel upon the finishing blade of grass.’)

Back to your room still growing memories –
Handwriting, bottles half-drunk, and us – drunk –
Chester, in prayers, still prayed for your ‘dear C.’,
Hunched as Rigoletto, spluttering
Ecstatic sobs, already slanted
Down towards you, his ten-months-hence
Grave in Athens – remembers
Opera, your camped-on heaven, odourless
Resurrection of your bodies singing
Passionate duets whose chords resolve
Your rows in harmonies. Remembers
Some tragi-jesting wish of yours and puts
‘Siegfried’s Funeral March’ on the machine.
Wagner who drives out every thought but tears –
Down-crashing drums and cymbals cataclysmic
End-of-world brass exalt on drunken waves
The poet’s corpse borne on a bier beyond
The foundering finalities, his world,
To that Valhalla where the imaginings
Of the dead makers are their lives.
The dreamer sleeps forever with the dreamed.

Above: W.H. Auden’s grave, Kirchstetten, Austria

It has been observed that much of Spender’s other works from the same early period—including his play, Trial of a Judge: A Tragedy in Five Acts (1938), his poems in Vienna (1934), and his essays in The Destructive Element: A Study of Modern Writers and Beliefs (1935) and Forward from Liberalism (1935)—address Communism.

Trial of a Judge: A Tragic Statement in Five Acts | Stephen Spender | First  Edition, First Printing

Vienna by Stephen Spender

The Destructive Element. A Study of Modern Writers and Beliefs | Stephen  SPENDER

In Poets of the Thirties, D.E.S. Maxwell commented:

The imaginative writing of the thirties created an unusual milieu of urban squalor and political intrigue.

This kind of statement — a suggestion of decay producing violence and leading to change — as much as any absolute and unanimous political partisanship gave this poetry its Marxist reputation.

Communism and ‘the Communist’ (a poster-type stock figure) were frequently invoked.

Poets of the thirties,: Maxwell, D. E. S: 9780389010616: Amazon.com: Books

The attitudes Spender developed in the 1930s continued to influence him throughout his life.

As Peter Stansky pointed out in the New Republic

The 1930s were a shaping time for Spender, casting a long shadow over all that came after.

It would seem that the rest of his life, even more than he may realize, has been a matter of coming to terms with the 1930s, and the conflicting claims of literature and politics as he knew them in that decade of achievement, fame and disillusion.

Amazon.co.uk: Peter Stansky: Books, Biography, Blogs, Audiobooks, Kindle
Above: American historian Peter Stansky

From Stephen Spender’s The Destructive Element (1935):

I have taken Henry James as a great writer who developed an inner world of his own through his art.

I have also tried to show that his attitude to our civilization forced him to that development.

The process had two stages:

The first was his conviction that European society – and particularly English society – was decadent, combined with his own despair of fulfilling any creative or critical function in civilization as a whole.

Secondly, he discovered, in the strength of his own individuality, immense resources of respect for the past and for civilization.

He fulfilled his capacity to live and watch and judge by his own standards, to the utmost.

The Portrait of a lady cover.jpg

His characters have the virtues of people who are living into the past: an extreme sensibility, consideration for and curiosity about each other’s conduct, an aestheticism of behaviour.

In some ways their lives are a pastiche, but this pastiche is an elaboration of traditional moral values.

The life that James is, on the surface, describing, may be false.

The life that he is all the time inventing is true.

The Wings of the Dove (Henry James Novel) 1st edition cover.jpg

James, Joyce, Yeats, Ezra Pound and Eliot have all fortified their works by creating some legend or by consciously going back into a tradition that seemed and seems to be dying.

They are all conscious of the present as chaotic (though they are not all without their remedies) and of the past as an altogether more solid ground.

Portrait of James Joyce
Above: Irish writer James Joyce (1882 – 1941)

photograph of Ezra H. Pound
Above: American poet Ezra Pound (1885 – 1972)

In the destructive element immerse.

That is the way.

(Joseph Conrad)

Head shot with moustache and beard
Above: Polish-British writer Joseph Conrad (né Józef Teodor Konrad Korzeniowski) (1857 – 1924)

Things fall apart. The centre cannot hold.

Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world.

The blood dammed tide is loosed and everywhere.

The ceremony of innocence is drowned.

(Yeats)

Above: William Butler Yeats

Paris Review interview, May 1978:

I met Yeats, I think probably in 1935 or 1936, at Lady Ottoline Morrell’s.

Ottoline asked me to tea alone with Yeats.

Lady Ottoline Morrell, 1902
Above: Ottoline Morrell (1873 – 1938)

He was very blind and I don’t know whether he was deaf, but he was very sort of remote, he seemed tremendously old.

He was only about the age I am now, but he seemed tremendously old and remote.

Above: William Butler Yeats

He looked at me and then he said:

Young man, what do you think of the Sayers?

I hadn’t the faintest idea what he was talking about — I thought perhaps he meant Dorothy Sayers’s crime stories or something — I became flustered.

Dorothy L Sayers 1928.jpg
Above: English writer Dorothy Sayers (1893 – 1957)

What he meant was a group of young ladies who chanted poems in chorus.

Ten Poems Students Love to Read Out Loud by… | Poetry Foundation

Ottoline got very alarmed and rushed out of the room and telephoned to Virginia Woolf, who was just around the corner, and asked her to come save the situation.

Virginia arrived in about ten minutes’ time, tremendously amused, and Yeats was very pleased to meet her because he’d just been reading The Waves.

TheWaves.jpg

He also read quite a lot of science — I think he read Eddington and Rutherford and all those kinds of things — and so he told her that The Waves was a marvelous novel, that it was entirely up to date in scientific theory because light moved in waves, and time, and so on.

Arthur Stanley Eddington.jpg
Above: English astrophysicist Arthur Stanley Eddington (1882 – 1944)

Sir Ernest Rutherford LCCN2014716719 - restoration1.jpg
Above: New Zealander-British Physicist Ernest Rutherford (1871 – 1937)

Of course Virginia, who hadn’t thought of all this, was terribly pleased and flattered.

And then I remember he started telling her a story in which he said:

And as I went down the stairs there was a marble statue of a baby and it started talking in Greek to me.”—

That sort of thing.

Virginia adored it all, of course.

Portrait of Virginia Woolf 1927
Above: Virginia Woolf

Ottoline had what she called her Thursday parties, at which you met a lot of writers.

Yeats was often there.

He loosened up a great deal if he could tell malicious stories, and so he talked about George Moore.

Portrait, 1879
Above: Irish writer George Moore (1852 – 1933)

Yeats particularly disliked George Moore because of what he wrote in his book Hail and Farewell, which is in three volumes, and which describes Yeats in a rather absurd way.

Moore thought Yeats looked very much like a black crow or a rook as he walked by the lake on Lady Gregory’s estate at Coole.

Head and shoulders profile of a dignified older woman with hair swept back and a slightly prominent nose. Underneath is the signature "Augusta Gregory".
Above: Irish writer Isabella Augusta, Lady Gregory (1852 – 1932)

Lady Gregory's Lodge - Unique Irish Homes
Above: Lady Gregory Lodge, Coole Park, County Galway, Ireland

He also told how Yeats would spend the whole morning writing five lines of poetry and then he’d be sent up strawberries and cream by Lady Gregory, and so Yeats would have to get his own back on George Moore.

Hail and Farewell! by George Moore

Another thing that amused Yeats very much for some reason was Robert Graves and the whole saga of his life with Laura Riding.

Graves in 1929
Above: British poet Robert Graves (1895 – 1985)

He told how Laura Riding threw herself out of a window without breaking her spine, or breaking it but being cured very rapidly.

All that pleased Yeats tremendously.

Woman with shoulder length brown hair wearing a white coat
Above: American writer Laura Riding Jackson (née Laura Reichenthal) (1901 – 1991)

I remember his telling the story of his trip to Rapallo to show the manuscript of The Tower to Ezra Pound.

The sea front and harbour of Rapallo.
Above: Rapallo, Italy

He stayed at the hotel and then went around and left the manuscript in a packet for Pound, accompanied by a letter saying:

I am an old man, this may be the last poetry I’ll ever write, it is very different from my other work?

All that kind of thing — and:

What do you think of it?

Next day he received a postcard from Ezra Pound with one word on it putrid.

Yeats was rather amused by that.

Apparently Pound had a tremendous collection of cats, and Yeats used to say that Pound couldn’t possibly be a nasty man because he fed all the cats of Rapallo.

Pound: poet and political prisoner - spiked
Above: Ezra Pound, Rapallo, Italy

I once asked him how he came to be a modern poet, and he told me that it took him 30 years to modernize his style.

He said he didn’t really like the modern poetry of Eliot and Pound.

He thought it was static, that it didn’t have any movement, and for him poetry had always to have the romantic movement.

He said:

For me poetry always means:

‘Yet we’ll go no more a-roving / By the light of the moon.’

Portrait of Byron
Above: English poet George Gordon Byron (1788 – 1824)

So the problem was how to keep the movement of the Byron lines but at the same time enlarge it so that it could include the kind of material that he was interested in, which was to do with everyday life —politics, quarrels between people, sexual love, and not just the frustrated love he had with Maud Gonne.

Maude Gonne McBride nd.jpg
Above: English-Irish activist Maude Gonne McBride (1866 – 1953)

The idea for a book on James gradually resolved itself, then, in my mind, into that of a book about modern writers and beliefs or unbeliefs.

The difficulty of a book about contemporaries is that one is dealing in a literature of few accepted values.

At best, one can offer opinions or one can try to prove that one living writer is, for certain reasons, better than another.

At worst, such criticism degenerates into a kind of bookmaking or stockbroking.

A living writer does not diminish in accordance with rules laid down by donnish minds.

Impertinent criticism means that the critic is projecting on to writing some fantasy of his own as to how poems should be written.

TheAmbassadors.jpg

D.H. Lawrence is a kind of traveller to uncharted lands.

As a psychologist, in his poems, and in Fantasia of the Unknown, he is unique and has no follower.

D. H. Lawrence, 1929
Above: David Herbert Lawrence (1885 – 1930)

All these writers seem to me faced by the destructive element, the experience of an all-pervading present which is a world without belief.

On the one hand, there are the writers who search for some unifying belief in the past or in some personal legend.

On the other, those who look forward to a world of new beliefs in the future.

Both of these attitudes are explained by the consciousness of a void in the present.

The Destructive Element: A Study Of Modern Writers And Beliefs by Stephen  Spender

What interests me is what writers write about, the subjects of literature today.

I am not defending the young writers from the old writers.

I am defending what is, in the widest sense, the political or moral subject in writing.

The Trance | Poem Summary | Snappynotes
Above: Stephen Spender

Lawrence’s own books are descriptions of his experience.

His writing is so inextricably bound up with the value he set on living, that it seems a part of the experience.

It does not seem at all cut off from his life.

Sonslovers.jpg

The organ of life, the moral life of human beings, is the subject, the consistent pattern.

To write a poetry which represents the modern moral life, which is yet not isolated from tradition.

Dust jacket, Lawrence, The Rainbow, Methuen, 1915.jpg

In Yeats I see a fundamental division of the realist from the practical politician and mystic, the reporter attending séances.

Above: William Butler Yeats

I see Eliot as an extremely isolated artist of great sensibility, a deaf and neurotic sensibility that produced great quartets.

Above: Thomas Stearns Eliot

James believed that the only values which mattered at all were those cultivated by individuals who had escaped from the general decadence.

Above: Henry James

Before everything else, the individual must be agonizingly aware of his isolated situation.

Nor is he to be selfish.

He is still occupied in building up the little nucleus of a real civilization possible for himself and for others possessing the same awareness as himself.

More recently, however, the situation seems to have profoundly altered, because the moral life of the individual has become comparatively insignificant.

365 Ways to Change the World – The Speaking Tree

In times of revolution or war, there is a divorce between the kind of morality that affects individuals and the morality of the state, of politics.

In time of war, the immoral purpose invented by the state is to beat the enemy and the usual taboos affecting individuals are almost suspended.

Those taboos which serve to make an individual conform to a strict family code may become regarded as ludicrous.

In revolutionary times it is questions of social justice, of liberty, of war or peace, of election, that become really important.

Civilization series logo (2016).svg
Above: Civilizations video game series logo

Questions of private morality, of theft, of adultery, become almost insignificant.

In private life there remain few great saints and absolutely no great sinners.

Yin and yang.svg

The old question of free will, of whether the individual is free to choose between two courses of action, becomes superseded by another question:

Is a society able to determine the course of its history?

Society is, of course, made up of individuals, and the choice, if there is any, lies finally with individuals.

But there is a difference between public acts and private acts of individuals.

There is a difference between the man who considers that he is a great and exciting sinner because he leads a promiscuous sexual life, and the man who decides not to live too promiscuously because to do so embarrasses and complicates his revolutionary activities.

Casanova film.jpg

To the second man the question of a morality in his private life becomes a matter of convenience, whereas his political conscience governs his actions.

In times of rest, of slow evolution and peace, society is an image of the individual quietly living his life and obeying the laws.

A painting of a man and woman with stern expessions standing side-by-side in front of a white house. The man holds a pitch fork.
Above: American Gothic, Grant Wood

In violent times the moral acts of the individual seem quite unrelated to the immense social changes going on all around him.

He looks at civilization and does not see his own quiet image reflected there at all, but the face of something fierce and threatening that may destroy him.

It may seem foreign and yet resemble his own face.

He knows that if he is not to be destroyed, he must somehow connect his life again with this political life and influence it.

Stop Reading the News by Rolf Dobelli, Caroline Waight | Waterstones

The extraordinary public events of the last few years, the war, revolutions, the economic crisis, are bound eventually into the tradition of literature, the organ of life.

It is not true to say that poetry is about nothing.

Poetry is about history, but not history in the sense of school books.

Poetry is a history which is the moral life, which is always contemporary.

The pattern, the technique, is the organ of life.

Dead poets society.jpg

I find myself opposed to the distinguished critic who says that art is, or should be, non-moral and non-political, but external and satiric, as much as I am bound also to oppose those who say that literature should become an instrument of propaganda.

Why I Write (Great Ideas #020) by George Orwell

The greatest art is moral, even when the artist has no particular moral or political axe to grind.

Conversely, that having a particular moral or political axe to grind does destroy art if the writer:

  • suspends his own judgments and substitutes the system of judging established by a political creed
  • assumes knowledge of men and the future course of history, which he may passionately believe, but which, as an artist, he simply hasn’t got

Utopia by Thomas More

The poet is not dealing in purely esthetic values, but he is communicating an experience of life which is outside his own personal experience.

He may communicate his own experience yet he is not bound by this, but by his own understanding.

Pure poetry does communicate a kind of experience and this is the experience of a void.

For the sense of a void is a very important kind of experience.

All theories of art for art’s sake and of pure art are the attempt to state the theory of a kind of art based on no political, religious or moral creed.

Gallery of Light, Space, and Movement Become Art During the Mesmerizing  Sensory Experience of "VOID" - 3

The old gang to be forgotten in the spring

The hard bitch and the riding master

Stiff underground; deep in clear lake

The lolling bridegroom, beautiful, there

(W.H. Auden)

Above: W.H. Auden

I am not stating how writers should write or even what they should write about.

That is their business, not mine.

Writer at Work - Writers Write

At some time in his life an artist has got to come to grips with the objective, factual life around him.

He cannot spin indefinitely from himself unless he learned how to establish contact with his audience by the use of symbols which represent reality to his contemporaries.

If he does not learn this lesson, he ceases to be.

He needs to be islanded with imagery, which is derived from realistic observation.

Just as dreams express the desires censored by our waking thoughts figure those desires in pictures which are actual to us.

Thus we find a museum full of the symbols which were at first observed as conditions in real life are used as symbols for different states of mind.

The Museum of Innocence.jpg
Above: The Museum of Innocence, Istanbul, Turkey

I have not the least hesitation in saying that I aspire to write in such a way that it would be impossible for an outsider to say whether I am at a given moment an American writing about England or an Englishman writing about America, and far from being ashamed of such an ambiguity I should be exceedingly proud of it, for it would be highly civilized.

(Henry James)

Above: Henry James

The most limited theme is capable of the greatest development and variation.

From humble beginnings come great things | Inspirational Quotes |  Typography inspiration, Words, Lettering

James is the spectator at the edge of life always refusing to enter into it.

His characters all listen and talk and comment and do not act.

The Beast in the Jungle is the study of a man in whose life nothing happens, it is all spent in waiting for the beast to spring.

The Beast in the Jungle eBook by Henry James - 9788822868657 | Rakuten Kobo  United States

A life of leisured and comfortable journeys to frequented and beautiful cities or parts of the country is, in the majority of cases, the most uneventful life our society has to offer.

If it provides excitement, it provides excitement with the least possible amount of friction.

The personal conflict is a conflict between the desire to plunge too deeply into experience and the prudent resolution to remain a spectator, to absorb the tradition without losing own individuality, to choose between two kinds of isolation:

  • the isolation of a person so deeply involved in experiencing the sensations of a world foreign to him that he fails to affirm himself as a part of its unity
  • to be isolated in the manner of absolutely refusing to be an actor in the play which so impressed him

I Am A Rock 45.jpg

What, then, have you dreamed of?

A man whom I can have the luxury of respecting!

A man whom I can admire enough to make me know I am doing it, whom I fondly believe to be cast in a bigger mould than most of the vulgar breed – large in character, great in talent, strong in will.

In such a man as that, one’s weary imagination at last may rest or may wander if it will, but with the sense of coming home again a greater adventure than any other.

(Henry James)

James Washington Square cover.JPG

The tragic muse is a book in which all the conflicting aspects of life are represented:

The life of political action, the aesthetic life, and the drama.

Intelligently responsive critical interest in an artist’s work is an almost necessary stimulus to creation.

Bookmark: Authors, readings, launches move to online | Star Tribune

It was as if he had said to me on seeing me:

Lay hands on the weak little relics of our common youth:

Oh, but you are not going to give me away, to hand me over in my raggedness and my poor accidents, quite helpless, friendless.

You are going to do the best for me you can, aren’t you?

And since you are going to let me seem to justify them as I possibly can?

(Henry James)

The Bostonians by Henry James

At the Shakespeare and Company bookstore in Paris, which published the first edition of James Joyce’s Ulysses, historic figures made rare appearances to read their work: 

Shakespeare and Company bookstore, Paris 13 August 2013.jpg
Above: Shakespeare and Company bookstore, Paris, France

JoyceUlysses2.jpg

Paul Valéry, André Gide and Eliot.

Paul Valéry photographed by Henri Manuel, 1920s.
Above: French writer Paul Valéry (1871 – 1945)

André Gide.jpg
Above: French writer André Gide (1869 – 1951)

T. S. Eliot | Poetry Foundation
Above: T.S. Eliot

Hemingway even broke his rule of not reading in public if Spender would read with him.

Since Spender agreed, Hemingway appeared for a rare reading in public with him.

Dark-haired man in light colored short-sleeved shirt working on a typewriter at a table on which sits an open book
Above: American writer Ernest Hemingway (1899 – 1961)

Paris Review interview, May 1978:

Hemingway I knew during the Spanish Civil War.

He often turned up in Valencia and Madrid and other places where I happened to be.

We would go for walks together and then he would talk about literature.

ErnestHemmingway ForWhomTheBellTolls.jpg

He was marvelous as long as he didn’t realize that he was talking about literature —

I mean he’d say how the opening chapter of Stendhal’s La Chartreuse de Parme was the best description of war in literature, when Fabrizio gets lost, doesn’t know where he is at all in the Battle of Waterloo.

Stendhal, by Olof Johan Södermark, 1840
Above: French writer Marie-Henri Beyle (aka Stendhal) (1783 – 1842)

StendhalCharterhouseParma01.jpg
Above: The Charterhouse of Parma, first edition

Battle of Waterloo 1815.PNG
Above: The Battle of Waterloo, Waterloo, Belgium, 18 June 1815

Then I’d say:

Well, what do you think about Henry IV?

Portrait of Henry IV
Above: English King Henry IV (1367 – 1413)

Do you think Shakespeare writes well about war?

Oh, I’ve never read Shakespeare,” he would say.

Shakespeare.jpg
Above: William Shakespeare (1564 – 1616)

What are you talking about?

You seem to imagine I’m a professor or something.

I don’t read literature.

I’m not a literary man.”—

That kind of thing.

Above: The Hemingway family (Hadley, Bumby and Ernest), Schruns, Austria, 1926

In Chicago, Hemingway worked as an associate editor of the monthly journal Cooperative Commonwealth, where he met novelist Sherwood Anderson.

It is believed that Anderson suggested Paris to Hemingway because “the monetary exchange rate” made it an inexpensive place to live, more importantly it was where “the most interesting people in the world” lived.

Anderson in 1933
Above: American novelist Sherwood Anderson (1876 – 1941)

In Paris, Hemingway met American writer and art collector Gertrude Stein, Irish novelist James Joyce, American poet Ezra Pound (who “could help a young writer up the rungs of a career“) and other writers.

Above: American writer Gertrude Stein (1874 – 1946)

Picture of James Joyce from 1922 in three-quarters view looking downward
Above: James Joyce

Above: Ezra Pound

The Hemingway of the early Paris years was a “tall, handsome, muscular, broad-shouldered, brown-eyed, rosy-cheeked, square-jawed, soft-voiced young man.”

He and Hadley lived in a small walk-up at 74 rue du Cardinal Lemoine in the Latin Quarter, and he worked in a rented room in a nearby building.

74 rue du Cardinal Lemoine | Hemingway's Paris-37 | This was… | Flickr
Above: 74 rue du Cardinal Lemoine, Paris

File:Rue Cardinal Lemoine-Plaque Hemingway.JPG - Wikimedia Commons

Stein, who was the bastion of modernism in Paris, became Hemingway’s mentor and godmother to his son Jack. 

She introduced him to the expatriate artists and writers of the Montparnasse Quarter, whom she referred to as the “Lost Generation“—a term Hemingway popularized with the publication of The Sun Also Rises.

Generation timeline.svg

A regular at Stein’s salon, Hemingway met influential painters such as Pablo Picasso, Joan Miró and Juan Gris.

Portrait de Picasso, 1908.jpg
Above: Spanish painter Pablo Picasso (1881 – 1973)

Portrait of Joan Miro, Barcelona 1935 June 13.jpg
Above: Spanish painter Joan Miro (1893 – 1983)

Juan Gris, 1922, photograph by Man Ray, Paris. Gelatin silver print.jpg
Above: Spanish painter Juan Gris (1887 – 1927)

He eventually withdrew from Stein’s influence, and their relationship deteriorated into a literary quarrel that spanned decades.

Ezra Pound met Hemingway by chance at Sylvia Beach’s bookshop Shakespeare and Company in 1922.

Sylvia Beach at Shakespeare & Co Paris 1920.jpg
Above: American bookseller/publisher Sylvia Beach (1887 – 1962)

The two toured Italy in 1923 and lived on the same street in 1924.

They forged a strong friendship, and in Hemingway, Pound recognized and fostered a young talent. 

Pound introduced Hemingway to James Joyce, with whom Hemingway frequently embarked on “alcoholic sprees“.

During his first 20 months in Paris, Hemingway filed 88 stories for the Toronto Star newspaper.

Passport photograph
Above: Hemingway’s 1923 passport photo. At this time, he lived in Paris with his wife Hadley, and worked as a foreign correspondent for the Toronto Star.

Toronto-Star-Logo.svg

By-Line Ernest Hemingway 1967.jpg

In September 1923, the Hemingways returned to Toronto, where their son John was born on 10 October.

He missed Paris, considered Toronto boring, and wanted to return to the life of a writer, rather than live the life of a journalist.

Hemingway, Hadley and their son (nicknamed Bumby) returned to Paris in January 1924 and moved into a new apartment at 113 rue Notre-Dame des Champs.

Ernest Hemingway, 113 rue notre-dame des champs, Montparnasse, Paris,1926.  (from Kiki's Paris by Billy Kluver… | Great short stories, Dorothy parker,  The new yorker
Above: Ernest Hemingway, 1926

Hemingway helped Ford Madox Ford edit The Transatlantic Review, which published works by Pound, John Dos Passos, Baroness Elsa von Freytag-Loringhoven, and Stein, as well as some of Hemingway’s own early stories, such as “Indian Camp“.

When In Our Time was published in 1925, the dust jacket bore comments from Ford.

Indian Camp” received considerable praise.

Ford saw it as an important early story by a young writer.

Critics in the United States praised Hemingway for reinvigorating the short story genre with his crisp style and use of declarative sentences.

c. 1905 photo
Above: English writer Ford Madox Ford (1873 – 1939)

Six months earlier, Hemingway had met F. Scott Fitzgerald.

The pair formed a friendship of “admiration and hostility“. 

A photograph of F. Scott Fitzgerald by Nickolas Muray. Fitzgerald is bent over a desk and is examining a sheaf of papers. He is wearing a light suit and a polka-dot tie. A white handkerchief is in his breast pocket.
Above: American writer Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald (1896 – 1940)

Fitzgerald had published The Great Gatsby the same year:

Hemingway read it, liked it, and decided his next work had to be a novel.

The book cover with title against a dark sky. Beneath the title are lips and two eyes, looming over a city.

He was very nice when one was alone with him, but the public Hemingway could be troublesome.

On one occasion, I remember we went into a bar where there were girls.

Hemingway immediately took up a guitar and started strumming, being “Hemingway”.

One of the girls standing with him pointed at me and said, “Tu amigo es muy guapo.”—

Your friend is very handsome.

Hemingway became absolutely furious, bashed down the guitar and left in a rage.

He was very like that.

Another time, my first wife and I met him and Marty Gellhorn in Paris.

Yours, for Probably Always: Martha Gellhorn's Letters of Love and War  1930-1949 – review | History books | The Guardian
Above: Marty Gellhorn

They invited us to lunch, someplace where there were steaks and chips, things like that, but my wife ordered sweetbread.

Also she wouldn’t drink.

Inez Spender', Sir William Coldstream, 1937–8 | Tate
Above: Inez Pearn Spender (née Marie Agnes Pearn) (1913 – 1976)

So Hemingway said:

Your wife is yellow, that’s what she is, she’s yellow.

Marty was like that, and do you know what I did?

I used to take her to the morgue in Madrid every morning before breakfast.

Well, the morgue in Madrid before breakfast really must have been something.

photograph of three men and two women sitting at a sidewalk table

Above: Ernest Hemingway with Lady Duff Twysden, his wife Hadley, and friends, July 1925 trip to Spain

Hemingway always said of me:

You’re okay.

All that’s wrong with you is you’re too squeamish.

MoveableFeast.jpg

So he would describe modern war.

He’d say:

If you think of modern war from the point of view of a pilot, the city that he’s bombing isn’t all these people whom you like to worry about, people who are going to suffer —

It’s just a mathematical problem.

It’s like shading in a circle with dark areas where you drop your bombs.

You mustn’t think of it in a sentimental way at all.

Hemingway farewell.png

At that same meeting in Paris, he told me again I was squeamish, and then he said:

This is something you ought to look at, it will do you good.

He produced a packet of about 30 photographs of the most horrible murders, which he carried around in his pockets.

This toughened one up in some way.

The Murders in the Rue Morgue eBook by Edgar Allan Poe - 9783967993257 |  Rakuten Kobo Greece

He told me that what motivated him really, while he was in Spain, wasn’t so much enthusiasm about the Republic, but to test his own courage.

He said:

Only if you actually go into battle and bullets are screeching all around you, can you know whether you’re a coward or not.

He had to prove to himself that he wasn’t a coward.

And he said:

Mind, you shit in your pants with fear.

Everyone does that, but that isn’t what counts.

I don’t remember quite what it is that counts —

But he always wanted to test his own courage.

Physical courage to him was a kind of absolute value.

photograph of three men
Above: Hemingway (center) with Dutch filmmaker Joris Ivens (1898 – 1989) and German writer Ludwig Renn (1889 – 1979) (serving as an International Brigades officer) during the Spanish Civil War, 1937

In 1936, Spender became a member of the Communist Party of Great Britain. 

Communist Party of Great Britain (Provisional Central Committee) - Wikipedia

(The Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB) was the largest Communist party in Great Britain between 1920 and 1991.

Founded in 1920 through a merger of several smaller Marxist parties, the CPGB gained the support of many socialist organisations and trade unions following the political fallout of the First World War and the Russian October Revolution.

Ideologically the CPGB was a socialist party organised upon Marxism-Leninist ideology, strongly opposed to British colonialism, sexual discrimination and racial segregation.

These beliefs led many leading anti-colonial revolutionaries, feminists, and anti-fascist figures, to become closely associated with the Party.

Many prominent CPGB members became leaders of Britain’s trade union movements.)

Join the party or become a supporter | The Communists

Harry Pollitt, its head, invited him to write for the Daily Worker on the Moscow Trials.

Above: Henry Pollitt (1890 – 1960) giving a speech to workers in front of Whitehall, London, 1941

(The Moscow Trials were a series of show trials held in the Soviet Union between 1936 and 1938 at the instigation of Joseph Stalin.

Stalin Full Image.jpg
Above: Joseph Stalin (1878 – 1953)

They were nominally directed against “Trotskyists” and members of the “Right Opposition” of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.

Above: Leon Trotsky (1879 – 1940)

Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels
Above: Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, German authors of The Communist Manifesto

At the time the three Moscow Trials were given extravagant titles:

  • the “Case of the Trotskyite-Zinovievite Terrorist Center” (or the Zinoviev-Kamenev Trial, also known as the ‘Trial of the Sixteen‘, August 1936)

Grigory Zinoviev
Above: Russian revolutionary Grigory Zinovieff (né Hirsch Apfelbaum) (1883 – 1936)

Lev Kamenev 1920s (cropped).jpg
Above: Russian revolutionary Lev Kamenev (né Rozenfeld) (1883 – 1936)

  • the “Case of the Anti-Soviet Trotskyist Center” (or the Pyatakov-Radek Trial, January 1937)

Pyatakov GL.jpg
Above: Russian revolutionary Georgy Pyatakov (1890 – 1937)

Karl Radek 1.jpg
Above: Ukrainian revolutionary Karl Radek (1885 – 1939)

  • the “Case of the Anti-Soviet ‘Bloc of Rights and Trotskyites’” (or the Bukharin-Rykov Trial, also known as the ‘Trial of the Twenty-One‘, March 1938)

Bucharin.bra.jpg
Above: Russian revolutionary Nikolai Bukharin (1888 – 1938)

Alexei Rykov.jpg
Above: Alexei Rykov (1881 – 1938)

The defendants were Old Bolshevik Party (“old party guard“) leaders and top officials of the Soviet Secret Police (KGB).

Emblema KGB.svg
Above: Emblem of the KGB

Most were charged under Article 58 of the RSFSR Penal Code with conspiring with the Western powers to assassinate Stalin and other Soviet leaders, dismember the Soviet Union, and restore capitalism.

Several prominent figures were sentenced to death during this period outside these trials.

The Moscow Trials led to the execution of many of the defendants.

The trials are generally seen as part of Stalin’s Great Purge, a campaign to rid the party of current or prior opposition, including Trotskyists and leading Bolshevik cadre members from the time of the Russian Revolution or earlier, who might even potentially become a figurehead for the growing discontent in the Soviet populace resulting from Stalin’s mismanagement of the economy.

Stalin’s rapid industrialization during the period of the First Five Year Plan and the brutality of the forced agricultural collectivization had led to an acute economic and political crisis (1928 – 1933), made worse by the global Great Depression, which led to enormous suffering on the part of the Soviet workers and peasants.

Stalin was acutely conscious of this fact and took steps to prevent it taking the form of an opposition inside the Communist Party of the Soviet Union to his increasingly totalitarian rule.)

КПСС.svg
Above: Flag of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union with face of Vladimir Lenin (1870 – 1924)

In late 1936, Spender married Inez Pearn, whom he had recently met at an Aid to Spain meeting.

She is described as ‘small and rather ironic‘ and ‘strikingly good-looking‘.

Spender was married to his first wife, Inez, having been part-converted to heterosexuality through an affair with an American, Muriel Gardiner.

Sleeping with a woman, he told Isherwood, was “more satisfactory, more terrible, more disgusting, and, in fact, more everything“.

One of his poems speaks of having “a third mouth of the dark to kiss“.

The marriage to Inez ended as the Second World War began.

The poet who was Britain's pottiest parent: His son describes the love  affairs, the holidays alone and breastfeeding kittens | Daily Mail Online
Above: Inez and Stephen Spender

In 1937, during the Spanish Civil War, the Daily Worker sent him to Spain on a mission to observe and report on the Soviet ship Komsomol, which had sunk while carrying Soviet weapons to the Second Spanish Republic.

Leninsky Komsomol-class cargo ship - Wikipedia
Above: The Leninsky-Komsomol class cargo ship Ravenstvo

Spender travelled to Tangier and tried to enter Spain via Cadiz, but was sent back.

He then travelled to Valencia, where he met Ernest Hemingway and Manuel Altolaguirre. 

5 poemas de Manuel Altolaguirre - Zenda
Above: Spanish poet Manuel Altolaguirre (1905 – 1959)

You stared out of the window on the emptiness
Of a world exploding:
Stones and rubble thrown upwards in a fountain
Blasted sideways by the wind.
Every sensation except loneliness
Was drained out of your mind
By the lack of any motionless object the eye could
find.
You were a child again
Who sees for the first time things happen.

When you smiled,
Everything in the room was shattered;
Only you remained whole
In frozen wonder, as though you stared
At your image in the broken mirror
Where it had always been silverly carried.

To A Spanish Poet” (for Manuel Altolaguirre), The Still Centre, 1939

Manuel Altolaguirre - Alchetron, The Free Social Encyclopedia
Above: Manuel Altolaguirre

(Tony Hyndman, alias Jimmy Younger, had joined the International Brigades, which were fighting against Francisco Franco’s forces in the Battle of Guadalajara.)

Emblem of the International Brigades.svg
Above: Emblem of the International Brigades (1936 – 1938), Spanish Civil War

RETRATO DEL GRAL. FRANCISCO FRANCO BAHAMONDE (adjusted levels).jpg
Above: Spanish dictator Francisco Franco (1892 – 1975)

Bundesarchiv Bild 183-2006-1204-500, Spanien, Schlacht um Guadalajara.jpg
Above: Nationalist forces, Battle of Guadalajara, Spain, 8-23 March 1937

The guns spell money’s ultimate reason
In letters of lead on the spring hillside.
But the boy lying dead under the olive trees
Was too young and too silly
To have been notable to their important eye.
He was a better target for a kiss.

His name never appeared in the papers.
The world maintained its traditional wall
Round the dead with their gold sunk deep as a well,
Whilst his life, intangible as a Stock Exchange
rumour, drifted outside.

Consider his life which was valueless
In terms of employment, hotel ledgers, news files.
Consider. One bullet in ten thousand kills a man.
Ask. Was so much expenditure justified
On the death of one so young and so silly
Lying under the olive tree, O world, O death?

Ultima Ratio Regum“, The Still Centre, 1939

In July 1937, Spender attended the Second International Writers’ Congress, the purpose of which was to discuss the attitude of intellectuals to the war, held in Valencia, Barcelona and Madrid, and attended by many writers, including Ernest Hemingway, André Malraux and Pablo Neruda. 

Malraux in 1974
Above: French writer André Malraux (1901 – 1976)

Pablo Neruda 1963.jpg
Above: Chilean poet Pablo Neruda (1904 – 1973)

Pollitt told Spender “to go and get killed.

We need a Byron in the movement.”

Above: Lord Byron on his Death-bed, Joseph-Denis Odevaere – Byron planned to attack the Turkish-held fortress of Lepanto, at the mouth of the Gulf of Corinth. Byron employed a fire-master to prepare artillery, and he took part of the rebel army under his own command, despite his lack of military experience. Before the expedition could sail, on 15 February 1824, he fell ill, and bloodletting weakened him further. He made a partial recovery, but in early April he caught a violent cold, which therapeutic bleeding, insisted on by his doctors, aggravated. This treatment, carried out with unsterilized medical instruments, may have caused him to develop sepsis. He contracted a violent fever and died in Missolonghi on 19 April 1824.

Deep in the winter plain, two armies
Dig their machinery, to destroy each other.
Men freeze and hunger. No one is given leave
On either side, except the dead, and wounded.

All have become so nervous and so cold
That each man hates the cause and distant words
Which brought him here, more terribly than bullets.

Two Armies“, The Still Centre, 1939

Above: Italian tankettes advancing with a flame thrower tank in the lead at Guadalajara

Spender was imprisoned for a while in Albacete.

Above: Members of the International Brigades in the British cookhouse at Albacete raising their fists

In Madrid, he met André Malraux.

They discussed André Gide’s Retour de l’U.R.S.S..

André Gide's Return From the USSR: Retour de l' U.R.S.S. a book by André  Gide and David Grunwald

Because of medical problems, Spender went back to England and bought a house in Lavenham.

In 1939, he divorced.

Lavenham High Street.jpg
Above: High Street, Lavenham, England

His 1938 translations of works by Bertolt Brecht and Miguel Hernández appeared in John Lehmann’s New Writing.

Brecht in 1954
Above: German writer Bertolt Brecht (1898 – 1956)

Miguel Hernandez
Above: Spanish poet Miguel Hernandez (1910 – 1942)

John Lehmann biography
Above: English poet John Lehmann (1907 – 1987)

Spender felt close to the Jewish people.

His mother, Violet Hilda Schuster, was half-Jewish.

(Her father’s family were German Jews who converted to Christianity, and her mother came from an upper-class family of Catholic German, Lutheran Danish and distant Italian descent).

Judaica.jpg
Above: Judaica – Shabbat (Sabbath) candlesticks, the handwashing cup egg-shaped etrog box, the ram’s horn shofar, Torah pointer, the Torah in book-form Tanach

Spender’s second wife, Natasha, whom he married in 1941, was also Jewish.

 In 1941, he married Natasha Litvin, 10 years his junior.

The end of the War coincided with the birth of their first child.

Photos, Biography, Literary Movement - LIFE OF STEPHEN SPENDER
Above: Stephen and Natasha Spender

Spender continued to write poetry throughout his life, but it came to consume less of his literary output in later years than it did in the 1930s and 1940s.

Critics praised his work as an autobiographer and critic.

In a Times Literary Supplement review, Julian Symons noted “the candor of the ceaseless critical self-examination Spender has conducted for more than half a century in autobiography, journals, criticism, poems.

Julian Symons (1912 – 1994) – A Crime is Afoot
Above: British writer Julian Symons (1912 – 1994)

Spender was at his best when he was writing autobiography.

The poet himself pointed echoed this assertion in the postscript to The Thirties and After: Poetry, Politics, People, 1933 – 1970 (1978):

“I myself am, it is only too clear, an autobiographer.

Autobiography provides the line of continuity in my work. I am not someone who can shed or disclaim his past.”

The Thirties and After | SpringerLink

In 1942, he joined the fire brigade of Cricklewood and Maresfield Gardens as a volunteer.

Spender met several times with the poet Edwin Muir.

Edwin Muir.jpg
Above: Scottish poet Edwin Muir (1887 – 1959)

After he was no longer left-wing, he was one of those who wrote of their disillusionment with Communism in the essay collection The God that Failed (1949), along with Arthur Koestler and others.

(The God that Failed is a 1949 collection of six essays by Louis Fischer, André Gide, Arthur Koestler, Ignazio Silone, Stephen Spender and Richard Wright.

The common theme of the essays is the authors’ disillusionment with and abandonment of Communism.)

The God that Failed - Wikipedia

It is thought that one of the big areas of disappointment was the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact between Germany and the Soviet Union, which many leftists saw as a betrayal.

Vyacheslav Molotov Anefo2.jpg
Above: Soviet Foreign Minister Vyacheslav Molotov (1890 – 1986)

Portrait of a middle-aged man with short grey hair and a stern expression. He wears a dark military uniform, with a swastika on one arm. He is seated with his hands on a table with several papers on it, holding a pen.
Above: Nazi Foreign Minister Joachim von Ribbentrop (1893 – 1946)

Like Auden, Isherwood and several other outspoken opponents of fascism in the 1930s, Spender did not see active military service in World War II.

He was initially graded “C” upon examination because of his earlier colitis, poor eyesight, varicose veins and the long-term effects of a tapeworm in 1934.

But he pulled strings to be re-examined and was upgraded to “B“, which meant that he could serve in the London Auxiliary Fire Service.

Spender spent the winter of 1940 teaching at Blundell’s School.

Above: Blundell’s, Tiverton, Devon, England

After the War, Spender was a member of the Allied Control Commission, restoring civil authority in Germany.

Allied Control Commission In Berlin Photograph by Mary Evans Picture Library
Above: Allied Control Commission in Berlin

All the posters on the walls
All the leaflets in the streets
Are mutilated, destroyed or run in rain,
Their words blotted out with tears,
Skins peeling from their bodies
In the victorious hurricane.

All the lessons learned, unlearned;
The young, who learned to read, now blind
Their eyes with an archaic film;
The peasant relapses to a stumbling tune
Following the donkey`s bray;
These only remember to forget.

But somewhere some word presses
On the high door of a skull and in some corner
Of an irrefrangible eye
Some old man memory jumps to a child
— Spark from the days of energy.
And the child hoards it like a bitter toy.

Fall of a City“, Selected Poems, 1941

Battle of Berlin - Wikipedia
Above: Berlin at the end of World War II

With Cyril Connolly and Peter Watson, Spender co-founded Horizon magazine and served as its editor from 1939 to 1941.

Above: Cyril Connolly

Queer saint' Peter Watson left his mark on British culture by bankrolling  artworld giants | The Independent | The Independent
Above: English arts benefactor Peter Watson (1908 – 1956)

Horizon: April 1940 by edited by Cyril - First edition - 1940 - from  Between the Covers- Rare Books, Inc. ABAA (SKU: 75362)

A poet can only write about what is true to his own experience, not about what he would like to be true to his experience.


Poetry does not state truth.

It states the conditions within which something felt is true.

Even while he is writing about the little portion of reality which is part of his experience, the poet may be conscious of a different reality outside.

His problem is to relate the small truth to the sense of a wider, perhaps theoretically known, truth outside his experience.

Foreword“, The Still Centre (1939)

Stephen Spender Quotes | Profound quotes, Writing poetry, Wise quotes

From 1947 to 1949, he went to the US several times and saw Auden and Isherwood.

Flag of the United States
Above: Flag of the United States of America

Since we are what we are, what shall we be
But what we are?
 We are, we have
Six feet and seventy years, to see
The light, and then resign it for the grave.

Spiritual Explorations” from Poems of Dedication (1947)

POEMS OF DEDICATION | Stephen Spender | First Edition

He was the editor of Encounter magazine from 1953 to 1966, but resigned after it emerged that the Congress for Cultural Freedom, which published it, was covertly funded by the CIA. 

Spender insisted that he was unaware of the ultimate source of the magazine’s funds.

Encounter - Powerbase

Annual program 2017 - Announcements - e-flux

Seal of the Central Intelligence Agency.svg

He taught at various American institutions and accepted the Elliston Chair of Poetry at the University of Cincinnati in 1954.

University of Cincinnati seal.svg

In 1961, he became professor of rhetoric at Gresham College, London.

Gresham College logo.svg

Spender helped found the magazine Index on Censorship, was involved in the founding of the Poetry Book Society and did work for UNESCO.

UNESCO logo English.svg

(Index on Censorship is an organization campaigning for freedom of expression, which produces a quarterly magazine of the same name from London.

Index raster-rgb.png

It is directed by the non-profit-making Writers and Scholars International, Ltd. (WSI) in association with the UK-registered charity Index on Censorship (founded as the Writers and Scholars Educational Trust), which are both chaired by the British television broadcaster, writer and former politician Trevor Phillips.

Flickr - boellstiftung - Trevor Phillips.jpg
Above: Trevor Phillips

 

Index is based at 1 Rivington Place in central London.

WSI was created by poet Stephen Spender, Oxford philosopher Stuart Hampshire, the publisher and editor of The Observer David Astor, and the writer and expert on the Soviet Union Edward Crankshaw.

Above: Stuart Hampshire (1914 – 2004)

David Astor: a king in the golden age of print | David Astor | The Guardian
Above: David Astor (1912 – 2001)

Edward Crankshaw - Peters Fraser and Dunlop (PFD) Literary Agents
Above: Edward Crankshaw (1909 – 1984)

The founding editor of Index on Censorship was the critic and translator Michael Scammell, who still serves as a patron of the organization.

Mike Scammell
Above: Michael Scammell

The original impetus for the creation of Index on Censorship came from an open letter addressed “To World Public Opinion” by two Soviet dissenters, Pavel Litvinov and Larisa Bogoraz.

Russian Dissident Litvinov Condemns Zeman - Supports Drahos - Prague  Business Journal
Above: Soviet dissident Pavel Litvinov

BogorazL.jpg
Above: Soviet dissident Larisa Bogoraz

In the words of the samizdat periodical A Chronicle of Current Events, they described “the atmosphere of illegality” surrounding the January 1968 trial of Ginzburg and Galanskov and called for “public condemnation of this disgraceful trial, for the punishment of those responsible, the release of the accused from detention and a retrial which would fully conform with the legal regulations and be held in the presence of international observers.

A Chronicle of Current Events Nr 58: 9780862100360: Amazon.com: Books

(Alexander Ginzburg resumed his dissident activities on release from the camps, until expelled from the USSR in 1979.

Alexander Ginzburg 1980.jpg
Above: Alexander Ginzburg (1936 – 2002)

The writer Yuri Galanskov died in a camp in November 1972.)

Yury Galanskov, 1939-1972 (28.2) – A Chronicle of Current Events
Above: Yuri Galanskov (1939 – 1972)

The Times (London) published a translation of the open letter and in reply the English poet Stephen Spender composed a brief telegram:

We, a group of friends representing no organisation, support your statement, admire your courage, think of you and will help in any way possible.

The Times logo.svg

Among the other 15 British and US signatories were:

  • the poet W. H. Auden

WH Auden: the poet for our times | Saturday Review | The Times
Above: W.H. Auden

  • English philosopher A. J. Ayer

Alfred Jules Ayer.jpg
Above: Alfred Jules Ayer (1910 – 1989)

  • American-British musician Yehudi Menuhin

Above: Yehudi Menuhin (1916 – 1999)

  • English man of letters J. B. Priestley

J. B. Priestley at work in the study at his home in Highgate, London
Above: John Boynton Priestley (1894 – 1984)

  • English actor Paul Scofield

Paul Scofield Allan Warren.jpg
Above: Paul Scofield (1922 – 2008)

  • English sculptor Henry Moore

Henry Moore in workshop Allan Warren.jpg
Above: Henry Moore (1898 – 1986)

  • British philosopher Bertrand Russell

Bertrand Russell 1957.jpg
Above: Bertrand Russell (1872 – 1970)

  • American writer Mary McCarthy

The Formidable Friendship of Mary McCarthy and Hannah Arendt | The New  Yorker
Above: Mary McCarthy

  • Russian-French-American composer Igor Stravinsky

Above: Igor Stravinsky (1882 – 1971)

Later that year, on 25 August, Bogoraz, Litvinov and five others demonstrated on Red Square against the invasion of Czechoslovakia.

Above: “For your freedom and ours“, one of the banners of the Red Square demonstrators

Lobnoe place Moscow.jpg
Above: Lobnoye Mesto (Place of Proclamation), Red Square, Moscow, Russia

František Dostál Srpen 1968 4 (cropped).jpg
Above: Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia, 20-21 August 1968

A few weeks before, Litvinov sent Spender a letter (translated and published several years later in the first May 1972 issue of Index).

He suggested that a regular publication might be set up in the West “to provide information to world public opinion about the real state of affairs in the USSR“.

Flag of the Soviet Union
Above: Flag of the Soviet Union (1922 – 1991)

Spender and his colleagues, Stuart Hampshire, David Astor, Edward Crankshaw and founding editor Michael Scammell decided, like Amnesty International, to cast their net wider.

They wished to document patterns of censorship in right-wing dictatorships — the military regimes of Latin America and the dictatorships in Greece, Spain and Portugal — as well as the Soviet Union and its satellites.

Latin America (orthographic projection).svg
Above: Latin America (in green)

Flag of Greece
Above: Flag of Greece

Flag of Portugal
Above: Flag of Portugal

Meanwhile, in 1971, Amnesty International began to publish English translations of each new issue of A Chronicle of Current Events, which documented human rights abuses in the USSR and included a regular “Samizdat Update“.

Amnesty International logo.svg

In a recent interview, Michael Scammell explains the informal division of labour between the two London-based organizations:

When we received human rights material we forwarded it to Amnesty and when Amnesty received a report of censorship they passed it on to us.”

View of Tower Bridge from Shad Thames
Above: Tower Bridge, London

Originally, as suggested by Scammell, the magazine was to be called Index, a reference to the lists or indices of banned works that are central to the history of censorship: the Roman Catholic Church’s Index Librorum Prohibitorum (Index of Forbidden Books), the Soviet Union’s Censor’s Index, and apartheid South Africa’s Jacobsens Index of Objectionable Literature.

Above: Title page of Index Librorum Prohibitorum (Venice 1564)

USSR: Censoring history, literature, science and religion - August 1980  Index on Censorship

Guide – The Literature Police

Scammell later admitted that the words “on censorship” were added as an afterthought when it was realised that the reference would not be clear to many readers.

Panicking, we hastily added the words ‘on Censorship’ as a subtitle“, wrote Scammell in the December 1981 issue of the magazine, “and this it has remained ever since, nagging me with its ungrammaticality (Index of Censorship, surely) and a standing apology for the opacity of its title.”

Describing the organization’s objectives at its inception, Stuart Hampshire said:

The tyrant’s concealments of oppression and of absolute cruelty should always be challenged.

There should be noise of publicity outside every detention centre and concentration camp and a published record of every tyrannical denial of free expression.”

Autumn magazine 2015: Spies, secrets and lies - Index on Censorship Index  on Censorship

Index on Censorship magazine was founded by Michael Scammell in 1972.

It supports free expression, publishing distinguished writers from around the world, exposing suppressed stories, initiating debate, and providing an international record of censorship.

The quarterly editions of the magazine usually focus on a country or region or a recurring theme in the global free expression debate. 

Index on Censorship also publishes short works of fiction and poetry by notable new writers. 

Challenging the censors - April 1987 Index on Censorship

Index Index, a round-up of abuses of freedom of expression worldwide, was published in the magazine until December 2008.

While the original inspiration to create Index came from Soviet dissidents, from its outset the magazine covered censorship in right-wing dictatorships then ruling Greece and Portugal, the military regimes of Latin America, and the Soviet Union and its satellites.

The magazine has covered other challenges facing free expression, including religious extremism, the rise of nationalism, and Internet censorship.

In the first issue of May 1972, Stephen Spender wrote:

Obviously there is the risk of a magazine of this kind becoming a bulletin of frustration.

However, the material by writers which is censored in Eastern Europe, Greece, South Africa and other countries is among the most exciting that is being written today.

Moreover, the question of censorship has become a matter of impassioned debate and it is one which does not only concern totalitarian societies.

Index on Censorship: Complicity: Why and when we choose to censor ourselves  and give away our privacy (Index on Censorship) by Rachael Jolley | WHSmith

Issues are usually organised by theme and contain a country-by-country list of recent cases involving censorship, restrictions on freedom of the press and other free speech violations.

Occasionally, Index on Censorship publishes short works of fiction and poetry by notable new writers as well as censored ones.

Over the half century it has been in existence, Index on Censorship has presented works by some of the world’s most distinguished writers and thinkers, including: 

  • Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn 

Solzhenitsyn in February 1974
Above: Russian writer Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (1918 – 2008)

  • Milan Kundera

Milan Kundera in 1980
Above: Czech writer Milan Kundera

  • Václav Havel

Vaclav Havel.jpg
Above: Czech writer/President Vaclav Havel (1936 – 2011)

  • Nadine Gordimer

Gordimer at the Göteborg Book Fair, 2010
Above: South African writer/activist Nadine Gordimer (1923 – 2014)

  • Salman Rushdie

Rushdie at the 2016 Hay Festival
Above: Indian-British-American writer Salman Rushdie

  • Doris Lessing

Lessing at the Lit. Cologne literary festival in 2006
Above: British-Zimbabwean writer Doris Lessing (1919 – 2013)

  • Arthur Miller

Miller in 1997
Above: American playwright Arthur Miller (1915 – 2005)

  • Noam Chomsky

A photograph of Noam Chomsky
Above: American linguist/philosopher/activist Noam Chomsky

  • Umberto Eco

Italiaanse schrijver Umberto Eco, portret.jpg
Above: Italian writer Umberto Eco (1932 – 2016)

Issues under the editorship of Rachael Jolley have covered taboos, the legacy of the Magna Carta and William Shakespeare’s enduring legacy in protest.

Magna Carta (British Library Cotton MS Augustus II.106).jpg
Above: The Magna Carta (Great Charter) of 1215

Index on Censorship: Staging Shakespearian Dissent : Plays That Provoke,  Protest and Slip by the Censors (Paperback) - Walmart.com - Walmart.com

There have been special issues on China, reporting from the Middle East, and on Internet censorship.

China: Unofficial texts for the first time in English- September 1979 Index  on Censorship

Middle East: Algeria erupts, Taboo in Tunisia - January 1989 - Index on  Censorship

Global Freedom of Expression | Internet Censorship 2020: A Global Map of  Internet Restrictions - Global Freedom of Expression
Above: Global Freedom of Expression – Internet Censorship 2020: A Global Map of Internet Restrictions

The Russia issue (January 2008) won an Amnesty International Media Award 2008 for features by Russian journalists Fatima Tlisova and Sergei Bachinin, and veteran Russian free speech campaigner Alexei Simonov, founder of the Glasnost Defence Foundation.

List of issues Index on Censorship

Other landmark publications include Ken Saro-Wiwa’s writings from prison (Issue 3/1997) and a translation of the Czechoslovak Charter 77 manifesto drafted by Václav Havel and others in Issue 3/1977.

Ken Saro-Wiwa.jpg
Above: Nigerian writer/environmental activist Ken Saro-Wiwa (1941 – 1995)

Above: Charter 77 Memorial, Prague, Czech Republic

Index published the first English translation of Alexander Solzhenitsyn’s Nobel Prize acceptance speech. 

A golden medallion with an embossed image of Alfred Nobel facing left in profile. To the left of the man is the text "ALFR•" then "NOBEL", and on the right, the text (smaller) "NAT•" then "MDCCCXXXIII" above, followed by (smaller) "OB•" then "MDCCCXCVI" below.

Index on Censorship published the stories of the “disappeared” in Argentina and the work of banned poets in Cuba, the work of Chinese poets who escaped the massacres that ended the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. 

Nunca Mas: Argentina's 9,000 "disappeared" persons - March 1986 Index on  Censorship

Flag of Cuba
Above: Flag of Cuba

Tank Man (Tiananmen Square protester).jpg
Above: “Tank Man” blocks a column of Type 59 tanks heading east on Beijing’s Chang’an Boulevard (Avenue of Eternal Peace) near Tiananmen Square during the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. This photo was taken from the 6th floor of the Beijing Hotel, about half a mile away, through a 800 mm lens at 1/30th of a second on 5 June 1989. The name and fate of the man is unknown.

(The Tiananmen Square protests were student-led demonstrations held in Tiananmen Square, Beijing during 1989.

In what is known as the Tiananmen Square Massacre, troops armed with assault rifles and accompanied by tanks fired at the demonstrators and those trying to block the military’s advance into Tiananmen Square.

The protests started on 15 April and were forcibly suppressed on 4 June when the government declared martial law and sent the People’s Liberation Army to occupy parts of central Beijing.

Estimates of the death toll vary from several hundred to several thousand, with thousands more wounded.

The popular national movement inspired by the Beijing protests is sometimes called the ’89 Democracy Movement or the Tiananmen Square Incident.

Tiananmen Square: What happened in the protests of 1989? - BBC News

The protests were precipitated by the death of pro-reform Chinese Communist Party (CCP) General Secretary Hu Yaobang in April 1989 amid the backdrop of rapid economic development and social change in post-Mao China, reflecting anxieties among the people and political elite about the country’s future.

Hu Yaobang 1953.jpg
Above: Chinese reformer Hu Yaobang (1915 – 1989)

The reforms of the 1980s had led to a nascent market economy that benefited some people but seriously disadvantaged others.

The one-party political system also faced a challenge to its legitimacy.

Common grievances at the time included inflation, corruption, limited preparedness of graduates for the new economy, and restrictions on political participation.

Although they were highly disorganized and their goals varied, the students called for greater accountability, constitutional due process, democracy, freedom of the press, and freedom of speech.

At the height of the protests, about one million people assembled in the Square.

Rare Photos Of China's 1989 Tiananmen Square Protests : The Picture Show :  NPR

As the protests developed, the authorities responded with both conciliatory and hardline tactics, exposing deep divisions within the party leadership.

By May, a student-led hunger strike galvanized support around the country for the demonstrators.

The protests spread to some 400 cities.

Among the CCP top leadership, Premier Li Peng and Party Elders Li Xiannian and Wang Zhen called for decisive action through violent suppression of the protesters, and ultimately managed to win over Paramount Leader Deng Xiaoping and President Yang Shangkun to their side.

Lipeng.jpg
Above: Li Peng (1928 – 2019)

Li Xiannian.png
Above: Li Xiannian (1909 – 1992)

Wangzhen1955.jpg
Above: Wang Zhen (1908 – 1993)

Deng Xiaoping and Jimmy Carter at the arrival ceremony for the Vice Premier of China. - NARA - 183157-restored(cropped).jpg
Above: Deng Xiaoping (1904 – 1997)

中央办公厅主任杨尚昆.jpg
Above: Yang Shangkun

On 20 May, the State Council declared martial law.

They mobilized as many as 300,000 troops to Beijing.

The troops advanced into central parts of Beijing on the city’s major thoroughfares in the early morning hours of 4 June, killing both demonstrators and bystanders in the process.

The military operations were under the overall command of General Baibing, half-brother of President Yang Shangkun.

Yang Baibing.jpg
Above: Yang Baibing

As it happened June 4-5, 1989: Tanks rumble out of Tiananmen Square | The  Times of Israel

The international community, human rights organizations, and political analysts condemned the Chinese government for the massacre.

Western countries imposed arms embargoes on China.

The Chinese government made widespread arrests of protesters and their supporters, suppressed other protests around China, expelled foreign journalists, strictly controlled coverage of the events in the domestic press, strengthened the police and internal security forces, and demoted or purged officials it deemed sympathetic to the protests.

More broadly, the suppression ended the political reforms begun in 1986 and halted the policies of liberalization of the 1980s, which were only partly resumed after Deng Xiaoping’s Southern Tour in 1992.

Considered a watershed event, reaction to the protests set limits on political expression in China, limits that have lasted up to the present day.

Remembering the protests is widely associated with questioning the legitimacy of CCP rule and remains one of the most sensitive and most widely censored topics in China.)

No, 10,000 were not killed in China's 1989 Tiananmen crackdown – SupChina

Index on Censorship has a long history of publishing writers in translation, including Bernard Henri Lévy, Ivan Klima, Ma Jian and Nobel laureate Shirin Ebadi, and news reports including Anna Politkovskaia’s coverage of the war in Chechnya (Issue 2/2002).

Bernard Henri Lévy (cropped).jpg
Above: French philosopher Bernard Henri Lévy

Ivan Klíma (May 2009)
Above: Czech writer Ivan Klima

Ma Jian in November 2018
Above: Chinese-British writer Ma Jian

Shirin Ebadi 01.jpg
Above: Iranian political activist Shirin Ebadi

Politkovskaya during a March 2005 interview in Leipzig, Germany
Above: Russian journalist Anna Politkovskaya (1958 – 2006)

Tom Stoppard’s play Every Good Boy Deserves Favour (1977) is set in a Soviet mental institution and was inspired by the personal account of former detainee Victor Fainberg and Clayton Yeo’s expose of the use of psychiatric abuse in the USSR, were published in Index on Censorship (Issue 2, 1975).

The play was first performed with the London Symphony Orchestra.

Stoppard became a member of the advisory board of Index on Censorship in 1978 and remains connected to the publication as a patron of Index.

Man smiling wearing open necked shirt indoors
Above: Czech-British playwright Tom Stoppard

Index on Censorship published the World Statement by the International Committee for the Defence of Salman Rushdie in support of “the right of all people to express their ideas and beliefs and to discuss them with their critics on the basis of mutual tolerance, free from censorship, intimidation and violence“.

The Satanic Verses by Salman Rushdie 1st/1st Viking 1988: Amazon.co.uk: Salman  Rushdie: Books

(The Satanic Verses is British writer Salman Rushdie’s 4th novel, first published 26 September 1988 and inspired in part by the life of the Islamic prophet Muhammad.

As with his previous books, Rushdie used magical realism and relied on contemporary events and people to create his characters.
The title refers to the Satanic Verses, a group of Quranic verses that refer to three pagan Meccan goddesses: Allat, Uzza, and Manat.

The part of the story that deals with the “satanic verses” was based on accounts from the historians al-Waqidi and al-Tabari.

In the United Kingdom, The Satanic Verses received positive reviews, was a 1988 Booker Prize finalist, and won the 1988 Whitbread Award for novel of the year.

However, major controversy ensued as Muslims accused it of blasphemy and mocking their faith.

The outrage among Muslims resulted in Supreme Leader of Iran Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, calling for Rushdie’s death on 14 February 1989.




Ruhollah Khomeini portrait 1.jpg

Above: Ayatollah Khomeini (1900 – 1989)




The result was several failed assassination attempts on Rushdie, who was placed under police protection by the UK government, and attacks on several connected individuals, including the murder of translator Hitoshi Igarashi.




Hitoshi Igarashi.jpg

Above: Hitoshi Igarashi (1947 – 1991)




The book was banned in India as hate speech directed toward Muslims.)

Horizontal tricolour flag bearing, from top to bottom, deep saffron, white, and green horizontal bands. In the centre of the white band is a navy-blue wheel with 24 spokes.
Above: Flag of India

(As much as I advocate freedom of expression, I feel that this power to express one’s opinions needs to be balanced by a sense of responsibility.

Those who were surprised by the trouble caused by Rushdie’s book failed to understand that in questioning the singularity of God the Satanic Verses ignored or subverted the supreme importance that all Muslims bestow on God’s unity – in addition to being disrespectful to the Prophet.

Rushdie’s sin was to give credence to a pre-Islamic belief that Allah had three daughters, each of whom held divine power.

The Prophet Muhammad’s teaching holds that God had neither wife nor children, and this would have been incompatible with His role as the Creator and the Almighty.

To believe that God is not omnipotent (all and solely powerful) is to commit shirk.

In strict Muslim societies, shirk is so serious that the only appropriate punishment is death.

The West regarded the outcry over the Verses as an affront to freedom of speech.

However, the important lesson to be learned from the Rushdie incident is that, to strict Muslims, the central tenets of Islam are so powerful that they can transcend all other considerations.

Personally, I think that God, should He exist, can defend Himself and does not need Man to defend His honour for Him.

That being said, Rushdie is a fool who should have known better, considering he came from an Islamist background and is a highly-educated man.)

Above: Salman Rushdie

Six months later, Index published the Hunger Strike Declaration from four student leaders of the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989, Liu Xiaobo, Zhou Duo, Hou Dejian and Gao Xin.

Liu Xiaobo.jpg
Above: Liu Xiaobo (1955 – 2017)

He Stayed at Tiananmen to the End. Now He Wonders What It Meant. - The New  York Times
Above: Zhou Duo

Hou Dejian ((Chinese: 侯德健; pinyin: Hóu Déjiàn; Wade–Giles: Hou Te-Chien,  Cantonese: Hau Dak-gin) şarkı sözleri - TR

324 Gao Xin Photos and Premium High Res Pictures - Getty Images
Above: Gao Xin

Index Index, a round-up of abuses of freedom of expression worldwide, continued to be published in each edition of the magazine until December 2008, when this function was transferred to the website.

The offences against free expression documented in that first issue’s Index Index listing included censorship in Greece and Spain, then dictatorships, and Brazil, which had just banned the film Zabriskie Point on the grounds that it “insulted a friendly power” – the United States, where it had been made and freely shown.

1ZabriskiePoint.jpg

(Zabriskie Point is a 1970 American drama film directed by Michelangelo Antonioni (1912 – 2007) and starring Mark Frechette (1947 – 1975), Daria Halprin and Rod Taylor (1930 – 2015).

It was widely noted at the time for its setting in the counterculture of the United States.

Some of the film’s scenes were shot on location at Zabriskie Point in Death Valley.

The film was an overwhelming commercial failure and was panned by most critics upon release. 

Its critical standing has increased, however, in the decades since. 

It has to some extent achieved cult status and is noted for its cinematography, use of music, and direction.)

Index on Censorship paid special attention to the situation in then Czechoslovakia between the Soviet invasion of 1968 and the Velvet Revolution of 1989, devoting an entire issue to the country eight years after the Prague Spring (Issue 3/1976).

Praha 1989-11-25, Letná, dav (01).jpg
Above: Prague during the Velvet Revolution, 25 November 1989

10 Soviet Invasion of Czechoslovakia - Flickr - The Central Intelligence Agency.jpg
Above: During the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia, Czechoslovaks carry their national flag past a burning tank in Prague, 1 January 1968.

It included several pieces by Václav Havel, including a first translation of his one act play Conversation, and a letter to Czech officials on police censorship of his December 1975 production of The Beggar’s Opera by John Gay.

Czechoslovakia eight years after: 4 cases - Autumn 1976 Index on Censorship

The magazine also carried articles on the state of the Czech theatre and a list of the so-called Padlock Publications, 50 banned books that circulated only in typescript.

Cuba today:identity, soul, Fidel, and worldview - March 1989 - Index on  Censorship

Index also published an English version of Havel’s play Mistake, dedicated to Samuel Beckett in gratitude for Beckett’s own dedication of his play Catastrophe to Havel.

Both short plays were performed at the Free Word Centre to mark the launch of Index‘s special issue looking back at the changes of 1989 (Issue 4, 2009).

Beckett in 1977
Above: Irish playwright Samuel Beckett (1906 – 1989)

Free Speech is not For Sale, a joint campaign report by Index on Censorship and English PEN highlighted the problem of so-called libel tourism (actively searching for reasons to sue) and the English law of defamation’s chilling effect on free speech.

Free Speech Is Not For Sale | PDF | Defamation | Freedom Of Speech

After much debate surrounding the report’s ten key recommendations, the UK Justice Secretary Jack Straw pledged to make English defamation laws fairer.

A free press can’t operate or be effective unless it can offer readers comment as well as news.

What concerns me is that the current arrangements are being used by big corporations to restrict fair comment, not always by journalists but also by academics.

He added:

The very high levels of remuneration for defamation lawyers in Britain seem to be incentivising libel tourism.”

Jack Straw 2.jpg
Above: MP Jack Straw

These campaigns and others were illustrative of then CEO John Kampfner’s strategy, supported by then chair Jonathan Dimbleby, to boost Index‘s public advocacy profile in the UK and abroad beginning in 2008.

John Kampfner, Creative Industries Federation in London.jpg
Above: Singaporean-British writer John Kampfner

Until then the organization did not regard itself as “a campaigning organisation in the mould of Article 19 or Amnesty International“, as former news editor Sarah Smith noted in 2001, preferring to use its “understanding of what is newsworthy and politically significant” to maintain pressure on oppressive regimes (such as China, from 1989) through extensive coverage.

LOGO ARTICLE 19.jpg

Index on Censorship also runs a programme of UK based and international projects that put the organization’s philosophy into practice.

In 2009 and 2010, Index on Censorship worked in Afghanistan, Burma, Iraq, Tunisia and many other countries, in support of journalists, broadcasters, artists and writers who work against a backdrop of intimidation, repression, and censorship.

The organization’s arts programmes investigate the impact of current and recent social and political change on arts practitioners, assessing the degree and depth of self-censorship.

It uses the arts to engage young people directly into the freedom of expression debate.

It works with marginalised communities in UK, creating new platforms, on line and actual for creative expression.

Editor's letter: All hail those who speak out - Index on Censorship Index  on Censorship

Index on Censorship works internationally to commission new work, not only articles for print and online, but also new photography, film & video, visual arts and performance.

Examples have included an exhibition of photo stories produced by women in Iraq, Open Shutters, and programme involving artists from refugee and migrant communities in UK, linking with artists from their country of origin, imagine art after, exhibited at Tate Britain in 2007.

Standard8 | Open Shutters Iraq
Above: Open Shutters Iraq exhibition, Tate Gallery, London

Index has also worked with Burmese exiled artists and publishers on creating a programme in support of the collective efforts of Myanmar’s creative community.

Index also commissioned a new play by Actors for Human Rights, Seven Years With Hard Labour, weaving together four accounts from former Burmese political prisoners now living in the UK. 

Flag of Myanmar
Above: Flag of Myanmar

Index also co-published a book of poetry by homeless people in London and St. Petersburg.

Index on Censorship: The Global Magazine for Free Expression Index on  Censorship

In December 2002, Index on Censorship faced calls to cancel a charity performance of the John Malkovich film The Dancer Upstairs at London’s Institute of Contemporary Arts (ICA).

The Dancer Upstairs Poster.jpg

Speaking to students the previous May, Malkovich had been asked whom – as the star of Dangerous Liaisons – he would like to fight a duel with.

John Malkovich at a screening of "Casanova Variations" in January 2015.jpg
Above: John Malkovich

He picked Robert Fisk, The Independent newspaper’s Middle East correspondent, and George Galloway, at the time a Glasgow Labour MP, adding that rather than duel them, he would “rather just shoot them“.

George Galloway 2007-02-24, 02.jpg
Above: George Galloway

Fisk wrote an article saying that Malkovich’s comment was one of many threats he now received and that “almost anyone who criticizes US or Israeli policy in the Middle East is now in this free-fire zone“.

Robert Fisk at Al Jazeera Forum 2010 (cropped).jpg
Above: Robert Fisk (1946 – 2020)

The media rights group Reporters sans Frontieres (RSF) (Reporters without Borders) condemned Malkovich, but in an online article Index‘s then Associate Editor (now deputy CEO) Rohan Jayasekera, dismissed the actor’s comments as “flippant” in an article on the organization’s site.

File:RSF 2020 logo min.svg

In November 2004, Index on Censorship attracted further controversy over another indexonline.org blog post by Jayasekera that, to many readers, seemed to condone or justify the murder of Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh.

The blog described Van Gogh was a “free speech fundamentalist” on a “martyrdom operation, roaring his Muslim critics into silence with obscenities” in an “abuse of his right to free speech“.

Theo van Gogh
Above: Theo van Gogh (1957 – 2004)

Describing Van Gogh’s film Submission as “furiously provocative“, Jayasekera concluded by describing his death as:

A sensational climax to a lifetime’s public performance, stabbed and shot by a bearded fundamentalist, a message from the killer pinned by a dagger to his chest, Theo Van Gogh became a martyr to free expression.

His passing was marked by a magnificent barrage of noise as Amsterdam hit the streets to celebrate him in the way the man himself would have truly appreciated.

And what timing!

Just as his long-awaited biographical film of Pim Fortuyn’s life is ready to screen.

Bravo, Theo!

Bravo!”

Submission Part I.png

Submission is a 2004 English-language Dutch short drama film produced and directed by Theo van Gogh, and written by Ayaan Hirsi Ali (a former member of the Dutch House of Representatives for the People’s Party for Freedom and Democracy).

It was shown on the Dutch public broadcasting network (VPRO) on 29 August 2004.

The film’s title is one of the possible translations of the Arabic word “Islam“.

The film tells the story of four fictional characters played by a single actress wearing a veil, but clad in a see-through Hijab, her naked body painted with verses from the Quran.

The characters are Muslim women who have been abused in various ways.

The film contains monologues of these women and dramatically highlights three verses of the Koran, by showing them painted on women’s bodies.

Writer Hirsi Ali has said:

It is written in the Koran a woman may be slapped if she is disobedient.

This is one of the evils I wish to point out in the film“. 

In an answer to a question about whether the film would offend Muslims, Hirsi Ali said that:

If you’re a Muslim woman and you read the Koran, and you read in there that you should be raped if you say ‘no’ to your husband, that is offensive.

And that is insulting.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali by Gage Skidmore.jpg
Above: Somali-Dutch-American social activist Ayaan Hirsi Ali

Director of the film, Theo Van Gogh, who was known as a controversial and provocative personality, called the film a “political pamphlet“.

Van Gogh'un Kardeşinin, Hollanda'nın Ortasında Öldürülen Torunu: Theo Van  Gogh - Ekşi Şeyler
Above: Theo van Gogh

The film drew praise for portraying the ways in which women are abused in accordance with fundamentalist Islamic law, as well as anger for criticizing Islamic canon itself. 

It drew the following comment from movie critic Phil Hall:

Submission was bold in openly questioning misogyny and a culture of violence against women because of Koranic interpretations.

The questions raised in the film deserve to be asked:

Is it divine will to assault or kill women?

Is there holiness in holding women at substandard levels, denying them the right to free will and independent thought?

And ultimately, how can such a mind frame exist in the 21st century?

From defending Fred Goodwin to Qatar: Former News of the World editor Phil  Hall on ten years in PR - Press Gazette
Above: Phil Hall

 

Film critic Dennis Lim, on the other hand, stated that:

It’s depressing to think that this morsel of glib effrontery could pass as a serious critique of conservative Islam.

Another critic referred to the stories told in the film as “simplistic, even caricatures“.

Dennis Lim, director of programming at the Film Society of Lincoln Center -  UniFrance
Above: Dennis Lim

After the film’s broadcast on Dutch television, newspaper De Volkskrant reported claims of plagiarism against Hirsi Ali and Van Gogh, made by Internet journalist Francisco van Jole.

File:Volkskrant.svg - Wikimedia Commons

Van Jole said the duo had “aped” the ideas of Iranian American video artist Shirin Neshat.

Francisco van Jole - The Next Speaker
Above: Francisco van Jole

Neshat’s work, which made abundant use of Persian calligraphy projected onto bodies, had been shown in the Netherlands in 1997 and 2000.

Viennale talk (2), Shirin Neshat.jpg
Above: Shirin Neshat

On 2 November 2004, Van Gogh was assassinated in public by Mohammed Bouyeri, a Dutch-Moroccan Muslim with a Dutch passport.

A letter, stabbed through and affixed to the body by a dagger, linked the murder to Van Gogh’s film and his views regarding Islam.

It was addressed to Ayaan Hirsi Ali and called for a jihad (holy war) against kafir (unbelievers or infidels), against America, Europe, the Netherlands, and Hirsi Ali herself.

Bouyeri was jailed for life, for which in the Netherlands there is no possibility of parole, and pardons are rarely granted.

Bouyeri.jpg
Above: Mohammed Bouyeri

Following the murder of Van Gogh, tens of thousands gathered in the center of Amsterdam to mourn Van Gogh’s death.

The murder widened and polarized the debate in the Netherlands about the social position of its more than one million Muslim residents.

Flag of Netherlands
Above: Flag of the Netherlands

It also put the country’s liberal tradition further into question, coming only two years after Pim Fortuyn’s murder. 

Pim Fortuyn - May 4.jpg
Above: Pim Fortuyn (1948 – 2002)

(Pim Fortuyn was a Dutch politician, author, civil servant, businessman, sociologist and academic who founded the party Pim Fortuyn List (Lijst Pim Fortuyn or LPF) in 2002.

Fortuyn criticized multiculturism, immigration and Islam in the Netherlands.

He called Islam “a backward culture“, and was quoted as saying that if it were legally possible, he would close the borders for Muslim immigrants.

Fortuyn was assassinated during the 2002 Dutch national election campaign by Volkert van der Graaf, a left-wing environmentalist and animal rights activist. 

In court at his trial, van der Graaf said he murdered Fortuyn to stop him from exploiting Muslims as “scapegoats” and targeting “the weak members of society” in seeking political power.

The assassination shocked many residents of the Netherlands and highlighted the cultural clashes within the country. )

Familie Pim Fortuyn woedend: niets wijst op emigratie moordenaar Volkert  van der Graaf | Politiek | AD.nl
Above: Volkert van der Graaf

In an apparent reaction against controversial statements about the Islamic, Christian and Jewish religions— such as those Van Gogh had made — the Dutch Minister of Justice, Christian Democrat Piet Hein Donner, suggested Dutch blasphemy laws should either be applied more stringently or made more strict.

Piet-hein-donner-portret.jpg
Above: Piet Hein Donner

The liberal D66 party suggested scrapping the blasphemy laws altogether.)

D66 logo (2020).svg

There were many protests from both left- and right-wing commentators regarding Rohan Jayasekera’s comments.

Rohan Jayasekera of Index on Censorship, for IREX Iraqi eMedia - YouTube
Above: Rohan Jayasekera

Nick Cohen of The Observer newspaper wrote in December 2004, that:

When I asked Jayasekera if he had any regrets, he said he had none.

He told me that, like many other readers, I shouldn’t have made the mistake of believing that Index on Censorship was against censorship, even murderous censorship, on principle – in the same way as Amnesty International is opposed to torture, including murderous torture, on principle.

It may have been so its radical youth, but was now as concerned with fighting ‘hate speech’ as protecting free speech.

Nick Cohen
Above: Nick Cohen

Ursula Owen, the chief executive of Index on Censorship, while agreeing that the blog post’s “tone was not right” contradicted Cohen’s account of his conversation with Jayasekera in a letter to The Observer.

NPG x31000; Ursula Margaret Owen - Portrait - National Portrait Gallery
Above: Ursula Owen

In December 2009, the magazine published an interview with Jytte Klausen about a refusal of Yale University Press to include the Mohammed cartoons in Klausen’s book The Cartoons that Shook the World.

The magazine declined to include the cartoons alongside the interview.)

The Cartoons that Shook the World cover.jpg

Across this dazzling
Mediterranean
August morning
The dolphins write such
Ideograms:
With power to wake
Me prisoned in
My human speech
They sign: ‘I AM!’

Dolphins“, Stephen Spender

Bottlenose dolphin

Spender was appointed the 17th Poet Laureate Consultant in Poetry to the Library of Congress in 1965.

Seal of the United States Library of Congress.svg

During the late 1960s, Spender frequently visited the University of Connecticut, which he declared had the “most congenial teaching faculty” he had encountered in the United States.

University of Connecticut seal.svg

Great poetry is always written by somebody straining to go beyond what he can do.

As quoted in The New York Times (26 March 1961)

Stephen Spender : The Authorized Biography: Sutherland, John:  9780670883035: Amazon.com: Books

Spender was Professor of English at University College London (UCL) from 1970 to 1977 and then became Professor Emeritus.

University College London logo.svg

He was made a Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) at the 1962 Queen’s Birthday Honours, and knighted in the 1983 Queen’s Birthday Honours.

CBE AEAColl.jpg

At a ceremony commemorating the 40th anniversary of the Normandy Invasion on 6 June 1984, US President Ronald Reagan (1911 – 2004) quoted from Spender’s poem “The Truly Great” in his remarks:

Gentlemen, I look at you and I think of the words of Stephen Spender’s poem.

You are men who in your “lives fought for life and left the vivid air signed with your honour”.

File:President Ronald Reagan giving speech on the 40th Anniversary of D-Day  (cropped).jpg - Wikimedia Commons

The Truly Great

I think continually of those who were truly great.
Who, from the womb, remembered the soul’s history
Through corridors of light, where the hours are suns,
Endless and singing. Whose lovely ambition
Was that their lips, still touched with fire,
Should tell of the Spirit, clothed from head to foot in song.
And who hoarded from the Spring branches
The desires falling across their bodies like blossoms.


What is precious, is never to forget
The essential delight of the blood drawn from ageless springs
Breaking through rocks in worlds before our earth.
Never to deny its pleasure in the morning simple light
Nor its grave evening demand for love.
Never to allow gradually the traffic to smother
With noise and fog, the flowering of the spirit.


Near the snow, near the sun, in the highest fields,
See how these names are fêted by the waving grass
And by the streamers of white cloud
And whispers of wind in the listening sky.
The names of those who in their lives fought for life,
Who wore at their hearts the fire’s centre.
Born of the sun, they travelled a short while toward the sun
And left the vivid air signed with their honour.

Stephen Spender – The Truly Great | Genius

Spender also had profound intellectual workings with the world of art, including Pablo Picasso.

The Worlds of Stephen Spender – Hauser & Wirth

The artist Henry Moore did etchings and lithographs conceived to accompany the work of writers, including Charles Baudelaire and Spender.

Moore’s work in that regard also included illustrations of the literature of Dante Alighieri, André Gide and William Shakespeare.

The exhibition was held at The Henry Moore Foundation.

Portrait of Stephen Spender – Works – Henry Moore Artwork Catalogue

Spender collected and befriended artists such as: 

  • Jean Arp

Hans Arp.JPG
Above: French artist (1886 – 1966)

  • Frank Auerbach

Above: German-British artist Frank Auerbach

  • Francis Bacon

Above: Irish-British artist Francis Bacon (1909 – 1992)

  • Lucian Freud

LucienFreud.jpg
Above: British artist Lucian Freud (1922 – 2011)

  • Alberto Giacometti

Above: Swiss artist Alberto Giacometti

  • Arshile Gorky

Archives of American Art - Arshile Gorky - 3044.jpg
Above: Armenian-American Arshile Gorky (1904 – 1948)

  • Philip Guston

Profile of the artist
Above: Canadian-American artist Philip Guston (né Goldstein) (1913 – 1980)

  • David Hockney

David Hockney 2017 at Flash Expo.jpg
Above: English artist David Hockney

  • Giorgio Morandi

Giorgio Morandi, cropped.jpg
Above: Italian artist Giorgio Morandi (1890 – 1964)

  • and others.

In The Worlds of Stephen Spender, the artist Frank Auerbach selected art work by those masters to accompany Spender’s poems.

The Worlds of Stephen Spender ARTBOOK | D.A.P. 2018 Catalog Books  Exhibition Catalogues 9783906915197

Spender wrote China Diary with David Hockney in 1982, published by Thames and Hudson art publishers in London.

China Diary. DAVID HOCKNEY | Stephen Spender

The Soviet artist Wassily Kandinsky created an etching for Spender, Fraternity, in 1939.

Wassily Kandinsky | Radierung für Stephen Spender, from Fraternity (1939) |  Artsy
Above: Fraternity – Etching for Stephen Spender, Wassily Kandinsky

Personal Life

In 1933, Spender fell in love with Tony Hyndman, and they lived together from 1935 to 1936.

In 1934, Spender had an affair with Muriel Gardiner.

In December 1936, shortly after the end of his relationship with Hyndman, Spender fell in love with and married Inez Pearn after an engagement of only three weeks.

The marriage broke down in 1939.

In 1941, Spender married Natasha Litvin, a concert pianist.

The marriage lasted until his death.

Stephen Spender - Index on Censorship Index on Censorship
Above: Stephen Spender

Spender’s sexuality has been the subject of debate.

Spender’s seemingly changing attitudes have caused him to be labelled bisexual, repressed, latently homophobic or simply something complex that resists easy labelling. 

Many of his friends in his earlier years were gay.

NPG x2952; W.H. Auden; Christopher Isherwood; Stephen Spender - Portrait -  National Portrait Gallery
Above: W.H. Auden, Christopher Isherwood and Stephen Spender

Spender had many affairs with men in his earlier years, most notably with Hyndman, who was called “Jimmy Younger” in his memoir World Within World.

WORLD WITHIN WORLD. THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF STEPHEN SPENDER by Stephen SPENDER  - First Edition - (1951) - from Charles Agvent (SKU: 015132)

After his affair with Muriel Gardiner, he shifted his focus to heterosexuality, but his relationship with Hyndman complicated both that relationship and his short-lived marriage to Inez Pearn.

His marriage to Natasha Litvin in 1941 seemed to have marked the end of his romantic relationships with men but not the end of all homosexual activity, as his unexpurgated diaries have revealed.

Subsequently, he toned down homosexual allusions in later editions of his poetry.

Nevertheless, he was a founding member of the Homosexual Law Reform Society, which lobbied for the repeal of British sodomy laws.

Sir Stephen Spender : London Remembers, Aiming to capture all memorials in  London
Above: Stephen Spender

Spender sued author David Leavitt for allegedly using his relationship with “Jimmy Younger” in Leavitt’s While England Sleeps in 1994.

The case was settled out of court with Leavitt removing certain portions from his text.

While England Sleeps: A Novel: Leavitt, David: 9781620407080: Amazon.com:  Books

I am not really sure what I should say in regards to Spender’s proclivities.

Frankly, what happens in the bedroom in my opinion should remain in the bedroom.

Do I really need to know about Spender’s extracurricular affairs to enjoy (or not) his poetry?

Cover of the Behind Closed Doors album with the singer Charlie Rich in a cowboy hat.

In the 1980s, Spender’s writing — The Journals of Stephen Spender, 1939-1983, Collected Poems, 1928-1985, and Letters to Christopher: Stephen Spender’s Letters to Christopher Isherwood, 1929-1939, in particular—placed a special emphasis on autobiographical material.

Stephen Spender_ Journals 1939-1983 | Stephen Spender, John Goldsmith |  Cloth/dust jacket Octavo

Letters to Christopher: Stephen Spender's Letters to Christopher Isherwood,  1929-1939: With "The Line of the Branch"--Two Thirties Journals by Stephen  Spender

I’m struggling at the end to get out of the valley of hectoring youth, journalistic middle age, imposture, moneymaking, public relations, bad writing, mental confusion.

On turning 70 in Journals 1939 – 1983 (1986), as quoted in Time magazine (20 January 1986)

Time Magazine logo.svg

What I had not foreseen
Was the gradual day
Weakening the will

Leaking the brightness away

For I had expected always
Some brightness to hold in trust,
Some final innocence

To save from dust

What I Expected Was“, Stephen Spender

Journals, 1939-1983: Spender, Stephen: 9780571139224: Amazon.com: Books

One, a poet, went babbling like a fountain
Through parks. All were jokes to children.
All had the pale unshaven stare of shuttered plants
Exposed to a too violent sun.

Exiles From Their Land, History Their Domicile“, The Still Centre, 1939

The Still Centre (Audio, Faber): Spender, Stephen, Spender, Stephen:  9780140863963: Amazon.com: Books

In the New York Times Book Review, critic Samuel Hynes commented that:

The person who emerges from Spender’s letters is neither a madman nor a fool, but an honest, intelligent, troubled young man, groping toward maturity in a troubled time.

And the author of the journals is something more.

He is a writer of sensitivity and power.

Samuel Hynes, 'highly respected scholar-critic' of British literature and  World War II veteran, dies at 95
Above: Samuel Hynes (1924 – 2019)

On 16 July 1995, Spender died of a heart attack in Westminster, London, aged 86.

He was buried in the graveyard of St Mary on Paddington Green Church in London.

St Mary on Paddington Green Church side entrance.jpg
Above: St Mary on Paddington Green Church, Paddington Green, London

Death is another milestone on their way.
With laughter on their lips and with winds blowing round them
They record simply
How this one excelled all others in making driving belts.

The Funeral

Spender’s name was most frequently associated with that of W.H. Auden, perhaps the most famous poet of the 1930s.

However, some critics found the two poets dissimilar in many ways.

57 Stephen Spender Photos and Premium High Res Pictures - Getty Images

In the New Yorker, for example, Vendler observed that:

At first Spender imitated Auden’s self-possessed ironies, his determined use of technological objects. … But no two poets can have been more different.

Auden’s rigid, brilliant, peremptory, categorizing, allegorical mind demanded forms altogether different from Spender’s dreamy, liquid, guilty, hovering sensibility.

Auden is a poet of firmly historical time, Spender of timeless nostalgic space.

The New Yorker Logo.svg

In the New York Times Book Review, Kazin similarly concluded that Spender “was mistakenly identified with Auden.

Although they were virtual opposites in personality and in the direction of their talents, they became famous at the same time as ‘pylon poets’— among the first to put England’s gritty industrial landscape of the 1930s into poetry.

New York Times Book Review cover June 13 2004.jpg

The term “pylon poets” refers to “The Pylons” a poem by Spender that many critics described as typical of the Auden generation.

A Short Analysis of Stephen Spender's 'The Pylons' – Interesting Literature

The much-anthologized work, included in one of Spender’s earliest collections, Poems (1933), as well as in his Collected Poems, 1928 – 1985, includes imagery characteristic of the group’s style and reflects the political and social concerns of its members.

A Literary Blog of Twentieth-Century and Beyond Poetry in English
Above: The Auden group of poets: W.H. Auden, Louis MacNiece, Cecil Day-Lewis, Stephen Spender and Christopher Isherwood

In The Angry Young Men of the Thirties (1976), Elton Edward Smith recognized that in such a poem:

The poet, instead of closing his eyes to the hideous steel towers of a rural electrification system and concentrating on the soft green fields, glorifies the pylons and grants to them the future.

And the nonhuman structure proves to be of the very highest social value, for rural electrification programs help create a new world of human equality.”

The Angry Young Men of the Thirties. by Elton Edward Smith - 1 - from  ATGBooks (SKU: 38505)

The Pylons

The secret of these hills was stone, and cottages
Of that stone made,
And crumbling roads
That turned on sudden hidden villages

Now over these small hills, they have built the concrete
That trails black wire
Pylons, those pillars
Bare like nude giant girls that have no secret.

The valley with its gilt and evening look
And the green chestnut
Of customary root,
Are mocked dry like the parched bed of a brook.

But far above and far as sight endures
Like whips of anger
With lightning’s danger
There runs the quick perspective of the future.

This dwarfs our emerald country by its trek
So tall with prophecy
Dreaming of cities
Where often clouds shall lean their swan-white neck.

Anchor tower of overhead power line.jpg

Over a 65-year career, Stephen Spender wrote scores of poems, hundreds of reviews and essays, and arguably one of the finer memoirs of the 20th century.

And yet he may end up better remembered for a cab ride.

In 1980, Spender battled a lost wallet, an octogenarian driver, and 287 miles of dismal weather to taxi from a lecture in Oneonta, NY, to a dinner date with Jacqueline Onassis in Manhattan.

(“I simply had to get there” is the breathless quote detractors are happy to supply.)

Mrs Kennedy in the Diplomatic Reception Room cropped.jpg
Above: Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis (née Bouvier) (1929 – 1994)

Fairly or unfairly, Spender’s reputation as a toady has steadily consolidated, while his reputation as a poet has steadily declined.

His most recent defender, John Sutherland, over 600 pages of an otherwise reverent biography, makes only the meekest case for Spender the literary artist.

They never stopped trying”, Sutherland writes on Page 1 of Stephen Spender: A Literary Life, alluding cryptically to unidentified enemies.

But somehow his quality (and I would argue, his literary greatness) weathered the assault.”

It’s nice to know Sutherland would argue it.

Maybe one day he will.

In his current book, though, the case for Spender’s greatness stays parenthetical, optative, and firmly stuck on Page 1.

John Sutherland (author) - Alchetron, the free social encyclopedia
Above: John Sutherland

So we’re faced with an interesting question.

Why has every decade since the ‘30s bothered to rough up an “indifferent poet”, as Spender’s good friend Cyril Connolly once described him?

Why has posterity consigned Stephen Spender to oblivion?

NPG P536; Stephen Spender - Portrait - National Portrait Gallery
Above: Stephen Spender

As aforementioned, Spender first emerged in the 30s as part of a coterie of Oxford prodigies that included Louis MacNeice, W.H. Auden, Cecil Day-Lewis, and Christopher Isherwood.

In a round robin of mutual admiration, the poets dedicated their early books to one another and soon came to be known, somewhat derisively, as “Macspaunday”.

If a coterie is incidental to a genius, as it certainly became to Auden, it can get rung around the neck of a lesser talent.

And Spender has never quite lived down the suspicion that he was little more than a well-placed satellite.

Above: Sputnik I, the first artificial satellite in space

He produced indifferent poems —

Hope and despair and the vivid small longings/ Like minnows gnaw the body” is a fair sampling —

But he was deft at courting the great, to whom he appeared pleasantly unchallenging.

The Court Jester (1955 poster).jpg

A loose jointed mind,” Virginia Woolf wrote in her diary after one encounter, “misty, clouded, suffusive.

Nothing has outline.

We plunged and skipped and hopped — from sodomy and women and writing and anonymity and — I forget.”

A Writer's Diary by Virginia Woolf: Very Good Hardcover (1954) 1st American  Edition | onourshelves

Not surprisingly, this was not a personality that organized itself around abiding convictions.

To piece together his literary life, Spender went high and went low.

He spent weekends with the Rothschilds at Mouton, and he trundled as a stipendiary from American college to American college.

Great coat of arms of Rothschild family.svg
Above: Rothschild family coat of arms

When Auden told him to stick to poetry, he dutifully complied, just as he complied when Auden later told him to write nothing but autobiographical prose.

Wyndham Lewis – Stephen Spender, 1939
Above: Stephen Spender, Wyndham Lewis

He fell into the reigning Oxford cult of homosexuality, and just as easily fell out of it.

Above: Aerial view of Oxford

Communism was a brief, intense fascination — he even announced his party membership in the Daily Worker — but the depth of the Party’s hatred of the bourgeoisie finally only baffled him.

The Daily Worker

Before the war, Spender was gay, Communist, and a poet of reportedly blazing promise.

Soon after the war, Spender was a husband, a liberal demi-Cold Warrior, and a thoroughly bland cultural statesman.

Yin and yang.svg

Both he and Auden posed an answer to a question that has, always and everywhere, overwhelmed poets, but had lately taken on new powers of vexation.

That question was:

What does a poet still have to offer a modern world?

Question mark and man concept illustration Stock Photo by ©mstanley  122688212

Auden answered it with great, painstaking care, and correctly, or at least importantly.

Spender answered it facilely, and incorrectly, or unimportantly.

To understand their answers, one has to have some appreciation of the atmosphere of the 1930s.

Above: Dust storm, Texas, 1935

As self-pleased as Auden and his circle were, they were also deeply serious poets-in-the-making, who to a man wanted to address themselves to — and change — the world.

Change the World Primary Cover.jpg

The modern poet is “acutely conscious of the present isolation of the individual and the necessity for a social organism which may restore communion,” wrote Cecil Day-Lewis in 1933.

Why my father Cecil Day-Lewis's poem Walking Away stands the test of time |  Poetry | The Guardian
Above: Cecil Day-Lewis

The majority of artists today are forced to remain individualists in the sense of the individualist who expresses nothing except his feeling for his own individuality, his isolation,” Spender wrote in the same year.

Stephen Spender (Print #620735). Photographic Prints, Framed Photos
Above: Stephen Spender

How to restore public communion, when public speech is increasingly being given over to sloganeering — or, worse, aggression and persecution?

History, they felt, had handed them a choice, to be aesthetes or to be propagandists, and with their collective heart they hated the choice.

Manugactorinconsent2.jpg

Consequently, two seemingly contrary complaints have been lodged against the Auden generation.

The first was that they naively overcommitted themselves to political causes.

The literary history of the thirties,” Orwell wrote, in the essay “Inside the Whale”, “seems to justify the opinion that a writer does well to keep out of politics.”

The second was that, enamored of their own feline ambivalence, they lacked any conviction whatsoever.

The confusion is not baseless.

Photograph of the head and shoulders of a middle-aged man, with black hair and a slim mustache
Above: Eric Blair (aka George Orwell) (1903 – 1950)

Even in his mature poetry, Auden can appear as both a dealer in hopelessly obscure private parables and the over-explicit schoolmaster.

But this confusion was also the source of Auden’s triumph, which was to rescue from a debased public life the possibility of genuine, eccentric human intimacy, and to rescue from intimacy, in turn, something like a quasi-public idiom.

We need to love all since we are/ Each a unique particular/ That is no giant, god or dwarf,/ But one odd human isomorph.” 

Above: W.H. Auden

This was the task of the poet, then.

To remind people they were fully human, which is to say, not reducible to convenient ends by dictators, or for that matter, by corporate managers or mass marketers.

And to remind them in a language that bore no trace of manipulation or officialdom.

You'reOnlyHuman.jpg

How did Spender answer the question?

Poorly.

He chose … poorly.” – Keet's Cocktails
Above: Julian Glover (Walter Donovan), Alison Doody (Elsa Schneider), Robert Eddison (The Grail Knight) and Harrison Ford (Indiana Jones), Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade

To begin with, unlike Auden, Spender seemed to possess no guile whatsoever.

When the muse first came to Mr. Spender,” Randall Jarrell once wrote, “he looked so sincere that her heart failed her, and she said:

‘Ask anything, and I will give it to you.’

And he said: ‘Make me sincere.’

Sincerity is a nice enough virtue in acquaintances, but it keeps a literary voice from carrying.

Randall Jarrell.jpg
Above: American poet Randall Jarrell (1914 – 1965)

His poem about meeting the French phenomenologist Merleau-Ponty begins:

I walked with Merleau-Ponty by the lake.

Mmp2.jpg
Above: French philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty (1908 – 1961)

Part of the problem, apparently, was that Spender was averse to loneliness.

And so he crammed his life with luncheons and international symposia.

The loneliness pandemic | Harvard Magazine

Visiting D.H. Lawrence’s widow, Frieda, in New Mexico, Spender treated himself to six weeks’ isolation on the ranch where Lawrence’s ashes were laid.

Later in life, Sutherland tells us, Spender recalled this as the “only time in his life that he had truly experienced loneliness(a condition he normally abhorred).

During these lonely weeks he produced a first draft of what would become World Within World.”

Is it any accident this remains his one eminently readable book?

D. H. Lawrence Ranch, San Cristobal, NM – Brick and Stone: Architecture and  Preservation
Above: D.H. Lawrence Ranch, San Cristobal, New Mexico

The larger defect, though, was that Spender, as perfect counterpoint to his facile idea of the revealed self (the original title for World Within World was “Autobiography and Truth”), maintained an equally facile belief in the poet’s duty to projects of large public renovation.

Spender Stephen - World Within World

In the postwar years, Spender jetted from conference to conference, as if something as delicate and strange as poetry might be featured as part of the Marshall Plan.

Trans World Airlines Globe Map Logo 1.png

(The Marshall Plan (officially the European Recovery ProgramERP) was an American initiative enacted in 1948 to provide foreign aid to Western Europe.

The US transferred over $13 billion (equivalent of about $114 billion in 2020) in economic recovery programs to Western European economies after the end of World War II.

It operated for four years beginning on 3 April 1948. 

The goals of the United States were to rebuild war-torn regions, remove trade barriers, modernize industry, improve European prosperity, and prevent the spread of communism.

The Marshall Plan required a reduction of interstate barriers and the dissolution of many regulations while also encouraging an increase in productivity as well as the adoption of modern business procedures.)

Portrait of a man in military uniform.
Above: George Catlett Marshall (1880 – 1959)

For his part, Spender was indefatigable, lecturing at one point on how the modern writer “is a kind of super egotist, a hero, and a martyr, carrying the whole burden of civilization in his work.”

For their part, modern writers were happy to take Spender’s handouts, then disparage to others his missionary naiveté.

Sir Stephen Harold Spender (1909-1995) was an Engl - 1887 | LeeMiller
Above: Stephen Spender

I met Spender a few weeks ago,” Dylan Thomas wrote to a friend.

It was very sad.

He is on a lecture tour.

It is very sad.

He is bringing the European intellectuals together.

It is impossible.

He said, in a lecture I saw reported:

‘All poets speak the same language.’

It is a bloody lie:

Who talks Spender?

Dylan Thomas Marathon am 27.10.2021 (Serie 'Literatur', Teichwiesen #  1714), 27.10.2021 : : my.race|result
Above: Dylan Thomas

Exactly.

Who talks Spender?

Though cruelly arrived at, this is the rub.

No one talks Spender, just as no one talks Esperanto.

Flag of Esperanto.svg
Above: Flag of Esperanto

Until we are firmly rooted in our strange selves, we cannot begin to speak to others meaningfully.

Conversely, if you start from that lovely ideal, of culture as a universal idiom, you quickly find yourself softened into a nonentity.

(This is why Auden, I suspect, was willing to court the disgust of the high-minded when he wrote, in his elegy for Yeats, that:

Poetry makes nothing happen”.)

Above: Yeats’s final resting place in the shadow of the Dartry Mountains, Drumcliffe, County Sligo, Ireland

The aim of serious writing isn’t statesmanship, proximity to the rich, or the production of culture, whatever that is.

People lock themselves in rooms, and tolerate the sound of their own inane voices on the page, to rescue from “the most recent cacophonies … the delicate reduced and human scale of language in which individuals are able to communicate in a civilized and affectionate way with one another.”

The strength of Spender’s literary reputation, which was international in scope, made him something of a nomad as scholar and poet.

His homes were in St. John’s Wood, London, and Maussanne-les-Alpilles, France, where he spent his summers.

A House in St John's Wood: In Search of My Parents: Spender, Matthew:  9780374269869: Amazon.com: Books

Becoming French in Ninety Days: November 2005
Above: View from Maussane les Alpilles

But he was often on the road, giving readings and lectures and serving as writer in residence at various American universities.

Spender’s domicile in Houston was a penthouse apartment atop a high-rise dormitory on the university campus.

The walls of the apartment are glass and afforded the poet a 270° view of America’s self-proclaimed 20th century city.

His fellow residents in the dorm were mostly athletes, a fact that especially delighted Spender at breakfast, for with them he was served steaks, sausage, ham, eggs, biscuits and grits.

Above: Houston, Texas

At the time, Spender was busy with several projects:

Besides preparing for his imminent departure and saying goodbye to his many friends, he was completing the text for Henry Moore: Sculptures in Landscape, which was published in 1978.

Henry Moore Sculptures in Landscape (Hardcover) for sale online | eBay

He had also been invited by the University to deliver its commencement address, an event that took place on the afternoon of 13 May.

I’ve never even been to a commencement before.

What does one say?” he asked.

I suppose I will tell them to read books all their lives and to make a lot of money and give it to the university.

University of Houston seal.svg

In 1960, Spender was renowned as a figure from the past – a poet of the 1930s – and his work was deeply out of fashion.

Indeed, the 1930s were out of fashion.

He was seen as a tragicomic literary epoch in which poets had absurdly tried, or pretended, to engage with current politics – one in which pimply young toffs had linked arms with muscular proletarians in order to “repel the Fascist threat” when they weren’t at Sissington or Garsinghurst for the weekend, sucking up to Bloomsbury grandees.

Bloomsbury-publishing-logo.PNG
Above: Logo of Bloomsbury publishing group

Cyril Connolly called them:

Psychological revolutionaries, people who adopt left-wing political formulas because they hate their fathers or were unhappy at their public schools or insulted at the Customs, or lectured about sex.”

Connolly | Lapham's Quarterly
Above: Cyril Connolly

Someone else had dubbed Spender “the Rupert Brooke of the Depression.”

Rupert Brooke Q 71073.jpg
Above: English poet Rupert Brooke (1887 – 1915)

Most of us had been told in school that of all the 30s poets Spender was the one whose reputation had been most inflated.

He lacked the complexity of Auden, the erudition of Louis MacNeice, the cunning of Cecil Day-Lewis.

He was the one who had believed the slogans. –

Oh, young men.

Oh, young comrades.“-

And, after the War, the one who had recanted most shamefacedly.

He was the fairest of fair game.

I remember my school’s English teacher reading aloud from Spender’s “I think continually of those who were truly great” and substituting for “great” words like “posh” and “rich” and “queer“.

The same piece involving Spender’s “Pylons, those pillars / Bare like nude, giant girls that have no secret.

Even you lot,” he would say, “might draw the line at girls who looked like that.”

My teacher was in line with current critical opinion.

He usually was.

The late 50s was a period of skeptical naysaying.

It was modish to be cagey, unillusioned.

The only brave cause left was the cause of common sense, the only decent political standpoint the refusal to be taken in.

Look what happened in the 30s!” was the common cry.

And it was not just political wind-baggery that was distrusted.

There was suspicion, too, of anything religious, arty, or intense.

Above: Cary Grant (Roger O. Thornhill), North by Northwest (1959)

A neutral tone is nowadays preferred,” Donald Davie wrote in a mid-50s poem called “Remembering the Thirties“.

Above: English poet Donald Davie (1922 – 1995)

Thom Gunn – the young poet 1960s students most admired – was preaching a doctrine of butch self-reliance:

        I think of all the toughs through
	   history
	And thank heaven they lived,
	   continually.
	I praise the over dogs from Alexander
	To those who would not play with 
	    Stephen Spender

It was better, Gunn said:

To be insensitive, to steel the will, / Than sit irresolute all day at stool / Inside the heart.

Such tough talk was music to our ears.

Paris Review - The Art of Poetry No. 72
Above: English poet Thom Gunn (1929 – 2004)

After the war, Spender joined UNESCO as Counsellor to the Section of Letters, and this marked an new phase of his celebrity:

A 20-year-long stint as a kind of globe-trotting cultural emissary.

Above: Flag of UNESCO

The postwar years were good years in which to be an intellectual.

The civilized world had to be rebuilt, but thoughtfully:

This time, we had to get it right.

Huge congresses were organized at which famous thinkers debated the big questions: “Freedom and the Artist“, “The Role of the Artist“, “Art and the Totalitarian Threat“.

Spender was in regular attendance at such gatherings in Europe, and was soon in demand for trips to India, Japan, even Australia.

These “junkets“, as he described them, were usually paid for by the Congress for Cultural Freedom, based in Washington, as part of America’s hearts-and-minds offensive against Communism.

In 1953, he was approached by the Congress to edit the literary side of a new monthly, Encounter, which would be “anti-Communist in policy but not McCarthyite.”

(He was told that the money for it came from the Fairfield Foundation, a supposedly independent body.)

Indiana University Press on Twitter: "POEMS WRITTEN ABROAD by Stephen  Spender and edited by @chrisirmscher is hot off the press! Start reading  here: https://t.co/1jZWeQKQmV #stephenspender #poetry #poem…  https://t.co/E0nTwKYWeS"

Spender, it had been noted, contributed to the much discussed 1949 anthology “The God That Failed“, a collection of contrite essays by six of Europe’s most prominent ex-Communists.

His 1936 flirtation with the Party was no longer to be laughed at:

He had experienced that of which he spoke and could thus be seen as a Cold Warrior of high potential.

As Spender saw it, there was nothing at all warlike in the politics he had settled for – a politics that transcended immediate East-West disputes, that dealt not in power plays but in moral absolutes.

I am for neither West nor East,” he wrote in 1951, “but for myself considered as a self–one of the millions who inhabit the Earth.”

Freedom of speech, the preeminence of the individual conscience – in short, the mainstream liberal verities – would from now on be the components of his faith.

The God That Failed Six Studies in Communism: Koestler, Wright, Gide,  Fischer, Spender, Richard Crossman: Amazon.com: Books

I am for neither West nor East, but for myself considered as a self — one of the millions who inhabit the Earth.

If it seems absurd that an individual should set up as a judge between these vast powers, armed with their superhuman instruments of destruction I can reply that the very immensity of the means to destroy proves that judging and being judged does not lie in these forces.

For supposing that they achieved their utmost and destroyed our civilization, whoever survived would judge them by a few statements. a few poems, a few testimonies surviving from all the ruins, a few words of those men who saw outside and beyond the means which were used and all the arguments which were marshaled in the service of those means.

Thus I could not escape from myself into some social situation of which my existence was a mere product, and my witnessing a willfully distorting instrument.

I had to be myself, choose and not be chosen.

But to believe that my individual freedom could gain strength from my seeking to identify myself with the “progressive” forces was different from believing that my life must be an instrument of means decided on by political leaders. 

I came to see that within the struggle for a more just world, there is a further struggle between the individual who cares for long-term values and those who are willing to use any and every means to gain immediate political ends — even good ends.

Within even a good social cause, there is a duty to fight for the pre-eminence of individual conscience.

The public is necessary, but the private must not be abolished by it.

And the individual must not be swallowed up by the concept of the social man.

World Within World, 1951

He had by this time become the Spender who disconcerted us in Oxford.

No longer the holy fool of 30s legend, he was transmuting into an itinerant representative of liberal unease.

During the late 50s and throughout the 60s, Spender was perpetually on the move, sometimes as troubled ambassador for Western values, for the Congress, for International PEN, or for the British Council, as agency for promoting British culture abroad, and sometimes as hard-up literary journeyman, lecturing on modern poetry at Berkeley or Wesleyan or the University of Florida – wherever the fees were sufficiently enticing – or dreaming up viable book projects, such as “Love-Hate Relations“, a study of Anglo-American literary relationships, and “The Year of the Young Rebels” and account of the 1968 upheavals in Paris, Prague, New York, and West Berlin.

The ultimate aim of politics is not politics, but the activities which can be practised within the political framework of the State. 

Therefore an effective statement of these activities — e.g. science, art, religion — is in itself a declaration of ultimate aims around which the political means will crystallise.

A society with no values outside of politics is a machine carrying its human cargo, with no purpose in its institutions reflecting their care, eternal aspirations, loneliness, need for love.

Life and the Poet (1942)

Pin by D Norwich on Steve Maraboli Quotes | Life is an adventure, Words  quotes, Poems

Would I have liked Spender had we lived at the same time and had met one another?

Hard to say.

Do I think Spender is overrated as a poet?

I guess this depends on whom is rating him.

1114 3d Man With Multiple Question Mark Stock Photo | PowerPoint Slide  Presentation Sample | Slide PPT | Template Presentation

I am very honoured by your wanting to write a life of me.

But the fact is I regard my life as rather a failure in the only thing in which I wanted it to succeed.

I have not written the books I ought to have written and I have written a lot of books I should not have written. 

My life as lived by me has been interesting to me but to write truthfully about it would probably cause much pain to people close to me — and I always feel that the feelings of the living are more important than the monuments of the dead.

Response to a would be biographer in 1980, “When Stephen met Sylvia“, The Guardian, 24 April 2004

The Guardian 2018.svg

There is a certain justice in criticism.

The critic is like a midwife — a tyrannical midwife.

Lecture at Brooklyn College, as quoted in The New York Times (20 November 1984)

Brooklyn College Seal.svg

In my humble opinion I find Spender overrated as a poet no more than Andy Warhol (1928 – 1987) was overrated as an artist.

There is much about Spender’s craving for the spotlight and surrounded himself with celebrated society that is reminiscent of Warhol.

What does come through is Spender’s talent for friendship – and how his seemingly artless curiosity opened him to people, places and experiences he would otherwise have missed.

There was a kind of bravery in that.

A shrewdness, too.

He’d have liked to write more poems.

But in the end it mattered more to him to have an interesting life.

Nice Quotes about Life by Chines curse – May you always live in interesting  times - Quotespictures.com

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Ian Hamilton, “Spender’s Lives“, The New Yorker, 28 February 1994 / Magsie Hamilton Little, The Thing About Islam: Exposing the Myths, Facts and Controversies / Stephan Metcalf, “Stephen Spender: Toady?“, Slate.com, 7 February 2005 / Blake Morrison, “A talent for friendship“, The Guardian, 23 January 2005 / Richard Skinner, Writing a Novel / Stephen Spender: The Destructive Element / The God that Failed / Life and the Poet / Poems of Dedication / Poems / Ruins and Visions / Selected Poems / The Still Centre / The Temple / World Within World / John Sutherland, Stephen Spender: The Authorised Biography

Canada Slim and the Dreaming Place

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Tuesday 19 January 2021

On this day in history, a play was first performed that essentially asked the question:

What is the meaning of life?

Goethe's Faust: Amazon.de: Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von, Kaufmann, Walter,  Kaufmann, Walter: Fremdsprachige Bücher

It begins with a prologue in Heaven, where the Lord bets Mephistopheles, an agent of the Devil, that Mephistopheles cannot lead astray the Lord’s favorite striving scholar, Dr. Faust.

All the city's a stage: Munich celebrates Goethe's Faust with group show  and festival | The Art Newspaper

We then see Faust in his study, who, disappointed by the knowledge and results obtainable by science’s natural means, attempts and fails to gain knowledge of nature and the universe by magical means.

Goethes Faust – Wikipedia

  • Well, that’s Philosophy I’ve read,
    And Law and Medicine, and I fear
    Theology, too, from A to Z;
    Hard studies all, that have cost me dear.
    And so I sit, poor silly man
    No wiser now than when I began
    .

Dejected in this failure, Faust contemplates suicide, but is held back by the sounds of the beginning Easter celebrations.

Delacroix's Rare Illustrations for Goethe's Faust | Eugène delacroix, Goethe's  faust, Illustration

He joins his assistant Wagner for an Easter walk in the countryside, among the celebrating people, and is followed home by a poodle.

Full attention (8067543690).jpg

Back in the study, the poodle transforms itself into Mephistopheles, who offers Faust a contract:

He will do Faust’s bidding on Earth, and Faust will do the same for him in Hell (if, as Faust adds in an important side clause, Mephistopheles can get him to be satisfied and to want a moment to last forever).

Faust signs in blood, and Mephistopheles first takes him to Auerbach’s tavern in Leipzig, where the Devil plays tricks on some drunken revelers.

Having then been transformed into a young man by a witch, Faust encounters Margaret (Gretchen) and she excites his desires.

Through a scheme involving jewellery and Gretchen’s neighbour Marthe, Mephistopheles brings about Faust’s and Gretchen’s liaison.

Faust-1926-Poster-MGM.jpg

After a period of separation, Faust seduces Gretchen, who accidentally kills her mother with a sleeping potion given to her by Faust.

Gretchen discovers that she is pregnant, and her torment is further increased when Faust and Mephistopheles kill her enraged brother in a sword fight.

Deutschland-Lese | Meine Ruh ist hin

Mephistopheles seeks to distract Faust by taking him to a witches’ sabbath on Walpurgis Night, but Faust insists on rescuing Gretchen from the execution to which she was sentenced after drowning her newborn child while in a state of madness.

In the dungeon, Faust vainly tries to persuade Gretchen to follow him to freedom.

At the end of the drama, as Faust and Mephistopheles flee the dungeon, a voice from Heaven announces Gretchen’s salvation.

W.W. Jacobs Quote: “Be careful what you wish for, you may receive it.” (7  wallpapers) - Quotefancy

That I may understand whatever
Binds the world’s innermost core together,
See all its workings, and its seeds,
Deal no more in words’ empty reeds.

Toronto – London, Ontario, Sunday 12 January 2020

We all make Faustian pacts.

We all sell our souls searching for something from outside ourselves that will somehow fill the emptiness within ourselves.

Mephistopheles is my travelling companion on this train bound for nowhere.

My mind feels his hot breath in my ear, incessantly suggesting that the abandonment of one friend in Brampton will somehow be eased by a reunion in London with a classmate I have not seen in a decade.

I am in southern Ontario where winter is not so brutal, so fatal as much as it is in most of Canada.

And yet the flat snowfields outside the window leave me cold.

I am a child of the digital revolution, afraid of thought, fearful of emotion that slices across cherished illusions.

I distract myself with Wikipedia and read of the places this train hurtles me unfeelingly.

Onwards, ever westwards, to Brantford.

Clockwise from top: Flowerbed outside RBC Building, Statue of Joseph Brant, Bell Homestead, Grand River, City Hall, Colborne Street in Downtown Brantford

Above: Images of Brantford

Brantford is named after Joseph Brant (1743 – 1807), an important Mohawk leader during the American Revolution and later, who led his people in their first decades in Upper Canada.

Joseph Brant painting by George Romney 1776 (2).jpg

Above: Joseph Brant

Many of his descendants, and other First Nations citizens, live on the nearby Reserve of Six Nations of the Grand River, 15 kilometers (10 miles) from Brantford.

It is the most populous reserve in Canada.

Place sign, Six Nations, Ontario.JPG

I am again reminded of how much was lost with the white man’s invasion of the “New World“, heritage lost, clinging to cliffs of pride, tradition that remains mocked and misunderstood by the blood-soaked victors and their descendants.

Of the places this train journey visits, only Brantford and London are somewhat familiar to me, for in my youth, during my daze of walking the land in search of myself, I spent some time touring Brantford and working in London.

Brantford affects me more.

Brantford is known as the “Telephone City” as the city’s famous resident, Alexander Graham Bell, invented the first telephone at his father’s homestead, Melville House, now the Bell Homestead.

Alexander Graham Bell.jpg

Above: Alexander Graham Bell (1847 – 1922)

The Iroquoian-speaking Attawandaron, known in English as the Neutral Nation, lived in the Grand River valley area before the 17th century.

Their main village and seat of the chief, Kandoucho, was identified by 19th-century historians as having been located on the Grand River where present-day Brantford developed.

This community, like the rest of their settlements, was destroyed when the Iroquois declared war in 1650 over the fur trade and exterminated the Neutral nation.

In 1784, Captain Joseph Brant and the Mohawk people of the Iroquois Confederacy left New York State for Canada.

As a reward for their loyalty to the British Crown, they were given a large land grant, referred to as the Haldimand Tract, on the Grand River.

Living on Stolen Land | A\J – Canada's Environmental Voice

The original Mohawk settlement was on the south edge of the present-day city at a location favourable for landing canoes.

Brant’s crossing (or fording) of the river gave the original name to the area: Brant’s ford.

Above: Joseph Brant

The area began to grow from a small settlement in the 1820s as the Hamilton and London Road was improved.

By the 1830s, Brantford became a stop on the Underground Railroad, and a sizable number of runaway African-Americans settled in the town.

Undergroundrailroadsmall2.jpg

From the 1830s to the 1860s – several hundred people of African descent settled in the area around Murray Street, and in Cainsville (today’s Kingsville).

In Brantford, they established their own school and church, now known as the S.R. Drake Memorial Church.

In 1846, it is estimated 2,000 residents lived in the city’s core while 5,199 lived in the outlying rural areas.

There were eight churches in Brantford at this time – Episcopal, Presbyterian, Catholic, two Methodist, Baptist, Congregational, and one for the African-Canadian residents.

By 1847, Europeans began to settle further up the river at a ford in the Grand River and named their village Brantford.

At the Forks of the Grand: Volume I: County of Brant Public Library Digital  Collections

The population increased after 1848 when river navigation to Brantford was opened and again in 1854 with the arrival of the railway to Brantford.

Brantford VIA Station 2014 p1.jpg

Above: Brantford Station

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, both the United States and Canadian governments encouraged education of First Nations children at residential schools, which were intended to teach them English and European-American ways and assimilate them to the majority cultures.

These institutions in Western New York and Canada included the Thomas Indian School, Mohawk Institute Residential School  (also known as Mohawk Manual Labour School and Mush Hole Indian Residential School) in Brantford, Haudenosaunee boarding school, and the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Carlisle, Pennsylvania.

Above: Carlisle Indian Industrial School

Perhaps the most fundamental conclusion that emerges from boarding school histories is the profound complexity of their historical legacy for Indian people’s lives.

The diversity among boarding school students in terms of age, personality, family situation, and cultural background created a range of experiences, attitudes, and responses.

Boarding schools embodied both victimization and agency for Native people and they served as sites of both cultural loss and cultural persistence.

These institutions, intended to assimilate Native people into mainstream society and eradicate Native cultures, became integral components of American Indian identities and eventually fueled the drive for political and cultural self-determination in the late 20th century.“)

Decades later and particularly since the late 20th century, numerous scholarly and artistic works have explored the detrimental effects of the schools in destroying Native cultures.

Examples include:

  • the film Unseen Tears: A Documentary on Boarding School Survivors,
  • Ronald James Douglas’ graduate thesis titled Documenting Ethnic Cleansing in North America: Creating Unseen Tears 
  • the Legacy of Hope Foundation’s online media collection: “Where are the Children? Healing the Legacy of the Residential Schools”.

Watch Unseen Tears: The Native American Boarding School Experience in  Western New York | Prime Video

Documenting Ethnic Cleansing in North America: Creating Unseen Tears :  Ronald James Douglas : 9781248979235

Where are the Children? – Legacy of Hope Foundation

White colonization was never about “when in Rome, do as the Romans do“.

It was always about the seizure of what was and the removal of the past in the name of the white man’s notion of progress.

In June 1945, Brantford became the first city in Canada to fluoridate its water supply.

Oral Health Milestones

Brantford generated controversy in 2010 when its city council expropriated and demolished 41 historic downtown buildings on the south side of its main street, Colborne Street.

The buildings constituted one of the longest blocks of pre-Confederation architecture in Canada, and included one of Ontario’s first grocery stores and an early 1890s office of the Bell Telephone Company of Canada.

The decision was widely criticized by Ontario’s heritage preservation community, however the city argued it was needed for downtown renewal.

Colborne Street Breakdown II: Demolition and Community History – Active  History

Plaques and monuments erected by the provincial and federal governments provide additional glimpses into the early history of the area around Brantford.

The famed Mohawk Chief Joseph Brant (Thayendanega) led his people from the Mohawk Valley of New York State to Upper Canada after being allied with the British during the American Revolution where they lost their land holdings.

A group of 400 settled in 1788 on the Grand River at Mohawk Village which would later become Brantford. 

Nearly a century later (1886), the Joseph Brant Memorial would be erected in Burlington in honour of Brant and the Six Nations Confederacy.

The Mohawk Chapel, built by the British Crown in 1785 for the Mohawk and Iroquois people (Six Nations of the Grand River) was dedicated in 1788 as a reminder of the original agreements made with the British during the American Revolution.

In 1904 the chapel received Royal status by King Edward VII in memory of the longstanding alliance.

Her Majesty’s Royal Chapel of the Mohawks is an important reminder of the original agreements made with Queen Anne in 1710.

It is still in use today as one of two royal Chapels in Canada and the oldest Protestant Church in the province.

Joseph Brant and his son John Brant are buried here.

The Mohawk Chapel was originally built in 1785 - Picture of Mohawk Chapel,  Brantford - Tripadvisor

Chief John Brant (Mohawk leader Ahyonwaeghs) (1794 – 1832) was one of the sons of Joseph Brant.

He fought with the British during the War of 1812 and later worked to improve the welfare of the First Nations.

He was involved in building schools and improving the welfare of his people.

Brant initiated the opening of schools and from 1828 served as the first native Superintendent of the Six Nations.

Chief Brant was elected to Legislative Assembly of Upper Canada for Haldimand in 1830 and was the first aboriginal Canadian in Parliament.

John Brant (Mohawk leader) - Wikipedia

Above: Chief John Brant

The stone and brick Brant County Courthouse was built on land purchased from the Six Nations in 1852. The structure housed court rooms, county offices, a law library and a gaol.

During additions in the 1880s, the Greek Revival style, with Doric columns, was retained.

Brantford Ontario - Canada - Brant County Courthouse - Heritage Building -  a photo on Flickriver

Among the most famed residents were Alexander Graham Bell and his family, who arrived in mid 1870 from Scotland while Bell was suffering from tuberculosis.

They lived with Bell’s father and mother who had settled in a farmhouse on Tutela Heights (named after the First Nations tribe of the area and later absorbed into Brantford.)

Then called Melville House, it is now a museum, the Bell Homestead National Historic Site.

This was the site of the invention of the telephone in 1874 and ongoing trials in 1876.

Above: Melville House

The Bell Memorial, also known as the Bell Monument, was commissioned to commemorate Bell’s invention of the telephone in Brantford.

It is also one of the National Historic Sites of Canada.

A majestic, broad monument with figures mounted on pedestals to its left and right sides. Along the main portion of the monument are five figures mounted on a broad casting, including a man reclining, plus four floating female figures representing Inspiration, Knowledge, Joy, and Sorrow.

Above: Bell Memorial

Some articles suggest that the telephone was invented in Boston where Alexander Graham Bell did a great deal of work on the development of the device.

(Before the development of the electric telephone, the term “telephone” was applied to other inventions, and not all early researchers of the electrical device called it “telephone“.

The concept of the telephone dates back to the string telephone or lover’s telephone that has been known for centuries, comprising two diaphraphms connected by a taut string or wire.

Sound waves are carried as mechanical vibrations along the string or wire from one diaphragm to the other. The classic example is the tin can telephone, a children’s toy made by connecting the two ends of a string to the bottoms of two metal cans, paper cups or similar items.

The essential idea of this toy was that a diaphragm can collect voice sounds from the voice sounds for reproduction at a distance.

Tin Can Telephone, 19th Century - Stock Image - C030/4142 - Science Photo  Library

Perhaps the earliest use of the word for a communications system was the telephon created by Gottfried Huth in 1796.

Allgemeines Magazin für die bürgerliche Baukunst., Book by Gottfried Huth  (Paperback) | www.chapters.indigo.ca

Huth proposed an alternative to the optical telegraph of Claude Chappe (1763 – 1805) in which the operators in the signalling towers would shout to each other by means of what he called “speaking tubes“, but would now be called giant megaphones.

AduC 175 Chappe (Claude, 1765-1828).JPG

Above: Claude Chappe

Above: Demonstration of the Chappe semaphone

A communication device for sailing vessels called a “telephone” was invented by Captain John Taylor in 1844.

This instrument used four air horns to communicate with vessels in foggy weather.

The Telephone, a Telegraphic Alarm (Foghorn) from the London Illustrated  News (1844)

One precursor to the development of the electromagnetic telephone originated in 1833 when Carl Friedrich Gauss (1777 – 1855) and Wilhelm Eduard Weber (1804 – 1891) invented an electromagnetic device for the transmission of telegraphic signals at the University of Göttingen, in Lower Saxony, helping to create the fundamental basis for the technology that was later used in similar telecommunication devices.

Gauss’s and Weber’s invention is purported to be the world’s first electromagnetic telegraph.

Carl Friedrich Gauss 1840 by Jensen.jpg

Above: Carl Friedrich Gauss

Wilhelm Eduard Weber II.jpg

Above: Wilhelm Eduard Weber

Uni Göttingen Siegel.svg

Above: Logo of the University of Göttingen

In 1840, American Charles Grafton Page  passed an electric current through a coil of wire placed between the poles of a horseshoe magnet.

He observed that connecting and disconnecting the current caused a ringing sound in the magnet.

He called this effect “galvanic music“.

CGPageportrait.jpg

Above: Charles Grafton Page (1812 – 1868)

Innocenzo Manzetti (1826 – 1877) considered the idea of a telephone as early as 1844.

Above: Innocenzo Manzetti

He may have made one in 1864, as an enhancement to an automaton built by him in 1849.

Charles Bourseul (1829 – 1912) was a French telegraph engineer who proposed (but did not build) the first design of a “make-and-break” telephone in 1854.

That is about the same time that Meucci later claimed to have created his first attempt at the telephone in Italy.

Bourseul explained:

Suppose that a man speaks near a movable disc sufficiently flexible to lose none of the vibrations of the voice, that this disc alternately makes and breaks the currents from a battery, you may have at a distance another disc which will simultaneously execute the same vibrations.

It is certain that, in a more or less distant future, a speech will be transmitted by electricity.

I have made experiments in this direction; they are delicate and demand time and patience, but the approximations obtained promise a favorable result.”

Above: Chalres Bourseul

Johann Philipp Reis used the term in reference to his invention, commonly known as the Reis telephone, in 1860.

His device appears to be the first device based on conversion of sound into electrical impulses.

The term telephone was adopted into the vocabulary of many languages.

It is derived from the Greek: tēle, “far” and  phōnē, “voice”, together meaning “distant voice“.

Credit for the invention of the electric telephone is frequently disputed.

As with other influential inventions such as radio, television, the light bulb, and the computer, several inventors pioneered experimental work on voice transmission over a wire and improved on each other’s ideas.

New controversies over the issue still arise from time to time. 

Elisha Gray (1835 – 1901), of Highland Park, Illinois, also devised a tone telegraph of this kind about the same time as La Cour.

Portrait elisha gray.jpg

Above: Elisha Gray

In Gray’s tone telegraph, several vibrating steel reeds tuned to different frequencies interrupted the current, which at the other end of the line passed through electromagnets and vibrated matching tuned steel reeds near the electromagnet poles.

Gray’s ‘harmonic telegraph,’ with vibrating reeds, was used by the Western Union Telegraph Company.

Since more than one set of vibration frequencies – that is to say, more than one musical tone – can be sent over the same wire simultaneously, the harmonic telegraph can be utilized as a ‘multiplex‘ or many-ply telegraph, conveying several messages through the same wire at the same time.

Each message can either be read by an operator by the sound, or from different tones read by different operators, or a permanent record can be made by the marks drawn on a ribbon of traveling paper by a Morse recorder.

On 27 July 1875, Gray was granted US patent 166,096 for “Electric Telegraph for Transmitting Musical Tones” (the harmonic).

The 'Musical Telegraph' or 'Electro-Harmonic Telegraph', Elisha Gray. USA,  1874 – 120 Years of Electronic Music

On 14 February 1876, at the US Patent Office, Gray’s lawyer filed a patent caveat for a telephone on the very same day that Bell’s lawyer filed Bell’s patent application for a telephone.

The water transmitter described in Gray’s caveat was strikingly similar to the experimental telephone transmitter tested by Bell on 10 March 1876, a fact which raised questions about whether Bell (who knew of Gray) was inspired by Gray’s design or vice versa.

Although Bell did not use Gray’s water transmitter in later telephones, evidence suggests that Bell’s lawyers may have obtained an unfair advantage over Gray.

Above: Excerpts from Elisha Gray’s patent caveat of February 14 and Alexander Graham Bell’s lab notebook entry of March 9, demonstrating their similarity.

Alexander Bell was born in Edinburgh, on 3 March 1847.

The family home was at South Charlotte Street, and has a stone inscription marking it as Alexander Graham Bell’s birthplace.

He had two brothers: Melville James Bell (1845–1870) and Edward Charles Bell (1848–1867), both of whom would die of tubercolis.

His father was Professor Alexander Melville Bell, a phonetician, and his mother was Eliza Grace Bell (née Symonds).

Alexander Melville Bell.png

Above: Alexander Melville Bell (1819 – 1905)

Born as just “Alexander Bell“, at age 10, he made a plea to his father to have a middle name like his two brothers.

For his 11th birthday, his father acquiesced and allowed him to adopt the name “Graham“, chosen out of respect for Alexander Graham, a Canadian being treated by his father who had become a family friend.

To close relatives and friends he remained “Aleck“.

Lower Canada around 1820 – Societies and Territories

As a child, young Bell displayed a curiosity about his world.

He gathered botanical specimens and ran experiments at an early age.

His best friend was Ben Herdman, a neighbour whose family operated a flour mill.

At the age of 12, Bell built a homemade device that combined rotating paddles with sets of nail brushes, creating a simple dehusking machine that was put into operation at the mill and used steadily for a number of years.

In return, Ben’s father John Herdman gave both boys the run of a small workshop in which to “invent“.

Threshing machine (19th century) - 3D scene - Mozaik Digital Education and  Learning

From his early years, Bell showed a sensitive nature and a talent for art, poetry, and music that was encouraged by his mother.

With no formal training, he mastered the piano and became the family’s pianist. 

Despite being normally quiet and introspective, he revelled in mimicry and “voice tricks” akin to ventriloquism that continually entertained family guests during their occasional visits.

Sharis Lewis.jpg

Above: Ventriloquist Shari Lewis (1933 – 1988) and Lamb Chop

Bell was also deeply affected by his mother’s gradual deafness (she began to lose her hearing when he was 12), and learned a manual finger language so he could sit at her side and tap out silently the conversations swirling around the family parlour.

He also developed a technique of speaking in clear, modulated tones directly into his mother’s forehead wherein she would hear him with reasonable clarity.

Bell’s preoccupation with his mother’s deafness led him to study acoustics.

Elizabeth Bell, mother of Alexander Graham Bell, c 1840s. at Science and  Society Picture Library

Above: Elizabeth Bell

Reading this and it is yesterday once more.

I was raised by foster parents.

He was an elderly French Canadian Catholic retired labourer and musician.

She was an Irish-Canadian Baptist spinster and homemaker.

My background of a dozen homes prior to my arrival at the Zenon Frederick “Freddy” Allard house, managed by Doris Evelyn O’Brien, made me more of a product of where I was rather than what bloodline might produce.

In most households women rule the roost and tolerate us living with them.

So in most conversations that revolve around my childhood (or at least the little I remember of it) Doris dominates the discussion.

But Freddy remains mostly in the shadows, for as his world became increasingly inaudible he became increasingly invisible.

I recall seeing an old faded photograph of Fred performing on the stage of a now non-existent Bar X – by the Ottawa River between Hawkesbury (Ontario) and Carillon (Québec) – fiddle beneath his chin and a grin across his face.

But the man he was wasn’t the man I knew.

Sometimes I weep inside when I think of the moments when I would see him walk to the bedroom closet, take the fiddle from its black case, and embracing it to his cheek as if reunited with a first lover, he would try to coax from it the sounds he remembered once making.

The light from the window at his back cast shadowsacross his face.

A grey man in a grey room.

Though the melodies of yesteryear still remained in his mind and heart, the music could not be repeated from his old fiddle.

Fred and I tolerated one another, for the only connection between us was Doris.

Fred and I were separated by age and experiences.

He was already ancient when I first arrived and I was unforgivably young.

Fred had his hockey and his silent love of nature and a fierce platonic loyalty towards Doris.

He filled a chair in the living room, faithfully following his Habs (Montréal Canadiens) on TV, a silent man in his silent world, selectively seeing what he wished to and ignoring all else.

I lived in his house and yet I never lived with him.

There might have been a universe of knowledge he could have given me.

I learned in my youth how to be old.

His failing hearing was his salvation from the turmoil that is the drama of sharing a place with a woman.

My salvation was the world of books, carefully adhering to the adage that “children are best seen but not heard“.

The story of Bell’s mother fills me with an intolerable sadness and a longing for the love that mother and son shared in their struggle to maintain communication between them.

But I was not theirs, being merely a ward of the province.

Doris had her regime of cleanliness more divine than godliness, maintaining the house much like a pristine museum of antiquities.

Fred had his hockey and a fiddle he could no longer play.

Bell’s family was long associated with the teaching of elocution:

His grandfather, Alexander Bell, in London, his uncle in Dublin, and his father, in Edinburgh, were all elocutionists.

Alexander Bell (Grandfather of Alexander Graham Bell). (LoC) Dating Early  Photographs Intro | 1840s | 186… | History of photography, Old photos,  Historical figures

Above: Alexander Bell

His father published a variety of works on the subject, several of which are still well known, especially his The Standard Elocutionist (1860), which appeared in Edinburgh in 1868. 

The Standard Elocutionist appeared in 168 British editions and sold over a quarter of a million copies in the United States alone.

In this treatise, his father explains his methods of how to instruct deaf-mutes (as they were then known) to articulate words and read other people’s lip movements to decipher meaning.

Bell's Standard Elocutionist: Principles And Exercises, Chiefly From  Elocutionary Manual (1889): Bell, David Charles, Bell, Alexander Melville:  9781166624231: Amazon.com: Books

Bell’s father taught him and his brothers not only to write Visible Speech but to identify any symbol and its accompanying sound.

Bell became so proficient that he became a part of his father’s public demonstrations and astounded audiences with his abilities.

He could decipher Visible Speech representing virtually every language, including Latin, Scottish Gaelic, and even Sanskrit, accurately reciting written tracts without any prior knowledge of their pronunciation.

Above: Bell learned acoustics from his father, Alexander Melville Bell, who created diagrams of how the human mouth formed consonants and vowels for his book on Visible Speech.

As a young child, Bell, like his brothers, received his early schooling at home from his father.

At an early age, he was enrolled at the Royal High School, Edinburgh, Scotland, which he left at the age of 15, having completed only the first four forms.

His school record was undistinguished, marked by absenteeism and lacklustre grades.

His main interest remained in the sciences, especially biology, while he treated other school subjects with indifference, to the dismay of his father.

Above: Royal High School

Upon leaving school, Bell travelled to London to live with his grandfather, Alexander Bell, on Harrington Square.

During the year he spent with his grandfather, a love of learning was born, with long hours spent in serious discussion and study.

The elder Bell took great efforts to have his young pupil learn to speak clearly and with conviction, the attributes that his pupil would need to become a teacher himself.

Harrington Square, Camden, London 2 bed flat - £2,383 pcm (£550 pw)

Above: Harrington Square, London

At the age of 16, Bell secured a position as a “pupil-teacher” of elocution and music, in Weston House Academy at Elgin, Moray, Scotland.

Although he was enrolled as a student in Latin and Greek, he instructed classes himself in return for board and £10 per session.

File:Kings Weston House south east facade.jpg - Wikimedia Commons

Above: Weston House Academy, Elgin, Moray, Scotland

The following year, he attended the University of Edinburgh, joining his older brother Melville who had enrolled there the previous year.

University of Edinburgh ceremonial roundel.svg

In 1868, not long before he departed for Canada with his family, Bell completed his matriculation exams and was accepted for admission to University College London.

University College London logo.svg

His father encouraged Bell’s interest in speech and, in 1863, took his sons to see a unique automaton developed by Sir Charles Wheatstone based on the earlier work of Baron Wolfgang von Kempelen.

Wheatstone Charles drawing 1868.jpg

Above: Charles Wheatstone (1802 – 1875)

A charcoal self-portrait of Kempelen, with signature.

Above: Baron Wolfgang von Kempelen (1734 – 1804)

The rudimentary “mechanical man” simulated a human voice.

Bell was fascinated by the machine and after he obtained a copy of von Kempelen’s book, published in German, and had laboriously translated it, he and his older brother Melville built their own automaton head.

Their father, highly interested in their project, offered to pay for any supplies and spurred the boys on with the enticement of a “big prize” if they were successful.

While his brother constructed the throat and larynx, Bell tackled the more difficult task of recreating a realistic skull.

His efforts resulted in a remarkably lifelike head that could “speak“, albeit only a few words.

The boys would carefully adjust the “lips” and when a bellows forced air through the windpipe, a very recognizable “Mama” ensued, to the delight of neighbours who came to see the Bell invention.

Intrigued by the results of the automaton, Bell continued to experiment with a live subject, the family’s Skye Terrier, “Trouve“.

Skye terrier 800.jpg

After he taught it to growl continuously, Bell would reach into its mouth and manipulate the dog’s lips and vocal cords to produce a crude-sounding “Ow ah oo ga ma ma“.

With little convincing, visitors believed his dog could articulate “How are you, grandma?

Indicative of his playful nature, his experiments convinced onlookers that they saw a “talking dog“.

These initial forays into experimentation with sound led Bell to undertake his first serious work on the transmission of sound, using tuning forks to explore resonance.

At age 19, Bell wrote a report on his work and sent it to philologist Alexander Ellis (1814 – 1890), a colleague of his father (who would later be portrayed as Professor Henry Higgins in Pygmalion).

Alexander ellis.jpg

Above: Alexander Ellis

Above: Bell was aided in his telephone experiments by a thorough understanding of how human speech works.

At the age of 19, he did primary research into the production of vowel sounds that was recognized as novel by leading philologists.

Ellis immediately wrote back indicating that the experiments were similar to existing work in Germany, and also lent Bell a copy of Hermann von Helmholtz’s work, The Sensations of Tone as a Physiological Basis for the Theory of Music.

Hermann von Helmholtz.jpg

Above: Hermann von Helmholtz (1821 – 1894)

Dismayed to find that groundbreaking work had already been undertaken by Helmholtz who had conveyed vowel sounds by means of a similar tuning fork “contraption“, Bell pored over the German scientist’s book.

Working from his own erroneous mistranslation of a French edition, Bell fortuitously then made a deduction that would be the underpinning of all his future work on transmitting sound, reporting:

Without knowing much about the subject, it seemed to me that if vowel sounds could be produced by electrical means, so could consonants, so could articulate speech.

He also later remarked:

I thought that Helmholtz had done it and that my failure was due only to my ignorance of electricity.

It was a valuable blunder.

If I had been able to read German in those days, I might never have commenced my experiments!

On the Sensations of Tone as a Physiological Basis for the Theory of Music  (Cambridge Library Collection - Music): Helmholtz, Hermann L. F., Ellis,  Alexander J.: 9781108001779: Amazon.com: Books

In 1865, when the Bell family moved to London, Bell returned to Weston House as an assistant master and, in his spare hours, continued experiments on sound using a minimum of laboratory equipment.

Bell concentrated on experimenting with electricity to convey sound and later installed a telegraph wire from his room in Somerset College to that of a friend.

Somersetshire College – House Historian

Above: Somerset College, Bath

Throughout late 1867, his health faltered mainly through exhaustion.

His younger brother, Edward “Ted” was similarly bed-ridden, suffering from tuberculosis.

While Bell recovered (by then referring to himself in correspondence as “A. G. Bell“) and served the next year as an instructor at Somerset College, Bath, England, his brother’s condition deteriorated.

Edward would never recover.

Upon his brother’s death, Bell returned home in 1867.

His older brother Melville had married and moved out.

With aspirations to obtain a degree at University College, London, Bell considered his next years as preparation for the degree examinations, devoting his spare time at his family’s residence to studying.

Helping his father in Visible Speech demonstrations and lectures brought Bell to Susanna E. Hull’s private school for the deaf in South Kensington, London.

His first two pupils were deaf-mute girls who made remarkable progress under his tutelage.

Susanna Hall - Wikiwand

Above: Susanna Hall’s School for the Deaf, South Kensington

While his older brother seemed to achieve success on many fronts including opening his own elocution school, applying for a patent on an invention, and starting a family, Bell continued as a teacher.

However, in May 1870, Melville died from complications due to tuberculosis, causing a family crisis.

Alexander Graham Bell | Family Tree | Articles and Essays | Alexander  Graham Bell Family Papers at the Library of Congress | Digital Collections  | Library of Congress

His father had also suffered a debilitating illness earlier in life and had been restored to health by a convalescence in Newfoundland.

Bell’s parents embarked upon a long-planned move when they realized that their remaining son was also sickly.

Acting decisively, Alexander Melville Bell asked Bell to arrange for the sale of all the family property, conclude all of his brother’s affairs.

Bell took over his last student, curing a pronounced lisp, and then joined his father and mother in setting out for the “New World“.

Reluctantly, Bell also had to conclude a relationship with Marie Eccleston, who, as he had surmised, was not prepared to leave England with him.

alexander graham bell | BOOK OF DAYS TALES

Above: Young Bell

In 1870, 23-year-old Bell travelled with his parents and his brother’s widow, Caroline Margaret Ottaway, to Paris, Ontario, to stay with Thomas Henderson, a Baptist minister and family friend.

Grand River riverfront in Paris, Ontario

Above: Paris, Ontario

The Bell family soon purchased a farm of 10.5 acres (42,000 m2) at Tutelo Heights (now called Tutela Heights), near Brantford, Ontario.

The property consisted of an orchard, large farmhouse, stable, pigsty, hen-house, and a carriage house, which bordered the Grand River.

Alexander Graham Bell in Brantford, Ontario, Canada -the Bell Homestead, the Bell Family's first home in Canada, now preserved as a museum to A.G. Bell.JPG

At the homestead, Bell set up his own workshop in the converted carriage house near to what he called his “dreaming place“, a large hollow nestled in trees at the back of the property above the river.

Above: The carriage house / “dreaming place

Despite his frail condition upon arriving in Canada, Bell found the climate and environs to his liking, and rapidly improved.

He continued his interest in the study of the human voice and when he discovered the Six Nations Reserve across the river at Onondaga, he learned the Mohawk language and translated its unwritten vocabulary into Visible Speech symbols.

For his work, Bell was awarded the title of Honorary Chief and participated in a ceremony where he donned a Mohawk headdress and danced traditional dances.

After setting up his workshop, Bell continued experiments based on Helmholtz’s work with electricity and sound.

He also modified a melodeon (a type of pump organ) so that it could transmit its music electrically over a distance.

Above: A portion of Melville House’s parlour, restored to the Victorian era style maintained by the Bells, using many of their original furnishings and artifacts, including their melodeon, seen in front of the window at centre (2009).

Once the family was settled in, both Bell and his father made plans to establish a teaching practice and in 1871, he accompanied his father to Montréal, where Melville was offered a position to teach his System of Visible Speech.

Montreal from the tower of Notre Dame Church, looking north, QC, about 1870  | Old montreal, East canada, American architecture

Above: Montréal, 1870

Bell’s father was invited by Sarah Fuller, principal of the Boston School for Deaf Mutes (which continues today as the public Horace Mann School for the Deaf), to introduce the Visible Speech System by providing training for Fuller’s instructors, but he declined the post in favour of his son.

1893 Horace Mann School for the Deaf, Miss Fuller and Her Class byAHFolsom BostonPublicLibrary.png

Travelling to Boston in April 1871, Bell proved successful in training the school’s instructors.

He was subsequently asked to repeat the programme at the American Asylum for Deaf-mutes (today’s American School for the Deaf) in Hartford, Connecticut, and the Clarke School for the Deaf in Northampton, Massachusetts.

American School for the Deaf, main building, August 10, 2008.jpg

Above: American School for the Deaf

CS SIGN.JPG

Returning home to Brantford after six months abroad, Bell continued his experiments with his “harmonic telegraph“.

The basic concept behind his device was that messages could be sent through a single wire if each message was transmitted at a different pitch, but work on both the transmitter and receiver was needed.

Unsure of his future, he first contemplated returning to London to complete his studies, but decided to return to Boston as a teacher.

His father helped him set up his private practice by contacting Gardiner Greene Hubbard (1822 – 1897), the president of the Clarke School for the Deaf for a recommendation.

Gardiner Greene Hubbard, LCCN2010645713 (cropped).jpg

Above: Gardiner Greene Hubbard

Teaching his father’s system, in October 1872, Alexander Bell opened his “School of Vocal Physiology and Mechanics of Speech” in Boston, which attracted a large number of deaf pupils, with his first class numbering 30 students.

While he was working as a private tutor, one of his pupils was Helen Keller (1880 – 1968), who came to him as a young child unable to see, hear, or speak.

She was later to say that Bell dedicated his life to the penetration of that “inhuman silence which separates and estranges“.

In 1893, Keller performed the sod-breaking ceremony for the construction of Bell’s new Volta Bureau, dedicated to “the increase and diffusion of knowledge relating to the deaf“.

A woman with full dark hair and wearing a long dark dress, her face in partial profile, sits in a simple wooden chair. A locket hangs from a slender chain around her neck; in her hands is a magnolia, its large white flower surrounded by dark leaves.

Above: Helen Keller

Several influential people of the time, including Bell, viewed deafness as something that should be eradicated, and also believed that with resources and effort, they could teach the deaf to read lips and speak (known as oralism) and not use sign language, thus enabling their integration within the wider society from which many were often being excluded.

Owing to his efforts to suppress the teaching of sign language, Bell is often viewed negatively by those embracing Deaf culture.

In 1872, Bell became professor of Vocal Physiology and Elocution at the Boston University School of Oratory.

During this period, he alternated between Boston and Brantford, spending summers in his Canadian home.

At Boston University, Bell was “swept up” by the excitement engendered by the many scientists and inventors residing in the city.

Boston University seal.svg

He continued his research in sound and endeavored to find a way to transmit musical notes and articulate speech, but although absorbed by his experiments, he found it difficult to devote enough time to experimentation.

While days and evenings were occupied by his teaching and private classes, Bell began to stay awake late into the night, running experiment after experiment in rented facilities at his boarding house.

Keeping “night owl” hours, he worried that his work would be discovered and took great pains to lock up his notebooks and laboratory equipment.

Bell had a specially made table where he could place his notes and equipment inside a locking cover.

Worse still, his health deteriorated as he suffered severe headaches.

Above: Building on work by Helmholtz, Bell transmitted musical tones in 1872 using a tuning fork sounder, in which an electric current passed through a wire dipped into liquid in a cup (C) that was vibrated by the tuning fork.

Returning to Boston in fall 1873, Bell made a far-reaching decision to concentrate on his experiments in sound.

Deciding to give up his lucrative private Boston practice, Bell retained only two students, six-year-old “Georgie” Sanders, deaf from birth, and 15-year-old Mabel Hubbard (1857 – 1923).

Mabel Hubbard Bell ppmsc.00849.jpg

Above: Mabel Hubbard

Each pupil would play an important role in the next developments.

George’s father, Thomas Sanders, a wealthy businessman, offered Bell a place to stay in nearby Salem with Georgie’s grandmother, complete with a room to “experiment“.

Although the offer was made by George’s mother and followed the year-long arrangement in 1872 where her son and his nurse had moved to quarters next to Bell’s boarding house, it was clear that Mr. Sanders was backing the proposal.

The arrangement was for teacher and student to continue their work together, with free room and board thrown in.

Mabel was a bright, attractive girl who was ten years Bell’s junior but became the object of his affection.

Having lost her hearing after a near-fatal bout of scarlet fever close to her fifth birthday, she had learned to read lips but her father, Gardiner Greene Hubbard, Bell’s benefactor and personal friend, wanted her to work directly with her teacher.

By 1874, Bell’s initial work on the harmonic telegraph had entered a formative stage, with progress made both at his new Boston “laboratory” (a rented facility) and at his family home in Canada a big success.

While working that summer in Brantford, Bell experimented with a “phonautograph“, a pen-like machine that could draw shapes of sound waves on smoked glass by tracing their vibrations.

Bell thought it might be possible to generate undulating electrical currents that corresponded to sound waves.

Bell also thought that multiple metal reeds tuned to different frequencies like a harp would be able to convert the undulating currents back into sound.

But he had no working model to demonstrate the feasibility of these ideas.

Above: Bell’s neighbor, P.D. Richards, drew a sketch on 9 November 1874, showing the experiments he had witnessed in which Bell sent telegraphic messages over wires using a liquid transmitter filled with mercury.

In 1874, telegraph message traffic was rapidly expanding and in the words of Western Union President William Orton, had become “the nervous system of commerce“. 

Antonio Meucci sent a telephone model and technical details to the Western Union telegraph company but failed to win a meeting with executives.

When he asked for his materials to be returned, in 1874, he was told they had been lost.

Above: P.D. Richards, Bell’s friend and neighbor, wrote the inventor a letter on November 9, 1874 describing the transmission of telegraphic messages over wires using a liquid transmitter filled with mercury.

This is a detail of the drawing included with the 1874 letter, which is in the Library of Congress.

Two years later Bell, who shared a laboratory with Meucci, filed a patent for a telephone, became a celebrity and made a lucrative deal with Western Union.

Western Union Logo 2019.svg

Meucci sued and was nearing victory—the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case and fraud charges were initiated against Bell—when the Florentine died in 1889.

The legal action died with him.

Orton had contracted with inventors Thomas Edison (1847 – 1931) and Elisha Gray to find a way to send multiple telegraph messages on each telegraph line to avoid the great cost of constructing new lines.

Above: Thomas Edison invented the carbon microphone which produced a strong telephone signal.

When Bell mentioned to Gardiner Hubbard and Thomas Sanders that he was working on a method of sending multiple tones on a telegraph wire using a multi-reed device, the two wealthy patrons began to financially support Bell’s experiments.

Patent matters would be handled by Hubbard’s patent attorney, Anthony Pollok.

In March 1875, Bell and Pollok visited the scientist Joseph Henry (1797 – 1878), who was then director of the Smithsonian Institution, and asked Henry’s advice on the electrical multi-reed apparatus that Bell hoped would transmit the human voice by telegraph.

Henry replied that Bell had “the germ of a great invention“.

When Bell said that he did not have the necessary knowledge, Henry replied, “Get it!

Joseph Henry (1879).jpg

Above: Joseph Henry

That declaration greatly encouraged Bell to keep trying, even though he did not have the equipment needed to continue his experiments, nor the ability to create a working model of his ideas.

However, a chance meeting in 1874 between Bell and Thomas A. Watson, an experienced electrical designer and mechanic at the electrical machine shop of Charles Williams, changed all that.

With financial support from Sanders and Hubbard, Bell hired Thomas Watson as his assistant, and the two of them experimented with acoustic telegraphy.

Pin by Janus Stefanowicz on WATSON | Different tones, Hypothesis, Alexander  graham bell

On 2 June 1875, Watson accidentally plucked one of the reeds and Bell, at the receiving end of the wire, heard the overtones of the reed:

Overtones that would be necessary for transmitting speech.

That demonstrated to Bell that only one reed or armature was necessary, not multiple reeds.

This led to the “gallows” sound-powered telephone, which could transmit indistinct, voice-like sounds, but not clear speech.

HI Mailbag: The New Telephone Company | Tech history, Historical people,  History

In 1875, Bell developed an acoustic telegraph and drew up a patent application for it.

Since he had agreed to share US profits with his investors Gardiner Hubbard and Thomas Sanders, Bell requested that an associate in Ontario, George Brown, attempt to patent it in Britain, instructing his lawyers to apply for a patent in the US only after they received word from Britain (Britain would issue patents only for discoveries not previously patented elsewhere).

George Brown.jpg

Above: George Brown

Meanwhile, Elisha Gray was also experimenting with acoustic telegraphy and thought of a way to transmit speech using a water transmitter.

On 14 February 1876, Gray filed a caveat with the US Patent Office for a telephone design that used a water transmitter.

That same morning, Bell’s lawyer filed Bell’s application with the patent office.

There is considerable debate about who arrived first and Gray later challenged the primacy of Bell’s patent.

Bell was in Boston on 14 February and did not arrive in Washington until 26 February.

Seal of the United States Patent and Trademark Office.svg

Bell’s patent 174,465, was issued to Bell on 7 March 1876, by the US Patent Office.

Bell’s patent covered “the method of, and apparatus for, transmitting vocal or other sounds telegraphically by causing electrical undulations, similar in form to the vibrations of the air accompanying the said vocal or other sound

Bell returned to Boston the same day and the next day resumed work, drawing in his notebook a diagram similar to that in Gray’s patent caveat.

Above: A Bell drawing from March 8, 1876 that shows a liquid transmitter was witnessed by numerous individuals, who initialed Bell’s notebook.

On 10 March 1876, three days after his patent was issued, Bell succeeded in getting his telephone to work, using a liquid transmitter similar to Gray’s design.

Vibration of the diaphragm caused a needle to vibrate in the water, varying the electrical resistance in the circuit.

When Bell spoke the sentence “Mr. Watson—Come here—I want to see you” into the liquid transmitter,Watson, listening at the receiving end in an adjoining room, heard the words clearly.

Although Bell was, and still is, accused of stealing the telephone from Gray, Bell used Gray’s water transmitter design only after Bell’s patent had been granted, and only as a proof of concept scientific experiment, to prove to his own satisfaction that intelligible “articulate speech” (Bell’s words) could be electrically transmitted.

March 10, 1876: "Mr. Watson, come here, I want to see you" - Alexander  Graham Bell, in the first succ… | American folk art, Newspaper collection,  Historical society

After March 1876, Bell focused on improving the electromagnetic telephone and never used Gray’s liquid transmitter in public demonstrations or commercial use.

The question of priority for the variable resistance feature of the telephone was raised by the examiner before he approved Bell’s patent application.

He told Bell that his claim for the variable resistance feature was also described in Gray’s caveat.

Bell pointed to a variable resistance device in his previous application in which he described a cup of mercury, not water.

He had filed the mercury application at the patent office a year earlier on 25 February 1875, long before Elisha Gray described the water device.

Datei:Pouring liquid mercury bionerd.jpg – Wikipedia

In addition, Gray abandoned his caveat, and because he did not contest Bell’s priority, the examiner approved Bell’s patent on 3 March 1876.

Gray had reinvented the variable resistance telephone, but Bell was the first to write down the idea and the first to test it in a telephone.

But are the famous always worthy of their fame?

The patient examiner, Zenas Fisk Wilber, later stated in an affidavit that he was an alcoholic who was much in debt to Bell’s lawyer, Marcellus Bailey, with whom he had served in the Civil War.

He claimed he showed Gray’s patent caveat to Bailey.

Wilber also claimed (after Bell arrived in Washington D.C. from Boston) that he showed Gray’s caveat to Bell and that Bell paid him $100 (equivalent to $2,300 in 2019).

Bell claimed they discussed the patent only in general terms, although in a letter to Gray, Bell admitted that he learned some of the technical details.

Bell denied in an affidavit that he ever gave Wilber any money.

ALEXANDER GRAHAM BELL – Hillsgate

I have no doubt that Bell was talented, but I cannot shake the whispers of a Faustian pact.

Charles Bourseul, Antonio Meucci, Johann Philipp Reis, Alexander Graham Bell, and Elisha Gray, amongst others, have all been credited with the invention of the telephone.

Above: the Meucci telephone

Above: the Reis telephone

Alexander Graham Bell was the first to be awarded a patent for the electric telephone by the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) in March 1876. 

Above: Alexander Graham Bell’s telephone patent drawing

Before Bell’s patent, the telephone transmitted sound in a way that was similar to the telegraph.

This method used vibrations and circuits to send electrical pulses, but was missing key features.

Bell found that this method produced a sound through intermittent currents, but in order for the telephone to work a fluctuating current reproduced sounds the best.

The fluctuating currents became the basis for the working telephone, creating Bell’s patent.

That first patent by Bell was the master patent of the telephone, from which other patents for electric telephone devices and features flowed.

Above: The master telephone patent, 174465, granted to Bell, 7 March 1876

The Bell patents were forensically victorious and commercially decisive.

Above: re-enactment of Bell’s first telephone transmitter

In 1876, shortly after Bell’s patent application, Hungarian engineer Tivadar Puskás proposed the telephone switch, which allowed for the formation of telephone exchanges, and eventually networks.

Bell confirmed Brantford as the birthplace of his device in a 1906 speech:

The telephone problem was solved, and it was solved at my father’s home“.

At the unveiling of the Bell Memorial on 24 October 1917, Bell reminded the attendees that “Brantford is right in claiming the invention of the telephone here which was conceived in Brantford in 1874 and born in Boston in 1875” and that “the first transmission to a distance was made between Brantford and Paris” (on 3 August 1876).

Continuing his experiments in Brantford, Bell brought home a working model of his telephone.

On 3 August 1876, from the telegraph office in Brantford, Ontario, Bell sent a tentative telegram to the village of Mount Pleasant four miles (six kilometres) distant, indicating that he was ready.

He made a telephone call via telegraph wires and faint voices were heard replying.

The following night, he amazed guests as well as his family with a call between the Bell Homestead and the office of the Dominion Telegraph Company in Brantford along an improvised wire strung up along telegraph lines and fences, and laid through a tunnel.

This time, guests at the household distinctly heard people in Brantford reading and singing.

The third test on 10 August 1876, was made via the telegraph line between Brantford and Paris, Ontario, eight miles (thirteen kilometres) distant.

This test was said by many sources to be the “world’s first long-distance call“.

World's First Successful Long Distance Telephone Call, Aug 10 1876 -  Brantford ON (Canada) - First of its Kind on Waymarking.com

The final test certainly proved that the telephone could work over long distances, at least as a one-way call. 

The first two-way (reciprocal) conversation over a line occurred between Cambridge and Boston (roughly 2.5 miles) on 9 October 1876.

During that conversation, Bell was on Kilby Street in Boston and Watson was at the offices of the Walworth Manufacturing Company.

Newhaven Display on Twitter: "#TodayInTechHistory On this day in 1876: Mr. Alexander  Graham Bell and Thomas Watson, one in Boston and the other in Cambridge,  demonstrate the first two-way telephone call utilizing

Canada’s first telephone factory, created by James Cowherd, was located in Brantford and operated from about 1879 until Cowherd’s death in 1881.

On This Day in Telephone History December 13TH 1878 - The Telephone Museum,  Inc.

The first telephone business office which opened in 1877, not far from the Bell Homestead, was located in what is now Brantford.

The combination of events has led to Brantford calling itself “The Telephone City“.

The Telephone City | fashion with compassion

Bell and his partners, Hubbard and Sanders, offered to sell the patent outright to Western Union for $100,000.

The president of Western Union, Willliam Orton, balked, countering that the telephone was nothing but a toy.

Two years later, he told colleagues that if he could get the patent for $25 million he would consider it a bargain.

By then, the Bell company no longer wanted to sell the patent.

William Orton (Western Union President).jpg

Above: William Orton (1826 – 1878)

Bell’s investors would become millionaires while he fared well from residuals and at one point had assets of nearly one million dollars.

Bell began a series of public demonstrations and lectures to introduce the new invention to the scientific community as well as the general public.

A short time later, his demonstration of an early telephone prototype at the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia brought the telephone to international attention.

Centennial Exhibition, Opening Day.jpg

Above: Opening ceremonies, Centennial Exposition, Philiadelphia, 10 May 1876

Influential visitors to the exhibition included Emperor Pedro II of Brazil.

Half-length photographic portrait of an older man with white hair and beard dressed in a dark jacket and necktie

Above: Pedro II of Brazil (1825 – 1891)

One of the judges at the Exhibition, Sir William Thomson (later, Lord Kelvin), a renowned Scottish scientist, described the telephone as “the greatest by far of all the marvels of the electric telegraph“.

Lord Kelvin photograph.jpg

Above: Lord Kelvin (1824 – 1907)

On 14 January 1878, at Osborne House, on the Isle of Wight, Bell demonstrated the device to Queen Victoria, placing calls to Cowes, Southampton and London.

Osborne-iow-3Ja10-10876.jpg

Above: Osborne House

These were the first publicly witnessed long-distance telephone calls in the UK.

The Queen considered the process to be “quite extraordinary” although the sound was “rather faint“.

She later asked to buy the equipment that was used, but Bell offered to make “a set of telephones” specifically for her.

Photograph of Queen Victoria, 1882

Above: Queen Victoria (1819 – 1901)

The Bell Telephone Company was created in 1877.

By 1886, more than 150,000 people in the US owned telephones.

Bell Company engineers made numerous other improvements to the telephone, which emerged as one of the most successful products ever.

In 1879, the Bell company acquired Edison’s patents for the carbon microphone from Western Union.

This made the telephone practical for longer distances, and it was no longer necessary to shout to be heard at the receiving telephone.

Emperor Pedro II of Brazil was the first person to buy stock in Bell’s company, the Bell Telephone Company.

One of the first telephones in a private residence was installed in his palace in Petrópolis, his summer retreat forty miles (sixty-four kilometres) from Rio de Janeiro.

From upper left: skyline of downtown, city's Cathedral, Imperial Museum, 16 de Março street, Quitandinha Palace, and aerial view from the Cathedral.

Above: Images of Petrópolis

In January 1915, Bell made the first ceremonial transcontinental telephone call.

Calling from the AT&T head office at 15 Dey Street in New York City, Bell was heard by Thomas Watson at 333 Grant Avenue in San Francisco. 

AT&T logo 2016.svg

The New York Times reported:

On 9 October 1876, Alexander Graham Bell and Thomas A. Watson talked by telephone to each other over a two-mile wire stretched between Cambridge and Boston.

It was the first wire conversation ever held.

Yesterday afternoon [25 January 1915], the same two men talked by telephone to each other over a 3,400-mile wire between New York and San Francisco.

Dr. Bell, the veteran inventor of the telephone, was in New York, and Mr. Watson, his former associate, was on the other side of the continent.

San Francisco from the Marin Headlands

Above: San Francisco

On 11 July 1877, a few days after the Bell Telephone Company was established, Bell married Mabel Hubbard at the Hubbard estate in Cambridge, Massachusetts.

His wedding present to his bride was to turn over 1,487 of his 1,497 shares in the newly formed Bell Telephone Company.

Shortly thereafter, the newlyweds embarked on a year-long honeymoon in Europe.

During that excursion, Bell took a handmade model of his telephone with him, making it a “working holiday“.

The courtship had begun years earlier.

However, Bell waited until he was more financially secure before marrying.

Alexander Graham Bell and Montessori - Montessori Education

Although the telephone appeared to be an “instant” success, it was not initially a profitable venture and Bell’s main sources of income were from lectures until after 1897.

One unusual request exacted by his fiancée was that he use “Alec” rather than the family’s earlier familiar name of “Aleck“.

From 1876, he would sign his name “Alec Bell“.

They had four children:

  • Elsie May Bell (1878–1964) who married Gilbert Hovey Grosvenor of National Geographic fame.
  • Marian Hubbard Bell (1880–1962) who was referred to as “Daisy“. Married David Fairchild.
  • Two sons who died in infancy (Edward in 1881 and Robert in 1883).

The Bell family home was in Cambridge, Massachusetts, until 1880 when Bell’s father-in-law bought a house in Washington DC.

In 1882 he bought a home in the same city for Bell’s family, so they could be with him while he attended to the numerous court cases involving patent disputes.

Mabel Gardiner Hubbard - Wikipedia

Bell was a British subject throughout his early life in Scotland and later in Canada until 1882 when he became a naturalized citizen of the United States.

In 1915, he characterized his status as:

I am not one of those hyphenated Americans who claim allegiance to two countries.”

Despite this declaration, Bell has been proudly claimed as a “native son” by all three countries he resided in: the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom.

Alexander Graham Bell - Wikiwand

By 1885, a new summer retreat was contemplated.

That summer, the Bells had a vacation on Cape Breton Island in Nova Scotia, spending time at the small village of Baddeck.

Returning in 1886, Bell started building an estate on a point across from Baddeck, overlooking Bras d’Or Lake.

By 1889, a large house, christened The Lodge was completed and two years later, a larger complex of buildings, including a new laboratory, were begun that the Bells would name Beinn Bhreagh (Gaelic: Beautiful Mountain) after Bell’s ancestral Scottish highlands.

Bell also built the Bell Boatyard on the estate, employing up to 40 people building experimental craft as well as wartime lifeboats and workboats for the Royal Canadian Navy and pleasure craft for the Bell family.

He was an enthusiastic boater, and Bell and his family sailed or rowed a long series of vessels on Bras d’Or Lake, ordering additional vessels from the H.W. Embree and Sons boatyard in Port Hawkesbury, Nova Scotia.

In his final, and some of his most productive years, Bell split his residency between Washington DC, where he and his family initially resided for most of the year, and Beinn Bhreagh, where they spent increasing amounts of time.

Until the end of his life, Bell and his family would alternate between the two homes, but Beinn Bhreagh would, over the next 30 years, become more than a summer home as Bell became so absorbed in his experiments that his annual stays lengthened.

A three-story gray mansion, with a covered front entrance

Above: The Brodhead–Bell mansion, the Bell family residence in Washington DC, from 1882 to 1889

Both Mabel and Bell became immersed in the Baddeck community and were accepted by the villagers as “their own“.

The Kidston Island Lighthouse which also appears on the village seal.

Above: The Kidston Island Lighthouse, Baddeck

The Bells were still in residence at Beinn Bhreagh when the Halifax Explosion occurred on 6 December 1917.

Mabel and Bell mobilized the community to help victims in Halifax.

Summer, a warm evening, Halifax Harbour.

Andrea Müller, the perfect travelling companion.

We shared a tent, thoughts, were emotionally intimate without physical complications.

Her customary T-shirt ever a reminder of the constant beauty beneath, dirty blonde hair, brilliant mind, a far more experienced traveller than I who introduced me to Lonely Planet Canada‘s first edition (which would be her parting gift to me after we parted later at Barrington Passage).

Buy 2, get a 3rd free on Guide Books with Lonely Planet (US and Canada)

We met hitching the same road to Port aux Basques, rode the ferry to North Sydney, hitched to Halifax.

She was the Aaron to this Moses of a faltering tongue.

She taught me how to charm strangers, how to compel sympathy and generosity, all done with an ease I envied.

I knew little about her and was in equal measure attracted and repulsed by her.

She dressed like an unmade bed as if soiled laundry had a life of its own.

She would be the first German I ever met, the first woman I ever saw, unconcerned as to whether underarms and legs were shaven, not at all concerned if I approved of her perpetual cigarette aroma.

She told me of her experiences pre-Halifax, how she was mugged in LA, how she was propositioned on the ferry by an old man who offered her compensation if she would offer him relief.

(She refused, he relented.)

She showed me an attitude, a worldly wisdom, a quiet confidence.

Her tales of travel were descriptive, but her past a blank sheet upon which imagination could only hazard a guess.

Location North America.svg

A tall redheaded man, calling himself John Mackenzie, gave us a lift into town, a place to crash for the night, a boat ride across the harbour, drove us to the outskirts of the metropolitan area heading west the next morning.

A motorboat at sunset accompanied by an endless patter of legend and lore about all we were seeing.

Luxury Motor Yacht at Sunset, Stock Footage Video (100% Royalty-free)  14141027 | Shutterstock

It happened right here,” he says, suddenly killing the engine in the middle of the channel.

1: Map of Halifax Harbour, Nova Scotia, Canada (from Fader and Miller... |  Download Scientific Diagram

Dartmouth, Halifax’s neighbouring twin, lies on the east shore of Halifax Harbour, and Halifax is on the west shore.

By 1917, Halifax’s inner harbour had become a principal assembly point for merchant convoys leaving for Britain and France.

Halifax and Dartmouth had thrived during times of war.

The harbour was one of the British Royal Navy’s most important bases in North America, a centre for wartime trade, and a home to privateers who harried the British Empire’s enemies during the American Revolution, the Napoleonic Wars, and the War of 1812.

The completion of the Intercolonial Railway and its Deep Water Terminal in 1880 allowed for increased steamship trade and led to accelerated development of the port area, but Halifax faced an economic downturn in the 1890s as local factories lost ground to competitors in central Canada.

The British garrison left the city in late 1905 and early 1906. 

The Canadian government took over the Halifax Dockyard (now CFB Halifax) from the Royal Navy.

This dockyard later became the command centre of the Royal Canadian Navy upon its founding in 1910.

Just before the First World War, the Canadian government began a determined, costly effort to develop the harbour and waterfront facilities.

The outbreak of the war brought Halifax back to prominence.

As the Royal Canadian Navy had virtually no seaworthy ships of its own, the Royal Navy assumed responsibility for maintaining Atlantic trade routes by re-adopting Halifax as its North American base of operations.

In 1915, management of the harbour fell under the control of the Royal Canadian Navy under the supervision of Captain Superintendent Edward Harrington Martin.

By 1917 there was a growing naval fleet in Halifax, including patrol ships, tugboats, and minesweepers.

The population of Halifax/Dartmouth had increased to between 60,000 and 65,000 people by 1917.

Convoys carried men, animals, and supplies to the European theatre of war.

The two main points of departure were in Nova Scotia at Sydney, on Cape Breton Island, and Halifax. 

Hospital ships brought the wounded to the city, and a new military hospital was constructed in the city.

The success of German U-boat attacks on ships crossing the Atlantic Ocean led the Allies to institute a convoy system to reduce losses while transporting goods and soldiers to Europe.

Merchant ships gathered at Bedford Basin on the northwestern end of the harbour, which was protected by two sets of anti-submarine nets and guarded by patrol ships of the Royal Canadian Navy.

The convoys departed under the protection of British cruisers and destroyers. 

A large army garrison protected the city with forts, gun batteries, and anti-submarine nets.

These factors drove a major military, industrial, and residential expansion of the city, and the weight of goods passing through the harbour increased nearly ninefold. 

All neutral ships bound for ports in North America were required to report to Halifax for inspection.

Commissioners House, in the Naval Yard, Halifax, 1804.png

The Norwegian ship SS Imo had sailed from the Netherlands en route to New York to take on relief supplies for Belgium, under the command of Haakon From.

The ship arrived in Halifax on 3 December 1917 for neutral inspection and spent two days in Bedford Basin awaiting refuelling supplies.

Though she had been given clearance to leave the port on 5 December, Imo‘s departure was delayed because her coal load did not arrive until late that afternoon.

The loading of fuel was not completed until after the anti-submarine nets had been raised for the night.

Therefore, the vessel could not weigh anchor until the next morning.

Halifax explosion - Imo.jpg

The French cargo ship SS Mont Blanc arrived from New York late on 5 December, under the command of Aimé Le Medec.

The vessel was fully loaded with the explosives TNT and picric acid, the highly flammable fuel benzol and guncotton.

She intended to join a slow convoy gathering in Bedford Basin readying to depart for Europe but was too late to enter the harbour before the nets were raised.

Ships carrying dangerous cargo were not allowed into the harbour before the war, but the risks posed by German submarines had resulted in a relaxation of regulations.

Navigating into or out of Bedford Basin required passage through a strait called the Narrows.

Ships were expected to keep close to the side of the channel situated on their starboard (“right“), and pass oncoming vessels “port to port“, that is to keep them on their “left” side.

Ships were restricted to a speed of 5 knots  (9.3 km/h; 5.8 mph) within the harbour.

Flashback in Maritime history: SS Mont Blanc explosion in Halifax 6 Dec 1917  (video) - MaritimeCyprus

Imo was granted clearance to leave Bedford Basin by signals from the guard ship HMCS Acadia at approximately 7:30 on the morning of 6 December, with Pilot William Hayes on board.

The ship entered the Narrows well above the harbour’s speed limit in an attempt to make up for the delay experienced in loading her coal. 

Imo met American tramp steamer SS Clara being piloted up the wrong (western) side of the harbour.

The pilots agreed to pass starboard-to-starboard.

Soon afterwards, Imo was forced to head even further towards the Dartmouth shore after passing the tugboat Stella Maris, which was travelling up the harbour to Bedford Basin near mid-channel.

Horatio Brannen, the captain of Stella Maris, saw Imo approaching at excessive speed and ordered his ship closer to the western shore to avoid an accident.

The Halifax explosion, 6 December 1917 « Quotulatiousness

Francis Mackey, an experienced harbour pilot, had boarded Mont Blanc on the evening of 5 December 1917.

He had asked about “special protections” such as a guard ship, given the Mont Blanc‘s cargo, but no protections were put in place.

Mont Blanc started moving at 7:30 am on 6 December and was the second ship to enter the harbour as the anti-submarine net between Georges Island and Pier 21 opened for the morning.

Mont Blanc headed towards Bedford Basin on the Dartmouth side of the harbour.

Remembering the Halifax Explosion: 100 years later - HalifaxToday.ca

Mackey kept his eye on the ferry traffic between Halifax and Dartmouth and other small boats in the area. 

He first spotted Imo when she was about 0.75 miles (1.21 km) away and became concerned as her path appeared to be heading towards his ship’s starboard side, as if to cut him off.

Mackey gave a short blast of his ship’s signal whistle to indicate that he had the right of way but was met with two short blasts from Imo, indicating that the approaching vessel would not yield its position.

The captain ordered Mont-Blanc to halt her engines and angle slightly to starboard, closer to the Dartmouth side of the Narrows.

He let out another single blast of his whistle, hoping the other vessel would likewise move to starboard but was again met with a double-blast.

Ship whistle stock image. Image of maritime, whistle - 20144169

Sailors on nearby ships heard the series of signals and, realizing that a collision was imminent, gathered to watch as Imo bore down on Mont Blanc.

Both ships had cut their engines by this point, but their momentum carried them right on top of each other at slow speed.

Unable to ground his ship for fear of a shock that would set off his explosive cargo, Mackey ordered Mont Blanc to steer hard to port (starboard helm) and crossed the bow of Imo in a last-second bid to avoid a collision.

The two ships were almost parallel to each other, when Imo suddenly sent out three signal blasts, indicating the ship was reversing its engines.

The combination of the cargoless ship’s height in the water and the transverse thrust of her right-hand propeller caused the ship’s head to swing into Mont Blanc

Imo‘s prow pushed into the No. 1 hold of Mont Blanc, on her starboard side.

The collision occurred at 8:45 am.

The Halifax Explosion Was One Of History's Tragedies

The damage to Mont Blanc was not severe, but barrels of deck cargo toppled and broke open.

This flooded the deck with benzol that quickly flowed into the hold.

As Imo‘s engines kicked in, she disengaged, which created sparks inside Mont Blanc‘s hull.

These ignited the vapours from the benzol.

A fire started at the water line and travelled quickly up the side of the ship.

Surrounded by thick black smoke, and fearing she would explode almost immediately, the captain ordered the crew to abandon ship.

Tall cloud of smoke rising over the water

A growing number of Halifax citizens gathered on the street or stood at the windows of their homes or businesses to watch the spectacular fire.

The frantic crew of Mont Blanc shouted from their two lifeboats to some of the other vessels that their ship was about to explode, but they could not be heard above the noise and confusion.

As the lifeboats made their way across the harbour to the Dartmouth shore, the abandoned ship continued to drift and beached herself at Pier 6 near the foot of Richmond Street.

The Bob Newbon` Lifeboat by Charles Napier Hemy (1841-1917, United Kingdom)  | Paintings Reproductions Charles

Towing two scows at the time of the collision, Stella Maris responded immediately to the fire, anchoring the barges and steaming back towards Pier 6 to spray the burning ship with their fire hose. 

The tug’s captain, Horatio H. Brannen, and his crew realized that the fire was too intense for their single hose and backed off from the burning Mont Blanc.

They were approached by a whaler from HMS Highflyer and later a steam pinnace belonging to HMCS Niobe.

HMS Highflyer AWM 302207.jpeg

Captain Brannen and Albert Mattison of Niobe agreed to secure a line to the French ship’s stern so as to pull it away from the pier to avoid setting it on fire.

The five-inch (127-millimetre) hawser initially produced was deemed too small and orders for a ten-inch (254-millimetre) hawser came down.

It was at this point that the blast occurred.

Niobe

At 9:04:35 am the out-of-control fire on board Mont Blanc set off her cargo of high explosives.

The ship was completely blown apart and a powerful blast wave radiated away from the explosion initially at more than 1,000 metres (3,300 ft) per second.

Temperatures of 5,000 °C (9,000 °F) and pressures of thousands of atmospheres accompanied the moment of detonation at the centre of the explosion.

White-hot shards of iron fell down upon Halifax and Dartmouth. 

Mont Blancs forward 90-mm gun landed approximately 5.6 kilometres (3.5 mi) north of the explosion site near Albro Lake in Dartmouth with its barrel melted away, and the shank of Mont Blanc‘s anchor, weighing half a ton, landed 3.2 kilometres (2.0 mi) south at Armdale.

Halifax Maps and Orientation: Halifax, Nova Scotia - NS, Canada

A cloud of white smoke rose to at least 3,600 metres (11,800 ft).

The shock wave from the blast travelled through the earth at nearly 23 times the speed of sound and was felt as far away as Cape Breton (207 kilometres or 129 miles) and Prince Edward Island (180 kilometres or 110 miles).

Atlantic Provinces Map | Digital| Creative Force

An area of over 160 hectares (400 acres) was completely destroyed by the explosion, and the harbour floor was momentarily exposed by the volume of water that was displaced.

A tsunami was formed by water surging in to fill the void. 

It rose as high as 18 metres (60 ft) above the high-water mark on the Halifax side of the harbour.

Imo was carried onto the shore at Dartmouth by the tsunami. 

Two men observe a large beached ship with "Belgian Relief" painted on her side

Above: SS Imo aground on the Dartmouth side of the harbour after the explosion

The blast killed all but one on the whaler, everyone on the pinnace and 21 of the 26 men on Stella Maris.

She ended up on the Dartmouth shore, severely damaged.

The captain’s son, First Mate Walter Brannen, who had been thrown into the hold by the blast, survived, as did four others.

All but one of the Mont Blanc crew members survived.

Over 1,600 people were killed instantly and 9,000 were injured, more than 300 of whom later died. 

Every building within a 2.6-kilometre (1.6 mi) radius, over 12,000 in total, was destroyed or badly damaged.

Panoramic view over traintracks to destroyed cityscape

Hundreds of people who had been watching the fire from their homes were blinded when the blast wave shattered the windows in front of them.

Stoves and lamps overturned by the force of the blast sparked fires throughout Halifax, particularly in the North End, where entire city blocks were caught up in the inferno, trapping residents inside their houses.

The Halifax Explosion 1917 Nova Scotia, Canada - YouTube

Firefighter Billy Wells, who was thrown away from the explosion and had his clothes torn from his body, described the devastation survivors faced:

The sight was awful, with people hanging out of windows dead.

Some with their heads missing, and some thrown onto the overhead telegraph wires.”

He was the only member of the eight-man crew of the fire engine Patricia to survive.

Halifax Regional Fire & Emergency Crest

Large brick and stone factories near Pier 6, such as the Acadia Sugar Refinery, disappeared into unrecognizable heaps of rubble, killing most of their workers. 

Cityscape bisected by central traintracks, with dense buildings to the left and harbourfront to the right

Above: Looking north from a grain elevator towards Acadia Sugar Refinery, circa 1900, showing the area later devastated by the 1917 explosion

The Nova Scotia cotton mill located 1.5 km (0.93 mile) from the blast was destroyed by fire and the collapse of its concrete floors.

The Royal Naval College of Canada building was badly damaged, and several cadets and instructors maimed.

The Richmond Railway Yards and station were destroyed, killing 55 railway workers and destroying and damaging over 500 railway cars.

The North Street Station, one of the busiest in Canada, was badly damaged.

The death toll could have been worse had it not been for the self-sacrifice of an Intercolonial Railway dispatcher, Patrick Vincent (Vince) Coleman, operating at the railyard about 750 feet (230 m) from Pier 6, where the explosion occurred.

He and his co-worker, William Lovett, learned of the dangerous cargo aboard the burning Mont Blanc from a sailor and began to flee.

Coleman remembered that an incoming passenger train from Saint John, New Brunswick, was due to arrive at the railyard within minutes.

He returned to his post alone and continued to send out urgent telegraph messages to stop the train.

Several variations of the message have been reported, among them this from the Maritime Museum of the Atlantic:

MMAabove.JPG

Hold up the train.

Ammunition ship afire in harbor making for Pier 6 and will explode.

Guess this will be my last message.

Good-bye boys.”

Coleman’s message was responsible for bringing all incoming trains around Halifax to a halt.

It was heard by other stations all along the Intercolonial Railway, helping railway officials to respond immediately.

Passenger Train #10, the overnight train from Saint John, is believed to have heeded the warning and stopped a safe distance from the blast at Rockingham, saving the lives of about 300 railway passengers.

Coleman was killed at his post.

The exact number killed by the disaster is unknown.

The Halifax Explosion Remembrance Book, an official database of the Nova Scotia Archives and Record Management, identified 1,782 victims.

As many as 1,600 people died immediately in the blast, tsunami, and collapse of buildings.

The last body, a caretaker killed at the Exhibition Grounds, was not recovered until the summer of 1919.

Large building with windows and part of roof missing

 

An additional 9,000 were injured.

1,630 homes were destroyed in the explosion and fires, and another 12,000 damaged.

Building with walls bent outward and floor collapsing

Roughly 6,000 people were left homeless and 25,000 had insufficient shelter. 

Destroyed buildings, with harbour in background

The city’s industrial sector was in large part gone, with many workers among the casualties and the dockyard heavily damaged.

Many of the wounds inflicted by the blast were permanently debilitating, such as those caused by flying glass or by the flash of the explosion.

Thousands of people had stopped to watch the ship burning in the harbour, many from inside buildings, leaving them directly in the path of glass fragments from shattered windows.

Roughly 5,900 eye injuries were reported.

41 people lost their sight permanently.

Blindness (2008 film).png

The Halifax Explosion was one of the largest artificial non-nuclear explosions.

An extensive comparison of 130 major explosions by Halifax historian Jay White in 1994 concluded that it “remains unchallenged in overall magnitude as long as five criteria are considered together: number of casualties, force of blast, radius of devastation, quantity of explosive material, and total value of property destroyed.

Tall, oddly-shaped concrete structure with bells

Above: Halifax Explosion Memorial Bell Tower

For many years afterward, the Halifax Explosion was the standard by which all large blasts were measured.

For instance, in its report on the atomic bombing of Hiroshima, Time wrote that the explosive power of the Little Boy bomb was seven times that of the Halifax Explosion.

How Japan and the U.S. Reconciled After Hiroshima, Nagasaki | Time

Above: Bombing of Hiroshima, 6 August 1945

The many eye injuries resulting from the disaster led to better understanding on the part of physicians of how to care for damaged eyes, and “with the recently formed Canadian National Institute for the Blind (CNIB), Halifax became internationally known as a centre for care for the blind“, according to Dalhousie University Professor Victoria Allen.

What Does the CNIB Do? | Mountain Eye Care

The lack of coordinated pediatric care in such a disaster was also noted by William Ladd, a surgeon from Boston who had arrived to help.

His insights from the explosion are generally credited with inspiring him to pioneer the specialty of pediatric surgery in North America.

The Halifax Explosion also inspired a series of health reforms, including around public sanitation and maternity care.

Clockwise from top: Downtown Halifax skyline, Crystal Crescent Beach, Central Library, Sullivan's Pond, Peggy's Cove, Macdonald Bridge

Above: Images of modern Halifax, Nova Scotia

I still remember how beautiful women can be in the sunset.

I still remember how the story of a deadly tragedy made me grateful to be alive.

It is ironic that a man who sought to help the deaf hear would be present at an accident where so many would be blinded.

Although Alexander Graham Bell is most often associated with the invention of the telephone, his interests were extremely varied.

According to one of his biographers, Charlotte Gray, Bell’s work ranged “unfettered across the scientific landscape” and he often went to bed voraciously reading the Encyclopædia Britannica, scouring it for new areas of interest.

Alexander Graham Bell | Book by Charlotte Gray | Official Publisher Page |  Simon & Schuster

The range of Bell’s inventive genius is represented only in part by the 18 patents granted in his name alone and the 12 he shared with his collaborators.

These included 14 for the telephone and telegraph, four for the photophone, one for the phonograph, five for aerial vehicles, four for “hydro airplanes“, and two for selenium cells.

An image of darkened brass historical plaque with a streak of green corrosion running down it, mounted on the exterior side of a brick building.

Above: A historical plaque on the side of the Franklin School in Washington DC, which marks one of the points from which the photophone was demonstrated

Above: A photophone receiver and headset, one half of Bell and Tainter’s optical telecommunication system of 1880

Gramophone History - Invention of the Gramophone and Vinyl

Above: Alexander graham bell’s phonograph

Bell’s inventions spanned a wide range of interests and included a metal jacket to assist in breathing, the audiometer to detect minor hearing problems, a device to locate icebergs, investigations on how to separate salt from seawater, and work on finding alternative fuels.

audiometer | Edhird's Blog

Above: Bell’s audiometer

Bell worked extensively in medical research and invented techniques for teaching speech to the deaf.

During his Volta Laboratory period, Bell and his associates considered impressing a magnetic field on a record as a means of reproducing sound.

Volta Bureau Washington DC.JPG

Although the trio briefly experimented with the concept, they could not develop a workable prototype.

They abandoned the idea, never realizing they had glimpsed a basic principle which would one day find its application in the tape recorder, the hard disc and floppy disk drive and other magnetic media.

Bell’s own home used a primitive form of air conditioning, in which fans blew currents of air across great blocks of ice.

He also anticipated modern concerns with fuel shortages and industrial pollution. 

Methane gas, he reasoned, could be produced from the waste of farms and factories.

At his Canadian estate in Nova Scotia, he experimented with composting toilets and devices to capture water from the atmosphere.

In a magazine interview published shortly before his death, he reflected on the possibility of using solar panels to heat houses.

Bell and his assistant Charles Sumner Tainter jointly invented a wireless telephone, named a photophone, which allowed for the transmission of both sounds and normal human conversations on a beam of light.

Both men later became full associates in the Volta Laboratory Association.

On 21 June 1880, Bell’s assistant transmitted a wireless voice telephone message a considerable distance, from the roof of the Franklin School in Washington DC, to Bell at the window of his laboratory, some 700 feet (213 m) away, 19 years before the first voice radio transmissions.

Bell believed the photophone’s principles were his life’s “greatest achievement“, telling a reporter shortly before his death that the photophone was “the greatest invention I have ever made, greater than the telephone“.

The photophone was a precursor to the fiber-optic communication systems which achieved popular worldwide usage in the 1980s.

Its master patent was issued in December 1880, many decades before the photophone’s principles came into popular use.

Bell is also credited with developing one of the early versions of a metal detector through the use of an induction balance, after the shooting of US President James A. Garfield in 1881.

Garfield wears a double breasted suit and has a full beard and receding hairline

Above: James Abram Garfield (1931 – 1981)

Above: Garfield, shot by Charles J. Guiteau, collapses as Secretary of State Blaine gestures for help

An ornate Victorian Gothic style building with a square tower

Above: Baltimore & Potomac Railroad Passenger Terminal,Washington, where Garfield was shot 2 July 1881

According to some accounts, the metal detector worked flawlessly in tests but did not find Guiteau’s bullet, partly because the metal bed frame on which the President was lying disturbed the instrument, resulting in static.

Garfield’s surgeons, led by self-appointed chief physician Doctor Willard Bliss, were skeptical of the device, and ignored Bell’s requests to move the President to a bed not fitted with metal springs.

Alternatively, although Bell had detected a slight sound on his first test, the bullet may have been lodged too deeply to be detected by the crude apparatus.

Bell’s own detailed account, presented to the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 1882, differs in several particulars from most of the many and varied versions now in circulation, by concluding that extraneous metal was not to blame for failure to locate the bullet.

Who Invented Metal Detector ?

Perplexed by the peculiar results he had obtained during an examination of Garfield, Bell “proceeded to the Executive Mansion the next morning to ascertain from the surgeons whether they were perfectly sure that all metal had been removed from the neighborhood of the bed.

It was then recollected that underneath the horse-hair mattress on which the President lay was another mattress composed of steel wires.

Upon obtaining a duplicate, the mattress was found to consist of a sort of net of woven steel wires, with large meshes.

The extent of the area that produced a response from the detector having been so small, as compared with the area of the bed, it seemed reasonable to conclude that the steel mattress had produced no detrimental effect.

In a footnote, Bell adds:

The death of President Garfield and the subsequent post-mortem examination, however, proved that the bullet was at too great a distance from the surface to have affected our apparatus.

Presidential Trivia on Twitter: "In 1881, Dr. Alexander Graham Bell used  the metal detector he invented to search for the bullet in President  Garfield. The device is now part of the Smithsonian's

The March 1906 Scientific American article by American pioneer William E. Meacham explained the basic principle of hydrofoils and hydroplanes.

Scientific American, the oldest U.S. magazine, hits another milestone as  the appetite for science news heats up - Poynter

Bell considered the invention of the hydroplane as a very significant achievement.

Based on information gained from that article, he began to sketch concepts of what is now called a hydrofoil boat.

Bell and assistant Frederick W. “Casey” Baldwin began hydrofoil experimentation in the summer of 1908 as a possible aid to airplane takeoff from water.

Above: Casey Baldwin (1882 – 1948)

Baldwin studied the work of the Italian inventor Enrico Forlanini and began testing models.

Above: Enrico Forlanini (1848 – 1930)

This led him and Bell to the development of practical hydrofoil watercraft.

During his world tour of 1910 – 1911, Bell and Baldwin met with Forlanini in France.

They had rides in the Forlanini hydrofoil boat over Lake Maggiore.

Baldwin described it as being as smooth as flying.

On returning to Baddeck, a number of initial concepts were built as experimental models, including the Dhonnas Beag (Scottish Gaelic for little devil), the first self-propelled Bell-Baldwin hydrofoil.

The experimental boats were essentially proof-of-concept prototypes that culminated in the more substantial HD-4, powered by Renault engines.

A top speed of 54 miles per hour (87 km/h) was achieved, with the hydrofoil exhibiting rapid acceleration, good stability, and steering, along with the ability to take waves without difficulty.

In 1913, Dr. Bell hired Walter Pinaud, a Sydney yacht designer and builder as well as the proprietor of Pinaud’s Yacht Yard in Westmount, Nova Scotia, to work on the pontoons of the HD-4.

Pinaud soon took over the boatyard at Bell Laboratories on Beinn Bhreagh, Bell’s estate near Baddeck, Nova Scotia.

Pinaud’s experience in boat-building enabled him to make useful design changes to the HD-4.

After the First World War, work began again on the HD-4.

Bell’s report to the US Navy permitted him to obtain two 350 horsepower (260 kilowatts) engines in July 1919.

On 9 September 1919, the HD-4 set a world marine speed record of 70.86 miles per hour (114.04 kilometres per hour), a record which stood for ten years.

In 1891, Bell had begun experiments to develop motor-powered heavier-than-air aircraft.

The AEA was first formed as Bell shared the vision to fly with his wife, who advised him to seek “young” help as Bell was at the age of 60.

In 1898, Bell experimented with tetrahedral box kites and wings constructed of multiple compound tetrahedral kites covered in maroon silk.

The tetrahedral wings were named Cygnet I, II, and III, and were flown both unmanned and manned (Cygnet I crashed during a flight carrying Selfridge) in the period from 1907 to 1912.

BELL: CYGNET I, 1907. Alexander Graham Bell with his #13638358

Some of Bell’s kites are on display at the Alexander Graham Bell National Historic Site.

Bell was a supporter of aerospace engineering research through the Aerial Experiment Association (AEA), officially formed at Baddeck, Nova Scotia, in October 1907 at the suggestion of his wife Mabel and with her financial support after the sale of some of her real estate.

The AEA was headed by Bell and the founding members were four young men:

  • American Glenn H. Curtiss, a motorcycle manufacturer at the time and who held the title “world’s fastest man“, having ridden his self-constructed motor bicycle around in the shortest time, and who was later awarded the Scientific American Trophy for the first official one-kilometre flight in the Western hemisphere, and who later became a world-renowned airplane manufacturer

Glenn Curtiss - 1909 (cropped).jpg

Above: Glenn Curtiss (1878 – 1930)

  • Lieutenant Thomas Selfridge, an official observer from the US Federal government and one of the few people in the army who believed that aviation was the future
Thomas selfridge smoking pipe.jpg

Above: Thomas Selfridge (1882 – 1908)

  • Frederick W. Baldwin, the first Canadian and first British subject to pilot a public flight in Hammondsport, New York 
  • J.A.D. McCurdy–Baldwin and McCurdy being new engineering graduates from the University of Toronto.

John A.D. McCurdy.jpg

Above: John A.D. McCurdy (1886 – 1961)

The AEA’s work progressed to heavier-than-air machines, applying their knowledge of kites to gliders.

Moving to Hammondsport, the group then designed and built the Red Wing, framed in bamboo and covered in red silk and powered by a small air-cooled engine.

On 12 March 1908, over Keuka Lake, the biplane lifted off on the first public flight in North America.

The innovations that were incorporated into this design included a cockpit enclosure and tail rudder (later variations on the original design would add ailerons as a means of control).

One of the AEA’s inventions, a practical wingtip form of the aileron, was to become a standard component on all aircraft.

AEA Red Wing (Aerodrome 1).jpg

The White Wing and June Bug were to follow and by the end of 1908, over 150 flights without mishap had been accomplished.

Bell's Boys

However, the AEA had depleted its initial reserves and only a $15,000 grant from Mrs. Bell allowed it to continue with experiments.

Lt. Selfridge had also become the first person killed in a powered heavier-than-air flight in a crash of the Wright Flyer at Fort Myer, Virginia, on 17 September 1908.

1909-Wright-Military-flyer.jpg

Their final aircraft design, the Silver Dart, embodied all of the advancements found in the earlier machines.

On 23 February 1909, Bell was present as the Silver Dart flown by J. A. D. McCurdy from the frozen ice of Bras d’Or made the first aircraft flight in Canada.

Bell had worried that the flight was too dangerous and had arranged for a doctor to be on hand.

With the successful flight, the AEA disbanded and the Silver Dart would revert to Baldwin and McCurdy, who began the Canadian Aerodrome Company and would later demonstrate the aircraft to the Canadian Army.

Several movies have had scenes shot at the Brantford Airport, including Welcome to Mooseport and Where the Truth Lies.

RCAF Brantford Airfield.jpg

Above: Brantford Airport

Welcome To Mooseport.jpg

Where the truth lies.jpg

Thomas Bertram Costain (1885 – 1965) was a Canadian-American journalist who became a best-selling author of historical novels at the age of 57.

Thomas B. Costain.jpg

Costain was born and educated in Brantford.

His first job was on the Brantford Expositor.

He went on to work in Guelph (Daily Mercury) and in Toronto, where he was editor of Maclean’s from 1914 until 1920, when he moved to the United States.

His success there brought him to the attention of The Saturday Evening Post in New York City where he was fiction editor for fourteen years.

After the success of his first novel, For My Great Folly (1942), he wrote several bestselling historical romances, including The Black Rose (1945).

For My Great Folly: Thomas B. Costain: Amazon.com: Books

His most popular novel was The Black Rose (1945), centred in the time and actions of Bayan of the Baarin (also known as Bayan of the Hundred Eyes).

TheBlackRoseNovel.jpg

Costain noted in his foreword that he initially intended the book to be about Bayan and Edward I, but became caught up in the legend of Thomas Becket’s parents: an English knight married to an Eastern girl.

The book was a selection of the Literary Guild with a first printing of 650,000 copies and sold over two million copies in its first year.

His research led him to believe that Richard III was a great monarch tarred by conspiracies, after his death, with the murder of the princes in the tower.

Richard III earliest surviving portrait

Above: Richard III (1452 – 1485)

Above: Princes Edward and Richard

Costain supported his theories with documentation, suggesting that the real murderer was Henry VII.

Enrique VII de Inglaterra, por un artista anónimo.jpg

Above: Henry VII (1457 – 1509)

Among his books about Canada are:

  • The White and the Gold: The French Reign in Canada (1954), a work of popular history, fiction that relies heavily on historic events (one review stated it was hard to tell where history leaves off and apocrypha begins)

The White and The Gold: Costain, Thomas B.: Amazon.com: Books

  • High Towers (1954), the 17th century adventures of the LeMoyne family

Amazon.com: High Towers: Thomas b. Costain: Books

  • Son of a Hundred Kings (1950), a story set in the Brantford area that follows the life of an orphaned boy during the 1890s

Son of a Hundred Kings: Thomas B. Costain: 9780380000029: Amazon.com: Books

Costain died in 1965 at his New York City home of a heart attack at the age of 80.

He is buried in the Farringdon Independent Church Cemetery in Brantford.

Thomas Costain (1841-1921) - Find A Grave Memorial

Sara Jeannette Duncan (1861 – 1922) was a Canadian author and journalist, who also published as Mrs. Everard Cotes among other names.

Duncan was born in Brantford at 96 West Street.

The First Baptist Church next door, at 70 West Street, bears a provincial plaque to her.

The Trials of Sara Jeannette Duncan | The Grand River Saga | Susan Minsos

Educated at Brantford Collegiate, Duncan briefly attended the Toronto Normal School.

She had poetry printed as early as 1880, two years before she fully qualified as a teacher.

Toronto Normal School 1890s.jpg

Above: Toronto Normal School

A period of supply teaching in the Brantford area ended in December 1884, when she travelled to New Orleans after persuading The Globe newspaper in Toronto and the Advertiser in London, Ontario to pay her for articles about the World Cotton Centennial.

1884 Fair Octaganal.jpg

Above: Engraving of the Octagonal Building, part of Mexico exhibit, World Cotton Centennial

Her articles were published under the pseudonym “Garth” and reprinted in other newspapers.

They led The Globe to offer her a regular weekly column when she returned to Canada some months later.

Duncan wrote her “Other People and I” column for The Globe (1844 – 1936) during the summer of 1885 using the name “Garth Grafton“.

She then moved to the Washington Post, where she was soon put in charge of the current literature department.

The Logo of The Washington Post Newspaper.svg

She was back as “Garth Grafton” at The Globe in summer 1886, taking over the “Woman’s World” section that had emerged.

As in Washington, she contributed more generally as a member of the editorial staff.

While the “Woman’s World” column was fairly light in tone, she also wrote a more serious column for Week, a Toronto-based literary periodical, using the names “Jeannette Duncan” and “Sara Jeannette Duncan“.

Her biographer, Misao Dean, says that “well-suited to the Week, her strongly defined progressive views on international copyright, women’s suffrage, and realist fiction made her work remarkable in such conservative journals as the Globe and the Post.

In early 1887, Duncan became parliamentary correspondent for the Montréal Star (1869 – 1979), basing herself in Ottawa.

Montrealstar.png

In 1888, she embarked on a world tour with a friend, Montréal journalist Lily Lewis.

The idea of a woman travelling alone at that time was unconventional.

Her intention was to gather material for a book, although both also filed stories to the Star as they travelled.

Sara Jeannette Duncan

In 1889, during this tour, she attended a function in Calcutta organised by Lord Lansdowne, then Viceroy of India, whom she had previously known in Canada.

Marquess of Lansdowne.jpg

Above: Lord Lansdowne (1845 – 1927)

There she met the Anglo-Indian civil servant Everard Charles Cotes, who was working as an entomologist in the Indian Museum.

Indian Museum Kolkata.jpg

Above: Indian Museum, Kolkota

The couple married a year later on 6 December 1890, after a proposal at the Taj Mahal.

Taj-Mahal.jpg

Above: Taj Mahal, Agra

After her marriage, Duncan split her time mostly between England and India, often spending much of it alone in rented flats in Kensington, London.

The travelling was necessitated by her continued writing commitments in several countries.

There had been plans for her and Everard to return permanently to England in 1894, but these came to nothing:

Her husband reinvented himself as a journalist and edited the Calcutta-based Indian Daily News (1894 – 1897), later becoming managing director of the Eastern News Agency.

Although Marian Fowler, a biographer, argued that the couple’s marriage was unhappy (based on E.M. Forster’s off-hand and misinterpreted observation that “Mrs. Cotes is difficult and I fancy unhappy“), hers is not the accepted view.

Duncan certainly supported her husband in various work-related endeavours.

Clockwise from top: Victoria Memorial, St. Paul's Cathedral, Central Business District, Rabindra Setu, City Tram Line, Vidyasagar Setu

Above: Images of Kolkota

She also cultivated a friendship with James Louis Garvin while he was editor of The Outlook and The Observer, at least in part hoping he might find a position for Everard in Britain.

Warkentin suggests that theirs may have been “one of those marriages in which a difficult woman and a gentle, agreeable man made common cause.”

James Louis Garvin.jpg

Above: James Louis Garvin (1868 – 1947)

Sometimes she lived at Simla, the summer capital of the British Raj.

Shimla Montage

Above: Images of Simla

There she entertained E.M. Forster in November 1912.

He noted a characteristic ambivalence in her manner, saying that she was “clever and odd – at times very nice to talk to alone, but at times the Social Manner descended like a pall.”

His letters also speak to Duncan’s continued involvement with political ideas:

I don’t talk about politics although at the Cotes, I have been living in them.”

E. M. Forster, by Dora Carrington c. 1924–1925

Above: E.M. Forster (1879 – 1970)

Around the time of World War I, during which Duncan and her husband were unable to be together, she began to take an interest in writing plays, but had little success.

She maintained her interest until 1921, two years after her husband had finally left India and the couple had taken residence in Chelsea.

Duncan had been treated for tuberculosis in 1900, spending the summer out of doors in the fresh air of Simla, as chronicled in On the Other Side of the Latch (1901), published in the US and Canada as The Crow’s Nest.

Buy On the Other Side of the Latch Book Online at Low Prices in India | On  the Other Side of the Latch Reviews & Ratings - Amazon.in

Childless, she died of chronic lung disease on 22 July 1922 at Ashtead, Surrey, whence she and her husband had moved in 1921.

She had been a smoker and it is possible that the cause of death was emphysema, although her lung problems generally may have been exacerbated by the climate and sanitation in Calcutta.

She was buried at St Giles’s Church, Ashtead, and left a CAD$13,000 estate.

Pages 33-41

Though she rarely returned to Canada after marrying Cotes, and last visited in 1919, she had always insisted that the royalties from her books were paid into her bank account in Brantford.

Everard Cotes, who was her beneficiary and worked as parliamentary correspondent for the Christian Science Monitor, outlived her and remarried in 1923, fathering two children before his death in 1944.

The Christian Science Monitor masthead.png

Among Duncan’s contacts in the literary world were the journalists Goldwin Smith (of the Week) and John Stephen Willison, the novelist and editor Jean McIlwraith (1858 – 1938), and George William Ross.

Goldwin Smith.jpg

Above: Goldwin Smith (1823 – 1910)

John Stephen Willison.png

Above: John Stephen Willison (1856 – 1927)

Jean N. McIlwraith, from a 1901 publication.

Honourable GW Ross, Prime Minister for Ontario (HS85-10-12129).jpg

Above: George William Ross (1841 – 1914)

She also had some contact with William Dean Howells and Henry James, whose writings she admired.

W. D. Howells.jpg

Above: William Dean Howells (1837 – 1920)

She wrote 22 works of fiction, many with international themes and settings.

Her novels met with mixed acclaim and are rarely read today.

Duncan’s first book was her most successful.

Cheerfully anecdotal“, says Warkentin, and “written with flair and self-conscious charm.

It was written to sell, and sell it did.”

Titled A Social Departure: How Orthodocia and I Went Around The World by Ourselves, it was published in 1890 and fictionalized her around-the-world trip with Lewis.

Social Departures: Sara Jeannette Duncan (1861-1922) « Women Suffrage and  Beyond

It contains the first description of the city of Vancouver in fiction.

According to Dean, the book “relies on the strengths of Duncan’s journalism – close observation, description of manners, and wry humour – while transforming the narrator’s travelling companion from the sophisticated Lewis into a naive and romantic English girl.”

Views from Vancouver, Looking North 1890-1970

Above: Vancouver, 1890

Her next two novels, An American Girl in London (1891) and The Simple Adventures of a Memsahib (1893) followed a similar pattern, but then came A Daughter of To-day (1894), described by Dean as her first “serious novel” and by Warkentin as a “new woman” work that is “flawed but fascinating“.

It was with this 4th book that she took to using both her married and maiden name.

An American Girl in London by Sara Jeannette Duncan : (full image  Illustrated) - Kindle edition by Sara Jeannette Duncan, F. H. Townsend.  Literature & Fiction Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

The Simple Adventures of a Memsahib: Duncan, Sara Jeannette: 9781987428971:  Amazon.com: Books

A Daughter of Today by Sara Jeanette Duncan, Fiction, Classics, Literary:  Amazon.co.uk: Duncan, Sara Jeannette, Cotes, Mrs. Everard: 9781603121170:  Books

A Voyage of Consolation (1897) was a sequel to internationally themed An American Girl in London.

A Voyage of Consolation by Sara Jeanette Duncan, Fiction, Classics,  Literary, Romance: Amazon.co.uk: Duncan, Sara Jeannette, Cotes, Mrs.  Everard: 9781603125994: Books

The autobiographical On the Other Side of the Latch (1901) was set in Duncan’s garden in Simla, where she had been forced to spend seven months while recovering from her tuberculosis infection.

Warkentin sees this work as an example of her eye for a commercial opportunity.

Duncan occasionally strayed from the subject of Anglo-Indian society and is best-known and most studied today for The Imperialist, a 1904 work which was her only novel set in Canada and centers on a fictional town modeled on Brantford.

It had, at best, a mixed reception:

Germaine Warkentin says that despite being “the first truly modern Canadian novel“, it was too progressive for its audience, poorly received and remained largely unread until the 1960s.

Nowadays, it is the most popular of her works and the remainder, once generally much more popular, are read mainly as a means of contextualizing it.

Dean says that at the time of publication:

The London Spectator complained that it hid a medicinal message in a spoonful of jam while the Globe asserted that Duncan was disqualified by her gender from writing on political subjects.

The New York Times praised the work, however, as did Toronto Saturday Night:

To the Canadian, to the Ontarian especially, it means more than any other Canadian story, for it gives with truth and with art a depiction of our own community.

The Imperialist (1904). By: Sara Jeanette Duncan: Novel By:Sara Jeannette  Duncan (22 December 1861 – 22 July 1922) was a Canadian author and ... as  Mrs. Everard Cotes among other names.: Duncan, Sara Jeanette:  9781719360494: Amazon.com: Books

Cousin Cinderella (1908) is set in London, and with His Royal Happiness (1914) constitutes the other work by Duncan that has significant Canadian themes, although neither is set in Canada.

His Royal Happiness eBook: Duncan Sara Jeannette: Amazon.in: Kindle Store

While not studied to the extent of The ImperialistCousin Cinderella is considered by Anna Snaith to be an important work:

While Duncan was no radical, Cousin Cinderella‘s feminism, its Canadian nationalism and its critique of Canada’s place within the empire make it an important text of colonial modernity, particularly in relation to gender and urban space.

Duncan’s is a rare and subtle look, for the period, at how the economic and political workings of imperialism affect women and the private sphere of personal relations.

Cousin Cinderella: Duncan Sara Jeannette: 9780919662452: Books - Amazon.ca

Some later books – notably Set in Authority (1906), written in particularly ironic style, and The Burnt Offering (1909) – took as their theme the subject of Indian nationalism.

The Burnt Offering: Amazon.co.uk: Duncan, Sara Jeannette: 9781115432481:  Books

In these she was able to draw on the similarities of experience between her colonised homeland and her colonised adopted land. 

Set in Authority, which was titled The Viceroy until very near to publication, stands out as a notable failure in her commercial sense and an act perhaps of stubbornness, being an overtly political novel published immediately after the poor reception of The Imperialist, which itself had been a novel about politics.

Amazon.com: Set in Authority (9781551110806): Duncan, Sara Jeannette,  Warkentin, Germaine: Books

Its central character, Anthony Andover, is now known to have been based on Lord Curzon, who was unpopular with Anglo-Indians.

His Royal Happiness was adapted for the stage in 1915.

Today, says Warkentin, with the exception of The Imperialist, Duncan’s œuvre “appears only occasionally in the writings of students of feminism and post-colonialism trawling the backwaters of the Edwardian novel, and almost never in accounts of Anglo-Indian literature“.

In 2016, she was named a National Historic Person on the advice of the Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada.

Amazon.com: Sara Jeannette Duncan, Collection novels (9781500642938): Duncan,  Sara Jeannette: Books

Deborah Ellis is a Canadian fiction-writer and activist, based in Brantford.

Her themes are often concerned with the sufferings of persecuted children in the Third World.

Much of her work as a writer has been inspired by her travels and conversations with people from around the world and their stories.

She has held many jobs advocating for the peace movement and the anti-war movement.

Deborah Ellis in Renaissance, Florida, 2011.

She travelled to Pakistan in 1997 to interview refugees at an Afghan refugee camp.

From these interviews, she wrote The Breadwinner series, which includes The Breadwinner (2001), a book about a girl named Parvana, Parvana’s Journey (2002), its sequel, Mud City (2003), about Shauzia, Parvana’s best friend, and My Name is Parvana (2011), the final book in the series.

The Breadwinner Trilogy - MS - ZIS Middle School Library - LibGuides at  Zurich International School

While The Breadwinner was inspired by an interview with a mother and a girl who disguised herself as a boy in a refugee camp, the subsequent books in the series were more imaginative explorations of how children would survive.

The Breadwinner: Ellis, Deborah: 9781554987658: Amazon.com: Books

In 1999, her novel Looking for X was published.

It follows a young girl in her day-to-day life in a poor area of Toronto.

It received the Governor General’s Award for English language children’s literature in 2000.

Looking for X by Deborah Ellis

One of her best known works is the 2004 book The Heaven Shop, which tells of a family of orphans in Malawi who are struggling with sudden displacement as a result of the HIV/AIDS impact.

The novel was written to dispel myths about HIV/AIDS and celebrate the courage of child sufferers.

The Heaven Shop by Deborah Ellis

In 2006, she wrote the best-seller, I Am a Taxi, which tells the story of a Bolivian boy named Diego whose family was accused of smuggling coca paste, which is used to produce cocaine.

After an accident causes Diego’s family to owe money to the prison in which they are incarcerated in, the boy must earn them money.

He ends up in the coca “pits” where the coca leaves are made into coca paste, and the story follows his adventures from there.

I Am a Taxi by Deborah Ellis

The sequel, Sacred Leaf, is about Diego’s time with the Ricardos (a family who helped Diego) and a giant coca leaf protest.

Sacred Leaf by Deborah Ellis

In 2007, with Eric Walters, Ellis wrote Bifocal, a novel about racism and terrorists in Canada.

Bifocal by Deborah Ellis

In 2008, Ellis published Lunch with Lenin and Other Stories, a collection of short stories that explores the lives of children who have been affected directly, or indirectly, by drugs.

The stories are set against backdrops as diverse as the remote north of Canada to Moscow’s Red Square to an opium farm in Afghanistan.

Lunch with Lenin and Other Stories: Amazon.de: Ellis, Deborah:  Fremdsprachige Bücher

In 2014, she published Moon at Nine, a YA novel based on the true story of two teenage girls who are arrested and thrown in prison in Iran, a country where homosexuality is punishable by death.

Ellis is a philanthropist, donating almost all of her royalties on her books to such organizations as “Canadian Women for Women in Afghanistan” and UNICEF.

Due to this work, she has been threatened by the Taliban.

Moon at Nine - Deborah Ellis - Englische Bücher kaufen | Ex Libris

Philip Edward Hartman (né Hartmann; 1948 – 1998) was a Canadian-American actor, comedian, voice actor, screenwriter, and graphic designer who gained fame in the late 1980s as a long-time performer of the NBC sketch comedy show Saturday Night Live (SNL).

Phil Hartman - IMDb

Hartman was born in Brantford.

His family moved to the United States when he was ten years old.

After graduating from California State University, Northridge, with a degree in graphic arts, Hartman designed album covers for bands including Poco and America.

Album Covers Designed By Phil Hartman | R. ONE Creative

Album Covers Designed By Phil Hartman | R. ONE Creative

In 1975, Hartman joined the comedy group The Groundlings, where he helped Paul Reubens develop his character, Pee-wee Herman.

Phil Hartman - Notable alumni of the Groundlings improv troupe - CBS News

Above: The Groundlings

Hartman co-wrote the film Pee-wee’s Big Adventure and made recurring appearances as Captain Carl on Reubens’s show Pee-wee’s Playhouse.

Peeweebigadventure.jpg

Peeweesplayhouse.jpg

In 1986, Hartman joined SNL, where he won fame for his impressions and stayed for eight seasons until 1994.

Nicknamed “Glue” for his ability to hold the show together and help other cast members, Hartman won a Primetime Emmy Award for his SNL work in 1989.

SNL logo 2015.svg

In 1995, he later starred as Bill McNeal in the sitcom NewsRadio after declining his return to SNL.

The Real Deal: The No-Rules Comedy Genius of NewsRadio | 25YL

He also voiced various characters on The Simpsons, and had minor roles in the films Houseguest, Sgt. Bilko, Jingle All the Way, and Small Soldiers.

Hartman was divorced twice before he married Brynn Omdahl in 1987, with whom he had two children.

Their marriage was troubled by Brynn’s drug use, domestic violence, and Phil’s frequent absence from home.

In 1998, while Hartman was sleeping, his wife shot and killed him, and later committed suicide.

Phil Hartman's brother-in-law breaks his silence 20 years after the star's  murder | Daily Mail Online

In the weeks following his murder, Hartman was celebrated in a wave of tributes.

Dan Snierson of Entertainment Weekly opined that Hartman was “the last person you’d expect to read about in lurid headlines in your morning paper … a decidedly regular guy, beloved by everyone he worked with“.

He was posthumously inducted into the Canada and Hollywood Walks of Fame in 2012 and 2014, respectively.

Phil Hartman - Hollywood Star Walk - Los Angeles Times

Emily Pauline Johnson (1861 – 1913), also known by her Mohawk stage name Tekahionwake (pronounced dageh-eeon-wageh, literally ‘double-life’), was a Canadian poet, author, and performer who was popular in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

E. Pauline Johnson, c. 1885–1895

Her father, George Johnson, as a hereditary Mohawk chief of mixed ancestry and her mother, Emily Howells, was an English immigrant.

Chief George Henry Martin “Onwanonsyshon” Johnson (1815-1884) - Find A  Grave Memorial

Pauline was born at Chiefswood, 10 miles east of Brantford in Middleport.

Above: Chiefswood

Because George Johnson worked as an interpreter and cultural negotiator between the Mohawk, the British, and the government of Canada, the Johnsons were seen as affluent and part of Canadian high society, and were visited by distinguished intellectual and political guests of the time, including the Marquess of Lorne, Princess Louise, Prince Arthur, inventor Alexander Graham Bell, painter Homer Watson, anthropologist Horatio Hale, and the Governor General Lord Dufferin.

John Campbell, 9th Duke of Argyll.jpg

Above: Governor General John Campbell, the Marquess of Lorne (1845 – 1914)

Louise Marguerite Prussia.png

Above: Princess Louise (1860 – 1917)

Homer Watson.jpg

Above: Homer Watson (1855 – 1936)

Above: Figure on the road, Homer Watson

Horatio Hale.jpg

Above: Horatio Hale (1817 – 1896)

Lord Dufferin.jpg

Above: Lord Dufferin (1826 – 1902)

Johnson’s mother emphasized refinement and decorum in raising her children, cultivating within them an “aloof dignity” that she felt would earn them respect in their adulthood.

Pauline Johnson’s elegant manners and aristocratic air owed much to this background and training.

George Johnson encouraged their four children to respect and learn about their Mohawk and English heritage.

Because George Johnson had partial Mohawk ancestry his children were, by British law, legally considered Mohawk and wards of the British Crown.

However, because Emily Johnson was English and according to the Mohawk kinship system, the children were not officially born into a tribal clan and excluded from important aspects of the tribe’s matrilineal culture.

A sickly child, Johnson did not attend one of Canada’s first residential schools, Brantford’s Mohawk Institute, which was established in 1834.

Her education was mostly at home and informal, derived from her mother, a series of non-Native governesses, a few years at the small school on the reserve, and self-guided reading in her family’s expansive library.

She familiarized herself with the works of Byron, Tennyson, Keats, Browning and Milton and enjoyed reading tales about Indigenous people such as Longfellow’s epic poem The Song of Hiawatha and John Richardson’s Wacousta, all of which would later inform her literary and theatrical work.

Portrait of Byron

Above: Lord Byron (1788 – 1824)

Alfred Tennyson, 1st Baron Tennyson by George Frederic Watts.jpg

Above: Alfred Tennyson (1809 – 1892)

Posthumous portrait of John Keats by William Hilton. National Portrait Gallery, London

Above: John Keats (1795 – 1821)

Browning, c. 1888

Above: Robert Browning (1812 – 1889)

Portrait of Milton, circa 1629

Above: John Milton (1608 – 1674)

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow photographed by Julia Margaret Cameron in 1868

Above: Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (1807 – 1882)

Major John Richardson by Frederick William Lock

Above: John Richardson (1796 – 1852)

Despite growing up in a time when racism against Indigenous people was normalized and common, Johnson and her siblings were made to appreciate their Mohawk ancestry and culture.

Her paternal grandfather John Smoke Johnson was a respected authority figure for her and her siblings and educated them through traditional Indigenous oral storytelling before his death in 1886.

The children were taught various life lessons and stories from Johnson in the Mohawk language which resulted in their comprehension of the language but inability to speak it fluently.

Smoke Johnson’s dramatic talents as a storyteller rubbed off on his granddaughter evident by her talent for elocution and her stage performances where she wore artifacts passed onto her by her grandparents such as a bear claw necklace, wampum belts and various masks.

Six Nations survivors of War of 1812 - John Smoke Johnson.jpg

Above: John Smoke Johnson (1792 – 1886)

Later in her life, Pauline Johnson expressed regret for not learning more of his Mohawk heritage and language.

She attended Brantford Collegiate (1875 – 1877), when she left the school and lived in a boarding house nearby.

This was the end of her formal education.

Brantford Collegiate Institute Threat Investigation – 4BRANT.com

Above: Brantford Collegiate

In his roles as government interpreter and hereditary chief, George Johnson developed a reputation as a talented mediator between Native and European interests.

He was well respected in Ontario.

He also made enemies because of his efforts to stop illegal trading of reserve timber.

Physically attacked by Native and non-Native men involved in this and liquor traffic, Johnson suffered from severe health problems contributing to his death of a fever in 1884.

Chief George Henry Martin Johnson (1816–1884) • FamilySearch

Following the death of her father in 1885, Johnson, with her mother and sister, lived first at Chatham and West Streets, then moved to 7 Napoleon Street (now Dufferin Avenue) in Brantford.

Her poems first appeared in print in October 1886 after she delivered a poem at the unveiling of the Joseph Brant statue in Victoria Park, a performance that was widely praised in the local newspapers.

A successful career of public readings – in which she wore Indigenous dress when reading Indigenous poems – began in 1892 after a very effective stage appearance in Toronto.

She visited her family in Brantford regularly, but in 1909 she retired to Vancouver.

E. Pauline Johnson, 1861 - Canada Postage Stamp

Pauline Johnson attracted many potential suitors and her sister recalled more than half a dozen marriage proposals from Euro-Canadians in her lifetime.

Though the amount of official romantic interests remains unknown there have been two later romances identified with Charles R. L. Drayton in 1890 and Charles Wuerz in 1900.

However, Johnson never married nor remained in relationships for very long despite her reputation of teasing boys in her time in Grand River and her composition of “intensely erotic poetry.”

Due to her fame, she, unlike many other women of multi-ethnic backgrounds, was unwilling to set aside her racial heritage to placate partners and in-laws and transform into a respectable settler matron.

Despite everything, Johnson consistently had a strong network of supportive female friends and attested to the importance they had in her life.

In her own words, Johnson stated:

Women are fonder of me than men are.

I have had none fail me, and I hope I have failed none.

It is a keen pleasure for me to meet a congenial woman, one that I feel will understand me, and will in turn let me peep into her own life – having confidence in me, that is one of the dearest things between friends, strangers, acquaintances, or kindred.

Johnson — whose poetry was published in Canada, the United States, and Great Britain — was among a generation of widely-read writers who began to define Canadian literature.

Ethel Reed | The White Wampum by E. Pauline Johnson | The Metropolitan  Museum of Art

She was a key figure in the construction of the field as an institution and has made an indelible mark on Indigenous women’s writing and performance as a whole.

Canadian Born (Classic Reprint): Johnson, E Pauline: 9780266709312:  Amazon.com: Books

Johnson was notable for her poems, short stories, and performances that celebrated her mixed race heritage, drawing from both Indigenous and English influences.

Pauline Johnson's “Flint & Feather” | Zócalo Poets

She is most known for her books of poetry The White Wampum (1895), Canadian Born (1903), and Flint and Feather (1912); and her collections of stories Legends of Vancouver (1911), The Shagganappi (1913), and The Moccasin Maker (1913).

Legends of Vancouver by JOHNSON, E. Pauline (Tekahionwake) - 1928

While her literary reputation declined after her death, from the late 20th century there has been a renewed interest in her life and works.

The Shagganappi by E. Pauline Johnson - Tekahionwake 1913 HC/DJ | eBay

In 2002, a complete collection of her known poetry was published, entitled E. Pauline Johnson, Tekahionwake: Collected Poems and Selected Prose.

The Moccasin Maker (Illustrated) - Kindle edition by Johnson, E. Pauline.  Literature & Fiction Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

Due to the blending of her two cultures in her works, and her criticisms of the Canadian government, she was also a part of the New Woman feminist movement.

E. Pauline Johnson by E. Pauline Johnson

The Brant County Museum, 57 Charlotte Street, displays Johnson memorabilia (along with other local authors).

Brant Museum & Archives | | Brant Historical Society

There is also a granite memorial to Johnson at St. Paul’s, her Majesty’s Chapel of the Mohawks on Mohawk Street.

Tablet for E. Pauline Johnson in Memorial Tablets Ad.: Six Nations Public  Library-Digital Archive

Chiefswood is now a provincial museum.

Ohsweken: A Day of Rest | Muscle and Bone

Jay Silverheels (born Harold Jay Smith) (1912 – 1980) was an Indigenous Canadian actor and athlete.

He was well known for his role as Tonto, the Native American companion of the Lone Ranger in the American western television series The Lone Ranger.

Clayton Moore as the Lone Ranger and Jay Silverheels as Tonto.

Above: Clayton Moore (1914 – 1999) as the Lone Ranger and Jay Silverheels as Tonto. Moore is riding Silver, while Silverheels is riding Scout.

Silverheels was born Harold Jay Smith, on the Six Nations of the Grand River Reserve, near Hagersville, Ontario.

Silverheels excelled in athletics, most notably in lacrosse, before leaving home to travel around North America.

In 1931, owners of NHL’s franchises in Toronto and Montreal created indoor lacrosse (also known as “box lacrosse“) as a means to fill empty arenas during the summer months, and, playing as Harry Smith, Silverheels was among the first players chosen to play for the Toronto Tecumsehs. 

Toronto Tecumsehs - Wikipedia

Tecumsehs de Toronto — Wikipédia

Along with his brothers and cousins Russell (Beef), Sid (Porky) and George (Chubby), he also played on teams in Buffalo, Rochester, Atlantic City, and Akron throughout the 1930s on teams in the North American Amateur Lacrosse Association. 

First Nations Lacrosse Association - Home | Facebook

He lived for a time in Buffalo, New York, and in 1938 placed second in the Middleweight class of the Golden Gloves tournament.

Silverheels was inducted into the Canadian Lacrosse Hall of Fame (New Westminster, British Columbia) as a veteran player in 1997.

Jay Silverheels Was a Lacrosse Star Before he Was Tonto

Canadian Lacrosse Hall of Fame - Wikipedia

While playing in Los Angeles on a touring box lacrosse team in 1937, Silverheels impressed Joe E. Brown, with his athleticism.

Brown encouraged him to do a screen test, which led to his acting career.

Joe E. Brown 1945.JPG

Above: Joe E. Brown (1891 – 1973)

Silverheels began working in motion pictures as an extra and stunt man in 1937. 

He was billed variously as Harold Smith and Harry Smith, and appeared in low-budget features, westerns, and serials. 

He adopted his screen name from the nickname he had as a lacrosse player. 

Jay Silverheels was cast in a short feature film, I Am an American (1944).

I Am an American (1944) - IMDb

From the late 1940s, he played in major films, including:

  • Captain from Castile starring Tyrone Power (1947) 
Captain from Castile FilmPoster.jpeg

  • Key Largo with Humphrey Bogart (1948) 
Key largo432.jpg

  • Lust for Gold with Glenn Ford (1949) 
Lustforgoldposter.jpg

  • Broken Arrow with James Stewart (1950) 
Broken Arrow Film Poster.jpg

  • War Arrow with Maureen O’Hara, Jeff Chandler and Noah Berry Jr. (1953)
War Arrow.jpg

  • The Black Dakotas as Black Buffalo (1954)
Tbdpos.jpg

  • Drums Across the River (1954)
Drums Across the River FilmPoster.jpeg

 

  • Walk the Proud Land with Audie Murphy and Anne Bancroft (1956)

Walk the Proud Land.jpg

 

  • Alias Jesse James with Bob Hope (1959)

Alias Jesse James poster.jpeg

  • Indian Paint with Johnny Crawford (1964)

Indian Paint (film) - Wikipedia

He made a brief appearance in True Grit (1969) as a condemned criminal about to be executed.

Truegritposter.jpg

He played a substantial role as John Crow in Santee (1973), starring Glenn Ford.

Santee poster.jpg

One of his last roles was a wise white-haired chief in The Man Who Loved Cat Dancing (1973).

Tmwlcd.jpg

Jay Silverheels achieved his greatest fame as Tonto on The Lone Ranger (1949 – 1957).

Lone ranger silver 1965.JPG

The fictional story line maintains that a small group of Texas Rangers were massacred, with only a “lone” survivor.

The Lone Ranger and Tonto then ride throughout the West to assist those challenged by the lawless element.

Their expenses and bullets are provided through a silver mine owned by The Lone Ranger, who also names his horse “Silver“.

Being irreplaceable in his role, Silverheels appeared in the film sequels: 

  • The Lone Ranger (1956)
The Lone Ranger (1956 film) poster.jpg

  • The Lone Ranger and the Lost City of Gold (1958)
The Lone Ranger and the Lost City of Gold poster.jpg

When The Lone Ranger television series ended, Silverheels continued to be typecast as a Native American.

On 6 January 1960, he portrayed a Native American fireman trying to extinguish a forest fire in the episode “Leap of Life” in the syndicated series, Rescue 8, starring Jim Davis and Lang Jeffries.

Remembering The Cast From Rescue 8 1958 - YouTube

Silverheels appeared in an episode of the TV series, Love, American Style, in which two tribe members try to talk a young white man, who wishes to marry a girl from their tribe, into enduring the tribe’s “test of manhood” a barbaric ritual of surviving in the wilderness.

No matter how she pleads and begs, using all her womanly wiles, he refuses, thus passing the tribe’s true “test of manhood.” 

Love, American Style logo.jpg

Eventually, he went to work as a salesman to supplement his acting income. 

He also began to publish poetry inspired by his youth on the Six Nations Indian Reserve and recited his work on television.

In 1966, he guest-starred as John Tallgrass in the short-lived ABC comedy/western series The Rounders, with Ron Hayes, Patrick Wayne and Chill Wills. 

The Rounders (TV Series 1966–1967) - IMDb

Despite the typecasting, Silverheels in later years often poked fun at his character.

In 1969, he appeared as Tonto without The Lone Ranger in a comedy sketch on The Tonight Show starring Johnny Carson.

(“My name is Tonto. I hail from Toronto and I speak Esperanto.”)

Tonightshowtitlecard1980s.jpg

In 1970, he appeared in a commercial for Chevrolet as a Native American chief who rescues two lost hunters, who had ignored his advice, in that year’s Chevy Blazer.

1979 Chevrolet K5 Blazer Cheyenne.jpg

The William Tell Overture is heard in the background.

Above: The William Tell Overture composer Gioachino Rossini (1792 – 1868)

Silverheels spoofed his Tonto character in a Stan Freburg Jeno’s Pizza Rolls TV commercial opposite Clayton Moore, and in The Phynx, opposite John Hart, both having played The Lone Ranger in the original television series.

Jeno's Pizza Rolls Commercial from 1993 | Pizza rolls, Food, 80s food

Poster of The Phynx.jpg

He appeared in three 1964 – 1965 episodes of NBC’s Daniel Boone, starring Fess Parker in the title role.

Daniel boone-show.jpg

His later appearances included an episode of ABC’s The Brady Bunch, as a Native American who befriends the Bradys in the Grand Canyon, and in an episode of the short-lived Dusty’s Trail, starring Bob Denver (Gilligan’s Island). 

BradyBunchtitle.png

Dusty's Trail.jpg

In the early 1960s, Silverheels supported the Indian Actors Workshop, where Native American actors refined their skills in Echo Park, Los Angeles.

Today the workshop is firmly established.

Watch Indian Actors' Workshop | Prime Video

Silverheels raised, bred and raced Standardbred horses in his spare time.

Once, when asked about possibly running Tonto’s paint horse Scout in a race, Silverheels laughed off the idea:

Heck, I can outrun Scout!

Pin on la télé de mon enfance

Married in 1945, Silverheels was the father of first son, Steve, four daughters named Marilyn, Gail, Pamela, and Karen, and a second son, Jay Anthony Silverheels Junior, who also was briefly an actor.

Silverheels suffered a stroke in 1976, and the following year, Clayton Moore  – his co-star on The Lone Ranger  – rode a paint horse in Silverheels’ honor in the Pasadena Tournament of Roses Parade. 

Silverheels died on 5 March 1980, from complications of a stroke, at age 67, in Calabasas, Los Angeles County, California.

He was cremated at Chapel of the Pines Crematory.

His ashes were returned to the Six Nations Reserve.

Six Nations on The Grand River considers reserve brewery - Ontario Beverage  Network

In 1993, Silverheels was inducted into the Hall of Great Western Performers at the Natonal Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum in Oklahoma City.

National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum logo file.jpg

He was named to the Western New York Entertainment Hall of Fame.

His portrait hangs in Buffalo’s Shea’s Buffalo Theatre.

BAD SEATS! - Review of Shea's Performing Arts Center, Buffalo, NY -  Tripadvisor

He has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame at 6538 Hollywood Boulevard. 

Datei:Jay Silverheels star HWF.JPG – Wikipedia

James Hillier (1915 – 2007) was a Brantford-born scientist and inventor who designed and built, with Albert Prebus, the first successful high-resolution electron microscope in North America in 1938.

James Hillier.jpg

Above: James Hillier

Amazon.com: Photo: RCA electron microscope, inventors, scientists, Dr VK  Zworykin, James Hillier, 1930: Photographs

Above: the Hillier / Prebus electron microscope

Poet John B. Lee is the Poet Laureate of Brantford.

John B. Lee | Brick Books

Above: John B. Lee

I love the titles of some of his collections:

  • Poems Only a Dog Could Love
  • Love Among the Tombstones
  • Fossils of the 20th Century
  • Rediscovered Sheep
  • The Bad Philosophy of Good Cows
  • The Pig Dance Dreams
  • The Hockey Player Sonnets
  • When Shaving Seems Like Suicide
  • The Art of Walking Backwards
  • The Beatles Landed Laughing in New York
  • Don’t Be So Persnickety: The Runaway Sneezing Poems, Songs and Riddles
  • The Half-Way Tree
  • Totally Unused Heart
  • Poems for the Pornographer’s Daughter
  • But Where Were the Horses of Evening?
  • The Place that We Keep After Leaving
  • Island on the Wind-Breathed Edge of the Sea
  • Dressed in Dead Uncles
  • In the Muddy Shoes of Morning
  • You Can Always Eat the Dogs: The Hockeyness of Ordinary Men
  • The Day Jane Fonda Came to Guelph
  • In a Language with No Word for Horses
  • The Echo of Your Words Has Reached Me
  • An Almost Silent Drumming
  • Though Their Joined Hearts Drummed Like Larks
  • Thirty-Three Thousand Shades of Green
  • The Bright Red Apples of the Dead
  • One Leaf in the Breath of the World
  • Let Light Try All the Doors
  • Building Bicycles in the Dark: A Practical Guide to Writing
  • Left Hand Horses: a meditation on Influence and the imagination
  • That Sign of Perfection: From Bandy Legs to Beer Legs — Poems and Stories on the Game of Hockey
  • Losers First: Poems and Stories on Game and Sport
  • I Want to Be the Poet of Your Kneecaps: Poems of Quirky Romance
  • Following the Plough: Recovering the Rural — Poems and Stories on the Land
  • Under the Weight of Heaven: writing from Gethsemani
  • Tough Times: when the money doesn’t love us
  • Window Fishing: the Night We Caught Beatlemania

Poems only a dog could love: Lee, John B: 9780919910065: Amazon.com: Books

Lawren Harris, founder of the Group of Seven, was born in Brantford.

Lawren Harris.JPG

Above: Lawren Harris (1885 – 1970)

Above: The Group of Seven – From left to right: Frederick Varley, A. Y. Jackson, Lawren Harris, Barker Fairley, Frank Johnston, Arthur Lismer, and J. E. H. MacDonald.

The Idea of North: The Paintings of Lawren Harris | Hammer Museum

Above: The Idea of North, Lawren Harris

Albert Wade Hemsworth (1916 – 2002) was a Brantford-born folk singer and songwriter. 

Wade Hemsworth | Cypress Choral Music

Although he was not a prolific composer, having written only about 20 songs during his entire career, several of his songs – most notably “The Wild Goose“, “The Black Fly Song” and “The Log Driver’s Waltz” — are among the most enduring classics in the history of Canadian folk music.

Wade Hemsworth – The Blackfly Song Lyrics | Genius Lyrics

Few things give me more homesickness than watching the National Film Board (NFB) animation vignettes, “Blackfly” and “The Log Driver’s Waltz“.

Blackfly (1991) - IMDb

Canada Vignettes: Log Driver's Waltz by John Weldon - NFB

I still remember with fondness the Brantford-born, Toronto-based band Ohbijou (2004 – 2013) with their hushed heart-tugging music.

I rarely relish listening to cover versions of favourite songs, but their cover of the Beatles’ Dear Prudence is one I could listen to, again and again.

Ohbijou, Beacons | DOMINIONATED

Dear Prudence, won’t you come out to play
Dear Prudence, greet the brand new day

The sun is up, the sky is blue
It’s beautiful and so are you
Dear Prudence, won’t you come out to play

Dear Prudence, open up your eyes
Dear Prudence, see the sunny skies

The wind is low, the birds will sing
That you are part of everything
Dear Prudence, won’t you open up your eyes?

Look around round
Look around round round
Look around

Dear Prudence, let me see you smile
Dear Prudence, like a little child
The clouds will be a daisy chain
So, let me see you smile again
Dear Prudence, won’t you let me see you smile?

Dear Prudence, won’t you come out to play
Dear Prudence, greet the brand new day
The sun is up, the sky is blue
It’s beautiful and so are you
Dear Prudence won’t you come out to play

Dear prudence sheet music 1.PNG

It is a sweet song to pass the time away on the train.

A song Fred could never hear when he lived.

A song Fred can never hear now that he’s gone.

There is no Faustian pact I wouldn’t make if I could turn back time.

The train whistle is a mournful sound in the darkness.

Railways at Night': Amazing nocturnal pictures across the world | CNN Travel

The Sorrow of Young Chatterton and the Poetic City

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Saturday 10 October 2020

Sliced through by the Mendip and Quantock Hills, the undulating emerald swards of Somerset encapsulate the rural allure of England’s West Country.

A varied region where tidy cricket greens and well-kept country pubs contrast with wilder, more dramatic landscapes.

One interpretation of the West Country, shown on this map as identical to the South West region of England, incorporating the counties of Cornwall, Devon, Dorset, Somerset, Bristol, Wiltshire and Gloucestershire.

A world away from this bucolic charm, the main city in these parts is Bristol, one of the most dynamic and cosmopolitan centres outside London, with a busy go-ahead vibe.

The city’s dense traffic and some hideous postwar architecture are more than compensated for by the surviving traces of its long maritime history, not to mention a great selection of clubs, pubs and restaurants.

Bristol skyline sunset.jpg

Above: Bristol skyline

On the borders of Gloucestershire and Somerset, Bristol has harmoniously blended its mercantile roots with a slick, modern culture, fuelled in recent years by technology-based industries, a large student population and a lively arts & media community.

As well as its vibrant youth culture, that includes the region’s best nightlife, the city’s sights range from medieval churches to cutting-edge attractions highlighting its scientific achievements.

Coat of arms of the City Council

Above: Coat of arms of the City of Bristol

A good place to start exploring Bristol, the Centre was once a quay-lined dock but it is now the traffic-ridden nucleaus of the city, with cars swirling round the statue of Edmund Burke (MP for Bristol from 1774 to 1780) and the former site of the statue of local merchant and benefactor Edward Colston (1636 – 1721).

EdmundBurke1771.jpg

Above: Edmund Burke (1729 – 1797) was an Irish statesman and philosopher.

(Born in Dublin, Burke served as a Member of Parliament (MP) between 1766 and 1794 in the House of Commons of Great Britain with the Whig Party after moving to London in 1750.

Burke was a proponent of underpinning virtues with manners in society and of the importance of religious institutions for the moral stability and good of the state. 

These views were expressed in his A Vindication of Natural Society.

He criticized the actions of the British government towards the American colonies, including its taxation policies.

Burke also supported the rights of the colonists to resist metropolitan authority, although he opposed the attempt to achieve independence.

He is remembered for his support for Catholic emanicipation, the impeachment of Warren Hastings from the East India Company, and his staunch opposition to the French Revolution.

In his Reflections on the Revolution in France, Burke asserted that the revolution was destroying the fabric of good society and traditional institutions of state and society and condemned the persecution of the Catholic Church that resulted from it.

BurkeReflections.jpg

This led to his becoming the leading figure within the conservative faction of the Whig Party, which he dubbed the Old Whigs as opposed to the pro-French Revolution New Whigs led by Charles James Fox (1749 – 1806).

In the 19th century, Burke was praised by both conservatives and liberals.

Subsequently in the 20th century, he became widely regarded as the philosophical founder of modern conservatism.)

Jonathan Richardson - Portrait of Edward Colston.jpg

Above: Edward Colston (1636 – 1721)

(Colston was an English merchant, philanthropist and Tory Member of Parliament who was involved in the Atlantic slave trade.

Colston followed his father in the family business becoming a sea merchant, initially trading in wine, fruits and textiles, mainly in Spain, Portugal and other European ports.

By 1680, he became involved in the slave trade as a member of the Royal African Company, which held a monopoly on the English trade in African slaves.

He was deputy governor of the company in 1689–90.

Colston’s name was widely commemorated in Bristol landmarks and a statue of Colston was erected in 1895.)

Larger than lifesize bronze statue of man in period clothes, standing with one hand on a staff, the other raised to his chin. It is on a white stone pedestal with inscription Edward Colston Born 1636 Died 1721", and bronze inscribed plaques below. Large bronze dolphins are on each corner of the base. It is in an urban setting with a large tree behind and above it.

The statue of Colston had more than once been the subject of graffiti attacks and calls for its removal.

Above: Art installation, showing figures representing slaves on a ship, in front of the Colston statue, during Anti-Slavery Day 2018

Black Lives Matter demonstrators tore down the statue of Edward Colston during a protest in Bristol on Sunday 7 June 2020.

Street map of central Bristol with a red line showing the route from original location south towards the western edge of the harbour

The pedestal is seen with purple spraypaint graffiti "BLM" over two of the bronze plaques and black "Black Lives Matter" and stencilled raised fists on the plinth. Placards propped on the pedestal include "Black Lives Matter", "Silence is Violence", "The UK is not innocent" and "In unity is strength". Many more placards lie on the ground around the pedestal, with "Black Lives Matter","Racism is a global pandemic" and other slogans.

Above: The empty pedestal, showing placards and graffiti

Bristol City Council said it needed to be removed from the water because the city had a “working harbour“.

Statue of slave trader Edward Colston pulled down and thrown into harbour  by Bristol protesters

The statue w

as taken to a secure location to be hosed down before becoming a museum exhibit.

It was fished out at about 0500 because the Council “didn’t want anybody to get hurt if there was a crowd there or anyone looking“.

We’ve had a diver down there who attached the ropes to crane it out of the water and take it away,” Ray Barnett, head of collections and archives at Bristol City Council, said.

The ropes that were tied around him, the spray paint added to him, is still there so we’ll keep him like that.

Mr. Barnett said the statue would be hosed down to remove the mud and ensure “we preserve him as he was tipped into the dock, while the decision is made how to move on for there“.

Opinion | Edward Colston's Toppled Statue Glorified Slavery - The New York  Times

Avon and Somerset Police elected not to intervene when the statue was toppled, saying officers would have faced a violent confrontation.

The monument has been a controversial fixture in the city, with repeated calls for it to be removed.

Previously, Bristol’s Mayor Marvin Rees said he “felt no sense of loss” at its removal.

Marvin Rees, 2016 Labour Party Conference 2.jpg

Above: Marvin Rees, Mayor of Bristol, speaking at the 2016 Labour Party Conference in Liverpool

A large brick building, built in a shallow curve, with a central porch. In front of that a pool and a water fountain.

Above: Bristol City Hall

Although the 18th century sugar magnate is known and revered as a great philanthropist – his name given to numerous buildings, streets and schools in Bristol – for many he is reviled as a leading light in the London-based Royal African Company, which held the monopoly on the slave trade until the market was opened in 1698.

An engraving showing at the top a sailing ship and paddle steamer in a harbour, with sheds and a church spire. On either side arched gateways, all above a scroll with the word "Bristol". Below a street scene showing pedestrians and a horse-drawn carriage outside a large ornate building with a colonnade and arched windows above. A grand staircase with two figures ascending and other figures on a balcony. A caption reading "Exterior, Colston Hall" and Staircase, Colston Hall". Below, two street scenes and a view of a large stone building with flying buttresses and a square tower, with the caption "Bristol cathedral". At the bottom views of a church interior, a cloister with a man mowing grass and archways with two men in conversation.

Above: An 1873 engraving showing Colston Hall, the port and cathedral of Bristol

From 1698 until the abolition of the British slave trade in 1807, Bristol merchants sent out a total of more than 2,000 ships in search of slaves on the African coast.

In 1750 alone, Bristol ships transported some 8,000 of the 20,000 slaves sent that year to British colonies in the Caribbean and North America.

Few slaves actually came to Bristol, though the grave of one who did can be seen in Henbury Churchyard: a servant to the Earl of Suffolk, the slave was named Scipio Africanus and was just 18 when he died.

It is thought that 10,000 black slaves and servants were in Britain in the early 18th century, but this is one of the very few memorials to them.

Despite the quality of the memorial, there is no record of his burial in the church registers.

Sometime between 16 and 17 June 2020 the headstone was vandalised, apparently in retaliation to the damage caused to the statue of Edward Colston by Black Lives Matter protesters.

The two incidents have caused local and national uproar.

The author Eugene Byrne featured Scipio Africanus in his 2001 alternative history novel Things Unborn.

In this novel people who had suffered an untimely death were reincarnated in an England recovering from a nuclear war.

Scipio Africanus was a famous war hero and a detective inspector in the Metropolitan Police.

Things Unborn: Byrne, Eugene: 9780743409117: Amazon.com: Books

The Bristol-based reggae band Black Roots wrote a song about Scipio Africanus which they performed live at Trinity Hall, Bristol on Channel 4’s 10-part series Rockers Roadshow, produced by Mike Wallington and hosted by Mikey Dread in the 1980s.

They featured a short scene of the grave.

Black Roots - Africa - YouTube

Samuel Taylor Coleridge made a famous anti-slavery speech in Bristol in 1795.

Coleridge in 1795

Above: Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1772 – 1834)

Olivette Otele, professor of the History of Slavery at the University of Bristol, said she hoped the statue would “be studied and analysed and people will learn about this because it’s still part of Bristol’s history“.

All these continents, Europe, America, Africa, Asia, these are intertwined histories.

It’s completely intertwined and mashed together and you can’t really separate them,” she said.

Arms of the University of Bristol.svg

Above: Coat of arms of the University of Bristol

A Palladian style nineteenth century stone building with a large colonnaded porch. In front a large metal statue on a pedestal and fountains with decorations.

Above: The Victoria Rooms, owned by the University of Bristol

Other organisations, including schools, that use the Colston name are now looking at changing their names following the protest.

(If you are interested in the city’s involvement in the slave trade, the Georgian House has a small but informative section on it, as does the British Empire and Commonwealth Museum (now in London), while the Industrial Museum (now the M Shed) has a permanent exhibition devoted to it and gives out a free “Slave Trade Trail” booklet pointing out some of the places in Bristol connected in it.)

Bristol Temple Meads old station frontage (750px).jpg

Above: Former site of the British Empire and Commonwealth Museum, Bristol

The Matthew, M Shed, Bristol CNV00035 (10391769196).jpg

Above: The Matthew, M Shed, Bristol

The Centre is just a few steps from the Cathedral and the oldest quarter of town.

Two ornate metal pillars with large dishes on top in a paved street, with an eighteenth-century stone building behind, upon which can be seen the words "Tea Blenders Estabklishec 177-". People sitting at café-style tables outside. On the right are iron railings.

Above: Two of the four Nails (bronze tables used for conducting business) in Corn Street, Bristol

A short walk west of the Centre, the grassy expanse of College Green is dominated by the crescent-shaped Council House from 1856 and the contrasting medieval lines of Bristol Cathedral.

A stone built Victorian Gothic building with two square towers and a central arched entrance underneath a circular ornate window. A Victorian street lamp stands in front of the building and on the right part of a leafless tree, with blue skies behind.

Above: Bristol Cathedral

Founded around 1140 as an abbey on the supposed spot of Augustine’s convocation with Celtic Christians in 603, the abbey became a cathedral church with the Dissolution of the Monasteries (1536 – 1541).

Among the many additions in subsequent centuries are the two towers on the west front, erected in the 19th century in a faithful act of homage in Edmund Knowle, architect and abbot at the start of the 14th century.

West front of Bristol Cathedral.jpg

The Cathedral’s interior offers a unique example among Britain’s cathedrals of a German-style hall church, in which the aisles rise to the same height as the central area.

Abbot Knowle’s choir offers one of the country’s most exquisite illustrations of early decorated Gothic, while the adjoining Elder Lady Chapel, dating from the early 13th century, contains some fine tombs and eccentric carvings of animals, including a monkey playing the bagpipes accompanied by a ram on the violin.

The ornate Eastern Lady Chapel has some of England’s finest examples of heraldic glass.

From the south transept, a door leads through to the Chapter House, a richly carved piece of late Norman architecture.

Opposite the Cathedral’s west front, the Norman Abbey Gateway blends harmoniously with the Cathedral on one side and the city library – constructed at the beginning of this century – on the other.

The northeast side of the green has one more vestige from the Middle Ages: the Lord Mayor’s Chapel, conspicuous by its large perpendicular window – the interior has some lovely French and Flemish stained glass and striking effigie of the 13th century founders of the hospital of which the church once formed a part.

Weaving through its centre, the River Avon forms part of a system of waterways that made Bristol a great inland port, in later years booming on the transatlantic trafficking of such goods as rum, tobacco and slaves.

Bristol, Avon Gorge from Clifton Down.jpg

In the 19th century the illustrious Isambard Kingdom Brunel laid the foundations of a tradition of engineering, creating two of Bristol’s greatest monuments – the SS Great Britain and the lofty Clifton Suspension Bridge.

A 19th century man wearing a jacket, trousers and waistcoat, with his hands in his pockets and a cigar in mouth, wearing a tall stovepipe top hat, standing in front of giant iron chains on a drum.

Above: Isambard Kingdom Brunel (1806 – 1889)

(Isambard Kingdom Brunel was an English civil engineer who is considered “one of the most ingenious and prolific figures in engineering history“, “one of the 19th-century engineering giants” and “one of the greatest figures of the Industrial Revolution, who changed the face of the English landscape with his groundbreaking designs and ingenious constructions“.

Brunel built dockyards, the Great Western Railway (GWR), a series of steamships including the first propeller-driven transatlantic steamship, and numerous important bridges and tunnels.

His designs revolutionised public transport and modern engineering.

Though Brunel’s projects were not always successful, they often contained innovative solutions to long-standing engineering problems.

During his career, Brunel achieved many engineering firsts, including assisting in the building of the first tunnel under a navigable river (the River Thames) and the development of the SS Great Britain, the first propeller-driven, ocean-going, iron ship, which, when launched in 1843, was the largest ship ever built.

On the GWR, Brunel set standards for a well-built railway, using careful surveys to minimise gradients and curves.

This necessitated expensive construction techniques, new bridges, new viaducts, and the two-mile (3.2 km) long Box Tunnel.

Above: Inside the Box Tunnel between Bath and Chippenham, England

One controversial feature was the wide gauge, a “broad gauge” of 7 ft 14 in (2,140 mm), instead of what was later to be known as “standard gauge” of 4 ft 8 12 in (1,435 mm).

Graphic list of track gauges

He astonished Britain by proposing to extend the GWR westward to North America by building steam-powered, iron-hulled ships.

He designed and built three ships that revolutionised naval engineering: the SS Great Western (1838), the SS Great Britain (1843), and the SS Great Eastern (1859).

In 2002, Brunel was placed second in a BBC public poll to determine the “100 Greatest Britons“.

In 2006, the bicentenary of his birth, a major programme of events celebrated his life and work under the name Brunel 200.)

Brunel 200: Home

More recently, spin-offs from the aerospace industry have placed the city at the forefront of the fields of communications, computing, design and finance.

The old docks area now forms the heart of an extensive leisure and entertainment scheme which includes a pedestrian and cycle pathway linking the train station at Temple Meads with the docks as far as the SS Great Britain, taking in St. Mary Redcliffe and Queen Square.

Bristol MMB 43 SS Great Britain.jpg

Bristol’s pride and joy is the mighty steamship SS Great Britain, designed by the genius engineer Brunel in 1843.

Driven by a revolutionary screw propeller, this massive vessel was one of the largest and most technologically advanced steamships ever built, measuring 322 feet / 98 metres from stern to tip.

Originally built as a luxury transatlantic liner, she later fell into disrepair but has since been painstakingly restored to her full glory.

The ship has had a chequered history.

Built in 1843 by Brunel, the SS Great Britain was the first propeller-driven, ocean-going iron ship, used initially between Liverpool and New York, then between Liverpool and Melbourne, circumnavigating the globe 32 times over a period of 26 years.

Between 1843 and 1886, the SS Great Britain served her intended duty as a passenger liner, completing the transatlantic crossing between Bristol and New York in just 14 days.

Above: Fitting out in the Bristol Floating Harbour, April 1844. This historic photograph by William Talbot (1800 – 1877) is believed to be the first ever taken of a ship.

Unfortunately, enormous running costs and mounting debts left her towards an ignominious end:

She was eventually sold off and subsequently served as a troop vessel, quarantine ship, emigration transport and coal hulk, before finally being scuttled near Port Stanley in the Falklands in 1937.

Above: The ship’s mizzen mast in Port Stanley

Happily, that wasn’t the end.

The ship was towed back to Bristol in 1970 and has since undergone a 30-year restoration program.

The ship’s interior has been impeccably refurbished, including the galley, surgeon’s quarters, dining saloon and a working model of the original steam engine (weighing 340 tons and measuring three storeys high).

The highlight is the “glass sea” on which the ship sits, enclosing an airtight dry dock that preserves the hull and allows visitors to view the screw propeller.

Beneath the prosperous surface, Bristol has its negative aspects – one of England’s highest populations of homeless people, some of the most notorious housing estates and the highest proportion of cars to inhabitants.

Homelessness in Bristol - Emmaus Bristol

Nonetheless, Bristol remains an attractive city, predominantly hilly, and surrounded by rolling countryside.

If there ever was a British city on the rise, it is Bristol.

Once a centre for heavy industry, over the last half-century the southwest’s largest city has reinvented itself as a hub of culture and creativity, known for its offbeat, alternative character with a wealth of art collectives, community-run cafés and music venues dotted around the city’s streets – not to mention murals left behind by Bristol’s baddest boy, the mischievous street artist Banksy.

Banksy-art.jpg

Above: “Banksy” art, Brick Lane, East End, London

Culture vultures should make time to visit Spike Island, a lively centre for visual arts that is home to a collective of artists’ studios, a contemporary art gallery and a cracking little café.

It is a short walk south from the SS Great Britain.

Above: The Chocolate Block Path beside the Avon New Cut, Spike Island

The city’s avant-garde art gallery, the Arnolfini, occupies a hulking red-brick warehouse by the river.

It remains the top venue in town for modern art, as well as occasional exhibitions of dance, film and photography.

Arnolfini from across the harbour arp.jpg

Above: The Arnolfini, Bristol

Bristol’s harbourside Aquarium has underwater habitats including a Bay of Rays, a Coral Sea, a Shark Tank, and an Amazon River Zone, as well as a resident giant Pacific octopus and an underwater viewing tunnel.

Bristol’s interactive science museum, At Bristol, has several zones spanning space, technology and the human brain.

In the Curiosity Zone (or We the Curious) you get to walk through a tornado, spin on a human gyroscope and strum the strings of a virtual harp.

ExploreAtBristol.JPG

There is also a great planetarium.

Explore is an interactive science centre.

Wildwalk is a multimedia wildlife complex, including an indoor tropical forest and an IMAX cinema.

Although chiefly aimed at families and schoolkids, there is enough here to occupy everyone for an entire day or more.

The wildlife displays and scientific wizardry are most impressive.

At Bristol is fun and interactive and should keep kids of all ages entertained for hours.

The city’s Zoo is on the north side of Clifton.

Bristol Zoo Gardens Main Entrance.jpg

Highlights include a brand-new GBP 1 million house for the zoo’s family of seven gorillas, as well as reptile and bug zones, a butterfly forest, a lion enclosure, a monkey jungle and the Zooropia treetop adventure park.

The Bristol Zoo is renowned for its animal conservation work and also features a collection of rare trees and shrubs.

Throw in the revamped harbourside, the landmark new M Shed history museum and a fast-growing foodie reputation, and it is little wonder that Bristol was once named Britain’s most liveable city (ironically).

Opened in 2011 alongside the iconic cranes of Bristol’s dockside, the impressive M Shed museum is a treasure trove of memorablia rummaging through the city’s past.

M Shed - Visit Bristol

The exhibits are divided into three sections (People, Place, Life) and provide a panoramic overview of Bristol’s history – from slaves’ possessions and vintage buses to Wallace and Gromit figurines and a set of decks once used by Massive Attack.

Sea Mills Bristol Omnibus C8320 UHY360.jpg

Three Afro-Caribbean men in conversation; behind them can be seen the upper part of a double-decker bus.

Above: Audley Evans, Paul Stephenson and Owen Henry, pictured in front of a 1960s Bristol bus

(The Bristol Bus Boycott of 1963 arose from the refusal of the Bristol Omnibus Company to employ Black or Asian bus crews.

In line with many other British cities at the time, there was widespread racial discrimination in housing and employment against so-called “Coloureds“.

An organisation founded by Roy Hackett and led by youth worker Paul Stephenson as the spokesperson of the group which included, Owen Henry, Audley Evans, Prince Brown and Guy Bailey and the West Indian Development Council, the boycott of the company’s buses by Bristolians lasted for four months until the company backed down and overturned their discriminative colour bar policy.

The boycott drew national attention to racial discrimination in Britain and the campaign was supported by national politicians, with interventions being made by church groups and the High Commissioner for Trinidad and Tobago.

The Bristol Bus Boycott was considered by some to have been influential in the passing of the 1965 Race Relations Act which made “racial discrimination unlawful in public places” and the 1968 Race Relations Act, which extended the provisions to employment and housing.)

Wallace and Gromit exhibition now open at Bristol's M Shed until September  2014

The band onstage

Above: British rock group Massive Attack

(Massive Attack are an English musical group formed in 1988 in Bristol, by Robert “3D” Del Naja, Adrian “Tricky” Thaws, Andrew “Mushroom” Vowles and Grant “Daddy G” Marshall.

The band currently consists of Del Naja, Thaws and Marshall, with Shara Nelson and Horace Andy as guest vocalists.

The debut Massive Attack album Blue Lines was released in 1991, with the single “Unfinished Symphony” reaching the charts and later being voted the 63rd greatest song of all time in a poll by NME.

MassiveAttackBlueLines.jpg

1998’s Mezzanine, containing “Teardrop“, and 2003’s 100th Window charted in the UK at #1.

Massive Attack - Mezzanine.png

Both Blue Lines and Mezzanine feature in Rolling Stone‘s list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.

The group has won numerous music awards throughout their career.

They have released five studio albums that have sold over 13 million copies worldwide.)

Rolling Stone 2019.svg

M Shed is all highly interactive, child-friendly – and, best of all, free.

In summer, look out for special weekend activities including the chance to ride on the dock cranes, watch the old Pyromat fireboat in action or catch a lift aboard the little steam locomotives of the Bristol Harbour Railway.

Bristol Prince's Wharf - Henbury going to the Create Centre.JPG

Pyronaut (6641963479).jpg

The museum also runs guided tours exploring the harbour’s history.

A long two-storey building with 4 cranes in front on the quayside. Two tugboats are moored at the quay.

Above: Site of the former Bristol Industrial Museum, now the M Shed

The Bristol Museum and Art Gallery is a classic old Edwardian museum that is full of mix-and-match exhibits, taking in everything from dinosaurs and Asian antiques to Assyrian reliefs.

Bristol art gallery and museum 2 (3763133570).jpg

The French and Eastern Art sections are particularly strong:

Look out for paintings by Pissarro and Renoir, and a new “Red Gate” sculpture by the Chinese artist Guan Donghai.

Above: Camille Pissaro’s Landscape with Farmhouses and Palm Trees

Above: Pierre-Auguste Renoir’s Theatre Box

Friends of Bristol Art Gallery: Red Gate by Guan Donghai

Above: Guan Donghai’s Red Gate

As you enter, look up to see the famous Bristol Boxkite, an early design of propeller-powered biplane, dangling from the ceiling.

Above: Bristol Boxkite flying over Stonehenge on Salisbury Plain

The ground floor sections on local archeology, geology and natural history are pretty well what you would expect, but the scope of the Museum is occasionally surprising.

It has an important collection of Chinese porcelain, glassware, stoneware and ivory, and some magnificent Assyrian reliefs carved in the 8th century BC.

The 2nd floor gallery of paintings and sculptures includes work by English Pre-Raphaelites and French Impressionists, as well as a few choice older pieces, among them a portrait of Martin Luther by Cranach and Giovanni Bellini’s unusual Descent into Limbo.

The Descent of Christ into Limbo | Art UK

Outside the Museum, look out for the bronze plaque recording the spot where, in 1643, Colonel Washington (an ancestor of America’s first president) won a decisive battle against Bristol’s Roundhead defenders.

The victory opened the way for the occupation of the city by Prince Rupert’s army – one of the greatest Royalist triumphs in the Civil War, and one of the bloodiest.

Washington's Breach | War Imperial War Museums

Built in 1590 but remodelled in 1730, the Red Lodge, a mix of Elizabethan, Stuart and Georgian architecture, was originally a merchant’s home when built in the 16th century, later became a finishing school for young ladies and subsequently England’s first girls’ reform school.

The highlight is the Great Oak Room, which still features its original Elizabethan oak panelling, plasterwork ceiling and carved chimney piece.

Redlodge2.JPG

The city began as a Saxon village and developed into the medieval river-port of Brigstow, an important trading centre for cloth and wine.

Fifteenth-century pictorial map of Bristol, radiating from the town centre

Above: Robert Ricart’s map of Bristol, drawn when he became common clerk of the town in 1478. At the centre, it shows the High Cross.

In 1497, “local heroGiovanni Caboto (aka John Cabot) (1450 – 1500) sailed from Bristol to discover Newfoundland.

JohnCabotPainting.jpg

For much of the year, a replica of Cabot’s ship, the Matthew, is moored in Bristol’s Floating Harbour.

It is a reconstruction of the vessel in which the explorer made his landmark voyage from Bristol to Newfoundland in 1497.

Licensed by King Henry VII, Cabot’s landing formed the basis of England’s later claims on the New World.

(Cabot disappeared on his second expedition the following year.)

His statue stands outside the Arnolfini Arts Centre.

Bristol - John Cabot

The Matthew allows visits Tuesday to Sunday, and also runs trips around the city’s harbour and along the Avon Gorge.

Located in the small park of Brandon Hill, the red-brick Cabot Tower was built between 1896 and 1898 to commemorate Cabot’s pioneering voyage in search of Canada.

The tower was closed in 2007 when suspicious cracks appeared, but was reopened in 2011.

It offers an unparalleled bird’s-eye panorama over the whole of Bristol.

The Cabot Tower, Bristol - geograph.org.uk - 904859.jpg

Above: Cabot Tower

The city subsequently became one of Britain’s major ports, growing rich on the aforementioned “Triangular Trade” (in which African slaves were shipped across the Atlantic to New World colonies, where they were bartered for luxury goods such as sugar, rum, tobacco and cotton that fetched a healthy profit back home.

Above: Black and white etching of the harbour in Bristol, England in about 1850, with 10 sailing vessels and rowing boats. The towers in the background are those of St Stephen’s parish church (left), St Augustine the Less (centre) and Bristol Cathedral (right). The channel was filled in 1892–1938 and the church of St Augustine the Less was demolished in 1962.

Much of Bristol’s 18th century splendour – including Clifton’s terraces and the Old Vic Theatre – were part-financed on profits from this Triangular Trade.

An imposing eighteenth-century building with three entrance archways, large first-floor windows and an ornate peaked gable end above.

Above: The Coopers Hall, entrance to the Bristol Old Vic Theatre Royal complex

During the 18th and 19th centuries, wealthy Bristol merchants transformed the former spa resort of Clifton into an elegant hilltop suburb packed with impressive Georgian mansions.

Some of the finest examples can be seen along Cornwallis Crescent and Royal York Crescent.

These days, Clifton is still the poshest postcode in Bristol, with fancy shops and a village atmosphere that is far removed from the rest of the city.

Clifton Village, its select enclave, is centred on the Mall, close to Royal York Crescent, the longest Georgian crescent in the country, offering splendid views over the steep drop to the River Avon below.

Clifton’s most famous and photographed landmark is a Brunel masterpiece, the 76-metre high Clifton Suspension Bridge, which spans the Avon Gorge.

Rocky side to a gorge with a platform in front of a cave halfway up. To the right are a road and river. In the distance are a suspension bridge and buildings.

The Bridge is 702 feet long and poised 245 feet above high water.

Suspension bridge between two brick built towers, over a wooded gorge, showing mud and water at the bottom. In the distance are hills.

Money was first put forward for a bridge to span the Avon Gorge by a Bristol wine merchant in 1753, though it was not until 1829 that a competition was held for a design.

Construction began in 1836, but Brunel died five years before its completion in 1864.

Designed to carry light horse-drawn traffic and foot passengers, these days the bridge carries around 12,000 cars every day – testament to the vision of Brunel’s design.

Clifton Suspension Bridge-9350.jpg

Hampered by financial difficulties, the bridge never quite matched the engineer’s original ambitious design, which included Egyptian-style towers topped by sphinxes on each end.

The original drawings of Brunel’s designs are in the university’s Brunel Collection and can be viewed on application, or you can see copies in the Visitor Centre, next to the Bridge, alongside the other designs proposed by Brunel’s rivals, some of them frankly bizarre.

It is free to walk or cycle across.

Car drivers pay a toll.

There is an information point near the tower on the Leigh Woods side.

Clifton Suspension Bridge Late Evening.jpg

Above: Clifton Suspension Bridge

Near the Clifton Suspension Bridge, the grassy parks of Clifton Down and Durdham Down (often referred to as just the Downs) make a fine spot for a picnic.

Nearby, the small Clifton Observatory houses a camera obscura and a tunnel leading down to the Giant’s Cave, a natural cavern that emerges halfway down the cliff with dizzying views across the Avon Gorge.

Clifton Suspension Bridge and the Observatory in Bristol, England.jpg

After being usurped by rival ports in London and Liverpool, Bristol repositioned itself as an industrial and shipbuilding centre.

In 1840, Bristol became the western terminus for the newly built Great Western Railway line from London.

Two trains and two empty rail tracks below an ornate roof which recedes into the distance

Above: The interior of Brunel’s train-shed at Temple Meads, the first Bristol terminus of the GWR

Georgian House, once the home of the wealthy West India merchant John Pinney, provides an evocative insight into aristocratic life in Bristol during the Georgian era.

It is decorated in period style, typified by the huge kitchen (complete with cast-iron roasting spit), the book-lined library and the grand drawing rooms, as well as Pinney’s cold-water plunge pool for early morning dips in the basement.

This faithfully restored former home of this local sugar merchant has spacious rooms filled with examples of period furniture – sumptuous cabinets, divans and armchairs.

The basement kitchens are fitted with equipment that would have been used in the early 18th century.

In one of the upstairs rooms, illustrated panels put it all into context and tell the engrossing story of the family’s dealings in the West Indies, including their involvement in slavery.

Georgainhousebristol.jpg

Above: Georgian House Museum, Bristol

At the top of Park Street stands central Bristol’s other chief landmark, the Wills Memorial Tower, erected in the 1920s to lend some stature to the newly opened university.

One of the last great neo-Gothic buildings in England, the Tower was the gift of the local Wills tobacco dynasty, the university’s main benefactors.

Bristol (15988640042).jpg

Above: Wills Memorial Building

In the northern suburb of Henbury is the Blaise Castle House Museum.

Displays include vintage toys, costumes and other Victorian ephemera.

Blasiecastle.jpg

Above: Blasie Castle, Bristol

In the early 20th century, local engineers pioneered the development of a ground-breaking aeroplane design, known as the Bristol Boxkite.

The city became a hub for aeronautics…..

Many parts for the Concorde were made in nearby Filton.

A view from below of an aeroplane in flight, with a slender fuselage and swept back wings.

Above: Final Concorde flight on 26 November 2003, shortly before landing on the Filton runway

Unfortunately, Bristol’s industrial importance made it a target for German bombing during WW2 and much of the city centre and harbourside was reduced to rubble.

Above: St Mary le Port Church, destroyed on 24 November 1940

In 2006, the city celebrated the bicentary of the birth of Isambard Kingdom Brunel, the aforementioned pioneering Victorian engineer responsible (among many things) for the Great Western Railway, the Clifton Suspension Bridge and the SS Great Britain.

Greater west railw logo.svg

King Street, a short walk east from the Centre, was laid out in 1633 and still holds some fine 17th century buildings, among them the Merchant Venturers’ Almshouses for retired seamen, founded in the 15th century but restored in 1699 by Edward Colston.

Merchantventurersalmshouses.jpg

Further down, the Theatre Royal is the oldest working theatre in the country, opened in 1766 and preserving many of its original Georgian features.

The Theatre hosted most of the famous names of its time, including Sarah Siddons, whose ghost is said to stalk the building.

Bristol Old Vic (750px).jpg

In a different architectural style, one of King Street’s most prominent buildings is the timber-framed Llandoger Trow pub, its name taken from the flat-bottomed boats that traded between Bristol and the Welsh coast.

Traditionally the haunt of seafarers, the pub is reputed to have been the meeting place of Daniel Defoe and Alexander Selkirk, the model for Robinson Crusoe.

A seventeenth-century timber-framed building with three gables and a traditional inn sign showing a picture of a sailing barge. Some drinkers sit at benches outside on a cobbled street. Other old buildings are further down the street, and in the background part of a modern office building can be seen.

Above: The Llandoger Trow, a historic Bristol pub

Robinson Crusoe 1719 1st edition.jpg

South of King Street, Queen Square is an elegant grassy area with a statue of King William III (1650 – 1702) at its centre, reckoned to be the best equestrian statue in the country.

Colour oil painting of William

Above: William III of England

Equestrian statue of William III, Bristol - Wikipedia

The square was the site of some of the worst civil distrubances ever seen in England when Bristolians rioted in support of the Reform Bill of 1832, burning houses on two sides of the square.

Above: 3rd Dragoon Guards violently suppressing the Bristol Riots of 1831

Among the survivors was #37, where the first American consulate was established in 1792.

Site of the First American Consulate in Britain, Queen Squ… | Flickr

American Consulate | VCH Explore

The square has a decent pub at its southeastern corner, the Hole in the Wall, so-called after the narrow window at the back of the building used to keep watch for press gangs.

THE HOLE IN THE WALL, Bristol - Old City - Updated 2020 Restaurant Reviews,  Menu, Prices, & Reservations - Tripadvisor

It was reputedly the model for the Spyglass Inn in Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island.

Treasure Island, first edition.png

The southeast corner of the square leads to Redcliffe Bridge and the Redcliffe district, where the spire of St. Mary Redcliffe provides one of the distinctive features of Bristol’s skyline.

A tall church spire over a quayside with wooden sheds and boats covered with tarpaulins. In front of these on the water a twin masted sailing boat and a narrowboat

Above: St. Mary Redcliffe Church and the Floating Harbour, Bristol

Described by Queen Elizabeth I as “the goodliest, fairest and most famous parish church in England“, the church was largely paid for and used by merchants and mariners who prayed here for a safe voyage.

Darnley stage 3.jpg

Above: Elizabeth I of England (1533 – 1603)

The present building was begun at the end of the 13th century, though it was added to in subsequent centuries and the spire was constructed in 1872.

St Mary Redcliffe church.jpg

Inside, memorials and tombs recall some of the figures associated with the building, including the arms and armour of Sir William Penn, admiral and father of the founder of Pennsylvania, on the north wall of the nave, and the Handel Window in the North Choir aisle, installed in 1859 on the centenary of the death of Handel, who composed on the organ here.

The whale bone above the entrance to the Chapel of St. John the Baptist is thought to have been brought back from Newfoundland by John Cabot.

Weird Bristol on Twitter: "The American Chapel in St Mary Redcliffe  includes this whale bone, brought back from America by John Cabot after his  original 1497 voyage.… https://t.co/HtQLv6O5O6"

The poets Samuel Taylor Coleridge and Robert Southey were both married (to ladies, not to each other) in St. Mary, within six weeks of each other in 1795.

Above: Sara Coleridge (Mrs. Samuel Taylor Coleridge)

Portrait, c. 1795

Above: Robert Southey (1774 – 1843)

Above the church’s north porch is the muniment room where Thomas Chatterton claimed to have found a trove of medieval manuscripts.

Bristol - St. Mary Redcliffe - Chatterton in the Muniment … | Flickr

In 2020, it is the fervent desire of Bristol to celebrate, with a series of projects, the 250th anniversary of Thomas Chatterton’s death.

Thomas Chatterton (1752 – 1770) was an English poet whose precocious talents ended in suicide at age 17.

He was an influence on Romantic artists of the period such as Percy Bysshe Shelley (1792 – 1822), John Keats (1795 – 1821), William Wordsworth (1770 – 1850) and Samuel Taylor Coleridge.

Portrait of Shelley, by Alfred Clint (1829)

Above: Percy Bysshe Shelley

Posthumous portrait of John Keats by William Hilton. National Portrait Gallery, London

Above: John Keats

Wordsworth on Helvellyn by Benjamin Robert Haydon.jpg

Above: William Wordsworth (1770 – 1850)

Although fatherless and raised in poverty, Chatterton was an exceptionally studious child, publishing mature work by the age of 11.

He was able to pass off his work as that of an imaginary 15th-century poet called Thomas Rowley, chiefly because few people at the time were familiar with medieval poetry, though he was denounced by Horace Walpole (1717 – 1797).

Horace Walpole, 4th Earl of Orford

Above: Horace Walpole (1717 – 1797)

At 17, he sought outlets for his political writings in London, having impressed the Lord Mayor, William Beckford (1709 – 1770), and the radical leader John Wilkes (1725 – 1797), but his earnings were not enough to keep him, and he poisoned himself in despair.

William Beckford 2.jpg

John Wilkes by Richard Houston (1769)

Above: John Wilkes

His unusual life and death attracted much interest among the romantic poets, and Alfred de Vigny (1797 – 1863) wrote a play about him that is still performed today.

Vigny, by Félix Nadar.

Above: Alfred de Vigny

The oil painting The Death of Chatterton by Pre-Raphaelite artist Henry Wallis has enjoyed lasting fame.

The Death of Chatterton, 1856, by Henry Wallis (Tate Britain, London)

Above: Henry Wallis, The Death of Chatterton

Now a series of projects marking the 250th anniversary of Chatterton’s death is, corona virus permitting, underway to remind people of his extraordinary life, and, perhaps, inspire a new generation of Romantic poets.

Poetic City Comic Published - Bristol Festival of Ideas

The planned celebration includes the commissioning of new poems based on the deathbed painting of Chatterton by Henry Wallis, which hangs in Tate Britain, London.

Tate Britain (5822081512) (2).jpg

Above: Tate Britain, London

Andrew Kelly, director of the Bristol Cultural Development Partnership, said one of the main aims of the anniversary celebrations – called A Poetic City – was simply to make sure Bristolians knew about him.

Despite his accolade by some as the father of Romantic poetry and the centuries of fascination that he has held for poets, artists and musicians, he is largely unknown in his home city.“, said Kelly.

About Us - Bristol Festival of Ideas

Chatterton was born in November 1752.

A solitary, precocious child, Chatterton spent many hours reading and writing near a tomb in the Church of St. Mary Redcliffe in Bristol.

He adopted the persona of an imaginary 15th century monk, Thomas Rowley, and produced work – not only poems, but maps, letters and even fake business accounts – in Rowley’s name.

Chatterton’s death in August 1770 is shrouded in mystery.

It has long been thought that he took his own life, but some modern academics believe it was an accident.

Kelly said:

His story raises more themes including artistic credulity and credibility, the role of the fake in art, young artists, arts and mental health, and the nature of celebrity.

Above: Kim Kardashian, reality TV star

The great Romantic poets became huge Chatterton enthusiasts.

At the time they were writing, Britain was moving towards industrialization.“, said Kelly.

They liked the fact that Chatterton looked back to the medieval period, writing under the guise of Thomas Rowley.

They were influenced by his politics.

He was very radical, against the Establishment.

There was also the doomed romanticism – his supposed suicide, though the opinion now is that it was accident rather than suicide.

Above: In the Western cultural context, romanticism substantially contributed to the idea of what a real poet should look like.

An idealized statue of a Czech man Karel Hynek Macha (1810 – 1836)(in Petrin Park, Prague) represents him as a slim, tender and perhaps unhealthy boy.

However, he had in reality a strong, robust and muscular body.

Karel Hynek Mácha

As well as looking to the past, A Poetic City will touch on issues from Chatterton’s lifetime which are still relevant today, such as young people and mental health, and fake news.

Poetic City Poetry Anthology Published - Bristol Festival of Ideas

While there is a statue of Chatterton in Millennium Square in Bristol, only fragments of a monument to him that used to stand at St. Mary Redcliffe Church survive in a city museum.

A competition is to be held to design a new monument, which will hopefully be erected within a few years.

Bristol - Thomas Chatterton

Another highlight will be a collection of poems by 12 contemporary writers responding to the Wallis painting.

They will be compiled in a book and read in public.

Bristol Poetic City - Home | Facebook

Theresa Lola, the Young People’s Laureate for London, has composed one of the poems, focusing on the window behind Chatterton’s deathbed and wondering why it is open.

Theresa Lola on Community, Identity, Movement, and Music | by Blue Milk |  Blue Milk | Medium

Above: Theresa Lola

Danny Pandolfi, a director of the Lyra Poetry Festival, which has commissioned the work, said:

Chatterton is not someone who is massively talked about or celebrated.

He should be.

Tickets — Lyra Bristol Poetry Festival

The key milestone dates at which most projects were due to converge were in March (Lyra Poetry Festival), September (Bristol Open Doors) and October-November (Bristol Poetry Institute Annual Reading, the University of Bristol Annual Art Lectures and Chatterton’s Birthday).

The Covid-19 situation has necessitated several changes to the timetable with some events moving online and the possible extension of the programme into early 2021.

Illustration of a SARS-CoV-2 virion

(As of 8 October 2020:

There are 279,000 confirmed cases and 36,765 deaths from Covid-19 in England.

There are 576,000 confirmed cases and 42, 679 deaths from Covid-19 in the United Kingdom.

There are 36,900,000 confirmed cases and 1,007,000 deaths from Covid-19 worldwide.

More than 250 students have tested positive for coronavirus at universities across our region.

New cases have been confirmed at the University of Bristol, the University of Bath, the University of Gloucestershire, and more.

In response to the overall rise in coronavirus infections, Bristol City Council has announced two local testing sites have been opened to the public.

One of these is located close to the university, at the Victoria Rooms.

To support the return of students to the city, two mobile testing sites will also be deployed, for a limited period of time, to increase testing capacity for students on campus.

With no official government figures for university corana virus outbreaks, new cases will be tracked via local reports for the South West.

A total of 119 students and two members of staff have tested positive for Covis-19 at the University of Bristol.

Professor Sarah Purdy, Pro Vice Chancellor for Student Experience at the University of Bristol, said:

We continue to monitor the situation closely with PHE and the local public health team, and welfare support is being provided for students and staff.

We are committed to ensuring students’ health and safety and protecting the local community and robust plans are in place should the situation escalate.”)

University of Bristol logo.svg

Highlights of Bristol: A Poetic City include:

  • Romantic Bristol: Writing the City – creating two new interpretation layers to this free smartphone app: one on Chatterton and one on contemporary poetic responses to his life and work.
  • The Poetic City Comic and A Poetic City Poetry Anthology – two new publications distributed free across the city.

Poetic City Anthology cover

Artist and writer appointed for A Poetic City comic - Bristol Festival of  Ideas

Poetic City Comic Published - Bristol Festival of Ideas

  • Writers in residence at Royal West of England Academy, St. Mary Redcliffe, Glenside Hospital Museum and Red Lodge.
  • Piloting of a new interpretation scheme for the Chatterton room at St Mary Redcliffe.
  • Gathering of ideas for a new Chatterton sculpture commission.
  • Development of new tourism content on the theme of Literary Bristol.
  • Suicide awareness programme at Glenside Hospital Museum.

SuicidePrevention YouTube Title Page Verses 1-10 Video 1

  • Exhibition centred on Henry Wallis’ painting, The Death of Chatterton.

  • Special themed events within the Bristol Festival of Ideas, including partnering with the Bristol Poetry Institute Annual Reading.
  • A wide range of talks, workshops, panel discussions, walking tours, poetry readings, and symposiums.

News of events and other activity will be regularly posted on the A Poetic City Facebook page and in the Festival of Ideas blog, along with links to background material (both historic and current-day).

Facebook Logo (2019).svg

https://www.ideasfestival.co.uk/blog/

Chatterton was born in Bristol where the office of sexton (custodian) of St. Mary Radcliffe had long been held by the Chatterton family.

Chatterton’s birthplace is just across the busy Redcliffe Way, administered by the city museum and viewable only on application there – though there is precious little to see inside.

Redcliffe Way: the Birthplace of Chatterton | Map your Bristol

Redcliffe Way: the Birthplace of Chatterton | Map your Bristol

The poet’s father, also named Thomas Chatterton, was a musician, a poet, a numismatist (coin collector), and a dabbler in the occult.

Thomas Senior had been a sub-chanter – helping with the preparation and conduct of the liturgy including psalms, preces (prayers) and responses – at Bristol Cathedral and master of the Pyle Street Free School, near Redcliffe Church.

Above: The wall at the right of the house where Chatterton was raised is that of the c. 1739 school where Chatterton’s father was master.

The school was demolished in 1939 to widen Pile Street into Redcliff Way, but the façade was rebuilt on the line of the former back wall.

After Chatterton’s birth (15 weeks after his father’s death on 7 August 1752), his mother established a girls’ school and took in sewing and ornamental needlework.

Chatterton was admitted to Edward Colston’s Charity, a Bristol charity school, in which the curriculum was limited to reading, writing, arithmetic and the catechism.

Chatterton, however, was always fascinated with his uncle the sexton and the Church of St Mary Redcliffe.

The knights, ecclesiastics and civic dignitaries on its altar tombs became familiar to him.

Then he found a fresh interest in oaken chests in the muniment (document) room over the porch on the north side of the nave, where parchment deeds, old as the Wars of the Roses (1455 – 1487), lay forgotten.

Chatterton learned his first letters from the illuminated capitals of an old musical folio, and he learned to read out of a black-letter Bible.

His sister said he did not like reading out of small books.

Wayward from his earliest years, and uninterested in the games of other children, he was thought to be educationally backward.

His sister related that on being asked what device he would like painted on a bowl that was to be his, he replied:

Paint me an angel, with wings, and a trumpet, to trumpet my name over the world.

From his earliest years, he was liable to fits of abstraction, sitting for hours in what seemed like a trance, or crying for no reason.

His lonely circumstances helped foster his natural reserve, and to create the love of mystery which exercised such an influence on the development of his poetry.

When Chatterton was age six, his mother began to recognise his capacity.

At age eight, he was so eager for books that he would read and write all day long if undisturbed.

Thomas Chatterton – Wikipedia

Stories of Chatterton’s apparent early inability to learn to read and being in consequence judged stupid, his falling in love with an illuminated manuscript at the age of six, after which he did little but read and demonstrate his precocity, his haunting of bookshops, his passion for fame, and his sense that the loss of his father deprived both himself and his family of the standing they might have otherwise had in the community all add color and poignancy to his story.

The constant proximity of the old and beautiful church, however, with whose fabric his ancestors had been so closely connected, nurtured his extraordinary sensibility and sheltered his strong ego from the rebuffs which a thriving commercial and maritime community dealt to the growth of his wayward temperament.

At the age of eight Chatterton was sent to Colston’s charitable foundation, where his education was geared to the vocational requirements of his community—commerce and law—rather than to encouraging the development of his imagination through classical training.

At the end of his schooling he was indentured to a local lawyer, John Lambert, as a scrivener or copy clerk.

His employer beat him on finding out that he wrote poetry in his spare time, and, tearing up what he had written, forbade him to continue.

There were like-minded young men with whom he gossiped and for whom he produced verse exercises of various kinds.

Thomas Phillips, the usher at Colston’s, had been regarded as a remarkable versifier, but Phillips died in 1769.

Chatterton’s three elegies to Phillips show he had been to some extent a fellow spirit.

Above: Colston’s Almshouses

By the age of 11, he had become a contributor to Felix Farley’s Bristol Journal.

Chatterton’s first attempt to confront present-day Bristol with its past came with his successful submission to the local newspaper, Felix Farley’s Bristol Journal, of a piece on the opening of the Old Bridge over the river Severn so that it might be compared with the opening of the new in 1768.

Bristol Bridge (April 2011).jpg

Civic pride and a sense of occasion, pageantry, and history combine in Chatterton’s piece, which re-creates ancient Bristol for the 18th-century reader.

It attracted the attention of William Barrett, a surgeon and local antiquary, whose History of Bristol (1789) was to include much Rowley material as genuine and of George Catcott, a local pewterer, who questioned Chatterton on his sources for the 15th century account (as it had been represented) of the Old Bridge.

A three-arched bridge viewed from an oblique angle, illuminated by lights

At this point the existence of the manuscripts in the muniment room and in Mrs. Chatterton’s house became public.

Barrett’s own collection of such manuscripts was augmented by Rowleian productions handed to him by Chatterton.

Following the publication of the Old Bridge piece on 1 October 1768, Chatterton gave Barrett Rowley’s “Memoirs”, “Epitaph on Robert Canynge”, “Songe to Ælla”, “Yellow Roll”, “Bristow Tragedy”, the first part of “The Battle of Hastings”, “The Parliament of Sprytes”, “Three Eclogues” and the “Tragedy of Godwynn”, as well as a “History of Bristol”, supposedly by the 11th-century prior of Durham, Turgot, with Rowley’s emendations.

(Chatterton cunningly offered material which would attract an antiquary and reinforced the forgery with pedantry, also forged, to enhance its supposed authenticity).

So it was to impress the somewhat opaque intelligence of his Bristol acquaintances that Chatterton entrusted to them a great part of his richest and most spontaneously produced Rowley material.

Consequently, not only was none of the Rowley poetry published during Chatterton’s lifetime, but his “friends” were among the most adamant after his death in asserting that the boy they had known could not possibly have written the Rowley poems.

A yellow water taxi on the water between stone quaysides. The far bank has large buildings and in the distance is a three arch bridge.

His confirmation inspired him to write some religious poems published in that paper.

In 1763, a cross which had adorned the churchyard of St Mary Redcliffe for upwards of three centuries was destroyed by a church warden.

The spirit of veneration was strong in Chatterton, and he sent to the local journal, on 7 January 1764, a satire on the parish vandal.

St Mary Redcliffe Cross | War Imperial War Museums

He also liked to lock himself in a little attic which he had appropriated as his study, and there, with books, cherished parchments, loot purloined from the muniment room of St Mary Redcliffe, and drawing materials, the child lived in thought with his 15th-century heroes and heroines.

Chatterton memorial plaque - Picture of St Mary Redcliffe Church, Bristol -  Tripadvisor

Chatterton’s earliest recollections were of the Gothic beauty of the church of St. Mary Redcliff.

It had been founded in the 15th century by William II Canynges, mayor of Bristol and a romantic figure of enormous wealth and property.

Rather than obey King Edward’s command to marry a second wife after the death of his first, he entered a monastery.

Among his contemporaries had been Thomas Rowley, at one time sheriff of Bristol.

For Chatterton, William II Canynges was to become enshrined in the role of patron to Rowley, who was cast by the boy as priest, poet, and chronicler.

The strategic role of Bristol as gateway to the West Country and the men who ventured from Bristol to fight in patriotic struggles against the invaders who threatened the independence of England and the liberty of its people were to be “Rowley’s” themes.

Flag of England

William II Canynges’s name had been featured in leases, heraldry, buildings, grants of property, and bequests in documents housed in chests in the muniment room of St. Mary Redcliffe.

Chatterton’s father had used old parchments left in disorder to cover his pupils’ books, and after his death his widow used strips of the parchments for thread papers.

Chatterton collected all the remnants of parchment he could find and took them to a lumber room which he appropriated for his own use.

There his solitary brooding, combined with the unsatisfactory nature of his daily life, encouraged the surrealistic dreamlike quality of his narratives, the vigorous dramatic evocativeness of his poems, and the passionate outpourings of his heroes and heroines.

Muniment Room, Redcliffe | Map your Bristol

Above: Entry of muniment room, St. Mary Redcliffe, Bristol

In his reading Chatterton encountered the Ossian fragments and epics of James Macpherson, which had become the rage of the polite world in the 1760s.

James Macpherson by George Romney.jpg

Above: Scottish poet James Macpherson (1736 – 1796)

Chatterton also read Thomas Percy’s three-volume Reliques of Ancient English Poetry (1765), with Percy’s “Essay on the Ancient Minstrels”, where differences between ancient and modern ballads were discussed.

Above: Bishop Thomas Percy (1729 – 1811)

Equally important was Elizabeth Cooper’s The Muses Library (1737), a 400-page account of such older English poets as Edward the Confessor, Samuel Daniel, William Langland, John Gower, Geoffrey Chaucer, Thomas Occleve, Alexander Barclay, and the Earl of Surrey.

The Historical and Poetical Medley: Or, Muses Library; Being a Choice and  Faithful Collection of the Best Antient English Poetry, From the Times of  ... to the Reign of King James the

If one adds to these the collection Old Plays (1744) by Robert Dodsley, the works of the antiquarians of the previous century, the dictionaries and encyclopedias of the 18th century, Thomas Speght’s edition of the works of Geoffrey Chaucer (1598), and the poetry of Edmund SpenserThomas GreyWilliam Collins and William Shakespeare, one can see that Chatterton’s imaginative resources were rich indeed.

Above: Robert Dodsley (1703 – 1764)

Portrait of Geoffrey Chaucer (4671380) (cropped) 02.jpg

Above: Geoffrey Chaucer (1340 – 1400)

Edmund Spenser oil painting.JPG

Above: Edmund Spenser (1552 – 1599)

Portrait by John Giles Eccardt, 1747–1748

Above: Thomas Gray (1716 – 1771)

The sole portrait of William Collins, aged 14

Above: William Collins (1721 – 1759)

Shakespeare.jpg

Above: William Shakespeare (1564 – 1616)

The first of Chatterton’s literary mysteries, the dialogue of Elinoure and Juga, was written before he was 12, and he showed it to Thomas Phillips, the usher at the boarding school Colston’s Hospital, where he was a pupil, pretending it was the work of a 15th-century poet.

Chatterton remained a boarder at Colston’s Hospital for more than six years, and it was only his uncle who encouraged the pupils to write.

ColstonsSchool.jpg

Above: Logo of Colstons School

Three of Chatterton’s companions are named as youths whom Phillips’s taste for poetry stimulated to rivalry, but Chatterton told no one about his own more daring literary adventures.

His little pocket-money was spent on borrowing books from a circulating library.

Chatterton’s “Rowleian” jargon appears to have been chiefly the result of the study of John Kersey’s Dictonarium Anglo-Britannicum, and it seems his knowledge even of Chaucer was very slight.

Buy Dictionarium Anglo-Britannicum: Or, a General English Dictionary Book  Online at Low Prices in India | Dictionarium Anglo-Britannicum: Or, a  General English Dictionary Reviews & Ratings - Amazon.in

His holidays were mostly spent at his mother’s house, and much of them in the favourite retreat of his attic study there.

He lived for the most part in an ideal world of his own, in the reign of King Edward IV (r. 1461 – 1470), during the mid-15th century, when the great Bristol merchant William II Canynges (1399 – 1474), five times Mayor of Bristol, patron and rebuilder of St Mary Redcliffe “still ruled in Bristol’s civic chair.”

Canynges was familiar to him from his recumbent effigy in Redcliffe church and is represented by Chatterton as an enlightened patron of art and literature.

Chatterton soon conceived the romance of Thomas Rowley, an imaginary monk of the 15th century, and adopted for himself the pseudonym Thomas Rowley for poetry and history.

According to psychoanalyst Louise J. Kaplan, his being fatherless played a great role in his imposturous creation of Rowley

The development of his masculine identity was held back by the fact that he was raised by two women: his mother Sarah and his sister Mary.

Therefore, “to reconstitute the lost father in fantasy“, he unconsciously created “two interweaving family romances [fantasies], each with its own scenario.”

Freud's couch, London, 2004 (2).jpeg

Above: Sigmund Freud’s couch, Freud Museum, London

The first of these was the romance of Rowley for whom he created a fatherlike, wealthy patron, William Canynge, while the second was as Kaplan named it his romance of “Jack and the Beanstalk“.

He imagined he would become a famous poet who by his talents would be able to rescue his mother from poverty.

Ironically, at the same time, there was indeed a real poet named Thomas Rowley (1721 – 1796) in Vermont, although it is unlikely that Chatterton was aware of the existence of the American poet.

Thomas Rowley, Sr. (1721 - c.1796) - Genealogy

To bring his hopes to life, Chatterton started to look for a patron.

At first, he was trying to do so in Bristol where he became acquainted with William Barrett, George Catcott and Henry Burgum.

He assisted them by providing Rowley transcripts for their work.

The Rowley Poems by Thomas Chatterton | Read & Co. Books

The antiquary William Barrett relied exclusively on these fake transcripts when writing his History and Antiquities of Bristol (1789) which became an enormous failure.

William Barrett.jpg

Above: William Barrett (1733 – 1789)

But since Chatterton’s Bristol patrons were not willing to pay him enough, he turned to the wealthier Horace Walpole.

Horace Walpole, 4th Earl of Orford

Above: Horace Walpole (1717 – 1797)

In 1769, Chatterton sent specimens of Rowley‘s poetry and “The Ryse of Peyncteynge yn Englade” to Walpole who offered to print them “if they have never been printed.”

Later, however, finding that Chatterton was only 16 and that the alleged Rowley pieces might have been forgeries, he scornfully sent him away.

Poems, supposed to have been written at Bristol by Thomas Rowley, 1777:  Thomas Chatterton, Thomas Rowley: 9780854179671: Amazon.com: Books

Badly hurt by Walpole’s snub, Chatterton wrote very little for a summer.

The Castle of Otranto by Horace Walpole

Bristol was the second largest city in England and was growing fast in commerce.

Its historic role as a strategic gateway to the West Country, and consequently in the warlike struggles of the remote past, enabled Chatterton to cast it in a mythical role.

Its origin was swathed in legend:

Its fortunes were intertwined with the fate of the nation.

It had played its part in the lives and deaths of the Saxon monarchs.

Its men had fought against foreign invaders.

Its citizens and poets had been munificent and learned.

The present reality of the town for anyone who was poor and lacked social connections, however, was dire.

If influential friends did not exist, they had to be made.

The caliber of friends that might be made in Bristol did not seem promising, an irritating state of affairs for so proud and sensitive an adolescent as Chatterton.

Above: Church of St. John the Baptist, Bristol, with the tower over the city gateway.

Then, after the end of the summer, he turned his attention to periodical literature and politics, and exchanged Farley’s Bristol Journal for the Town and Country Magazine (1769 – 1796) and other London periodicals.

Lot-Art | 1788 Volume Town and Country Magazine

Assuming the vein of the pseudonymous letter writer Junius, then in the full blaze of his triumph, he turned his pen against the Duke of Grafton (1735 – 1811), the Earl of Bute (1713 – 1792) and Augusta of Saxe-Gotha, the Princess of Wales (1719 – 1772).

Augustus-Henry-FitzRoy-3rd-Duke-of-Grafton.jpg

Above: Augustus Henry FitzRoy, 3rd Duke of Grafton (1735 – 1811)

3rd Earl of Bute by Sir Joshua Reynolds.jpg

Above: John Stuart, 3rd Earl of Bute (1713 – 1792)

Augusta of Saxe-Gotha, Princess of Wales by Charles Philips.jpg

Above: Augusta of Saxe-Gotha, Princess of Wales (1719 – 1772)

Chatterton had just dispatched one of his political diatribes to the Middlesex Journal when he sat down on Easter Eve, 17 April 1770, and penned his “Last Will and Testament“, a satirical compound of jest and earnest, in which he intimated his intention of ending his life the following evening.

Among his satirical bequests, such as his “humility” to the Rev. Camplin, his “religion” to Dean Barton, and his “modesty” along with his “prosody and grammar” to Mr. Burgum, he leaves “to Bristol all his spirit and disinterestedness, parcels of goods unknown on its quay since the days of Canynge and Rowley.”

In more genuine earnestness, he recalls the name of Michael Clayfield, a friend to whom he owed intelligent sympathy.

The will was possibly prepared in order to frighten his master into letting him go.

If so, it had the desired effect.

Shakespeare-Testament.jpg

Above: Last page of the handwritten 1616 will of William Shakespeare

John Lambert, the attorney to whom he was apprenticed, cancelled his indentures.

His friends and acquaintances having donated money, Chatterton went to London.

Above: A view of London from the east in 1751

Chatterton already was known to the readers of the Middlesex Journal as a rival of Junius under the nom de plume of Decimus.

He also had been a contributor to Hamilton’s Town and Country Magazine, and speedily found access to the Freeholder’s Magazine, another political miscellany supportive of John Wilkes and liberty.

His contributions were accepted, but the editors paid little or nothing for them.

Chatterton wrote hopefully to his mother and sister, and spent his first earnings in buying gifts for them.

Wilkes had noted his trenchant style “and expressed a desire to know the author“.

John Wilkes by Richard Houston (1769)

Above: John Wilkes (1725 – 1797)

Chatterton could assume the style of Junius or Tobias Smolett, reproduce the satiric bitterness of Charles Churchill, the parody of James Macpherson’s Ossian, or write in the manner of Alexander Pope or with the polished grace of Thomas Gray and William Collins.

Tobias Smollett c 1770.jpg

Aove. Tobias Smollett (1721 – 1771)

Charles Churchill (satirist).jpg

Above: Charles Churchill (1732 – 1764)

Above: Ossian Singing, Nicolai Abildgaard, 1787

Pope c. 1727

Above: Alexander Pope (1688 – 1744)

Chatterton wrote political letters, eclogues (poems on a pastoral topic), lyrics, operas and satires, both in prose and verse.

In June 1770, after nine weeks in London, Chatterton moved from Shoreditch, where he had lodged with a relative, to an attic in Brook Street, Holborn (now beneath Alfred Waterhouse’s Holborn Bars building).

Above: Prudential Assurance Building (formerly Holborn Bars), 142 Holborn, Camden

Chatterton was still short of money, and now state prosecutions of the press rendered letters in the Junius vein no longer admissible, and threw him back on the lighter resources of his pen.

In Shoreditch, he had shared a room, but now, for the first time, he enjoyed uninterrupted solitude.

His bedfellow at Mr. Walmsley’s, Shoreditch, noted that much of the night was spent by him in writing.

Now Chatterton could write all night.

Big Ben by Lamp light by =mym8rick on deviantART | Big ben, Amazing  destinations, London

The romance of his earlier years revived, and he transcribed from an imaginary parchment of the old priest Rowley his “Excelente Balade of Charitie“.

This poem, disguised in archaic language, he sent to the editor of the Town and Country Magazine, where it was rejected.

An Excellent Ballad of Charity

Mr. Cross, a neighbouring apothecary, repeatedly invited him to join him at dinner or supper, but Chatterton refused.

His landlady also, suspecting his necessity, pressed him to share her dinner, but in vain.

She knew“, as she afterwards said, “that he had not eaten anything for two or three days.

But he assured her that he was not hungry.

The note of his actual receipts, found in his pocket-book after his death, shows that Hamilton, Fell, and other editors who had been so liberal in flattery, had paid him at the rate of a shilling for an article, and less than eightpence each for his songs.

Much which had been accepted was held in reserve and still unpaid for.

According to his foster mother, he had wished to study medicine with Barrett, and in his desperation he wrote to Barrett for a letter to help him to an opening as a surgeon’s assistant on board an African trader.

Above: Andreas Vesulius’s 1543 De humani corporis fabrica contained intricately detailed drawings of human dissections

While walking along St. Pancras Churchyard, Chatterton much absorbed in thought, took no notice of an open grave, newly dug in his path, and subsequently tumbled into it.

His walking companion, upon observing this event, helped Chatterton and told him in a jocular manner that he was happy in assisting at the resurrection of genius.

Chatterton replied:

My dear friend, I have been at war with the grave for some time now.

Chatterton died by suicide three days later. 

St Pancras Old Church - geograph.org.uk - 757784.jpg

Above: St. Pancras Old Church

On 24 August 1770, he retired for the last time to his attic in Brook Street, carrying with him the arsenic which he drank, after tearing into fragments whatever literary remains were at hand.

He was 17 years and nine months old.

The Death of Chatterton, 1856, by Henry Wallis (Tate Britain, London)

Some folks suggest that the young poet committed suicide when his Rowley forgery was exposed, thereby supplying English literature with one of its most glamourous stories of self-destructive genius.

There has been some speculation that Chatterton may have taken the arsenic as a treatment for a venereal disease, as it was commonly used for such at that time.

A few days later, one Dr Thomas Fry came to London with the intention of giving financial support to the young boy “whether discoverer or author merely“.

A fragment, probably one of the last pieces written by the impostor-poet, was put together by Dr. Fry from the shreds of paper that covered the floor of Thomas Chatterton’s Brook Street attic on the morning of 25 August 1770.

The would-have-been patron of the poet had an eye for literary forgeries, and purchased the scraps which the poet’s landlady, Mrs. Angel, swept into a box, cherishing the hope of discovering a suicide note among the pieces.

This fragment, possibly one of the remnants of Chatterton’s very last literary efforts, was identified by Dr. Fry to be a modified ending of the poet’s tragical interlude Aella.

The fragment is now in the possession of Bristol Public Library and Art Gallery.

Above: Bristol Public Library

Coernyke.
Awake! Awake! O Birtha, swotie (sweet) mayde!
Thie Aella deadde, botte thou ynne wayne wouldst dye,
Sythence (Since) he thee for renomme (renown) hath betrayde,
Bie hys owne sworde forslagen (slain) doth he lye;
Yblente (Blind) he was to see thie boolie (lovely) eyne,
Yet nowe o Birtha, praie, for Welkynnes (Heavens), lynge (stay)!
How redde thie lippes, how dolce (soft) thie deft (neat) cryne (hair),
…………………………………scalle (shall) bee thie Kynge!
…………………………………a.
…………………………………….omme the kiste (coffin)
……………………………………………………….

The final Alexandrine is completely missing, together with Chatterton’s notes.

However, according to Dr. Fry, the character who utters the final lines must have been Birtha, whose last word might have been something like “kisste.”

The Works of Thomas Chatterton Volume 2: Chatterton, Thomas: 9781231059050:  Books - Amazon.ca

The death of Chatterton attracted little notice at the time, for the few who then entertained any appreciative estimate of the Rowley poems regarded him as their mere transcriber.

He was interred in a burying ground attached to the Shoe Lane Workhouse in the parish of St. Andrew, Holborn, later the site of Farrington Market.

There is a discredited story that the body of the poet was recovered, and secretly buried by his uncle, Richard Phillips, in Redcliffe Churchyard.

The Marvellous Boy is remembered by a memorial stone in Redcliffe’s south transept.

There a monument has been erected to his memory, with the appropriate inscription, borrowed from his “Will” and so supplied by the poet’s own pen.

To the memory of Thomas Chatterton.

Reader! Judge not.

If thou art a Christian, believe that he shall be judged by a Superior Power.

To that Power only is he now answerable.

Church of St. Mary, Redcliffe, Bristol

There is another one to his family, who were long associated with the church, in the churchyard.

A Poetic City - Bristol Festival of Ideas

It was after Chatterton’s death that the controversy over his work began. 

Poems supposed to have been written at Bristol by Thomas Rowley and others, in the Fifteenth Century (1777) was edited by Thomas Tyrwhitt, a Chaucerian scholar who believed them genuine medieval works.

However, the appendix to the following year’s edition recognises that they were probably Chatterton’s own work. 

Thomas Tyrwhitt | English scholar | Britannica

Above: Thomas Tyrwhitt (1730 – 1786)

Thomas Warton, in his History of English Poetry (1778) included Rowley among 15th-century poets, but apparently did not believe in the antiquity of the poems.

Thomas Warton by Reynolds.jpg

Above: Thomas Warton (1728 – 1790)

In 1782 a new edition of Rowley‘s poems appeared, with a “Commentary, in which the antiquity of them is considered and defended“, by Jeremiah Milles, Dean of Exeter.

Above: Reverend Jeremiah Milles (1714 – 1784)

The controversy which raged round the Rowley poems is discussed in Andrew Kippis’ Biographica Britannica (vol. iv., 1789), where there is a detailed account by George Gregory of Chatterton’s life (pp. 573–619).

This was reprinted in the edition (1803) of Chatterton’s Works by Robert Southey and Joseph Cottle, published for the benefit of the poet’s sister.

Above: Andrew Kippis (1725 – 1795)

The neglected condition of the study of earlier English in the 18th century alone accounts for the temporary success of Chatterton’s mystification.

It has long been agreed that Chatterton was solely responsible for the Rowley poems.

The language and style were analysed in confirmation of this view by W.W. Skeat in an introductory essay prefaced to vol. ii. of The Poetical Works of Thomas Chatterton (1871) in the “Aldine Edition of the British Poet.”

The Chatterton manuscripts originally in the possession of William Barrett of Bristol were left by his heir to the British Museum in 1800.

Others are preserved in the Bristol Library.

Above: Walter William Skeat (1835 – 1912)

Chatterton’s genius and his death are commemorated by Percy Bysshe Shelley in Adonais (though its main emphasis is the commemoration of Keats), by William Wordsworth in “Resolute and Independence“, by Samuel Taylor Coleridge in “Monody on the Death of Chatterton“, by Dante Gabriel Rossetti in “Five English Poets“, and in John Keats’ sonnet “To Chatterton“.

DOC) Resolution and Independence | MAHA LAKSHMI K - Academia.edu

The Complete Poems by Samuel Taylor Coleridge

Portrait of Dante Gabriel Rossetti c. 1871, by George Frederic Watts

Above: Dante Gabriel Rossetti (1828 – 1882)

Sonnet To Chatterton Poem by John Keats

Keats also inscribed Endymionto the memory of Thomas Chatterton“.

Two of Alfred de Vigny’s works, Stello and the drama Chatterton, give fictionalized accounts of the poet:

In the former, there is a scene in which William Beckford’s harsh criticism of Chatterton’s work drives the poet to suicide.

The three-act play Chatterton was first performed at the Théâtre Francais, Paris, on 12 February 1835. 

Chatterton - Label Emmaüs

Herbert Kroft, in his Love and Madness, interpolated a long and valuable account of Chatterton, giving many of the poet’s letters, and much information obtained from his family and friends.

Amazon.com: Love and Madness: A Story Too True; In a Series of Letters,  Between Parties Whose Names Would Perhaps Be Mentioned Were They Less Known  or Less Lamented (Classic Reprint) (9780265904169): Croft

The most famous image of Chatterton in the 19th century was The Death of Chatterton (1856) by Henry Wallis, now in Tate Britain, London.

Two smaller versions, sketches or replicas, are held by the Birmingham Museum and Art Galley and the Yale Centre for British Art.

The figure of the poet was modeled by the young George Meredith.

Two of Chatterton’s poems were set to music as glees by the English composer John Wall Callcott.

These include separate settings of distinct verses within the Song to Aelle.

Above: John Wall Callcott (1766 – 1821)

Chatterton’s best known poem, O synge untoe mie roundelaie was set to a five-part madrigal by Samuel Wesley.

Samuel Wesley organist.jpg

Above: Samuel Wesley (1766 – 1837)

Chatterton has attracted operatic treatment a number of times throughout history, notably Ruggiero Leoncavello’s largely unsuccessful two-act Chatterton, the German composer Matthias Pintscher’s modernistic Thomas Chatterton, and Australian composer Matthew Dewey’s lyrical yet dramatically intricate one-man mythography entitled The Death of Thomas Chatterton.

Above: Ruggiero Leoncavello (1857 – 1919)

MATTHIAS PINTSCHER

Above: Matthias Pintscher

Image of Matthew Dewey

Above: Matthew Dewey

There is a collection of “Chattertoniana” in the British Library, consisting of works by Chatterton, newspaper cuttings, articles dealing with the Rowley controversy and other subjects, with manuscript notes by Joseph Haslewood, and several autograph letters. 

British library london.jpg

Above: British Library, London

E.H.W. Meyerstein, who worked for many years in the manuscript room of the British Museum wrote a definitive work — “A Life of Thomas Chatterton” — in 1930. 

British Museum (aerial).jpg

Above: British Museum, London

Peter Ackroyd’s 1987 novel Chatterton was a literary re-telling of the poet’s story, giving emphasis to the philosophical and spiritual implications of forgery.

In Ackroyd’s version, Chatterton’s death was accidental.

Ackroyd in 2007

Above: Peter Ackroyd

Chatterton: Amazon.co.uk: Ackroyd, Peter: 9788435005432: Books

In 1886, architect Herbert Horne and Oscar Wilde unsuccessfully attempted to have a plaque erected at Colston’s School, Bristol.

Wilde, who lectured on Chatterton at this time, suggested the inscription: “To the memory of Thomas Chatterton,

One of England’s greatest poets and sometime pupil at this school.

Wilde in 1882

Above: Oscar Wilde (1854 – 1900)

In 1928, a plaque in memory of Chatterton was mounted on 39 Brooke Street, Holborn, bearing the inscription below.

The plaque subsequently has been transferred to a modern office building on the same site.

In a house on this site Thomas Chatterton died, 24 August 1770

Thomas Chatterton blue plaque | Open Plaques

Within Bromley Common, there is a road called Chatterton Road: this is the main thoroughfare in Chatterton Village, based around the public house, The Chatterton Arms.

Both road and pub are named after the poet.

Chatterton Arms, Bromley Common • whatpub.com

French singer Serge Gainsbourg entitled one of his songs “Chatterton“, stating:

Chatterton suicidé

Hannibal suicidé

Quant à moi

Ça ne va plus très bien

Serge Gainsbourg par Claude Truong-Ngoc 1981.jpg

Above: Serge Gainsbourg (1928 – 1991)

The song was covered (in Portuguese) by Seu Jorge live and recorded in the album Ana & Jorge: Ao Vivo.

Seu Jorge.jpg

Above: Seu Jorge

Sadly, still, too many people know too little about Chatterton.

To be fair, there is a living Bristolian that nearly everyone has heard about, it is Banksy – the guerilla street artist whose distinctive stencilled style and provocative artworks have earned him worldwide notoriety.

Though Banksy’s true identity is a secret, it is believed he was born in 1974 in Yate, 12 miles from Bristol, and honed his artistic skills in a local graffiti outfit.

His works take a wry view of 21st century culture – especially capitalism, consumerism and the cult of celebrity.

Among his best-known pieces are the production of spoof banknotes (featuring Princess Diana’s head instead of Queen Elizabeth II’s), a series of murals on Israel’s West Bank barrier (depicting people digging holes and climbing ladders over the wall) and a painting of a caveman pushing a shopping trolley at the British Museum (which the Museum promptly claimed for its permanent collection).

Banksy 'Princess Diana £10 note' donated to British Museum - BBC News

Macdonald Caveman Banksy Framed Art Giclee Art Print

Locations of Banksy art - General - Atlas Obscura Community - Travel Forum

Banksy’s documentary Exit through the Gift Shop about an LA street artist, was nominated for an Oscar in 2011.

Exit-through-the-gift-shop.jpg

Long despised by the authorities, Banksy has become an unlikely tourist magnet.

Though many of his works are short-lived, a few still survive around Bristol.

Look out for:

  • the Well Hung Lover on Frogmore Street, featuring an angry husband, a two-timing wife and a naked man dangling from a window
A painting on a building showing a naked man hanging by one hand from a window sill. A man in a suit looks out of the window, shading his eyes with his right hand, behind him stands a woman in her underwear.

  • a stencil of the Grim Reaper on the side of the Thekia (Bristol’s club boat)

  • the Paintpot Angel outside the Bristol Museum and Art Gallery

Banksy Busts His Hometown Museum for Scamming His Fans With Hundreds of  Unauthorized Prints

  • Mild Mild West (featuring a Molotov cocktail-wielding teddy bear) on Cheltenham Road

Banksy Graffiti Mild Mild West - Visit Bristol

Banksy hit the headlines again in 2014 when one of his murals unexpectedly appeared on a wooden panel outside the Broad Plain Boys’ Club in April 2014.

Known as Mobile Lovers, the mural depicted a young couple who appear to be embracing but are actually staring into their phones.

Predictably enough, a furore over ownership ensued, but the artist made it clear that he had painted the mural as a gift to the boys’ club, which he is thought to have attended as a young man.

After a few months on display at the Bristol City Museum, the work was sold for GBP 400,000 to a private collector in August 2014, with all the proceeds going to fund the boys’ club’s ongoing projects.

Banksy Mobile Lovers letter: Bristol's Broad Plain Boys' Club to keep  painting | Metro News

It may be a stretch of my imagination, but Banksy strikes me as art’s 21st century equivalent to literature’s 18th century Chatterton.

Who is Banksy?

Who was Chatterton?

What is the real Bristol?

I think the search for these answers is well worth the effort.

A panoramic view looking over a cityscape of office blocks, old buildings, church spires and a multi-story car park. In the distance are hills.

Above: Bristol

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Steven Morris, “Bristol celebrates its poet genius“, The Guardian, 30 March 2020 / Shasana Brown, “More than 250 university coronavirus cases confirmed in our region“, Bristol Live, 8 October 2020 / Lonely Planet England / Rough Guide to England

The Death of Chatterton, 1856, by Henry Wallis (Tate Britain, London)

Canada Slim and the Love of Landscape

Landschlacht, Switzerland, Monday 20 July 2020

Think of this blog as a prologue.

It is named “Building Everest“, for it is here where I practice building something impressive (hopefully), my writing career.

Everest kalapatthar.jpg

Above: Mount Everest

On Monday (13 July) I phoned an old friend in Gatineau, Québec, Canada and we got to talking about our literary passions and ambitions.

Both of us in our 50s we have come to the realization that there are probably more years behind us than ahead of us, and there is no guarantee that the years that remain will necessarily be healthy years.

Happily, our creative projects do not conflict.

Gatineau downtown area

Above: Gatineau, Québec, Canada

He would like to write science fiction and fantasy similar to C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien.

Monochrome head-and-left-shoulder photo portrait of 50-year-old Lewis

Above: C(live) S(taples) Lewis (1898 – 1963)

Tolkien as a second lieutenant in the Lancashire Fusiliers (in 1916, aged 24)

Above: J(ohn) R(onald) R(euel) Tolkien (1892 – 1973)

I want to write novels and travel books similar to Charles Dickens and Paul Theroux.

Charles Dickens

Above: Charles Dickens (1812 – 1870)

Theroux in 2008

Above: Paul Theroux (b. 1941)

I miss my friend and Ottawa where our sporadic reunions usually take place and I wish we lived closer to one another and we could be like his literary heroes.

Centre Block on Parliament Hill, the Government House, Downtown Ottawa, the Château Laurier, the National Gallery of Canada and the Rideau Canal

Above: Images of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada (across the river from Gatineau)

Lewis, Tolkien and their friends were a regular feature of the Oxford scenery in the years during and after the Second World War.

From top left to bottom right: Oxford skyline panorama from St Mary's Church; Radcliffe Camera; High Street from above looking east; University College, main quadrangle; High Street by night; Natural History Museum and Pitt Rivers Museum

Above: Images of Oxford, England

They drank beer on Tuesday at “the Bird and Baby” (The Eagle and Child Pub) and on Thursday nights they met in Lewis’s Magdalen College rooms to read aloud from the books they were writing, jokingly calling themselves “the Inklings“.

The Eagle and Child.jpg

Above: The Eagle and Child, Oxford

Magdalen-may-morning-2007-panorama.jpg

Above: Magdalen (pronounced Maud-lin) College, Oxford

Above: The corner of the Eagle and Child where the Inklings regularly met

Lewis and Tolkien first introduced the former’s The Screwtape Letters and the latter’s The Lord of the Rings to an audience in this company.

Thescrewtapeletters.jpg

First Single Volume Edition of The Lord of the Rings.gif

As a English Canadian living in Deutschschweiz, I long for some sort of local creative writing club where I could share my writing worries and hopes in a way much like Lewis, in a letter to his friend A(lfred) K(enneth) Hamilton Jenkin (1900 – 1980), described the idyllic setting of his college rooms:

Above: Linguistic map (German, French, Italian, Rumansh) of Switzerland

The Story of Cornwall: A.K. Hamilton Jenkin: Amazon.com: Books

I wish there was anyone here childish enough (or permanent enough, not the slave of his particular and outward age) to share it with me.

Is it that no man makes real friends after he has passed the undergraduate age?

Because I have got no forr’arder, since the old days.

I go to Barfield (Owen Barfield) for sheer wisdom and a sort of richness of spirit.

Owen Barfield – AnthroWiki

Above: Arthur Owen Barfield (1898 – 1997)

I go to you for some smaller and yet more intimate connexion with the feel of things.

But the question I am asking is why I meet no such men now.

Is it that I am blind?

Some of the older men are delightful:

The younger fellows are none of them men of understanding.

Oh, for the people who speak one’s own language!

I guess this blog must serve this capacity.

So many ideas float through my mind and are captured in my chapbook.

(Normally, a chapbook refers to a small publication of about 40 pages, but I use this word in the context of a portable notebook where ideas are recorded as they spontaneously occur.)

Above: Chapbook frontispiece of Voltaire’s The Extraordinary Tragical Fate of Calas, showing a man being tortured on a breaking wheel, late 18th century

Just a sample:

  • Scaling the Fish: Travels around Lake Constance

Bodensee satellit.jpg

  • Mellow Yellow: Switzerland Discovered in Slow Motion

  • The Coffeehouse Chronicles (an older man in love with a much younger woman)

Above: Café de Flore in Paris is one of the oldest coffeehouses in the city.

It is celebrated for its famous clientele, which in the past included high-profile writers and philosophers

  • America 47 (think 47 Ronin meets Trumpian times)

Flag of the United States

  • 20th Century Man (think time travel)

The Time Machine (H. G. Wells, William Heinemann, 1895) title page.jpg

  • Lover’s Cross (a Beta male escapes his Alpha wife)

Jim Croce - Lover's Cross (1985, Vinyl) | Discogs

  • Alicia in Switzerland (Alice in Wonderland meets Gulliver’s Travels in Switzerland)

Alice in Wonderland (1951 film) poster.jpg

  • Love in the Time of Corona (though the title is reminiscent of Love in the Time of Cholera, the story is more about the virtues of faith, family and hope in periods of plague)

LoveInTheTimeOfCholera.jpg

  • Gone Mad (what is sanity and how is the world seen by those judged ill in this regard)

Above: Engraving of the eighth print of A Rake’s Progress, depicting inmates at Bedlam Asylum, by William Hogarth.

  • The Forest of Shadows (sci-fi that asks the question what if the past never dies?)

Above: Conifer forest, Swiss National Park

I have the ideas.

I believe I have the talent.

What is lacking is the ability to market myself and the discipline to be a prolific writer.

Still I believe that each day I am getting closer to the realization of my ambitions.

Doug And The Slugs - Day By Day (1985, Vinyl) | Discogs

One thing that inspires my creativity is my travels and sometimes even a drive through the country can be the spark that ignites my imagination.

Landschlacht to Flims (Part One), Thursday 28 May 2020

Transport of the mails, transport of the human voice, transport of flickering pictures – in this century, as in others, our highest accomplishments still have the single aim of bringing men together.” (Antoine de Saint-Exupéry)

Saint-Exupéry in Toulouse, 1933

Above: Antoine de Saint-Exupéry (1900 – 1944)

He and She

In a sense, it is travelling together that can make (or break) a relationship.

My wife and I don’t always live together harmoniously, but, generally, we travel well together.

Like any relationship with two (or more) people, harmony is possible once an understanding of who the other person is and what they like becomes clearer.

He said she said.jpg

My wife is an efficient German doctor who sets a goal and will not stop until it is realized, and for this she does have my respect.

I am the “life is a journey, not a destination dreamer in the relationship.

Life Is a Highway Tom Cochrane.jpg

I recall a bitter battle of poorly chosen words between us when on a journey between Freiburg im Breisgau (Black Forest of southwestern Germany) and Bretagne (on the Atlantic coast of France) we argued over efficiency over effectiveness.

I wanted to explore the regions between the Black Forest and Bretagne instead of simply rushing through them.

She, the driver, found driving through towns far more exhausting than sticking to motorways.

I, the passenger, wanted to see more than concrete rest stops where we wouldn’t stop and far-off fields we would never walk.

Main eventposter.jpg

Over the years we have come to an unspoken compromise.

We travel slowly to our travel destination and zoom home after our time there was complete.

Above: The Tortoise and the Hare“, from an edition of Caleb’s Fables illustrated by Arthur Rackham, 1912

On this day our journey in Switzerland (as of this day the borders around Switzerland were not yet open) wasn’t far by Canadian driving standards: a little over an hour and an half if we followed Highway 13 and Expressway 62 from Landschlacht in Canton Thurgau to Flims in Canton Graubünden.

Instead we opted to take the scenic route, avoiding as much as humanly possible heavily trafficked Autobahns, extending the journey at least another hour if we did not stop on the way.

Flag of Switzerland

I’ve no use for statements in which something is kept back, ” he added.  “And that is why I shall not furnish information in supprt of yours.

The journalist smiled.

You talk the language of St. Just.

Without raising his voice Rieux said he knew nothing about that.

The language he used was that of a man who was sick and tired of the world he lived in – though he had much liking for his fellow men – and had resolved, for his part, to have no truck with injustice and compromises with the truth.

His shoulders hunched, Rambert gazed at the doctor for some Moments without speaking.

Then, “I think I understand you,” he said, getting up from his chair.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

La Peste book cover.jpg

The Private Secret Language of Altnau

What I do know for certain is that what is regarded as success in a rational materialistic society only impresses superficial minds. 

It amounts to nothing and will not help us rout the destructive forces threatening us today. 

What may be our salvation is the discovery of the identity hidden deep in any one of us, and which may be found in even the most desperate individual, if he cares to search the spiritual womb which contains the embryo of what can be one’s personal contribution to truth and life.

(Patrick White)

White in Sydney, 1973

Above: Patrick White (1912 – 1990)

Heading east along Highway 13 from Landschlacht, the Traveller comes to Altnau (population: 2,244).

During the Lockdown (16 March to 10 May 2020) I often followed the walking path that hugs the shore of Lake Constance, north of both the Lake Road (Highway #13) and the Thurbo rail line, from Landschlacht to Altnau.

Visitors that zoom past Landschlacht often zoom past Altnau as well, as both Highway #13 and the railroad lie north of the town centre, so neither connection to Altnau is a boon to tourism or the economy as a whole.

Altnau remains for most people only a deliberate distant choice, which is a shame as the town entire has been designated as part of the Inventory of Swiss Heritage Sites, with a special focus on the town’s Reformed and Catholic churches and the Apfelweg (apple path).

Oberdorf Altnau

Above: Upper town, Altnau, Canton Thurgau, Switzerland

The Apfelweg, the first fruit educational path in Switzerland, is a nine-kilometre long circular route which explains with 16 signs everything you didn’t know you wanted to know about apples and apple production.

Understandably the Apfelweg is best done in the spring when the blossoms are on the orchards or late summer when the apples are ready to be harvested.

Apfelweg Altnau - Thurgau Tourismus

What can be seen by the lakeside visitor, even viewed from the highway or the train, is the Altnau Pier (Schiffsanlegesteg Altnau).

Completed in 2010, at a length of 270 metres, because of the wide shallow water zone, the Pier is the longest jetty on Lake Constance.

Altnauers call this jetty the Eiffel Tower of Lake Constance because the length of the jetty is the same as the height of the Tower.

Above: Altnau Pier

Notable people have formed the fabric of Altnau.

Hans Baumgartner (1911 – 1996), a famous (by Swiss standards) photographer was born here.

He studied in Kreuzlingen and Zürich and would later teach in Steckborn and Frauenfeld.

He would later sell his photographs to magazines and newspapers.

In 1937, Baumgartner met the Berlingen artist Adolf Dietrich who would feature in many of Baumgartner’s future photographs.

Adolf Dietrich.jpg

Above: Adolf Dietrich (1877 – 1957)

Baumgartner travelled and photographed Paris, Italy, the Balkans, southern France, North Africa and the Sahara, Croatia and the Dalmatian Coast, Burgundy, Spain, Portugal, Sweden, Finland, the US, Mexico, Belgium and Germany.

He also visited Bombay, Colombo, Saigon, Hong Kong and Yokohama.

He even photographed his spa visits in Davos.

Der Chronist mit der Kamera | Journal21

Above: Hans Baumgartner (1911 – 1996)

Altnau attracted the likes of composer-poetess Olga Diener (1890 – 1963).

Born in St. Gallen, Olga lived in Altnau from 1933 to 1943.

Diener, Olga Nachlass Olga Diener

Above: Olga Diener

In a letter to Hans Reinhart in June 1934, Hermann Hesse wrote about Olga’s work:

“I like Olga’s dreams very much.

I also love many of her pictures and their rhythms, but I see them enclosed in a glasshouse that separates her and her poems from the world.

That miracle must come about in poetry, that one speaks his own language and his pictures, be it only associative, that others can understand – that distinguishes the dream from poetry.

Olga’s verses are, for me at least, far too much dream and far too little poetry.

She has her personal secret language not being able to approximate the general language in such a way that the sender and recipient correspond to each other.

So I am privately a genuine friend of Olga’s and her books, but as a writer I am not able to classify them.

Hermann Hesse 2.jpg

Above: Hermann Hesse (1877 – 1962)

Besides Hesse, of the visitors Olga Diener had in her Altnau home, of interest is fellow poet Hans Reinhart (1880 – 1963).

Reinhart came from a Winterthur trading family, which allowed him the opportunity to lead a financially independent poet’s life.

During a spa stay in Karlovy Vary in the late summer of 1889, Reinhart read Hans Christian Andersen‘s fairy tales for the first time.

Andersen in 1869

Above: Hans Christian Andersen (1805 – 1875)

They deeply impressed Reinhart and he later transformed them into stage plays.

After his secondary studies, “Müggli” studied philosophy, psychology, German, art, theatre and music history in Heidelberg, Berlin, Zürich, Paris, Leipzig and Munich.

After completing his studies, he met Rudolf Steiner for the first time in 1905, whom he recognized as a spiritual teacher.

Reinhart later helped Steiner build the first Goetheanum and made friends with other anthroposophists.

In 1941 Reinhart brought his friend Alfred Mombert and his sister from the French internment camp Gurs to Winterthur.

Reinhart Hans, 1880-1963, Dichter - Winterthur Glossar

Above: Hans Reinhart (1880 – 1963)

Another of Olga’s Altnau guests was writer / poet Emanuel von Bodman (1874 – 1946).

Bodman lived in Kreuzlingen as a child and attended high school in Konstanz.

After studying in Zürich, Munich and Berlin, he chose Switzerland’s Gottlieben as his adopted home.

His home, like Olga’s, was the meeting point for many artists, including the famous Rainer Maria Rilke and Hermann Hesse.

Bodman wrote several dramas, short stories and hundreds of poems.

He was seen as a poet, storyteller and playwright in the neo-romantic, neo-classical tradition.

Emanuel von Bodman - Liebesgedichte und Biographie

Above: Emanuel von Bodman

I write about these members of a long-departed Dead Poets Society, whose works we have not read and might never read, to inspire us.

If writers, poets, artists and musicians can come from Here and their works be loved (at least in their times) then perhaps we too can rise above our humblest of origins and find such luck to inspire others.

Dead poets society.jpg

All of these wordsmiths and miracle scribes seem, without exception, all thick and heavy with each other.

And herein lies my weakness.

By temperament, I am more like the Americans Charles Bukowski and Eric Hoffer than I am like those one might call the litterati.

Charles Bukowski smoking.jpg

Above: Charles Bukowski (1920 – 1994)

Eric Hoffer in 1967, in the Oval Office, visiting President Lyndon Baines Johnson

Above: Eric Hoffer (1898 – 1983)

But there is the Internet – a potential tool I have yet to master.

Visualization of Internet routing paths

Above: Visualization of Internet routing paths

Today, hardly anyone knows the poet Olga Diener.

It almost seems as if her existence was as unreal as the tone of her poems.

She was once a very real phenomenon on Lake Constance where she had her permanent residence during the 1930s.

She had an exchange of letters with Hermann Hesse.

The poets Hans Reinhart and Emanuel von Bodman were among the guests at her annual anniversary celebrations (4 January) by candlelight.

Pin by Rine Ling on bokeh art photography | Candles photography ...

Otherwise she avoided the company of people with their too many disappointments and losses.

Her house “Belrepeire“, which she had planned herself, was a little bit away from the village.

Belrepeire” is the name of a city in Wolfram von Eschenbach’s poem “Parzival“.

Above: Statue of Wolfram von Eschenbach (1160 – 1220), Abenburg Castle, Bavaria, Germany

The poet was under the spell of the Grail myth.

Above: The Holy Grail depicted on a stained glass window at Quimper Cathedral, France

Olga found in the silence of her seclusion, the voice of her poems, which bore fairytale titles like “The Golden Castle” or “The White Deer“.

In this mystery game, a character named Blaniseflur sings the verses:

All the gardens have woken up. 

Dew fell from the stars and

Venus Maria walked through them with her light feet. 

Now flowers breathe the sky

And the Earth fulfills the dream

Received from spring night.

How a blackbird sings! 

The longing carries the swans

Swinging across the lake. 

The sun rises red from the water.

Light is everything.

Sunrise on the Lake Constance | Bodensee, in German. Konstan… | Flickr

The images Olga saw on long walks on the shores of the Lake, as she would have said, condensed into dreamlike structures, the form of which was often difficult to understand.

Even Hans Rheinhart, who made the only attempt for decades to critically appreciate Olga in the Bodenseebuch (the Book of Lake Constance) in 1935, did not understand her “private secret language“.

jahrgaenge 1935 - ZVAB

Olga was actually a musician.

For her there was no creative difference between writing and composing.

How musical her language was can immediately be heard when her poetry is read out loud.

Her words are full of sound relationships far beyond the usual measure, which Hesse described:

In your newer verses there is often such a beautiful sound.”

Music notes set musical note treble clef Vector Image

Olga wrote notes like other people speak words.

In the guestbook of Julie and Jakobus Weidenmann, she immortalized herself with a song instead of verses.

She was often a guest at the Weidenmanns.

Julie shared Olga’s natural mystical worldview, which was coloured Christian, while Olga tended to esotericism.

Julie’s first volume of poems is entitled Tree Songs, while Olga wrote a cycle called Rose Songs in Altnau.

Jakobus Weidenmann – Personenlexikon BL

Above: Jakobus and Julie Weidenmann

The seventh poem of Olga’s cycle contains her lyrical confession:

Leave me in the innermost garden

Faithfully my roses wait:

Fertilize, cut, bind,

Cut hands from thorns.

The blooming light, awake moonlight

Enter the flower goblets.

The winds pull gently over it,

And rain roars in some nights.

I am earthbound like her

And once again disappeared.

Unlike Olga, Golo Mann (1909 – 1994) was anything but a mystic.

As the son of Thomas Mann, Golo belonged to one of the most famous literary families in the world.

Not only his father, but also his uncle Heinrich and his siblings Erika, Klaus, Monika, Elisabeth and Michael worked as writers.

Writing was in Golo’s blood.

Above: Golo Mann (1909 – 1994)

This does not mean that writing was always easy for him.

On the contrary, like all of Thomas Mann’s children, Golo was overshadowed by his father and did not feel privileged to be the son of a Nobel laureate in literature.

Golo saw himself primarily as a historian and thus distinguished himself from the novelist who was his father.

Above: Thomas Mann (1875 – 1955)

Nevertheless, Golo used a thoroughly literary approach to history.

Two of his books are titled History and Stories and Historiography as Literature.

The fact that Golo cultivated a narrative style that earned him condescending reviews and the derisive ridicule of fellow historians, but this did not stop the general public from enthusiastically reading his books.

Deutsche Geschichte des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts - Golo Mann ...

Golo Mann’s first bestseller was largely created in Thurgau.

Again and again Golo retired to Altnau for several weeks in the Zur Krone Inn, for the first time in summer 1949.

His memories of Lake Constance were published in 1984 in the anthology Mein Bodensee: Liebeserklärung an eine Landschaft (My Lake Constance: Declaration of Love for a Landscape), under the title “Mit wehmütigen Vergnügen” (with wistful pleasure).

There he writes about the Krone:

There was an inn on the ground floor, the owner’s family had set up an apartment on the first floor, and on the second floor a few small rooms connected by a forecourt were available to friends of the Pfisters, the bookseller Emil Oprecht and his wife Emmi.

Thanks to my friend Emmi, they became my asylum, my work and retirement home.

Emmi and Emil Oprecht belonged to the circle of friends of Julie and Jakobus Weidenmann in Kesswil.

The Oprecht home in Zürich was a meeting point for all opponents of the Hitler regime during the war.

Ziviler Ungehorsam gegen Hitler: Wie Emil und Emmie Oprecht auch ...

Above: Emil and Emmi Oprecht

Europa Verlag (Europa Publishing) was committed to the same democratic and social spirit as that of the Weidenmann guests in the 1920s, including Golo’s siblings Erika and Klaus.

Above: Erika Mann (1905 – 1969) and Klaus Mann (1906 – 1949)

Golo’s father was good friends with Emil Oprecht and published the magazine Mass und Wert (Measure and Value) together with Konrad Falke (1880 – 1942).

It is ultimately thanks to these diverse relationships that Golo Mann put his Deutsche Geschichte des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts (German History of the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries) in paper in 1956 and 1957, primarily in Altnau.

The success of this book made it possible for Golo Mann, who had gone into American exile like his father, to finally return to Europe.

It looked like nothing stood in the way of his academic career.

When his appointment to the University of Frankfurt did not come about, Golo retired from teaching and lived from then on a freelance writer in his parents’ home in Kilchberg on Lake Zürich and in Berzona in Canton Ticino, where fellow writers Alfred Andersch (1914 – 1980) and Max Frisch were his neighbours.

Above: Max Frisch (1911 – 1981)

In Kilchberg, Berzona, and again in Altnau, Golo wrote his opus magnum, Wallenstein – Sein Leben erzählt von Golo Mann (Wallenstein: His Life Told by Golo Mann).

Telling history was completely frowned upon by academic historians in 1971, the year this monumental biography was published, but Golo didn’t care nor did the thousands of his readers.

Wallenstein“ (Golo Mann) – Buch gebraucht kaufen – A02lgtja01ZZ4

Despite hostility from university critics, Golo was awarded two honorary doctorates, in France and England, but not in the German-speaking world.

In addition, he was awarded a number of literary prizes for his books: the Schiller Prize, the Lessner Ring, the Georg Büchner Prize, the Goethe Prize and the Bodensee Literature Prize.

Große Kreisstadt Überlingen: Bodensee-Literaturpreis

The last will have particularly pleased him, because the Lake smiled at the beginning of his literary fame.

(For more on the entire Thomas Mann family, please see Canada Slim and the Family of Mann in my other blog, The Chronicles of Canada Slimhttps://canadaslim.wordpress.com)

The Lake seemed to be smiling at the beginning of our journey as we left Highway #13 in the direction of Sommeri.

Summery Sommeri Summary

The word ‘plague’ had just been uttered for the first time….

Everybody knows that pestilences have a way of recurring in the world.

Yet somehow we find it hard to believe in ones that crash down on our heads from a blue sky.

There have been as many plagues as wars in history.

Yet always plagues and wars take people equally by surprise.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

Above: The plague, Marseille, France, 1720, Michel Serré

Sommeri (population: 591) is first mentioned in 905 as Sumbrinaro.

Between 1474 and 1798, the villages of Niedersommeri and Obersommeri formed a court of the PrinceAbbot of St. Gall.

In 1474 the Church of St. Mauritius was dedicated.

It was renovated to its current appearance in the first half of the 15th century.

After the Protestant Reformation reached Sommeri in 1528, the church became a shared church for both faiths in 1534.

Originally the major economic activities in Sommeri were predominantly grain production and forestry.

Wappen von Sommeri

Above: Coat-of-arms of Sommeri

It was nearly obliterated by the Black Death in 1629.

In the second half of the 19th century, fruit production, hay production, cattle and dairy farming were added.

A cheese factory was opened in 1852.

In the last third of the 20th century, some industrial plants moved into the villages, especially embroidery and furniture manufacturing.

At the beginning of the 21st century there were companies in the HVAC industry, precision engineering and manufacturing school furniture in Sommeri.

Sommeri

Above: Sommeri, Canton Thurgau, Switzerland

To be frank, there is no reason to linger in Sommeri, except to say that it was the birthplace of the writer Maria Dutli-Rutlishauser (1903 – 1995) of whom I have previously written.

Alt- Steckborn

Above: Maria Dutli-Rutlishauser

(For more on Maria, please see Canada Slim and the Immunity Wall of this blog.)

Onwards.

From Sommeri, Google Maps leads her hapless wanderers onwards to Langrickenbach.

Google Maps Logo.svg

Query:

How contrive not to waste time?

Answer:

By being fully aware of it all the while.

Ways in which this can be done:

By spending one’s days on an uneasy chair in a dentist’s waiting room, by remaining on one’s balcony all Sunday afternoon, by listening to lectures in a language one doesn’t know, by travelling by the longest and least convenient train routes, and, of course, standing all the way, by queuing at the box office of theatres and then not booking a seat. 

And so forth.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

Longing for Langrickenbach

Langrickenbach (population: 1,291) was first mentioned in 889 as “Rihchinbahc“.

It is a place for crops and fruit, cattle breeding and dairy farming, general goods, timber and cattle trading.

Again, not much to see.

Hit the road.

Above: Langrickenbach, Canton Thurgau

Watching cows and calves playing, grooming one another or being assertive, takes on a whole new dimension if you know that those taking part are siblings, cousins, friends or sworn enemies.

If you know animals as individuals you notice how often older brothers are kind to younger ones, how sisters seek or avoid each other’s company, and which families always get together at night to sleep and which never do so.

Cows are as varied as people.

They can be highly intelligent or slow to understand, friendly, considerate, aggressive, docile, inventive, dull, proud or shy.

All these characteristics are present in a large enough herd.”

(Rosamund Young, The Secret Life of Cows)

The Secret Life of Cows: Amazon.co.uk: Young, Rosamund ...

The Birwinken Bulletin

Makes me think of Bullwinkle, the cartoon moose and his squirrel friend Rocky.

No moose or squirrels spotted.

Above from left to right: Rocky, Bullwinkle, and Captain Peter “Wrongway” Peachfuzz

Birwinken (population: 1,319) was first mentioned in 822 as “Wirinchova“.

In the 19th century, the village economy added animal husbandry….

Cattle feedlot

(My wife is an animal?)

….to the traditional agriculture and fruit growing.

In 1878, a weaving firm and three embroidery factories provided 165 jobs.

However the decline of the textile industry in the 20th century and the village’s remoteness from Anywhere led to high levels of emigration.

As a result, the village never developed much industry and has remained a farmer’s hamlet.

In 1990, for example, 63% of the population worked in agriculture.

Birwinken

Above: Birwinken, Canton Thurgau

It was only a matter of lucidly recognizing what had to be recognized, of dispelling extraneous shadows and doing what needed to be done….

There lay certitude.

There, in the daily round.

All the rest hung on mere threads and trivial contingencies.

You couldn’t waste your time on it.

The thing was to do your job as it should be done.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

The Doctor Luke Fildes crop.jpg

Above: The Doctor, Luke Fildes, 1891

What is an extremely interesting product of the village is native son Stefan Keller (b. 1958), a writer, journalist and historian.

Rotpunktverlag

Above: Stefan Keller

Keller is best known for:

  • Die Rückkehr: Joseph Springs Geschichte (The Return: Joseph Spring’s Story)

The Berlin youth Joseph Sprung was chased through half of Europe by the Nazis.

He lived in Brussels, Montpellier and Bordeaux with false papers and worked as an interpreter without being recognized.

He survived invasions and rail disasters, but never kissed a girl when he fell into the hands of the Swiss border authorities in November 1943.

At the age of 16, the fugitive was handed over to the Gestapo by the Swiss border guards and denounced as a Jew.

He was transferred to the Auschwitz concentration camp via the Drancy collective warehouse near Paris.

Sixty years later, Joseph Sprung returned to Switzerland.

Today his name is Joseph Spring, he lives in Australia and demands the justice he deserves.

He accused the Swiss government of aiding and abetting genocide.

In a sensational trial, the Swiss federal court decided in 2000 that the extradition of a Jewish youth to the National Socialists can no longer be judged.

Joseph Spring had at least asked for symbolic reparation.

In November 2003, he returned to Switzerland to tell his story:

The story of a survivor who sued an entire country, went through a process to demand justice, lost it, and still has the last word.

Die Rückkehr: Joseph Springs Geschichte (Hörbuch-Download): Amazon ...

  • Die Zeit der Fabriken (The Age of Factories)

The worker Emil Baumann was already dead when his former superior Hippolyt Saurer died unexpectedly.

The whole of Arbon mourned the truck manufacturer Saurer.

At that time, almost all of Arbon mourned Baumann, for whom the workers in Saurer’s factory were responsible for his death.

Emil Baumann died shortly after an argument with his boss Saurer.

It is 1935 when everything starts with two deaths.

The young lathe operator Emil Baumann dies from suicide because his master harasses him and because he cannot cope with the new working conditions.

The college immediately went on strike.

Then the entrepreneur and engineer Hippolyt Saurer dies.

He choked on his own blood after an tonsil operation.

Based on the death of these two men, Stefan Keller tells the story of a small town in eastern Switzerland, its conflicts, triumphs and defeats.

The city of Arbon on the Swiss shore of Lake Constance is ruled by the “Reds” (by the Social Democrats, the left).

The Adolph Saurer AG factory was and still is legendary for its (military) trucks.

Above: Memorial to Franz, Adolph und Hippolyt Saurer, Arbon

Arbon is an example of many places in Switzerland:

The time of the factories is also a history of the Swiss industry and workers’ movement.

Starting with the motor carriages of the Wilhelminian era to the Saurer gasification trucks of the National Socialists, from the big strikes after 1918 to the dismantling of almost all jobs in the 1990s and from the resistance of an editor against censors in the Second World War to the union’s «fight against» against foreign colleagues.

Die Zeit der Fabriken: Amazon.de: Stefan Keller: Bücher

  • Grüningers Fall (The Grüninger Case)

A historical report about the St. Gallen police captain Paul Grüninger, who in the 1930s, according to his conscience and not in accordance with the law, saved the lives of numerous Jews.

The facts:

In 1938/1939, Grüninger saved the lives of hundreds, if not thousands, of Austrian, Jewish refugees by providing them with the wrong papers and thus enabling them to enter Switzerland legally.

He was suspended from duty due to breach of official duties and falsification of documents.

He was severely fined for his conduct and sentenced to prison.

The book aims to make it clear that today it was not Grüninger who would have to sit on the dock, but the inhumane refugee policy of the Swiss government during the Nazi era.

The book was made into a film in 1997 based on a screenplay by Stefan Keller and directed by Richard Dindo with Keller’s expert advice.

Grüningers Fall

  • Maria Theresia Wilhelm: Spurlos verschwunden (Maria Theresia Wilhelm: Disappeared without a trace)

In the mid-1930s Maria Theresia Wilhelm met the Swiss mountain farmer and gamekeeper Ulrich Gantenbein, who subsequently left his first wife.

From the beginning Maria and Ulrich’s marriage suffered from official regulations.

Ulrich is admitted to a psychiatric clinic shortly after their marriage.

Maria is barely tolerated by the neighbourhood.

Eventually she too comes to a psychiatric clinic and there experiences inhumane therapy methods from today’s perspective.

Her seven children are torn away, placed in orphanages and put to work.

Maria is finally released in June 1960.

On the way to buy shoes, she disappears without a trace….

Maria Theresia Wilhelm - spurlos verschwunden - Stefan Keller ...

Rieux asked Grand if he was doing extra work for the Municipality.

Grand said No.

He was working on his own account.

“Really?”, Rieux said, to keep the conversation going.

“And are you getting on well with it?”

“Considering I’ve been at it for years, it would be surprising if I wasn’t.

Though, in one sense, there hasn’t been much progress.”

“May one know” – the doctor halted – “what it is that you’re engaged on?”

Grand put a hand up to his hat and tugged it down upon his big, protruding ears, then murmured some half-inaudible remark from which Rieux seemed to gather that Grand’s work was connected with “the growth of a personality”.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

Bürglen Bound

Next town Google leads us to is Bürglen (population: 3,841), first mentioned in 1282 as “Burgelon“.

Even though the village was fortified around 1300, it was never considered a city, due to the decline of its owner, the Baron of Sax-Hohensax, and from other neighbouring villages.

After the disastrous fire of 1528, the villagers went into debt for the reconstruction of Bürglen.

To help pay off their debt, in 1540 they granted the nobility rights to St. Gallen.

Under St. Gallen, Bürglen lost most of its autonomy.

St. Gallen appointed the bailiff and the chairman of the Lower Court, promoted the settlement of its citizens to form a local elite and change the succession order of inheritances.

Despite this, the local farmers enjoyed a certain independence.

In the 17th century, they promoted the expansion of the Castle as well as the creation of new businesses.

This relative prosperity was followed in the 18th century by a government practice that hindered the formation of viable village government and led to general impoverishment.

Reformierte Kirche und Schloss Bürglen

Above: Bürglen, Canton Thurgau

Power mattered more than people.

A problem eternal and universal.

Worth seeing is the Bürgeln Castle, the old quarter and the Reformed Church.

Above: Bürglen Castle

Of notable personalities connected to Bürgeln, it was home to artists Gottlieb Bion (1804 – 1876), Fritz Gilsi (1878 – 1961) and Jacques Schedler (1927 – 1989) as well as the writer Elisabeth Binder (b. 1951).

I haven’t read Ms. Binder’s work as yet, but the titles sound appealing…..

  • Der Nachtblaue (The Night Blue)
  • Sommergeschicht (Summer Story)
  • Orfeo
  • Der Wintergast (The Winter Guest)
  • Ein kleiner und kleiner werdender Reiter: Spurren einer Kindheit (A rider getting smaller and smaller: Traces of a childhood)

Above: Elisabeth Binder

Ever south and east the long and winding road continues….

The long and winding road.png

Cottard was a silent, secretive man, with something about him that made Grand think of a wild boar.

His bedroom, meals at a cheap restaurant, some rather mysterious comings and goings . these were the sum of Cottard’s days.

He described himself as a traveller in wines and spirits.

Now and again he was visited by two or three men, presumably customers.

Sometimes in the evening he would go to a cinema across the way.

In this connection Grand mentioned a detail he had noticed – that Cottard seemed to have a preference for gangster films.

But the thing that had struck him most about the man was his aloofness, not to say his mistrust of everyone he met.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

Nighthawks by Edward Hopper 1942.jpg

Above: Nighthawks, Edward Hopper, 1942

Few Words for Wuppenau

Wuppenau (population: 1,111) was first mentioned in 820 as “Wabbinauwa” and is primarily an agricultural community.

Wuppenau

Above: Wuppenau, Canton Thurgau

(It is funny how so many of the original names seem similar to those of the Original Peoples of the Americas.

Or akin to something Elmer Fudd might say about wascally wabbits.)

ElmerFudd.gif

….and that’s all I have to say about that.

Film poster with a white background and a park bench (facing away from the viewer) near the bottom. A man wearing a white suit is sitting on the right side of the bench and is looking to his left while resting his hands on both sides of him on the bench. A suitcase is sitting on the ground, and the man is wearing tennis shoes. At the top left of the image is the film's tagline and title and at the bottom is the release date and production credits.

We are now in Canton St. Gallen and the city of Wil (pronounced “ville”).

Wappen von Wil

Above: Coat of arms of Wil, Canton St. Gallen

The Word Pump and the Swan Song of Wil

“I have the same idea with all my books: an attempt to come close to the core of reality, the structure of reality, as opposed to the merely superficial. 

The realistic novel is remote from art. 

A novel should heighten life, should give one an illuminating experience. 

It shouldn’t set out what you know already. 

I just muddle away at it. 

One gets flashes here and there, which help. 

I am not a philosopher or an intellectual. 

Practically anything I have done of any worth I feel I have done through my intuition, not my mind.”  (Patrick White)

There are times in a man’s life when he simply must ask for assistance and my trying to convey to you an accurate mental image of Wil may require the services of an expert.

Above: Wil Castle

Ask Fred.

Fred Mast, excuse me, Professor Dr. Mast.

Born and raised in Wil, Fred is a full professor at the University of Bern, specialized in mental imagery, sensory motor processing and visual perception.

Perhaps he is one of the few folks who can truly answer the question:

Do you see what I see?

Über uns: Prof. Dr. Fred Mast - Kognitive Psychologie, Wahrnehmung ...

Above: Dr. Fred Mast

I mean, Fred should know, he has been educated and worked at universities esteemable, such as Zürich, the Federal Institute of Technology (ETHZ)(Switzerland’s equivalent to MIT), Harvard, MIT, Lausanne and Bern.

Some of his published papers suggest he does know what he is talking about:

  • Visual mental imagery interferes with allocentric orientation judgments
  • Visual mental images can be ambiguous
  • Mental images: always present, never there

Black Mamba oder die Macht der Imagination: Wie unser Gehirn die ...

Thanks, Dr. Fred, for demystifying the fuzzification.

Let me say for the record that as a place to visit I have always liked Wil….

But as a place to work….not as much.

Wil (population: 23,955), today the 3rd biggest city in Canton St. Gallen, was founded around 1200 and was handed over by the Counts of Toggenburg to the Abbey of St. Gallen in 1226.

(Look, Ma!  Look at what I founded!)

Disputes between the Abbey and Habsburg King Rudolf I (1218 – 1291) led to the destruction of Wil in 1292.

(If Rudolf couldn’t have Wil, then no one will?)

Above: Statue of Rudolf I, Speyer Cathederal, Germany

Wil was again besieged in the Old Zürich War in 1445 and yet again in the Toggenburg War in 1712.

On 1 January 2013, Susanne Hartmann became the first female mayor, not only of Wil-Bronschhofen, but in the entire canton of St. Gallen.

Hartmann announced her candidacy in April 2012.

Despite all forecasts the result of the elections was a landslide victory for Susanne Hartmann.

Despite (or perhaps because) the bus being driven by a woman, Will carries on.

Susanne Hartmann :: CVP Kanton St. Gallen

Above: Her Honour Wil Mayor Susanne Hartmann

In addition to many small and medium-sized enterprises, Wil is also home to a number of large, some international, industrial firms, including Stihl, Larag, Camion Transport, Brändle, Heimgartner Fahnen, Schmolz & Bickenbach, Kindlemann….

So it stands to reason that a city of industry may attract schools to teach those in these industries.

Such was the Wil school (now defunct) where I taught.

It was, what we in the business of freelance teaching refer to as a “cowboy school“, an institution more interested in the school’s acquisition of money than in the students’ acquisition of an education.

It was one of those schools where parents sent their children who lacked either the capacity or the desire to learn.

A paid education in all senses of the word.

It was a nightmare to teach there.

Blackboard Jungle (1955 poster).jpg

The students, best defined as juvenile deliquents or little criminal bastards, would not do their assignments, stay off their damn phones, bring their textbooks to class, listen in class or stop talking to one another.

The worst of them brought out the worst in me, so it was to everyone’s mutual relief when we parted company.

Above: Student – Teacher Monument, Rostock, Germany

As for the city of Wil itself, putting aside my feelings towards my ex-employer now extinct, there is much that is positive to relate.

Wil is considered to be the best preserved city in Eastern Switzerland and best seen from afar standing atop the Stadtweiher (a hill with a pond overlooking Wil) overlooking the silhouette of the old quarter.

The pedestrian promenade from Schwanenkreisel (Swan Circle) towards the old quarter is the place where most of the shops are, including a farmer’s market every Saturday.

On 8 July 2006, the 37-metre high Wiler Tower was inaugurated on the Hofberg (the mountain above Wil).

It is a wooden structure with a double spiral staircase and three X supports.

It is worth the climb for the view, if not for the exercise.

Around 180 kilometres of hiking trails are signposted around Wil.

The almost 33 kilometres long Wilerrundweg (Wil Circle Path)….

(Safer than a cycle path?)

….was established in 2013.

Kussbänkli: Kantonsrat Sennhauser hat es hergestellt – und ...

Above: The Kissing Bench

The 87-kilometre Toggenburger Höhenweg (high road) starts in Wil and leads to Wildhaus via Mühlrüti, Atzmännig and Arvenbüel.

Toggenburger Höhenweg - Ferienregion Toggenburg - Ostschweiz

The Thurweg passes near Wil at Schwarzenbach (black creek), following the Thur River from Wildhaus to Rüdlingen where it meets the Rhine River in Canton Schaffhausen.

Thurweg von Stein nach Ebnat- Kappel - MeinToggenburg.ch

Worth seeing in Wil are the Maria Hilf Wallfahrtskirche (Mary of Charity Pilgrim Church), the Abbey Castle, the St. Katarina Dominican and the Capuchin Cloisters, the Courthouse, Ruddenzburg (Ruddenz Castle), St. Niklaus and St. Peter Catholic Churches, the old Guardhouse, the City Archive, the Schnetztor gate, the City Museum (open on weekends from 2 to 5 pm), the psychiatric clinic (ask, in vain, for Dr. Fred) and the former Hurlimann tractor factory.

Wil has the Challer Theatre, the Kunsthalle (art hall), the Tonhalle (concert hall) and the Remise (for more modern music), but excepting these cultural remnants the young generally don’t party here if they can get away to Zürich.

The room was in almost complete darkness.

Outside, the street was growing noisier and a sort of murmur of relief greeted the moment when all the street lamps lit up, all together.

Rieux went out on to the balcony and Cottard followed him.

From the outlying districts – as happens every evening in our town – a gentle breeze wafted a murmur of voices, smells of roasting meat, a gay perfumed tide of freedom sounding on its ways, as the streets filled up with noisy young people released from shops and offices.

Nightfall with its deep remote baying of unseen ships, the rumour rising from the sea and the happy tumult of the crowd – that first hour of darkness which in the past had always had a special charm for Rieux – seemed today charged with menace, because of all he knew.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

Mediterranean side – Oran

Above: Oran, Algeria

Of the many famous people native to Wil, noteworthy (by Swiss standards) are the filmmaker Max Peter Ammann (b. 1929) and the TV star Kurt Felix (1941 – 2012).

LESE-THEATER-STÜCK VON MAX PETER AMMANN IM HOF ZU WIL – wil24.ch

Above: Max Peter Ammann

Kurt Felix

Above: “When I must go, I will leave a happy man.

Daniel Imhof (b. 1977), the Swiss son of a Smithers (British Columbia) bush pilot, is a retired footballer from Canada’s national soccer team and now resides in Wil.

Canada Soccer

I think to myself:

I have finally gotten so impossible and unpleasant that they will really have to do something to make me better….

They have no idea what a bottomless pit of misery I am….

They do not know that this is not some practice fire drill meant to prepare them for the real inferno, because the real thing is happening right now.

All the bells say:

Too late.

It’s much too late and I’m so sure that they are still not listening.

(Elizabeth Wurtzel, Prozac Nation)

ProzacNationBook.jpg

Of human interest is the story of Wil native, the opera singer Anna Sutter (1871 – 1910).

Her brief affair with royal Württemberg court conductor Aloys Obrist proved to be fatal.

After she ended their two-year relationship in 1909, Obrist entered her Stuttgart apartment on 29 June 1910 and killed her with two pistol shots before taking his own life.

Sadly, Anna is best remembered for how she died than for how she lived.

Cows are individuals, as are sheep, pigs and hens, and, I dare say, all the creatures on the planet however unnoticed, unstudied or unsung.

Certainly, few would dispute that this is true of cats and dogs and horses.

When we have had occasion to treat a farm animal as a pet, because of illness, accident or bereavement, it has exhibited great intelligence, a huge capacity for affection and an ability to fit in with an unusual routine.

Perhaps everything boils down to the amount of time spent with any one animal – and perhaps that is true of humans too.

(Rosamund Young, The Secret Life of Cows)

CH cow 2 cropped.jpg

Also worth mentioning is the writer René Oberholzer (b. 1963), who has been teaching in Wil (in a non-cowboy school it is hoped) since 1987.

He began writing poetry in 1986 and prose in 1991.

(I must confess my rural roots and prejudices appear when I find myself asking:

Do real men write (or even read) poetry?

I believe they do, but whether the fine folks in Argenteuil County in Canada feel that way is debatable.)

Shakespeare.jpg

Above: William Shakespeare (1564 – 1616)

Oberholzer founded the Höhenhöhe (higher heights) writers group in 1991.

As founding can be addictive, the following year he then founded the literary experimental group Die Wortpumpe (the Word Pump) together with his colleagues (co-conspirators?) Aglaja Veteranyi and Gabriele Leist.

He is a member of several author associations.

His work has been mainly published in anthologies, literary and online magazines.

He is best known for:

  • Wenn sein Herz nicht mehr geht, dann repariert man es und gibt es den Kühen weiter: 39 schwarze Geschichten (When his heart stops beating, repair it and give it to the cows: 39 dark tales)
  • Ich drehe den Hals um – Gedichte (I turn my stiff neck: Poems)
  • Die Liebe würde an einem Dienstag erfunden (Love was invented on a Tuesday)
  • Kein Grund zur Beunruhigung – Geschichten (No reason to panic: Stories)

Die Liebe wurde an einem Dienstag erfunden: 120 Geschichten | René ...

As my wife and I are married (no reason to panic) and it was a Thursday (as love only visits Wil on Tuesdays), we faithfully follow fatalistic Google Maps, and continue on to….

Why is it that one can look at a lion or a planet or an owl or at someone’s finger as long as one pleases, but looking into the eyes of another person is, if prolonged past a second, a perilous affair?

(Walker Percy)

Percy in 1987

Above: Walker Percy (1916 – 1990)

Restful Rickenbach

Rickenbach (population: 2,774), first mentioned in 754 as “Richinbach“.

After the end of the crop rotation system in the 19th century livestock and dairy farming became the major sources of income.

A mill, built in the 13th century, was expanded in 1919 to become Eberle Mills, which operated until 2000.

The Eschmann Bell Foundry existed until 1972.

After the construction of the A1 motorway and the growth of Wil, by 1990 the population of Rickenbach had doubled.

Langrickenbach

Above: Rickenbach

A bridged Lütisburg

When a war breaks out people say:

It’s too stupid.  It can’t last long.”

But though a war may well be ‘too stupid’, that doesn’t prevent its lasting.

Stupidity has a knack of getting its way.

As we should see if we were not always so much wrapped in ourselves.

In this respect our townsfolk were like everybody else, wrapped up in themselves.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

Duns cup helps with concentration

Lütisburg (population: 1,576), though smaller than Rickenbach, is far more interesting to the casual visitor.

It is first mentioned on 1214 as “Luitinsburch“.

Wappen von Lütisburg

Above: Lütisburg coat of arms

The Castle, built in 1078 by the Abbey of St. Gallen, was abandoned by the Abbey a short time later, but due to the Castle’s strategically important location, it became the headquarters of the Counts of Toggenburg from the 13th to the 15th centuries.

After the Abbey acquired the County of Toggenburg in 1468, the Castle served as a bailiwick.

In the 19th century, alongside agriculture, ironworks, copper hammering and manufacturing dominated.

The train station has existed since 1870.

Above: Lütisburg, 1700

Lütisburg’s townscape is characterized by bridges and footbridges, including the Letzi Bridge (1853), the Guggenloch Railway Viaduct (1870) and the “new” Thur Bridge (1997).

The covered wooden bridge (1790) over the Thur River, on the cantonal road to Flawil, was used for car traffic until 1997.

Upon the wooden Letzi Bridge, the hiking trail to Ganterschwil crosses the Neckar River.

The nearby hamlet of Winzenburg with its Winzenberger Höhe (heights) (836 m) is a popular destination with local lovers of landscape.

B&B Winzenberg (Schweiz Lütisburg) - Booking.com

Lütisburg’s claim to fame, beside its bridges, lies with the two brothers Germann….

War of any kind is abhorrent. 

Remember that since the end of World War II, over 40 million people have been killed by conventional weapons. 

So, if we should succeed in averting nuclear war, we must not let ourselves be sold the alternative of conventional weapons for killing our fellow man. 

We must cure ourselves of the habit of war.

(Patrick White)

Modern warfare: Into the Jaws of Death, 1944

Kilian Germann (1485 – 1530) was the son of Johannes Germann, the Chief bailiff of Lütisburg, and brother of the mercenary leader (and later bailiff) Hans Germann (also known as the Batzenhammer) and Gallus Germann (also chief bailiff of Lütisburg).

Kilian was governor in Roschach (1523 – 1528) and in Wil (1528 -1529).

In 1529, Kilian was elected to be the next Prince-Abbot of St. Gallen in Rapperswil.

After his confirmation by Pope Clement VII (1478 – 1534), Kilian was also proposed for this position to Emperor Charles V (1500 – 1558) who confirmed him in February 1530.

Above: Coat of arms of Kilian Germann

But life often thwarts the best-laid plans….

What I am interested in is the relationship between the blundering human being and God.

I belong to no church, but I have a religious faith.

It is an attempt to express that, among other things, that I try to do.

Whether he confesses to being religious or not, everyone has a religious faith of a kind.

I myself am a blundering human being with a belief in God who made us and we got out of hand, a kind of Frankenstein monster.

Everyone can make mistakes, including God.

I believe that God does intervene.

I think there is a Divine Power, a Creator, who has an influence on human beings if they are willing to be open to Him.

(Patrick White)

Michelangelo - Creation of Adam (cropped).jpg

Above: Creation of Adam, Michelangelo, Sistine Chapel, Vatican City

Prince-Abbot Kilian fled to Meersburg (on the German side of Lake Constance) in 1529 after the outbreak of the First Kappel War.

From February 1530, Kilian lived at Wolfurt Castle near Bregenz (on the Austrian part of Lake Constance).

Above: Wolfurt Castle

In exile, Kilian nonetheless cultivated his social network with the southern German nobility in order to secure political pressure on the reformed movement on the Prince-Abbot’s lands, which did not escape the attention of his enemy, the reformer Vadian.

Above: Vadian statue, St. Gallen

In 1530, Kilian represented the Abbey of St. Gallen at the Council of Basel.

In July, he visited the Augsburg Reichstag (government).

It looked like Kilian’s fading star was beginning to shine once more.

That same year of his visits to Basel and Augsburg, returning to Bregenz after a visit to the Earl of Montfort, Kilian drowned when his horse fell into the Bregenz Ach (stream).

He was buried in the Mehrerau Monastery near Bregenz.

Abtei Mehrerau – Blick vom Gebhardsberg

Discipline is the soul of an army.

It makes small numbers formidable, procures success to the weak and success to all.

(George Washington)

Gilbert Stuart Williamstown Portrait of George Washington.jpg

Above: George Washington (1730 – 1799)

Hans Germann (1500 – 1550), Kilian’s younger brother, was an officer in the service of the French Crown for many years.

After returning home, Hans supported his brother Kilian during the turmoil of the Reformation.

Contemporaries described Hans as “a firm, brave, but rough, frivolous journeyman, who had sold many of his fellow countrymen to France for boring gold.”

Above: Coat of arms of Captain Hans Germann, Kreuzenstein Castle, Austria

I guess we find both sinners and saints in every family and in every community.

The socially disadvantaged of Ganterschwil

In my books I have lifted bits from various religions in trying to come to a better understanding.

I have made use of religious themes and symbols.

Now, as the world becomes more pagan, one has to lead people in the same direction in a different way.

(Patrick White)

Down the road (so to speak) is the village of Ganterschwil (population: 1,186).

It is first mentioned in 779 as “Cantrichesuilare“.

(Try saying that five times fast….)

Pfarrkirche von Ganterschwil

Above:  Parish church, Ganterschwil, Canton St. Gallen

Grain and oats were grown and processed in three mills here.

From the 18th century, contract weaving became important.

Small textile factories developed from family businesses.

In the 19th century, the livestock and dairy indutries replaced grain cultivation.

After the crash in the textile industry in 1918, only smaller companies could be built.

In 2000, around half of the working population was employed in the service sector.

Wappen von Ganterschwil

Above: Coat of arms of Ganterschwil

The Home for Socially Disadvantaged Children, founded in 1913 by Reformer Pastor Alfred Lauchener, developed into the Centre for Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Sonnenhof.

Klinik Sonnenhof Ganterschwil

Above: Centre for Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Sonnenhof, Ganterschwil

In Ganterschwil, there are many small businesses that offer jobs.

The best-known is the Berlinger Company, which was active in tape production.

Today it plays a leading role in the production of doping control systems, in the form of counterfeit-proof sample glasses.

Temperature Monitoring / Doping Control Equipment- Berlinger & Co. AG

In the parish church there are frescoes from the Middle Ages discovered and restored in 1941 and now under the protection of the Swiss Confederation.

Ganterschwil is a place difficult to define.

Is it the past?

The future?

What is it now?

The Beautiful Minds of Lichtensteig

Lichtensteig (population: 1,870) is first mentioned in 1228 and was founded by the Counts of Toggenburg as “Liehtunsteige“.

A market is mentioned in 1374 and the right to hold markets was confirmed in 1400.

A letter of privileges issued by the Lords of Raron (1439) confirms the existence of 12 burghers and the appointment of judges by the burghers and the Lords.

After the acquisition of the Toggenburg by St. Gallen Abbey in 1468, Lichtensteig became the seat of the Abbot’s reeve.

The council declared Lichtensteig’s support for the Reformation in 1528.

The sole church at this time was shared by both Reformed and Catholic believers, while their schools were kept separate until 1868.

Lichtensteig’s importance as a market town increased in the 19th century with the development of the textile home working industry in the Toggenburg.

In the early 20th century, there were six yearly markets and a weekly livestock market.

Lichtensteig’s connection to the railroad dates to 1870.

Lichtensteig

Above: Lichtensteig, Canton St. Gallen

I don’t quite know how to say this politely, so I will say it directly.

It seems the further south one travels in Deutschschweiz, the smarter people seem to be.

Thurgau is blood, sweat, tears and toil.

Thurgau is always in the middle of things, between two places but belonging to neither.

Wars of religion and between nations have been fought here for centuries.

Tourists do not linger in Thurgau but traverse it en route to places deemed more interesting.

This is farm country, a land of labour and pragmatism, where poets party in private homes but never parade themselves in political protest processions.

Coat of arms of Kanton Thurgau

Above: Coat of arms of Canton Thurgau

St. Gallen, both city and canton especially the City itself, bears the scent of incense, the stains on a faithful shroud, the remnants of religious rule.

Coat of arms of Kanton St. Gallen

Above: Coat of arms of Canton St. Gallen

St. Gallen is reminiscent of (Giovanni Bocaccio’s Decameron) Ceppello of Prato, who after a lifetime of evil, hoodwinks a holy friar with a deathbed confession and comes to be venerated as St. Ciappelletto, except in reverse with the holy friar hoodwinking the world into venerating it as holier than it could have been.

Decameron, The (unabridged) – Naxos AudioBooks

Granted that the St. Gallen Abbey Library is truly worthy of its UNESCO designation as “an outstanding example of a large Carolingian monastery and was, since the 8th century until its secularisation in 1805, one of the most important cultural centres in Europe”.

The library collection is the oldest in Switzerland, and one of earliest and most important monastic libraries in the world.

The library holds almost 160,000 volumes, with most available for public use.

In addition to older printed books, the collection includes 1,650 incunabula (books printed before 1500), and 2,100 manuscripts dating back to the 8th through 15th centuries – among the most notable of the latter are items of Irish, Carolingian, and Ottonian production.

These codices are held inside glass cases, each of which is topped by a carved cherub offering a visual clue as to the contents of the shelves below – for instance, the case of astronomy-related materials bears a cherub observing the books through a telescope.

Books published before 1900 are to be read in a special reading room.

The manuscript B of the Nibelungenlied (The Song of the Nibelungs, an epic poem written around 1200, the first heroic epic put into writing in Germany, helping to found a larger genre of written heroic poetry) is kept here.

Above: St. Gallen Abbey Library

Granted that the University of St. Gallen (“from insight to impact“) is, according to international rankings,  considered among the world’s leading business schools.

University of St. Gallen logo english.svg

But, my view of the city of St. Gallen is coloured by my experience, which has meant a working man’s life split between teaching at private schools similar to the cowboy outfit of Wil and formerly working as a Starbucks barista.

Neither side seems reflective of St. Gallen’s intellectual potential.

Above: Old houses, St. Gallen

(To be fair, people don’t actually hate places.

They hate their experiences of places.)

The two half-cantons of Appenzell Innerrhoden and Appenzell Ausserrhoden have, over time, perhaps without justification, become the butt of many a joke from the rest of Switzerland when one seeks a place to label as backwards.

Coat of arms of Appenzell

Above: Coat of arms of the half-cantons of Appenzell

To be fair to the comedians, Appenzell still has elections where folks line up in the town square to cast their votes by raising their arms to show their assent and it was the last place in the nation to give women the right to vote.

Farmers still lead their cattle in great processions through towns to Alpine pastures in springtime and back again when winter threatens.

As one travels from Thurgau south towards Ticino one senses a change in spirit.

Swiss cantons

Already we have encountered a village that fostered the growth of a Pulitzer Prize-deserving journalist and we have traversed towns of castles and artists, of epic tales and bridges over troubled waters.

But it is here in Lichtensteig where the air becomes rarified, where farmers think and plowmen wax poetic.

The time has come when scientific truth must cease to be the property of the few, when it must be woven into the common life of the world.” (Louis Agassiz)

Louis Agassiz H6.jpg

Above: Louis Agassiz (1807 – 1873)

Jost Bürgi (1552 – 1632) is probably the kind of man Agassiz had in mind.

Lichtensteiger Bürgi was a Swiss clockmaker, a maker of astronomical instruments and a mathematician.

Although an autodidact (he taught himself), Bürgi was already during his lifetime considered one of the most excellent mechanical engineers of his generation (think of a Da Vinci or an Edison).

Bürgi’s employer, William IV (1532 – 1592), the Landgrave of Hesse-Kessel, in a letter to Tycho Brahe (1542 – 1601)(Denmark’s greatest astronomer) praised Bürgi as “a second Archimedes” (287 – 212 BC).

The lunar crater Byrgius (the Latin form of Bürgi) is named in this Lichtensteiger’s honour.

Above: Portrait of Jost Bürgi

Another thinking man from Lichtensteig was Augustine Reding (1625 – 1692), a Benedictine, the Prince-Abbot of Einsiedeln Abbey and a respected theological writer.

At Einsiedeln, Reding organized the construction of the Abbey’s choir, confessional and the Chapel of St. Magdalena.

In 1675, Einsiedeln took charge of the college at Bellinzona, which was conducted by the monks of the Abbey until their suppression in 1852.

Reding watched carefully over discipline of Abbey affairs and insisted on a thorough intellectual training of his monks.

Above: Einsiedeln Cloister, Canton Schwyz

Lichtenberger Johann Ulrich Giezendanner (1686 – 1738) learned the profession of goldsmithing in Toggenburg.

Through his parish priest Niklaus Scherrer and his friend August Hermann Francke in Halle, Giezendanner began to practice pietism.

Giezendanner was banished from Toggenburg on suspicion of pietism, because he threatened the authorities with the criminal judgment of God.

His threats led to an investigation by a pietist commission set up by the Council, in which the secular side had the majority.

As a result, Giezendanner was expelled without a trial in 1710.

And so he went to Zürich.

In 1714, Giezendanner began studying theology at the University of Marburg, heard lectures from Johann Heinrich Hottinger (1681 – 1750) and worked as a teacher in the Marburg orphanage.

Because Giezendanner preached on his own initiative in Marburg, he was expelled from the state of Hesse.

Logo

After a short stay in Heidelberg, he returned to eastern Switzerland and began to hold secret meetings in Bottinghoffen near Scherzingen, less than 10 klicks (Canadian for kilometres) from my Landschlacht driveway.

Above: Bottighofen Harbour

As a representative of the radical pietism in German-speaking Switzerland, he returned to Zürich until he was expelled from there for his preaching.

On 29 June 1716, Giezendanner’s most memorable sermon of inspiration was given at the country estate of Johann Kaspar Schneeberger in Engstringen (just outside Zürich), in which Giezendanner said:

Hear now, my word, you stupid sticky clods of earth, where is your lie?

And so, hear, hear, heads of this place, you enter as gods and lords, but what kind of god you have for your rule, is it not with you all that you bring your belly to God?

With great arrogance to exclaim sins on the streets, when you walk on the streets, sin will take place and all of you will find it.

Unterengstringen, im Vordergrund das Kloster Fahr

Above: Engstringen, Canton Zürich

Unable to win friends and influence people in Switzerland, Giezendanner emigrated to America in 1734, working as a goldsmith in Charleston.

In 1736, he founded the first church of Toggenburger, Rhine Valley and Appenzell pietists in South Carolina’s Orangeburg County.

Above: Historic houses, Charleston, South Carolina, USA

It is a pity that those trained in the uncertainties of faith couldn’t be made responsible for the training of those who lead nations.

Perhaps a rigorous examination of our leaders’ intellectual and moral training might prevent the rise of demagogues and populists whose only qualification for power is their desire to dominate others.

Another man whose mind was a beautiful thing to behold was Max Rychner.

Max Rychner (1897 – 1965) was a writer, journalist, translator and literary critic.

Hannah Arendt (1906 – 1975), widely considered to be one of the most important political philosophers of the 20th century, called Rychner “one of the most educated and subtle figures in the intellectual life of the era“.

Rychner is considered, among other things, to be the discoverer of the poet Paul Celan (1920 – 1970), the publisher of the memoirs of Walter Benjamin (1892 – 1940), the editor-translator of philosopher-poet Paul Valéry (1871 – 1945), as well as being himself a poet, novelist and essayist.

Rychner is best known for:

  • Freundeswort (Word of a friend)
  • Die Ersten: Ein Epyllion (The first: an epyllion)(not sure what an epyllion is)
  • Unter anderem zur europäischen Literatur zwischen zwei Weltkriegen (On European literature between two world wars)
  • Arachne
  • Bedelte und testierte Welt (Affirmed and certified world)

Bei mir laufen Fäden zusammen - Max Rychner | Wallstein Verlag

According to Wikipedia, Rycher’s “method of literary admiration, based on hermeneutic models, raised formal aesthetic criteria far beyond questions of content and meaning.”

I have no idea of what that means, but it sure sounds impressive.

An incomplete sphere made of large, white, jigsaw puzzle pieces. Each puzzle piece contains one glyph from a different writing system, with each glyph written in black.

Wikivoyage (German version only) recommends Lichtensteig for:

  • the alleys and houses in the old quarter of the town

  • the Toggenburger Museum (Sundays 1 – 5 pm)

  • Fredy’s Mechanical Music Museum (last weekend of the months April to December at 3 pm / guided tours only / five-person minimum / CHF 14 per person)

Fredy's Mechanical Music Museum | Switzerland Tourism

  • Erlebniswelt Toggenburg (Adventure World Toggenburg)(Wednesdays and weekends: 1030 to 1630)

(It’s a small world, after all.)

Erlebniswelt Toggenburg - BESUCHER

  • Various sports facilities, including a climbing wall and an outdoor pool
  • the Thurweg which wends through the town

Datei:Thurweg..jpg

  • Jazz Days, with international jazz greats, annually

Jazztage Lichtensteig | Erlebnisregion Ostschweiz & Bodensee

Travel as a Political Act

Now you may be wondering why I bother telling you all of this, explaining in painful prose what lies beneath the surface of places.

Travel guide writer Rick Steves said it best:

Travel connects people with people.

It helps us fit more comfortably and compatibly into a shrinking world.

It inspires creative new solutions to persistent problems facing our nation.

We can’t understand our world without experiencing it.

There is more to travel than good-value hotels, great art and tasty cuisine.

Travel as a political act means the Traveller can have the time of his life and come home smarter – with a better understanding of the interconnectedness of today’s world and just how we fit in.”

Travel as a Political Act (Rick Steves): Steves, Rick ...

Steves sees the travel writer of the 21st century like a court jester of the Middle Ages.

Rick Steves cropped.jpg

Above: Rick Steves

While thought of as a comedian, the jester was in a unique position to tell truth to power without being punished.

Back then, kings were absolute rulers – detached from the lives of their subjects.

The court jester’s job was to mix it up with people that the King would never meet.

The jester would play in the gutter with the riffraff.

Then, having fingered the gritty pulse of society, the true lifeblood of the Kingdom, the jester would come back into the court and tell the King the truth.

Above: “Keying Up” – The Court Jester, by William Merritt Chase, 1875.

Your Highness, the people are angered by the cost of mead. 

They are offended by the Queen’s parties. 

The Pope has more influence than you. 

Everybody is reading the heretics’ pamphlets. 

Your stutter is the butt of many rude jokes.

Is there not a parallel here between America and this Kingdom?

Comedians like Seth Meyers, Stephen Colbert and Trevor Noah are listened to more by the average American than the actual news these comedians parody.

For these jesters of 21st century television know the pulse of the nation far more accurately than do the mandarins of power in Washington.

Seth Meyers by Gage Skidmore.jpg

Above: Seth Meyers

Stephen Colbert December 2019.jpg

Above: Stephen Colbert

Trevor Noah 2017.jpg

Above: Trevor Noah

Trump is the butt of many rude jokes, because he deserves to be.

Trump has leaders from around the world openly laughing at him at ...

Meyers, Colbert and Noah are graffiti writers on the walls of sacred institutions, watching rich riffraff ride roughshod over the rest of those whose sole hopes from the gutter is that their only direction from their perspective is up.

File:Who Watches the Watchmen.jpg - Wikimedia Commons

In the Kingdom, the King did not kill the jester.

In order to rule more wisely, the King needed the jester’s insights.

In America, the President would love to kill his critics.

He is not interested in ruling wisely, only perpetually.

Official Keep America Great 45th President Hat – Trump Make ...

Many of today’s elected leaders have no better connection with real people (especially beyond their borders) than those divinely ordained monarchs did centuries ago.

Any Traveller, including your humble blogger and you my patient readers, can play jester in your own communities.

Sometimes a jackass won’t move unless a gesturing mosquito is biting its behind.

Mosquito 2007-2.jpg

Consider countries like El Salvador (where people don’t dream of having two cars in every garage) or Denmark (where they pay high taxes with high expectations and are satisfied doing so) or Iran (where many compromise their freedom for their fidelity to their faith).

Travellers can bring back valuable insights and, just like those insights were needed in the Middle Ages, this understanding is desperately needed in our age of anxiety.

Ideally, travel broadens our perspectives personally, culturally and politically.

Suddenly, the palette with which we paint the parameters of our personalities has more colour, more vibrancy.

We realize that there are exciting alternatives to the social and community norms that our less-travelled neighbours may never consider.

It is like discovering there are other delicacies off the menu, that there is more than one genre of music available on the radio, that there is an upstairs alcove above the library yet to be discovered, that you haven’t yet tasted all 31 flavours.

1970s Baskin Robbins 31 Flavors Ice Cream logo

That there are more things in Heaven and Earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy.

I will never be against tourists who travel to escape their workaday lives and simply wish to relax in as uncomplicated a fashion as humanly possible.

Sometimes this is needed.

Kokomo song cover.jpg

No, I am referring to Travellers who travel with a purpose on purpose.

People who try to connect with other people.

People who take history seriously.

Yesterday’s history informs today’s news, which becomes all our tomorrows.

Those with a knowledge (or at least a curiosity) of history can understand current events in a broader context and respond to them more thoughtfully.

As you travel, opportunities to enjoy history are everywhere.

Work on cultivating a general grasp of the sweep of history and you will be able to infuse your travels with more meaning.

Even if, in this time of corona, our travels are local.

Above: History by Frederick Dielman (1896)

I digress.

The Warriors of Wattwil

The long and winding road leads us to Wattwil (population: 8,740), first documented in 897 as “Wattinurlare” (which sounds exotic but only means “Watto’s village“).

Wattwil Gesamtansicht Yburg.jpg

Above: Wattwil, Canton St. Gallen

Around 1230, Heinrich von Iberg had Iberg Castle built here.

It was destroyed during the Appenzell Wars (1401 – 1429) and rebuilt.

It served as the seat of the bailiffs until 1805.

Above: Iberg Castle, Wattwil

In 1468, the entire Toggenburg County (the last Toggenburg Count, Friedrich VII died without heirs) was bought by St. Gallen Abbey.

The Pfaffenweise (place of assembly) (today a cemetery) served as a community and war gathering point and as a place to demonstrate hommage to the Prince-Abbots of St. Gallen.

Above: Wattwil station

In 1529, Pastor Mauriz Miles from Lichtensteig introduced the Reformation to Wattwil.

The population, which supported the religious innovations by a large majority, was able to prevail against the Catholic abbots.

Catholic Services were only reintroduced in 1593.

The Wattwil church was used by both faiths until a new Catholic church was built in 1968.

Above: Wattwil Reformed Church

Above: Wattwil Catholic Church

In 1621, the Capuchin Convent of St. Mary the Angel was built on the slope called the Wenkenürti (I have no idea what this translates to.) after a devastating fire at their previous location on Pfanneregg (a hill where the Vitaparcours – think “outdoor gym path” – is practiced).

The Convent is an excellently preserved complex with a highly baroque church.

Sadly, the Sisters left the monastery in 2010.

Above: St. Mary the Angel Convent

In the 17th century, St. Gallen Abbey wanted to expand the road known as Karrenweg via Rickenpass, in order to ensure a better connection between St. Gallen and Catholic Central Switzerland.

The majority of the Reformed Wattwil populace refused to work on it or contribute to it, tirggering the Toggenburg Turmoil (1699 – 1712), which led to the Second Villmerger War of 1712.

The road was only realized in 1786.

Wattwil’s traditional linen weaving mill was replaced by a cotton factory in 1750.

In the 19th century, more than a dozen companies started operating in the town.

In 1881, the Toggenburg weaving school was founded, from which the Swiss Textile Technical School later emerged.

The spirit of intelligence, the thirst for knowledge, the expression of wisdom can also be found in Wattwil.

Ulrich Bräker (1735 – 1798) was an autodidact, writer and diarist, known for his autobiography, widely received at the time as the voice of an unspoiled “natural man” of the lower classes, based on the title which Bräker became known “der arme Mann im Toggenburg” (the poor man of Toggenburg).

Bräker was born the oldest of eight siblings.

Above: Bräker’s birth house in Näppis near Wattwil

Bräker was educated in literacy and basic arithmetic during ten weeks each winter, working as a goatherd for the rest of the year.

In 1754, the family moved to Wattwil, where Bräker worked various jobs.

In 1755, he entered the service of a Prussian recruiting officer.

Against Bräker’s wishes, he was pressed into military duty in the 13th infantry regiment of the Prussian army in 1756, but he managed to escape later that same year in the midst of the Battle of Lobositz.

War Ensign of Prussia (1816).svg

Above: War flag of Prussia

Returning to his native Toggenburg, Bräker married Salome Ambühl (1735 – 1822) of Wattwil in 1761 and had several children.

Bräker built a house “auf der Hochsteig” (on the high slope) outside of Wattwil and traded in cotton for the local home industry.

Above: Bräker’s house auf der Hochsteig, contemporary drawing (c. 1794; the house was destroyed in 1836)

He began writing a diary.

Der arme Mann im Tockenburg - Ulrich Bräker - Buch kaufen | Ex Libris

Bräker’s writing talent was discovered by local writer and intellectual Johann Ludwig Ambühl.

Bräker published some texts in Ambühl’s Brieftasche aus den Alpen (Letter Bag from the Alps).

Bräker’s writing is based on the pietistic outlook and reflects familiarity with the Bible as well as a keen observation of nature and an enthusiastic interest in the translated works of Shakespeare.

9781166984809: Die Brieftasche Aus Den Alpen (1780) (German ...

Bräker’s diary is a touching human document containing Lebensweisheit (pearls of pure pramatic wisdom).

Sämtliche Schriften, 5 Bde., Bd.1, Tagebücher 1768-1778: Amazon.de ...

Bräker lived to see, and was perturbed by, the French invasion of Switzerland in the spring of 1798.

He died in September that same year.

Johann Ludwig Ambühl (1750 – 1800) was a civil servant and a writer – much like my aforementioned Canadian friend at the beginning of this post.

Ambühl was the son of the schoolmaster of Wattwil, Hans Jacob Ambühl (1699 – 1773).

At the age of 23, Johann became his father’s successor in 1733, for he had helped Hans, increasingly blind, with seven hours of instruction every day since he was 12.

In his free time, Johann mainly devoted himself to studying geometry, music, reading, drawing and collecting natural objects.

In Wattwil, Ambühl was considered a Stölzling (nerd), because of his always strict and serious appearance in public.

9781120610225: Die Brieftasche Aus Den Alpen (1780) (German ...

In 1783, on the recommendation of Gregorius Grob, Ambühl was hired as a court master by the rich Rheineck merchant Jacob Laurenz Custer.

In this function, he accompanied one of his students to Strasbourg in 1786, to Geneva (1788 – 1789) and in 1790 on a study trip through Italy.

The majority of Ambühl’s literary work consists of plays of extremely patriotic content.

It was like sawdust, the unhappiness.

It infiltrated everything.

Everything was a problem, everything made her cry….but it was so hard to say exactly what the problem was in the first place.” 

(Melanie Thernstrom, The Dead Girl)

The Dead Girl by Melanie Thernstrom

Hans Adolf Pestalozzi (1929 – 2004) was a social critic of late 20th century capitalism, which eventually led to his becoming a bestselling author.

Hans A Pestalozzi - Alchetron, The Free Social Encyclopedia

Born in Zürich, Pestalozzi, after his studies at the University of St. Gallen, started working for Migros.

Logo

In the 1960s he built up the Gottlieb Duttweiler Institut, a think tank named ater the Migros founder, in Rüschlikon (on Lake Zürich).

The Institute was established to investigate the range of possible shortcomings and negative effects of capitalism, in particular within Western consumer society, so that they could be combated more effectively.

Pestalozzi fulfilled that task very thoroughly, too thoroughly, especially in his lectures, so much so that in 1977 he was fired by Migros.

Rather than looking for a new job, he became a freelance writer and self-proclaimed “autonomous agitator” who sided with the fledging European youth, peace and ecological movements.

He preached “positive subversion” and tried to convince people that using their own intelligence was the right thing to do.

HANS A. PESTALOZZI | Autor, Positiv

Above: Pestalozzi (centre), After us the future, from positive subversion (left) and Off the trees of the apes (right)

Moreover, Pestalozzi demanded a guaranteed minimum income for everybody.

Pestalozzi died a recluse by suicide in his home near Wattwil.

Einsamer Tod eines wirtschaftskritischen Managers

Wikivoyage recommends the Cloister, the Castle and the Kubli Church in Wattwil.

The current Wikivoyage logo

The Wattwil area is great for hiking and mountain biking.

And somewhere down the highway….

The Afterglow of Ebnat- Kappel

Perhaps the easiest way of making a town’s acquaintance is to ascertain how the people in it work, how they love and how they die. 

In our little town (is this, one wonders, an effect of the climate?) all three are done on much the same lines, with the same feverish yet casual air. 

The truth is that everyone is bored and devotes himself to cultivating habits.

(Albert Camus, The Plague)

The Plague (1992 film).jpg

Ebnat-Kappel (population: 5,031) was first mentioned in 1218 as “Capelle“.

On 26 July 1854, a fire almost completely destroyed the village.

In 1847, Johann Gerhard Oncken founded the first Swiss Baptist church here in E-K.

Ebnat-Kappel Vilagxo kun preghejo 611.jpg

People visit Ebnat-Kappel primarily to ski or to follow the 60-kilometre Thurweg.

Worth viewing are:

  • the Reformed Church in the centre of Ebnat along with the church hall with its front tower

  • the Steinfels House (a Gothic building with Baroque decor)

  • the Ackerhaus (built for Albert Edelmann who donated the house to serve as the local museum)

Museum Hauskultur Toggenburg Ackerhaus, Ebnat-Kappel

  • Typical wooden Toggenburg houses preserved in nearby Eich

Bäuerliches Toggenburger Haus in Ebnat-Kappel Foto & Bild ...

  • the Felsenstein House in Kappel with Gothic windows and cross-vaulted rooms
  • the willow wood figures near the station depicting a chapel and an unicorn

Wappen von Ebnat-Kappel

Above: Coat of arms of Ebnat – Kappel

  • the Sinnepark (a sensory park) just south of the village

Der Sinnepark - Verkehrsverein Ebnat-Kappel

Above: Ebnat-Kappel station

Notable people of Ebnat-Kappel are:

  • Albert Edelmann (1886 – 1963) was a teacher, painter and sponsor of local folk and cultural assets.

His Ackerhaus museum shows objects of Toggenburg culture from four centuries.

In addition to household items and equipment from the Toggenburg, the collection contains rural paintings, pictures by Babeli Giezendammer and other painters, seven house organs and neck zithers.

By the end of the 19th century, the neck zither game in Toggenburg was forgotten.

Thanks to Edelmann this tradition was revived.

There is a room dedicated to the Biedermeier period (1815 – 1848) in Toggenburg.

Edelmann’s former studio shows his CV and his work.

While the Museum offers encounters with the past, the culture of Now is everpresent.

Above: Albert Edelmann

I enjoy decoration. 

By accumulating this mass of detail you throw light on things in a longer sense. 

In the long run it all adds up. 

It creates a texture – how shall I put it – a background, a period, which makes everything you write that much more convincing. 

Of course, all artists are terrible egoists. 

Unconsciously you are largely writing about yourself. 

I could never write anything factual. 

I only have confidence in myself when I am another character. 

All the characters in my books are myself, but they are a kind of disguise.

(Patrick White)

  • Babeli Giezendanner (1831 – 1905) was a painter, representative of Appenzeller / Toggenburger peasant painting.

She was born the third of nine children.

In 1861, she married master shoemaker Ulrich Remisegger.

In 1873, he died in an accident.

As a widow with three children, Babeli supported her family through weaving, drawing and painting.

In 1904, she moved to the Hemberg poorhouse and lived there until she died in her 74th year.

Possibly all art flowers more readily in silence. 

Certainly the state of simplicity and humility is the only desirable one for artist or for man. 

While to reach it may be impossible, to attempt to do so is imperative.

(Patrick White)

Babeli Giezendanner learned to draw from her father, which meant that she had a good knowledge of perspective drawing that characterizes her work.

Furthermore, she worked temporarily in Lichtensteig for the lithographer Johan Georg Schmied.

Stylistic relationships to the work of the Swiss peasant painter Johannes Müller from Stein (AR) can be proven.

He may have been one of her role models.

The artist’s oeuvre is diverse and extensive, the inventory includes around 100 works.

They include the depiction of houses and villages, alpine lifts and cattle shows.

She created numerous livery paintings and memorial sheets for birth, baptism, wedding and death.

For commemorative albums, she painted pictures and wrote poems.

The painting of umbrellas and dials of clocks has been handed down in the vernacular, but cannot be proven.

Today, many of her paintings and drawings are exhibited in the Toggenburg Museum in Lichtensteig and in the Museum Ackerhus in Ebnat-Kappel.

Very early in my life it was too late.

(Marguerite Duras, The Lover)

OnFiction: Marguerite Duras The Lover

I start to get the feeling that something is really wrong.

Like all the drugs put together – the lithium, the Prozac, the desipramine and the Desyrel that I take to sleep at night – can no longer combat whatever it is that was wrong with me in the first place. 

I feel like a defective model, like I came off the assembly line flat-out f….d and my parents should have taken me back for repairs before the warranty ran out. 

But that was so long ago.

I start to think there really is no cure for depression, that happiness is an ongoing battle, and I wonder if it isn’t one I’ll have to fight for as long as I live. 

I wonder if it’s worth it.

I start to feel like I can’t maintain the facade any longer, that I may just start to show through. 

And I wish I knew what was wrong.

Maybe something about how stupid my whole life is.

I don’t know.

(Elizabeth Wurzel, Prozac Nation)

Prozac Nation film.jpg

  • Guido Looser (1892 – 1937) was a writer.

Looser attended high school in Zürich and then studied history, German and geography at universities in Zürich and Berlin.

He then worked as a teacher in Zürich.

From 1922, he suffered increasingly from depression which led to long hospital stays in Kreuzlingen and Oetiwil.

In 1937, Looser committed suicide, given the impossibility of continuing to fund adequate hospitalization.

Guido Looser

Looser wrote novels, essays and poems, strongly influenced by his psychological suffering and revolving around illness, melancholy and death.

Looser is known for:

  • Nachglanz (Afterglow)
  • Josuas Hingabe (Joshua’s dedication)
  • Die Würde (Dignity)
  • Nur nie jemandem sagen, wohin man reist (Just never tell anyone where you are going)

Nur nie jemandem sagen, wohin man reist. Prosa - Guido Looser ...

“You only live twice: once when you are born and once when you look death in the face.”

(Ian Fleming)

Above: Ian Fleming (1908 – 1964)

Bridges over troubled waters

Bridge Over Troubled Water single.jpg

When I think of all the things he did because he loved me – what people visit on each other out of something like love. 

It is enough for all the world’s woe. 

You don’t need hate to have a perfectly miserable time.

(Richard Bausch, Mr. Field’s Daughter)

Mr. Field's Daughter: Bausch, Richard: 9780671640514: Amazon.com ...

Stein (population: 1,429) has a few sites worth viewing:

In the village centre, the 18th century church and the Appenzeller Folklore Museum with, among other things, looms and embroidery machines from the 19th century.

Wappen von Stein

Above: Coat of arms, Stein, Canton Appenzell

Between the hamlet of Störgel and the St. Gallen suburb of Haggen lies the Haggen Bridge, the highest pedestrian footbridge in Europe, which spans the 355-metre wide gorge of the Sitter at a height of 99 metres.

The structure called “Ganggelibrugg” (wobbly bridge) was actually planned for traffic between Stein and St. Gallen, but due to serious structural defects it could never be handed over to its intended purpose.

For a long time it was the most used bridge for suicide in Switzerland.

Since 2010, the bridge has been secured with nets that help prevent such tragedies.

Nearby are the Kubelbrücke (the Talking Bridge, a covered wooden bridge over the Urnäsch River in the hamlet of Kubel), the Abtebrücke (the Abbey Bridge, a covered wooden bridge over the River Sitter in the hamlet of Kubel, built by the St. Gallen Monastery) and the Hüsli covered wooden bridges across the Sitter and the Wattbach beneath the Ganggelibrugg in the hamlets of Blatten and Zweibruggen.

Also worth visiting in Stein is the Appenzeller Show Dairy, where you can watch the production of Appenzeller cheese.

(Open: 0900 – 1800 / Guided tours: Wednesday and Sundays, 1400 and 1700)

Everybody is interested (or should be) in Switzerland.

No other country in Europe offers a richer return to the Traveller for his time and effort.

To revisit Switzerland is for the old to renew one’s youth, while for the young it is to gain a lifelong sense of the inspiring grandeurs of this wonderworld.

Above: The Matterhorn

The Traveller goes to Switzerland chiefly to look at mountains, the Swiss Alps are as effectively displayed as the treasures in a well-arranged museum, but the mountains are not the only things in Switzerland.

There are the towns and cities and the people, those admirable Swiss people, who have made their land in many respects the model country of the world.

Above: Lake Lucerne, view from Pilatus

(If you are not sure about this, just ask the Swiss.)

Coat of arms of Switzerland

The sad thing is that while Switzerland may be the playground of Europe, it is not the playground of the Swiss.

Switzerland is their workshop, where they toil at many industries and practice many useful arts of which the outside world knows little.

The world knows of music boxes, cheese and watches and that the Swiss are born hotel keepers with comfort and courtesy as their watchwords.

Non-Swiss tend to dismiss Switzerland as an irrelevance in the broader sweep of European history.

Because the country is peaceful today, the assumption is that it has always been somehow inherently tranquil, but this is an illusion.

Until the middle of the 19th century, Switzerland was the most unstable country in Europe.

The Alpine calm of today came at the price of a millennium of war.

The Swiss may no longer be an offensive force, but they are defensively armed to the teeth.

The Reformation, which began in Germany in the early 16th century, was sparked in Switzerland by a native of the next town down the road….

Above: Map of the Old Swiss Confederacy 1536 showing the religious division

Within a few days I will go to the Papal Legate [Pucci], and if he shall open a conversation on the subject as he did before, I will urge him to warn the Pope not to issue an excommunication [against Luther], for which I think would be greatly against him [the Pope].

For if it be issued I believe the Germans will equally despise the Pope and the excommunication.

But do you be of good cheer, for our day will not lack those who will teach Christ faithfully, and who will give up their lives for Him willingly, even though among men their names shall not be in good repute after this life…

So far as I am concerned I look for all evil from all of them: I mean both ecclesiastics and laymen.

I beseech Christ for this one thing only, that He will enable me to endure all things courageously, and that He break me as a potter’s vessel or make me strong, as it pleased Him.

If I be excommunicated I shall think of the learned and holy Hilary, who was exiled from France to Africa, and of Lucius, who though driven from his seat at Rome returned again with great honour.

Not that I compare myself with them: for as they were better than I so they suffered what was a greater ignominy.

And yet if it were good to flourish I would rejoice to suffer insult for the name of Christ.

But let him that thinketh he standeth take heed lest he fall.

Lately I have read scarcely any thing of Luther’s, but what I have seen of his hitherto does not seem to me to stray from gospel teaching.

You know – if you remember – that what I have always spoken of in terms of the highest commendation in him is that he supports his position with authoritative witness.”

(Huldrych Zwingli)

Ulrich-Zwingli-1.jpg

Above: Portrait of Ulrich Zwingli (1484 – 1531)

Swiss city after city overthrew ecclesiastical overlords in favour of the new Protestantism, with city authorities gaining new power over the countryside in the process.

Zwingli’s attempts in 1531 to reorganize the Confederation under the urban leadership of Zürich and Bern led to armed conflict and the eventual loss of his life in battle.

The Reformation continued to spread, with Geneva – at the time not Swiss – emerging as a major centre for Protestantism, thanks to the zealotry of French priest and Reformer Jean Calvin.

Increasingly the Catholic cantons nurtured an inferiority complex towards the Protestant cities, which held a grip on political authority.

Above: Religious division of the Old Confederacy during the 17th and 18th century

Only shared economic interests keep the Swiss Confederation together.

I have mentioned the textile industry as crucial to the towns we passed through, for it was textiles, among other industries, where merchants in the cities (generally Protestant) supplied raw materials to peasants in the countryside (generally Catholic) who worked up finished products and returned them for trading on.

Wildhaus (population: 1,205) is first mentioned in 1344 as “Wildenhuss“.

In addition to tourism, agriculture and forestry from the economic focus.

The birthplace of the Reformer Huldrych Zwingli, built in 1449, is one of the oldest wooden houses in Switzerland.

(For more on Zwingli and travels following his life, please see:

Canada Slim… 

  • and the Road to Reformation
  • and the Wild Child of Toggenburg
  • and the Thundering Hollows
  • and the Battle for Switzerland’s Soul
  • and the Monks of the Dark Forest
  • and the Battlefield Brotherhood
  • and the Lakeside Pilgrimage

….of my other blog, The Chronicles of Canada Slim at https://canadaslim.wordpress.com.)

Wildhaus is both a summer and winter sports resort.

Two chair lifts and several ski lifts lead to the Gamsalp and the Gamserrugg.

The Obertoggenburg and the Churfirsten ski area, which Wildhaus operated together with Unterwasser and Alt St. Johann until separated by the Cablecar Conflict of 2019.

The 87-kilometre Toggenburger Höhenweg begins in Wildhaus and ends in Will, as does the 60-kilometre long Thurweg.

Wildhaus SG

Above: Wildhaus, Canton St. Gallen

Wildhaus is a place my wife and I have together and apart have repeatedly visited.

I have followed both the Höhenweg and the Thurweg from start to finish.

We have driven to and through Wildhaus.

On this trip we do not tarry but continue swiftly onwards.

Coat of arms of Wildhaus

Above: Coat of arms of Wildhaus

What follows is a place so seductive that an afternoon seems to stand still….

(To be continued….)

Wildhaus SG

Sources: Wikipedia / Google / Wikiquote / Wikivoyage / Giovanni Boccaccio, The Decameron / Albert Camus, The Plague / Humphrey Carpenter, The Inklings / Albert M. Debrunner, Literaturführer Thurgau / Rick Steves, Travel as a Political Act / Elizabeth Wurzel, Prozac Nation / Rosamund Young, The Secret Life of Cows